Vedas predicted everything, or did they? | Critical thinking 101

[@scienceisdope]

Support me at: Buymeacoffee: buymeacoffee.com/scienceisdope Patreon: www.patreon.com/scienceisdope_ UPI: scienceisdope@icici

[@risenrisenrise]

Hey! U should make a video on how indians got the technology to build such amazing temples! I would like to hear u on that topic.

[@Vizrd58]

@@risenrisenriseAwesome engineers, Trial and error, professional architects, immense budget and labour. No aliens, no futuristic tech, no lasers... I would bet that today's engineers and architects can build 100x better temples if they had the same budget. I mean just look at ISS we have built a lab In space iN thE fREakinG SpACe

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

@@Vizrd58 👍

[@adarshkumaryadav9758]

Hello Pranav make a video on a channel called HYPERQUEST ..

[@moulikgupta6979]

bro regrow the beard back you looked 10X better😭

[@puneetmaheshwari]

the saddest part about these prediction is it only takes 1min to draw these parallels but it take minimum 10min of explanation/monolog to explain why they r not "scientific"

[@shashwatpandey7939]

and 100 years to make the scientific discovery.

[@puneetmaheshwari]

@@shashwatpandey7939 soo tru (until superAI enters teh chat😭)

[@gamingandtechnoworld8407]

Comforting lie >>> bitter truth

[@samarth_raghuvanshi]

There is one important thing I'd like to share with everybody is that, “please be compassionate and understanding to any other person who's views you don't agree with. Berating and making fun won't get us anywhere if what we want to spread is scientific temperament.” Take me for example, I used to be like the guy in the video, being proud of Hinduism after watching those wrong and absurd connections between scientific literature and vedas, and hated any form of criticism against them but as I got to know more about the other side of the story, more I developed scientific temperament and critical thinking, but with this also came ‘arrogance’ that I'm better than these morons who are stuck with these non-sensical ideas. Instead of having proper discussion with a person I didn't agree with, I was having a full on banter and mocking them. *I jumped from one extreme to another. Please be aware of it, just because you don't agree with someone, doesn't mean he/she is below you, always be respectful. And understand where he's coming from, than only we can see changes or else it'll only a fight between two extremes!*

[@sharadkumardubey9004]

Yes ,I have had similar experience...and I think I was arrogant even when I was with the Pseudoscience team and was arrogant also when I came to the rational side. The arrogance of knowing more than other people and being better than others...this I think is within every one and it goes away with time...I am in the process of reducing my arrogance and I think it will go on forever...but certainly it reduces with time never becoming zero but decreasing ...like the grapgh of e^(-x) ;)

[@SukhveerSingh-kw1ve]

Its so true bro, I also feel the same.

[@_dxpk]

@@sherloc10 vedanta ( 1 of 6 schools of thoughts of Hinduism ) is only a part of Hinduism, there are further two parts of vedanta philosophy ( dvait and advait ) one of them is highly inspired by Buddhism vedanta also means last parts of Vedas which r also known as upnishads so no only vedanta is not Hinduism Hinduism consists of various texts like puranas dharmsutras smritis itihahas etc

[@sherloc10]

@@_dxpk don't give Abrahamic Copy paste definition of Hinduism from google Vedas/vedant are the oldest and at centre. We should focus on that first And then try to understand the other There are many corruptions in society accumulated over the centuries many of which have taken the disguise of Culture..and people follow it without reasoning India a not Abrahamic. In a civilization a society should learn from what went bad reject that and proceed with good.

[@_dxpk]

@@sherloc10 your Adi Shankaracharya quotes from various dharmsutras n smritis upholding their authenticity Adi Shankaracharya for sure more credible than a faceless KZbin comment or anyone go first learn about Hinduism ( not from some youtuber )

[@rabikiranpanda2199]

0:50Maybe just maybe,we can leave Aditi a bit alone. Everybody bullies her for her short height. She is a good girl.

[@aftabansari2010able]

In my college, most boys had a crush on her 🥴🥴🥴

[@f12736]

Who is Aditi?

[@kalebj7001]

@@f12736 Kabhi kabhi aditi zindagi mein yuhi koi apna lagta hai, Kabhi kabhi aditi wo bichad jaaye to ek sapna lagta hai, Aise mein koi kaise apne aasuon ko behne se roke?

[@niccolopaganini1782]

The aditi I know is also a shortie

[@dinkarupadhyay]

Aditi in my college is also tiny

[@satyasaranpatra]

Going to come back here when the angry vedas supremacy proclaimers comment

[@viccysd]

+1

[@yuvinaveen8705]

let me bring my popcorn

[@curiosity_fan]

*offended vedas supremacy...

[@rmj-zh3hy]

And ....

[@rrlegend1850]

vedas are really supreme

[@tanishqpandey9564]

As a critical thinker and someone who is learning science and philosophy I don't understand why people don't just study the actual philosophical texts such as Upanishads or just study science critically. Like why do we come to all this BS made to just elevate our pride which the "hindu dharma" opposes itself. It's seriously such an important thing to promote critical thinking and actual Indian philosophy and Empirical sciences hand to hand not just the bogus things going in the market. You're doing a great job yourself Pranav ♥️.

[@slayingswordrxrr1377]

Lwda dharma

[@tanishqpandey9564]

@@slayingswordrxrr1377 okay bro 🤓

[@frankcastle1862]

@@slayingswordrxrr1377 this is the reason why there is a gap between the different populas so much hatred for the other group that it destroys any communication or understanding to be made

[@tattvamashi]

@@slayingswordrxrr1377 People are getting away from their culture; they are forgetting their moral values. They don't know how to respect others. Using abusive words is not cool; it's foolishness. People can be atheists while still consuming moral values from their culture's scriptures like the Mahabharata, Ramayana, Puranas, and Upanishads. Your moral values will enhance!

[@RealCherry8085]

@@slayingswordrxrr1377 i am not religious but still using slurs against anything is disgusting its just sence of Ignorance and Frustration.

[@Rationalgeography1]

Where is my "galiyan nikalo" "you're brainwashed by west " "do other religions not ours" gang at??

[@anishlale4330]

I was wondering the same 😂😅

[@_dxpk]

brainwashed by west gang is my favourite :D

[@deepakmt92]

There is a new gang called, "your so called science" and continues to use the internet, electronic devices and all which are the products of this "so called" science🤣. They are even oblivious to the fact that they are alive because of this "so called" science (National Immunization Schedule)😅

[@hehehehehehe7878]

Well he didn't said the Vedas are wrong, he just made completely different point that science can have it's failure but ok, aren't we here discussing Vedas and Science ?

[@nazimrizvi7743]

By the way your name and ur behavior is showing irony

[@Thanos-hp1mw]

Bro this is so helpful! No joke, I have a presentation on The Scientific Method and Falsifiablility in 2 days. I was already doing my research and this is an extremely nice addition!

[@uusimaa5646]

wow, what are you studying?

[@Thanos-hp1mw]

@@uusimaa5646 computer science but I have a mandatory communication course. We had to pick any topic to present on and I had picked this one.

[@chaoticneutral7573]

​@@Thanos-hp1mw Hows going searching infinite stones ?

[@jackyjack9660]

@@uusimaa5646 What did you find 'wow' in this?

[@pratyushghimire1143]

​@@jackyjack9660A boy studying computer science prolly is intelligent she is a girl so ya she may wanna marry him so 'wow' He mentioned scientific methods and falsifiability it's a new term for her maybe she was fascinated Seeing that she didn't reply to him for weeks maybe the fascination vanished away I'm also a computer science student and haven't done my practical tomorrow is the submission 😥

[@Beckham6578]

I will become father in upcoming 10 years...See, I can predict my future 💀

[@Endrin911]

Omg..May be you're a future prophet.

[@manishmalviya1620]

@@Endrin911 😁🤣

[@random_shit_online6104]

Not if youre impotent

[@Endrin911]

@@random_shit_online6104 No problem at all, bro He can edit and twist his scripture aka prediction or may be he can claim its a metaphor and 'being father' means being guardian of his followers 😁

[@xrayz3207]

what if you die,or get castrated

[@yuvinaveen8705]

*some new discovery happens in science Conspiracy theorists : My time has come.! I need to relate it with some random texts written thousands of years ago.

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

😂

[@kaizen_monk]

They are pseudo scientists..their job is to associate every scientific discoveries from Religious texts & claim we already knew it 😅😅😆🤣

[@vivekgarg561]

Kuki science ki bat krege to kon dekhega

[@IndiaAgainstSlaveryIAS]

If only they could spend that much time and energy in researching the actual science than in researching the connection between some past texts and current science

[@pauldirc..]

@@IndiaAgainstSlaveryIAS prople who even can't solve first order differential equation, teach quantum mechanics to other by using buzzwords like maya , energy, vibrations Physics without mathematics is just philosophy But people are too busy in over glorifying their past , like finding rocket science and 5 g technology in vedas Yeah vedas was great and ancient indian have contributed greatly in science like aryabhatta , panini and more but science is more advance now from transistors to computer to Ai to advancement in medical science all belongs to modern science

[@HolyRamanRajya]

This is where Skepticism, Empiricism and Rationality combine together to establish critical thinking around scientific research. To that end, modern cooking, linguistics, mixology, history, even art courses a lot many unexpected things today fall under Science because of them. Falsifiability is the base for the three epistemologies. Falsifiability-Empiricism is one thing that Charvak-Lokyat philosophy got right among all bs Indian philosophies; that only pratyaksh(empirical senses) can be a source of Truth, not Pramana, not Anumana(Estimation/Inference), not Anupulabdhi(inter/extrapolation) and most certainly never Shabd(passed down word of mouth infallible knowledge)

[@HolyRamanRajya]

@@pratapmandal1046 1. Its not outright denial, but attaching a degree of falsifiability to inference for future revisions e.g. Newton's gravity, potentially Einstein's relativity. 2. Again Pratyaksh is just acknowledgement of what empirical senses directly or indirectly can percieve. What we percieve is often correlation and Correlation is not always causation. This is another way to insert falsifiability. 3. Never encountered this, so cant say anything here. Charvak-lokyat has no proper direct written records anymore so is it possible there are "variants" of it based on location? I prefer to stick to the epistemology rather than the ancient abstractions and explanations on top of it. I would bet the ones who wrote this Svabhavada or something similar, did not want their followers to consider it as infallible truth but thats just my opinion.

[@HolyRamanRajya]

@@pratapmandal1046 Also I only implied Charvak-lokyat to be ahead of the other ancient Indian schools and probably the closest among them to Modern thought. I did not say Charvak-Lokyat is at par with modern thought; at best it is a stepping stone which if ancient Indians had chosen to develop deeper they could have progressed parallely with other civilizations.

[@sukritdubey2630]

The great irony is that there are verses in the Rig Veda which express doubt over the question of who created the universe or even if there was any creation at all (Nasadiya Sukta). There is enough room for self-reflection, self-correction and skepticism in our ancient culture however it seems in an attempt to amplify pride people have gone backwards with regards to their own intellectual legacy.

[@purptube678]

THIS, people in our past had disagreements, discussions and thought a lot, totally not the case now

[@matrixsmarther2325]

We should consider the ancient texts as philosophy and as ideas.

[@anishbhanushali]

this is an underrated comment on this whole thread

[@kiwiwooq]

pride is a dangerous addiction

[@AritraChakrabarty-uf4gt]

True. Here's a link if anyone is wondering: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasadiya_Sukta. It actually shows that Vedas have been compiled by some ancient scholars and are not God-created. The interpretations changed over time.

[@sameer_katti]

I have a smart door that opens when I say "Alohomora". Our ancestor, JK Rowling predicted this way back. Now, I am creating a religion, "Potterism", where Harry Potter is my supreme lord. Everyone is free to join my religion, except people who have green eyes (descendants of Voldemort and Death eaters) since we hate them (sorry guys every religion needs to have an innocent community as their enemy)

[@am824]

Count me in. Jai pottery 🚩🚩

[@theodiscusgaming3909]

be careful you are going to get canceled by twitter. harry potter is now haram

[@bluewater9196]

💀💀

[@Zia_Ali.]

Verily, Lord Potter is our exalted savior and His teachings should be our guide in life! Whosoever does not believe that will be subject to eternal torment and torture in Azkaban

[@tattvamashi]

Do you have any philosophical book, like Upanishads or any moral or book of ethics, like Ramayana and Mahabharata,which teaches you moral value, how to respect other???? Hinduism is not about stories or any fictional character. It is about Morals, ethics, how to respect, how to behave, how to live a perfect lfe. Being an athiest, follower of Hinduism

[@CrimeEpisode1]

No Hate to Any Religion Or Culture But if Today's discoveries is already written in the books. Then I am sure there are so many Discoveries which is about to Happen I think that is also mentioned in this Texts Then let's just prove before it happens As Gaurav said (GetSetFlyScience) in his one of Live video 'Uss mai Quote kuch aur hota hai Aur ham samjh kuch aur lete hai'. The problem is we just want to feel proud Ignoring the Facts.

[@lollolol69]

But that guy also spreads pseudoscience lol

[@gargimahapatra3581]

Absolutely right

[@sourangshuchakraborty6945]

We earned my respect bro

[@AtTheCricketPitch]

You are right bro. We are in a society where people just want to feel proud to satisfy their religious ego and to do so they take the help of pseudoscience and false conspiracy theories of linking everything to their religious texts.

[@zz2793]

If someone says this to you, just ask them " Ok can you please invent/discover something new and big from those books now? We students or scientists won't have to study anymore to discover anything"

[@AkshayShukla.]

they'll reply, ab to "western" education ne kabza kar liya hai,

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

Vedas are concerned with experiencing Paramatma and the associated karmas and yoga required to achieve true understanding. Everything else is just an extension of it. Simply put the only useful knowledge is that which helps you towards enlightenment

[@smellyfut4277]

@@shreenivasrangarajan4378 define "enlightment"

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

@@smellyfut4277 ramana maharishi can explain that much better than anyone else. You might be aware of 'who am i' please do read that

[@zz2793]

@@shreenivasrangarajan4378 yes religious scriptures have knowledge for your faith and enlightenment or salvation, etc. People should stop saying that it has knowledge about every science and discoveries. Otherwise there's my Q above.

[@erenyaeger9407]

Forget about China and Pakistan, we're gonna compete with USA in the field of conspiracy theories. Pheeling Paraaood Indian Army 😎😎😎

[@yuvinaveen8705]

OMG it's Eren himself !!!

[@Shiven_Singh]

People call the vedas as apurusheya. I don't think Vedas Call themselves so. Vedas were written by those time's thinkers and scholars. They may be wrong also. In fact Nasadiya Sukta in Rig Veda questions the very existence and intelligence of So called Gods. It's time may be we should also start reading Vedas and not as a religious book but as a Philosophical work and figure out ourselves what's wrong and what's right

[@Manas-manthan-v3f]

500 quintals of wood burned in UP for Yagna to reduce pollution, please make videos on Gaumutra and Yagna it is important. 🙏🙏

[@idkjffifkfkrnwjwp]

yes please do this actually harms the environment and the biosphere as a whole

[@Pihu523]

Bruh😂up people are always like that.

[@omgupta-bz1th]

He should also make videos upon why Christians cut lakhs of tree for chritsmas

[@darshita1270]

the hindu side of indian social media is a circus in itself. and thanks to our awesome media literacy.

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

Majority of the people trying to make links between such scientific discoveries and our scriptures either lack knowledge of either subjects or do it for clout. As for those who raise the question whether reading vedas can provide platform for further discoveries - we honestly don't know since we no longer follow the gurukul system where Vedas are taught nor the varna system(not to be confused with caste)

[@RealCherry8085]

Considering the sheer size of Vedas and Other Hindu scriptures its actually a never ending show, they can always interpret it so many ways, now obviously those scriptures shouldn't be banned because of Freedom of religion and academic freedom. But its actually important to make everyone realize that they just a book. Like any other book one should only take ideas from it and not make it code of conduct.

[@sarthakarya02]

why ban them, hindu scriptures are prescriptive in nature not descriptive, these scriptures and hindu philosophy are ever evolving

[@nova_sw]

Couldn't have said it any better

[@mayursawant111]

​@@sarthakarya02 you must get your eyes checked for once.

[@sarthakarya02]

@@mayursawant111 for what for seeing truth or for showing people like you your ignorance

[@pizzaparkerhotdogmaguire3225]

They are not just a book. Not all books are equal. Modern science isn't as modern as people think either. There are things which are just beyond your control and no matter what you do, you aren't above them. That's where Vedas come on. People who think they are just a book, it's funny, let them. Each to their known. Not everyone can decode everything.

[@keerthi3086]

I tell you, you have a patience more than that of a saint. As a matter of fact, Sadhguru and Ramdev have publicly lost their cool when cornered by logic. I can't imagine the strength one needs to listen and analyze all these BS claims and stay calm. Thanks for the work you do!

[@hethekumar]

Rational Thinkers require so much calmness, it is better utilize a little bit of time to meditate and understand.

[@idkwhy77]

@@hethekumar no wonder those sages tried to learn about the world around them and they came to many great conclusions and fantastic discoveries, many also being debatable and probably "false" (in my eyes at least haha).. I think it is great that we can try to do this but I do wish many others in my class would take a moment to realize..

[@ShubhamBhushanCC]

Vedas predicted that you'll make this video!!

[@Vededits6542]

Bhimta

[@vivekgarg561]

@@Vededits6542 gobar ramte har koi bhimta nhi hota comment section me mostly upper caste h 🤣

[@Vededits6542]

@@vivekgarg561 tu toh bhimta hai 😂😂😂 mere idhar garg wale bhimte hi hai 😂😂 chamar 😆🖕

[@vivekgarg561]

@@Vededits6542 chup sale lunpujari gobarbhakt to kya teri tarah fictional hathi bandro ko God man lu ek bar science journey dekh tere linduism ki reality pta chal jaegi Or wese v ye hindu persian ne dia h🤣🤣🤣🤣 or phle khud k hi scriptures padh kitni illogical bate likhi h🤣🤣 aise illogical religion ko koi v lat mar dega mene padha to mene v lat mar di or tere bhgwan ko bol agr wo h to ham bhimto ko peda na kre 😔 jai varah avtar 🐷🐖

[@romilmahant2971]

@@Vededits6542 arey andbhakt galat channel mai kaha a gye

[@ompawar1493]

Nikhil chandwani is great man, he has helped lot of Hindus from Pakistan and is doing till date and advocate for Hindus and their suffering. So please help him in his quest against injustice done against Hindus around the world. Turly a great soul.

[@sumeetj3628]

The most important YT Channel of current indian times, Much needed

[@Aryan-gc6ze]

The most half began knowledge because India doesn't have a department in the culture and history of science . Still thinks church vs science story is true. Church established ivy league in past Even brought so called science which was already there in India at that time of period through Macaulay 1835 act .

[@dreamxd9331]

Bhadva Atheist channel mere Laude pe

[@govindkrishna7003]

I am a rationalist but to be honest every Vedic scholar describes Vedas in a different way so in order to challenge it we have to read them ourselves instead of relying on a KZbin Vedic expert. The Gods of Hinduism or for that matter any other religion are easier to debunk because their mere depiction is illogical but the scriptures are much more complex.

[@antulii5390]

What i find interesting, is that people who believe that everything proved by modern science now are in the vedas, have most likely never read the vedas and quote misleading sources. The truth is often not entertaining, but conspiracy videos like the Insta reel are.

[@priyanshunimbalkar]

1st comment...... Keep up the great work, and continue to use your platform to educate and empower your viewers to think critically about the information they encounter online.

[@Darkypekka]

To the people who keep saying that our ancestors knew what many modern scientists know or they had built those machines back then But I want to ask those people saying this do you know how the ancestors did this, you would have any clue only if have they given a manual to do so ...,, but they never gave. We are proud of our scientists because we know how they did but you people keep asking other people to prove how your ancestors did it. Now many people will say they had divine powers so they could do this, But are their divine powers of any use now are they helping us build any sort of device. now at this time, it is the scientists who are doing things, not your ancestors. Now you will say why people followed them back then. Earlier people had to do it because they had no choice they were kept away from knowledge by some smart people and when normal people tried to do things on their own smart people refused to help them by giving excuses of them having divine powers. which was not the case they wanted normal people to remain stupid and that is what many religious institutions do now, they just say people to follow things. and not ask questions Now if a normal person knows how to do things they can learn and do things on their own and not be dependent on anyone.

[@praneethb8037]

Thanks

[@siddharthsid3638]

Awesome bro.. your videos always tell core messages like skeptism, doubt and questions ..

[@thecuriousguy9734]

Is this sarcastic ?

[@Rational_Human1]

​@@thecuriousguy9734 I thought the same seeing ur comment.

[@AK-kn9ob]

In the course of the last thirty or forty years a huge pseudo-historical literature has sprung up in India, the melancholy product of a subject people’s inferiority complex. Industrious and intelligent men have wasted their time and their abilities in trying to prove that the ancient Hindus were superior to every other people in every activity of life. Thus, each time the West has announced a new scientific discovery, misguided scholars have ransacked Sanskrit literature to find a phrase that might be interpreted as a Hindu anticipation of it. A sentence of a dozen words, obscure even to the most accomplished Sanskrit scholars, is triumphantly quoted to prove that the ancient Hindus were familiar with the chemical constitution of water. Another, no less brief, is held up as the proof that they anticipated Pasteur in the discovery of the microbic origin of disease. A passage from the mythological poem of the Mahabharata proves that they had invented the Zeppelin. Remarkable people, these old Hindus. They knew everything that we know or, indeed, are likely to discover, at any rate until India is a free country; but they were unfortunately too modest to state the fact baldly and in so many words. A little more clarity on their part, a little less reticence, and India would now be centuries ahead of her Western rivals. But they preferred to be oracular and telegraphically brief. It is only after the upstart West has repeated their discoveries that the modern Indian commentator upon their works can interpret their dark sayings as anticipations. On contemporary Indian scholars the pastime of discovering and creating these anticipations never seems to pall. Such are the melancholy and futile occupations of intelligent men who have the misfortune to belong to a subject race. Free men would never dream of wasting their time and wit upon such vanities. From those who have not shall be taken away even that which they have. Aldous Huxley - Jesting Pilate: An Intellectual Holiday (1926). pp. 141-143.

[@therationalindian7]

I get a newsletter every-week and the latest one had the same thing on how to differentiate science from "pseudoscience". It said the same, that the models given by science would "fail" when the underlying conditions necessary are not there. This doesn't happen with pseudoscience, they are never wrong :) Do you follow that newsletter too?

[@lollolol69]

What newsletter?

[@perfumedfart1527]

What newsletter man?

[@vishpraveen1]

Thanks!

[@scienceisdope]

Thank you!

[@WorldandSumeet]

Just imagine. Thousands of years later people talking about us predicting Skynet taking over the world using machines or Humans taking over Pandora or People using the Force to become Jedi Knights.

[@pauldirc..]

prople who even can't solve first order differential equation, teach quantum mechanics to other by using buzzwords like maya , energy, vibrations Physics without mathematics is just philosophy But people are too busy in over glorifying their past , like finding rocket science and 5 g technology in vedas Yeah vedas was great and ancient indian have contributed greatly in science like aryabhatta , panini and more but science is more advance now from transistors to computer to Ai to advancement in medical science all belongs to modern science

[@AbhiramN_1289]

It is the very vagueness that allowed a so many philosophical schools in India. In ancient India philosophers would make their own views of realities and try to find relevant Vedic verses. What Indians are doing today is something like that.

[@villianbehindglasses8969]

Hello! I started watching your videos a while ago. I am a devout Hindu. I believe in God 100%. But I also love watching your videos. There are people who say " "watching such videos will make you loose faith" well, I still have faith. I just view things as they are and not by the lens of something extraordinary. I can call out bullshit that's in our scriptures too. We must forsake the negatives by first looking at them as a negative. Only then can we move ahead as humans.

[@hethekumar]

You are the first commenter on this page with some sense. Have a happy life man

[@IndiaAgainstSlaveryIAS]

Amazing, this is the kind of attitude which is needed 🙌🏼

[@whatyoudoin3125]

You can't pick and choose from scriptures & than call yourself hindu. Either Believe it all, or trash it all.

[@villianbehindglasses8969]

@@whatyoudoin3125 This is an example of extremism. I take what's good and chuck the rest. I am not an extremist. I don't like how women are treated inferior to men in our scriptures. That's why all the big epics, religious texts were written exclusively by men. The women we read about in these epics are also from a male pov. Aside from philosophers like Gargi, saints like Meerabai, Anandamai Ma, we do not have a good female pov. Even the last 2 are pretty modern compared to the dating of our epics. Extremism divides the world my friend. Ultimately, if people become 1% more loving daily, we wouldn't need religion.

[@whatyoudoin3125]

@@villianbehindglasses8969 The point, why do you even want to take some "good things" from the scriptures? Don't you already know what's good, Why even need to have moral compass set on just one Scripture ? And if you say , "i just don't only get good morals from the scripture, but also believe in the gods Mentioned in the scriptures" than only you can somewhat claim to be hindu but alas... What God would write such weirdly immoral things that you can't even accept hence you not accepting god.

[@insanesam0827]

Your channel is a breath of fresh air

[@agnostic_aarif4676]

first compare your religion with science* Random rationalist: (Debunked with scientific fact) They: Umm Hindu/islam/Christianity phobic😭😭

[@thelife_game0157]

I want you to cover the topics of ghost hunting and paranormal activities where they claim of using electromagnetic field detecting devices to stop them.

[@frontman4736]

watch jay alani's video on this

[@random22453]

its just nonsense clickbaiting

[@yd6094]

As a Hindu I would like to say that though now it is proved that the earth is round and earth revolve around sun and theory of evolution. It was not know in western world before 17th century but Hindu Vedas knew it and had mentions in scripture. But we don't mind you criticising you Hindus vedas but surely we are waiting for you to criticize prophet flying on donkey cutting the moon in half and surely the best of all the flat earth theory....

[@Prathmesh_369]

Exactly 💯

[@JimedBro]

Cool, why don't you back it up with a page source

[@yd6094]

@@JimedBro dude it's a word used since centuries.. "bhugol " for earth in Sanskrit which literally means round earth... it doesn't need any page to substantiate. Just google the word for earth geography in Sanskrit and you will know..

[@JimedBro]

@@yd6094 Googled it, Bhugol just meant Geography no round earth

[@yd6094]

@@JimedBro sorry I didn't know I have to be this specific. Now we know bhugol means geography of earth . Now search sphere in Sanskrit and write the word in reply. I hope I don't have to explain any further then this.

[@sharmisthatralalala]

Hey can you elaborate on science and philosophy and how is it related or how do they differ? I think most of the misinformation and conspiracy theories would end if we could just recognize that.

[@Pantheist2602]

See Philosophy is the study of everything (which includes science and mathematics which is called Natural Philosophy).. that's the accurate meaning of the word in first place .. and what you mean may be philosophy of metaphysics, ethics etc . Different people have given different viewpoints on life and it's purpose from years ago (which includes both religious and non religious text) . Science (which is mostly material) has little to less relation to metaphysics ,ethics and logic.

[@thethreespikes9737]

I used to get mad at yo videos first. Now i love them. I may not agree with you fully most of the times. But you have kind of opened my mind to see things with pragmatic approach. Thanks man. Keep up the work. We need to develop scientific temprament 👍🏻

[@Aryan-gc6ze]

Colonial temperament Now present science and maths is based Christianity theology .

[@neerajvashisht5364]

@@Aryan-gc6ze Not even close...it doesn't have anything that leads to science and its methods....Theology is dogmatic in nature...and the followers of Christianity have killed multiple people who have discovered something that contradicts the bible.....science comes from modernity which means freedom from the burden of the past.

[@random22453]

@@Aryan-gc6ze modern science literally disagrees with christianity. have you heard of evolution. science has nothing to do with religion, politics or ideologies. Its literally just a tool to discover truth

[@sharadkumardubey9004]

Bro ...the intro was nice..quality getting better each day..🔥

[@anushnandanrao2483]

Amazing explanation bro, you wonderfully explained how science progresses and improves over time. Yet again another great video🙌❤

[@atulxess5565]

Everything is mentioned in vedas after gora's discover it

[@itacs-english2787]

We discovered it which was hidden from us by the goras

[@atulxess5565]

@@itacs-english2787 vedas is in the country right, it's not as if they took it and they're not letting us have access to it.

[@ashwanikumarpasi5152]

​@@atulxess5565 British and French have one of the oldest manuscripts and artifacts from different parts of the world, they don't even give access to outsiders to examine them.

[@pauldirc..]

i am very sad seeing state of science and mathematics in my country We are nowhere in modern technology research to America and China like in quantum computers , Artificial intelligence language models like chatgpt , superconductors etc

[@slomojohnjoshi5990]

I agree with you

[@adwaitjog4571]

Ya sort of! But in america its mostly 30 plus ppl doing all research stuff, the youth of india iss mucchh much more sanee like us. Youth in their country is so f'ing polluted now they dont give an f about technology until they define what is a 'woman' and other '70' genders😂

[@kickassguy704]

Though your intent is correct, your knowledge is bleak. No Indian text, aims to predict the future accurately. Moreover, the Vedas are just a book of knowledge. I have studied the Vedas and nowhere do they make predictions for our generations. I come from a science background ( BE Mech + MSc Phy), and I am a sceptic. I had a interest in classical religion and philosophy so therefore studied it as a hobby. Joined non credit courses at University during my MS and attended tons of lectures to get me into it. Vedas are a book of knowledge which have been compiled in no proper order. The purpose of Vedas is to impart knowledge and so over the course of time, the hymns got compiled according to their purpose. For eg. Sam Veda compliments Rig veda to set the tone for the hymns. Similarly, Brahmanas and Aranyakas complement the Vedas by imparting ritualistic nature to the Vedas. Upanishads or Vedanta (meaning the end of the Vedas) expands on the philosophy of the Vedas. Nowhere do we find an attempt to predict the future except the concept of Kali Yuga which is illustrated in various texts with the core message that humans will lose the spiritual zeal and intellect. Moreover, Indian number system is a product of Post Gupta era. We don’t even know what the numbering system was used prior to it. We even had zero before Aryabhatta assigned it a value (read about the Bakshali manuscript) but we didn’t assign it a value. Add to this that Indian scriptures by nature are written in poetry and not in prose. The purpose is to pass the message not the exact literal meaning. The problem with Indian system is that there is no Indologist which have been brought to the forefront. Everyone who has studied post Independence history, knows the heavy Marxist influence on the dissemination of knowledge of Indian religions and culture to the public. I find it laughable when people of far right and people of far left fight on it. As none of them is an Indologist. The interesting thing to note is the concepts which Indians developed around the explanation of matter and energy. Indian texts don’t aim to define the gross nature of being but the purpose of it. Ancient Greece and India differs on this. This is civilizational and that’s why since today’s education is a byproduct of the west, the mental framework which is necessary to understand Indian texts and culture has itself gone missing in India. You should try to focus on science only. Don’t go into Indian texts unless you have a deep background on it. Otherwise you’ll bring out the wrong message. It has been more almost 2 decades since I started studying Indian culture and philosophy having a background in science. It’s not easy. You need a different mental framework for it.

[@mathematicalmonk1427]

You said so much didn't said anything he is taking about people who like to sell these texts as they contain modern science in it which is a pretty ridiculous claim not backed by any evidence

[@kickassguy704]

@@mathematicalmonk1427 Your semantics are a bit hard to decipher but I get the jist. I pointed out that there is no future predictions in Vedas, Brahmanas, Aranyakas and Upanishads. To use it to make future predictions is non-sensical. It is to be noted that Indian culture uses poetry to pass on messages. The texts are to be taken in that sense and not word by word. This is the modern day approach to classical Indian history. There are scientific facts in the texts. You can read the works of Dr. Subhash Kak on it. I also pointed out the difference between Indian and western approach. Where the Ancient Greece focussed on the gross, Indians focussed on the purpose for existence of the gross. To go into Indian texts for both a right wing and a left wing guy without having a deep understanding of the framework with which is to be understood is a farce attempt. So from a scientific view, people should not use them and those using it for philosophical understanding should not use it as a book for science as that is not the purpose for it. Though there are a good amount of Indian texts where there is information on science and mathematics like the works of Charaka, Vahamira, Brahmadutta, Aryabhatta etc. but these a pure scientific treatise. I have received my education in science. But I started to explore classical Indian philosophy and religion when I was doing my MS. I have continued to do so ever since in more detail. I strongly feel for pure and applied sciences since I received by graduation in these. But I don’t want to do injustice to Indology by mixing in modern day science and classical Indian texts.

[@mathematicalmonk1427]

@@kickassguy704 I didn't disagreed with you I just said that pranav's content is against channels like beer biceps ,Sadhguru etc but do you really think those ancient texts contain contain modern science like quantum mechanics relativity theory etc as these people like to suggest

[@kickassguy704]

@@mathematicalmonk1427 I am not against Beer Biceps and Sadhguru. I think It is childish to shun someone just because some of his opinions are not right. I am not for the so called Woke “Cancel Culture” which has screwed up academic institutions globally. Beer Biceps have invited some great people of their respective fields. I respect that, some of their opinions, not all. I don’t agree with him when he talks about flying Vimanas. But as a student of history, I find it fascinating that people were aware of the concept of aerodynamics. Similarly there are a lot of such concepts which intrigue me from a purely academic point of view. You’ll not find Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle or Pauli exclusion in the texts. No need to do so. Just an interesting fact which might amuse you. A lot of tenured professors which I met during my studies did gravitate towards philosophy, not necessarily Vedanta. In fact, pure sciences at its peak have a philosophical touch and it kinda makes people go crazy apart from screwing their career. Same reason I did not go for a PhD 🤓🥲. My father is a Math PhD. He drove me away from Mathematics towards Physics as Mathematics at higher levels is not about solving problems but all about theorems etc. most of which have yet to be proved conclusively. There is a lot of abstraction involved in Math. Respect Science but don’t disrespect other fields. That’s why I said that Pranav’s intent is right but before contradicting someone, one should study the position from which the other person is speaking. I get a sense of immaturity from him,that’s it. Might be because of his young age. He might improve on it as he grows and learns.

[@mathematicalmonk1427]

@@kickassguy704 I am also a student of physics and mathematics and I also like philosophy so I have great respect for all these fields and not all beer biceps or Sadhguru's content is bad I just think they have a lot of followers and they spread a lot of misleading information in the name of science or science involved in Hinduism the kinds the video shown in this video or other videos that pranav debunks are very misleading and also attract a lot of audience in India and I am glad someone is speaking against them and no I don't think it is childish to debunk pseudoscience which he does pretty respectfully And I don't think I mentioned anything like cancel culture

[@lollolol69]

As a science student it hurts how these conspiracy guys conveniently use quantum science, dark matter and so many complicated science terms 😣

[@cataminz933]

Same notions against them. Why couldn't they do a pure and perfect research if they know about them and practically show the audience that how does things works.

[@lollolol69]

@@cataminz933 ya

[@cataminz933]

@@lollolol69 For example Numberphile, Vsauce, Action Lab and so on…

[@lollolol69]

@@cataminz933 you are in favour or against?

[@cataminz933]

@@lollolol69 I am in favour of you. I am atheist too

[@sujaymanchali5264]

I agree that these gurus should not associate vedic cosmology with modern day research like dark matter dark energy. However, i believe the power of perception. Like ants perceive the world very differently than we do. We are limited with our senses and we perceive the world how we see and think. So are we that egoistic that we are denying existence of higher beings who may perceive the world very differently and may have given us thier understanding of the universe?

[@sheshankjoshi]

Finally a Sane comment amongst so many polarized comments.

[@mr.phantom6969]

Sir, have you read vedas yourself, if yes just quote that shloka you are referring to... You don't know any ancient language like Sanskrit and just start mocking, it's ok to be inquisitive and not believe whatever is written but first read that and then conclude The problem with this generation is they want everything in a clear and simple way, The ancient scriptures do not explain the technology or mechanism that exists today but it mentioned the probability with a logical explanation in a metaphorical way most of the time as it is not possible to teach a student of class 11 about rocket science or quantum physics in detail, Earlier they meditate and understand things through their body and by observation of nature (jat pinda tat bhramnda, means what is within you is what is in the universe) You can take a simple glimpse of it by going to any VIPASNA meditation centre You will understand the body at a deeper level as you will not be allowed to talk to anyone and will be completely disconnected to the outer world (material world not the actual nature) You will feel what you can never even think of then just imagine someone doing this for years , The scriptures were not written from dreams and fantacy, it's same as thesis of a PHD, Which can also be wrong and is open for improvement, Hindu scriptures are not written by one person as in other religion but 1000s of saints contributed their life to understand life and nature at the most basic level, You said science is all about discovery, And that's why science keeps on improving itself every minute and that's the beauty of it, it has explained many of the things in a easier way to us also given more clarification to it, But the most amazing thing is those saints gave this theories and some explanations 1000s of years ago and are mostly correct, And science resemble in most cases to them, It's not that someone is talking credit of the discovery, it's not a war between science and Vedas it's just the expansion of the scriptures in a more understandable way to us... You can also read a few scriptures and make a video on your personal observation on them, It will be more fun to see that... Just decode a few shlokas or scriptures on your own, Thank you if someone have read that, You can always question sanatan but you should be open to answer and counters of your beliefs you are not forced to follow it, don't hate someone just because you have scrolled a video on KZbin or read a few science books...

[@sukhchainsingh-iv6jx]

Lol u urself are saying its not easy to understand written in a metaphorical way but when a discovery happens u suddenly pick up some scriptures which u urself said cannot be understood but suddenly those scriptures explain the new discoveries by science if u scriptures are expansion of science why are scientific contributions of indians is zero in 21st centuries everything is there right why even lose to mughals or british how can such an advanced people be enslaved😂😂 u are another religious supremacist fighting ur inferiority complex through these claims

[@karansagarkathuria7763]

Very polite and to the point. Great video and great human. This is what Hinduism needs, at least the Hinduism of scholars.

[@pixel_dino]

Where's the part where he proved any prediction wrong?

[@bhupenderjangra7111]

That’s the point there were no predictions Only false equivalence

[@RR_theproahole]

The basic principles of science, Falsifiability and verifiability, are the reasons science is still developing and didn't died out with deaths of great scientists like Newton or Einstein, while religious philosophy requires a charismatic leader and as soon as that leader dies, the philosophy becomes weak and dies out or ake forms of irrational beliefs.

[@heisenberg8827]

Why KZbin algorithm advertising astrotalk application(which is about astrology) before this vedio which is atheist channel..

[@Bunny8121]

Same here bruh why they advertising it doest make sense.

[@mrmeme-cs3gr]

Wtf... I think i am only person got that ad before this vedio

[@Rokade108]

Bro I have a doubt. Why do you always debunk the myths which are only related to Hinduism ???? Why not other religions too ???? Is it because you get views only when you make videos on Hinduism ??? Well I'm not against you try to debunk Myths but your videos are only focused towards one religion - Hinduism Why ??? Please reply

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

Pagal ho Kya? Kya West athiest hamesha Hindu ke bhare meh bat karate hai?. dark matter 2525, genetically modified skeptics, rationality rules, carp Sagan, etc everyone talks about 90% abrahamic religion , religion which they grew up from. Stop whataboutery

[@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599]

You tell me why can't he make videos only on Hinduism. Why are you so obsessed with arguing "why only us". Go check other people (athiest) of west , they are against thier own religion teaching's (no proof). Science is the same everywhere. What is a fact is a fact. Whatever argument he uses Against Hinduism is almost the same as every other religion in the world do. It's infuriating

[@theodiscusgaming3909]

he made a video on zakir naik

[@Rokade108]

@@fictionsolosanyverseyounam7599 If you come out of your home. You'll get so many Myths in every religion not just in Hindu religion. And If someone is making debunks them so that's good but I have an issue when only one religion is at the focus. Because It seems more like - He's doing for views or he's doing out of any frustration towards one religion rather than spreading awareness or debunking the Myths.

[@theadityabasak]

​@@Rokade108 Well one of the reasons for doing this type of videos is the sudden rise in toxic Hinduism. Every Hindu is being misled by individuals or groups about their religion to achieve a political milestone. Hindus are being told that their religion is the most superior. So these type of videos are needed to show those people their places.

[@vimoh]

All thesereels say is "what if something like this were true? wouldn't it be amazing?" That's it. That's all it takes to fuel this circlejerk.

[@VedaBhasya]

Vedic scriptures are in classical samskrt which requires hardwork to really translate and correlation across multiple scriptures. Yes, I think they convey a lot of cosmic phenomena and have been passed on to human race, probably from a more intelligent species and those who received it, did not know what it is, but knew it has to be treasured and they defined a human tape-recorder mechanism to transfer this over several generations. This is my hypothesis. I do original translation work around this. Maybe i will be proven wrong also. That's perfectly fine. For eg. Aditi means undivide or integrate.. Diti means divided. Adityas are those that integrate. Daityas are those that divide. This is a very broad term. In puranic humans those who divide and rule are daityas. Those who integrate and rule are Adityas. Such names are derived from the original meanings. Visualizing aditi as a lady is Ralph Girffit's interpretation because they saw Vedic texts as written by soma drunk seers who moved from village to village. They did not translate word by word, but tried to make sense overall. Lot of people started putting metaphysical meanings on these interpretations and we are having a huge body of nonsense work floating all around. But this does not mean that modern science is all described in vedic scriptures. By claiming all kind of nonsense, without doing original translation, but relying some third party interpretations (not original translations), people end up any talk of vedas as stupid faith based work. Science is hardwork. It will always be.

[@tanishqpandey9564]

IMO Vedas are just collection of a long time debate and discussion of the people of that time who wondered about this universe and existence of this world itself. Those people are perhaps whom we call sages or rishis. Although from Upanishads we can go into depth. (I'm currently reading mandukya upanishad do you have any suggestions?)

[@sumeetj3628]

Birhadaranyaka Upanishad 1.4.3-4

[@sumeetj3628]

Chandogya Upanishad 5/8/1 Chandogya Upanishad 2/13/1-2 Brihadranyak Upanishad 6/4/7

[@Vededits6542]

@@tanishqpandey9564 bro read chandogya upanishad it is really interesting i am also reading this only

[@mathematicalmonk1427]

Dude on what basis do you have such ridiculous hypothesis

[@ThatisnotHair]

Ask them about future predictions that has not yet happened. They will go dead silence.

[@chiku6488]

They tell about past discoveries by showing supremacy and divert the question or else talk shit about religion

[@Indianguy_]

6:20 but. When did any book of snatan told to treat any other religion as enemy....we are the only one who says whole world is oir family

[@nakul6969]

Hey pranav love your channel and your videos. Always refreshing to see someone combat pseudoscience logically the way you do. Please consider making a video about Amogh Lila Prabhu and the ISKON foundation thanks !

[@rrlegend1850]

💀 this doesn't make any sense he is person that debunks myth and iskon is just spreading their religion so what's the problem with that

[@mayursawant111]

​@@rrlegend1850 the religion itself

[@parthkashyap6381]

@@mayursawant111 😂 even if you have problem with a religion you cannot do anything in today's world

[@mayursawant111]

@@parthkashyap6381 true, people are blinded by the pseudo science these religion's peddle. Sad reality.

[@tanishqpandey9564]

@@rrlegend1850 if I'm not wrong that guy supports a lot of BS such as population explosion is a myth and his logic being there were 10⁶⁷ vanars in vanara sena so population is controlled and the earth will adjust it's resources as per karma so give birth to people and quite a lot so that guy needs to be discussed imo

[@Aryan-gc6ze]

Vedas are not angry it has the concept of purushartha which is not related to science. Dharma artha kam moksha

[@prashantdeopa9809]

For a channel named Science is Dope, he sure is quite fixated on religion. Religion is not scientific, even a middle schooler knows this. Start making some videos on real science instead of taking cheap shots at people on the internet. It's a reaction channel at this point.

[@scienceisdope]

Before talking smack here in the comments like some know it all, maybe take a look at the rest of the channel

[@prashantdeopa9809]

Oh, I did. You should change the name.

[@xandex69]

​@@prashantdeopa9809 ye the documentary on ramanujan so religious

[@fintechtelugu6980]

Exactly

[@phazezio5594]

There r still many things mentioned in vadas like big bang = hiranya garbha Gravity is also mentioned in vadas and many more stuff

[@xandex69]

It's not

[@hooman3669]

@PHAZ EZIO Vada pav Samosa Shawarma DHOKLA CHICKEN CHILLI

[@Juicelord001]

Hindsight Bias, Google it

[@Crabbyfeet]

Amazing explanation Pranav! Also a question, why did you change your channel logo back?

[@sheshankjoshi]

I was a hardcore Science fan, until I came across Modern Physics. Cosmology is even more perplexing, adding to my confusion and contemplation. That's when I realized all sciences are just phenomena observed, tabulated and modeled to fit some formula to make it predictable. But, when I realized that as soon as I take an observer into account, everything falls apart and I run into so many paradoxes and self contradictions, that I for now surely believe (albiet unjustified) we are missing a key piece of puzzle here i.e. ourselves; our own minds, our own conceptions, our own brains and our own thought processes. Until and unless we have a good model of our own human mind, I am not going to trust science completely. It may be falsifiable, predictable or whatever it is, it doesn't matter. All that matters to me is whether it has some utility right now or not. I place both religion and philosophy in the same bucket and let them co-exist with each other while I try to find utility of them both. What matters finally is, whether it is utilitarian or not. From my own observations, it is religion that has more utility on a day to day life for a given individual that scientific method is. Technology, based on science, surely makes his life better, but religion has been here before the science was ( and technology was here before it was associated with science), and is still serving its purpose well i.e. answering more fundamental questions/aspects of human life and existence. So, I will place science in my back pocket and religion in my front pocket to navigate my life.

[@thunderred5263]

Day to day maybe religion makes your life simple but we wont be able to progress this way

[@Saptami-wi7oi]

​@@thunderred5263 Religion or God gives you strength, courage.. God Doesn't forbid you to Progress

[@saurabhstrauss]

If Religious books have everything that have be founded and everything that will be founded, why wait to scientists to discover it? Why just not read the books and tell about quantum field theory? Why not tell everything about dark energy and dark matter? Why to wait for years for scientists to find out and than claim it's already there? 😂😂😂

[@pauldirc..]

Unfortunately people who believe in this kind of nonsense doesn't have enough logical ability to think this argument .prople who even can't solve first order differential equation, teach quantum mechanics to other by using buzzwords like maya , energy, vibrations Physics without mathematics is just philosophy But people are too busy in over glorifying their past , like finding rocket science and 5 g technology in vedas Yeah vedas was great and ancient indian have contributed greatly in science like aryabhatta , panini and more but science is more advance now from transistors to computer to Ai to advancement in medical science all belongs to modern science

[@JimedBro]

Because the people who believe this are delusional and should be put in a mental asylum

[@leo_pi]

8:00 made a little typo there (errors in gps - erros in gps)!

[@superemewarrior]

I love how he proudly takes name of Sanatan in vagueness example but not take name of islam or christanity when it comes to 6:12

[@Ind_u.]

Lol 😂.

[@AsifAli-zp5wu]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKXSq5iXedOen5o

[@superemewarrior]

@@AsifAli-zp5wu ye kyun bheja sadguru ko to waise bhi nahi maante log aaj kal

[@Vor567tez]

500yr ago religions were against science and now they r claiming it's all written in their text. 😂

[@Pranay_singh_]

Oo talking about abharamic religions . Sanatan allowed research , aryabhatta and many more are a example

[@Vor567tez]

@@Pranay_singh_ I agree but when asked to prove the god's existence to any religious grp they all a acted the same.

[@Pranay_singh_]

@@Vor567tez right but i asked the question to many gurus , finnaly i got my answer in arya samajh thats why i support them. Namaste

[@ashwanikumarpasi5152]

​@@Vor567tezYou started with the wrong question, right question should have been "who I am?", "why I am?"

[@Indianguy_]

7:15 , Hmmm , interesting.....but Aren't the facts of snatan like 1. Distance between sun & earth 2. 84lakh species on planet Were put as bold statement? That means they were falsifiable ...... Which later on found out that they were pretty accurate.....doesn't that makes hindu texts, a book that can used a scienctific efforts done by that time

[@AnalystSarvesh]

A good scientific book also publishes method and doesn't publishes numbers with wrong unit baseless claims airly.

[@imtiajsiam2205]

The eath rounds the sun by elipse figure ...

[@Indianguy_]

@@imtiajsiam2205 so what? did i mention about any shape earth revolves around sun?????

[@Indianguy_]

@@AnalystSarvesh go read aryabhatiya and other books by aryabhatta....you'll find so much there

[@AnalystSarvesh]

@@Indianguy_ except distance between sun and number of plant species (extremely far off) weren't mentioned in aryabhatta.

[@sarthakarya02]

Infinity foundation has done great work by making 10vol work on Indian Contribution to world sciences all must read this

[@VijayaLakshmi-wo7ej]

'this is India don't be andhabhakt , pseudo science is Indian science all west , Greek gave science to us , only 0 from India , Some contribution which acknowledged by western historians of Indian science are crct , eternal truth Don't be sanghi , Hinduism is just superstitious religion , castiest , no scientific temper there before British . We are civilized by the great Christianity driven British Empire.' - All Marxist, leftist , so called rational atheist , secular Hindus this our own PPL don't respect our ancestors of Indic civilization and there knowledge and effort to protect , and sufferd , sacrificed . History injustice.

[@sarthakarya02]

@@VijayaLakshmi-wo7ej correct but sarcastically 😂

[@VijayaLakshmi-wo7ej]

@@sarthakarya02 kya kare vinaash kaale viparit buddhi for seculars , rational atheist, anti India forces . Don't argue with them . We should revive our culture by research and facts , develop framework, ideology, think tanks , school of thoughts in a institute way like west to counter them . Satyamev Jayate

[@ayushsarangi7242]

@@VijayaLakshmi-wo7ej rational athiests se kya problem h hutiyo? Acharya prashant , stephen hawking and carl sagan bhi whi h

[@ayushsarangi7242]

@@VijayaLakshmi-wo7ej this video was only for those who says each and everything in modern science was droven from vedas and themselves not read any vedas

[@astrosapien4839]

This is some eye opening content and I totally support your cause to bring out the scientific temper of people. It is certainly a hard job to wake up people to the reality of what is traditional knowledge and how it has been existed in our scriptures. I myself am an astrologer and i keep all this nonsense aside while reading a birthchart. The basis of astrology is totally different from what is presented on the internet. As a woke person i am sharing some of it with you. Since the birth of a human being, its body keeps developing in a repeated pattern till its death. This process remains the same till a person dies. For example, No person can digest food Without eating first. No one can speak without breathing air inside. There is a chronology that a human body follows. Every human being follows the same pattern of growth and it is common throughout every human being. This repeated pattern of growth of the human body is the foundation of astrology. A birth chart or kundli is constructed on the basis of this repeated pattern. Each part of this repeated pattern is categorized into a house. There are twelve houses in a birth chart or a kundli. Each of these houses represents a process happening with the body. For example- Every human being eats. Eating through the mouth is a process which is common throughout earth among every human being. Second house of a birth chart represents consumption a person will have. The trick here is to look the other way round. A person will eat only what he has. Hence the second house represents the resources of a person. It is the house that represents the bank balance of a person. If Ketu transits this house then there has to be loss of wealth, belongings and every other thing that the second house represents. The reason for the loss will be the natal placement of Ketu. Suppose Ketu is placed in the third house and it is transiting the second house then the person will lose money or belongings because of subordinates, younger brothers, juniors etc. For the sake of convenience, our forefathers made the division to study the effects of light on these particular processes. But before that we have to understand houses in totality. Houses are a collection of processes that occur simultaneously with the human body.

[@loneranterism]

I could not help but sing...Kabhi kabhi Aditi zindagi mein koi apna lagta hai....😃

[@abhinovenagarajan.s7237]

As always, this was a great video. I just want to make a clarification regarding the Vedas being the word of God. I have also heard this claim before, but I don't think the episode of The Ranveer Show that you use as reference/evidence for this claim is a good idea. You know better than others that a lot of the stuff from his podcasts are highly questionable, so unless you think that specific episode somehow got things magically right, I would look at other sources of information to support the (fairly common) claims that the Vedas are considered the word of God. Keep up the great content man! You're doing much needed work.

[@abirbo]

You might also want to ask, if Vedas are the word of god, who heard them first? Who was the guy/girl? Is it only 1 person who heard it or multiple people? What was the person/people doing when god came to tell them? Also, why god chose to tell these stories to only the people from the subcontinent, when neighboring China, is as ancient as India? Also, why these stories were not told to the people in Africa since homo sapiens evolved from the African continent?

[@scienceisdope]

You're right. But I've heard this 'apurusheya' name before

[@AsifAli-zp5wu]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKXSq5iXedOen5o

[@Aryan-gc6ze]

​​​@@scienceisdope what about 6 vedangas Astronomy - jyotish which misunderstood astrology which separate from vedang Jyotish . Phenotics Chandas Siksha Niruktha Kalpa Gandwarvedam Arthshastra Dhanurvedam Ayurvedam Arthmetic and big 10 of power number in Yajur Vedam We are advanced civilization in the past According to that time of knowledge . We had our framework of science which was influenced by culture .and we stopped advancing futher because of invasion and doctrine of discovery , church education came through Macaulay education system . Ganit is different from math think about this divide by 0 undefined but in Bharat it's get a value we lost our ganit to develop futher which different . History of science and maths department not established in our country .

[@Anurag-if9re]

Well. Don't just point out on things related to Hinduism. We want equality, so kindly speak up about Islam and Christianity too, if you're really concerned about the truth. Thank you.

[@whatsup3519]

He already made a video,and why r u obsessed with minority?Does showing there superstition solve the issue,or u find it entertaining. But frustrated when u looking at your religion

[@eeriemyxi]

What a moron, you couldn't the deny the facts on this video because it hurts your cult's claims, so you decided to make this unconstructive claim that he's solely focusing on Hinduism; even though he has criticized all popular religions. The reason for him to make more videos on Hinduism is toddler's work to make sense out of: because 80% of Indians are Hindus. Can't even take the topic without it not being specific to your emotional speculative unfalsifiable stupid abtract notion.

[@Anurag-if9re]

@@whatsup3519 the comment wasn't to you, it was to the person who targets a specific group.

[@Anurag-if9re]

@@whatsup3519 do some research, Muslims aren't a minority in India.

[@Anurag-if9re]

@@eeriemyxi i believe you are a Muslim. If you knew Dharma, you wouldn't have replied in this impolite manner. First learn to respect opinions and to talk with humility and politeness. Secondly, the comment wasn't made to you, it was made to @scienceisdope who, if he thinks he's the only scholar and knows everything, then he should focus on spreading equality and pointing out the mistakes in all religions. Lately he's been targeting Hinduism, neglecting the moral values it teaches. He's true in his claims, but he's defaming a path by focusing solely on the superstitions. Not to mention the other ways of living, the religions have enough to question and to point out and to criticize. I want him to spread his "utter" knowledge into topics of other religions too. Moreover, I wouldn't disrespect you like you did to me, because it shows how different we are.

[@sai_69]

Amazing presentation. I especially love how you word it all.

[@sanath111]

I simply do one thing to whom you oppose I will simply subscribe that channel 😊😊

[@AnalystSarvesh]

You know how insignificant you are in this community? Well you are 10^-5 times insignificant.

[@Red_Dusk]

when you start living in past, you have lost all hope for future.

[@kaushikrayadurga1592]

bangalore mei ek meetup... plzzz..... been following your channel ever since 16k subs

[@Dr.AshishSehgal]

Good that someone is talking about it. Kudos. Excellent work. Sharing it

[@pankajseerapu3902]

@Pranav - quite frankly, I think no one cares, and it reflects in your youtube views, as much as I want this channel to succeed, it is better that you figure out a different way to promote scientific ideology- a well wisher and honest subscriber

[@lifeitself9]

It’s like making conclusions about science by watching science fiction movies. Falsifiability is the basis of Indian intellectual debates in these scriptures. They were dialogical. Philosophical discourses in these texts are astonishingly logical. Science is not just for some cold inane practical ends. Essence of it is impersonal objective presupposition less inquiry. Likes of Albert Einstein understand it. (World as I see it). Irony is their minions think that they alone are personification of logic and rationality. Read more!

[@navinraut5920]

The Vedas are such a random gibberish that, if you are adamant, you can even find the formula for coca-cola in the vedas 😂

[@Soham.69]

😂😂😂

[@itacs-english2787]

I bet you never read it and understood the core philosophy of vedas

[@emperormeiji1868]

@@itacs-english2787 lol what philosophies are there in vedas

[@JimedBro]

​@@emperormeiji1868apparently religious with no science

[@emperormeiji1868]

@@JimedBro yeah

[@chandrakant9085]

Trust me bro it's all in Vedas

[@devarshnayyar3910]

Trust me bro, there is only moral knowledge in vedas

[@Pihu523]

@@devarshnayyar3910 he's being sarcastic.

[@tanishqpandey9564]

@@devarshnayyar3910 moral knowledge ✅ philosophical questions and ideas regarding life ✅ Empirical sciences ❌❌❌ people just don't understand this simple thing.

[@sumeetj3628]

@@devarshnayyar3910 This is there moral knowledge- Chandogya Upanishad 5/8/1 Chandogya Upanishad 2/13/1-2 Brihadranyak Upanishad 6/4/7 🤣🤣🤣

[@heheboiii3566]

Science: discovers something new. Religion: look my religious texts already new that.

[@tusharkumar4213]

yajurveda says "surya sthir nehi hai". par tumhare scientist pehle ye mante the k ye sthir hai. par baad m jab technology aage badhi toh pata chala jo hazaron saalon pehle likhi gyi yajurved mai jo likha hai wohi sahi hai...ab bataao idiots

[@electrondynamics9721]

Extraordinary claims require Extraordinary evidence -Carl Sagan

[@kalebj7001]

Kabhi kabhi aditi zindagi mein yuhi koi apna lagta hai, Kabhi kabhi aditi wo bichad jaaye to ek sapna lagta hai, Aise mein koi kaise apne aasuon ko behne se roke?

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

I found some inconsistencies in this video which i would like to point out: 1) You say that whatever is in the scriptures to be written in stone and a complete disregard to other religions. However, the vedas does not mention any other religion or call them to be bullshit. Infact, our scriptures highlight that God can be visualised in any form, not limited to the sculpture form (archa avataram). Plus our religion has always been open to interpretation and discussion. Note that there exist 3 prominent schools of though in Advaita, Dvaita and Vishishtadvaita. But for one to participate in such debate/discussion you should be learned enough 😉. This comment has become long enough, can raise the rest in a separate comment/within this thread

[@scienceisdope]

I never said that. What I said was that ideas in scripture are unfalsifiable. You haven't argued against that

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

@@scienceisdope Sure, although what you quoted at 6:20 was an example of sorts, it came off as something that every religion is guilty of (not the case with sanatana dharma/hinduism). Regarding falsifiability, I'll be sticking to vedas as that seems to be the topic and in the title. The vedas concern themselves with providing a path to experience God and the karmas that can be performed to work towards the same. Now for someone to go and disprove the hypothesis, he/she has to be learned of the ways mentioned right? It is the same as many flat earthers today, they themselves do not have any command over the subject but still try to prove something wrong. You have to start with belief and only after working your way up, can you start questioning. Now you may say that even beginners in science can question and get proofs by their teachers. For that you'll have to join a guru learned in vedas and yoga (not only the exercise version common today). You can definitely question him and you will get proofs, just not in terms of written down formula, but proof through your own experience.

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

Now you may say that getting experience is not scientific and cannot be proven en masse. That will bring us to the limitation of our body, we are naturally not capable of sharing our thoughts and experience, which can only be felt through the five senses. This is the domain of spirituality or where vedas shine. I don't think it is right to see vedas from the constricted view of modern science. Both should be left alone. As for those trying to fit modern science and vedas together, they should be ignored as they generally don't have mastery over either of the subjects.

[@Endrin911]

@@shreenivasrangarajan4378 Is our planet (& universe) a creation of god according to hinduism?

[@shreenivasrangarajan4378]

@@Endrin911 It will depend on how you understand God. God is not a man/woman and is not restricted to our imagination/perception and far exceeds it. He is someone who possesses the quality suddha sattva. Now, according to our scriptures, the universe originated from a sentient brahman (a very nuanced concept, need to learn from Upanishads to get a grasp). I can refer you to a book if you are interested in learning about these things. Although the correct method is to learn from a guru.

[@335haan5]

Ur earlier videos had better clarity man, I've always agreed with you but to those who don't I don't think they would get the point For some reason feels like ur bouncing around different points in the video, pls look at ur older content

[@shaam3214]

The thing with unfalsibile theories or statements is they're easy to create and more easier to spread. Because the spreader likes to be lazy and believe whatever he observes blindly without any basic scientific temper... The efforts of Pranav to teach the Critical thinking ability to the people are commendable. Keep Going!!

[@sanjaynitave4050]

The speech is very monotonous and continuous, without any pauses- so this part of oratory should be improved, because then it will make the message more effective, more interesting and more understandable. This channel is actually the best ! Rational thinking though science is the need of hour , especially in our country at this moment.

[@vivekgarg561]

Is desh ka kuch nhi ho skta 🤣🤣 har roj ek vedic scientist peda ho rha h 😂 ek bar media k samne debate v honi chahiye yr

[@sskarter]

Religion and science are two different things

[@rameshdevasi6720]

diti is limitation and aditi is infinite, but its a spiritual concept of mind and consciousness

[@mdhvdubey]

Being a hindu i can confirm he said the truth.

[@hehehehehehe7878]

In whole video he didn't said Vedas are wrong, he was just explaining something different theories of how science works to sound smart 😂😂😂

[@Aryan-gc6ze]

6 vedangas and UPA vedas

[@RJ-vk5kh]

​@@hehehehehehe7878 true 😂

[@yohanan5947]

Please make an article on the Unites States of Kailasa!!! Keep the good work coming, bro!

[@vivekgarg561]

Saar believe me... Everything is in our vedas 🤡

[@percybeck923]

Pranav how do u plan to apply falsifiability on social science ??? Social sciences can't work like natural sciences, like Democracy is social science concept now what are the falsifiability conditions for a democracy???

[@xandex69]

It's a subjective field not a classic branch of objective science 💀

[@percybeck923]

@@xandex69 so not science u mean?

[@xandex69]

@@percybeck923 nope it's not, anyone can know everything there is know about that field in about 3 days to a week. You'll atleast need 8 years to be decent at physics

[@percybeck923]

@@xandex69 nah man pls be objective, first of all it's not possible to know everything about social sciences in just 3 days to a week ( people doing PhDs in social sciences) secondly time to understand isn't actually decider to judge whether somthing is science or not, my orginal question was regarding complexities of testability, verifiability and falsifiability in social sciences.

[@adityasinghjadoun6675]

there are three people claiming 1st comment but saksham is actually first

[@mdsuhel597]

There is not a single manuscript of ved older then 1875 nothing like 1000s years old