Unity vs Unreal | Graphics Comparison 2021

[@SpeedTutor]

EVERYONE!!! Is there UNITY in something UNREAL? ;) 🔥UNITY SAVINGS: bit.ly/UnitySalesHub 🔥SpeedTutor Unity Store: bit.ly/STUnityStorePuzzlePacks 🔥HUMBLE SAVINGS: bit.ly/HumbleBundleDeals

[@Futureblur]

I had everything right except number 3... I'm honestly surprised that Unity can achieve these graphics as well!

[@SpeedTutor]

It's an amazing thing, especially when everyone can be so surprised about it. Maybe you can create something just as good? :P

[@2killnspray9]

You take the "Un" of from Unreal and from Unity it becomes Real•ity It's probably not a coincidence!

[@byicee5059]

i could tell which ones were which. Unreal just has a certain rendering style that's instantly recognizable for me. I did prefer the Unity scenes personally though. Good video!

[@SpeedTutor]

I actually had a harder time myself as the gap has become a little closer, I think it's great talented people either side of the fence that create the awesome work! Thanks for watching! :)

[@maritimesoul]

Funny you mentioned that, I don't really game at all and have just seen a few graphics demos on youtube but still could pick out every unreal scene. I think it comes down to shadow rendering instead of light rendering where unreal shine, Unity has a much better realism to it I found

[@bebohk]

I watched the first three videos and didn't get a single one right 🤦😆

[@vigosaurus4665]

@@maritimesoul Unity kind of gives that crisp look of realism, while unreal is giving more smooth-like graphics. Still both of them great but i'd still prefer unity for archviz like the first one. It's just feels more natural.

[@Dr.Fluffles]

Absolutely blown away at how far Unity has come. I love it.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you're exactly right! How long have you been using it?

[@Dr.Fluffles]

@@SpeedTutor Only on and off experimenting over the last couple of years. Haven't made a full project myself yet, but have been keeping up with development and seeing what people create

[@SpeedTutor]

I think that's one of the best ways to do it, unless you're like me and forget how to code after a week of not doing it! :P

[@Chris_t0]

It hasn't come far, running this shit in unity is very heavy work and takes 5x longer than doing it unreal. ANYTHING is possible with time. Personally I work in Unity, I get jealous of how unreal looks default good but I make it up with very incredibly fast development

[@shitshow_1]

@@SpeedTutor lol, you are my kinda guy

[@amrsaleh9954]

You have to imagine the amount of work spent on these scenes. amazing... I couldnt tell which from which. and I've been using Unity for 4 years now.

[@SpeedTutor]

It just shows what some people can make with the appropriate skills, what are you working on? :)

[@amrsaleh9954]

@@SpeedTutor yeah, creating all these 3D models in this quality with adjusting the light, that requires a big team of 3d modelers. Im working on an app that I cant talk about using Unity. It is not just for games as many people think.

[@SpeedTutor]

Best of luck with your app! I hope its just as awesome!

[@mintesnotmelese7912]

@@amrsaleh9954 I have made an online Geography Quiz, Calculator, and Math Quiz game with Unity. What I love about Unity is you can make a non-game/interactive app.

[@hiddenvoid]

I see no difference. Both engines in the right hands can make awesome stuff.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you summed it up beautifully! That's exactly the way you need to look at it. Anything in the hands of true craftmanship can be turned into a masterpeice!

[@SacWebDeveloper]

The rain caustics on the windows looks absolutely amazing and outright like real life in 6, I'm glad the effect was created with my favorite engine. That scene particularly looked like someone actually walking around with a video camera, I would have been fooled if it were on TV.

[@SpeedTutor]

I completely agree, some of these might have caught me out too! It's some amazing work by some incredibly talented developers! :) Thanks for coming along to watch.

[@imDanoush]

Wow! Been using Unity for a hot minute, though this video surprised me. Both are great engines, Unity is a beast on the hands of skilled game devs.

[@SpeedTutor]

You're exactly right! Some developers can make truly epic things, on all levels. What are you working on? :)

[@imDanoush]

@@SpeedTutor This one: kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKabkpWJqMSLptU . All the best! :)

[@EpicGamer63637]

Ohhhhhh man, I have no words..... I use unity everyday and could not tell the difference.... I guess now both engines have come so far, that now it's only upto the level of production of the project.....

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you're exactly right! If you've got the right skills, it can be a great mix. You can do it with your eyes closed, I bet! :P

[@sps014]

Wow Unity in proper hands can be as amazing as Unreal. Great video

[@SpeedTutor]

I completely agree, it's truly inspiring that such amazing developers can do! :)

[@-jrstudio6137]

1,2 ,6is unity for sure. I recognize those furnitures from archiviz package.

[@SpeedTutor]

You're close but not 100% correct, results at the end of the video! ;)

[@sooiv3572]

This was the most useful video comparing unity and unreal. Although there are some differences, it is difficult to tell the two engines apart unless you look carefully.

[@SpeedTutor]

What do you think the biggest differences are?

[@sooiv3572]

@@SpeedTutor If I hadn't told you the correct answer, I wouldn't have guessed it correctly. I think the difference between the two engines is the way the light spreads. Based on the video alone, I prefer Unity more.

[@randomcat4344]

Ok so idk if anyone else agrees with me about this but I think unity is looks for the inside of buildings and I think unreal looks better with nature

[@SpeedTutor]

You might be right, Unreal can have a nice transition between indoor and outdoor environments but in Unity I'm not sure if this is as easily achieved.

[@berdt4870]

03:40 damn i got inspired by that lamp above the pool table, thanks!

[@SpeedTutor]

That's awesome! I'm glad you're feeling inspired!

[@impheris]

1 - Unity 2 - Unreal ez (the blur on the roof is very obvious, that lumen effect) 3 - i think is Unity Because the bad use of chromatic aberration (very popular on unity users) 4- Unity 5 - IDK maybe Unreal 6 - Unity 7 - mmm Unreal? OMFG i have the one eyes, i spot every video, fuck yeah...

[@SpeedTutor]

You've got a good eye! You should be a Unity vs Unreal investigator for a profession! :P

[@nel9954]

It seems as if the Unreal scenes have a slight blur to them. Maybe it's the bright light and the white models? Unity seems to be able to handle lighting better, but I would like to see some darker scenes for comparison too!

[@SpeedTutor]

I think darker scenes would be interesting! Well lit scenes always look the best due to bounced lighting but you make some good points! :)

[@damaomiX]

Because Unreal use TAA (temporal anti-aliasing).

[@occularmalice]

Well I'm shocked. I use Unity every day and I only got 1 right (#4) and rest totally opposite to what they were. I was sure the Unity scenes were Unreal and vice versa. Tells me Unity seems to have come a long way with realistic rendering as I thought I could tell the difference (or I'm a complete git and have no idea what I'm doing, that's always a possibility).

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, don't put yourself down. I think it really depends on what you have direct experience in but anything in the hands of skilled developers in a particular task can achieve amazing results. Not everyone has the skills or need for such realistic things in either engine, needless to say. It doesn't mean it's achieved easily anyway! The journey of GameDev is about improvement so it's good to know that you have lots of power at your fingertips! :)

[@occularmalice]

@@SpeedTutor Totally agreed. I stick to 2D games as that's what I'm good at and "dabble" in 3D but by no means can achieve anything other than following lighting tutorials or using 3D assets. It's amazing what some people can do with the tools and the toolset gets better and better every day. This shows, to me at least, the gap between the two is can be narrowed when in the hands of some skilled people.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you do what you're most confident with and if that's 2D, that's great. I think it lends itself to a single developer and such. As with many things in game development, there's so many elements to each part. Adding 3D, UVMapping, texturing, rigs, animations to the mix - It can make life complicated but you keep going and never stop!

[@GameDev1]

May I ask what you used as camera in UE? With the zoom effect and such.

[@SpeedTutor]

Some of these were built into the assets, so I couldn't tell you what it was. Sorry about that!

[@michalrv3066]

Great looking scenes! I couldn't tell a difference but it would be even better to see how each engine performs in terms of FPS.

[@SpeedTutor]

They most likely perform pretty well because most of them used baked lighting! :)

[@michalrv3066]

@@SpeedTutor ach, makes sense. Thanks for the update :)

[@zelo89]

Guessed all right, but i basically cheated.. the 1st person camera behaviour is a dead giveaway. Also it seems like there is a bit of TAA trail on all unreal footage, but tbh i'm not surprised both look extremely good and similar.

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, dammit. Have to try better next time to trick the eagle eyed viewers! :P

[@DamonPowell-s5v]

@SpeedTutor Loved this, got lots wrong lol XD. Could you share performance stats? Stuck in the middle between both.

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, which ones did you get wrong?

[@DamonPowell-s5v]

@@SpeedTutor Most, I cant remember, by any chance do you have anything on performance

[@behrampatel3563]

It doesn't matter. Just look at how far Real Time has come since 2013 (when VR reemerged ). The future has so much potential. Cheers and thanks for the video. b

[@SpeedTutor]

You're exactly right and it's an amazing achievement! Thanks for coming along to watch! :)

[@snowboyken]

Appreciated your sharing! This help me alot After more investigation and watch more result on both engine, I can easily identify them. Unity lighting makes the environment look more realistic, also the color tone, the motion quality on shadow are very smooth. Unreal look more blury and lower resolution and the color look like more gamming tone. But i doubt that it is not in the same level, e.g look like some of the output res and texture are in 4K some is not. I have an idea , if it is possible to have specialist on both side to make an optimized version until they think it cannot be improve any more, then compare and get the review from both specialist for which section they think the engine cannot satisfy them but other side did better result. I think that would be so interesting! :D

[@SpeedTutor]

I think that's a fair observation. Maybe you could become the specialist you're looking for? :P

[@jasontaylor2142]

Best video showcasing Unity vs Unreal I've seen yet! I use both Unity and Unreal but I prefer Unity and this video really shows off Unity as a legit option for AAA graphics. Thanks

[@7of9]

Went in thinking Unreal was going to be the best, but looks like they are both potentially equally good.

[@SpeedTutor]

Everything can be surprising in life! :) How many did you get right?

[@rataman098]

Not by far, these comparisons are made specifically to make Unity look better than it really is. Closed interiors with pre baked lights, Unreal can do much more. That's why I don't generally like these kind of videos.

[@renebarrow.virtualreality]

I've always assumed that Unreal = Better Photorealism. The only ones I didn't like were number 2 and number 5 because it felt a bit blurry when turning. Based on this video, I got pretty much everything wrong except number 7. This video has proved that I really don't know anything after all.

[@SpeedTutor]

I suppose it's good to get expectations adjusted, even in this small way. It allows you to see that amazing things can always be achieved by absolutely amazing creators! :) Thanks for coming to check this out.

[@Ced3kGama]

I can tell because of the camera controller lol

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, what gives it away?

[@makramboukaiz3303]

the engine here is real-life, cuz dude it looks so realistic 😂

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, I wish my house looked like these! :D

[@michuXYZ]

Holy shit... Remember that unity started as 3d game engine for browser games

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, humble beginnings!

[@antdx316]

lol at adding the gimbal roll to the 3D

[@carlosarangoVFX]

Unity won with this one 6:51 , tho.. a Demo from Quixel in unreal is King so far. TOUGH PICK!

[@SpeedTutor]

I completely agree, it's a very touch choice but that's a good choice to have! :)

[@sirus312]

That’s insane, I thought the same thing. In love with it

[@MEGA_TREE]

I like the Unity

[@SpeedTutor]

I feel as if your username gives it away! :P

[@lemon777r]

Its a trick question. The answer is its all camera recorded footage

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, real life doesn't look that good! :P

[@lowkeygaming4716]

Wow the Unity renders are so realistic for me.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think so too, which was your favourite?

[@lowkeygaming4716]

@@SpeedTutor I personally like Unity because I prefer to study C# than C++

[@MEGA_TREE]

Technically, both are 100% equal and differ only in terms of optimization methods ... Optimization in Unity has a better result than Unreal

[@DVPPV]

Why? What about the Nanite system in UE5? If it were in Unity, we wouldn't even think about optimization.

[@vladkostin7557]

Unity dev for 11 years here. I guessed wrong every single one except three of them that I already knew XD

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, I got you! Thanks for coming along to watch. :P Just shows that there is always more to learn. :)

[@xavierchavezm.3240]

I need a photorealism for archviz course using Unity, can you recommend where can i find a course like that. Thanks

[@SpeedTutor]

I don't think it really exists, sadly. Other than taking a look on Udemy or my channel has a realistic graphics tutorial.

[@homerbuntin4751]

This was my first time comparing the 2 platforms and I was actually able to tell the difference between the two. They both look absolutely amazing, but in my opinion Unreal does a better job when it comes to motion, particularly in the case of light, shadows, and reflections movement. Unity looks extremely picturesque, almost to the point that it makes be feel like nothing is supposed to be interactive. I also felt the rain scene could have been rendered better on Unreal when the water it the ground. I was watching the tiny splashes and noticed that as soon as they hit the ground the event was over. The individual droplets didn't accumulate into a puddle like they would in real life. Maybe I'm looking for a bit too much in terms of realism, but that small detail is why I was able to tell the difference.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you're right, the small nuances make all the difference sometimes but what you suggestion isn't directly in the scope of these projects, nor in many game projects as it requires a fairly custom solution. I think you're very right on them being just slightly away from real life but they do a great job. Thanks for coming to watch! :)

[@yuguojiang9408]

Wow, the third one is so beautiful

[@SpeedTutor]

I completely agree! :D

[@etgmaster44]

I can easily quess Unity, with the straightforward lighting and the clarity of textures.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you're a smart man!

[@Tryste]

The chromatic aberration gave Unity away hahahah

[@SpeedTutor]

This is the exact reason I never use Chromatic Aberration! Haha.

[@2killnspray9]

You take the "Un" off from Unreal and from Unity it becomes Real•ity It's probably not a coincidence!

[@SpeedTutor]

You're a genius! Which one was your favourite?

[@2killnspray9]

@@SpeedTutor hard to tell, both are amazing!

[@shitshow_1]

It's impossible if Unity didn't introduced HDRP.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you'd be surprised at the quality that was achievable with SRP.

[@apersunthathasaridiculousl1890]

my guesses 1: unreal 2: unity 3: unreal 4:unity 5: unreal 6: unreal 7: unity

[@SpeedTutor]

Were you right? Haha.

[@apersunthathasaridiculousl1890]

@@SpeedTutor no… not one bit

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha! It's all the fun of trying! :P

[@AfryMark]

Wow ! What a masterpiece. This is what you call real artists. May I ask, did you use blender then import the project into unity first, or model it straightaway in unity ? I’m curious..

[@SpeedTutor]

Most of these will have been made using a 3D modelling program, Substance painter for texturing and then imported and put together in Unity / Unreal.

[@AfryMark]

@@SpeedTutor I read some comments saying that the lighting method used is baked lighting. Is it baked before it is imported to unreal/unity (in blender) or baked straight in unreal/unity ?

[@SpeedTutor]

@@AfryMark It will be baked within the engine, they will only use the 3D program for creating and authoring the 3D models! :)

[@AfryMark]

@@SpeedTutor thanks for the answer appreciate it man

[@snowboyken]

@@SpeedTutor Thanks for the comparison, I would like to know is it a fair comparison due to there are different ways and technique/skills for rendering and optimizing

[@ehaviv]

Unity looks better!! I got all my guesses wrong...

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, I'm glad you came along and gave it a go! :P Which was your favourite?

[@ehaviv]

@@SpeedTutor 1 , 3 && 6

[@oneiroschannel]

I guessed all of them :D

[@SpeedTutor]

You might have cheated...

[@ralphsayah2453]

@@SpeedTutor lol

[@xXBrutus67Xx]

Got 2 wrong, i had a doubt on number 6, and number 7 looked like Unity for me 😐

[@SpeedTutor]

You did pretty well but do you think it surprised you?

[@xXBrutus67Xx]

​@@SpeedTutor Pretty surprised by Unity because a few years back i could tell on which game engine it was made; now it's way harder to guess

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, well there you go! :) Thanks for watching it, my friend! :) Now time for you to create something and shock everyone else? :P

[@marciopereira1726]

my God...is there any course that teaches creating this such good archviz in unity? please

[@SpeedTutor]

I do have a tutorial on realistic lighting in Unity, on my channel and also have some tips from developers of the "ArchVizPro" packs (If you search those in my channel too).

[@MrSquishedsquashed]

What is the point in something like this when 90% of everything is baked and the other 10% is envmap reflections... It hardly shows the capability of a realtime rendering engine at all, functionally the scenes are just 3d pictures.

[@SpeedTutor]

Irrespective of whether these projects are baked or not, it still shows a high level of quality which can be achieved. Just the same as you would if you did an ArchViz piece in VRay or similar but in these cases you can walk around, in VR, with interactions and in some cases use real-time effects. :)

[@MrSquishedsquashed]

@@SpeedTutor Perhaps if the video were intended to be an artist comparison that would mean something. However we both know this is not a meaningful 'Unity vs Unreal | Graphics Comparison'. You might as well be using pre-rendered cut-scenes or FMV cutscenes for that matter.

[@xlexkin]

Sadly didn't tell which is which. People will assume Unreal graphic = Unity graphic

[@SpeedTutor]

At the end of the video, I list which one is which! :)

[@raikiriramen6257]

You can tell which is unreal by the bad rendering. When you move the camera, an instant blur appears which hurts the eye. That's how you know it's the unreal engine

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, they do love their motion blur!

[@jpalmer999]

I got 1/7 right. My answers were: UE, UN, UE, UE, UE, UE, UN. In my defence I had switched for the most part to unreal by the time the new rendering types were coming into unity.

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, at least you gave it a good go! Unity has been able to reach a decent level for some years but you can just push it a little further with HDRP. Why did you make the switch?

[@jpalmer999]

@@SpeedTutor There are a few reasons: 1) BSP geometry makes it very easy to block out levels. 2) Free assets given out each month 3) Free access to Quixel Megascans 4) Free access to Meta Humans 5) UE5 lighting and poly count :P That being said, I still use unity for 2d games occasionally.

[@SpeedTutor]

How very dare you! You've betrayed me. My heart and soul. Haha. Those are some awesome reasons! Have you been using much UE5?

[@jpalmer999]

@@SpeedTutor I've been mostly messing around in it, the content drawer is a very useful feature and easily overlooked over the flashier additions. In regards to unity though, I did start a small side project that is ludicrously inefficient. I'm trying to make a full 3d game using nothing but c# code. Only in the menu design currently, but pretty fun to work everything out and I'm learning a fair amount as well while doing it. Been watching your videos since your unity 5 javascript days. The one I remember most is the simple lightning effect by turning a light on and off.

[@SpeedTutor]

That's pretty amazing! And why did you decide to create a game only using code? To challenge yourself and make something you' haven't seen before? It sounds pretty awesome needless to say. Thanks for being with me for so long, I will admit that one was a classy, timeless tutorial! Haha. It is awful listening back to some of my older tutorials! :S

[@NehezTheWrackful]

Now compare UE5 and Unity using only realtime light :)

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, that's not fair!

[@michaelsills8038]

I am renovating a portion of my house and want to use Unity or Unreal to model it (obviously not to this standard) anyone know which would be better? (Ideally I’d want to use this to make mock ups and don’t expect anything close to the quality of the lighting and set ups in this video)

[@SpeedTutor]

That's very dependent on which game engine you're most comfortable with using, either could work for you. I think overall, if you have some experience - Unreal will yield faster results and faster lighting but stick with Unity if you're most comfortable with it. In either case, highly skilled individuals worked on both. :)

[@XP_HUNTER7]

I guessed and every single one was correct

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, you should do the lottery next! :P Lets see if you can win big.

[@altontoni5436]

the level of detail....... i want to cry

[@SpeedTutor]

Tears of joy, or tears of sadness? That's the question! Haha.

[@SnakeEngine]

Unity looks more real, and UE4 looks unreal.

[@SpeedTutor]

I see what you did there, very creative! :P

[@nocultist7050]

Proves old truth. It's never the engine's fault.

[@lewis1180]

Unity looks more realistic. Unreal looks more like a video game.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think that's the hope when anyone creates this type of thing! :)

[@CreateDefaultSubobject]

All were correct except for number 6. As many say, Unity has come a long way, but it's fundamentally different from Unreal. It is not a situation where the engine is being used to its maximum right now. Unity is obviously more productive, but I can't agree that the two engines have similar performance levels. Among the projects made with Unity, it seems that the only high quality projects are the ones they made. You will have to pay a lot of money to access the engine source. If I'm wrong, try make the Unreal 5 demo project in Unity. When I look at the games that are actually being developed, no games with aaa graphics made with Unity have been developed, and when they are asked this question, they blur the point like 'graphics aren't everything'. It is true that Unreal has been suitable for large companies, but recently, it is helping small companies or solo dev in various ways by releasing high-quality assets and Quixel Megascans for free to individuals. Their efforts should not be ignored. For most projects that don't require extreme performance, looking at a static mesh can be difficult to tell apart, but when you look at the VFX you'll notice in seconds. They claim that they can achieve the same level of performance with a more complex process and effort but it's hard to admit that this is practically impossible, given that no such game has ever been developed. I also like Unity. There are so many fun games made with Unity. There's no reason to fall in love with the engine. I just want to say that it serves a different purpose.

[@SpeedTutor]

You've got a keen eye, I think you're right. It takes knowledge either side of the fence to get the best out of either engine. I think it's just fantastic that the amazing developers can do such great work! :)

[@snowboyken]

I am having similar thought and I am looking for benefits to ArchViz in Unreal or Unity, decided to stick with by picture quality and money if I would like to create demo

[@RubenGoMoRadioboyPlus]

Wow, I guessed all of them right 😶

[@SpeedTutor]

You're an absolute hero! :P

[@llIIllIlIIllX_XIillIIllIIllIll]

in conclusion, Unity is slightly better despite all the hips around the new unreal.

[@SpeedTutor]

Maybe when people have enough time to break into Unreal Engine 5, we might well see a bigger difference but only time will tell! :)

[@llIIllIlIIllX_XIillIIllIIllIll]

@@SpeedTutor unreal was slightly lagging though, either the scene was not configured correctly or there is something fundamentally wrong with scenes/engine.

[@SpeedTutor]

It may have just been an issue with the recording rather than the projects themselves but making it run smoothly is a massive job!

[@llIIllIlIIllX_XIillIIllIIllIll]

@@SpeedTutor wait, if it was an issue with the recording only, how come only the unreal simulations have this issue? It should have been with both. I think maybe unreal might need some performance update. But they're both almost as good, only the unreal simulations are a bit jittery.

[@panteleymonschekochikhin-k1978]

I almost always guess unity because stuff in it has that white tint to it idk how to describe, like at 1:00 on the blanket

[@SpeedTutor]

Maybe being over exposed?

[@EVE_ict]

I just want to see which of these catch my eyes. 1, 3, 6 are my favorite and I'm glad they are all from the same engine- Unity. Can't wait to learn it for the up-coming Metaverse world.

[@SpeedTutor]

You're absolutely right! I can't wait to see what the future holds either, thanks for watching! :)

[@deceptive_monkey]

Have a look at Bloktopia bro there building a metaverse on unity

[@SpeedTutor]

What does it mean? :o

[@vigosaurus4665]

I like the 1st one a lot too. It gives so much natural feel of a modern house for me.

[@kramproductions64]

If this is what gta 6 looks like , I’m scared

[@SpeedTutor]

It could be the game to do it! Easy wouldn't you say?

[@kramproductions64]

@@SpeedTutor you think rockstar could pull this off ?? If so I’m so excited for the game to release. Rdr2 was a beautifully made and that was 2018…

[@SpeedTutor]

I think the lighting and technology in both GTA V and RDR2 were really phenomenal, especially with large open world spaces. Although RDR was much more sparse. I don't think we'll see quality quite like this, especially if the games will run on older generation hardware. Never say never though! :)

[@MelvinVega]

I love both of them..

[@SpeedTutor]

That's the best way to be! :D

[@archanadevi2480]

It's his real home nice home and nice vlog .But why do you clickbait

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, I wish mine did look like that! :P

[@archanadevi2480]

@@SpeedTutor so that's effect

[@SpeedTutor]

It's all the magic of Unity and Unreal :D

[@archanadevi2480]

@@SpeedTutor so please upload a video making this.

[@Eduard0213-x7p]

Unity

[@ceyhunsamadov3200]

of course unity

[@SpeedTutor]

No question? :o

[@DayMoniakkEdits]

05:44 Unreal sliders 👀

[@SpeedTutor]

That's cheating!!!! :P

[@Futureblur]

Haha I tried hard to not focus on the UI for that exact same reason xD

[@SpeedTutor]

You two are as bad as each other! :P

[@garmadon-vo2yg]

Second one is unity

[@SpeedTutor]

Is it? :o

[@Basseloob]

Am with you second one is Unity

[@ElementIsland]

Well its not, results are at the end! ;)

[@stealthxg5045]

I'm gonna take a guess and say you think its Unity because of the fps. Well actually its Unreal and the 1st one was Unity.

[@Basseloob]

@@stealthxg5045 not just the fps. Also the graphics was really clear and awesome

[@pemituber926]

Yep, Unity best

[@ZaidA4K]

It's impossible how I got them right first time watching 👀

[@SpeedTutor]

You should do the lottery right now, or make a large bet because you're really lucky! :D

[@ZaidA4K]

@@SpeedTutor you won't believe this... I just won my first lottery!!!!!!!! WHAT!?

[@SpeedTutor]

@@ZaidA4K How much did you win? :o

[@ZaidA4K]

@@SpeedTutor two grand, baby!! At least I can pay most of my debts, lol.

[@LION303200]

1-3-6-7unity & unreal 2-4-5 I almost got it LOL

[@SpeedTutor]

Haha, not bad at all! :P Did I manage to trick you? :P

[@DanCreaMundos]

Well almost. I got 6 and 7 wrong but I was able to identify correctly 1 to 5. Both of them look amazing, but unity's lighting still looks a little more unrealistic compared to UE. For some reason unreal engine's lights look more dense and heavy, like they are actually casting the shadows.

[@SpeedTutor]

Unreal has always been superior in global illumination and post processing, I'm not sure it will ever be beaten but some of the things in Unity do look good!

[@DanCreaMundos]

@@SpeedTutorThey do indeed, unity has been improved a whole lot in the past years and it's kinda amazing by itself how much better it is now compared to even 5 years ago.

[@SpeedTutor]

@@DanCreaMundos Haha, I remember using Unity 4.3 and the horrors of it! :P So I completely understand. Who knows where we will be in another 5 years! If Unity don't make stupid business decisions!

[@DanCreaMundos]

@@SpeedTutor if they keep prioritizing game making and growing as an engine they will probably be even closer to UE by then. But if they start thinking with their wallets like so many others, well, they'll probably ruin it.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think it's difficult to say because they have expanded massively and I don't think they have clear goals in mind anymore, the slipping of the engine between 3 different pipelines really doesn't help. Haha. We shall see! :)

[@mubsdeveloper4523]

Unreal Engine

[@SpeedTutor]

To them all? :P

[@rataman098]

Haven't ever seen such a biased and tricky comparison to make Unity look good lmao

[@SpeedTutor]

Zero bias as I found these from creator of assets from both stores and I found a couple of extra exemplar examples from KZbin for Unreal. I of course could have given you technical demos but this isn't what the video was about. It's from developers making real-time visualisations that are perfectly achievable by an average developer.

[@lushen952]

Wow (2) was really bad and I thought it was unity. (1) looked like real life. You'll never have a valid comparison between unity and unreal because the shaders and lighting will be different no matter how much you try to match. It's really sad 99% of developers that want photorealism go to ue4. There's some seriously bad propaganda against unity - all unity games have anime/cartoons graphics.

[@SpeedTutor]

You're exactly right, I think it takes skill and expertise whichever side of the fence you end up sitting on. They say that Unreal does a better job out of the box and Unity has a much higher curve when it comes to achieving the quality. I think it just takes awesome people to make insanely good in either engine! :)

[@oozly9291]

The one thing that has bugged me from these showcases are that they are always interior shots or mostly, it’s much easier creating a realistic scene doing interiors. As shown with Unity demonstrating that it’s capable of beating Unreal engine with interiors at least. Unity starts to fall apart with environmental scenes as it’s lighting is not up to par with UE and there is a noticeable gap between the two. I wish there could be more videos and demonstrations comparing the two with environmental scenes, the only Unity environments that have genuinely impressed me and in my opinion looked better than most UE projects was Sakura Rabbits work, she’s possibly the most impressive Unity artist out there as far that I am aware.

[@SpeedTutor]

I think you're right but it's hard to make a side by side comparison in terms of environmental showcases because they don't always adhere to highest fidelity. Whereas the look at Visualisation is you know they're going for as close to realistic as the engines allow.

[@purringraven3648]

that's what I hate about unity vs unreal comparisons. We don't get to see which one is which I mean why can't we just get to know which one is unity and which one's unreal!!?

[@SpeedTutor]

You can see the options at the end, I've even added a timestamp for you. I just wanted to make a game out of it! :)

[@purringraven3648]

@@SpeedTutor oh thnx

[@vladkostin7557]

7 - disgusting AO X)

[@SpeedTutor]

AO? CRANK THAT SLIDER ALL THE WAY UPPP!!!

[@MEGA_TREE]

90% of the graphics are textures...

[@SpeedTutor]

That is very true but I think the technique of setting up lighting and post processing goes a long way! :)

[@serveladik]

Arch viz is all for unity, thats a fact So that video is only for newbies

[@SpeedTutor]

I'm not sure what you're trying to say? :) I think it's nice to inspire everyone that realistic environments can be created in both amazing engines.

[@serveladik]

@@SpeedTutor i mean that for newcommers it is But for me as junior, i clearly see difference and now what engine is:)

[@SpeedTutor]

I'd have to agree, how long have you been using the engine(s)?

[@serveladik]

@@SpeedTutor as a junior developer 4 month, as just learner over 1 year

[@arunachalpradesh399]

i am both unreal and unity user, the newbies watching the video must know that it takes double the amount of time in unity to match the same graphics ,which unreal do way faster. in unity you have to pass with hell lot of bugs ,trial error and time. whatever the best looking showcase like book of the dead or unity heretic are done by professional and pro experts. not some beginner or even intermediate, even the best looking unity game "escape of tarkov" its graphics can be easily matched by sample projects made by beginners in unreal engine. unreal is the future and many unity developer are switching to unreal , because how its less buggy and some work which unity will take one hour can easily be done in 15 minutes in unreal, i use unity only for mobile games. no other reason.

[@sirus312]

TLDR buy unity stonk?

[@dieice7124]

If you are going to do a comparison video, you need to indicate what you are showing, i'm not going to watch a 9 minute video not knowing what i'm looking at lol

[@SpeedTutor]

It's entirely your choice whether to watch it or not, I do mention at the start and in the description of what the video is about. It's just a look at some creations by the community and for everyone to play a little game of deciding which is Unity or which is Unreal! :)

[@dieice7124]

@@SpeedTutor Again, if you don't actually indicate which is which, it's really pointless to show this lol

[@SpeedTutor]

Again, as stated it would have spoiled the concept of the video. It was for the community to guess which engine the project was created in. If I'd have told everyone from the start, it would have been pointless, the results are at the end (as mentioned at the very beginning)

[@TheBlackbirdii]

lazy video

[@SpeedTutor]

You'd be surprised how long this actually took me to put together, haha.