Vocal Coach Reaction - Rahat Fateh Ali Khan & Momina Mustehsan 'Afreen Afreen'

Skype Lessons: www.carljohnfranz.com / [e-mail]
Becoming a Natural Singer channel: / @becominganaturalsinger
Carl John Franz channel: / @carljohnfranzmusic
'Becoming a Natural Singer' eBook links:
Amazon USA: amzn.to/2Gvqnvt
Amazon UK: amzn.to/2TU2BMA
Amazon India: amzn.to/2Xfkw2D
Amazon Japan: amzn.to/2NijFcO
Amazon Australia: amzn.to/2NfQQO2
Amazon Italy: amzn.to/2V7qAIv
Amazon Germany: amzn.to/2GUeqyT
Amazon France: amzn.to/2V7O9Rm
Website: www.carljohnfranz.com
** All Amazon sites sell my book just search 'becoming a natural singer' **
Buy, Download or Stream 'Go Viral or Go Home'
KZbin: bit.ly/3eNeKOj
Spotify: spoti.fi/2KszXPG
Apple: apple.co/350TArD
Amazon: amzn.to/2VWfiJ4
Google: bit.ly/3bBtg9Q
Bandcamp: bit.ly/2KrS74a
Website: www.carljohnfranz.com
Donations: bit.ly/2NcAF3Y
Patreon: bit.ly/2GOdyMg
Twitter: / carljohnfranz
Instragram: / becominganaturalsinger / carljohnfranz

[@cwehden]

Sorry I didn't realise these were Pakistani singers xx

[@kamillashah7684]

Great content 😊 plz do react to Quratulain Baloch 's voice. We have been listening to these songs but we knew nothing about what they are doing with vocal cords, laryngeal muscles etc, its like am in a science class 😂.

[@gauravbagga3430]

Music lovers don't really care, I reckon.

[@sadiarahman6008]

It doesn't matter his sing in Bollywood movies more than his own country his you can call him Indian singer he sing more in Indian song also his more famous in India than Pakistan all Pakistani singer is singing in Bollywood they are more famous in India

[@mdsiam4447]

React more of coke studio "season- 10"

[@utkarsh196]

Doesnt matter.. It's subcontinent same culture same language... Just hate for each other makes us different

[@TheInforefresh]

Pakistan has some of the world's finest artists. And the music that comes out of the country is absolutely outstanding. Lots of love and respect from India. :)

[@watcher1133]

❤

[@ashishthakur6666]

Bro you have no idea that you are judging a legend

[@demad777]

same here bro!!!

[@laishramtombisana2162]

It is called reacting. ...no judging.

[@udreacts24]

True

[@watcher1133]

@@laishramtombisana2162 he is judging not reacting.

[@DavidSawang]

And everything he has to say is positive. That’s because a legend proved that he is a legend, and even a person who knows little about Pakistan can acknowledge how amazing Ustaad Rahat Fateh Ali Khan is! Take it as a positive!

[@mitalisharma5305]

I am an Indian.. But believe me Pakistanis are the finest artists in the world ! You just saw 2 of them and there are still many. Peace💖

[@hemalbhatt4055]

Let me correct you. Pakistanis are not " The Finest Artist ", but they are actually " one of the finest artists ", singing songs based on Hindustani classical, semi classical and Indian folk songs. By the way this song was written by javed aktar Saab.

[@blackfedora5278]

Love You, you guyz are the one!✌🏼Peace

[@blackfedora5278]

hemal bhatt Nope most of singers follow nusrat...their genre is qawwali,and classical is not creation of india,it was mixed by two countries which are separate now...! But we can say sa re ga ma pa da nisa can be their creation...

[@hemalbhatt4055]

@@blackfedora5278 I am sending you one link about origins of quawaali. Please go through it. en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qawwali

[@sameerpatel3476]

Hmm they are really good in making bomb.

[@fitnesswithvaishali297]

He is ustad Rahat Fateh Ali Khan .....Ustad means 'Master'..... No one can match him....let's better not judge him..... He is Pakistani singer but equally loved and respected in India as well..... It was an honor for the lady to share stage with him...

[@abyslayer]

Seriously? No one can match him? What about Nusrat Saab?

[@atharvashende6490]

Yeah princess

[@losewool]

This comment made my day♥️

[@tariquediamonddiamondtariq9922]

abyslayer yes bro😎

[@drakoontag]

Here is what I am gonna say to the word Ustad, Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan was THE USTAD! Rahat could never match him. Don't get me wrong, I love Rahat singing but it's just not the same!

[@alishanmao]

Correction Dude. Those are Pakistani Singers. and 2nd, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan comes from a family of top notch professional legendary singers. you can't find a flaw in his singing :) unless if you are his teacher LOL

[@priyarana3242]

Hihihi true... He is legendary.... Love from India

[@azam1967]

I think his teacher was late Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan from Pakistan, who also performed with Peter Gabriël and Michael Brook. Top of the top artists.

[@imty8774]

The only singer that's flawless imo is NFAK.

[@vickyboy786]

@cheesayn Something is burning i guess..............

[@vishakhduttsingh1752]

Jism jese ajanta kii murat koi .... 😁 ajanta and allora is in pakistan ???? Well pakistan dont have its own culture ....

[@amirkhan-fp7qc]

this girl was the national crush of Pakistan at that time.

[@usamaakhter6153]

Amir bhai dil ke bat keh di chas kra diti

[@trinathparida7054]

wrong.international crush bro

[@manishmanbert8592]

Not just pakistan. India too.

[@zararobert4851]

still is for me

[@DJD1001]

@@trinathparida7054 Are u insane?

[@ElMagnifico0709]

It's not scatting what he did towards the end. It's extensive improvisation of Rāga(a mood based pre arrangement of a mode). A technique unique to Indian classical singing. Scatting, by definition, has jibberish/non sensical words. He was uttering the literal note while vocalizing it skillfully.

[@muhammadabubakarsaddique3216]

its a Pakistani song.

[@leojr.knight2187]

@@muhammadabubakarsaddique3216 we know that But thanks for informing...

[@leojr.knight2187]

@@muhammadabubakarsaddique3216 and Indian classical songs also goes like this... If you know it too... Nothing special that you have to point it is Pakistani song

[@rohan123456ful]

You can call that shredding in vocals like guitarists shred on guitar

[@muhtadaali8847]

You stupid it is still indian art. Pak was india 70 years ago​@@muhammadabubakarsaddique3216

[@bardock2525]

the sad part is that the best thing about "afreen afreen" is its lyrics.. beautifully written!! but anyone who doesnt know the language will miss out on it..

[@cwehden]

I need subs on, sorry!

[@bletwort2920]

Carl John Franz Subs won't do any good in fact subs will kill the song. The words are the life of this song if you translate it there's no meaning left. It's better if you just enjoy the music or learn the language if you want to understand it.

[@bardock2525]

Pack Man I agree.. When I said lyrics are the heart I did not mean that subs will help you out.. Sorry.. :D a lot gets lost in translation.. Most of all the exact wordings used which rhyme and alliterate and many times same words used which have different meanings in different context which all will get lost in translation..

[@QureshiBazil]

Very well said.

[@Msm1234msm]

.

[@thepervysageofmountmyoboku9093]

Hi Carl, brace yourself for 'they are pakistanis, not Indians' comments lol. Classical music tradition is same in both countries, people and culture do not change by drawing lines between countries.

[@sheikhsaklain15]

Well said.

[@harrynom7269]

and it is derived from Indian classical music

[@Drjaydeepsinh]

I am here for such comments only lol

[@rahulsps2009qwerty]

Well put.

[@user-oq2rk7ep8f]

I'd just like to draw attention to an interesting line in the song: "husn jaise ajanta ki Murat koi" Ajanta is in India. But a Pakistani song still praises it. It's nice.

[@debajyotisg]

Divided by hate, United by his music. Wish the two nations could peacefully co-exist!

[@mjron1269]

Well said bro..from pak

[@philipjoel1800]

Agreed

[@BilluAwann]

Most people in comments are criticizing you for judging a “legend” I can understand their emotions and also the fact you know music and you are probably doing this for living . So do what you do best man don’t pay attention to comment section. Although to certain extend they are right , what they are trying to say is this man is a proper legend of indian/Pakistani classic music culture. He comes from one of the biggest musical family in Pakistan and he is a proper master . His uncle was untouchable Nusrat Fateh Ali khan. RIP

[@nirajtanti8618]

The scale run in the end is eastern solfage. Do (Sa), Re (Re, its the same in pronunciation) Mi (Ga) Fa (Ma) So (Paa) La (Dha) Ti (Ni) Do (Sa, octave) i. e. Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Dha Ni Sa unlike in weatern music where singers don't sing out or vocal the solfages of the scale. In eastern basically Indian & Pakistan songs are written on specific raagas (scales, there is neumerous scales pertaining to mood, time of the day and even seasons (am not sure which raaga (scale) this song is based on) This specific piece of music is arranged by Pakistani musicians, the singers are Pakistani. However, having said that we Indians and Pakistaniz had one music before Independence i. e. in Greater India, before Bangladesh & Pakistan branched out, we had the same music. And we as Indians neesds to give credit to the arranger of this piece and the singers for presenting the song in such a beautiful way. Yes the song is penned by an Indian Lyricist, Javed Akhtar but there is no harm in giving the credit where it belongs and I believe this spreads love and respect and not hatred. And I also believe if the lyrics mentions of same place, the music needs not belong to that place itself. I can write a music about Eifel Tower on eastern scale, that doesn't make the song to belong to the place I mention in the song. Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan his uncle was loved in India Rahat Fateh Ali Khan (Nephew of Nusrat) is also loved in India. Lets love each other guys, there's no harm in giving the credit. It indeed is an awesome piece

[@iTalha]

Niraj Tanti love you bro ;D

[@cwehden]

thanks for info :)

[@solitechgamingreviews6401]

Bro are you mad are what...he is not indian. He is a Pakistani...You are a liar for sure...😂

[@RifayetUday]

Nice Says. Always dreaming of reunite GREAT INDIA.... MOTHER INDIA like she was before Partition of Bengal (1905) and Partition of Great India (1947) ! ♥ ♥ ♥ Love from Dhaka, Today's Bangladesh.

[@enricasasma]

Is not skat

[@romitpatel8262]

His uncle, nusrat fateh ali khan is one of the biggest legends in the music world, please check him out, song name "akheenya udeek diya" It will be 1994 bermingham, where ul find young Rahat fateh ali khan performing with his larger then life uncle and father

[@satishkumar-fd5jm]

rahat is nothing when compared to nusrat sahab.

[@SAMEOLDSTORY100]

satish kumar been saying this for years, people are so blinded by Rahat that they have forgotten how mesmerising Nusrat Sahab was. All Rahat do is take his songs and remake them into songs that I personally don’t enjoy, although when Atif Aslam sometimes adds some of Nusrat Sahab’s verse in his originals I kinda like it.

[@manmeetmalhar1021]

Nusrat fateh ali khaan saab cant be judged 😇

[@romitpatel8262]

@@manmeetmalhar1021 Who is this even judging him in the first place?

[@brianhylkema13]

Nusrat and Eddie Vedder have some extraordinary songs together.

[@user-oq3gm4uq7k]

i loved how indians are praising & defending pakistani singers. thank u guys, I've so many Indian fellows & friend in my university & thank God we are living peacefully 😊

[@erindsouza94]

The squeeze that you were referring to is intentional I guess , it's called harkat in classical music , it literally translates to naughtiness but it could be interpreted as character or charisma

[@Masterdoctorgenius14]

She is shit at singing.

[@AasimSoomro]

Harkat could also be translated as restlessness.

[@dr.amitrevandkar644]

@@Masterdoctorgenius14 Totally agree with that. if you listen just to the audio of this video, you immediately realise that she has ruined the whole thing... couldn't listen to it more than 3 times due to her flat rendition. Pathetic.

[@satyamdey4527]

Harkat nahi tha bhai. Harkat Ustad Rahat kar rahe hai. Ladki utna accha nahi gaati.

[@Iam-a-live]

@@AasimSoomro or waves

[@salonirai5413]

Do you know you are judging a LEGEND!!!!!

[@firstnamelastname061]

saloni rai Do you know he's not judging anything? It's called reaction. I mean it says right there in the title. How stupid can one be? Great job making a fool out outta yourself.

[@gorillajits]

Do you know the difference between reacting and judging ? Guess u need a dictionary.

[@uf1902]

@@firstnamelastname061 You're the one that looks like a fool. This video could easily be described as 'judging' since he critically analyses the singing. But that is not why you look like a fool. It's because you called someone commenting on a KZbin video stupid and foolish.

[@uf1902]

@@gorillajits 'You', not 'u', guess you need a dictionary.

[@kabirkhan7446]

tell him that he is your elton john🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@user-ih3tf5su3w]

Dude you literally make me laugh when commenting on Rahat Ali Khan notes. You have no idea what he is capable of....

[@sds187]

@@sunilmenaria8090 🤣

[@madhavgupta7399]

Bhai usko nahi pata ki vo legend ke song per reaction de rahe hai

[@asishrai1690]

Ohh u mean to say... This guy should watch video with mouth shut? Since he is vocal coach he will commend . Even in football the player plays better than coach but still the coach judges right ?

[@stormysamreen7062]

7:48 RFAK: "Husne jaanan ki tareef mumkin nahin" Carl: "Yeah, lovely"

[@AV0O0]

Bhaiii 😂😂😂😂😂😂👍

[@yoyoho1611]

Everytime he gave his remarks on Rahat Fateh Ali Khan I was like really dude ? 😂😂

[@urviyogi7578]

Actually he was not able to understand a thing what's going on ...all confused .... Mai toh bs end Ka reaction dekhne Ka wait kr Rai thi 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣 bichara galat video choose kr liya

[@yoyoho1611]

@@urviyogi7578 right 😂

[@ayeshathefairy8333]

chalo hud toh maza kare isse toh yeh bhi samajh nahi yeh lyrics kitni lajawab hai

[@shaheryaar]

@@urviyogi7578 When ustad Rahat was singing. Most of the times he said "So aggressive" and i was like dude? really? Do you have any idea what Ustad just did?

[@Iam-a-live]

@@shaheryaar if you arent in the field dont talk shit. He is interpretating it through his own style.

[@Glamwithjia]

Proud of Pakistan 🇵🇰 Rahat Fateh Ali Khan

[@Jewel193]

Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan is the Ustad of Qawali.

[@NehaThakur-uu2yn]

The fun fact is that Indian music industry is incomplete without the artist like them (RAHAT FATEH ALI KHAN, ATIF ASLAM AND MANY MORE) They are integral part of us Despite of having loads of tensions b/w our countries we still use to like to be part of each other.... Listen to his song sajda from MY NAME IS KHAN you will love it, great respect 😊 that is how we two countries are still connected to each other 🤗

[@NehaThakur-uu2yn]

@Viki M this is my personal based opinion i wanted to share it and i have freedom to do that If you have found any problem regarding this then sincerely ignore the comment and move ahead Stay healthy and have a good day 😊

[@himalayangypsy4472]

Umm we can manage without Atif,so many talented singers in India, just watch a random talent hunt show, Rahat is a different deal though.

[@NehaThakur-uu2yn]

@@himalayangypsy4472 yeah that's true but atif have got some kind of uniqueness in his voice he sounds different but who cares when you have loads of talented singers present in this world 🗺 Love music 🎶 like whoever and whatever sings main thing is it should toch the heart ♥ and that's all 😉

[@NehaThakur-uu2yn]

@Viki M seriously then i apologise to you if you have felt disturbed and you are not being direct but being rude i dont want to go anywhere i always wish everyone like that only you are not special Amd again sincerely i am really sorry if it does hurt you..... I just don't want to hurt anyone how do you know where i am coming from stop being judgemental 😐

[@pramedhindra5560]

if you think atif aslam is a good singer then i have nothing more to say

[@DS-of6ui]

Being an Indian myself I definetly dont mind you calling Rahat an Indian....even though he is a gem of Pakistan our neighbours. He has done a lot of work in India and equally loved in both countires and his uncle Ustad Nusrath Fateh Ali Khan was a legend in his own rights and Rahat is equally good if not better........never seen him ever go a note flat.... For me personally Rahat from Pakistan and Sonu Nigam from India are one the best these both countries have produced in the last 20 yrs

[@mjron1269]

👍

[@mjron1269]

sonu ? never..

[@nari8043]

The reason she looks "very pleased to be singing with him" is because he's a master! A legend to say the least! She's honoured to even be in his presence!

[@SAMEOLDSTORY100]

Take anything from pakistani coke studio, I don’t know how they do it but the whole premises is magic land.

[@tinadevi5817]

farozna rehman excluding koko Korina😂😂

[@aiineek2210]

Except season 11 😂

[@Sadidesifamily]

But not the latest season...dear lord

[@saadiahtariq920]

@@Sadidesifamily just add shikwa/jawab e shikwa , malang and aatish from current season , exclude everything else

[@yahyaarshadraeesani9116]

@@tinadevi5817 lol🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@NeerajSingh-lc7cu]

They both are Pakistani but the condition is true for both country

[@fakeffgamer4218]

@Viki M achi awaz the ke but on technical details very low profile both

[@Rida_sha.h]

No its not....

[@Azx12345]

I m Indian still this coke studio is my fav❤️

[@razz-2977]

@@Azx12345 same..😊

[@gamingsingh4004]

He said indian.. so stfu..bhai if something good apni horahi hai tou tujay kyaa problem hai.. Pakistan dont share good stuff with us anyway..

[@Cleansingmeditation]

Hi there from India. Well these are Pakistani singers or we can say legends and I’m happy to see such talent in our neighbour country.

[@nishith.r]

This just popped up on my recommendation and Could not be more happy. I'm Indian but let me say this, Pakistan has so many great artists and we are blessed from their talent. Rahat fate Ali Khan is a legend.

[@ns6043]

People are fighting like these are Pakistanis not Indians..... ....Yes they are Pakistanis and we indians have no right to claim these talented singers to be ours and also we dont claim them to be Indian but as they have worked for so long in Bollywood industry now they are a part and accepted as a part of Bollywood family........Also dont forget the fact that India and Pakistan were one big country before the partition of India Pakistan in August 14-15 1947......So all the taste in music and singing styles are all same.......Thats why this guy thought they are Indians..........Yes they are Pakistani's and i dont claim them to be indian...but i like them as singers .......

[@cwehden]

yeah my bad sorry :)

[@bhushanramdham]

@@cwehden No need to say sorry man. We are brother countries. We are same. Same music culture. We are just separated.

[@arshsingh07]

U have earned my respect

[@saadshahjahani4532]

Well said man well said.

[@natashakhan1022]

good comment

[@haidernaeem1931]

carl if you actually wanna experience aggression, real aggression, react to Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan.

[@arminius6506]

NFAK is beyond his understanding (cultural differences) but he should listen Rahet performance at Nobel peace prize ceremony

[@raghavnegi6932]

Ustaad.

[@adityabhattacharya4044]

If you want to experience speed then listen to INDIAN OCEAN TANDANU you wont be disappointed

[@nomanmridha3545]

Sukhwinder Singh is as well.😀

[@mrmalkootlp6858]

@@arminius6506 cultural difference doesn't matter when it comes to nfak you should know that

[@KabirSarkar143]

The way he speaks his name sounds like "Red-Hot-Fatty-Ali-Khan"

[@Private.R]

Okay, I know I should respect him, but still it made me laugh. idk why, may be am a bad human 😅.

[@The99Akshay99]

😂

[@Zayn-op3pe]

SHUT UP !!!!

[@ninthnirvana5682]

Lol.. so rude me🤣🤣😷😷😷

[@aniketp.8596]

IKRRRR and he didnt mean it so it's all good. But it did sound like it . 😆😆

[@sajidkhanmahmood]

The reason the girl singer is pleased is because she never thought she would be in the presence of such a legend never mind sing with him.

[@asamvav]

Finally a proper classical singer singing a semiclassical piece. So you get some idea of what Hindustani Classical Music is about. The end portion is not scatting, it's solfege. We call it Sargam Taan. He could go even twice or thrice that speed easily or exactly the opposite, that is extremely slow. The most interesting thing is that never through the Taan portion, he deviated once from the base raag which is Raageshree here. Check out the scale in KZbin. You will understand what I mean. Even the mixed frequencies which are basis of a swara(erroronously translated as notes) is maintained through out. We would die to bring out that GA-MA coalition in the end. Thanks for the reaction. Hoping to see more classical or fusion reactions.

[@theindiansmurf7829]

He understood nothing hence he never reacted to your comment !!

[@rohan64bit]

Neither did u xD

[@AMAL648]

Well, you need to watch a kacheri of South Indian classical music or carnatic music... The sargam that u call in Hindustani music is called krithi which is more often used in carnatic music, rather than Hindustani music. Hindustani music consists only off mukhada and antara. But carnatic music consists of pallavi, anupallavi, charanam and some more subdivisions. Carnatic music is little bit harder than Hindustani music. The Kacheri of carnatic music lasts for almost 2-2.5 hours. While in hindustani music, it only lasts for 1hour. I'm not trying to say that carnatic music is better than hindustani music or any sort of competition thing. Both of these styles are precious and both belong to India. I'm just stating the facts. That's it.........

[@cwehden]

thanks for the details, I'm a novice about all this stuff so this information is helpful thankyou!

[@asamvav]

@@AMAL648 indeed it is true that the Carnatic Classical Music is just as complex and lofty as Hindustani Classical Music. However, it is incorrect to assume that only Sthai and Antara are two parts that are available in the composition. In fact the older the composition the more standard 4parts system will be seen, i.e. Sthai, Antara, Abhog and Sanchari. In Carnatic system on the other hand there is Dhruva, Pallavi, Anupallavi, 3-4 or more Charanam. (Mind you I am mainly talking about Krithis, in varnam etc it will be much different) This structure is reminiscent of older Dhrupad tradition in Hindustani which has similar structure not only in Dhrupad but also in Dhamar pieces. Essentially both musical systems follow the same basic principles. However over time a lot of variations of Gamakas were lost in the northern system. This I personally believe is due to incursion of Persian music which is more melody driven. This lead to extinction of many ragas in the northern system that are still quite popular in the southern system. As far as Sargam taans go it is also available in Kalpanaswaram, Raagam Thanam Pallavi pieces. I am personally fond of all Indian classical music systems. And it is futile to fight over which system is superior. They both are amazing and very different. A mixture of techniques especially in the deshi ragas will be seen in the Kalinga and Marathi classical music which are musically somewhere in between. I am personally a student of Banaras gharana of Hindustani Classical Music. And I adore any form of classical music Indian or otherwise. Thank you for your well thought response.

[@justarandomperson9940]

Breathless by Shankar Mahadevan please please please

[@ayushchauhan8188]

Yes

[@AsitKumarGupta]

Here is the link to Live Performance of the same song kzbin.info/www/bejne/gKbMq2apgseKgck

[@mrudhulamohank328]

Why do you need him to assess great indan singers?..... Is it a subconcious thrive of our indian mind to get approval of a westerner.

[@nsd1690]

Yes current

[@skkhumukcham9848]

Yeahhhh

[@arslanimdad7768]

I hope you will react to his Nobel peace Prize performance.

[@cwehden]

Ooo sounds good

[@arslanimdad7768]

If you go looking for the truth, get the whole thing. It’s like a good fuck. Half is worse than none at all. Love you bro 😉

[@vinayc2378]

@Mansoor Shameel ❤️

[@HamzaBunny]

Western audience can't tell the difference between Indian and a Pakistani by looking at their appearance. So basically we're one just different nations.

[@aniketp.8596]

WDYM ? they arnt really different . Idk how can u tell the difference by looking at their appearances .. there r a LOT of muslims in india too .

[@qamarjavedbajwalumber1324]

@@aniketp.8596 onlynwe can identify each other hahah🤣🤣🤣

[@Samurai-463]

@@qamarjavedbajwalumber1324 for real 😂

[@qamarjavedbajwalumber1324]

@@Samurai-463 yes dude 🤣🤣🤣

[@userunknown3210]

Veronika Zimmermann ok no hate

[@hoobastankrulez]

In case you didn't know, he was improvising on the scale at the end there. Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Da Ni Sa corresponds to Do Re Me Fa So La Ti Do. So he lyricsed all the notes that he sang, a common way to adlib in music from India.

[@prashantsonone1279]

You are awesome yrr❤

[@angohar]

Just a tip for the next time you watch a Pakistan Coke Studio video (which you should totally do!!!!!) turn on the English subtitles! I’m originally Pakistani but lived in Canada forever so my language skills aren’t the best and it’s super helpful in understanding what they say! Makes the song even more beautiful! GREAT VIDEO BUD

[@textillion]

lol, pakistani..

[@abdulhadi8ballpool]

Can you speak urdu or punjabi?? Bcz i am from Pakistan

[@AnupamBarmanForever]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aXLJeZ5pbahlf8k

[@angohar]

@@abdulhadi8ballpool yeah I mean I can speak and understand everything comfortably but its not at a level that I can comprehend all the lyrics in the song, especially since they tend to incorporate languages other than Urdu too and I only speak Urdu so yeah :)

[@angohar]

​@@textillion whatever

[@4matic252]

agree with all the comments. you "can not judge a """legend""". he is like music and rhythem itself. love from indiA

[@rishabhsharma6084]

everyone is praising Rahat sir, but I'm Loving that girl❤️😍 the peace in her voice

[@aaaaankush]

Pakistani Coke studio always rocks.... Rahat sahab always full of energy.

[@anshdeo]

That last part he did is called Sargam and taan, in this case only Sargam, sargam is mostly singing different combinations of the notes in a raag. He was singing different combinations of notes of whichever raag the song is in.. Better way to explain is: I'll take an Simple raag, Bhopali, Bhopali has 5 notes (out of total 7) Sa Re Ga Pa Dha and ending with Sa an octave higher (it's like do re Mi fa so la ti do, and removing fa and ti) Now we make different combinations of the same 5 notes (mostly in respect to the song) An example of a Sargam in Bhopali is: Sa Ga Re Ga - Ga Sa Re Sa Dha - Dha Ga Re Ga ( - is like an extension of the previous note for another count) Now there's a lot lot lot more to all this and I'm lazy, hope you read and understand

[@twonarrators7267]

Dude you are like an Aunt in front of him his family and I mean while Family has dedicated themself to music For generations. The Family is called Patyala Gharana and in music for centuries

[@badisgood3234]

No doubt that you are a true vocal coach you did't even know the language but i do and i see that you judge very well👏

[@vivicktaj5812]

Okay. The host has apologized for him mistaking the singers as Indian. Now I saw a comment stating that it's okay to call them Indian since they sing more in India then pakistan. I saw another comment stating that they are singing Indian classical music or same with that. Point 1. No its not okay to call another nationality some one else. Fateh Ali khans are one of the singers we are proud of as Pakistanis we want then to be known by other country on the name of pakistan. Any Indian will also do the same if someone calls arijit Pakistani. And Indian classical music. dear music has no language no culture no boundaries. And singing more in india you're in India listening to Indian music sang by Pakistani singer thinking they sing more in India that's you're perspective. But u don't listen to Pakistani songs try listening and then comment and our singers come in India and sing because they are invited we don't seek or request from India. We get offers same as other maybe because Indian music directors see potential in some Pakistani singers. I am not patriotic I am just clearing some mind thought. Take it or leave it .

[@vivicktaj5812]

you just made it patriotism. if so called talented are in india .why in every new movie there is a song of atif aslam not arijit singh .we both should must admit that they both use auto tuner for their voices and and we both can agree on that there are much more talented singer then them in the industry . but why atif is again in the limelight ?

[@niimace]

Whether he is Pakistani or Indian doesn't matter he is just an amazing singer I know... God bless him and his voice 💓💓

[@alveenamumtaz8905]

it matters bro.....in case of pak nd india it really matters 👀

[@Rohit-gw9tq]

U judged a singer who's an ustad! Ustad means master! So the male singer is called ustad rahat fateh ali khan! He's a master!❤️

[@jayanthkumar7964]

You have a brilliant ear and mind for singing, Carl. I'm sure you're a fantastic singing coach!

[@cwehden]

😅👍🏻

[@BhupendraSingh-gd6mw]

React to Atif Aslam Taj Der e haram

[@drsyedahajer868]

Yes,

[@umernazir9271]

You've been reacting to the finest singers ever produced ,, I've seen your reactions to Sonu Nigam as well ,, one thing that I wanted to say is that the real range is ,, how much high you can you sing within the chest register without going into the head register or the head voice, that comes with a lot of practice and it demands some real patience ,, these singers they are living legends , Rahat fateh ali khan has the title of Ustad for his achievements , he is from one of the elite musical families in the Subcontinent , he is a student and the nephew of the greatest qawalli singer ever Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan,, and then Sonu Nigam , he's also been singing for almost three decades in Bollywood movies ,, he is the follower of arguably the greatest singer ever produced by the subcontinent ,, M Rafi

[@tamanna4697]

I'm an Indian but I love this Pakistani Love from India ❤️❤️

[@KhuramShahzad-mt5ec]

There is a reason why he is called Ustadh... That means Teacher. He's taught by a guy who was taught day and night Ustadh Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. Amazing voices.

[@khushbuhkhan1622]

Please do also react on Coke studio song “Chaap Tilak” by Rahat Fateh Ali Khan and Abida Parveen, you will be blown away by the vocals capabilities of them in this song

[@l0verdoseee]

yes please!!

[@abheeksinha3799]

ABSOLUTELY. Afreen isnt a song you wanna react to. Chap tilak explores vocal range better.

[@emusman5225]

Exactly. I want him to listen to "Rung" by Amjad Sabri and RFAK. Thats a proper qawwali by a proper qawwal. Lets see what he has to say about that part.

[@AbbasAley]

Yesss!!

[@aiineek2210]

Omg YESSSS!

[@charmoss_q8701]

Towards the end of the songs is eargasm,,,I felt I'm in different dimension,, chanting beautifully

[@vishushams]

He can only reach your ears Carl. To us from sub continent, he goes directly in our souls. Specially the last part, you will never understand the power of that part. Peace !!

[@drakedrones]

Talent transcends all barriers! Appreciate the beauty of human talent! I love beautiful singers....thank you world for all the great singers I am fortunate to enjoy!

[@aakash26159]

Please react to Paar Channa de from coke studio. You will be amazed

[@surtaalrecords4659]

Love and respect to all singing style this is why we call Music has no language, Music has no religion, Music has no boundaries, Music is just love and Respect.

[@sana_IITD]

You can't even imagine how even more beautiful the lyrics are. Its absolutely from heaven

[@know-less]

He is a living legend. His voice doesn't need any judgement. Master Nusrat Fateh Ali was his coach and Uncle too.

[@712forfirefox8]

if you want to see real magic of subcontinent singing listen 'Rang, Rahat Fateh Ali Khan & Amjad Sabri, Season Finale, Coke Studio Season 9 ', ...this song can take you to another galaxy ...

[@emusman5225]

Oye hoye hoye hoye... uffff can't get that qawwali out of my system. Amjad Sabri was at his absolute best at that time. Its so sad that we lost him so early. Even in the morning of the day he was murdered, he recited a beautiful "Na'at" in a TV show and everybody in the studio was stunned.

[@suvomua]

Its a good one If you wana here real RAHAT. LISTN TO “CHAAP TILAK” by rahat and abida parven. From coke studio season7 epi 6 Thts a master piece

[@yasmeenlistserve6774]

He has been trained by his world renowned musician and classic singer ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan since he was just a baby...

[@vroonvrooon]

When you judge a song you don't understand the language of or who the singer is, it takes guts. Anything can go wrong and cause an outrage. Yet you judge it so honestly! Much love to you, man..

[@hindifan861]

Please react to Ali Zafar singing 'Rockstar' ans 'Julie'. Hes an amazing Pakistani singer. Please put captions on

[@SparrowKhan]

You should've watched it with lyrics/meaning on, its a beautiful song

[@flarion100]

Thanks @Carl John Franz for pickin this song. Your doing great mate. Cheers. And my dear friends "Guys stop fighting. Be proud that someone overseas is doing a video about one of our singers" Let us just appreciate an artist and not quarell about their nationality. And don't forget an important thing and an undeniable fact "All Pakistanis are Indians' wether you agree or disagree or like or dislike that's the truth and learn accept it and live with it. Lots of love from India to the finest Pakistani singer the world has ever seen. Luv....v

[@jayeshrajput1445]

India has him..part of our culture..she is happy because she is sharing stage with some legend like Nusrat sir♥️♥️

[@sumrasheikh1758]

This is actually Pakistan’s 🇵🇰 music studio which is neighbouring country to India.

[@suhridguha2560]

Yeah pakistani coke studio is head and shoulders better than our version xD

[@triptishekhawat8297]

Sumra Saeed but what he is doing is indian classical music ....so shut the f up !

[@sumrasheikh1758]

Tripti Shekhawat no need to use profanities. It’s classical music of subcontinent. Indian, Bengali and Pakistani singers use this. I’m talking about the singers. They al use similar techniques. South Asian have similar styles.

[@pramedhindra5560]

I don't want to be offensive but subcontinent is India there is no concept of classical music or raga in Muslim culture it is Hindu but later muslims also started singing it and no doubts produced many great singers same with Indian classical dances all the dance forms except katthak was for performing inside temples only katthak was developed for performance in the court of kings and badshah

[@triptishekhawat8297]

Pramedh Indra on point

[@shabbeerahmed3236]

Those are Pakistani singers.... And pls react to "Ali Zafar's - Rockstar"

[@gamingsingh4004]

First of all ali zafar sucks part because no man should be that good looking and compared to rahat fateh ali khan he is nothing just like rahat fateh ali khan is nothing infront of ustad sahab.. 2nd whats this indian and Pakistani.. it’s nothing...i mean we talking music here.. its not Kashmir.. no need to say indian or Pakistani.. geez!

[@itsmeayana3220]

Shabbeer Ahmed us se thaka hua koi gana nahi mila

[@AnupamBarmanForever]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aXLJeZ5pbahlf8k

[@i-try8591]

Ustad Rahat Fateh Ali Khan Sahab the reason why she is 'so pleased, happy to be singing together'. A true legend, one of the many Godly musicians of Pakistan, and this one is from an Indian here.

[@debajyotisg]

Will be forever grateful to our neighbors for Rahat Fateh Ali Khan. This man sings near impossible notes with such strength and always a smile on his face. Legend. As nations, we may have our differences, but music hopefully brings us together. Hopefully one day we become allies.

[@emusman5225]

I shouted at the top of my voice when you said "INDIAN" at 5:00 No sir. We are "PAKISTANI". Period. Not gonna explain for that. We are proud Pakistanis. India is our neighbour. We have our own identity.

[@Noor_Aziz]

With due respect i think then there's a problem in Marketing

[@dynamo7372]

You were once INDIAN don't forget that....

[@dynamo7372]

@@angohar Ya that's why India growing and you guys begging for IMF loan, being china's bitch

[@nimishnagture7816]

This genre of singing is usually known as hindustani music which is common to both india and pakistan as we share the same cultural identity so its obvious that a "firang" will confuse it to a single more known as to of a country.

[@samiach2457]

@@angohar ❤❤

[@MrUmarjavaid1994]

Please correct he is not from India, he is from Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@sudipkumardas1073]

But earns mostly in India

[@subhadeepmandal1374]

Actually India nd Pakistan were one before partition. The origin of classical music is same... Nd Mr. Father Ali Khan is one of my favorite. Many Pakistani singers are ruling Bollywood coz of their immense talent nd beautiful voice. There are very good Indian classical singers too. I love listening to them all... 💓 from India

[@MrUmarjavaid1994]

@@subhadeepmandal1374 I just corrected him that's it.

[@b-deep_bom]

Aur Sikhao in goro ko... ghanta yeh samajh te hain Indo-Pak classical music.. inko malum hain idhar crore subscribers mil jayenge larte jhagarte Huwe...aur isika fyda utha kar yeh paisa kamayenge

[@hashtagnuman5475]

Sudip.. Das Indian earn money from rahat

[@itsnadaaaa]

His uncle Nusrat was wildly loved in India! My mother always spoke fondly of hearing him on the radio 😅

[@sumasu4496]

Lovely feedback. You have a great sense of tune and sound so it's nice to see the appreciation. ♡ will be watching your channel more often. Lots to learn x

[@user-oq2rk7ep8f]

Waiting for the day when he comes across DHINCHAK POOJA.

[@meowmeow193]

And ko ko korina by coke studio

[@user-kx3cm2ql4b]

He will die before he completes the song.💀

[@user-oq2rk7ep8f]

@@BikashKumar-ix6ho Bhai fan h Kya tu?

[@syedshakaibanwar2698]

And who allowed you to type such forbidden words?

[@user-oq2rk7ep8f]

@@syedshakaibanwar2698 😂😂

[@devanarayan4595]

Its a blend of pakistani and indian,thanks for reacting to my suggestion.

[@fatelvis6924]

It's lyrics are one of the best in Hindi/Urdu music history. The beauty he's describing is celestial. This type of beauty of Sufism, in which Sufi saints sang their praise to God through similar songs.

[@puspita282]

He is a Pakistani singer and equally loved and respected in India. We are grateful to be able to listen to this amazing singer. Rahat Sir is a class apart.

[@raziariaz1980]

Hye Carl you are judging a LEGEND, you never know what he is capable of, he is just amazing beyond your expectations, 🇵🇰👏

[@anupv63]

Abe chutiye, he is just giving reaction.

[@m.ahmadsaeed2666]

The person you are judging is the LEGEND :D

[@subab1601]

The reason why the singers love while singing has lot to do with the lyrics. This song is a pure poetry

[@everybitlocal]

Sir Did you realize This male singer is the nephew’s of Ustad Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan who you have reacted already and he’s the son of the singer who sit with Nusrat Sir. Luckily I had met them few year’s ago! This family has a long history for classical singing. Thanks for so great reaction 🙏

[@hanain-289]

He's a pride of the subcontinent

[@RandhirDhir]

Most of the people don't know that pakistani and Indian music is the same.. They both came from Indian classical music.. (Bhartiya shastriya sangeet). The taans Rahat is singing at the end of the song originated in Indian classical music.. Don't be foolish people.. Countries are different but the music is same..

[@romanatkins7182]

The song is Pakistani, the singers are Pakistani, the studio is Pakistani. Why would they call it Indian . I bet you call Sufi music Indian too...

[@chhingariindian]

Song was written by Javed Akhtar, an Indian song writer.

[@chhingariindian]

Artists and Studio belong to pakistanis.

[@aashuruslaankhan9686]

Yes because there was no Pakistan before 1947 but music roots were eternal

[@zeeshanbutt9039]

@@aashuruslaankhan9686 bro you can even search tan sen deep roots belong to land now called Pakistan better without auto tunes like Bollywood using

[@omarkhan1932]

Calm down ppl he is not judging he is merely explaining in the light of his expertise as a vocal coach and if u pay attention he is basically all praises for the maestro.

[@manashbarman7517]

A legend... divine voice, really a gift to the ears

[@FA-ge5sr]

Dude you are making a lot of ppl upset lol. This guy is Nusrat Fateh Ali's nephew. both Pakistani. Legends.

[@alindianacious1300]

Sorry to say this.. You're not enough to Judge him..Coz he is one of the Legends.. Tats y Momina seemed so happy to sing along with him

[@Vor567tez]

He is a vocal coach what do u expect. Don't come here if u get so easily triggered.

[@sidonculous]

These are Pakistani singers. A lot of phenomenal singers that lend their voice to Indian Film music originate from Pakistan and I cannot acknowledge them enough for that! Xx

[@tasneem0108]

We stand united when it comes to art

[@tonguelickster646]

Pakistan got lots of good talent Love from India ❤️

[@MidlifeRenaissanceMan]

Hey Carl Been a while. I need your help I’ve got a gig in 30 hours time and I have a throat infection, with a whole bunch of snot that’s settled in my throat. Most stuff I sing is in my lower registers. Nothing in head / falsetto But I’m kind of screwed Any suggestions? Natural remedies ? Drugs (legal or otherwise) ? Please please please...any suggestions

[@MidlifeRenaissanceMan]

BTW these reviews are so helpful for tips and tricks. It’s great having someone explain things in a way you can understand That said, my own singing still sucks. I could invest in lessons, but I’ve been buying gear instead:-)

[@cwehden]

If things are really tough and the cord aren't flexible sing on lighter coordinations if you have to.

[@MidlifeRenaissanceMan]

Carl John Franz cheers I cant even get chord closure at a G below my top F# before break. I’m actually starting to lose my voice. Having trouble speaking. Lots of squeaks and cracks I think I’m fucked, so to speak I’m loading up on vitamins. Drinking plenty of water, I smashed a good chunk of wasabi, and I’m about to hit the chilli I’m thinking of dropping into the doctors and grabbing a script for some opiated psuedoefadrine as the fuckers here have turned it into a script only medication when for the last 50 years I’ve been able to get them over the counter

[@TheRisingKarma]

@@MidlifeRenaissanceMan kzbin.info/www/bejne/oaGlnKKXob2hjq8 Also, after doing this, you can try to suck on a fresh ginger coated with salt.

[@MidlifeRenaissanceMan]

Sharminator boi I think that’s how I got my throat infection What’s more annoying is the bloke said he would pay me but he needed to visit an ATM. I waited 3 hours and he never came back...

[@sumitabhdas5638]

He is a legend sir...!! His singing is in another level....

[@adibalamin7677]

Ustad (Sir/Teacher) Rahat Fateh Ali khan, is the most famous singer of Pakistan. He has recorded over 50 albums. He has toured the world, his family has a tradition of singing more than 400 years. He was born into a Punjabi family of Qawwals and classical singers in Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan. He is the most paid Pakistani singer. He is the son of Farrukh Fateh Ali Khan, grandson of Fateh Ali Khan and the nephew of legendary Qawwali singer Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. Rahat displayed an adoration for music from a very young age and was often found to be singing with his uncle and father, as young as three. From an age of seven, he was already being trained by his uncle Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan in the art of singing Qawwali..You can watch more of his songs. He is a living Legend.

[@rohitashwanigam]

If this is his reaction on Rahat, just wait till he hears the real thing Nusrat Sahab.!

[@ScrapingNinja]

This song is Pakistani version of "In love with the shape of you"

[@Private.R]

what!!!! really?

[@ScrapingNinja]

Private R yes, if you know thr lyrics

[@Musivary]

@@Private.R it's not. He actually means that the song is about appreciation of beauty of a woman he loves

[@The99Akshay99]

Let's keep things separate

[@user-kg7tu1mn4o]

Fr😂💗💓💖💕💓💗

[@aashishadhikari354]

Goosebumps every time I listen this masterpiece

[@faran888]

BECAUSE HE IS AN ICON.