Ustad told Friday Khutbah must only be in Arabic Any other language is haram, TRUE?

[@theboywholovedkappapuzhukk]

I still remeber the days when we had disputes and clashes within masjid regarding the Khutbah should be in Arabic or in Native language. Sad part, I was with the people who wanted everything to be in arabic. After the opposition got legal permission to do the Khutbah in native language via court order, one day, we boycotted the Jumah salah when Khateeb started Khutbah in our native language and we prayed Duhur within the Masjid as jamath. Astagfiruallh!!! Feels sad about the days when I was a mere puppet that followed what elders did. Alhamdulillah, Now I am putting my own logical reasoning to the ones that we follow around here.

[@mrrebelbunny5316]

Astagfirullah, crazy how the elders protested by praying Duhur, may Allah guide all of us to the right path. Im glad you aren't following stupidity anymore

[@s.adnansami5106]

I think there's something that you should consider: The Sheikh didn't use logic to arrive at his conclusion. He looked at the evidences and the opinion that said that the Khutba can be in other than arabic appeared the closest to the truth in his eyes. ON TOP OF THAT, it logically made sense to follow this opinion because the purpose of the Khutbah is for people to understand and take heed. If you still disagree, take the matter of the Salah for example. Most Muslims don't understand a single thing that they say in Salah, are we therefore going to pray in English or Urdu? No because no scholar ever has said that! Same thing with the Khutbah

[@al-zayyadnalado118]

Not the same. The salah is clear cut supposed to be arabic without a doubt or confusion because Allah tells us to recite what we know from the Quran in salah. As for khutbah to my knowledge there isnt a clear cut command to only do it in Arabic. Allahu Alaam. @@s.adnansami5106

[@johanliebert8652]

Some what they do, they make a summary of the khotba in the native language and then when the real khotba starts, its only in arabic. It's important also to push the arabic language, because noadays in america and stuff, they keep surveiling the imams. So better keep it in arabic. For each situation, its remedy. That's how logic works.

[@Die.Ractor091]

​​@@s.adnansami5106bro he literally proved it with logic see the full video don't just comment watching 30seconds of it and he also said "since khutba is not reciting quran" what it means is khuba is a lecture its not something like prayer which is recitation of quran , the restriction of arabic is only for quran you can translate it to understand the meaning but you cannot recite it any other languages. JazakAllah Khairan

[@sabeehanjum6105]

2:10 IM CRYING MANNN it’s so cool to be an NBA fan and an “air conditioner” of the Sheikh 😃

[@rpb4865]

He even knows Naruto dude! He knows about nine tail fox and other characters 😂 I'm the cooler of Sheikh

[@SoudagerAamer]

😂😂😂

[@mohdquamartyagi331]

​@@rpb4865and he also say wakanda forever

[@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn]

​@@rpb4865cooler sheikh or the Sheikh who watched those haram stuffs?

[@The-Creative-Hub]

who says he watched it? He says that Anime should not be watched. He's just up to date@@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn

[@reedone816]

In indonesia, back in the dutch era, they created law that islam teaching must be taught in arabic, including friday khutbah. So they successfully creating secular, because the people understanding of islam decreased significantly.

[@VictoryorAkhira]

Everyone who disagrees should read this.

[@johanliebert8652]

A lot of people need to take basic courses of logic before studying fiqh. Thank you sheikh.

[@s.adnansami5106]

Akhi could you clarify whom you mean by that? Is it the Ustadh in question or Sh. Assim Al-Hakeem?

[@johanliebert8652]

@@s.adnansami5106 Sheikh Assim is good. I'm criticizing the uneducated ustadh.

[@godisgreat1786]

It ain’t logical to pray to god in a language u don’t understand - 🐑🐑🐑🐑🐑

[@zaidkapadia6824]

​​​​@@godisgreat1786 Then propose an alternative because no language can translate God's words of the Qur'an better than Arabic. I've seen your other comments, you are nothing but an absolutely ignorant sad trinitarian troll

[@s.adnansami5106]

​@@godisgreat1786 Then learn the meaning of what you are supposed to say in prayer. Your logic is the reason christianity was doomed and there is so many contradictions since the Bible wasn't preserved in its original language but translated from aramaic (or whatever was the language of Prophet Jesus, A'layhissalaam), to greek, then probably latin, to english.

[@swalihstudios]

In my country (india) our kutbah in arabic. Because when the imam pray kutbah in our language people in other state or other country they don't understand our language. if i want the meaning of that i need just learn and also my madrasa(islamic school 1 to 10 year all muslim compulsory to learn)teaching the meaning of kutbah.

[@Masood1810]

It depends on the school of thought you believe. For some it's not allowed, for others like the Sheikh said it is. In most countries they have a speech in local language and then Khutba in Arabic. This way the message is delivered and the "ritual" of khutba is retained.

[@syedsaadjamal7471]

They added the speech in jumah prayer that is also not correct. You should not add or subtract anything.

[@maryame.4282]

Alhamdulillah thank you for this sheikh may Allah bless us all ameen ❤

[@MrTellyBelly]

What I can add I lived away from home for two years and at the local mosque there the khutbah was in English and Alhamdulillah every jumma as I was walking back to work the words of the imam whether it was hadith or Quran and the lessons from them were in my mind and increased my knowledge. Where I live now the khutbah is in Arabic and even then it is the repetition of the same ayat and hadith every week and both khutbahs literally last for 3 or 4 minutes in total and I learn nothing. Man I miss the khutbah in English.

[@MRKHAN-rr8ct]

What the Hanafis do is they give a speech (not counted as khutbah) in local language not on the mimbar, then after the second adhan they give the Khutbah on the mimbar in Arabic taking a short break in between

[@lettuce3162]

Depends on which Hanafis. In Turkey both Khutbahs start with adhkar and Qur'an, then the day's topic is in turkish.

[@elafzal5866]

The break inbetween they use to pray 4 rakat sunnah. I dont even know if this is the sunnah. All I know is the salaf used to pray many rakat before the khutbah. Correct me if im wrong.

[@syedsaadjamal7471]

@@elafzal5866no its not sunnah. The 4 rakah prayer break and the speech before khutba both are not sunnah they created their own things.

[@wish1333]

@@elafzal5866 its 2 rakah sunnah idk where they made up 4 rakah there is hadith about prayin 2 rakkah before jummah

[@wish1333]

@@syedsaadjamal7471 agreed

[@Muhammad-nz9kz]

Allahumma salim wa barik ala nabiyina Muhammad (S.A.W)

[@godlessgod6609]

Thank you!

[@obaid9791]

Masha Allah

[@haneefsheikh]

Jazak Allah

[@QuranforTheWest]

I love it Sheikh

[@haynerr]

love what nigga?

[@MM-mc8hs]

جزاك الله خيرا In my local masjid unfortunately, the English “bayaan” is 25 minutes, masjid announcements 3 minutes, and Arabic “khutba” 2 minutes. At least they were able to squeeze the khutba within the 30 minutes before everyone heads back to work الله المستعان

[@Shawn-QNA]

I always feel like this and I want to know what the Imam is saying instead of just looking at his face.

[@LakshaDeirwa]

In my country the Khudbah is in Arabic but the sheikh translates into our local language after salatul Jumma.

[@دانيال-ح3ض]

Actually, my friend, if he had said at the time of the futuhat, he would have been correct. The sahaba were a minority, they couldn’t speak the language of the locals nor could the locals speak Arabic. Actually, ibn ‘Abbas had his own translator. It’s also reported in an athar of Umar to stick to the ways of the Arabs. During the futuhat, the sahaba were a minority. Then, locals eventually learned Arabic. As matter of fact, many of the tabi’een and muhadditheen were bilingual having kept their mother language. Imam Bukhari, himself, wrote one Persian (if I remember correct) word in his sahih. Noting the above, it seems that it’s more prudent to assume that the khutbah should be lead in Arabic, as did the sahaba do, the taabi’een, the mutaqaddimeen do, the salafus-saaliheen. After all, it seems that the purpose of a khutba wasn’t necessarily to deliver a message. If so, the sahaba and salaf would have adapted to the language of the native speakers of the lands. No one will die if there’s a translation before or after the khutbah. I hope this message helps readers. Allah knows best.

[@دانيال-ح3ض]

I’m not open for debate. I just wanted to show a glimpse of a valid point on the other side of the spectrum. May Allah bless you.

[@hasnain9654]

Your view is to be abandoned InshaAllah because u don't seem to make logic in your words... Not gonna debate on that because u have prevented to start a debate

[@JaponicaBelichii]

As salamu Aleykum brothers and sisters. I have a question: When you hear imam reciting Quran or listen the Quran or read Quran, shall you reply something when you hear/read the ayah: “Which favors of Allah you deny?” Because I heard a hadith where Prophet peace be upon him after the recitation of Surah Ar - Rahman told to his people, jinns were better than you, because whenever they heard “Which favors of Allah you deny?” They replied Alhamdullilah or better than it

[@thevlogboysullu2458]

Replying with Alhamdullilah should be fine but in which hadith is it ?

[@physicshuman9808]

Wa eayklum Asalam

[@samavlog8494]

Recently, there is a local mosque in our community who performs khutbah in arabic. Non speaks arabic. The imam who requires it may have knowledge about arabic but does not speak it. The locals only understand local dialect. They dont speak english or even the national dialect as it is a small and far flunch area. I hope it changed.

[@i.123-q]

they can just translate , in my mosque they do this they finish the full khutba in arabic like the sunnah and then at the end they do a quick recap in the language of the country

[@usamaqadir7910]

Assalamualikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh Q1: Why do we find some people doing jummah Khutbahs in ARABIC ENGLISH MIX can we find anywhere from the prophet doing it or requesting it to his companion any action of any of the three best generations or anyone before the fall of Othman empire? Q2: Is Arabic not Islamic language and moving away is striping people away from it ?

[@AbdulRahman-yt9of]

Like the sheikh said, you need to praise Allah and send salutations upon Muhammed SAW(in arabic) and mention some quranic verses. then you can continue the khutbah in your native language

[@usamaqadir7910]

@@AbdulRahman-yt9of Where is the proof from the Quran and Hadith for doing khutba in native language if not who cares what this sheikh is saying right

[@Sas-rf9sy]

The level of ignorance and the lack of common sense is amazing. Even today in 2023.

[@mss0206]

Do we want to include everybody especially those who just converted and need to understand our religion or exclude everybody ...our religion is a religion of tolerance inclusion and Rahma and not the.opposite mashallah

[@Muhammad-nz9kz]

Assalamualikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuhu Subhanallah Alhamdulilah Lailahailalah Alahuakbar

[@mushtaqali537]

In India, the main khutba is always in Arabic with explanations in the local language, the second part (sani khutba) is only in Arabic as its mainly duaa. It’s the same in France where I live now. Khutba is preaching to be understood by all the people. If the coran had not been translated in so many languages, we wouldn’t have muslims in all parts of the world with different races & culture. So understanding the message of the coran directly or from the khutba is important. Further, haram is only that which is clearly mentioned in the coran, qualifying other matters or things as haram by people is shirk !

[@abuhurairah8895]

Islamic law comes from both the Quran and the Sunnah.

[@mushtaqali537]

@@abuhurairah8895 Islamic jurisprudence comes from the sunna too, agree. But where does commun sense comes from ? Islam is easy and a practical religion, let not the different hadits make it difficult for people to understand and practice.

[@abuhurairah8895]

@@mushtaqali537 yes. We can’t interpret hadiths on our own without knowledge, so we should learn from scholars and follow them

[@mushtaqali537]

@@abuhurairah8895 the Koran apart from the references, stories and also the mysteries, gives even such details of how to enter someone’s house or how to walk or talk or how to contract a loan and many such. It’s an easy guide and manuel for Man. Ofcourse one CAN follow his religion by the Koran. There are many a so called & self proclaimed ‘scholars’ who seek importance and fame, misguide people, make the religion difficult & complex to understand to the layman. Hadits (apart from the advise of our prophet sws and his life’s work) were written by humans while the Koran is Devine. No hadit, an interpretation of the Koran, can go above and beyond the Koran ! The imam who said “khutba in any other language other than Arabic is haram” is stupid. Reference sura An Nour 24 verse 41 - what counts is the sincere intention for Allah swt knows what’s in our hearts. Peace to you and all.

[@awe1824]

Now it's time to have concern for our brothers in Palestine, that's the most authentic opinion according to the Qur'ān and the Sunnah

[@abuhurairah8895]

That doesn’t mean we neglect prayer!

[@gameon...1636]

You don't deserve to say something like that.

[@rashedashfaq]

In our country in most of the mosques even the khatib dont know Arabic far away the musollis nobody understands the arabi but still there will be lecture in arabic😂😂 so wether the lecture is really a khutba or a poem of romi we never know

[@invisible_Truth03]

So using the same logic that he's talking about, the Quran is also written in Arabic and since we don't understand Arabic, we should start using translated version of Quran as well. Might as well start using native languages in adhan also. Can anybody give a proof that qutbah was delivered in a local language anywhere in the before wahhabism came into existence (like 2 centuries back).

[@swabrianwar1020]

its called double standards where " The prophet, sahabi, tabiin, tabi tabiin did not do this so this is bidaa" but when they innovate they call it logic

[@starnutron6147]

first you have to understand what khudbah means and then talk

[@zeeshan0987]

As a child in India, I never understood what they said in Khutbah

[@rashedashfaq]

Wahabism, salafism makes much sense to me despite the j*ihad part, but i dont want to call myself a salafi i cause i dont want to be a salafi i want to be a muslim the ummat of the greatest prophet Mohammad sa:.

[@yousaffarman8008]

❤❤

[@FalseAlarm]

So by this logic so all 5 daily prayers should be in arabic as well.

[@gongkong-oi7qx]

They are😮

[@muhammedsadiq4392]

ASSALAMU ALAIKUM This is the belief of salafs we consider it as a not a khutbah when it read as native language . One doubt sheikh is it a innovation to read khutbah in native language , we dont hear any sahab oru thabi'een read khutbah in other language than arabic . The 4 imams of the madhab supported the khutbah in arabic only ( consider they studied one lakh+ hadiths )

[@yourfriends]

In Turkey, some people claim Salah & Azan are allowed in Turkish 😂 This guy asking about khutbah would’ve been laughed at

[@PikachuGamerSMT]

Lol

[@wonderwalls3565]

Did not Umar said If we followed logic in deen we would be wiping the sock from the underneath and not from the top? Also Since when sounding good to the brain is called logic? He did nto give which logical fallacies are made when people give fatwas that non Arabic khutbas are haram. Giving reasoning which sounds good to your brain is not logic. Also If we apply the same reasoning no non arab should read Quran. Should read the English translation, same with the Salah adn all the duas.

[@Musafeer360]

People transposing the actual world with the old world. A lot of confusion if you do that.

[@snipeshot83]

Sadly, this is all wrong. The questioner made a mistake. It is likely that his Ustad was talking about the time AFTER Rasulullah ﷺ Because in the time of Omar and Uthman ‏رضي الله تعالى عنهما There WERE more people who didn’t speak Arabic, Yet the khutbah was still in Arabic. The schools of Fiqh reflect this. This is why many senior scholars deliver a lecture in the local language BEFORE the khutbah, Which covers what the Arabic khutbah will address.

[@snipeshot83]

Additionally, many scholars hold the “Zikr” that is mentioned is Surah Jumuah to refer to the Khutbah. Hence; it is NOT considered a lecture, But rather a dhikr, classed as a FORM of worship. Forms of worship are not done in our own ways, Acts of WORSHIP are Followed by the example of Rasulullah ﷺ and Sahabah and their followers Neither did Omar, nor Uthman ‏رضي الله تعالى عنهم, none of the Sahabah in the later times had it translated. We can use logic, qiyaas, in other matters, not in these clear scenarios. We don’t read the Quran in salaat in our own language, nor do we say the dhikr in our own languages while prostrating, etc.

[@palestallion_tm]

When people want their khutbah to be in Arabic everywhere at everytime, that's arrogance

[@rabah7414]

My name is Rabah. Just "Rabah" . I'm 23 years old. Is this name allowed in islam. Should I change my name?

[@ebrahimi44]

It's both Arabic and Hebrew name but I don't know if it's a good name or not. Probably it's. Good luck with your search

[@dragonking1051]

I looked up your name on the "muslimnames" website and it seems to be a Muslim name of Arabic origins. The meaning of Rabah is Gainer, winner, profit. This is also not one of the 99 names of Allah either (in which you have to put Abdul (which means servant) in front of one of the 99 names of Allah). So, you don't have to change your name.

[@sunaaan]

what does it mean?

[@rastaarmando7058]

it is valid, try looking up Bilal ibn Rabah, he is very well known among Muslims.

[@BleskofTruth]

Here in india they give in Urdu, still only they understand most of the listeners dont get anything 😂

[@juwairiafatima1063]

JazakAllah o khairian kaseera Sheikh Most wanted question I was waiting for it , the answer from your side … Basically we Urdu Hindi telgu bangali etc speaking peoples don’t understand Friday kutba in Arabic although we are trying to learn Arabic but not successful (yet )…. may Allah make it easy for all of us Who want to listen in our languages also ,a part from Arabic only .. Allah Kareem

[@Hope4human]

How will you understand it if Arabic is not your mother tongue

[@shaiknihal8798]

Bogus mean not true right

[@gaziz3225]

Yea

[@Tamer55361]

May allah promote us all to air conditioners, sheikh always shooting bullets since he is ak-47

[@12345678981159]

😂😂😂😂😂.. i will never forget that comment the sheikh said 😂😂😂.. the sheikh has funny straight forward answers 😅😅😅

[@monzurhussain4813]

Sheikh this is still a disputed topic. When we had a discussion with our Imam about this he says that you guys should learn Arabic language to understand the Qutbah

[@Saif_Ali_Khan_1301]

That is why khutbah given in both languages, local language and Arabic too

[@eesaabdurrahman1569]

Learn Islam from scholars, not your local imam. Of course learning Arabic is ideal but reality is that many don’t know Arabic yet.

[@Abdullah_2442]

​​@@eesaabdurrahman1569khutbah must be in Arabic Khutbah in native languages is not proved from any sahaba,tabee and taba tabeen Jumma khutba in any other language is biddah and every biddah leads to Jahannam we should learn the translation of khutbah

[@Abdullah_2442]

@@nteHawk then in Salah recite the translation of surah fatiha

[@Abdullah_2442]

@@nteHawk also do zikr in your language don't say Allah hu akbar 33 times say Allah is the greatest

[@JackWong2-i1p]

Yeh, lets eat burgers from burger king in USA, they are halal.

[@bilal0824]

Sheikh is a Lakers fan?!

[@moshiourrahman4895]

Radical Hanafi scholars say this

[@s5loh974]

Israeli industry plant🧐 I think so

[@s5loh974]

@@WillScarlet1991 whats funny"?

[@s5loh974]

@@WillScarlet1991 yep

[@MoAli16180]

KZbin Sheikh al hakeem you are causing more division in the ummah than unity.

[@Unleashed_Beasts]

how??

[@helmgroup6535]

“Religion” can make you do very silly things

[@IAMJESUSPROOF]

Lol yes only in Arabic that's the only language Allah knows 😂🤦

[@sologamer8287]

Bro not true no language is hidden from Allah

[@usamaqadir7910]

Q1:Why is Friday Khutbah in other languages allowed or not, please provide proof from the Quran and Hadith, and biology and consensus of the three best generations? Q2: Is traweeh 20 or 8, please provide proofs from the Quran and Hadith, and biology and consensus of the three best generations?

[@soroushdarvish9281]

“We Muslims have logic” I don’t m ow your viewers and the questions they ask, not sure that is a fair statement.

[@Jbadamz]

Don't take it out of context just because it may not align with beliefs. I would like to ask you What's the PURPOSE OF KHUTBAH?