Vocal Analysis and Reaction to RUSH performing The Garden

What can I say? I'm hooked. We're listening to Rush again today, but this time with a more recent performance. This is my first time hearing the song The Garden, and this particular video is from their 2012 Clockwork Angels Tour.
Watch the original video uninterrupted: • Rush - Clockwork Angel...
🎶 Website: www.thevocalys...
💙 Patreon: / thevocalyst
#rush #reaction #vocalcoach

[@jmsmooch]

It warms this old man's heart knowing younger folks are discovering and appreciating the greatness that are Rush.

[@mikebliss1835]

I'm thirty. I was lucky enough to see them live on their Snakes & Arrows tour. They have been my favorite band for years.

[@ReverendDangles]

I'm 38 and been a fan for years. I got to see them on Vapor Trails tour. Still the top concert I've been to.

[@mycroft16]

44, been a fan since my brother introduced me to them on Hold Your Fire. Didn't get to see them in concert until R40, and man am I glad I did.

[@paulgale2565]

Amen brother. Fan from the early 70s, kids today dont understand what these guys, 3 guys, were able to do. Master musicians, each holding up their leg of the tripod. No band today or back then made such intensive music. RIP Professor.

[@larryjewell7048]

First time I saw Rush they were lead off group for KISS.

[@corwinchristensen260]

The last song from the last album. A tribute from Neil to his lost family members and ended up being an incredible swan song for Rush as a whole. Alex, Geddy, and Neil carefully planted and nourished a beautiful, magnificent Garden and we still get to enjoy it every day. If you'll excuse me ... I think I have something in my eye.

[@ionizer24]

Well said.

[@Fuzzywuzzywasawoman]

I thought exactly this,there isn’t a more beautiful journey,that song proves that

[@mvunit3]

🥲

[@furmanodell]

Big time. I'm not crying, you're crying.

[@stantuck3235]

Me too!!

[@clockworkangel4026]

😢 I still tear up when listening to this song (probably always will). Geddy did have a harder time with the higher register in later years, but to me, it makes this performance even more powerful.

[@pdcrmr]

Exactly. There’s a poignancy to the performance given the band was nearing final harvest. The melancholy in his voice matched the mood

[@vinceaaron8921]

the slight breaking when going for those high ones gives it a sadness that just wouldn't be there otherwise.

[@paulniemiec3165]

So spot on ❤

[@derekknight4214]

I tear up because the lyrics have new meaning since the passing of the Professor. 😢

[@ionizer24]

If you enjoy the Clockwork Angel album, check out the trilogy of novels of the same name he co-wrote. The Garden is the band’s swan song, the trilogy is Neil’s.

[@michaelcoady7085]

From Working Man to The Garden. A totally unique career span. Never to be repeated by any band.

[@eventhorizon2218]

100% my friend. Maybe it's just me, but the genius of RUSH never gets old. I can listen them over & over. They knew Neil was dying, thus this song. RIP NEIL, you will never be forgotten...but forever missed. God, I miss them so much.

[@imacmanx8562]

As you probably already know, this was the last song on their last album. This was Neil's way of saying "Goodbye" , and I get choked-up every time I listen to it, knowing what's coming years later. 😢 So obvious you're becoming a RUSH fan!!

[@markstromberg1148]

Neil Peart's passing still brings me sadness, and this song evokes the same tears as yours. As much of a prodigious talent as he was, I believe Neil Peart should have been better known for his prodigious love of life, his respect for other human beings, his gentility, and his intellect. This was reflected in his music and lyrics, but also in his books and interviews. I know it is strange to have felt such an intellectual closeness to someone I never had the privilege of meeting, but in Neil's case it is heart-felt.

[@ponderingnugget]

As a fellow fan who managed to catch every tour from Presto onward I would say, based on the shows that I saw, he could still hit the majority of his high notes, but he seemed to get fatigued. He would let you have it for a song, then take it easy for a few, then punch it again for a song or two, then back off again. etc.

[@DavidLazarus]

Yes, I get depressed when I hear the song even though I like it just knowing that it was Rush's last song. Darn I hope Geddy and Alex do a project together! They've earned their retirement for sure, but it would be so great to hear them together again even in the music is completely different.

[@Smartie1]

@@ponderingnugget the presto tour was fantastic !!

[@jmeakin4]

​@@Smartie1Bunnies!

[@scottgates6609]

This was the Daddy-Daughter dance at my daughter's wedding reception. We both wore concert shirts over our formal clothes. The DJ loved the song and said he had never done a Rush song for this dance. An amazing memory!

[@johnburger7098]

Lifeson's guitar work on this song is gorgeous.

[@dickmanson2081]

Always a master of his craft, yet so underrated because many people don't realize he's as capable at shredding as he is at melody and extensive chord knowledge. The Analog Kid and La Villa Strangiato are two of my favourite songs simply because of that.

[@Bartysquire]

Hauntingly beautiful

[@kriskollmar9728]

And his piano work.

[@Mozart1220]

It always is.

[@jmeakin4]

​@@kriskollmar9728- It's stunning to see him impersonating Geddy - playing his primary instrument PLUS keyboards, AND even singing too!

[@neilsackman4723]

I had the pleasure to cook dinner for Geddy when he came into the restaurant I worked at. And being a life long Rush fan after he finished his meal I went out and met him. He signed a menu with a nice message to me and took a good few minutes to talk with me. He was so nice and had no problem at all taking time for a nice chat. A truly genuine person.

[@apezeroviking]

I have met Geddy three times and the second and third time he remembered me and we chatted for about 15 mins each time. The man is the picture of authentic kindness and a genuine down-to-earth human being. There is absolutely no false or haute affect to the man. What you see is what you get. And what you get is pure niceness, despite being a global rockstar.

[@user-nm9ex5je4u]

well, hes Canadian eh? what a hoser!@@apezeroviking

[@supernicko123]

This isn't the most complicated song written by Rush, or the most technically impressive, and yet it remains one of the most powerful farewells that I have ever heard. Rest in peace Neil Peart, he will be missed forever.

[@danlawrence4351]

I’ve had so many people listen to this song, yet no one so far has been moved by it like I have. I don’t understand how it falls on deaf ears. It is a beautiful song.

[@peterschmidt1936]

There are very few songs that brings this old hardened Rush fan to tears. This does it every time….

[@shelleyharrop1419]

Me too

[@egnblu]

Tears now

[@allanperry6507]

One of the most beautiful songs Rush has ever put out .A farewell to Neil and 🤘RUSH🤘.Smiles 😃 from Canada 🇨🇦

[@imlistening1137]

What I enjoy most about watching your videos is the amazing understanding of body mechanics, for lack of a better term, and how a voice creates different sound. It’s really interesting! Like the lifting eyebrows to lift the soft palate to and how that closes of the nasal passages (did I get that right?) I’ll listen again to be sure!

[@pictureofuu]

A farewell to kings, literally.

[@daviddelollis245]

"with tears in my eyes I write this" There are many moments in ones life that we remember where we were when a moment happened, I remember clearly where I was hearing this for the first time. For some reason I knew this was the end. It still hits just as hard today. Rush's last song, Neil's last song. Crushes me to this day.

[@mikebell2112]

I hadn't heard the album before seeing them live and I knew they wouldn't be back. They threw everything they had into those new songs.

[@jranonomuse]

Hope is what remains to be seen, I wrote this down on paper and dated it when I went through a breakup five year's before this song was released, Same here, by the end tho, I have an enormous smile, feeling grateful that we alway"s have hope that us human's can change and make a difference in this mortal world...You had it before you can have it again, Neil was a sage

[@steeleye2112]

Man, did they build an impressive garden. One that will never age or whither.

[@pgmorrow]

The perfect finale to a band's career and a tribute to their beautiful lives. They had their peaks but never declined in skill and creativity. They never became a nostalgia act.

[@catmanpc9166]

At this point in my life, after several losses, it amazes me how a man I never met, or knew, can affect me so much. A true Renaissance man. This particular song touches every button and heart string. Neil Peart. Admired for his talent, respected for his intellect, loved for his humanity. RIP Professor. 😿

[@MrBearsfan34]

I always cry when I listen to this. Especially when I see Neil. It’s just heart wrenching to watch. The fact that it’s their very last song on the final album. The meaning behind the lyrics, and especially the connection to Neil, and the relevance to it. RIP Neil, you will always be missed, but never forgotten. 😢❤

[@funkster007]

And with this song, Rush closes their final chapter. I can only come back to this one on rare ocassions. Pretty emotional.

[@StefanEngler-rb8lu]

So true. It’s a tough one.

[@j.r.576]

Very few bands write such a meaningful album after doing it for over 40 years! Clockwork Angels is as relevant as any of their music. The Garden is an absolute gem.

[@therealivydawg]

To me it's my favorite

[@bobkitten8150]

You're so good at noticing and explaining all the nuances of a song. With over 40 years of music, I feel as if I grew up along with these guys, with this song being the culmination of what we've experienced. It breaks my heart that Neil is gone, but I feel so fortunate to have been in this world at the same time as Rush.

[@tomburns7544]

You nailed everything I was going to say. Not only of her explaining but also how I've felt growing up with Rush music and Neil's passing.

[@don-o-seven1437]

Very nice summary.. The theme of this song and it being their very last will always hit me

[@brilondon]

We all have. It's pretty emotional listening to Clockwork Angles for me still.

[@kenbourne8011]

The best band I ever have or ever will see live in concert. Absolute masters.

[@obxwave]

It’s really hard to credit, how good they were….

[@playbassken]

Like someone else commented, this was Neil's way of saying, "Goodbye." to all of us without us even knowing what he was going through. May he forever Rest In Peace.

[@raynscloud8072]

It can't be 11 years since this song came out. Geddy's diction (and Neil's lyrical word choice) has always made it really easy to hear what he was saying. And you are spot on about his deliberateness with diphthongs. As usual, you have a wonderful glow about you while you are listening to Rush. I love that they make you get a little flustered and make you grin. Geddy's voice changed as he aged; the highest pitches from earlier songs became unreachable, but the broadness of his sound increased giving the newer songs a different, wider tonal scale he could use. The band realized this (of course) and even dropped the tuning of some of their older songs when live to make it easier for Geddy to reach the top notes. It makes for a different sound and the renditions of some of the older songs can come across as a bit strained in later concerts. Of course, the newer songs were written with his present voice in mind, so there wasn't any fiddling needed with them.

[@TDOTMUSICNERD]

Man.. I really miss these guys 😔😔… my hometown heroes … they are the glue of the fabric of my youth ..and they moulded my appreciation for musicianship… truly 3 legends … thank you thank you thank you for giving them a listen … ♥️

[@LS-uv9gg]

No matter how many times I hear this song, I tear up.

[@iron_rush_theater1246]

Pinnacle song for an unmatched career. Goosebumps. Every. Time.

[@kkirw01]

A tear every time… I miss them so much

[@wendymotogirl]

I just wish they could match the instrumental part of this with the vocal from the album, as it's sad to hear Getty's voice so weak and off key.

[@michaelatkinson8291]

This song was the perfect conclusion to the Clockwork Angels story. It only became more apt with Neil's sad passing in January 2020 & took on a whole new perspective. One of Alex Lifeson's finest & emotive solo's too. Great articulate & informative reaction, thank you x

[@TheHabs2112]

The lyric "The future disappears into memory With only a moment between Forever dwells in that moment" might be my favourite Neil wrote. Think about it. It basically sums up how life is experienced. All we have is the moment we are in.

[@williamrodriguez296]

Some have mentioned it already but the day this album came out I purchased it. I listened to it and song by song I instantly realized it was going to be a classic. I was thrilled that it was not only great, but I enjoyed the rock opera feel. This album was a story. I didn't have a heads up on that and was pleasantly surprised by it. I was so happy......till "The Garden." It sounded beautiful. Too beautiful. The lyrics kicked in and I knew something was wrong. Something was happening. I never stop a song I am listening to for the first time, and I did several times. As some have written, I knew it was the end. Of what, I had no idea. By the end of the song, I was nearly having a meltdown. Irrationally emotional. It was a masterpiece, and I felt that would be the last song. Rush was over. I had no idea about Neil, his illness, or the gravity of it. I just knew that he wrote every word for Rush, and the man that wrote The Garden was writing about finality and saying goodbye. When I got the news Neil passed, I went over, put on the song and I could feel every single line come to life. A living farewell. A lesson on what matters. One last gift.

[@mycroft16]

Neil knew, and he put everything, all of the talent he had nurtured throughout his career into this one. And Alex and Geddy poured theirs in as well, even without knowing. You absolutely could feel the finality in this song as it goes. It's the quiet, soft, lingering goodbye that you don't want to happen, but is inevitable. It's difficult to explain but we all know what it's like.

[@stevestruthers6180]

Neil wasn't diagnosed with brain cancer until sometime in 2017, so he didn't write the lyrics with the idea that it would be a swan song because he was dying. However, in the years leading up to the band's final concert in 2015, he had repeatedly expressed a desire to retire from touring at least so he could be closer to his family. This song could be looked upon as a retrospective look at a long career in music as well as the beginning of the end of Rush as we knew it. A further signal that the end was coming was when Rush sold off their entire song catalogue in 2014, after Neil had agreed to do one more tour (the R40 tour) before retiring for good. It wasn't just a desire to be close to his family that drove him into retirement, but also the fact that he had developed chronic tendinitis, and it was negatively affecting his ability to play well.

[@jmilandry5544]

The Garden makes me tear up every time I hear it, it is such a beautiful introspective song and represents Rush's philosophy so well. I can't help but think how pleased Neil must have been to hear it all come together for the first time with the addition of the string section - a quietly glorious, sad yet uplifting, heartfelt thing of beauty - and their final gift to us. Thank you, guys, may your music live forever.

[@mikedown3219]

38 years on from their first tour and the first time they had other musicians on stage (apart from the odd guest appearance). The string section really added something to this concert. Geddy lost the ability to hit some of those really high notes so, as a Rush fan from the very beginning, it is interesting to see how he adapted his voice over time. The Garden, being the final track on their final studio album will always have a special place in the hearts of all Rush fans. Thsi was a stunning performance.

[@tedalfred9516]

It's so cool to see somebody with your youth and musical background starting to really appreciate these three guys and what they were and how incredibly talented and diverse they were for 45 years on stage. Even more amazing... through all the fame and fortune these three guys were best friends, never let their egos etc detract from what was important to them. All three of these guys got married young, had kids and put their wives, kids, families and friendships at the top of importance in their lives, which is so unusual in this business.

[@bigstyx]

He sounds like a friend giving advice to someone he loves.

[@billspruce8368]

I am a lifelong Rush fan... The Garden is one of the greatest songs they ever wrote. I still get choked uo everytime I hear it... RIP Neil.

[@hemispheresamusements7484]

I held it together til the 17-minute mark and that was it. I cried like a schoolgirl. Man it tears me up seeing neil play one of his last shows and knowing we'll never see them on stage again. Damn we had a great run didn't we?! I am so blessed to have lived in the era of Rush. I love these guys so much ❤ What a fantastic close to their career. Ugh... I can't see a damn thing right now

[@theverdestreet]

Yay, Rush--the band that influenced everyone's influences. I was fortunate enough to see them a few times over the years, and it was always an experience that make me strive to be a better musician.

[@cityhonors1]

😔 This song still puts me in a puddle. 🤗 As someone who was ready to pay for R50 tickets, I had no idea this Tour & Time Machine would be the last time I'd hear this song! 😔 RIP Professor.... 🥰🐰

[@bradc009]

So glad you are sharing Rush with your audience....

[@kevindohn6776]

The words to this song are so sad, especially since Neil died a short time after, quite unexpectedly to most of us. Us Rush fans have had to grow up in the past few years, and realize good things don't last forever, and that life goes by in a flash. The measure of a life, we all know the gifts these three guys gave to us, and I thank them !

[@jopay142]

I'm barely 54, but when I hear "The Garden" I cannot help myself and make a "life retrospective"... My goods, my bads and my "what if?"... Big big respect to these guys.

[@Alberto_1965_BR]

Great song. Best band ever! The last track from the last album "The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect" Peart recalled in the bio. “It occurred to me that all songwriters should experience the sensual delight of hearing their songs performed by an accomplished string section. For example, when these virtuoso artists on violin, viola, cello and double-bass executed David’s plangent orchestration for ‘The Garden,’ there was not a dry eye in the studio.” Rest in Peace Professor

[@itzel1735]

First violin here, Jonathan Dinklage, was also the violist for the first run of “Hamilton” on Broadway.

[@michaelpoe8332]

life long rush fan and drummer. when Neil passed, I openly wept. the only person I ever cried for that I had never met. thank you Rush !!

[@nwbourbonboys2115]

Its so amazing how Rush create their best record at the end.

[@donaldbass6737]

Neil’s swan song…makes a Rush fan tear-up. “The measure of a life, is a measure of Love and Respect, so hard to earn…so easily burned…”

[@RUSH__fan]

Saw them twice on their Angels tour. Great track off what I think is their best album. After all, they kept improving throughout their careers. They never lost a step or beat playing live.

[@conniedavis]

Me too! Saskatoon and Seattle. 2nd row in Saskatoon. Best concert ever. This song is my ❤.

[@lisaharrison1031]

The last song that RUSH ever wrote. They ended with perfection. ❤️❤️

[@tricia3114]

😢. Yes.. Rush = Perfection.

[@goodpainlive]

a masterpiece among many of their masterpieces

[@brilondon]

This is a song that could bring anyone to tears. It still does for me.

[@Mrbigp59]

rush are incredible musicians thank you young lady for listening to one of my favorite rock bands and giving your joyful evaluation. Wish there were more like you.

[@jeremynewcastle]

Yeah this is indeed a beautiful song from Rush. Another Canadian band comes to mind when I think of Rush. And I think it could be a very good reaction video. The band is called Triumph! Do a reaction on any live video of “Lay it on the Line”. I said any, because they are very good live. Anyone else here remember Triumph???

[@deniseanne45]

Go “Triumph”!!!! Now that’s an awesome band.

[@lballc9161]

Whoa! I remember Truimph!!! Here’s a good live version. Yes Rik Emmett is a powerhouse vocalist. kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJzbZWqQqN6cmcU

[@GEDDY37]

Of course midsummers daydream

[@adambratcher3444]

Saw them in concert twice. Great shows.

[@michaelmunson9195]

My intro was Sombodys out there. Went backwards and fell in love with Triumph.

[@dmanton300]

The last song on the final album. What a way to bookend a career. Yeah, I cried when I heard it live.

[@lisaharrison1031]

So emotional thinking about being there for this show in Dallas. Knowing now that Neil only had about a few years left to live…… I can’t hear this one without crying even all these years later. How I miss these guys. They were my life for over 40 years……….RUSH FOREVER!!

[@lockerius4208]

The most beautiful message ever put to music.

[@graybri]

Rush is always intentional in their composition. Such fantastic artists.

[@michaeltalley5826]

The last song on their last album, Rush leave us with something so profound and beautiful.

[@lindaward5376]

What I've always enjoyed about Rush's music is the pure depth of emotion in Geddy's voice, which is so beautifully brought out by the elements you discussed, and perfectly complemented by the instrumental arrangements, helping to bring out the pure poetry in Neil's lyrics. The Garden is the perfect way for Rush to close the book on an amazing career, and a fitting tribute to Neil and how he has inspired us all. Rest in peace Professor. Neil Peart R.I.P 🥁 🥁 🐐 🐐

[@cygnetseven]

Your appreciation and understanding of the place this song has in the hearts of Rush fans really moves me. These were some of Neil's final lyrics and one of the last songs composed by the band. That just adds to the weight of the impact each time I hear it. I don't listen to it very often so each time I do it's very special. Again, thank you for your appreciation.

[@michaelshawn2946]

The song I listened to going to see my mom who had passed away in the early morning , it makes think about that drive everytime I hear it... it says so much about life..... R.I.P Neil..

[@phiby123]

Just one of THE most beautiful songs ever, just amazingly talented musicians, Neil Peart an equally brilliant writer as he was a drummer. RIP Neil Peart 😢

[@chirigringo777]

He is THE PROFESSOR on many levels

[@PrattFan2112]

I appreciate that you noticed Geddy changing tone/inflection/meaning to lyrics that were repetitive in the chorus or other parts. Rush is really good at that especially in the percussion also. Neil typically changes up his fills in an area he repeats in most songs to bring new intention to parts. They are just brilliant virtuoso musicians❣️. Please check out Freewill from their Rio tour in 2002 released in 2003. He can still hit the high notes!

[@wxmaggot5669]

I tear up everytime I hear this. I can't help it. The lyrics are so powerful, so meaningful, and thought provoking. This song is, in my opinion, what music is about. The feelings a song can illicit, the memories they trigger... It's a gift. Rush, as a band, is a gift.

[@jasontrebilcock6496]

I'll go ahead and echo what some of the other commenters have already stated...there aren't a whole lot of songs that will bring me to tears, but this is one of them...and probably at the top of the list. Both for what the song is and for what it represented.

[@biggie25x]

This song brings tears to my eyes every time I listen to it. It encapsulates everything I love about the band and it has the most impactful lyrics I’ve listened to yet. Thanks for reacting to it with care.

[@Heathcoatman]

This song always bring a tear to my eye. Not just because it's a beautiful song, but because it's the last track on their last album. It signifies the end of Rush to me.

[@jameswelty4517]

For Neal this song very fitting…There will never be enough tears

[@ZenWithKen]

I don't think he could have sang this in the early part of his career. His voice certainly mellowed with age, in a good way. The concert was awesome, an experience to remember. Thanks for sharing.

[@andresgroove]

This song makes so sad. As a die fan of this unique, talented, genius instrumentalists trio... Means a good bye and thank you to everyone who listened and supported them for more than 40 years

[@timshelton8535]

I’m cutting onions again! Don’t know if I’ll ever listen to this song again without getting a bit emotional. Miss seeing them live!

[@metalmamasue3680]

What a band & what a career. From the classic Bob & Doug MacKenzie Take Off to this masterpiece. I'd say lives well lived, songs well sung and thanks for the memories. I will always treasure them. 🥰

[@hustler3of4culture3]

I miss the new messages every few years and then the tour. Right there with ya. They always had something to say that helped over the years. It's hard without anything new anymore.

[@standing0]

To write such poignant words shows how fully aware Neil was at the situation he was facing and how fulfilled a life it was...such a brilliant artist...RIP Professor.

[@udlilly]

You are an amazing woman , I've never seen or observed a more appreciation towards an artist in my life. Love it and you as a person

[@4570highwall]

I saw the Clockwork Angels Tour in Minneapolis Sept. 24th 2012. At that time in my life Rush was my favorite band. The music was fantastic. This tour was the first and only time that they had an orchestra tour with them. Of course Geddy Lee's voice had drastically changed and was unable to hit the high notes that he was able to in his earlier years, and had to struggle at times, but I'm so glad that I had the opportunity to see them. Rest In Peace Neil I miss you. In my mind you were and still are the greatest!

[@jodimayer225]

I am so happy you reacted to this beautiful song. Always brings me to tears. A special song to me. The reflection of one's life (or career in this case). I saw this concert, one of many over the years, with my best friend Conrad. He, like me was a life-long Rush fan, and was in his last few months with a terminal brain tumour. The words of this song helped me to eulogize him when he did pass at 46 yrs old. "The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect So hard to earn, so easily burned" "The measure of a life is a measure of love and respect The way you live, the gifts that you give In the fullness of time is the only return that you expect" "The future disappears into memory With only a moment between Forever dwells in that moment Hope is what remains to be seen" Rest in peace Conrad and Neil.

[@craigscott6975]

I was so looking forward to you doing this song and knew you would LOVE and respect this song and the genius of Rush. Did not disappoint. Thank you!😎

[@BalokLives]

I am so happy to hear that you love Geddy's voice in his later years. I agree! His voice became so rich and melodic as he aged. He had to lower his range an octave because he started to struggle with the high notes as he aged. Even though he lowered it, he still tried to sing things a bit too high, and you can hear his method of reaching the high notes. He has this thing he does where he swings his voice into place, and you can almost always hear him crack. It doesn't sound bad. As you get used to it, it begins to sound intentional. Almost like a trill. This song always reminds me how much Rush means to me, and how much I still miss them. They are still such a huge part of my life, and this song has become more and more important. Not only in its lyrics, but to me it also reminds me of the end of Rush, and Neil's death. It was as though Neil was saying goodbye. This song is truly a tearjerker. I have been obsessed with Rush almost my whole life. I've listened since I was in Jr. High in 1976, but since Neil's death I have been listening to them over and over and over. I can't get enough. I watch every live performance I can find on KZbin again and again.

[@garylagstrom3864]

I’m glad you dig RUSH! I play drums and have seen every tour since 1977. Neil Peart is the ultimate percussionist-drummer-lyricist. His command of the drums are like no other and his command of the English language and literature are second to none! All in All not bad for a guy who didn’t graduate high school but ironically is called: THE PROFESSOR! RIP PROFESSOR😢😢😢

[@user-og2wt3le4j]

Geddy was 60 at the time of the tour. His voice is in pretty good shape for a 60 year old.

[@polar315]

As many have said it appears this was Neil's farewell. Closing a chapter in his life to open a new one in his retirement. Sadly, it was a shorter than hoped and he was taken far too soon. Neil said the least of all 3 but, still spoken the greatest volume in his songs. This song grips me so strongly. I pair it with Time Stand Still. Life was moving so fast.

[@dragonmac1234]

RIP Professor, gone far too soon but never forgotten.

[@jimmiller8132]

There are three songs I've listened to in my 55 years that make me tear up EVERY time. 1. The Garden 2. Supper's Ready (Genesis) 3. 100 years (Five for Fighting) I am 55..and discovered RUSH as a 13 yr old and have been hooked for 40+ yrs. There will NEVER be another to span the decades, change with the sound of the times, and stay relevant. Thee masters of the Holy Trinity..never to again be duplicated and I am proud to say I watched them grow, age, and evolve into legendary virtuosos.

[@hemispheres6942]

Why do I tear up everytime I hear this... lovely, Respectful reaction!

[@k-popplayinklown5473]

Geddy’s voice has always been very comforting for me A familiar friend ( 48 years

[@tmage23]

After 2005 or so, Geddy's voice was incapable of hitting the same pitch he could hit when younger but became warmer and richer. IMO it was a pretty good tradeoff.

[@jonplatts7861]

This song will always give me goosebumps and makes me cry at the same time 😢. If there was such a thing as a perfect song to sign off a career, then this is it.

[@MinorIllusion42]

I just watched all your Rush videos, because KZbin wouldn’t stop telling me I needed to. For once, KZbin was right! It has been such a thrill watching you become a fan of the greatest band ever! (in my humble opinion) I’m glad to have found your channel, and am happily subscribing.

[@traumasurg2827]

This song was so special to my baby brother and I- we were both drummers until we lost him at only 45 a year ago almost to the day. This was the last song we had played at his funeral. So meaningful. RIP Lil brother and Neil.

[@isitrealgood]

I have been a Rush fan for years, but I didn't run out and buy "Clockwork Angels" and have only recently really heard "The Garden". It brings great meaning to me because my parents both died within four months of each other within four months in the last few months of 2021. Sitting at my mother's grave this past summer, the one thing that helped me meditate was pulling out my phone and listening to "The Garden". I'm struck by the strings, which seem to be playing the melody of the old hymn "In The Garden," but with vibrato, like the wind washing through willow fronds. It is a lyric born of maturity, written by Neil, sung with a performance born of maturity by Geddy.

[@debbieplato5107]

Such a beautiful song and as usual I really enjoyed your commentary. Cheers

[@ronmonroephotography]

Beautiful reaction ❤ one of my all time favorite rush songs.. rip Neil. Thank you so much for sharing ❤️

[@mwales2112]

Over the decades Alex has played some amazing solo's, but I feel this is one of his best if not the best.... The Garden is closer to the heart to so many people than any song, by anyone...

[@ThePensive8]

Getty is telling a story like a wise individual....moreover vocally as he/they as a group have matured....beautiful reaction.

[@JK-hf7fd]

I absolutely LOVE, LOVE, LOVE! your commentary and reflections about what makes this song so very special. Keep Being You! Grande Respect!

[@timothydukeman7619]

Huge RUSH fan, here... Geddy inspired me to play bass. Love this entire song, but when they transition from verse to chorus (@ 01:24), gets me every time... and the lyrics... so meaningful, to all of us.

[@brettking1014]

I love watching your analysis. Thank you! This is a beautiful song

[@michaelbriefs9764]

That was lovely. So glad you loved and appreciated that beautiful song. Way to nail that vocal, Geddy!

[@pahtar7189]

The Clockwork Angels tour was such a departure for Rush. An orchestra, Alex on keyboard, and this song that brings a tear to the eye.

[@carltuzza8076]

I adore all the tributes for probably the greatest band and the greatest song ever written. Thank you RUSH and mostly Thank You RUSH Fans!

[@capstan50g]

I've never heard this Rush song before. I have heard Geddy's lower register, though, and the contrast with his higher timbre and cries makes for a very emotional delivery. Great analysis as always, Bethany!

[@thornysnotsoepic]

Geddy's vocals matured as his career progressed. He always took very good care of it. Even while playing hundreds of shows. That's how Rush was as whole. They always had to do everything perfect, otherwise what was the point of doing it. In the R40 tour you could tell from the recording he was wearing out but still pressed on and sounded great. True professional.

[@chipsfalling8625]

It seems the earned respect and love it draws to it, are worthy. Integrity is not an illusion, after all.

[@kkirw01]

Tear up a little every time. I miss these guys so much.