US Ex-Visa Officer BRUTALLY HONEST on Indian Students Future & Immigration!

[@eyewaves...]

Great immigration officer ! Really down to earth and honest...

[@CluelessClicks]

17:49 We have a system where we don’t welcome people who want to come the right way but allow people to jump the wall.

[@tapashaviator]

that system has been designed carefully to promote human traff*** and cheap labour. It's all about what benefits the corporates.

[@wolfmangoland7972]

The Biden administration has permitted thousands of undocumented immigrants to enter the U.S. without restrictions, creating the impression that immigration laws are not being enforced. Meanwhile, immigration officers often deny visas to qualified applicants with legitimate reasons for visiting the U.S. and intending to return to their home countries.

[@izharkarim3537]

I applied in north Dakota state university twenty five years ago, when I went to the us. It's tuition and expenses were one of the lowest then.😊

[@vivek27789]

What was your major?

[@TheNikhilify]

Now where are you?

[@arshadali2312]

Still is one of the lowest. But it's a no-name school and ND has a very cold climate. No-one wants to go there.

[@legallyregarded]

And it shows...

[@RidleyHolmes-sr2tw]

Why go through all this hassle? Fly to Mexico and walk over the border. Done.

[@karthikpm9669]

😂😂😂

[@SJ-nu1ou]

Truth 😅

[@a-sk007]

This is absolutely best advice. Go for it, bro

[@RidleyHolmes-sr2tw]

@@a-sk007 The guy who cuts my lawn did. Now he is cutting 67 lawns. Not paying taxes and sending his money back to his country of origin. Only in America.

[@leekim8911]

😂lol

[@MrPharu500]

And let millions come through your borders, illegally!! We recently went to NY to attend a wedding of someone really close. In spite of having all the paperwork, we were asked a million and one questions. All was ok finally as it should have been but felt it was a waste of American resources!

[@jsryt6529]

Good 😂

[@WETALKINMEDIA]

Some people like easy targets....that's the main problem ur job should be to solve the real problems we don't have that anymore....your tint has two colors...don't u have bigger fish to fry

[@RattanLalHangloo]

If young Indians who r waiting for green card could b speedly given they could contribute to USA significantly.This is very truthful honest and brilliant interview the officer deserves all appreciation he is a gift of god to humanity and proud of America

[@Shelzastark]

His idea is great for the students..i am looking forward for taking help from his team in future.. thanks 👍

[@garv1177]

The amount of books in the background wow😮

[@bat__man__.w]

i ve graduated from in ohio state university now back in india working in a startup

[@badlav120]

Wow, my seniors say they will leave India saying it's a waste here . they want to enjoy their so-called luxurious life in foreign countries. I really admire Indians like you 👏 who want to bring change rather than criticize everything .

[@idkwhy77]

W❤❤

[@bat__man__.w]

@@badlav120 bro i agree they want good life but my motive is lets sacrifice our life work hard for our future generation so they can see a devloped india i know no one gonna remember me but in my heart and god both of us know it

[@hemendraravi4787]

@@badlav120 trust me if you want to dream big you are forced to leave india , want to buy a top notch laptop ? pay 2x the price in india, want to buy a luxurious car ? pay 2x the price. why should one sacrifice their dreams ? for a nation that denies them of their dreams ? or makes it twice as hard to achieve ?. its not their fault for having dreams, after all they teach you to dream high in schools. im not saying you should settle outside , but if you do i dont blame you. but those who come back to develop the country are thoes who sacrificed their dreams for the sake of their country. but they sadly dont get the respect they deserve.

[@iloveamerica4891]

@@hemendraravi4787 Yes Immigrate to America competition for ivy league for money is less and pay is much more, avoid all debt in America. Asian Americans are the highest-income, best-educated group in the U.S. South American spanish people now make up the largest share of recent immigrants. Make most of the time God has gifted you. Im comfortably living in America, I have money and I love to give back to America, time money food clothes, I have given back 250000 so far in my life. America is the most generous country in the history of the world.

[@AlbertSchmidt-u8i]

You always break down tough topics so well.

[@arshadali2312]

Honest and frank visa officer. Smart fellow. He's right about Harvard Yale Princeton -- the admissions process is deliberately opaque. Lots of legacy students. And money talks. MIT and CalTech are pure merit. Also, though he is honest and candid, he wouldn't be talking this open way if he still worked for the State Department -- it would probably cost him his job.

[@dushyantchaudhry4654]

Went for a tourist visa twice, got rejected. Went a third time, the exact same limited questions were asked and I was give the visa. There was no difference whatsoever. I was in the same job, traveling for the same reasons and the gap was barely 3 months. I travelled like a good disciplined tourist and came back to India within barely 10 days several times after that. I just never understood what the reasons for the first 2 rejections were.

[@user-fiF5ei8tyah]

It's very easy to understand though honesty is required. You probably look like one of the many people from poor countries with dark skin and a thick accent desperately trying to get into the US is why you were rejected twice during the first time. It got easier the next time because you actually did came back.

[@somefriend565]

Wow honest discussion especially about the point of view of the visa officer. The story about the medical visa denial being a death certificate was shocking. But the law seems simple dont give the officer any reason to beleive that one is going to immigrate to the us in a non immigrant category.

[@aceravi10]

Almost Every non immigrant category applicant wants to immigrate, who is getting fooled here - the law, the officer or the applicant? 😂

[@dPten]

Most importantly, your social media status. They will look at every online record of yours. This was something that was told to me by a professor in India, 10 years ago when I was applying for a visa after I got selected in a university abroad (not US). Given the kind of access they have now and also given the fact that American authorities spies on their own citizens, I can only wonder about the minute details they can know about you. Someone with zero social media record would theoretically have a better chance, after taking into account the other factors.

[@rajendramangalore7218]

One's own country is like a paradise! Why spending a lot on education abroad and coming back is not a good idea. Be faithful to one's motherland and serve it's humble citizens.

[@Kenneth.kwarteng]

Great guy, knowledgeable and clever. Interesting to know how minds work behind the curtain of an immigration office. Thanks Chris

[@MAGA1881USA]

Good job Chris. Thank you for your honest thoughts

[@jeanbaptiste-d4y]

Thank you for this video. I believe it's a must-watch before your VISA interview, as it summarizes the attitude of immigration officers very well

[@elkrutarth]

The guy is a straight Shooter, he reminds me about the Dutch directness. Many thanks and lots of love harnoor . 😊all the best❤🎉

[@vanisarada9886]

Stop going to countries who don’t want you. Stop giving importance to their universities.

[@abhaybrahmbhatt838]

Thank brother ,after one month I try for visa ,and i remember this information in my mind

[@CaptzaxTexas]

Work on your English proficiency and grammar first.

[@tinaalmeidam4479]

There was never a problem with this until the border issue happened damn sad. It should be a certain number of course but unfair or fair is beside the point. This guy's makes sense.

[@neoblackcyptron]

Finally, you have good content. This is important for Indian F1 students.

[@RishabhKumar-ir1pe]

Harnoor bhai aap bde lucky the apke time itna USA 🇺🇸 jana ke liye rush nhi tha jitna aaj rush aur complications hai 🙏

[@akshayganesh4144]

It’s because of no jobs in India but rapid growth of youth population

[@jsryt6529]

@@akshayganesh4144 salle jobs ni hai toh jo jare sb garib hai atleast 5/10 lakh jata or more hand money to settle there

[@TONIX-]

I had suffered from bad depression when my J1visa interview got rejected, coz i had put my effort and time for best hotel to find to do the training as well my money also got wasted for 1st attempt and also social fear too. it was very hard to return from that phase of rejection.

[@GigW]

Consider yourself lucky. I’ve seen many reports of J1 students working at hotels cleaning toilets and making beds with no opportunity of real training or cultural exchanges. They are treating J1s as cheap labor with not rights. Do yourself a favor and research the company/hotel you will be working for and how they treat J1s.

[@ib405]

Indian students should be able to build their own scilicon valley in India. If they build, America companies will go to India

[@latatha]

Watching your channel after a very long time. Glad to see you coming with this topic. Good information for the kids thinking of coming over.

[@supermastermind1732]

all i hear is "why is not india getting more free shit".

[@odynith9356]

Yup. So many Indians think they are entitled to what they want.

[@madhubabu3171]

Indian students should not be begging and worrying about immigration. Today we have plenty of opportunities in india. Unnecessary loans and burden on parents. Those who have money and get a visa can go and study.

[@praveenpayiran]

There is a reason people go abroad for studies you can only understand that only when you go abroad I did my studies abroad but within Asia it has opened a lot of options otherwise we're there but invisible and also helped me understand myself and what I wanted you will have a cleared view on life as a whole. It's more than just studies.

[@SioneFolau]

Learn from the Chinese

[@1pasupaty]

It's nit abt jobs a d eeki g out a living.its more to it.buying a house a car quality of ur shirt watch everything big bigger better........not possible here

[@Drganguli]

If the 214b immigrant intent rule is strictly applied very few people from any developing country will get the us non-immigrant visas like f1, h1, l1 etc. so stalls visa officers are being very nice and charitable…

[@somdebdas3591]

Superb ❤🎉 , thanks from bottom of my heart

[@overlord7096]

Highly intelligent and humble officer 😊

[@VenkatNaga-ls2gm]

Exactly. Immigration is just politicized differently. No one really will fix the system. Great officer.

[@awes868]

One question u missed is - his opinion on the H1B lottery! Is it fair OR not? And how can it be improved - may be wages and point based system. Many students who go to U.S. are still enduring from this unfair system of course taken advantage by IT consultancies from their own countries.

[@NoName-jz5re]

Same was in my mind . Picking people by lottery and denying refugees is ridiculus

[@4light26]

The books and pic of one of the greatest presidents in the background says a lot about the person.

[@bidishadutta2044]

Great insights. thank you 🙏

[@vj12343]

I tell anyone aspiring to study in the US - Please lower your expectations about a life after graduation here, be absolutely prepared financially and be ready to go back. This stress is not worth it and life in this country is getting increasingly difficult. Many of us are just stuck here.

[@murali5247]

Indians should study in China , Japan etc . China has the latest technology on almost everything.

[@grtinfulleffect8349]

See you there.

[@1897max]

The objective is to settle abroad and not to study . Nobody wants to settle in China or Japan.

[@1897max]

The objective is to settle abroad and not to study and nobody wants to settle in China or Japan.

[@aquilifergroup]

Yes, too many Indians in the USA. Go somewhere else. Please

[@deezeed2817]

@@1897max I went to Japan in 2019 and last year. In 2019 i didn't notice any Indians. In 2023 they very visible and some were even working.

[@Taeyangsmissingjacket]

34:45 maybe don’t drink and drive? If you do, take responsibility for your actions.

[@transplant-f3p]

Governments have laws that are enforced where convenient. I'll bet the Indians that graduate from one the worlds best schools for Computer Science do not have a problem. A foreigner with exceptional resumes will probably be end up working for a U.S. company.

[@soultravel8742]

Nothing ever changes with US immigration for Indians. It will take good 20 -25 years to become US citizens unless people marry locals.

[@ln7487]

That's not true, you can be a green card holder and US citizen from anywhere within 6 to 10 years. I got mine within 3 years as the skills were on demand.

[@braxtonshrianandan2438]

This Officer should make it HIS judgement on Indian Students.! The more he denies Indian Techs will make it more Difficult it will be for US Companies..! Also .. sometimes the LAW can be very UNFAIR..!

[@frezerkebe8164]

They are taken all the local IT jobs ....we have plenty IT expertise now but they keep bringing them

[@marcwalton9170]

Co panties started outsourcing from China and India anyway

[@tapaumakan]

Jobs should go to Americans. U.S. politicians, instead of focusing on countries thousands of miles away, should concentrate on limiting immigration, particularly from South Asia, as there are too many scammers are from this region. These immigrants are taking American jobs by filling American companies with their people, leading entire companies to continue recruiting primarily from India.

[@charmaine8512]

This is a fashion _ wanting to study abroad or really escaping to get a Western passport. Why feel like a criminal, study and explore opportunities where you are needed

[@indrarao9972]

With out citizenship checks how would we know who is voting!!

[@oma_gooner]

Students don't understand that these places like North Dakota State have extreme weather, and you need friends and car quickly, otherwise its gonna suck really! Education wise its ok, but life needs more and you are new and not ready for this lonely lifestyle!

[@braxtonshrianandan2438]

52 years ago.. I came on Scholarship because of the SPORT the University offered. If they asked why I chose the school .. my answer would NOT be sufficiently.. coz I would have said ..because the school/ University CHOSE me. ! So I very possibly could have been denied..!

[@aquilifergroup]

If you’re too dense to know how to answer that question then you deserve to be denied.

[@braxtonshrianandan2438]

Giving answers to someone who doesn't know his OWN states .. IS NOT a reason to deny a VISA .! That law to be discrete is a VERY irresponsible on the part of the officer. WHY ... because prejudice is imminent .

[@aquilifergroup]

Stop whinging

[@indrarao9972]

, just a speeding ticket in Texas will not affect visa. If you are drunk and speeding the you will be deported. The office is correct.

[@saravanana4294]

I had applied for MS in 1988 in US and australia and found the process so cumbersome without modern communication aids and costly application that i dropped halfway through as i felt that there is bias and they treat indian like beggars. I decided to stay back in India and joined premier scientific organisation and served the country for 33 years and indegenised so many technologies denied by western countries earlier. It is not worth the effort if you can find half worth job in India

[@iloveamerica4891]

I'll marry her to give US Citizenship after 2 years of living together if she is 25 years old in age or younger woman from any country. A healthy functioning woman as God made you, no drugs no tattoos no smoking no vaping, and in working order who is a helper to me. I am juggling other women so getting physical will be your decision and I have my requirements I will test you... step up

[@prashanthb6521]

You dont even realize that you are treading a dangerous path.

[@iloveamerica4891]

@@prashanthb6521 I know life is controlled by what I focus on. That's why I focus on success on where I want to go, not on fear. I know women have no principles and no loyalty women walk away when going gets tough.

[@DarkLord-pm1eg]

18:45 The fact that he called himself a horrible visa officer 💀😂🤣

[@shermanpeabody6102]

working for U.S. govt, one will never get fired, just like in India govt worker

[@rajvirdee1317]

These people should understand INDIA is bigger than all these countries put together.Going by population it is a very fair system.These people are only looking at the situation selfishly.

[@ShyamB-l4q]

One of our sculptors was recently denied a visa to receive a felicitation award and come back to India, though all documents were perfect.. the reality is they just don't make sense some times

[@CLAROSCURO-uu7vs]

Interesting channel and episode

[@KoolKeyes]

@Visa Officer you do realize that you’re giving applicants the answers that you’re looking for right? Doesn’t mean you’ll get genuine evidence. People can produce any evidence out of thin air these days.

[@DeniseGreen-c4j]

You always make complex topics feel simple.

[@nemesis11181]

Man the kid going to Harvard just could not take the hint. 🤦🏽‍♂️

[@mvaidjhaoyo]

Really nice person... Honest visa officer...

[@udoyxyz]

It was helpful.

[@sleepingbee101]

he couldn't do it the first time dummy because they didn't allow him. the supreme court has changed now so he has a better chance of doing it in his second term. he even said it in 2019 cause he knew it himself. that's why he's aiming for it his second term.

[@mandipsingh5188]

Plz Be careful it’s money making policies for USA .

[@nethbt]

Mandeep will explore every immigration loophole whenever he can

[@indrarao9972]

How expensive is North Dakota when compared to all the universities you listed, that’s what I would think.

[@gatestimonymiracle1302]

The problem is too many indian students

[@sudhirchandra9790]

Indian students should realise that India has become vishwaguru

[@sujoymukherjee1930]

Why should there be an obligation to deny? That is patently discriminatory and criminal

[@joealbert1136]

American people say enough of the free rides . We need to take care of Americans citizens first.

[@MrNickelpenny]

Guy looks like a young-ish Brian Lara

[@MuhammadZain-qv8oh]

Why did his channel went from giving educational information to involving politics

[@jesso-bn4tk]

He needs cash 😅😅

[@nemesis11181]

I can tell you have a really fast brain but you have always been faster.

[@WiseTreee]

He supports Khalistan

[@kaushalmaithi6019]

@@WiseTreeeok. Thanks. Unsubscribing.

[@the_welldressed_hippie]

They need to watch Indian students working 70 hrs whereas they can only work 20 legally!

[@FreeFire-uk5fi]

All Americans are immigrants 😂😂 except Native Americans

[@patriciasmith364]

But all of them have NOT contributed to building this country.

[@engineered-mind]

Each officer is different and some have higher and others have lower approvals just like judges - luck plays a part as well

[@arafatbinmonir]

make a video with an Italian Visa officer

[@AliTahir-y3p]

Can you please make this kind of video on 221g?

[@Thekiddio]

If you’re poor, how do you think you’re going to survive here in the US. Are we supposed to provide housing and food for these students? Most, if not all will want to stay in America via marriage, real or fake when they come here. Therefore, you should have money before coming to study here. Period.

[@kpw84u2]

Thank you for exposing the arbitrary biases visa officers capriciously employ seemingly stripped of humanity.

[@mandipsingh5188]

The officers are so crazy there They giving all visa to students Basically it’s money Source of The Government that’s it .

[@tapaumakan]

why would you go to usa , india does not have universities? just study and work in india, stay put whereever you are man. love your india.

[@Africanchild825]

The US is getting revenge for India not joining NATO PLUS AND BRICS.😂

[@Tech_in_AI_Era]

Now KZbin ditched his channel also😂

[@BharathKumarSampath]

What you mean

[@harshvaghanii]

@@BharathKumarSampath low views

[@BharathKumarSampath]

@@harshvaghanii harnoors?

[@Kookee_13]

As they should

[@ethanhunt937]

You are innocent until you are proven guilty and not the other way round.. He should run the next US prez election campaign 😂😂

[@mohanrao6]

How did that indian guy enter US what reasons did he give? But all these Satya Nadella and all these CEOs who stayed back if they had said i will return back after their masters what hypocrisy?

[@Milo-was-taken]

Timestamps please? Video is long

[@huiqinjinxi4514]

Am I the only one who think this is a video to teach people how to do their interview? Shouldn't they answer their questions honestly instead of preparing for them?

[@sumatanjunior231]

Bro tripping. North dakota state university is a huge and renowned public research university. His comment proves that state department officers have some bias in them.

[@marvinatienza2851]

Beacause he or she is don’t speak in English from India but not all I have a lot of friends of Indian people speak good in English but the other from India don’t understand in English

[@viknesh6481]

if Michael Jordan was a VISA officer

[@randallgoulet1550]

Pretty racist comment

[@TheGthom]

Train your self in climbing walls and obstacles Come from the Southern Border Current government prefers that route You will get phone house food and transportation 😂

[@KZ-po8wc]

you can be rich in poor village

[@FunNFury]

So in American system, honesty is not appreciated, you gotta say what they want to hear. Got it.

[@rajeevdadhe9493]

US needs talent.

[@odynith9356]

US has plenty of talent. I don’t get this idea that Indians have that the US needs talent from other places thinking there’s no talent there already. The US did very well on its own for a long time. Technological inventions and discoveries on its own. Yes there are many people that came that helped. Aerospace industry only hires American citizens (national security reason) so the idea that the IS NEEDS talent is ludicrous. It’s simply you thinking you deserve it but like he said you are not entitled to anything it’s a privilege

[@ib405]

US have talents. US needs employer willing to pay talents. US needs to abolish H1-b slavery. Real H1-b talent should be paid more.

[@odynith9356]

@@ib405 US doesn’t need to do anything to entitled people like you. You can work in your own country.

[@ib405]

@@odynith9356I’m not one of those slavers, I’m one of the American get impacted by the slavery system. A lot of IT workers can’t find job or force to retire early because of the H1-b slavery system. If a foreign worker being hired, he/she must be very talented that makes employers pay more.

[@odynith9356]

@@ib405 you’re not a slave bc you get paid. If you don’t like the laws then go somewhere else or back to India. It’s very easy no one is forcing you to do anything

[@ArgoSocial]

👏👏👏

[@shashikantsharma3873]

Laws of any country cannot be arbitrary, the immigration officer shall apply his or her mind objectively and judicially. The question on affirmative action caught him off-guard.

[@edlubitz2968]

I fail to see what this show is actually about, are you trying to insinuate that Indians are being discriminated against? In Canada we have 500k Indians coming in a year under the guise of student visas, when that doesnt work they claim asylum, Indian Immigration is out of control in North America, what's wrong with your own country, why not fix what's broke in India instead of invading North America

[@shubhamcweb]

35:40 “and that has to change” 🤡

[@ZenoSamaOmniKing]

dola r gonna collapse whats even the point

[@suzukigsxfa9683]

Totally pointless studying in USA. Over priced degrees. Same quality degree for much less outside USA

[@aricanaan1266]

Bullshit. The Visa offices needs to pretend that it the applicant doesn’t “intend to immigrate” . So now the applicant has to pretend to not have the “intent to immigrate”. How do we know that the state department isn’t at all serious about the intent? Because otherwise they could’ve simply made the visa non-convertible to anything else. Why does the state department has to perform this charade? Because if they change the visa that couldn’t be converted, no one will go to the US to study. And that’s a billion dollar industry. So, the state department has to deceive and the applicants have to lie. If the intent mattered, they could’ve decided to design the visa that way. That would have rendered the intent a moot point So, liars both The interview and interviewee

[@odynith9356]

Hey if you don’t like it. Don’t apply to the US. It’s that simple

[@aricanaan1266]

@@odynith9356 I ‘m American you d*mb f^*k

[@Redocx]

Bhaiya Scaler vs Abroad ❓

[@sanaali2874]

Abroad for sure no cap

[@lazydaug7147]

IIT

[@abhijitagaonkar1730]

For a green card waitline is 100 years for indians please be aware dont come under fomo, whole life we cant run behind a green card