Understanding Kashmir through the lens of border disputes between India, Pakistan & China

#CutTheClutter #Border #jammuandkashmir
In Episode 235 of #CutTheClutter, originally published on 10 August, 2019, Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta talks about the territorial jumble around Kashmir and how it figures in border disputes between India, Pakistan and China.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
» Subscribe to our KZbin Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

[@ThePrintIndia]

Exclusive content, privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/

[@himarsingh6522]

Excellent episode Shekhar - explains the complex issue with such ease and simplicity. Thank you for this...

[@Rustam_102]

Why siachin area not shown in india? Stop using wrong maps

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

because The Print is with Pakistan and Shekhar Gupta is a sell-out

[@anshul9462]

What nonsense. They are very well showing Siachen within India. What is wrong?

[@Arkham-kq9uf]

Liberandus ☕

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

Because Coupta is working for Pakistan/Congress!!

[@Mukesh_Devrari]

It is painful to see Congress could not even protect the territory of India handed over by the British.

[@rka-truthalwayswins5127]

It's much worse!! Nehru/Congress destroyed India's physical, cultural, civilization-al & economic security!!

[@chandu25abc20]

Whatever British occupied illegally doesn’t automatically comes to India, India has to come to reality and settle the issues with the nations impacted by British occupation, otherwise it will have to own the sins of British vis-à-vis becoming responsible for the creation of hostile neighborhood.

[@Mukesh_Devrari]

Well, Tibet was independent, Congress helped CCP to take control of Tibet, China assured Nehru don't worry about borders our claims are just maps by nationalist govt and were drawn in 1930s. There was no conflict till Tibet existed as buffer state. Yes you are right, India is too poor and weak to take back what China has already seized in 1962 war or Pakistan has seized in 1948 war. Not many people know that even Pakistan captured some of the Indian territory in 1971 war in Kashmir and Indira Gandhi let them keep it. Anyways. Now China and Pakistan demand Indian territory, we don't demand their territory. India is struggling to keep whatever we have for the last 75 years due to the revisionist totalitarian China and Islamic state of Pakistan want to add more and more land to their territories. @@chandu25abc20

[@hawkingdawking4572]

The whole India thing is a British invention just like Hinduism, Sanathana Dharma and Bharat. Proto-Hindus had no idea about the geography of the cow belt heartland let alone the Ladakh region which is related to Tibet.

[@Mukesh_Devrari]

Hinduism and other indigenous faiths are the threads that tied India together. Islamic invasion and civilizational colonization of some of our population forces them to hate their culture, identity and forefathers. @@hawkingdawking4572

[@mailtorajrao]

This was an excellent episode! Thank you for reposting.

[@siddharthdesai5707]

Thanks for the revision and update. It was nice as expected from you

[@ajayjoshi5251]

Mr Gupta , just a correction . Mr Mahaveer Tyagi was not an opposition M.P. He was a cabinet minister in Nehru cabinet from 1953 - 57 ( Minister of defence organization) and again in 1964 Minister for rehabilitation. In his book Azadi ka Andolan, Haste hue aansu he has very vividly discribed the incidence of exchange of arguments regarding Aksai chin with Mr Nehru.

[@harisundar8698]

SG, please do a ctc on the recently published consumer expenditure survey and its findings. Rural expenditure is the key that we are all waiting for decluttering.

[@mailtorajrao]

Yes please!

[@sagormoybanerjee8054]

Actually earlier we have been provided with an excellent program about siachin glacier by you, wish that link is also provided for present audience

[@vinodpillai]

I have seen this episode when it was published. The question to ask is.... Why has this been put out now!?.... What does The Print know that makes it necessary to re publish now?

[@sashinair1545]

Kudos to you !!! Excellent stuff.

[@born-to-fly]

Basics are important. No better way to explain than on a map.👍

[@asissinha4966]

Well researched and nuanced presentation. Request Mr Gupta to update/present a new episode keeping in mind the changed situation post-Galwan.

[@ghazanfardar1630]

Very informative and educating. Thanks for giving a perspective on it.

[@Meena57Ms]

Excellent episode. Mr. Shekar. You are making me aware of current affairs and rekindling the desire to go deeper into news which I had stopped in my early twenties mainly because info was was not so easily available. Now I am 66 and have started reading non fiction again thanks to curiosity that you have aroused in me.

[@shyam2061]

This episode should be titled, "India's borders with China-Pakistan and significance of Kashmir". At the earliest!

[@shambhavishukla547]

This old bald man is our national cutie indian uncle who actually knows what he’s talking about!! Indian uncle ftw❤️💕❤️💕❤️💕

[@zt3gaming796]

bruh wtf💀💀

[@pranovgoutam]

SG is making a fool of its paid subscribers by posting old CTC. 😂😂

[@rajbaniwal3236]

I hate the Print and its Political bias but a lot of Gupta ji’s videos are quite informative. Considering Article 370 has been stamped as legit, I think it’s a good reminder how the geo politics of that region works out. In India we were made to believe it was a Hindu Muslim thing but actually, it’s a geo political game.

[@janakiramrajkumar]

Thanks for educating us on this crucial topic on which so much misunderstanding exists.

[@vijeshwar.8157]

So beautifully explained.. I am not qualified to have my on view in front of such an experienced and qualified journalist / strategic analyst but I think Indian army's view point for not going beyond uri , Poonch Rajouri, ladakh to reclaim POK G .B areas is missing...Secondly in what circumstances col.Brown of British army gave away Gilgit Baltistan to pak should have also been mentioned for better understanding of whole of the issue. Thank you very much for this...

[@user-ne3sy8cc7d]

Lol pak gilgit scouts made dogra general surrender gilgit baltistan, even images if this are widespread

[@rajshekhar1147]

SG Sir, i really like your kurtas. Pls tell us from where do you buy them.

[@user-sf5ix7bs8p]

it is a very good discussion, people should be aware of the problems that Modi is facing from our enemies

[@sharabhpachory9810]

A good episode, even for Army officers like me who have served in these areas, including Siachin (Northern Glacier). A mention of Point NJ 9842 (a grid reference on the map) upto which the LoC was marked (it was mentioned , beyond this point, "moves thence northwards..." ) would have been in order.

[@dawn_alex]

Sir, do you think India can retake the whole of Kashmir in our lifetime? Also, huge thanks for your service sir. 🙏 🙏.

[@jackson7880]

The govt is either shy or afraid to disclose the real situation in ladakh for no ostensible reasons. When asked about it our honourable defence minister replied -" Indian armed forces are capable enough to give a befitting reply". That's way too vague and doesn't even address the question in the first place.

[@rajbaniwal3236]

What is the REAL situation of Ladakh? Are you referring to Subramaniam Swamy’s allegations that China has encroached?

[@lpfan247]

Is there an update to this?

[@anirudhsingh2228]

Im reading the book right now sir, and I must say, U have a kink of Book recommendation Absolutely.

[@Vagabond617]

There is no border dispute from India’s side with Pakistan. Why are you still keep parroting this Kashmir dispute story?

[@PankajGupta-df1kk]

Complex issues are to be solved and not given up. It will be difficult and time consuming task. No abrasive actions needed.

[@urldroidsuperbot2139]

Shekhar, you should have explained that Gilgit was never under the Dogra King's control, it was ruled by the British as Gilgit Agency because of British Russophobia to protect its colony from Russia since the 19th century, before Kashmir kingdom was created. It was only transferred to Hari Singh on 3rd June, 1947, and as you mentioned controlled by army units led by British. The Scottish chief of Gilgit Scouts, one William Brown, decided that the Muslim population of Gilgit don't want to join India when he learnt that Maharaja Hari Singh has signed the Instrument of Accession on 26th October, 1947 and arrested the King's army chief there, Ghansar Singh on 1st November, 1947 and made the region a part of Pakistan. Brown served the Pakistani military till 1959 and was awarded posthumously by the Pakistani government. It is truthful to treat Gilgit-Baltistan as different from Jammu and Kashmir and it is sad that Indian writers never let us know it, calling it all as Pakistan Occupied Kashmir. This is not to say that India has no claim there, but leaving out important details totally like that makes me unhappy.

[@virendrad9447]

well covered. it may be worthwhile to cover not well known historical events based on some authentic books at least once a month

[@angryhusky2467]

After reading history its not Nehru but Hari Singh who created all the problems we are facing. Nehru's as well as Patel's mistake was going to UN which was realised by them and 10 months later Hyderabad was captured by police action.

[@muhammadhanifgul4287]

Very informative episode. British ruled India by a policy of “divide & rule”. Before leaving, they ensured that this policy of division continues between the two nations who share common history and culture. We, the residents of India and Pakistan foolishly followed this trap and viewed each other as an enemy and poisoned our people against each other. It is high time that we consider taking a regional approach to our common issues and resolve them by embracing our common identity and making the region borderless in terms trade, tourism, economy and possibly currency too. If we move in that direction most of the discussion will no more be relevant.

[@kuldeepsharma7007]

How dare you have headline such as this Kashmir is India and don't you ever forget that You should close this lutyens Chanel Shame on you

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

Kashmir is India 🇮🇳 Balochistan is not Pakistan

[@user-lc5iy3st6c]

‌Ha ha ha why are you Indians so stupid?

[@mokhan2873]

Source: Trust Me Bro I'm from Balochistan you ass wipe 😂 Fact is Indian Occupied Jammu and Kashmir is Occupied hence why it's the most militarized region

[@LoyaAfghanistan]

I don’t know if Afghans are interested in our politics but we definitely are interested in their politics. This being said remember guys we tribal ppl take pride for being pathan and no need to know history but we are same race called Afgan. We are by far full proud Afghan of course after Islam. Which is why we don’t fight against pakistani brothers. But if we are being pushed too far we know how to defend ourselves. Our demand from pakistan 🇵🇰 1. Free Imran Khan 2. Kpk under PTI (Ali Amin Gandapur as governor or Sher Afzal Marwat) 3. Free FATA back to its original state as Imran khan planed to do so. 4. No fence border with Afghanistan 5. Our own language as the official languages in KPK no more urdu… If pakistan does follow demands from these lists things not easy for Pakistan inshallah our protests will continue then our demands by majority is.. 1. Will fight until Free Kpk/Balochistan back to Afghanistan or let us decide our own.. 2. Free Azad Kashmir and back to its motherland the rightful owner 🇮🇳 3. Punjab/sindh can form a new government singapor like without debt or join India. 😊😊 Ali Shah Afridi Gilgit Pok

[@goldenshamrock7267]

... seems to be Guptajee of Ayodhya walay. 😊😊😊

[@MAB68195]

Shekhar, for the interest of your viewers, I would like to mention Article 6 of the 1972 Shimla Agreement which states that... "Both Governments agree that the respective Heads will meet again at a mutually convenient time in the future and that, in the meanwhile, the representatives of the two sides will meet to discuss further the modalities and arrangements for the establishment of durable peace and normalization of relations, including the questions of repatriation of prisoners of war and civilians' internees, a final settlement of Jammu and Kashmir and the resumption of diplomatic relations"......... The last sentence clearly states that the "Final Settlement" of J&K still remains to be sorted out between India & Pak. Truth always gets buried under emotive statements on emotive issues....

[@mg.f.9023]

Pakistan has granted Russia access to a warm water port in the Arabian sea (Gwadar Port). Since Pakistan joined the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, relations between both sides have become closer.

[@abhirupsen1747]

India just had a ten year renewable contract for Chabahar port. This port is being used for transhipment to Afganistan, Russia , CIS countries. Wake up

[@temp1851]

Ya right. Just like how it granted Chinese access to Arabian sea under CPEC and made pakistan a trading hub😂😂

[@SaeedKhan-pj5zf]

Why r u focusing kashmir as part of India? Pakistan as a whole was part of India before partition. U r not dare to claim and u can't

[@shivasundar]

Thanks for LP Sen's book recommendation, Shekhar. Will check it out. BUT, one thing I had read that is I believe VERY inaccurate is your position on Gilgit Balitstan (GB). I believe I read in a book extract that Mountbatten had "ended the agreement" 15 days ahead of independence - on August 1!! So this means, it was HIS ploy to deliberately hand it over when the Maharaja was hardly ready to defend all portions of his kingdom and send people everywhere! Troops may have revolted, but the Political Agent - who was British - in GB did too! And imprisoned the governor! Again, THEY wanted "independence" not merger with Pakistan at that point - something which the British did NOT give as one of the choices to all 565 Princely States! NO ruler was given right to independence - per the terms of partition and transfer of power among the 565 (+ less than 20 I think from Pakistan) princely states: they had to join one of the 2 dominions! PLEASE note, the Maharaja signed a "Standstill agreement" with Pakistan (hence he was 'hinting' that it was a 'different country'!) He DID NOT sign one with India - before 15 August ot before October 1947 even!

[@sheshasaikumarsadu1496]

A map without Trans-Karakoram Tract?

[@zulkarneynhaydar8992]

When is India reuniting GB? We look forward to be back.

[@raghuveerdendukuri1762]

Lease agreement overridden and Gilgit baltistan occupied by British commanders who chose Pakistan for short-term benefit doesn't mean it will theirs. India/Bharatavarsha to take back all Pakistan occupied & China occupied indian territories back. People to stay aware of blunders of Shri Nehru. Thanks Gupta ji for sharing your understanding on the topic.

[@Moeed__123]

❤

[@pito6979]

How can india create a map that include the teritory that not controlled by india...just because british said so ? What different than chinese claim with 9 dash line. Just settle the dispute w china and pakistan peacefully. How hard it is ? If atitude is 0 sum game . There will be never a peaceful in india border. Compromise is take and give for greater good.

[@user-rn5lw1ub8p]

@ThePrintIndia why you guys have placed INDIA naming Map below Jammu-kashmir & Ladakh ? Please don't show fake interpreted Maps to educate others. It's a humble request!

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Kashmir is disputed.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Kashmir is disputed.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Kashmir is disputed.

[@rakeshmandliya782]

❤❤❤❤

[@magma9000]

INDIAN OCCUPIED KASHMIR

[@libshastra]

Shekarji, things are becoming ridiculous with regard to comments. My previous 4-5 comments are getting deleted by your channel or KZbin. I mentioned basic income, that got deleted, I talk about American support for independence movement that gets deleted, I highlight issues with a guests’ analysis, that gets deleted. It is evident that someone dislikes comments that doesn’t suit their agenda.

[@navdeepsugandhi6476]

My comments too got deleted, print is censoring comments or maybe it's youtube

[@chandu25abc20]

x country occupied countries A,B,C and few areas of D which is under sezurinity of Y, now when x left, A,B and C joined to form a single country and retained the parts of D in it. All the border issue between India-China is related to that few areas belonging to D which were taken by x, when Y was having internal issues. Remember, Indias so called claims on Aksai Chin starts from 1800's only with the entry of British in South Asia. Its unnecessary to be belligerant with China, what ever India already got in Kashmir or Ladakh is a bonus already. Resolving the border amicably by accepting the current one would be the saner decision on India's part, anything else is just greediness.

[@srikanthshastry4546]

Sir, please stop reposting videos from 5 years ago. Please listen to your audience

[@vimalkumar3815]

We lost these area.. Due to poor.. Administration.. 😢

[@Life.is.a.library]

Everything is fine except the map of J&K in the starting of the episode. On the upper side it says POK, which is factually correct, but just below the poonch Azad Kashmir is written. Goverment of India can take action against theprint bcs of that. Dont you afraid shekhar 😂

[@dgdilipdgdilip2959]

Shekhar, don’t be so shameless by calling addressing India and Kashmir. They both are same for us . Should be for you as well. But looks like fresh funds have arrived from China

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Kashmir is a colony of the Hindurashtra Bharat.

[@dgdilipdgdilip2959]

@@hawkingdawking4572 replace word colony with Mukut. Everything else is right

[@hawkingdawking4572]

@@dgdilipdgdilip2959 What is a Mukut? Property?

[@wokeymcwokeface1974]

The British had no authority to give it away to Pakistan. GB belonged to Kashmiri kingdom, which has acceded to India.

[@mruthyunjayasiddalingaiah7489]

Namaste 🙏Jai Shree Ganesh, Jai Sia Ram🏹 Har Har Mahadev 🔱 🌺🙏 Vande Maataram 🇮🇳🙏Jai Bharat Maata 🇮🇳🙏Satyameva Jayate👍🙏Embracing Sanatana Dharma is the only solution for Global Peaceful coexistence🔱🙏

[@user-lo2ee4oo7z]

You are deliberately misguiding . It was nehru who delayed accession treaty because he wanted major role for sheikh abudullah and diminished role of maharaja. Maharaja was forced out of j&k by nehru + abudullah gang and later death of shama prasad mukherjee

[@foodnetwork4309]

Why repost old videos

[@BRNavalgund]

Oldest😢

[@vishnumohannair8506]

Never knew the history of Pak claim on GB. By our on logic pakistan does seem to have somewhat of a claim on GB

[@mg.f.9023]

China has emerged as the biggest creditor to developing countries in the past decade as the part of Xi’s Belt and Road Initiative which focused mainly on Chinese built infrastructure. Loans to countries including Pakistan 26.6 Billion $ Sri Lanka 8.7 Billion $ Bangladesh 6.1 Billion$ Africa 55+ Billion $

[@HafiZzZzZz]

China helping countries out there to build up their infrastructure

[@mohitanand1844]

China is a minerally rich one party one polity nation .we have thousands of ethnicities here

[@srujithreddy335]

​@@HafiZzZzZzall those countries are bankrupt

[@srujithreddy335]

Of course China is but it doesn't have oil. A country like the USSR is a giant which broke.​@@mohitanand1844

[@HafiZzZzZz]

@@srujithreddy335 Thanks to World Bank and IMF where India is a major share holder. Loan shark India

[@kallachi729]

SG, Buddhism, before 300 BCE, preached that War is essential for peace, but only as the very last resort…. Just saying. Tailpiece: Are we at times over glorifying ordinary people who were mere products of circumstance, overlooking there monumental failures? Again, just asking

[@johnkite8576]

Making bollywood movies spread hate against Kashmir should be stopped as it only benefits bjp and situation will lead worsen...

[@user-gr5fr9cx5o]

China was in same situation, how did Chinese managed to get everything back except Taiwan. Our leadership was weak and not cunning, that’s fact. We would have taken it back in 1971.

[@kpdwivedi1672]

In 1947 our political leadership lacked strong will power. THE BRITISH ARMY CHIEF COULD have been overruled/bypassed to achieve important political objectives. Pak army chief was also British but it bypassed him to send irregular into Kashmir. Left to nehru, he would not have sent indian army into Kashmir. The best thing would have been for ndhru to call next rung of our army leadership for advice and set political objectives in front of them and discussed its feasibility. Dir of ops would have given unbiased advice. It was indeed nehru's failure and incompetence. In 1962 war he appointed a supply core General Kaul to fight in NEFA. Sheer foolishness!!!

[@luvmite2758]

Actually we could have settled the issue by acquiring the whole india

[@PhotonShower]

Then that would be akhand bharath

[@luvmite2758]

@Shower akhand bharat under the flag of Pakistan

[@PhotonShower]

@@luvmite2758 Pakistan is just a temporary arrangement that clown jinnah made.. Pakistan never existed... But bharath or india has existed for 40,000 years..and your hindu forefathers will slap you for cutting this country that they loved and converting into a foreign religion

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Chaganda Bharat is a wet dream. There was no Bharat before 19th century.

[@anildamle1154]

Now it seems Shekhar's Pakistani Indian Punjabi brotherhood seems to be waning out. 🤣🤣. Nowadays he says Pakistan cannot be trusted. Why such a huge change in stance? something is fishy.😃😃

[@jestfuldemigod]

Just a minor Nitpick, Indira isnt a godess, but a God (male) , or king of Devas.

[@mapa9456]

Sir, stand next to the map and explain clearly....

[@qamarhassan936]

If India is the world's largest democracy then why don't they let the Kashmiri people practice their democratic right by letting them choose what they want. Why doesn't India organize a referendum in Kashmir in a neutral setting?

[@tejesheconomics4072]

Our constitution doesn’t allow this….Sucession is a crime by constitution

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Pakistan is the actual India with Indus river. Bharat is a Hindu wannabe empire which is keen on keeping Kashmir as a colonial subject. Democracy doesn't negate the colonial mindset.

[@TamBramThankyouMam]

If Pakistan is an islamic democracy, why don't you let the people of Balochistan and KP choose what they want?

[@qamarhassan936]

@@TamBramThankyouMam Pakistan is neither an Islamic country nor a democracy and secondly the liberations voices in Balochistan do not represent the whole Baloch province and the proof for that is we don't have to deploy hundreds of thousands troops in Balochistan to suppress the separation struggle (like India has to do in Kashmir) and there is no separation struggle in KPK at all.

[@TamBramThankyouMam]

@@qamarhassan936 Looks like you’ve grown up on a steady diet of your establishment’s kool aid.

[@joal9235]

We want to eat beef, not worship it like idiots.

[@dilrajkaur3281]

Can you make this in Hindi too

[@enerzy27]

All of it shall be India

[@mg.f.9023]

“Na koi wahan hamari seema mein ghus aaya hai, na hi koi ghusa hua hai,..

[@yesb4258]

Nehru is one of the main candidates for all these border troubles.

[@realityspeaking7279]

Aakhir kahana kya chahte ho

[@BRNavalgund]

To see pak as developed country😂

[@nafeesahnaf2387]

Free Kashmir

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

Come and set your mother free. She is having fun with me. 😂

[@nafeesahnaf2387]

@@Maverick-zo4kc your mother is also with me and Iam having a lot of fun thanks

[@PhotonShower]

Dont worry..in 5 years even pak will be part of india..then we all can live happily in akhand bharath

[@MrKrizzer]

Yes definitely. Bharat would make sure to free Kashmir that is occupied by Pak.

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

@@PhotonShower Not at all. We do not want additional 25 crore radical Islamists to become Indian citizens. We already have enough in our country.

[@DDD-jg9pc]

Trust you to complicate every shit. Definition is much simpler. Mutually agreed is Boundary. Disputed is Line of Control. Active dispute is Line of Actual Control.

[@mruthyunjayasiddalingaiah7489]

🇮🇳 Modiji is an unique and the most unpredictable visionary dynamic selfless leader & even Chanukya would have failed under prevailing Geopolitical situation both in Global and as well in Bharat(Guided by Dovel, Jaiashankar,Gadkhari,Shaw & Rajanath)🙏🇮🇳 Modi Hi Toh Mumkin Hi 👌👌👌🙏

[@kushagrashah4160]

I thought we lost Aksai chin in 1962 war... but for godsake it was due to our own negligence. Thanks for opening our eyes. Nehru was a bigger idiot then I thought

[@learntechbasics]

India never had Aksai Chin just like POK. India was never able to fight and conquer it. Assume you had a kingdom. You lost a major part of it to your enemies and you came running to me to annex whatever is remaining to save your ass. What did I really get? Whatever remained & not the entire Kingdom. I need to go & fight to conquer the region again which I could not in the past nor can I in the present or in the future.

[@yaqootmir6761]

You cannot trust pakistan? Look who is talking 😂

[@BRNavalgund]

😂😮

[@sokikrong2649]

For the sake of the hairs remaining in your head please hire a video editor.

[@tamsolutions6377]

Salient truth.. at times unpalatable, but such is history.. something which ignoramus are blissfully unaware of!

[@punnavanamsubbiah7434]

Day, hours or weeks will not end comments about. Nehru. Talking such old unsettled and in the world of such. Conflicts where there is no sensible political head to solve conflicts solutions what HM speech will do? It is nothing but a murmur thro print by a government thro SG who self certifies himself but a journalist??

[@Wearethebossofupsc]

I believe in third term of modi gov try to take pok.

[@sahibzadashah4440]

India’s fantasy of invading remainder of the old J&K is possibly feasible in the coming years. Pakistan’s army which has lost all support of its citizens, would love for India to start the adventure soon . In Pakistan, all will be forgotten and the people will rally behind the unpopular generals. There is no other scenario that is better for the army brass. I am surprised that they haven’t taken a “ punga” themselves. They must love Amit Shah for his pronouncements.

[@ChoudharyFaizan007]

😂😂😂😂

[@dtzcom1933]

You have shown kashmir as if it is not part of india bad

[@SgrSgh-kk8bc]

Very ill informed comments of genesis of Aksai Chin border issue!!

[@jaintushartj8]

Excellent explanation but imho you need to get a better editor. you can't expect your audience to visualize the map with you hand wavy imagination.😆

[@shariatullahsiddiqi3256]

Both the Indian and Pakistani held Kashmir should be united and give independence. Independent Kashmir is the only permanent solution for peace in the sub-continent.

[@sanjaypawar356]

isne khudke ma ko ,,,,,,da hai

[@amarndeepbamra3137]

NEHRU WAS A FOOL MODI IS GREAT

[@kaushlendratripathi7984]

This episode appears to have a lot more opinion versus facts.

[@vvsnmurty7564]

Nothing new

[@rajugoborvas8964]

As usual very bad conclusion

[@dtzcom1933]

Bad for you your show must close bad bad

[@lochandp1]

Free Islamic packistan

[@rizwanhussain645]

Bharat is an historical outsider to this area, it has only brought misery to all.

[@shashamnk2525]

While you might be right about the plight of regular Kashmiris , and the problems they face , calling India and outsider to the region is factually incorrect, it is important to read all kinds of Historical documents to get the accurate picture just reading lopsided pieces of propaganda doesn't tell you the reality.

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

Kashmir is India 🇮🇳 Balochistan is not Pakistan

[@mohitanand1844]

Gupta empire will never go awag

[@shashamnk2525]

@@Maverick-zo4kc okay, enough with you guys, the IT cell keeps on going 24x7 is it?

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

@@shashamnk2525 Pakistani Abdul puncture wala spotted 😂

[@chethan2311]

Another shekar Gupta anti national CTC

[@ravindraharsoor3460]

This confirms that this guy Shekhar is a classic anti-India. His version of history doesn’t hold the truth when it is examined against the historic documentation. This has to be downloaded and kept as a proof of his treachery

[@IndianArma]

Tell us the truth my friend

[@sashinair1545]

What makes you believe that your version of history is the correct one ?

[@sandg507]

Kuch bhi😂😂

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Anti-Bharat you might say. He can't keep the Bharat Hindurashtra propaganda on an international platform like KZbin. Your delusional fake history narrative only works in your state sponsored religious TV channels.

[@BRNavalgund]

💯

[@LBW-SAB]

OLD DUEL MINDED JOURNALIST ?? GO SANDESH KHALI GO