Vanilla WoW Is 20 Years Old. Why Do We Still Play It?

[@hobberteevee7309]

To me, vanilla WoW has always felt like a real fantasy world. It's large, slow paced, and sometimes inconvenient. The modern game is more gameified, its about what's immediate and stimulating, now, now, now! Which has its own appeal, and I did enjoy dragonflight a lot until, but vanilla has this almost mystical appeal for me

[@madeizo]

Vanilla is simple a MMO RPG, while retail have nothing MMO neither RPG. MMO mean that its massively multiplayer, but Retail doesn't even let you play with other player, you never meet anybody in the wild and the games mechanic make that everyone tend to treat each other as NPC. In classic you always meet new people doing their quest, exploring, etc. Its simple, i don't even remember last time i made a friend on retail. On classic, i bonded with 6 people over two weeks.

[@Marcus-vo1tt]

@@madeizo not just that but also the enemy faction in a PvP server You never know if they are going to attack you or not Which adds to the RPG

[@LearnWithZ2023]

is not the game, is that person playing the game at that time. :)

[@LawfulBased]

What I liked in WoW is that you where pretty much *'a completely mundane commoner'.* No great lineage from which you hail, no great quest or reason why you start adventuring. Just an average dude who starts from rags and hopefully ends up in riches. At least this is what the Human story was pretty much like. Your background is a blank slate, you are nothing special and you are given very mediocre tasks for your station. And slowly but surely you up this curve and take on dangerous landscapes and quests. Mirroring the recognition you slowly build up by your faction. It is very brilliantly made. 👍

[@PoopSockJohnson]

As bellular said, retail is "Bing Bing wahoo"

[@1ButtonDash]

BRD is literally a city. I almost don't even look at it as a dungeon. There's so much to do there it's insane from the amount of quests to just different paths you could go, hell it even leads into molten core if you wanted lol the zone is genius.

[@bluemyst42]

This is what made things so great in Vanilla. Profession trainers werent posted up right next to they trade goods vendor, and some trainers were on other continents or hidden in a cave. Wanna smelt Dark Iron, better get a group together. Flasks? You guessed it. People had to work together, you had to make connections.

[@tylerk9455]

I agree. It's something that they have failed to re create in even there new mega dungeons. Mechagon or whatever it was called in bfa was alright, but it didn't have the feel that BRD has. I genuinely don't think they could make anything like that again in retail.

[@silviuvisan505]

People had a lot of time back then.

[@A_Goat]

​@@silviuvisan505 Possibly but I saw the contrary. Back when it first came out all the people I knew really only played toward the evening/nighttime. They still had school, work, social lifes, etc. Today it's common for gamers to not really have much of a social life. It is much more lacking and video games and the addictions that come with them or the endless amounts of people who don't want to work and stream to 10 viewers instead is significant. I can garuntee people have more time/waste more time now on this crap than they did back then simply because it's far more common now.

[@glenglen6386]

You even went in there for 20 fire resist enchant. It was like you were never done with that place.

[@TheLeadhound]

One underrated change that fundamentally altered the game was the addition of flying. That alone was a big part in shrinking the world, trivializing navigation and traversal, and modifying the way players view and interact with the world. The most important thing for classic plus content to retain the classic character is to keep travel as an important element of the game. There is a lot that could be said on this topic alone.

[@logosao88]

Yes, the "World" of Warcraft felt like more of an actual world, large and imposing if you really wanted to go from one side to the other.

[@dkaarvand9913]

No, the Looking for Group dungeon tool that teleported everyone to the dungeon ruined it. If we didn't have that, at least we'd be out flying - but we're not, we're all sitting in the capital cities waiting for any queue to pop

[@TheLeadhound]

@@dkaarvand9913 I agree with that as well.

[@hosannayeshua4446]

have to agree now that i played classic and now hc, flying is not a thing i miss one bit. I remember back in tbc when i started playing, that flying would be awesome and so cool, well it was for a little while until that initial excitement wore off. After that, it was just mindless flying, wouldn't need to worry, wouldn't need to think. Just pick a direction and auto-fly. But you said the core thing that plagues wow's development, trivializing game aspects such as talent trees and even class specific equipment usage. Rogue poisons and hunter ammunition comes into mind. Neither are casters or mages, so lore wise it seems weird for them to pull throwables and arrows out of thin air, not to mention poisons that seemingly never wear off. There is sure something that is lost when those things are trivialized, maybe some could call it the soul of the game. At least rpg element is gone, if nothing else. And gameplay becomes just another mindless grind, not having to play a rogue, making sure you have your poisons and blinding powder.

[@dkaarvand9913]

@@hosannayeshua4446 "But you said the core thing that plagues wow's development, trivializing game aspects such as talent trees and even class specific equipment usage." No I didn't :D

[@XxZaFantomuxX]

Classic WoW is a gem, it actually feels like you're in this world going on a long badass journey with your friends all the way up to level 60, this game has always felt so alive and still to this day unlike most games nowadays.

[@GokuIRL]

With real friends it really does feel good 😊

[@Mythansar]

Yes! And one example that striked me is the light/colors of the Elwynn Forest at day for example. The trees were different and so colorful. I can't explain it, but different vibes.

[@klavier285]

I feel that, minus the friends 😭 I still have fun though

[@ApplyBoosher]

"Because it's so long and hard, it feels better to beat it" -Asmon 2023

[@86Corvus]

If everyone can beat it its not an acomplishment.

[@mikeclarke3990]

"The texture of something being rougher makes it more enjoyable"

[@kristophersouza8104]

“Because it’s so long and hard it feels better to beat it.” - Asmongold

[@corneliussmiff2773]

Translation: It was horribly designed and esoteric for no good reason, but I still manged to beat it.

[@FriendlyArchpriest]

Ayo

[@Anonymous-mp2ln]

@@corneliussmiff2773 Hardly. Vanilla WoW was simple, but you still got filtered.

[@richarddevenezia8186]

A perfect "That's what she said"

[@akhsdenlew1861]

@@Anonymous-mp2ln Simple.. but not exactly. Vanilla wow is kinda wierd in that regard.

[@FantasyPiano317]

It’s always absolutely astonishing to me that even after knowing Classic since 2006 I always find new things that I didn’t knew about before! A few years ago whenever classic came out in 2019 I thought that I liked tbc the most, then wrath, then vanilla out of all the WoW expansions from what I remembered. But after replaying all of them I gotta agree with Asmon: Vanilla WoW was the best Version of WoW period. Sure…there are many flaws and things that are pretty annoying like for example not having as many flight routes as in tbc, needing one bagspace for each mount, mobs hitting you through z-axis etc. But those lose immense relevance whenever you weight them against the amount of love the developers put into building this massive world, into the class design, the music, the artstyle, into the many many different little stories that happen all over the different zones in Azeroth. It just feels alive and breathing! And as Asmon himself said, that’s something magical. I believe that Vanilla WoW was a once in a lifetime video game and I’m more than happy to still get to play it to this day.

[@djdenton6153]

As a new classic player , I agree . Seeing 60s just chilling in westfall or goldshire is crazy. It feels like a real world with all the people

[@arcc4]

It's the thing people don't understand about issues with modern retail. The QoL changes to leveling, questing, finding groups, and traveling have basically de-socialized, de-populated, and devalued the open world experience within the game all to funnel the players into prescribed time gated chores and repetitive instance loops as early as possible.

[@samnsamole9448]

@@arcc4 It's hard to condense into a single sentence, but yes, whatever activision did to the game basically removed or inverted every single feature of classic that made the game function on a social/MMO scale in the name of creating "accessibility" and Lobby-like features from Lobby based multiplayer games. Now, I actually like lobby based games and d2 is one of my favs. I actually *like* the idea of having dungeon finders, faster leveling, better raid design, but something about what they did fundamentally broke the "massive world" feeling vanilla had. They tried to cater to the CoD crowd, or people who only want to play 20-30 minutes a day, to ensure people can get some worthwhile experience in just 20 minute bursts. They want it to be like CS or CoD and you can just "press a button" and be in some type of game, whether it be a dungeon, BG, or whatever. This arcade style deisgn is fundamentally at odds with a massively multiplayer game. The other issue is the blizzard team became increasingly focused on short term player retention rather than expanding character progression horizontally. I would have preferred a more runescape style game where the level cap remains the same but a more complex and deep profession/stat system... rather than continuing to build a robust and massive world, they simply decided that dangling a carrot was the best way... new raids, new gear... no fundamental expansion of RPG elements, just button pressing and more grinds. I sometimes wonder what a PoE x Runescape type MMO could look like, sandbox style with open ended character progression. That would be fun...

[@nathamorteza1982]

@@arcc4this isn’t even true, take a look at old school RuneScape. It’s one of the greatest examples that eventually people will always find ways to min-max activities in games, regardless if it’s made easier or not.

[@Mythansar]

Exactly! One feeling that I will not forget is that when I was starting vanilla and I was on the Human race, I saw a Warlock Undead inside the Abbey of Northshire making firerain. I was like, "Duuuuude, what-IS-this!" 😮 I'm a bit out of topic, I know, but wanted to share it. 😊

[@laurensitter5250]

I played vanilla at age 16, obsessed. Quit Wrath during college, because… college. When I returned after a 7yr. break, not only was my Time-Lost Proto Drake missing (clearly over it), but a guildie gifted me BfA. As *soon* as Classic launched, I quit retail and began raiding MC. Guild drama, WoW friends, farming rare pets-can’t wait to get a computer to start HC.

[@neonmarblerust]

Vanilla is much more focused on fundamentals of the game. Things like aggro/leash range, or deciding how to get from one place to another.

[@BasedChadman]

Retail improved combat flow at the expense of everything else, it seems. The rpg elements are gone, the adventure is gone, and the immersion is gone. It feels hollow and bland now.

[@paradoxical247]

​@BasedChadman i would argue that combat feels better in classic expansions, Vanilla through Wrath. Personally, I prefer Wrath combat more than retail.

[@whiskoo9941]

shadow bolt shadow bolt shadow bolt shadow bolt shadow bolt god DAMN this combat is nuts@@paradoxical247

[@saskys]

​@@BasedChadmanthat's the most accurate description I've seen so far!

[@BasedChadman]

@@paradoxical247 I'm aware it's subjective, but I think the gameplay feels much more polished now than it did then. Kits are more cohesive with less downtime and a general build / spend playstyle. The smooth rotations feel more satisfying to me on a mechanical level. That being said, mob encounters are still a lot more fun in classic because they require some thought, cc, and managing your pulls. You can't pull 10 things and get out alive the way you can on a fury warrior in retail.

[@PlayfulFruitLPer]

I'll never forget that era and I'll always be eternally grateful for having gotten to experience it. Nobody today will ever quite grasp what we felt back in the day, because the internet has changed everything and MMO's are no longer a fresh idea that nobody is newly discovering. Back then, you'd never know all the content the game had to offer, you'd never imagine the scope or know what was coming. You joined blindly, explored and discovered everything on your own because you couldn't simply watch videos online about it. There was magic to be found, true magic that will likely never again be found by us or anyone ever again...

[@niklaslarsen1992]

You could just stop watching videos bro??? Litteraly nobody forced you to start watching guides etc

[@PlayfulFruitLPer]

spoken like a true person who wasn't there back then. The point is that nobody knew, nobody had the option of doing that. It changed the atmosphere of the game, how people played and interacted.@@niklaslarsen1992

[@GokuIRL]

@@niklaslarsen1992well this guy didn't get it

[@johnlappa5447]

​@@niklaslarsen1992Lol you completely missed the point didnt you

[@faux4780]

@@johnlappa5447 He's right, the experience isn't gone, people just rob themselves of it with google.

[@PureGigGaming]

I think you and that viewer hit the nail on the head for me. I was raiding in 10.1 after returning to the game from several years away, and ended up playing WOTLK classic now, even though I was able to get my AOTC and such, I just prefer the more laid back chill style of classic. I work oil rigs in Canada, I have a wife and 2 kids at home full time and a 3rd who lives with his mom and spends weekends here, 2 dogs, and elderly family members with dementia/Alzheimer's living with us as well. I play when I sit down at the end of my day to smoke a bit and catch some KZbin videos for myself before I go to bed. I dont want to have to be balls to the walls on 47 different mechanics I need to master as well as the size of my spell bars are ridiculous. I play Ret pally and Resto Druid on Retail and Prot Pally and Resto Druid on WOTLK and much prefer the classic chill vibe. Retails a great game if you wanna be a greaser for sure. Just as a lot of us age we don't have time for that. We don't create content for a living. We don't have time to sweat it out. Another big problem I found I encountered was if something came up irl and I needed 5 minutes, I wouldn't get it in retail but I get it in classic. Much chiller community.

[@Sp4c3gl1d3r]

your last point about the needing 5 minutes is so true. if you’re in a group setting in classic and politely ask for a few minutes because something popped up your group will just be okay with it! but in retail if you have something come up they’ll just kick and replace you with somebody else

[@Uhreg]

dungeons in vanilla were absolutely the best. i dont care if they are big and take a long time to do. the fact is i know every vanilla dungeon propably better than my own home and i can guide every quest and every boss and even brd is done in an hour when people listen and i love it.

[@GokuIRL]

Same 😊

[@dubecheck]

A big part of what made classic wow for me was the fact that you were out in the world and you were on foot, flying Mounts destroyed a lot of the random interactions with community out in the world including world PVP. There was nothing better than pulling a bunch of mobs on accident and some guy you grouped up with three nights ago comes and saves your ass, or rolling through winterspring going to farm up some mats and you see that bastard that tried to gank you the night before and you chase his ass across two zones before you finally catch him.

[@willischwabe1324]

​@jordanhurley7307what if they allowed the use of flying only available for a certain amount of time every day? So you can use the flight paths and all preferably, but have your mount if you need it for some occasion and when the mount is exhausted and needs to rest, then: too bad. (Maybe with the allowance, that it won't just throw you off, but you can fly as long as you want - but after dismounting then that's it for the day).

[@jarzota]

for me, I enjoyed the ceiling. The moment you hit 60, full BIS, you know that you've accomplished a lot on your character. Now it can be repeated multiple times at different classes. With Retail, i can barely hit the ceiling. Then next year comes; and a new expansion is out. I'm choking. theres no time to digest and enjoy the zero to hero progression. because it wont matter; the next expasion is already out before i could even start doing high end raids Ground mounts were a thing too. It was awesome riding my sabretooth, and seeing someone riding in and out of stormwind. Nowadays everyones teleporting, flying, in town queuing up in front of auction. Town is a lot more populated, but zones for questings arent so much.

[@nuggo8711]

I started playing WoW for the first time when WotLK classic pre-patch came out. Sitting on the dock with hundreds of other people waiting for the boat to Northrend was one of the best gaming experiences in my life.

[@PS-cq8qr]

You're too cute. But welcome to it!

[@framinthor]

Same, WotLK was my first real wow experience, and that Zeppelin ride to Northrend was an insane experience. That being said, that is where that experience should stay, I wouldn't get anything like that from doing that ride again, instead ill get annoyed at the lag of the game not being able to load players, and the error that will kick me out of the game failing to load me into northrend. The magic died way back then, people who play the classic servers now are trying to relive something that passed long ago. Nostalgia is a hell of a drug, and it is reinforced by other nostalgic players repumping each other's nostalgia. I legit cannot understand what people like about classic now, it is slow, annoying, most of your time is spent running back and forth, and you are paying a sub for.... nothing? like legit, people are paying a sub for a game that isn't even a live service game... Classic is a ripoff farming people's nostalgia, and good on blizzard for making money off those people

[@YoStYtOaStY100]

​@@framinthor Better than the absolute garbage that is Retail and has been retail since the end of legion shit mid legion

[@Random-yb5di]

@@framinthorbro most of wotlk classic players didn’t even play original wotlk KEKW. you’re argument cannot even exist.

[@shemsuhor8763]

I was playing WOTLK classic forawhile, I really enjoyed WOTLK back in the day. I didn't even play BC, just vanilla, and then got an itch and played some WOTLK when that came out. So when they did classic WOTLK, I thought it'd be fun to join up again. But then one day I login, and bam, there's this +50% xp buff? Nah. Fuck that.

[@Smalls989]

classic is magic, I couldn't imagine the process to make such a good game.

[@tolandankwood]

read the book: the wow diaries fascinating book about the creation of vanilla tl;dr play classic everquest, take notes, and casualize it

[@atraxian5881]

My guess is that much of the things in classic happened because a developer thought: "would be nice/cool to add this" and they added it. Instead of: "will this increase engagement metrics?" Then make it worse.

[@nathancasey7712]

​@@atraxian5881this

[@Haggis-Giggles4692]

It’s not magic. Classic wow is just made by people who actually play the game.

[@AndrewB383]

@@Haggis-Giggles4692 er, no it wasn't, WoW didn't exist before, y'know, classic WoW was made

[@tylerbreau4544]

@18 WotLK is when they started introducing automated grouping systems - Dungeon Finder. It was also when heirlooms became a thing. WotLK is when Blizzard started designing the game around "pre-end game is a waste of time". It was no longer an adventure through a world, it was an adventure through the end-game expansion. Sure they had some pretty big problems starting to occur, leveling through vanilla zones, outlands, and now northern. Then they already knew there was going to be more zones, Cataclysm, Panda patch, etc. And yea, when a new player is introduced to the game via friends they want to play with their friends. That makes sense. But still, the game was supposed to be an adventure and at the time, both the devs and community didn't want the vast majority of that adventure. They considered the vast majority of it to be a waste of time. I spent hours having fun in both casual end game content and pre-end game content, from very late BC to mid panda patch. I also ended up learning the layout of most of the pre-end game dungeons, even Wailing Caverns. If I recall correctly, they had simplified that dungeon at some point but I remember learning the full dungeon and understanding it simply because I had ran it so many times. I stopped in Panda patch because you know what pre-end game had. Zones void of players, heirloom-decked out people in dungeons. Tanks were just glorified DPS because a lot of DPS could tank. Heirlooms, blues, and dev tweaks made people over-powered while leveling. That doesn't mean heirlooms weren't fun. I still remember the time I was killing skull level monsters as a hunter with a ton of heirlooms. I was bored and I entertained myself by doing something that I shouldn't be able to do. I believe the zone was Silithus. Heirlooms was fun to play with for a while but they weren't meant to be fun. They were meant to save time. Imagine this, someone plays WoW for the first time. They end up speccing for tank. They get into a dungeon. Everyone else is decked in heirlooms, the DPS and healer just start running things down and the tank can't even begin to out-aggro the DPS and it doesn't matter. It doesn't matter because the DPS and healers are doing fine without a tank. I know that situation. It happened in Razerfen Down. I was not a new player but I wanted to try playing without heirlooms again and that situation happened. Granted 1 of the DPS was an arms warrior. No it was not a fun time. I wanted to tank but I was the inconvenience in the group because I wanted to tank and play without heirlooms. Good things don't last forever but they shouldn't be treated like previous expansion content in WoW was treated.

[@pkmChris]

It's almost scary how well made Vanilla WoW is. At least for me, it is perfection

[@Diactia]

what lmao@@oatraa

[@k9tirion927]

@@oatraa Are you on the spectrum or something?

[@ce8539]

​@oatraa you been watching too many skibidy toilet memes bro your mind has melted

[@A_Goat]

​@@oatraa You quit over one classes walking animation?

[@Lauwit]

Not really lol its buggy no qol and yeah for people with no lifevits perfect

[@thesoffen48]

We still play classic vanilla because the game is overall fun. You can lose yourself inside the game where you are an unknown adventure in a wide open world. Its simplicity makes it great.

[@agent00jesus41]

World of Warcraft was more then just a game. And it's a phenomen that will always stand for itself. Although today it may be different.

[@wickian9571]

It really was revolutionary. Nothing came close to competing with it besides maybe Counter Strike and the two weren't mutually exclusive so weren't really in competition. No other mmo has a leveling experience that is actually a fun journey. They all feel like a waste of effort time sink that you just want over with as soon as possible with the pointless quests and cookie cutter quest rewards.

[@6kembe4orba]

@@wickian9571 sounds like you've never played Lineage 2 (which came out 1 year earlier than vanilla WoW) - which is actually the better MMORPG overall from the two - precisely cause of the very same things that everyone praises vanilla WoW for --- L2 did it better and had better systems, a true open world MMORPG with active worldmap/guilds and politics. vanilla WoW was always a theme park MMORPG which had some sandbox/open world elements, those are the reason why it's good and still played today.

[@XTen1000DaysX]

@@6kembe4orba i played lineage 2, asherons call, everquest, etc. None compared to WoW. There is a reason WoW is still relevant and those games dont even have servers up anymore? The closest MMO back then to WoW was EverQuest (in terms of popularity).

[@trixdream]

classic wow was my by literal legends and maybe with some divine intervention idk :D

[@akhsdenlew1861]

@@6kembe4orba oh please, we all played lineage 2... the game was an RNG Fiesta-garbage, similar to 2016 archage. The game had 0 skill involved, all u were doing is auto attack ( 1) and soulshot (2). It was fun for it's time, but when wow came, we all ditched it and never looked back. Lineage 2 has NOTHING over wow... You are probably just 35-40 years old ,with tons of fun memories of lineage 2 and you are just full copium if you think Lineage 2 is actually superior to WoW.

[@Syrnix]

The no guides argument is a really important factor. When the last megadungeon launched in retail like a month or so ago I went in completely blind with 4 mates who also went blind. We had to see the fights ourselves, read the journal and think how to solve everything. It took us about 6hrs (3hrs each evening, two evenings). It was by far the best experience I've had in wow in MANY years.

[@yallahyallah4220]

no one said it better than Kevin Jordan, in classic "You the player are the content" and the community keeps everything together.

[@irrelevanthero7410]

I remember when I first started playing Vanilla back in '05 I had just made it to the barrens and there was a couple alliance attacking Crossroads npcs and griefing in Ashenvale. 15 minutes later no less than 20 level 50-60's dropped off at the Flight path and steamrolled them and just hung around for a half hour. Seeing all those high level chars was awesome as a lvl 15.

[@StefanCM15]

That's a memory that many players from that time share! For me personally i had to add, that i didn't even look at the levels, tried to attack them with no effect and got killed instantly. Questing around Crossroads was nearly always connected with the danger of alliance attacks. It added a lot to the feeling of this game. Crossroads, Tarrens Mill, Stranglethorn... those were the battlegrounds outside the battlegrounds.

[@Ogre32890]

I used to always tell people that I missed actually making the journey to the dungeon with my group and meeting up there to ready ourselves for it. It kind of hyped up the experience to me. I was always met with people saying they don't miss that and how much of a waste of time it was. Turned out they did miss it. Because now they play Classic.

[@red_river_radio7927]

Always had that one party member that would be on the opposite content and then scream "Summons?", forgetting that Vanilla doesn't have a summoning stone and the warlock is only lvl 17.

[@densetsuno6487]

@6:25 This likely came from classic EverQuest. Classic EverQuest was the all-time grand champion of doing this. Almost every non-dungeon zone, if not every zone, had reasons for a max level player, group, or raid to be there. Level 20 rare spawn/drop that is BIS or has a unique utility? It's there. Level 60 epic weapon quest that involves killing this roaming lvl 55 boss that killed you when you were level 8 grinding in that same zone months earlier? It's there. Rare spawn quest NPC that you need to turn in a material to for the next part of an endgame quest in a lvl 15 zone? It's there. @21:35 Also, EQ. EQ was completely a group game. Soloing couldn't get you very far (well, some classes could, but solo is still less efficient than grouping). The only way to "fast travel" is via a teleport, and the only teleports in the game were via players. Wizards could teleport, but only to wizard spires, and druids to druid circles, and both spires and circles were located in different zones from each other, giving each others' classes variance in utility and convenience. Also 100% agree, MMOs need to give people reasons to interact with each other, and give them benefits that aren't superficial to do so.

[@pearson674]

I just started playing WoW, completely new player, and I can tell you right now, that Retail does not feel like an MMORPG in any way whatsoever. Top two complaints for me (and why im playing Classic HC RIGHT NOW): Social aspect, and the Leveling Experience. Leveling is like a whole other game from the level 60 experience. My first Dungeon in retail, I was literally pulling teeth to get people to talk to me; Classic HC, we were having full conversations in the beginning middle and end of the dungeon (albeit most of it was about questing and the dungeon itself, but we were still talking)

[@aldebaran1977]

The problem is a portion of the player base of retail is so toxic, I dread the idea of having to talk to someone. I miss being social like back in Wrath, but now it's hard to find patient, helpful people in wow. I shit you not, I saw on the forums the other day saying they think new players should not be allowed to start out as tanks or healers. With a shortage of both, how tf do you think people will ever learn and fill those spots? 🤦‍♀️

[@Glonag]

To those who say that nostalgia is to blame, I played the Classiс in 2019 for the first time because I was bored playing Battle for Azerothi and stayed there, never returning to retail, and there were many such people with me in the guild.

[@silentwishs]

It’s because retail took out everything that made classic, classic. Retail is instant gratification, quick kills, quick travel, quick professions. It made it easy. Classic was slow. The world felt huge because you had to actually travel it. You had to watch pulling multiple mobs, you needed professions, you needed to farm up gold just to unlock skills and hope to have some left for better gear. You had to plan your specs or else it costs money to fix the mistake, leveling felt good because it took time. New gear felt good because of the same. Wow today is an arcade game compared classic.

[@PodTalk_Wresting]

I play WoW for 16 and a half years now, it still is and always will be, my top 1 favorite game, i just fell in love with it so much.

[@ihaxcookies]

@@Atrocitylol69you’re *

[@moquilla1]

Played it for 20 years. I miss it.

[@Thiswayisyours]

Classic wow confirmed that the vanilla wow experience we old timers remembered wasnt just nostalgia.

[@Femaroty]

Chess is older and still loved and played. Yes, it's different, but shows how age have nothing to do if the game is good.

[@TudorSicaru]

A few things that make this game better for me: - huge world and zone "bosses" (like Mor'Ladim in the video), the world is dangerous at the same time due to limited skills at your disposal and often times you are feeling powerless - capital cities where people of all levels are bunched together - classes are not balanced -> impactful class identity, not everybody can do and play your role, you feel more immersed and you don't have everybody sprinting or stealthing, you know they're druids or rogues - walking to dungeons/raids and having to fight your way through with sapper charges (see BRM raids on Sunday in EU region lol) - using a relatively simple toolkit to develop complex gameplay in order to have an edge above others - each upgrade feels really rewarding - also the dungeons mentioned in the video...once you step in BRM it's magic, like all dungeons in that zone are amazing and kinda connected - you have a damn sword that WHISPERS to you (Corrupted Ashbringer) - I know I started with "huge world" but did I add zone design, it kinda caters to all tastes - tirisfal/silverpine/elwynn/redrige/duskwood/stonetalon/stranglethorn/tanaris/un'goro/feralas/burning steppes/winterspring - so many different themes for the zones, I can't think of an ugly zone - maybe Desolace out of how many... There are others, but these come to my mind and I feel add to the magic of Vanilla WoW

[@marcelbruin9151]

Really try out HC, on an unknown alt mate. As a 2004 player, this whole HC stuff (witch is nothing like me, as a PvPer) feels like the opening of 2019 should have been. It's such an blast man.

[@bluemyst42]

It really does. Every zone feels full and brimming with life. The economy isnt destroyed yet because people keep getting reset. Everyone helps each other out (for the most part) because you dont want them to let you die either.

[@marcelbruin9151]

@@bluemyst42 ikr?!! Stay safe mate!

[@OkayyyIGetIt]

It’s a complete waste of time

[@marcelbruin9151]

@@OkayyyIGetIt so is, playing 90min of soccer mate. Still fun AF.

[@vXCozmoz]

1) I will play "Classic+" if they do it right. But if they are even thinking of adding level boost and especially wow token, *HARD* pass! Maybe that's why they charge 50 bucks, hence no token? 2) For the love of God if they add High Elves (BEs) please update the bow animation to newer one. Was a big welcomed change later on. Old animation is aweful. A simple toggle would work. 3) Scarlet Monastery raid. Considering how popular SM dungeons have always been. Fill the empty and unfinished areas with content. Many places on the world map to add more. 4) If they will add housing which was a plan for Vanilla back in the days, don't make it like in WoD. Last thing we need is "empty" servers where people sit in their houses and "farm/craft" all day. 5) But don't forget that they also lied to us. During that blizzcon announcing wow classic for 2019 they said "we want to reproduce an authentic version of the game as it were then" and look where we ended up with. Level boost for tbc, able to get a lvl 55 DK on a fresh account, fking wow token in wrath and much more. So don't just blindly trust them!

[@ElewIV]

Retail isn't doing itself any favors by killing off all the best Heroes. I still remember how Marshall Windsor was the GOAT walking through Stormwind to call-out Onyxia.

[@anonimowelwiatko9811]

But he died

[@proshielder60]

Classic WoW is like golf, knowledge of how and when to use the right tools matters a lot, but it’s leisurely played. Retail is like hockey

[@TheHewoks]

Id say it's like Basketball lol, gotta go fast fast and the quality of the goal isnt as important as the quantity

[@Roslerox]

Hockey is pretty technical.

[@wilcooper64]

I started WoW about 6 months after launch on EU Stormrage PVE. I've still got screenshots from summer '05 as a level 33 Nelf Warrior at Crossroads doing world PVE - I remember people commenting about it in SW and that people needed to get to Crossroads on Friday night. Man, it blew me away.

[@Infecti0us1]

Was on Stormage PVE EU and had a Nelf warrior also, great times!

[@wilcooper64]

@@Infecti0us1 I soon moved to Haumarush PVP when that opened not long after 👌

[@denisesorensenlindholm8072]

Me too! :) I played on Stormrage PVE with Genesis.

[@Kanmandetdu]

I've been grinding every single MMO that came out since Vanilla. Played D4 HC to 100 completing all objectives in Season 1. Me and a group of friends (all aged around 40) went back to try Classic Era WOW and i can easily tell you why i'm going to keep playing this game for a while again now: 1. Item system. Getting a green drop actually matters. No more seeping through hundreds (or thousands) of items to minmax or build the item you need (looking at you New World and D4) - you get a drop and it's either what you need or it isn't. 2. Convenience: I LOVE that it takes time to travel and that the game isn't designed to get you to keep playing. At times it feels like it wants you to quit. It takes effor to complete quests and some you just can't do alone. I hate the "handholding" of modern MMOs. Make me work for it! Make it hard to achieve your gold! 3. Solid mechanics. It's not overly complicated but it takes time to master any class. I don't know wtf happened to D4 and their 100 different stat parameters - it's unnecesary and overly complicated. KISS. I hope that Ashes of Creation look to classic wow more than modern MMOs. It just still works.

[@Coeurebene1]

Modern MMOs feel like a task list to me. Vanilla is indeed an adventure. What we need now is content generated on teh fly by AIs, so that every quest, NPC etc... happens once only. That would restore the magic and immersion.

[@blinkin7795]

i actually played WoW back when it first came out. i had a little gnome stun lock spec rogue (full mace tree spec, with as much attack speed as i could squeeze out), and i had so much fun confusing people by off tanking mobs and just holding them in place stunned in dungeons. it might take a while but my stun lock rogue could win a fight with almost any enemy where the level would actually display in game. unfortunately around level 40 most of the dungeon bosses became immune to stun, so my entire build became useless during most boss fights. when i was around level 20 to 30, there were a few times some level 60 horde character would come into the low level zone and just murder people en mass, but i would watch and wait. get used to their attack patterns. then i would move in and pop them with a cheap shot, throw down a couple other moves to build my combo up, and when the cheap shot stun wore off, hit them with a kidney punch to knock them out again. in between successive kidney punches, my random mace stun procs would go off too. i was only hitting for like 1 hp of damage per hit, but i was holding them there so the rest of the angry mob could also get their hits in for 1 hp of damage, and i would laugh as the level 60 predator became helpless prey during a feeding frenzy. i loved the stories that could come out of vanilla WoW more than anything.

[@Flapps96]

I haven’t watched much content about classic wow but I hope asmon goes back to it at some point. It seems to make him happy and it’d be nice to see that happiness

[@mikeriggs3891]

Wow, what an awesome comment and compliment to Mr Asmon.

[@StrawMan3]

@@Atrocitylol69 how is wanting people to be happy parasocial? Bit of a reach lol.

[@DG-rc8xf]

True. But he's gonna get carried to perfection then get bored...then TBC...then WRATH.. 😊

[@Haln_3148]

11:20 to put it simply, old world dungeons are designed with the world and lore in mind. Whereas currently the world is designed with dungeons inmind

[@lukekunka317]

One of my favorite memories was I worked at a Gamestop when TBC launched. I had my copy at 830pm EST, installed by 9:30pm EST. It was 11:50pm when all the people sitting outside the Dark Portal got to watch me walk into the portal and not through it. I stood alone at the top of the other side of the portal and looked down upon the Horde and Alliance NPCs battling the Legion forces assaulting them. I looked left and right and then it all hit me: I was the first person on my server to step foot into the newest content the game had seen at that time. I'll never forget it. And then there's also the hours of stories I have from vanilla...

[@MrZelegor]

One of my instrument teacher told me a story in 2008 about how did WoW completely destroyed her relationship with her boyfriend (she was ~27 years old). She said that her boyfriend was skipping showering on raid days (XD) but it was much more complicated. You can just Imagine what a gamer was her boyfriend, and i can relate with him as a 25 years old myself. Wow is such a complex game, even if we get every 3 years a complex AAA game which actually playable, it's nothing like having an actual complex multiplayer, where players are playing with passion.

[@mysterandir6348]

I've never really played this game but for some reason i am so very invested in its journey through time and its inevitable death... I dont know why :)

[@seregill13]

Start playing classic WoW

[@xmoxipavonispetinus8539]

play clasic hardcore

[@healz123]

Classic wow won't die!

[@cecollins68]

Your invested in asmongold and his opinion on it parse the difference

[@mwmwmw]

Play classic wow you won’t regret it

[@synjhesdxt]

Because of nostalgia. Classic is objectively a skeleton of a game that was a prototype - and a bad one at that - for how a mmo is supposed to work. All of the people saying here that it was "magical" and "good" are either lying to themselves or doing a very bad job at lying to us. For sure it was the start of something magical. But never in its entirety did vanilla or "classic" make a game that is worth writing anything about. Grab any rpg from around that time that's triple A or indie that had devs with passion - and classic will 100% of the time bite the dust. The community made the game, not the other way around. Stop trying to pretend that it was a 10/10 or a 9/10 game. Classic is a 6/10 and that's not a bad thing. Yes, it's a controversial take, but only if you choose to close your eyes to the actual truth. And to those who say that a lot of people play classic and not retail because classic was better - congratz on becoming a boomer. There are a lot of old people who say that tetris or solitaire or whatever old game was the real shit and it's a banger 10/10. To put it simply you just choose to stay behind and not move forward. I'm not saying that retail has no faults but it has actual gameplay rather than spamming frostbolts for maximum dps (which literally not a soul on this earth can justify as a "fun and engaging gameplay" and fighting bosses with 1 mechanic that people still fail to this day.

[@tallwyn]

Dunno if it was mentioned, but Item Identity is super important. You see that warrior and Ashkandi, you know where he went to, to get it. Same for armor. Once you play enough, epsecially in PVP, you can judge how a matchup with another player will go purely based on the gear they wear and you can see that almost at a glance.

[@alexclaton]

"people want to play a game that rewards knowledge and preparation thats chill and doesnt require twitch reflexes" thats a bingo!

[@Oxenia01]

Exactly, I don't know when reaction time became the only thing praised as skillfull but it's such a shitty community take. Preperation and patience, calculated risks and decisions can be skillfull too in their own way.

[@Mart-E12]

There many 20 year old games I still play. And the lord of the rings trilogy is still a masterpiece

[@dorsia6938]

1999-2009 was peak art for music, film and video games.

[@Mart-E12]

So many good games from 2004-2006

[@Viltreta]

To me, TBC will always be the expansion that felt like an actual expansion of the previous version. It was truly Vanilla+.

[@Junesong_777]

No it wasn't. It still deleted Azeroth. Level 60 endgame content in Vanilla still used the base game. In TBC, once you left the dark portal you never truly came back.

[@brimstonevalar6053]

​@@Junesong_777sure I agree but I still had fun in TBC with my guild doing dungeons and raids, overall I can play vanilla, tbc and wotlk and enjoy them all.

[@NekoinValhalla]

Sure. Cutting 15 people from your raids felt so vanilla. TBC wasn't bad but it was the beginning of the downfall. It just wasn't that much palpable then.

[@LouisKing995]

@@Junesong_777Hut getting there was still a long and meaningful experience. (And Kara made you come back for endgame anyway). Compared to modern wow where levelling is blink and you missed it.

[@chc2650]

Having fun from TBC doesnt take away from the fact that it ruined the game. Level cap should have never been expanded, and loot should have never been made easier to get.

[@fourjhin_cookies]

man this guy hit the nail on the head with why older mmo design is preffered by various people. As for not having as many resources back then, I think that also contributed to the fun. I mean when I played Elden Ring there was next to zero information online and I loved it.

[@morganfreeman5260]

🤦

[@Syrlantar]

the real beginning of the end was in TBC when they changed the Daily Quest cap from 10 a day to 25 a day. I remember celebrating because it meant i didn't have to pick and choose which dailies to do - i could grind it all. fast forward to current retail where you have a billion different things you HAVE to grind or you're behind

[@metallixro]

Vanilla WoW, and to a certain extent TBC, is the most fun Ive ever had in a video game. But its a combination of the times, the game and the community and this combination will never repeat itself.

[@BLSKauthor]

Having Played 4 hours(currently) of Retail... I find some questions with the position on the game... some of the changes like Enemies Level up with you... even on low level quests odd... it doesn't really change anything... testing out one or 2 things outside of that... but... its a level 1 or level 20 quest... why are mine level 20 on a like level 10 quest... curious but so far... minor as I do dunk on the mobs... lots of changes I can even Mention because too vast... I almost feel like: 1) Taking a Puppy and setting it in front of me(10 puppies still feel relevant currently) 2) Chaining it up so it can't move 3)Bashing it's skull easily and over and over 4) Feeling I have played this in some Mobiles.... not sure about later game yet... but it does add questions... 5)(seperate) I found myself at a Portal that lead to 'OTHER PORTALS' I felt so lost... I questioned each portal and so on.... I feel lost even though I know half of what I should know XD so sad Just to state: (Choosing a Genre so to speak) Yep can't be sure where I stand

[@chrispyy99]

"Why are we still here? Just to suffer?"

[@mikegonzalez9490]

In Vanilla, you get to be part of something. A group, a raid, the world, which is difficult to navigate, you get mobbed up and you'll die alone. It forces you to be social.

[@Tport712]

With Classic + you said don't give it updated graphics but I just don't think that is possible. I think that they can definitely increase the fidelity but go back to a classic Style. I think they should restart. Send us back to the beginning but let's take the story in a different direction. Keep the other ones for nostalgia/ testing. Stop retail where it is and don't continue story just make it a sandbox for testing indefinitely. Classic needs to be sectioned off, having it go through the xpacs again makes no sense. However having servers just meant for each expansion then that would make sense. Classic+ should be something new with something old and make the perfect game.

[@sm4sh3d]

40 yo here, I loved WoW vanilla and I loved Burning Crusade even more. I had to drop the game a little bit after WoLK came out because I just didn't have the time to play it properly, life catches up to you at some point and you need to make choices. While I still play stuff almost daily, I rarely can put more than 1 or 2 hours in it and I'll never enjoy a mmorpg if I can't sink at least 6 hours/day into it. But I still have fond memories of long evenings in NC, ZG, BWL, Karazhan Tempest Keep, Black Temple, Sunwell Plateau... Not to mention fighting in Alterac Valley and farming on many wonderful and unique regions. I understand why people who have time are still playing it it's a good effing game and gives you more memorable experiences than any other game.

[@Thezuule1]

That's my big issue. When I played WoW it was a time in my life I could sit and play 12 hours a day if I wanted. I have a wife and kids and work overtime now. Even if I could shave off the time to play I wouldn't want to. I have too many hobbies already fighting for my attention.

[@Fungus8mycrab]

I remember when I played WoW the only time I added people to my friends list was people I roleplayed with. Otherwise there was absolutely no incentive/reason to friend people. I had a lot more reason to add people on classic compared to retail because of how it encourages you to interact with other people.

[@alexbishop5004]

Vanilla wow was great, from the first warlock I ever roll, to my eventual prot warrior who got the Krol Blade from a trash mob in WPL. Later, I advocated that the TF was an amazing weapon for tanks, and no one believed me until I think Death and Taxes and another guild did it. We had 2 people(dps) get the left binding, and then gquit the guild shortly after. Then it was my turn when our 3rd left binding dropped, and then it took a YEAR for the right binding to drop for us, no cascading. Once I got that weapon, I was beating quite a few DPS in our raids... and back when threat was actually something you had to manage, it was a god send. Gone were the days of tanking onyxia with no chest, because you had too much avoidance and didn't get any rage to hold aggro. Another fun moment was with the TF in Warsong Gulch, fighting against Unfadable of Laughing Skull. The match went on for about an hour with only 1 score. An old guildiee who was "pvp leading" them eventually came on our own ventrillo to declare they were forfeiting, because they weren't prepared to fight a raid boss for 3 hours. Best moment ever though was the silithus AQ questline build-up. A guild mate, Demonic, and I were standing over the horde at the mouth of a hive, while all the alliance were standing at the very top of the path leading out of the hive(bottleneck, fight was GOING to happen). I slipped and fell inside 80+ horde, and just started wailing on everyone with the TF. Alliance charged in, Demonic, a mage, jumped down, and when the dust settled... Banana Boyz and Unfadable were dead, and we were still standing. Alliance won the AQ gate opening quest race for Laughing Skull. I just don't experience or hear stories like that in todays Wow. - Mockingcrow(V A N Q U I S H)

[@yozao5736]

Nostalgia goes a long way. It's also a solid game given the primitives. Original WoW broke boundaries and took chances being the easiest MMORPG for its time and still ended up having decent depth and well paced progression.

[@DS-mv2lk]

I sometimes think of a parallel universe where Asmongold is a Runescape streamer.

[@AkSpark90]

Flying anywhere and everywhere is one of the points that killed the game for me... While running you would actually run into other players, interact, buff, do an emote, maybe its an enemy from the other faction and you have some action...

[@Valkyrie4444]

Asmon: "because it's so long and hard, it feels better to beat it"

[@yaddayamean7769]

Man Asmon be speaking FACTS when talking about Wow. 💯💯

[@AC-cg6gz]

I am 3rd generation WOW out of 5. My Mom(R.I.P.) and Granny(R.I.P.) played and my son and grandson now play. It is now a part of our heritage!

[@preslim84]

One of the reasons i've realised recently is that I love that there's so much downtime / running that its a great game to play while watching youtube or streams. Like if i'm going to do those anyways, why not play classic?

[@CyberFreaked]

At level 30 in classic as human, there is a quest in SW where you have to go back to Northshire abbey and it feels so cool to come back there for the first time after lvl 5

[@HierophanticRose]

ive been playing ascension on vanilla xp and mob difficulty, and having a blast making my Elunite Warpriest :D My fav thing to do in vanilla is to level chill while keeping up with my gear/professions and money. There is no better feeling than hitting a level bracket and already having crafted a set gear for that level bracket.

[@droganstv]

I've played WoW from release to DF, and my brother played it till Wrath before he quit. Whenever we share stories from our history with this game 90% of our stories are from original vanilla.

[@fransken4412]

One of my most memorable moments in Classic all those years ago was in Redridge, after doing a quest for some orcs, I saw a path, the terrain got darker and I saw this large, busted open gate. "Damn, this place looks scary, I wanna check it out!" I didn't get far before I saw some skull level imps. I shouldn't mess with those, but they're also just imps I thought, so I pushed my luck and tried to explore further. Obviously I didn't get far. Being able to return much later, now armed with levels, gear and experience, I had my revenge. I felt like I was at the top of the world, until I got my teeth kicked in by Volchan. I had a new goal. I haven't had a similar experience in WoW outside of Classic, except maybe Fel Reaver in TBC to some extent.

[@DadGamer247]

All the woke pc bs nowadays. Why ppl try to instill their political agendas into gaming is beyond me. I just want to play a fun and well developed game without all the bullshit.

[@wizardlyfrog]

Basically: As an example, Guild Wars 1 and Guild Wars 2 have very, very different gameplay. The developers realized and acknowledged this, resulting in the two versions being separate. Had Blizzard recognized this at Cataclysm, and made a "WoW2" they would have had greater success in general: The hardcore/hesitant player-base that did not enjoy the changes could stick to the previous versions, and gently adapt to the new gameplay at leisure. New players would have been able to approach the WoW2 version, and have a community more aligned with their casual playstyle. If those new players then decide to try WoW1 for a different vibe or to experience the old lore, Blizzard is still making money with minimal effort to maintain their older servers. They could have even charged a higher base price for Cata by labelling it WoW2, and kept the same exact engine. The bitterness that came after Cataclysm resulted from removing features, not change alone. All they had to do was make a separate continuation, stop updating lore/expansions in WoW1(legacy support), and continue updating/implementing vanity items for both. They just could not let go of their "you don't want that" mentality, and they payed a multi-year long price. FFXIV has been pretty good the last few, gotta say.

[@Krsto777]

“Because it’s so long and hard, it feels better to beat it”. Words to live by my man

[@joshuamercer1376]

Came here to say this

[@biffgordon5775]

Haha same. Someone needs to make a clip of this

[@whisped8145]

11:30 Oh no, you're completely right. That's because Vanilla Dungeons were real dungeons. They seemed alive, real places, used. Not every mob needs to be there to be beaten, to be an obstacle in the path. They can be there as fluff to make it look more real too. Maraudon was a great example of that, as was Lower Blackrock Spire. That dungeon was an entire city where you could decide where to go INSIDE of it, not with 3 boring portals outside that then ended in just 3 lame tunnels. Everything past vanilla is just long tunnels, that one and only path, and mandatory mobs in your way. That is not adventure. UBS was adventure. Stratholme's a similar example, as well as Scholomance. That undead city on the island in the open world full of high level elite mobs was great. You just wouldn't go in there alone, or at least very very carefully. Just like pre-patch Silithus. There was only that one questline for the abandoned outpost, but exploring that place was just immense fun. Part because of the mobs, part because of the tension and mystery. Later WoW has none of that.

[@Kurthimself]

The simple joy of vanilla Alterac Valley can never be properly replicated or renewed and if you missed out on that you will never understand peak early 2K gaming.

[@Thezuule1]

I remember one single game of AV lasting like 36 hours on our server. Lok'holar is my homie.

[@StefanCM15]

"They are at the bridge! Defend the bridge!" Epic battles were fought in that valley... and then the TBC-prepatch came out and it was just a passing by and a race to run through first...

[@The_InFamous_El_Guapo]

His example about his mom not making any new friends after Wrath, same, until Classic hit, I didnt add anyone to my friends lists.

[@dwayne75]

because unfortunately no MMO in the last 15 years is actually significantly better even with how relatively worse wow is

[@Tommy_The_Gun]

I mean, if you ask some one who never played WoW, but was hoping to eventually "try it out" to see why the badly aged game was (or stil is) so popular, you will probably hear that they will be shocked about the monetisation model. I mean, game from 2004 costs more to play now than when it was new. On top of that, you can not just buy & play if you just want to "try out" new DLC... New players will undoubtedly point out that there are SO MANY pay-gates even to just try out new stuff. WoW simply seems to have very bad price-to-content ratio. Almost as if it was made only for the players who play this game since a long time & are already invested. There is this ilusion of "premium" game by making stuff overpriced, like in a Starbucks or Apple products. So players who are not biased towards or against WoW, will just to a cold calulation of money spend vs what it gives me and 90% of times will bounce off & try other game instead.

[@litterbox2010]

Because there's no other mmos.

[@knowwhoiamyet]

I think there's a place in the market for both streamlined and formulaic MMOs, like FF14 (it is VERY formulaic, dungeons follow the same pattern of packs to bosses, dungeons at certain level gaps consistently, patch content you know when raids will be and how many, etc etc.), a game that's very menu based in your selection of content, but also casual friendly, and has a lot of other features for players to engage with. But classic MMOs, the grindy, inconvenient time sinks that don't streamline you, find groups for you, have fast travel, etc., they also have a place on the market for people that want something to really sink their teeth into and dedicate time into. Both can exist. We don't have to choose.

[@candykit5382]

Frankly half the reason is nostalgia. People can't let go of the past and playing games over and over from 20 years ago. Current stuff is too different and the past things were better. Same as your grandpa who pines for the older better days. Thats you now. New stuff is too hard, too complicated, older is better, etc etc. The game just isnt as good nowadays and people dont wanna accept that.

[@ykonratev]

That can't be the only reason at the end of the day gameplay is all that matters. If there were actually good mmos out there then I'm sure many would play them...

[@candykit5382]

@@ykonratev thats what people like to say. What is gameplay? Just the reactiveness of buttons? If so elden ring and dark souls are trash as many weapons have noticable huge swing delays between you hitting a button and an animation and damage completing. Gameplay is everything as a whole, and wows gameplay is extremely simple and basic. Every facet of gameplay in wow is criticized by people like asmon, telegraphing is bad, snapshotting is bad, aoes not matching the size of the attack on the ground is bad, affixes are bad, color layering red on red on red is bad, visibility is bad. The only good part about wows combat is its responsiveness in feedback to clicks and dodging. Too bad everything else is mid at best.

[@marfurion1570]

It's a form of morphic resonance. We subconsciously detect the passion and mental frameworks underlying the development of something

[@leonardceres9061]

I feel like the viewership for modern. Wow has gone down because it’s just not that exciting. There’s no challenge to the game anymore. Good loot drops are all over the place. Modern wow is a great example of when you quality of life a game to death. It’s gotten to the point where they have updated the spirit out of the game.

[@rahn45]

In Vanilla even if you were 60 you were still in a lot of ways 'squishy', and a lot of the old dungeons could still kill you if you were careless. This isn't to mention due to how the game was itemized the old dungeons often had useful items for niche fights. The developers knew how to overlap content so that even at max level you had reasons to visit older content. Open world areas that were designed as if they were dungeons, dungeons that were designed like a raid. Since there was so much overlap a high level person travelling from point A to get to point B might run across a lower level between the two and spend a few minutes helping out with a quest. Everything just got pushed more and more into single areas. Grind for tokens instead of drops. Make drops the same regardless of dungeon. Make all of the best stuff only available in raids, and make sure that it's better by so much that dungeon drops are pointless. Get rid of all item attributes. Get rid of talents and professions perks. All of this just so people can't make 'bad' choices about anything. Raiding ultimately ruined the game, and it all began when developers talked about how less than 1% of the player base ever set foot inside Nax, let alone completed it.

[@Nayrock]

Only thing I like that came out after Classic was Transmog and RBGs

[@toprogress]

I have thought about it recently and I think WoW Vanilla has more flavor overall. It feels like when the game was developed, the developers were loving their projects and put love and a part of themselves into it. I don’t know if the game was designed to make money in the first place, but it feels very immersive.

[@tylerbreau4544]

Back then games were designed to be fun and people were sold an experience. Nowadays games are designed to make money.

[@celticnoble5650]

A thought that occurred to me while watching that Uldaman clip is that a lot of the mystery has been scrubbed away. Retail overexplains way too much. Like I don't need to know what the afterlife is like or what the Titans had for lunch.

[@apset6172]

Even after many years, Classic wow is the only game where I can instantly recognize specific in-game items just by looking at a player character, and I can even recall the names of these items aint that crazy?

[@brazensmusings2738]

Vanilla WoW has a special place in my heart. I actually was introduced to it by my first employer, I had to be a GM on his private server for 2 hours everyday as part of my work time haha.

[@NoFlare]

Classic dungeons are by far the best. I love kicking back with some wine and playing classic

[@Nick-Ramondo]

Will never forget when I saw a level 45 shadow priest in shadow form, when I was a fresh toon in Dun Morogh. I think it’s part of the reason I eventually switched mains to spriest many years later

[@matsu9999]

another thing that has destroyed the current game was, adding cross-servers. lfr and such. each server was its own bubble back then, you saw the same people each day, duelling etc.

[@aurei7775]

Classic vs modern wow probably has parallels of surviving hundreds of years ago vs today. Hundreds of yrs ago the Difficulty might not have been there in daily life routines, probably less stressful, but you had to be prepared months in advance or the winter would eat you up. Vs today everything is at your fingertips but there are other competitive problems, you have to be much more skilled to make it in todays world.

[@cottonbomb8272]

A good game is like a good story. You open the book and find a new world, you exploring in it having fun, the story lead you to deeper and the conflict arising, at certain points it get to the climax, it's such a epic experience and then it ends in glory and you close the book. Blizzard doesn't want to close the book, and the book is getting worse.

[@anonimowelwiatko9811]

And just like a good story, you don't mind if it has sequel or is part of the saga. As long as it has destination, never forgets what it was initially and just adds on good or best parts of it. It can be three books (LotR), can be five, eight (Witcher, HP, though it starts to get tedious and ending has to be very satisfying). WoW on other hand... it partially was and was not continuation of it's own story and definitely was not more of the best. It was experimenting and adapting to trends which changed it to something else.

[@jamesbondisamonkey]

If you have ever gotten slowfall and journeyed off the map to crazy unfinished zones, or high atop the cliffs of the badlands, or jumped on top of stormwind gate, or climbed inside of zul gurub from the hidden tree in duskwood, this was a true adventure. The exploration of wow classic was never created again in any of their games, and neither was the freedom or user experience. I kited teremus the devourer from the blasted lands, a 17 minute kite, all the way to stormwind and watched as he killed player after player ...the things you could do in this game, were just amazing. Blizzard built a giant world, and let people roam free, and that's what adventure is all about. Now people just read an online guide and copy, or netdeck in card games, and the internet has accidentally ruined the freedom and adventure that existed long ago. Be very careful in life, because sometimes when you get more convenience, you lose a bit of your spirit and soul in the process, and that's what the world is becoming...a controlled and optimized simulation, where people become robots, and in this sense, technological innovation has destroyed gaming, and much of the human spirit.

[@Nivolasy]

I Think preparation is a really undervalued part of RPGs. I really liked Witcher 1 for that. (At least on the first playthrough and on the higher difficulties) Do defeat a monster you had to learn about it, craft potions and use the right fighting stance to not get killed by the monster. Its also the part about Grounded I liked: you want to go into the sand? Well the sun will burn you unless you wear the right armour, hide in the shadow or go at night. But you get the priciple. Its way more interersting, fun and satisfying to harvest materials and hunt specific monsters to prepare for a greater challengen, then do the next sidequest you cant be bothered to read the story of, where you kill 15 Rabid Rabbits and collect their fur for 100xp and a belt that is 3% better than yours. Feels more organic in the world. You play a game, not an excel spread sheet.

[@anonimowelwiatko9811]

To be honest Vanilla didn't have enough of this. Idea of resistance gear (fire for MC, nature for AQ, ice for Naxx) was extremally cool but it was half assed at best. You didn't need fire res for MC (or a lot of it, maybe MT/OT?) or Nature for AQ (except for Princess?). Ice was used on Sapphiron. Shadow if I remember well was used on one of Four Horsemen. Still, usually normal raiding gear had these resistances but pre-raid gear resistances were not necessary.

[@cavestudios8944]

Childhood, nostalgia. Wanting to go back to a simpler, better time. Life had more colour and more magic. A beloved old game, book or series is the closest thing to a time machine.