Vocal Coach Reaction - Atif Aslam 'Tajdar-e-Haram'

[@DivjotSingh]

Wine is metaphorical here. As the song builds up, it talks about destitution and grief, be it materialistic or spiritualistic. Then it goes about how all peace and glory of world is contained in holy Medina. The filling up of chalices doesn't mean literal wine but rather getting all the matters resolved, getting rid of grief, and destitution (spiritualistic). As you might know, consumption of alcohol is forbidden in Islam. Here materialistic wine is compared to the spiritual bliss one gets by going to Medina.

[@f1aziz]

bravo for putting it so aptly.

[@f1aziz]

If I could dare to add to your comment, visiting Medina is portrayed as something like an ecstasy or euphoria that you normally get from intoxication, since intoxication is impermissible in Islam the metaphor of wine gives color to the experience of pilgrimage to the holy place.

[@abrishkhadija]

Wow wordings and explanation.. 👌

[@areeba1908]

Well explained brother😇♥️

[@shinylucky]

wow...u eleborated so nicely 👍

[@rahallivex]

english subtitles can never do justice to this song.

[@saadthefirstofhisname]

Not Song Qwalli

[@pzshakoor7013]

Yes

[@lostforever3451]

Not a song. This is Naat. Praise to Prophet Mohammed PBUH.

[@irebelabdulhannanabdulhann107]

exactly

[@user-bi8uh5fq3q]

True.

[@sandrameesala6804]

Im Christian and the song made feel some sort of way!! 😃

[@abbasgondal6691]

could u explain

[@azkhan3560]

Masallah

[@samitashafqat7774]

Yeah his voice has a certain pitch in this

[@sheenshah5253]

Oh wow. I recommend Beautiful Quran Tilawat. Will make u feel so much in peace. Especially good against all sorts of negative energy, depression, anxiety and for amnesia (chapter Rahman from Quran). Try it.

[@nazs.7303]

@@abbasgondal6691 he means it feels like a path to explore.

[@lifenur5095]

*Pakistani singers take singing to a next level*

[@randomstuffs844]

Indian here and I approve your statement

[@rakeshkshetrimayum7830]

Feeded by India though.

[@octaneplaysmc3156]

@@rakeshkshetrimayum7830 english 100

[@at1f_s]

@@rakeshkshetrimayum7830 nice English and the way your saying is like they've never worked in Pakistan.

[@mohsinehsan6264]

Exatly. But owner of this channel many time said Rahat fateh ali as INDIAN singer plese say him thy all are Pakistai singers

[@yeahehtheseguyseh3703]

*Urdu the language of poets*

[@yeahehtheseguyseh3703]

@haider ali bahadur Urdu-Punjabi Yes. Not Sanskrit/Hindi-Punjabi.

[@yeahehtheseguyseh3703]

@haider ali bahadur Urdu was made to be used as a disciple language that was polite and sweet. The loan words were taken from Turkish, Arabic and Farsi which was fused together and now we call it *Urdu*. While Punjabi has more then 20 different dialects. The main dialect is Majhi and It is broken down to Shahmuki or Gurumukhi. Gurmukhi using Sanskrit loanwords while Shahmuki using Urdu (Arabic, Turkish, Farsi) loanwords especially after 1837. 🤦‍♂️ Shahmuki Punjabi leans towards Urdu (arabic+turkish+persian=urdu) Gurmukhi Punjabi leans towards Hindi (sanskrit=hindi)

[@yeahehtheseguyseh3703]

@haider ali bahadur Did Sanskrit come first or Punjabi? Sanskrit influence Punjabi. Punjabi was then influence by Persian. Then when Urdu took hold in the 13th century. Urdu influenced Punjabi. Hence I only used it as a reference instead of calling it Shahmukhi-Persian Punjabi. I simply said Urdu-Punjabi. Which seem to hurt you? 🤦‍♂️🤷‍♂️ So either you can say Punjab is a bit influenced by Sanskrit/Hindi or by Persian/Urdu and when someone says Urdu (incorporating Arabic, Persian and Turkish) one shouldn't have an inferiority complex because that's what happened to Hindus when Urdu gained official status. 😁 Really not hard to understand buddy. No one is taking your Gurmukhi-(Sanskrit)Hindi Punjabi away from you though.

[@babansalve1139]

@@yeahehtheseguyseh3703 Sanskrit was the first language of India . It is also called as god's language. Marathi and Hindi are produced from sanskrit.

[@yeahehtheseguyseh3703]

@@babansalve1139 Arabic became God's language in the end to communicate with humanity.

[@Dontworryboutit247]

He didn't realize the most important thing about the song that atif was clearly singing in two different languages Urdu and Arabic and he didn't notice any difference when he switched from Urdu to Arabic....

[@artaholicsnotebook6743]

Ali Syed 3 actually also persian

[@Shaadmood]

I mean he doesnt really know the 3 languages so its forgivable. Its pretty hard to distinguish between langauges you've never really heard espeicially if they're similar.

[@zhin8294]

@@Shaadmood stop watching so much kpop ffs

[@Shaadmood]

@@zhin8294 Umm where did I mention Kpop and what right do you have to order me to do something or not? I don't know you nor do you know me so why would you tell me this? In fact, You should stop watching this much KZbin. And who told you I watch so much Kpop? You don't even know me.

[@zhin8294]

@@Shaadmood LMAO! Why so hyper aggressive? We both know that you watch too much Kpop. Just tell me if I'm wrong. You are addicted and that is not good. You need help. Just like every other person addicted to this cheap low lvl entertainment. Kpop is a cancerous industry. The less people watch it, the quicker it will die. You are probably too young for me to argue with you about this matter. Since most people who are addicted to kpop are young girls. And if you are older like 17-20 and still watching kpop, well then that is just sad and tragic. My advice is simple. Stop watching kpop and find other interests. I see that you watch anime. Maybe take more interest in that instead of Kpop.

[@mominx2412]

I don't know what he's singing, but it's beautiful and peaceful.

[@noorsabah1766]

Its Kalam .. Or you can say that HAMD ( ITS type of poem in which you praise allah and his nature )

[@taehyungtaetae1242]

@@noorsabah1766 😍

[@eishal5780]

@@noorsabah1766 ayy Muslim army

[@noorsabah1766]

@@eishal5780 hyyyy

[@sumairazia9106]

@Jeremy Savva Your should listen the original one. Original one is best.

[@shehran6936]

This kind of music is called a Qawwali. They're often religious and speak of the Prophet (PBUH) and Allah (SWT). It's an Islamic tradition of the subcontinent. A kalaam is a declaration or message and some qawwals are rooted in kalaams by Muslim poets throughout South Asian history.

[@shriyashsonar2369]

Its sufi ma bro quwallis not like this

[@shriyashsonar2369]

Kidding

[@Farn01]

It's a tradition (qawwali, sufi, music etc) It is no where near Islamic, please don't put it under name of Islam.

[@xtremeownage2]

Cade, you cockroach. Qawwalli is Islamic as it is poetry from Muslims about Allah and his holy Prophet (SAW) and was developed first by Sufis who conveyed the beautiful message of Islam through such poetry.

[@ninadob6868]

Cade lol google it , sufism is totally related to islam . Search in the dictionary or google it

[@midget1716]

The most beautiful thing about watching such reactions is the unity in the comments section between people of the Indian sub-continent who belong to India or Pakistan. ❤️

[@cwehden]

Yes 👍🏻😊

[@jugjivan]

We are all the same. False borders and government propaganda has split up brother and sister from one another. We share the same culture, languages, history, and so forth. It's things like music that remind us of we are the same. It's time that we wake up and see that these governments only want to divide us and we should reunite through things such as music, history, and culture so hopefully one day we can be reunited as a people and as a mighty nation.

[@Himalayan.girl12]

@@jugjivan you are absolutely right.. these bloody politicians spread hate...

[@KingofKingziam]

I have met him in person and experienced his live rehearsal before his show in Washington DC. Atif Aslam amazed me with his singing skills. I am a huge music fan and I can tell you this. This guy can sing!!!!! GIFTED BY GOD!!!

[@adipakiamerican4628]

Waleed Malik I was there too and I requested him to sing that song and if u remeber he said I am singing this quwali later lol

[@Vedangi_]

Lucky you

[@bajrangmma4929]

Pakistan has the best singers in the world..atif aslam is presently the undisputed champ

[@midget1716]

bajrang sharma Indian singers too, I bet no one can beat Lata’s voice.

[@asifkan2]

So as India got talented singers as well.

[@moazzamshahkhan174]

Those who are saying Indian singer is better then show me an Indian song in different languages.i will show you thousands of Pakistani song like resistance by Abdullah, runaway by krewella, isq kinara in Turkish lang..etc I will show you many more if you want

[@anjalidilish807]

@@moazzamshahkhan174 do you know how many languages India even has? A single singer like shreya ghoshal has sung more than 10 languages. And brilliantly, too.

[@ShahzadAhmad-cu3kk]

Sssshhhhh its all india and its indian, the languages, the people, the lands the geography. Stop it, borders doesn't make sense. We were same before the division and we are same still from the land of "The Hind". 👌👍 We rocks together.

[@user-bi8uh5fq3q]

We Indians absolutely love & respect Atif Aslam... he is one of the finest singers .... and he sings soulfully that makes it so beautiful and spiritual .

[@OsamaAdel]

I'm Egyptian and I wish I could understand the original lyrics because I can infer some of them from the translations and I love it. I also liked the few Arabic sentences at the end. It's a beautiful song.

[@sabihasultan5986]

English subtitles are available with all COKE Studio original songs . If you turn on, you can see and definitely will enjoy more

[@Mohammed.zeeshan.ansari.]

this is naat not song

[@harithwaseem8468]

@@Mohammed.zeeshan.ansari. This is a qawwali because it has music, a naat (comparable to nasheed for the arabs) it doesnt have music. So this song is a qawwali and a song

[@bibekrai1776]

His voice spreads the loves between India and Pakistan. It was my fortunate to watched him live in global village and couldn't believe that he was singing live like recorded.

[@ziadazeem976]

💘💘

[@SuperDexter212]

Now you are also going to be addicted to coke studio Pakistan.

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

SuperDexter212 Hahahah You’re right!

[@cwehden]

2 more coming soon :)

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Carl John Franz Waiting...

[@astridchavezcardenas3241]

Absolutely true!

[@TigerPrawn_]

Can confirm. I started recently from season 1

[@syedfaisalrizvi7575]

This qwwalli has 3 languages 1.)Urdu 2.)Avdhi 3.)Persian Subtitles be like :tou kya karun main ,job chodh dun

[@KGB-FSB]

And Arabic as well

[@prathameshkulkarni99]

Abhishek Upamanyu's line 😁😁

[@omieee8125]

Hilarious 😂

[@zunaishakhan6994]

😂

[@britishmaithils4557]

@@zunaishakhan6994 what's hilarious

[@bertizfranxen5970]

beautiful song..touch my soul.. one of my favorte of Atif is DIL DIYAN GALLAN... #from philippines

[@Julia-LArt]

Bertiz Franxen So soul touching 🌸🙏🏻

[@xlonewolfx1638]

Same

[@muhammadtaha4458]

One of my fav

[@rafayabbasi9826]

Love and Respect from Pakistan.

[@himanshusakure895]

What province dude

[@afeeraadil1930]

9:33 " this guy is a very very good singer so clear, so clean" Well absolutely right!!! This guy is a Legend in music . And legends don't have imperfections. I bet you you'll never find any unique or better voice than him , just search the world and come back you'll agree to me definitely. Yah you can find the more amount of music or more upbeat music but the quality of vocals you'll find here will not be found nowhere.

[@KingKhan-gh9hi]

Its Amazing To See Our Indian Brothers Are Also Requesting For Reaction On Coke Studio Pakistan

[@Julia-LArt]

Funny Stuff By Mushtaq I love that! :)

[@sailenkatel3436]

We have ears too😀😉 and a thing of beauty is a joy for ever.

[@octane6916]

@@sailenkatel3436 Well said, bro! :)

[@param4553]

Coke studio is just awesome whole world should hear it 😃 its something that makes the world more beautiful 😍 altogether.

[@sandeepsharma1527]

Music has no boundaries ! :) Love from INDIA :)

[@sharanyasinha3979]

Atif has a lot of respect in Pakistan as well as India because of the amazing singer and humble grounded nature! ❤️❤️

[@haideralipunjabi]

Sabri Brothers were legendary Qawaals, and Tajdar-e-Haram was one of their most famous qawaalis. The group consisted Ghulam Fareed Sabri and Maqbool Sabri as vocalists, along with their brothers on various instruments. They started before Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan started Qawaalis. The next generation of Sabri Brothers was lead by Ghulam Fareed's son Amjad Sabri. You should watch Amjad Sabri's performance with Rahat Fateh Ali Khan (Nusrat's Successor) on Coke Studio known as Rang. The special thing about it is that it was first public appearance of Sabri Brothers and Nusrat or Rahat Fateh Ali Khan. Although some say there was an unrecorded performance on Rang by Ghulam Fareed Sabri and Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan at some shrine.

[@kulwinderkumar5793]

wonderful... Pakistani music👌👌

[@abrishkhadija]

👌👌Knowledge👏👏

[@anildamodaran]

Fantastic background info. Thank you.

[@zaidikbal]

Surely Sabri brothers are the pioneers of qawalli

[@MuhammadAdnanNiazi]

If there were i wish i could listen that...

[@BilluAwann]

English subtitles and verbal translations of lyrics of this song can never ever ever ever do justice to how personal this song is to every urdu speaking individual . This is some next level lyrics and specially presented by Atif is like holy grail . One sentence conclusion for this song for non urdu speakers would be “Praise god “

[@syedasaba4368]

You mentioned jeff buckley, let me tell u Atif aslam told in one of his interviews that his fav singer from west is jeff buckley. By the way nice reaction. check out atif aslam's channa,charka nolkhan,rabba sacheya and jal pari..all from coke studio sessions.

[@muhammadmuhammad3625]

Rabba sacheya is my all time favorite❤

[@targa9]

Yeah and also " Maye Ni" by Atif Aslam from Coke Studio Pakistan.

[@grapegirl]

Jeff Buckley in turn was a huge fan of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and actually alluded to him as "He's my Elvis". Buckley covered a bit of 'Yeh Jo Halka Halka Suroor Hai'. You can find it on KZbin.

[@mohsinpervez]

@@grapegirl ya i know

[@ahmad_razaaa]

You mentioned Jeff Buckley Well he was the most passionate admirer of ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan He said when i firstly heard opening lines of ye Jo halka halka suroor ha i was about to faint that how can one sing like that So Pakistan has so so much music talent And Nusrat was the greatest Singer of all times

[@yusufnoor5852]

This was a good reaction. Most vocal coaches give such ordinary reactions. Like what's the point of you reacting as a vocal coach if I learn literally nothing vocal related in your reaction.

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Yusuf Noor You are right !!

[@sanakamran007]

When you mentioned Buckley for his Nusrat influence.. I died n went to heaven .. much love from a Pakistani!

[@Jokyl989]

saw title, immediately clicked. CokeStudio has so many fantastic songs. Do Naina Moray!

[@nomankhan-mc8fv]

ThisisJokyl989 do you understand these?

[@anonymousdonor7812]

Do you take bath ever?

[@kaxhaffatima5601]

@@anonymousdonor7812 some Indians like you have nothing good to say!

[@dullasado]

@@kaxhaffatima5601 Exactly

[@AshutoshShelkeP]

@@anonymousdonor7812 bro stop spoiling our name.

[@RK.Kayani]

Why are some people thinking he is "judging" these are just his "reactions" mentioned in the title of this video.

[@Julia-LArt]

Love this reaction, Atif is truly amazing. He's singing a devotional song and it's a mix of Arabic, Urdu and Hindi. Thanks so much, Carl 🌟xx

[@shaheryaar]

He is a natural singer you know. Never took classes of singing. Its all pure natural talent.

[@rockerjubin]

You are right about his voice subtlety hitting hi notes and melodic subtle drop on the notes, effortlessly yet with enough resonance.

[@ahsanayub6581]

This style of music is known as Qawali in India and Pakistan. There is classical singing and Qawali singing. You can chose one of them, but they are very different from each other, i know you have noticed that too. Just for information Thanks for reading.

[@azhargujjar7754]

When language changes the voice also changes with it

[@gamer-guru-official]

Carl John be like " Main apko aj Sufi Music Sikhaunga"

[@thoughtfulwitch00]

🤣

[@Cooking4MyFamily]

Hahaha

[@sayedaamiralibacha8993]

😆😁😜😜

[@kasana_gujjar]

Tajdar-e-Haram means “King of Haram” , Haram is reference to Holy Site of Muslims where Kaaba 🕋 is situatated , (Note it’s Haram not Haraam) it is a “Naat” which means “Praising Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) in poetry singing” ... This was originally sung by “Sabri Brothers from Pakistan 🇵🇰 “ whose son was also a great Qawal “Late Amjad Sabri” ... you have reacted on his song “Aaj Rang Hai” already ... he was sadly mudered political This Song is total Praising of Prophet Muhammad(PBUH) and refers Madina and Makkah both cities as reference ... 💖 🇵🇰 💖

[@harithwaseem8468]

Its a modern qawwali not a natt

[@sadiadurrani9358]

👏👏👏

[@bijaykoirala4789]

React on chaap tilak by abida parveen n rahat coke studio

[@anindanath1]

love chap tilak

[@shifaijaz7652]

oh yes please

[@scaryeyesdark]

Yes yes yes

[@sahiltiwari5646]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYSno52tqct-g80

[@trollypkonlineshopping3988]

Yes sure.. Also rang by Rahat and amjad sabri

[@ConsiderThis12]

Mate, you'd get blown away if you could actually understand the actual lyrics in their respected languages. Flows beautifully. Really strikes the heart.

[@ujwalneupane1030]

Atif is a great singer.I'm listening him from my childhood 😊Lots of love from Nepal😍😍

[@criousone181]

its not a song its actually religous stanzas

[@adacousticcovers5719]

He is proud for both pakistan and india die hard fan of atif 😚😚😚😚😚😚

[@shivanshdixit16]

Pride*

[@shivanshdixit16]

He is the pride of both the nations.

[@adacousticcovers5719]

@@shivanshdixit16 ok bro thanks

[@osamaalam7685]

People who consider cow as their mata might Lynch you, be careful

[@AliAhmed-dh4pl]

Ad Acoustic Covers Nope! He’s all ours.

[@ClingToFaith1]

phenomenal singer and voice😍

[@khushbuhkhan1622]

I like your way of explaining each and every thing happening in the song, please checkout “Chaap Tilak” by Coke studio, I bet you will be blown away by the quality of vocalists...

[@sahiltiwari5646]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bYSno52tqct-g80

[@HassaanBaig]

YES! It is sung by Abida parveen and her voice sounds like she's on autotune but she's not! Its just her natural notes that she sustains so cleanly!

[@JunaidMalikPlus]

I agree Faisal! Your suggestion is the best.

[@akanshgupta88]

The older version of Chaap tilak by Nusrat fateh is more good.. believe it or not bro but that is Love.. ❤️

[@shuya1063]

You: hmm... wonder what this is? *after watching "Addicted"

[@Surgviolinist]

At 4:30 you said about the using of nasal and sinuses. in classical music here (india) we are specifically taught and given notes to practice the sound to resonate sound from body cavities (very intricate details in classical music), sound resonating from abdomen , lung everything has a different characteristics and even sinuses, but nasal quality is specifically discouraged (nasal quality came to india with mainly himesh reshamiya, he used to sing with nasal quality and became a lot famous in 2000 and therefore after that a kot of nasal quality is included in bollywood but is highly discouraged in classical). Sustaining of vocal sounds for long time is practiced a lot by trainees , its also very important as it is included from the first lesson when you are taught classical music and sometimes the teacher wont teach you the next thing till you make the correct sound of Sa (Do/C) and other notes at 440Hz for a prolonged duration which shows the control over the voice.

[@depressedcheese6579]

That was so peaceful and amazing

[@ManinderSingh316]

React to Attaullah Khan. He has one of the most distinct style of singing. One of the folk legends and has cult following among masses. At one point had record for most number of albums released

[@onixinternational8093]

Attaullah esakhelvi??

[@ManinderSingh316]

@@onixinternational8093 Yes

[@AmirHussain78692]

Yes Ataullah Khan is in the Guinness book of records with the most records released

[@tech-ticks1417]

Only this guy can react to songs from coke studio Carl sounds logical in every point he makes Good job man

[@shashwatsingh2748]

you are reacting to one of the Legendary singers of Pakistan....you can't judge him...just listen him

[@TechInfoShorts5]

Right bro ... 😍😘😘💓

[@bigman2788]

He's not even judging DUMBASSSSS

[@JainamMehta]

Exactly

[@JainamMehta]

Grammy don't deserve those musicians.

[@syedadarakhshy7408]

Exactly

[@addanger100]

Nobody won't be able to sing like atif has sung this song! Nobody can even come close to the soulful voice he has! Love from India❤

[@usmanshahid2126]

And just in case if you don’t know that nusrat part is there because this is a cultural genre called “Qawali” in the subcontinental region. Thought I might tell you just in case you got confused:)

[@cwehden]

hey yeah I thought it might be something like that, thank you!

[@usmanshahid2126]

Your welcome man keep up the good work :)

[@nuhabukha8585]

This song is a masterpiece I love Atif’s voice so much♥️ and those musicians come one specially the one playing the beautiful instrument crossing his legs he is a legend ♥️

[@techmanservices]

You HAVE to do "chaap tilak" as many others have requested. Rahat is in there whom you are familar with now

[@sungwanarzary4318]

Atif is my favourite singer since i was little. His voice is what i listen yo every morning when i wake up and it just brightens my day. He is love

[@umarc9767]

So this song is actually a parise for Prophet Muhammad P.B.U.H., the poet is actually asking for mercy and blessings. Similar as to Christians ask Jesus P.B.U.H. for help. Coke studio has captions for all its songs + behind the scene vedios. The type of music is called Qawali, Nusrat was one of the pioneers of modern Qawali. Backup singers with their claps and traditional instruments is from where you can know.

[@shehran6936]

Nusrat brought it to mainstream but there have been many qawwals who started before Nusrat, the Sabri Brothers are people who started before Nusrat.

[@everythingmaul5990]

The way christians ask to hazrat eesa as is totally different from what we ask from mohammad saw They consider him son of God nauzubillah for us both prophet Mohamamd saw and eesa a.s are messengers of Allah And Mohammad saw is most beloved prophet to Allah

[@realisrare6053]

Yup much precise explaination! Gud 1

[@shaheedkatshaza4424]

@@everythingmaul5990 still shirk either way

[@xtremeownage2]

It is not similar to Christian songs in any way. Don't undermine the beauty of Qawwalli.

[@kulsumsheikh814]

ATIF is undoubtedly the best singer ❤ Love his voice & how amazingly he sing in both Arabia & Urdu language... Hat's off man

[@bilalmalik185]

Tajdar-e-Haram: King of the Sanctuary, The Prophet Muhammad, Peace and Blessings of God be upon him.

[@wahabafridi]

Just a clarification regarding your observation that Pakistani/Indian singers generally tend to lean toward more “pharyngeal vowel” sounds; it’s actually because Urdu/Hindi as languages have different vowel sounds, including pharyngeal. It’s usually the vowel sounds in verbs that are nasal vowels. Nasal vowels on verbs for example signify plural or the Royal Pronoun equivalent of verb- or the Royal Verb if you will. That’s just one example. There are other instances of pharyngeal vowels in these languages.

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

Thank you so much !! We were waiting for this ... ♥️♥️ Much Love from USA 🇺🇸

[@ShahidhameedUSA]

😊😊

[@haula251]

Trump ko vote kiye they ka??

[@manaalfatima19]

Atif Aslam has one of the most raw and beautiful voices! Thanks for reacting to him ❤️

[@lets-learn-something]

Thank you for the song, I got the chance to hear it. I didn't know about this at first.

[@salmangamingxdeditz5210]

Bro react on " Wohi Khuda Hai" Atif Aslam Coke studio season 12 2019

[@ankitsaini2642]

Would love to see it

[@nobitanobi1178]

Thanku so much....😘😍

[@ROXIEPLAY-ML]

Atif Aslam ; My experience has taught me that training is not a compulsion. You don’t need to go from teacher to teacher to learn different music genres. Once you master your basics, you can easily pull of any song,” says Atif, He adds that he didn’t undergo formal training in music, and that’s exactly how he plans to groom the talent . But anyways, thanks for making this reactions video's on singer's you gave us some knowledge about it... we appreciate alot😉👍 And a small request too from us: you must make a Reaction video's on Arijit singh songs too😊😇

[@khanvlogs3769]

Outstanding bro 👍❤️ please react coke studio session 10 ep 1 AllahuAkbar ❤️

[@VillageTV]

GREAT SINGER

[@rahmad5764]

You're analysis of the singing was just amazingly brilliant!! Please more of this stuff! Subscribed to your awesome channel!

[@PriyanshaPunjab]

Actually this song needs no reaction. I am from india. I am a hindu. But this song gives me peace. This is not a song actually, This is magic. When Atif says, "Ham gareebo ke din bhi sanwar jaenge" I hear this whenever i am in a fix.. This gives u confidence and inner peace. 😍

[@pictureworld131]

❤

[@EasternDresses]

that's a lovely comment.

[@bangalorecitizen3569]

Sister please listen to the recitation of Quran. It'll really help. You'll thank me. Try it once.

[@babiecacorriente762]

i heared lots of indian judges criticize Atif Aslam's vocal.. however people still like his songs... and here u can see a vocal coach reaction at 9:32... we should admit this is really a good vocal..

[@anushemalik2571]

When you talked about the ‘tension’ in the song and wanting it to resolve...that’s where I knew you know your stuff even if it is not western music, first time here and your making me stay !!! 😍❤️❤️

[@fawazathar1276]

sammi meri waar by umair jaswal and quratulain baloch please. You are going to love it

[@laiba5312]

Yes please. He is called the best vocalist in subcontinent.

[@123nadeemuu]

Yes please

[@thesheepinwolfsclothing6235]

Beautiful piece. Ty for sharing! And to think he was going to be a cricket player for Pakistan originally!!!

[@klubnitsa1209]

No.1 Pop singer of Pakistan Atif Aslam👍👍

[@9shazad]

Mudassar Shareef atm best singer in Asia

[@pakiboyhadrou]

pop and rock

[@Madrandom-t5f]

You makeme understand why i like what i like. Love your explanations.

[@talhasohail242]

Tajdar E Haram Means The King Of Makkah

[@babarkhalid2791]

King of holy sanctuary is more appropriate translation, the one ur referring to is also correct in context but as a translator I would say that phrase is more precise compared to other contexts besides the song, so certainly a professional did his job really well translating this song...

[@islamifinanceurdu1435]

Not literally,

[@pariwarthanpatel2103]

He is the best of our generation...He is worshipped not only in Pakistan or India but all over Asia. love u Atif....

[@sshakababy]

Just to clarify, he's not really worshipped... just admired and loved. I mean we have atif aslam fan clubs but no temples or shrines dedicated to him 😂

[@atifhussainmalik9123]

Oh thanku😀😀❤️😉

[@1920F]

@@sshakababy you think they have shrines and temples dedicated to arjit singh in India? No,by worship in this case he means that Atif is very loved,that was a pathetic attempt and this is coming from a fellow pakistani.

[@sshakababy]

@@1920F where did Arijit singh come in? What are you talking about mate? Who said they have shrines or temples dedicated to Arijit singh?? 🤔🤔🤔. I don't know how much you know about me but I'm not your fellow Pakistani.

[@1920F]

@@sshakababy where did shrines and temples come from? I think the person who commented that is smart enough to know that we "literally" don't worship him,that is used as a form of expression to describe something you really admire.Both sides know there are no temples and shrines dedicated to singers,that comment shows that you're trying to imply something else which can be considered rude and disrespectful for another religion not ours,coming from a pakistani.

[@musawernawaz9291]

Very pleased to listen ur reaction on coke studios and knowledge about Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Indo-Pak Music. Love the way u explain things much learning stuff along with reaction

[@SquashFiend]

I have heard Atif Aslam sing this live; all 15 glorious minutes of it. Just magical, his voice is, unbelievably divine and really takes you to the divine.

[@jackiejake23]

It was nice watching this video, would love to see you react on more of the coke studio’s tracks. Also, one thing you said about nasalised vowels, well I wouldn’t say it’s not true, it’s obviously there. But, it’s not a preference rather a requirement. Because there are some alphabets in Urdu language which are pronounced that way, it cannot come from mouth. The sound comes like a honk, like you said. So, it’s actually the way it is. I hope I am clear lol.

[@humajahangir1755]

Carl john your research, your observation and your analysis are mind boggling as western listening to eastern music, you definitely a quality vocal coach and do not ponder upon music just for sake of saying but do actually read it from every angle. I am impressed with your input and output.

[@fatimarizvi4713]

Love From Pakistan 🇵🇰 #loveatif😍

[@UnapologeticIslam]

More more more more more more Atif Aslam.... You haven’t even scratched the surface of his talent and quality... His voice is soooo powerful!

[@nazs.7303]

TAJDAR: crown wearer; HARAM: sacred sanctuary; e: Persian preposition OF, expressing a belonging. So the "Prince of the Sacred Sanctuary", referring to the Prophet of Islam, upon him be peace.

[@mrskullgaming1507]

Thanks❤️

[@franklinymail]

you got a new fan Carl! Love your knowledge of music. This is called true REACTION VIDEO. I was fed up of watching reactions by people who know nothing about music and they become the judge in their little videos but you nail it to the wall!

[@NitinKumar]

I am india trust me Pakistani singer are the best indian singer were used be good but now presently we have shity singer only badshah honeysingh annu malik with sjiry music edited voice..... Some of singer are good Shreya sonu nigam and many more but singer and songs quality of Bollywood is going down down and down ....even i stopped watching Bollywood movies and songs either english punjabi or coke studio or nusrat fateh ali khan ..... Bollywood is dead for me xD

[@muhammadasadshafiq194]

5,6 years ago Bollywood was producing brilliant songs but now they have lost the soul of music.

[@muhammadasadshafiq194]

Tumhi ho was my all time favourite.

[@samtaylor7279]

What about Arjeet Singh. He has a nice voice.

[@Raghav-ww1bt]

Bollywood songs r diverse don't split some random shit if u know nothing.

[@mubashirharal9789]

Bro ap Ik dafa Punjabi song suno Gulrez anmol Ammy ty Amrinder dy

[@abrishkhadija]

Like your reactions. Singer Atif Aslam is famous in both India and Pak... ❤️❤️

[@tushar8998]

Hi Carl, Very well spotted. Atif’s biggest inspiration was Jeff Buckley.

[@BlackProductionFilms]

and Jeff Buckley's biggest inspiration was Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan

[@flavorauthority]

One of my favourite songs ever by Atif Aslam. This song can never get old. Thank you for considering this song! Lots of love from Pakistan.

[@ZeeshanAliUOG]

Pakistani singers is best. I love Pakistani singers💚🇵🇰💚🇵🇰

[@NitinKumar]

Agreed

[@iamaadeez8562]

Oh my God What a singer Won my heart 💓💓💓💓

[@diveawayyy]

As an Indian I love this naat ,Lovely soothi ng

[@JaveriaSarib]

Heart touching style he has.... I love tajdar e Haram.....

[@tusharbehera8956]

Bro I Know a lot but seriously he isn't any rookie singer man,he is like the best one out there

[@542pixie1]

Atif sang this so beautifully, every pakistani radio channel played it in the month of Ramadan , it still makes me cry so beautiful:’)

[@KhanBaba-zw3kq]

John: I need a glass of wine after this🤣🤣🤣🤣 I don’t drink wine but gonna have a cup of tea and listen again ❤️4m🇵🇰

[@shahnaaznaby]

I feel so happy that you’ve paid such respect to this piece ❤️❤️❤️ It’s one of my family’s favourites and has spiritual meaning to us. It’s rare to find someone who appreciates something that’s different to what they may be used to. Loved your video so much, thank you!

[@DivaAsh]

Atif is amazing 😍😍

[@AyeshaKhan-of4pn]

Great song and great singer!!!! Thanks for commenting on him. Atif rocks!!!

[@ashaypallav4158]

You should do Aadat by atif aslam

[@sumasu4496]

Great song choice and love that you've activated the subtitles therefore you're really appreciating the message and tone of the sounds. Keep them coming!

[@ummyaymannaseem6008]

Its all about our prophet Muhammad SAW 😍😍❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@taslimahmaudarbocus498]

He is the one of the best original and natural voice using in bollywood songs