Vegan Chicken Patty Taste Test | Ranked 1-9

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Do you agree with our decision? What's your fav?

[@MsBeckly]

Absolutely! I finally tried the Gardein Ultimate Chicken Patty earlier this week and it is incredible! I like the tenders too but the patty is better.

[@whatscooking905]

Agreed!!

[@lanakayphillips2849]

My preference, and I have tried several over the years, is the Aldi brand. As a senior living on a fixed income I can afford to pay for these as an occasional "treat." and I like their taste as well.

[@ProfessorCupcakeTV]

I ate Qouon (sp?) today & I was impressed, but it was not spicy!!!

[@meensbeans]

Alpha Food and Gardein Ultimate have been my fave so far, but I haven't tried all the ones in your video yet. Garden Ultimate was scary good. I'm just disappointed that you only get 3 and not 4 for the price. Where I live these are $7 at conventional grocery store and $9 at Whole Foods. Really wish it was 4 patties at that price, but that doesn't stop me from buying them, because they're that good. 😊 Thanks to this video, though, I'm going to try Gardein original and Light Life next for cheaper options!

[@thevegfriend100]

Speaking of chik’n, Alpha Foods is lowering the prices of their chik’n (maybe only nuggets) because chicken prices are increasing… Just thought it was interesting and wanted to share!

[@LindaASJ]

The only thing I would like to see is Gardein Ultimate to have more than 3 in a package. I’m sure it’s because of how they’re pricing it. Here in Dallas/Ft Worth they go for $7.99 per bag. It’s just me and the hubs so it’s still reasonable for a meal. For a family it may be a little pricey

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Agree!

[@MrsIEllis]

Yes! I hate the price of them, but they are good. If you shop at Target watch their Circle app coupons, they will sometimes have a decent coupon for the Gardein ultimate stuff.

[@lenorawilson2326]

Yes for the price, and I can only find them in on store in my area. It's very good but over priced for the amount.

[@pineconey]

Check the weight, though. Gardein gives you 14 oz. in every bag, whether it's patties, tenders, or nuggets. It's a good deal.

[@LindaASJ]

@@pineconey I understand your comment about the weight but when you have 6 people in your family to feed like my in laws, you have to buy 2 bags.

[@LouieV6]

The Gardein Ultimate Chicken Patty is a banger! I stopped by my local target the other day and grabbed a couple bags and made a Popeye-inspired chicken sandwich, and let me just say, my tongue hasn’t left heaven ever since! 😂

[@lisasims4159]

That is my favorite one by far.

[@octoberopal8419]

REALLY LIKE WHEN Y'ALL DO TASTE-TESTS!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks! We appreciate that

[@whatscooking905]

I concur!!!!

[@nathanalvidrez261]

“You’re grandma not my grandma” 😂😂

[@hollitheexaltedempress6957]

I reluctantly purchased some ultimate chicken, I had tried yuall's suggestions on the old chicken stuff but they were horrible. So I was bracing to be jacked again. That Gardein's Ultimate chicken was off the chain. I ate it with vegan mayo, siracha, and salad on a sandwich. I was scared that my fingers would be bitten while eating that sandwich, it was the bomb! I haven't eaten chicken in 30 years. I feel like this is the answer to chicken in my future. Thank you I trust you now, you gave me two excellent products Gardein's Ultimate burger and chicken.

[@andrewbinghamjr]

😂😂

[@lollychessie]

😂😂😂

[@dominic8054]

What vegan Mayo do you recommend?

[@AshleyBlom]

Gardein Ultimate is the BEST! I love adding the spicy mayo from Popeye's to it. Really hits the spot.

[@Travybear1989]

I like them but they are too expensive. My wife and I are pretty much stuck with the Aldi brand as 4 patties go for $3.80-ish where we live. Impossible and beyond products run $8-12 for 2 patties. Mostly live on avocado's though these days, processed stuff is just too expensive.

[@Wwetitanfan27]

I've had the gardein in the purple bag and they're stellar and it makes me upset and confused that all the grocery stores carry a bunch of gardein products but not the chicken patties, when they are so top notch. Hopefully they start to carry the ultimate ones. Excited to try them

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We feel the same about not being able to find Gardein's fish & crab products more places!

[@ebh9163]

I love the way you interact when making the decision which product is better, is so entertaining and informative...just awesome 👍

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks so much!

[@ajperlman]

those gardein ultimates are my latest addicton! fantastic!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Really good!

[@imsosan74]

I really like and appreciate your taste test! Thank you!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you so much!

[@georgiap8354]

I’m actually a big fan of the morning star spicy chicken patty. Its not spicy, but I think the seasoning and flavor is so fire that it tastes like actual chicken!

[@kktrinese]

Tried the box of 10 Alpha patties from Costco, for about $6 it's a good deal

[@MakeItDairyFree]

no way!

[@jeridubin6931]

I was going to say that. Its true

[@jrclarke333]

Walmart has a new Great Value Grilled Chik'un patty I enjoy. I regard ya'll's reviews like law. 😆 I always look at ya'll's revues before I get anything. They have been spot on agreement with my findings

[@BITCHstfu234]

Really? I work at Walmart and haven't seen it, hopefully we get it soon 😭

[@jrclarke333]

@Tymira Smith it could be a store or region specific item. I find it in the section where the Morning star faarms frozen stuff is.

[@Shakaylafelice]

Loved this vid!! I’m not a huge vegan chicken patty person - not that I don’t like them, I just never really buy them not I do want to try the new gardein ones. I love that you guys did the price breakdown. That really helps.

[@Briana12906]

Love this!! Love your guys’ taste tests. They’re so fun and you give great descriptions. I have a recipe request! Vegan ramen 😊 I’d love to see your take on that!

[@torigillispie9823]

Enjoyed the video ..how did you cook the chicken pattys???

[@eb4696]

You guys are awesome! I recently discovered your channel and absolutely love watching you. I came for the recipes and vegan info, but find your videos so entertaining. I laugh out loud at least a few times in every single one. Plus, you two are adorable. Thanks for a great channel!

[@pineconey]

Gardein Ultimate has absolutely nailed it. The texture and seasoning are so much better than older Gardein, and for me, this one beats all current contenders to which I've had access, even the new Impossible nuggets.

[@RavensWingTarot]

Whole Foods done messed up their chicken recipe. They used to be so good, but they do have that weird aftertaste. I agree Ultimate chicken is bomb! I ate all three patties in 24 hours 😂😂😂

[@MakeItDairyFree]

hahah we don't even blame you for that! (and yes agree it's changed)

[@sha46327]

I was curious and had to look, apparently Boca has been around since 1979 with a vegetarian burger and was one of the originals. Today, it is showing, they really need to step up their game. Tbh, I haven't enjoyed anything of theirs that I've tried - I actually prefer the Aldi over Boca. I actually haven't tried the Gardein Ultimate bc of it's price to food ratio, lol, they need toss another piece in there and stop playing.😂 Tysmfs!! I hope you're all having an amazing week! Best of wishes.

[@mimigideon1359]

Congratulations on your 100k subscribers. I hope you get a million.

[@Inputdonutz]

Gardein everything is so good!! Just season yourself

[@MyLocsareREAL]

I’m just blown away how far vegan chicken has come, when I first started eating a vegan diet… Morningstar was the only chicken patty choice and boca just had burgers.. These videos are SO HELPFUL 🥰.. thank you so much

[@margarett_b]

3:35 I was about to write I was never into chicken burgers...and then I realised that at McDonalds I actually only ate the chicken sandwich when I was a kid (it happened very rarely, but still) :D You actually made me want to try some of the options I have available (including a few you tested)! . Anyways, thank you for trying all of these for us! I hope you did not feel too bad after this taste test! Lots and lots of love for the whole fam!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

ohhh so glad you have some available where you are!

[@margarett_b]

@Miss Sunrise I leave many creators a lot of comments since it is the only way I can make them know I appreciate their work and support them! :)

[@margarett_b]

@@MakeItDairyFree Yeah, for once XD But unfortunately, they are not near the top o f the list so I will be reading lots of reviews of the ones I can buy here :D Don't want to buy nasty ones!

[@e.m.8094]

Just tried the Impossible chicken patties. Very good, but a little too thin and skimpy. I would want two of them if I didn't have any side dishes.

[@bunk766]

The Gardein ultimate chicken patties are probably the best meat substitute on market right now. Toss up between that and impossible

[@mattnj22]

Have y'all ever tried Jack and Annies chicken nuggets or just anything from that brand? It's jack fruit 😁

[@thevegfriend100]

I’ve heard of it and desperately would like to try!

[@garlandstyle5797]

Tried the Gardien Ultimate ChickUN patties yesterday per your recommendations. No where juicy at all as Andrew said using the Air Fryer. Over $3 a patty. This is a no to future watchers. Make your own from Tofu, lots of videos on that. This is a quicky not worth the price. My 2¢

[@blaqbutterfly874]

The ultimate chicken has a after taste. I tried it because of this video. But wasn’t a fan. I prefer my morning star spicy. 🥰

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Fair enough

[@Zack-tc9us]

Gardein ultimate is mind blowing, tastes better than popeyes chicken sandwhich

[@MakeItDairyFree]

good right?

[@pennywise8919]

Haven't tried any of these yet, but looking forward to trying the Gardein ultimate chicken patties! Thanks again guys!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thanks for watching!

[@whatscooking905]

You will love the ultimate chicken patties and especially the tenders! I love them both but the tenders are the best IMO.

[@thomasraven]

Thanks for your honest reviews! The Morningstar spicy chick patties are my go-to. I like the Gardein ultimate but they're more expensive and they take longer to cook. Sometimes the smaller patties work on sandwiches better. I think the only way you can really compare prices is by comparing per-serving costs or per-ounce costs.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you have ones you love

[@tomithot261]

Another well done, informative video. Thanks. I get hungry for fried chicken, so this was excellent. Thanks.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@lyrablack8621]

Love these taste tests! Edit: don't comment before you finish the video xDD! They include the prices

[@susanmcmahon3811]

Moringstar makes a buffalo chik n patty which is yummy

[@MakeItDairyFree]

yes!

[@genoemi]

I was actually disappointed by ultimate gardein chicken patties. I thought they’d have the southern style breading like in the bag picture, but it fell flat and the seasoning is so underwhelming. I almost prefer the original considering the price.

[@MrsIEllis]

Loved the video and so far I really like the Gardein ultimate and the Morning Star brands chicken.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

nice, glad you are enjoying them

[@guttyrankz]

Your taste tests are the bees knees! Love y'all! Could you guys do a vegan frozen pizza brand taste test in the future? That would be dope!

[@chelleec23]

The Gardein Ultimate is too real for me. My boyfriend, who was a big meat eater before, loves it.

[@jadesreviewgems5158]

They are scary like meat. I swear the nuggets taste spot on like Chick Fillet

[@therealdeal894]

Gardein is what a major chain restaurant I know uses.

[@Sincerely_Tiffany]

Hey! First Off I want to say I am a HUGE FAN! Thank you for all you do for us. I have a question. have you all tried the Deliciou Plant based chicken mix yet? If so can you PLEASE Do a video on your opinion.

[@amady6]

It’s so hard to eat these vegan substitutes when you can’t have gluten! It would be so easy to make the breading GF. If anyone knows of one I would love to hear about it. Anyway, these reviews are great!

[@kelseydavies5390]

Amazing video from favourite youtubers 😄😄

[@biancarandolph2480]

I accidentally bought the quorn one that wasn't spicy and the front label looked all vegan and stuff saying meatless and no soy and stuff so I thought it was fully vegan till I was about to make it and saw in the ingredients that It has egg whites lol 😆then I was gonna come back here and mention it only to see that it was specifically said here that they have a non spicy version but it's not vegan lol 😆 welp oh well I'm gonna eat it anyway just won't buy it again lol im a freshly new plant based vegan eater but not fully vegan cos if I'm on the go and something may has just a splash of cheese in it I'm not gonna go crazy n not buy it just because haha but I really thought the non spicy version was vegan cos it looked sooo vegan on the front cover lol 😆

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Don't feel bad, we've all made the mistakes of thinking this at times

[@biancarandolph2480]

@@MakeItDairyFree thanks for your reply , and yea what I learned is not everything that says plant based is actually vegan lol and even some vegan stuff labeled vegan has small tiny words towards the bottom that says made in a factory that makes eggs milk etc so In my head I'm like so it's not vegan then lol 😆

[@shmpooch]

You're the best! Alfa and gardein are the best. I don't know if my tastes have changed or the formula changed but morning star chicken is on the bottom. I remember they used to be good?

[@MakeItDairyFree]

I wonder if others are just getting even better

[@NikiKuchipudi]

quorn is my absolute fave. i love all of their products

[@katiehemstreet8939]

I honestly haven't tried most of these, even though I should. We always buy the Boca Spicy Chicken Patties (we don't care for the original ones as much). They're not perfect but they're cheap, tasty, available everywhere. 🤷

[@charityselick6595]

I do the same with Morningstar Buffalo patties. The original are OK but the spicy just hit different lol. I'm super picky about veggie patties too lol

[@stephieeeg]

Iv been craving hot dogs but haven’t had the guts to buy any because idk if the flavors are good, can you guys do vegan hot dog taste test 🤗

[@homecookedwithnichole]

I was scrolling and happened to see your comment. They have a hotdog video here kzbin.info/www/bejne/nYi4Yqqwq8ygh5I

[@stephieeeg]

@@homecookedwithnichole thank you !!! 🥰

[@YahairaLeePerez]

Loveeeee the gardein ultimate chicken products. These filets are perfect for a chix parm sandwich! Sooo yum!! I’d like to see breakfast sausage taste test. I did a mini taste test last week and there are some foul ones out there!!! The light life breakfast sausage patties tasted like playground wood chips! Don’t ask 😵‍💫😵‍💫 took one bite and tossed the whole pack. scarred for lifeeee!

[@nburris1127]

Try the Beyond links...

[@hippieista7323]

I love the new Gardein patty.

[@r.p.5863]

You can NEVER go wrong with Gardein

[@sheraleeronan2326]

Surprised you did not include the Walmart Great Value plant based chicken nuggets They are surprisingly very good and affordable

[@ebh9163]

What breed are you using for this taste???..looks really good 👍

[@aidenalamo6262]

Gardein Ultimate is my favourite chicken style patty. I love the flavor and the texture of this meatless godsend.

[@mandydyer2426]

I am able to get boca and quorn because they have spicy patties cuz I like spice but I definitely will be checking for some of the other ones. Thanks for the honest taste test. Keep them up cuz I love them.

[@helens.undead666]

Am I the only one that hates the new gardein ultimate chicken patty and tenders 😭 I don’t know what it is but something about it is very off to me

[@bridgetstockdill98]

I did not like the Ultimate Gardein one, it had an odd taste I just didn’t care for. I’m curious as to how good the impossible one is so I’ll be trying it next. Ultimate Gardein was a hard no for me though. 😊

[@dir3en8grey]

The morning star Buffalo chicken patty is amazing

[@brittanybutler2211]

Whenever she said they shouldn't get an advantage for flavor...I stopped folding clothes. Uhhhh yes, flavor is the point for the video.

[@preparedsetapart9475]

😂 It's SEASONED like your Grandma's not mine 🤤

[@MessyBeans]

I love your taste tests 💕

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Thank you!

[@conradtaylor29]

For future taste tests, I recommend tasting the item without bread, and without condiments and providing a ranking. Then taste the item with bread and/or with other condiments. Now, you can provide another ranking. Next, don't forget to cleanse the palate to reset your taste buds before tasting another product. One can do this by taking a sip of water, eating a lemon wedge, or having a piece of fruit. I believe doing this can better analyze the range of flavors of the product. All in all, I love these vegan taste tastes and please do keep them coming!!!! 👍🏾👏🏾🙌🏾🔥😋

[@kickswithkam]

That ultimate gardien the best

[@givepeasachance_]

Love your videos! I always get excited when I see a new one pop up. Definitely want to try the new Gardein one soon.

[@debbieguthrie2307]

Quorn comes in first with texture

[@denisef2845]

My Meijer doesn’t carry a lot of those (yet). Gardein & Morningstar do go on sale often though,which is a plus. I love these videos!

[@LindaASJ]

I’ve found the more I request a product the more they end up popping up. My Target didn’t sell Just Egg until enough of us kept suggesting and emailing the company. Now if they could just keep it in stock.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Glad you have those options ! Hope you get more and thank you!

[@Lisa-wp1ff]

Have been getting the Boca ones for years, never thought to try anything else but now I will. Is there any such think as Vegan keto foods ?

[@nburris1127]

If you find out pls let me know. I have been subbing out diary for vegan alternatives & its an up in the air shuffle most of the time.

[@fay2244]

Me watching this at 3 in the morning while also trying a vegan chicken sandwich 👁👄👁

[@EmberLuna13]

I recently had a vegan chicken sandwich at a place in Tulsa OK and it was the best I'd ever had. My friends and I were wondering if it was house made but now looking at them in your video I'm wondering if it was the Gardein Ultimate just deep fried. I'll have to try those soon.

[@allyl8230]

I happen to enjoy the Boca and you are correct! Boca DOES have a spicy patty! I agree Aldi is just okay, but it does the job. I tend to feel like some of these have a greasy end after cooking though! I try to avoid those at all costs… I have yet to try Gardein or Light Life but I’m going to get on that!! Seeing that Light Life is definitely a fave brand for me. How did you guys make these? What method of cooking did you use should I say? (Perhaps you mentioned it but I somehow missed it LOL?)

[@MakeItDairyFree]

I'm not sure if we mentioned it or not LOL! We baked them

[@JADE1300]

Currently for taste and for your money, the Amazon Fresh brand Vegan Chicken Patty and Nuggets are the best.........

[@MakeItDairyFree]

glad you like

[@e.m.8094]

Which is better, Gardien Ultimate or VFC?

[@hollyjustice9858]

The gardein ultimate line is so great. I'm so happy :)

[@onlinekaren]

Please. do a ground beef/beef crumbles episode! I love this ones

[@MakeItDairyFree]

We've been discussing how to do that :)

[@RavensWingTarot]

@@MakeItDairyFree maybe make small patties and crumbles? I'd love to see this, but I'll prepare your for WF...total canned dog food vibe. Sorry in advance 😂

[@melissabanyas1315]

Great video, as usual! We’re Morning Star all the way. Price, availability, flavor and sales combined, make it an easy winner. While we enjoy trying all of the new options when our local stores have them, I consistently go back to MS.

[@MissouriPrepper64052]

I prefer to make my own homemade vegan burgers at home it’s so much cheaper and you can add your own ingredients

[@laurenwhetsel8712]

BOCA is the OG!!!! I went veggie in 2005 and BOCA was all I had!!! And the occasional morning star farms

[@laurenwhetsel8712]

Might not stand up to competitors today but I still appreciate them for being around so long!

[@nikki642653]

Boca does have a spicy one which I really enjoy. But my options are pretty limited. Andrew's facial expression when he had the ultimate gardein......I'm definitely going to pick that up if i ever find it Kinda annoyed with my grocery stores now that you've mentioned the gardein (regular) and Boca was the same cost at your location. The gardein is usually around $20 more than the Boca where I'm from.

[@allyl8230]

I agree ☝️ I thoroughly enjoy the Boca as well!!

[@MakeItDairyFree]

I hope you are able to find the ultimate ones!

[@user-et1qy8nd5y]

Thank you for this I'm new at being a Vegan

[@brittfox9038]

I have tried 6 of the 9 and the best IMO is #10, Simple Truth (Kroger) Meatless Crispy Patties/Tenders. They are a bit greasy but they absolutely cure my craving for fried chicken.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

hahha, we don't have Simple Truth here ;)

[@theresamnsota3925]

I can't wait to try those Gardein Ultimates. But again, I'm faced with an hour drive to get my hands on them.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

ughhhhhh

[@jotacrawl]

You guys need to try OZO as well

[@krisharrison9219]

Wish more Gardein products were gluten-free!!!

[@Aireybby]

That ultimate chickn tastes and smells like curry, which is not a flavor I’m fond of. So surprised to see it so high on the list for you guys and many of the people in the comments.

[@MakeItDairyFree]

oh wow, we didn't get that at all, but Andrew grew up with curry often and I like it too so maybe just taste differences

[@MissStasi77]

Yaaaay you guys tried the gardien Ultimate .... they also make nuggets and tenders in the the Ultimate... I need to try the alpha ones I have tried all the rest

[@DrDestinyPerry]

I love Alpha products. The Alpha patties and Alpha nuggets are really good in the air fryer. My kids love them! Incogmeato tenders are really good as well.

[@nburris1127]

I luv ya'll videos (kinda long but, I get it) 🤷🏾‍♀️ I think the Buffalo Morningstar chicken taste way better than the original but, imma have 2 get the Ultimate Gardein now, thanks 4 da 🔌! 🥰

[@christophermorin9036]

I love the Quorn Meatless Patties (Not the spicy one though, don't like too much spicy.) I have switched over to those completely and haven't had a real chicken patty in 6 months now. The Quorn Homestyle Meatless Chiqin Cutlets are like 3 steps above them though. So good, the coating crisps up into a satisfying crunch like I'm having a KFC Crispy thigh.

[@xio195]

My favorite is the morningstar❤

[@Araielle]

I haven't seen the Gardien Ultimate chicken patties. I get the ultimate burgers when I get burgers, though. I'll be looking for them. Thank you!

[@julieharden2433]

I just tried the Morningstar Buffalo Chicken Patty a couple of weeks ago - omg, so good. I had very low expectations, but these were delicious. I tried them on it's own - just cut up; and, I also tried them on bread with some Just Mayo. I really liked them. If only I could find a good vegan blue cheese.

[@235tracker]

Thanks for the review. I've tried almost all and agree with your assessment. My favorite so far is the Gardein Ultimate (pricey at an average of $7.99) My only disappointments are the price a along with the pkg only having 3 patties. For that reason, I won't be buying them often. Thanks again.

[@Gigi-ny6mc]

Those all looked so good, wish Gardein made a gluten and soy free option 🤤😩

[@MakeItDairyFree]

Hopefully they do! I was hoping the new Beyond would be but it doesn't look like it is either

[@hollitheexaltedempress6957]

I went to the stores: Jewels and whole foods and I could not find any ultimate anything at whole foods. I only found the ultimate burger at jewels. That burger is the best I have ever tasted! In my opinion, it beats both impossible and beyond they are not as good as the ultimate burger. So I have to find that chicken because I hate all of the other fake "chicken stuff. They taste like cornmeal and cardboard with grease.

[@victoriablanc761]

we like the yves chicken patty. it's great chopped up on salads and pasta. we do use the gardein also. and wow you both say the word LIKE like a LOT . I do appreciate all the time and effort it takes you guys to do these. they are so helpful. I will now go and look for that new gardein ultimate one. thx for that! enjoy you two.

[@r8derman]

I’ve had the Gardein products for yrs. Their stuff is good… Alpha is pretty good also.

[@submittofit]

Wow 😮 I'm shocked you didn't like the whole foods one I though that would have ranked high, at the very least better than boca. Interesting

[@kassadayj]

I am like Andrew I am very picky with meats and other food which made me decide to become a pescatarian

[@MakeItDairyFree]

👍🏻

[@jc9585]

What buns are ya'll using?