Uthman ibn Farooq "This is Nifaq!" | Shamsi

[@DUSDawah]

Public Advice is Nifaq?! | Advice for Uthman ibn Farooq | Shamsi kzbin.info/www/bejne/q32bdoKBfcabe9E

[@sura2proyect428]

He failed you and he is lying again, he is saying orround, that he has the original utmanic quran.

[@mohammedalmaamari4333]

وَأَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ وَلَا تَنَازَعُوا فَتَفْشَلُوا وَتَذْهَبَ رِيحُكُمْ وَاصْبِرُوا إِنَّ اللَّهَ مَعَ الصَّابِرِينَ" سورة الأنفال آية:٤٦

[@catgames2290]

لا تحتج مغالطا، المنهج لا لعب فيه او مشاعر

[@sarhadnaqvi8468]

My sincere prayers are for both of the brothers May Allay protect you away from the whispers of Shaytaan and give taufeeq to avoid The call of Nafs. These issues may seem challenging to either of you but an opportunity of bliss for the enemy. Remember that

[@محمد-ر6غ4ذ]

Look at the beauty of Islam! When knowledgeable people are in disagreement, they advise each other. May Allah guide you and us and protect all of us against our ego and arrogance and make us all able to accept our mistakes and to accept the truth.

[@rsza5911]

When popularity increases...be careful....your Ego will get the better of you.....guard against this as it will always be your biggest challenge.....message to both brothers.

[@a.a5584]

Let's unite upon haq(truth)

[@sadeqkaramah9815]

Muslims around the world praise and ask Allah to give blessing to our Dawah brothers for serving Islam. It is heartbreaking for us to see that our learned Da'ees 'callers to Islam' get involved in such conflict among themselves. The solution is simple for our brothers to overcome their differences. First of all, Dawah brothers teach us to have patience, they teach us Adaab (morals) of conversing and most important, if we don't agree on a certain issue we should refer to the learned scholars of Islam. We should be humble and apologize after learning the truth. If it is our pride that is stopping us from learning from each other, then we are among those who are arrogant. May Allah make you united and not divided in knowledge! Aameen

[@gustialfian]

Wallahi this is what i have been thinking. What a hard times to live in!

[@mohammedsultanalmemari4111]

الآية رقم 46 وقوله تعالى فى سورة الأنفال "وَأَطِيعُواْ اللّهَ وَرَسُولَهُ وَلاَ تَنَازَعُواْ فَتَفْشَلُواْ وَتَذْهَبَ رِيحُكُمْ وَاصْبِرُواْ إِنَّ اللّهَ مَعَ الصَّابِرِينَ".

[@r_oni10]

يخوي شمسي يتحدث عن ماذا في هذا المقطع ؟

[@twatik]

Crazy how the salafiyah dawah doesent change at all, subhanAllah, may Allah preserve the people at dus dawah, way of the salaf is the correct one

[@Randomhandlename]

When prophet peace and blessing be upon him would find out about sahaba doing something which was not according to his Sunnah he wouldn’t go up to them one by one and advice them personally/privately he would openly say I am free from them and he would refute people openly not have one on conversations with them without anyone else knowing

[@SaadMuhammadAmin]

Yet people claiming to follow salaf forget to follow The Prophet peace be upon him

[@ayyoubbouyaddou3280]

Do you have any proof akhi? ust curious, baraka allahu feek

[@Randomhandlename]

@@ayyoubbouyaddou3280 wa feek barakAllah I am paraphrasing when some of the beloved companions of prophet found out how great the worship and status of prophet was they said to themselves this.. one said I will not stop fasting one said I will not marry one said I will not stop praying night prayer when prophet found out he said what is wrong with people they do not do as I command them then he said I pray night prayer and I rest I fast some days and other days I don’t fast and I marry then he said whoever does not follow my Sunnah then he is not from me furthermore when prophet found out Khalid ibn Waleed killed people he said I am free from the actions of Khalid

[@T-19-]

@@ayyoubbouyaddou3280 There’s many but here is one clear evidence where the prophet stopped the entire Jumm’ah Khutbah mid way to enjoin the good i.e The Sunnah of Tahiyyatul Masjid and stopped the sahabi from making a mistake by not praying it. And I’m sure you know the importance of the Khutbah by listening to it and staying silent. The prophet has warned severely against talking and interrupting the Khutbah. However, he did this: (so imagine when it comes to Manhaj, Aqeeda etc) Narrated Jabir bin `Abdullah: A person entered the mosque while the Prophet (ﷺ) was delivering the Khutba on a Friday. The Prophet (ﷺ) said to him, "Have you prayed?" The man replied in the negative. The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Get up and pray two rak`at." Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari 930 In-book reference: Book 11, Hadith 54 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Vol. 2, Book 13, Hadith 52

[@kenkaneki9138]

@@ayyoubbouyaddou3280 I am not sure if this can be a comparison but when khalid ibn Al walid killed an innocent in war the prophet pbuh rebuked him openly and said Im free from this action.

[@محمد-ر6غ4ذ]

May Allah solves every problem that you and we have. May Allah protects you and us against ego and arrogance. May Allah bring peace, trust between both of you. And may He make the truth prevail and without any doubt He will.

[@taskinabdur-rahman3487]

After watching this video, I dont know how much more sincere, soft, nice this video can be in giving advice. Wallahul mustaan. May Allah bless you Shamsi for this excellent advice.

[@Abzman73]

I follow and listen to all of you Muslim brothers who do dawah and share useful information. However, I do see why we Muslims have failed and still failing to unite since many of you attack each other and unable to resolve your difference the Islamic way. Instead, it is shamelessly displayed in the most public way possible to further humiliate Muslims in the eyes of our enemies. Shame on everyone who participates in that.

[@Qaulim]

Salaam ahkey, I think once brothers come to western country they adopt the same habits as the people who they live among

[@Abzman73]

@@Qaulim Some do, yes. Unfortunately Muslims these days are desperate for living role models to help lead them but when they see all of this between leading figures they are extremely disappointed and then may carry the same bad behavior themselves.

[@hansanders5280]

shaitan is loving to see us fighting each other.

[@a.d2019]

We unite upon the truth, we don’t unite for the sake of uniting. That’s 1 of the reason the Quran and Sunnah have been preserved. Look at the Christian’s, Jews etc..

[@faaiz2785]

Akhi we can't unite upon falsehood. That is not the teaching of Salaf us Saalih. Only when the aqeedah is rectified can we really unite.

[@rachidgharib734]

sheikh uthman and Shamsi are from the best preachers of islam may allah help you both on your paths to spread the religion i love you all

[@mehmetoglu265]

My brothers InshAllah you both will reconcile and work together rather then work apart we're stronger united.

[@rubixcube7234]

uthman is a bit arrogant

[@Randomhandlename]

Unity is only upon the truth

[@elijahmohamed457]

@@rubixcube7234 akhi please no need for this

[@elijahmohamed457]

@@Randomhandlename what u tryna say is he only falsehood?

[@Kai99342]

@@elijahmohamed457 he’s trying to say they only unify upon truth and we never unify upon falsehood. It’s clear as day

[@mohhmmedadil9154]

ما أمور النساء هذه اللتي تفعلها انت ياشمسي وعثمان بن فاروق قال فينا وقلنا فيه تعوذوا من الشيطان وارجعوا الى الله وان كان هو أخطأ في حقكم فمن عفى واصلح فأجره على الله الهدف واحد فلا تنشغلوا عنه بسفاسف الأمور ولا يخدعنكم الشيطان

[@bilalbouheraoua2680]

اللهم اصلح حالنا وحال المسلمين في كل مكان

[@TheOnlyFearless]

@Imran AKA DawahMan, you my brother have done a great disservices first to Islam, then to Br Uthmaan and then the the general muslims. May ALlah forgive you. Your whole interview is a drama and was of zero benefit to anyone. If you claim to love Br Uthmaan then you would have helped him see how he has gone wrong (by praising known Khawarij and Ahlul Bidah). It looks like you had the interview only because you are biased against Br Shamsi. Allah knows best.

[@JustObserving7860]

💯

[@إلياسابننورالدين]

Actually they want to reach him but he block them...and Muslim should refute each other or the religion would be lost...so the people know who is flowing the truth and who is not...

[@BakrAli10]

"by praising known Khawarij and Ahlul Bidah" can you please elaborate on who he praised?

[@believer9773]

When two believers fight, winner is neither of them... Remember!

[@furqantarique3484]

Uthman ibn farooq should not transgress

[@sakinahhyman1283]

As Salaamu Alaykum my 19 year old grandchild introduced me to your lectures brother Shamsi. In the USA it is called playing the dozens. And although many people play the dozens it has had deadly consequences here in the states. As a Muslim to say "save the drama for your mama" he is very disrespectful and showing very bad adab may Allah rectify his affairs.

[@bigfish819]

Personally I think the social media has got into brother Uthman's head. May Allah SWT guide him back to reality.

[@The_Angry_BeEconomist]

to a certain extent I agree, the videos of him in the park have grown scarce these days- those were the videos I enjoyed of his

[@MS-Hussain]

Don't think so much.

[@ayoubel7825]

You think to much

[@Randomhandlename]

He’s misguided

[@speedster4647]

@@Randomhandlenamemisguided by what? May I know

[@jamesedwardedward3919]

Assalamualaykum....brother Shamsi stay strong and stay blessed....

[@letsplayshow198]

I advise my brothers to Not use street language or bad words in dawaa ,remember guys you are the mirror of the Islam, please watch your words 🙏

[@asadus1558]

إن من وعظ أخاه فيما بينه وبينه فهي نصيحة، ومن وعظه على رؤوس الناس فإنما فضحه

[@travelerslife8854]

As Muslims we should remember The two things that will pull us to hell our tongues and Our private parts and we should protect our self from the devils way say less than what you want to say and wants it this clear you do not need to repeat it and for those who think they’re on the path and that everyone should be on the same path and judge those who you think they are not remember what Allah said you might judge a person while the person is so dear to Allah

[@epitaphhk13]

Mashallah brother Shamsi god bless you you are a good man Mashallah

[@elfarah1343]

I love you brother Shamsi but I think you have taken a different understanding to the sheikhs clip. Save drama for your Mama, sh Uthman didn't say to save your questions for your Mama. After all, you are also against drama in my opinion. I love you both and you are doing great job to teach us and others about Islam. May Allah reward you both.

[@moerocco775]

Tell him Shamsi. His head has gotten too big because Allah gave him some shine.

[@AbdelRahmanSeyamEg]

Those who follow their brothers mistakes indeed Allah Azza Wajjal will expose them.

[@alaamasood4525]

انا أرى أن المسلم المخلص المستسلم لله لاتهزه نصيحة لا سرا ولا علنا مهما كانت النصيحة لأن الذي قبله معلق بالله ومع الله لن يهمه شيء ابدا ابدا ثانيا : لابد أن نعلم أن هناك كثير من "اليوتيوبرز" يريدون الشهرة على حساب الآخرين فيقومون بوضع عناوين لأشخاص ودعاة معروفين كالأخ عثمان.. ومن هنا يجب علينا الا نعول عليهم وان نتوجه إلى الله ومن صدق مع الله فلن يضره شيء حتى وإن ضره شيء فالعناية الربانية والطمأنينة تكون حاضرة بإذن الله.. فيا أخواني فراحة المسلم المؤمن الصادق في كل مكان زمان.. احبك في الله اخي شمسي اخوكم من اليمن

[@MohammedNurhusen-v5x]

Aww my advice to all of you i mean duat: If you have disagreement you have to settle it on private you have to be together.

[@EverydayAkram]

My two favs at disagreement 😢😢😢

[@yilmazabi2988]

We are one ummah dont fight against each other in the Ummah!!!!

[@kotexawa8183]

How did this start?

[@yemenmohd.karoot8559]

الاخ شمسي حفظك الله، والله انا نفرح بكم، ونتمنا انا نكون مثلكم ندعوا، ونحب ان نصل الى البلاد التي وصلتوا إليها، وانتم وفقكم الله، للدعوة، والله انا نفرح فرحا شديدا عند نا يسلم رجل او إمرأة على يديكم، فالواجب عليكم ان تحلوا مشاكلكم في ما بينكم، ولاتختلفوا حتى لا تكونوا اضحوكة في بلاد الغرب، وخاصة عند المسلمين الجدد، وفقكم الله واصلح بينكم.

[@hamzamuslim6141]

"Don't manhaj check me". He thinks is is above the deen of Allah? This is arrogance over the truth, we seek refuge in Allah from this misguidance.

[@sofianhammachi8248]

المداخلة وكلاء ال سعود من أعطاهم الحق لتقييم الناس

[@UltimatePiccolo]

No, he simply isn't interested in your politics.

[@Abrarronga5]

Who the heck are you to check his manhaj?

[@UnknownServant]

I dont think the video he was talking about him not needing other people help to correct himself. He was talking about people who check which manhaj people follow, that's what he Is talking about.

[@a.a5584]

What was the context?

[@rosam6226]

جزاك الله خيرا 🤲

[@shahinsainu1909]

If you're "sincere in your advice" then kindly meet him in private and advice, since he's in the UK.

[@MrTrueCaller619]

Did you even hear what he's been saying bro ?

[@XceedXFX]

Why are we taking these embarrassing measures to expose each other when you can set up a meeting and sort it like Muslim men who are brothers in the deen instead of involving the public and creating bias environment for others to judge between the two.

[@moerocco775]

Happens quite often. Someone get's a bit famous then they become arrogant. Uthman has got a big head.

[@UltimatePiccolo]

Or he isn't interested in your politics.

[@moerocco775]

@@UltimatePiccolo My politics? What on Earth are you talking about?? lolzz

[@UltimatePiccolo]

@@moerocco775 your politics.

[@moerocco775]

@@UltimatePiccolo yawn...

[@UltimatePiccolo]

@@moerocco775 Ok. He still isn't interested in your politics.

[@lancer792]

It appears that the clip has been taken out of context. I have been seeing a lot of that from different people in KZbin.

[@ibrahimmsulwa]

We should not bother to unity bearly rather to unity according to ahlul athary salaf . Let our argument guide us right path toward truth of manhaj swahihah. May allah guide us both in right path amiyn.

[@CobraTackle]

Your attempt to advise everyone is a power move in order to maintain authority over the narrative of the deen. Subtly, by advising in the manner you do it, you are communicating to the masses and conmunity that you are supior, more knowedgable and reliable to follow. That's why people don't respect it. We can see through it.

[@masternas777]

Plz dont give non muslim chance to mock islam... solve your issue privately plz

[@mx4279]

Too late.. video posted about them both by DCCI Ministries

[@Abu-Kurdi]

This is what we're proud of not embarrassed by. We're not blind followers like Christians. We correct eachother. There's nothing wrong with this.

[@believer9773]

“The supreme art of war is to subdue the enemy without fighting.” ~Sun Tuzu Please be united we are tired of this🙏

[@leyth3832]

... united upon the TRUTH, not just unite

[@nearharvy2735]

sun tzu is a kafir 0]

[@falsehoodrefuted]

You are tired of the truth being clarified! SubhannAllah

[@omarals2835]

He does not need Manhaj Checking? What human does not need to revise his tawheed and manhaj from time to time? He thinks he is an infallable person?! May Allah save us from arrogance and ego, for it is capable of making kings into slaves!

[@letsgetitit2987]

FOR THE PEOPLE THAT THINK THIS IS NOT AN IMPORTANT MATTER. Imām al-Barbahārī (rahimahullāh, died 329 AH) stated: “Know that Allah’s Messenger (salallāhu ‘alaihi wasallam) said: “My ummah will divide into 73 sects, all of them will be in the Fire except for one, and that is the Jamā’ah.” It was said, “And who are they, O Allah’s Messenger?” He (salallāhu ‘alaihi wasallam) responded, “That which I and my Companions are upon today.” this is not a stupid matter this is very important. A Manhaj check is to know what someone is upon so you know if you can listen to them or need to avoid them and the innovations they might follow. Ahmadis will tell you they are Muslim so if you think with the thinking of no we are all Muslim lets unite you are literally uniting with a people who are not Muslim they believe in a Prophet after the last and final Messenger.

[@hali8580]

Checking the Sheikh's manhaj doesn't need to come from a unknown kid who no one has praised. If anyone should do it then it should be a known well mannered scholar

[@ashifkhan5739]

Look at the double standards in your comment. Manners? When did you hear shamsi get personal, this is about aqidah and manhaj. Follow manners and you end up like the Nasaaraa

[@ashifkhan5739]

Rather follow the truth. And shamsi has been praised and is known

[@smh6234]

What innovation is Uthman ibn Farooq upon?

[@Jsp-m_oi]

@@smh6234 he is not upon innovation and no one claimed so.

[@abutajine4760]

The righteous Salaf used to say: whoever hides his innovation cant hide the innovators he like! ‎(من أخفى علينا بدعته لم تخف علينا ألفته)

[@VillaAA03]

الفته maybe means his friends or the people who he likes to sit with

[@abutajine4760]

@@VillaAA03 sahih May Allah forgive me ‏بارك الله فيكم

[@smh6234]

What innovation does Uthman ibn Farooq do?

[@salrathor1]

@@joshuajaffi4090 ? Uthman ibn Farooq literally has a video clarifying that book.

[@juxhinnexhipi9948]

@@smh6234 he is following misguided people such as saleh munajjid, ishaq huwaynee, abdulazeez turayfee, sulaiman al alwan

[@ebrahimcroats3216]

Hold onto the rope of Allah & be not devided amongst yourselves.

[@DUSDawah]

STOP CAUSING FITNAH: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZbEfX-mqbqHo9k

[@falsehoodexterminator2336]

Bro Shamsi, get in touch with the sheikh. Please do it for the sake of Allah. If he shuts you down, Allah knows you did your best. Also please advise some of these people including me in the comments not to backbite the sheikh or any other Muslim. Barakallah Fikum!

[@selametas-salafi3726]

@@getinspired7687 Kadhab, and you missed the point of the video and what he shared.

[@walidnct3757]

اخ شمسي من فضلك تواصل مع الشيخ عثمان فانتم على نفس المنهج. فالمؤمن الحقيقي يتلمس لأخيه العذر اذا صدر منه خطأ

[@cybertime4143]

@YusFun Causing fitnah by following the Sunnah?! ..you have a problem with the Sunnah bro?

[@meshowzaq6892]

@@walidnct3757 يا رجل ابعد عنهم ، لا يوجد شيخ او عالم مسلم يتحدث باسلوب العدائي واسلوب الشوارع ابدا... الاخلاق قبل العلم هكذا تعلمنا، شاهد كيف العلماء الحقيقين اهل العلم كيف تواضعهم وطيب حديثهم الذي يفتح قلبك لان تتعلم منهم الاخلاق قبل العلم، اما هؤلاء بدون تحديد اسماء فهم لا يعلم عنهم الى من اليوتيوب ، لاتدري اصلهم من فصلهم والله المستعان اصبح كثير يتابعنهم ويتابعون فيدويهاتهم كانها حلقات نتفلكس للتسليه لا انكر ابد ان لهم الفضل بعد الله في اسلام الكثر ، لكن هذا ليس منهج خير الخلق في الخلق والادب وطيب الكلام واحترام الغير حتى ان اساء لك

[@fxorigins6624]

Shaykh uthmaan is open to advise actually u can go to his youtube when he visited speakers corner recently, people can advise him privately.

[@shahanighazali1591]

Pls watch the videos again n again until we fully understand them.

[@arifgzaman]

Doesn't make any sense to bring it out in open, both of you should have gottten together and sort this out. It's a shame

[@AhmadNaveedKhan1996]

Why you making it so big wallahi khawarij and non believers want this amongst muslims

[@codmastersdirt]

يا اخي شمسي انت لازم تمشي على حديث البخاري ان الرسول محمد صلى الله عليه وسلم قال ( من ستر على اخيه المسلم ستر الله عليه يوم القيامه) لليش هيك تفعلون ببعض وبتفضحو بعض امام الجمهور ؟!

[@msb7356]

This is a regular occurrence, make peace brothers i love you all for the sake of Allah swt

[@againstfeminizingmenmustri7637]

يقول الشافعي رحمه الله:- تعمدني بنصحك في انفرادي & وجنبني النصيحة في الجماعة فإن النصح بين الناس نوع & من التوبيخ لا أرضى استماعه وإن خالفتني وعصيت قولي & فلا تجزع إذا لم تعط طاعه

[@mohammadsaedi5723]

People like you!!! Are not allowing this deen to remain clean.

[@Tmhrtcom]

I learned from this speech Respect and Sincerity.

[@ibrahim_y_u]

Why r u the only one who is making troubles with every din dawah channels you argue with everyone why is that don’t you think that you may have some problem with in you by the way just wanna ask do u get paid

[@aaliyah7queen623]

I’m think shak Othman is fed up of this way of saying he’s off. She’s off It’s tiring and he’s probably tired of certain groups scrutinizing and saying everyone else is not salafi. It’s tiring for everyone to be honest.

[@barhum77]

لا حول ولا قوة إلا بالله - الدعاة حتى في الغرب منشغلون ببعضهم وكأنه لا يوجد ما ينشغلوا به في بلاد الغرب

[@Hamany707]

Shamsi Stop making Racism in deen. No one is wrong but you causing fitnah. May Allah forgive you. The Deen is Perfect but not the people.

[@mrb7935]

Racism? How was shamsi racist??? Also, clarifying public errors preserve Islam, this is a part of the deen

[@albalushialbalushi6528]

Jazakumu Allahu Khair, but honestly we as Muslims now are in NO need for all this I honestly see it as a door of fitnah. What is the point of this being in public?! This is causing hate between Muslims والله أعلم

[@أندلسي-غ8ث]

كلاهما دعاة للخير ولا نزكيهم على الله. لكن كلام الأخ عثمان لا يستدعي كلّ هذه التهويلات من الأخ شمسي، ومن الفقه أن لا تعلن الخلاف بينكما في أمرٍ ليس من أصول الدين، خصوصاً وأنّكما في بلاد يحتاج فيها المسلمون إلى اجتماع الكلمة أكثر من أي بلاد! إن وجدت إشكالاً فبينه في مقطع دون ذكر عثمان فاروق على الطريقة النبوية: (ما بال أقوام)، فبيان الحق يحصل بهذا، فإن أبيت: فاذكر اسمه في سياق البيان وامضِ. أمّا أن تضخّم الموضوع، وتفرده بأكثر من مقطع، وتُشعر السامع أن الأخ عثمان مستكبر عن النصيحة معرض عن مذهب السلف = فهذا كله لا داعي له، وضرره أكبر من نفعه! ثمّ إني سمعت المقطع، ولا أدري حتى الآن ما سبب إعلان الخلاف؟ أصلح الله النوايا، وألّف بين قلوب المسلمين.

[@أندلسي-غ8ث]

بالمناسبة: المقطع المرفق لشيخنا الفوزان في الرد على أهل الضلال، نقول نعم إن رددت على أهل الضلال فتكلم علانية ولا كرامة، لكن هل توصل هذه المخالفة الأخ عثمان إلى أن يكون من دعاة الضلال -كما يقول شيخنا الفوزان-؟ أظنك لا تقول بهذا. وكثير من "النصائح العلنية" يكون فيها للنفس حظ -والله عليم بالسرائر ولا نتهم أحداً- لذلك قال الأخ عثمان أن كثير منها نفاق. الخلاصة: أعد النظر في كلامه بحسن الظن، والله يهدي الجميع ويؤلف بينهم.

[@rm3869]

بارك الله فيك يا ليته يقرأ كلامك

[@bloimlala42]

bismillah wa salatu wa salamu ala rasulilllah the problem is that uthmaan calls Manhaj politics and that is a really dangerous claim he also lives under the rules of innovation because the salif didn't reject people that came with nasiha! its weird how he tried to call christians to the truth but himself if someone wants to give him advice from the truth he says "safe it for you mama" allahul mustaan! Qaida: religious false information in public has to get corrected in public its a common qaida what the salaf did practice!

[@hocinebenabdellah722]

الله المستعان، الشيطان عدو الانسان يأتيه من كل مكان، لا حول و لا قوة الا بالله طهر الله قلب الشيخ عثمان من الغرور الذي اصابه و ليتذكر ان هذا دين ندين به لله سبحانه و تعالى و لا شيئ فوقه

[@DzCaster]

to be fair, dawah man wasnt refering to anyone directly, also, people were "refuting" uthman well before any of this, he didnt randomly defensivly say dont menhej check him. Finally he explained in the podcast the reason he responded to dawahman was because of his adhab, sometthing 99% of people providing refutation lack

[@DUSDawah]

So it's OK for Uthman Farooq to accuse Shamsi a nifaaq?! ..where is your fairness toward Shamsi?! "to be fair" Dawah Man spoke disrespectfully and unjustly in that video and he still needs to make tawbah for calling Salafis a cult Edit: The actual word Dawah Man used is: "hizb" not cult

[@DzCaster]

@@DUSDawah I dont think you read my message correctly. Also dawah man has never called salafiyah a cult. That is a lie

[@DUSDawah]

@@DzCaster Fear Allah brother and don't defend falsehood: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jZDRkpqId9Npo8U

[@hl8302]

@@DzCaster He found adhab in Dawah Man? Wow.

[@bidahbuster2227]

To be fair, you didn't say anything that's fair.

[@mohamedaydarus7418]

Each one of you attacked and belittled the predecessors and today you can see the result - one against the other and throwing curse left and right.

[@theancientsancients1769]

Shamsi subhanallah, I was about criticize you but now see the mistake . May Allah forgive me. What he said was rude and impolite.

[@jerrinator468]

Shamsi u want to give nasiiha why not in private why make everything public

[@aq4356]

great video. I benefitted from Sheikh Uthmaan greatly, but I advise people to watch the video sincerely with an open heart, Shamsi is clearly in the right here. Favor the truth over individuals.

[@wisamy5286]

Great Video?? Spreading fitnah, and showing the non Muslims this pointless video SMH

[@Muslim42029]

When I go to the masjid I see people praying with different feet positions when they are in the last part of prayer , in juloos when you sit down to recite durood etc. I want to know what is the correct position of feet of the salaf.

[@aq4356]

@@Muslim42029 my brother, firstly, dont seek ilm from KZbin comments. Secondly, the salaf differed in some specific issues in fiqh as salah, that's why we have different madhahib. But if I understand correctly, you mean when you sit after you doing sujood, the Sunnah is to put your leg above the other, if that makes sense(search for images online), but theres nothing wrong if you sit normally with both being on the ground equally.

[@om6343]

@@aq4356 الأفتراش بين السجدتين وفي التشهد الأول والتورك في التشهد الثاني

[@om6343]

@@aq4356please don’t speak without ilm

[@Farhan-ns2kg]

I love both ♥️ both doing Great work in dawah field plz don't argument each other

[@furqantarique3484]

Uthman ibn farooq should not transgress

[@sofianhammachi8248]

منهم تجريح و تعديل منهج أصيل لحفظ الدين من مبتدعة لكن في سنوات اخيرة حصل فيه غلو كبير جدا و هناك تدخلات سياسية و مخابراتية خاصة في ليبيا حيث استعملوهم و قد ادي هاذا لضعف الدعوة و تدميرها في بعض البلدان يا اخي في الجزاير الشيخ فركوس فقط اختلف معهم في فتوي قالو انه خوارج اتقو الله الولاء لدين الله و ليس لشخص او جماعة او نظام وفقك الله فانا احسبك علي خير

[@irfansaudagar3495]

Both my ❤ but fight unless truth come front of as of topic

[@directshop9516]

wash a khouya Shamsi mal9iti madir ash had niveau a khouya khelik fDaawah oube3ed men had lfitna lkhawya

[@aniisahali6033]

The unbelivers are laughing at us u know!

[@a-rare-jem7447]

Not to be funny.. but that statement sounds funny when the the brother Shamsi says it. But yes it's an American term.. meaning take your drama somewhere else. And nobody's too good to be corrected, if it's not with hikmah

[@cybermafia2828]

guys dont spread hate...please be united

[@cybertime4143]

Where's the hate? You watching a different video bro Lol

[@cybermafia2828]

@Liz Nonabiz And everytime someone tries to speak about the unity of the ummah..the keyboard warriors kicks in and reply to those comments

[@zakariazakari5433]

The point from reaching a person is to give him the benefit of the doubt and a chance to correct himself rather than making a video about it and creating tribulations

[@umarsualah2683]

Please but he sometimes which means sometimes the way our so called muslim brothers present their advice makes it look like an attack to follow muslim brothers why why ??

[@heyhey6821]

May Allah bless Shamsi and Uthman, I love them both.

[@1200montana]

I love Allah and the Messenger more ❤ wa Allahu alam

[@yusufahmed1993]

@@montblanc7279 say teach not learn because Allah is the owner of knowledge

[@JIHADNEWSNETWORK]

You love a Liar?

[@MrJamaleddine007]

Go speak to him man and sort it out between you … we don’t want to hear this … it does not benefit us at all …

[@itshaleemah_]

It benefit me cuz it stops me from following his nonsense. It saved me from being misinformed. Anyway… the ones who have SOUND intellect will understand why you have to talk publicly about certain things.

[@safinoori8]

المشكلة ان الجميع يرون انهم على الحق الحجاورة واتباع الصعافقة والمصعفقة ووووو يا اخوة اتقو الله واصلحوا ذات بينكم . كلكم تبدعون بعضكم بعضا والحلبى والمغراوي والمدخلى . انا لله وانا اليه راجعون

[@slimisslow244]

Why make a video , instead of going to talk to him directly.. your causing a greater fitnah brother

[@yassroa]

if its an advice from a brother to a brother , then why the video in English if both sides speaks Arabic?

[@Labid_Prime]

Uthman couldn't even speak arabic

[@worldlyviewer]

this is so very sad....mountain out of molehill.....no one is perfect, but why expose mistakes?

[@iMANTlS]

Respect to Shamsi for this stance

[@azfarhameedkhan7117]

ok guys, what going on here please explain to me?

[@Holydayred]

As Salaam alaikum trying to discredit or expose your brother instead of having a private conversation is crazy and wrong everything isn't for the internet

[@DUSDawah]

Wa Alaykum Salaam. Islam is not based on your opinion or emotions. Rather it is based on Quran and Sunnah: kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGm5pIemqpJoiKM

[@sofianhammachi8248]

@@DUSDawah من اعطي الحق للمداخلة بتقييم الناس فاصلا هاذه طايفة ظهرت بعد حرب خليج لمحاربة الاسلام و الدعوة و الله ما دخلت هاذه طايفة بلدا الا دمرت فيه الدعوة

[@omarmcknight]

Too much qeel wa qaal no need for this y akhi focus on dawah to the ppl instead of “Dawah tain ment”. I enjoy listening to both sheikhs Jazakullahu khayrun

[@syedyunus4782]

Come together and be united upon the Rope of Allah, verily Satan is our open enemy...for the sake of Allah please continue for the works which will help ummah and brothers Seeking right path..

[@lvrpool1]

Why don’t you meet him in person try to resolve any misunderstandings.

[@hl8302]

He said he doesnt want to discuss this.

[@rehanzamindar6533]

As Salaam alaikum pls unite. do not divide. don't fight

[@tukokitkat]

WHAT IS GOING ON? WHAT IS THE PROBLEM?

[@anegage]

Bro most of your videos focus more on finding fault with others. You seems to have issues with anyone and everyone.

[@abuahmed5427]

السلفية أصحاب فتنة عافانا الله منهم

[@hiroshi-kun8216]

I like Shamis dawah but ngl the Salafi group seems to have issues with every other Muslim including other atharis.