Vocal Coach Reacts to JJ Lin x Ronghao Li - If I were Young｜國外聲樂老師點評

[@盧育庭-j4b]

聽到老師說她想聽更多合音，希望老師可以聽動力火車，台灣原住民雙人組合音超厲害！非～～～～常和諧👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@leowang5364]

加1

[@vitachen2717]

+1 必須推

[@Farfar71597]

+1

[@smilefreeair]

推推

[@qelenluljuwan1020]

+1

[@雷安-v3b]

我懂老師的意思 有時候雙人對唱衝擊固然不錯但是這麼成名的歌手能夠 願意唱合聲真的很不容易 很佩服JJ音樂之路能走這麼遠不是沒有原因❤

[@JM_Rong]

JJ唱的和音真的好好聽！！他是細節魔人💜 老師好厲害居然有發現 ！！

[@cmymotion]

肯定的。他出道前當了陳潔儀的合音數年。

[@LivYang]

跟老師一起看視頻很開心耶❤ 聽到了更多的細節😊

[@Dear99999]

完全懂老師為什麼這麼愛JJ😂

[@carolyn5000]

I really appreciate that you're not only talking about music, but the cultural differences behind the stage. That's what makes your reaction unique! And those are really valuable discussions.

[@katherine3804]

很喜歡這一期的氣氛！ 有專業内容又可以enjoy輕鬆閑聊，支持你們，做你們想做想說😊 such a good way to start my Friday ❤

[@eraser7880]

I believe one thing we can agree on is that JJ's voice is so addictive.

[@mrjoe-y5t]

老實說如果老師明白歌詞涵義我相信她會更喜歡李榮浩唱這首歌，李榮浩唱傷感歌是真的讓我有感覺到歌詞裡悲傷的情緒

[@LU-cf7ll]

@@mrjoe-y5t jj 太油了

[@WongEthan-ge6pq]

我覺得李榮浩唱出悲傷情緒是MV的時候， 這裏如果單獨聽他的部分， 也聼不出悲傷感。 應該是因爲演唱會現場的氣氛很難嘉賓以來就帶動悲傷。

[@janiceleong3602]

Rozette老师的反应给我的感觉是。。李荣浩--他还不错，JJ--还用说吗?他就是我的菜啊😅。

[@陳柚蓁-r2w]

這首歌果然是屬於李榮浩的！JJ唱歌固然好聽，但更適合李榮浩唱

[@李孟倫-d4n]

因為看老師的影片 我才發現JJ唱歌真的很好聽耶 以前也覺得好聽，但不知道有這麼多細節

[@amyg1073]

Rozette, you are very good in your observation. Jj likes to do the accompaniment for most duets, never want to outshine the other singer , as he only invites singers whom he admire n has same quality n standard as he. It’s a respect.

[@葉秋英-r6m]

補充一下，就算來賓水準不如他，他也盡量不搶別人風采，幫別人補強

[@michellechang7568]

老師 不僅能評論音樂，在聊到東西方文化時，簡單的觀點馬上點出來差異，老師好可愛❤（來亞洲演出還是白一點好哦～)

[@DanielWang0525]

Really enjoy ur conversation today which goes beyond music, but also other aspect, eg fashion, under different culture.

[@lowgenpan]

很喜歡這種閒聊的節奏

[@ET_RUBY]

這兩天才被演算法推到這邊 很喜歡現場有人跟老師互動討論的影片，比早期的有趣多了 而且還多了其他衣着文化等的探討，好喜歡❤

[@TinSu-y8d]

老師說自己看起來像窮人那邊好好笑

[@jkasster]

這集的聊天好好聽～喜歡～

[@kapo_1010]

終於有Disney組曲的react了，超期待🥳🥳

[@宥崴普2022王]

怎麼沒看到?🤣

[@陳小足-o3f]

JJ唱功真的很棒～

[@cynthiaang6479]

Even for his invited artist or his fan sang JJ's song, he will also willing to play supporting role.. intention to make the whole song sound pleasing.. is pleasant to see such gesture

[@adeletan4833]

Disney+ launch was in Singapore 3 years ago. 2021 (pandemic year).

[@liuaimee7940]

I like your guys discuss culture topics

[@JJininin]

今天的閒聊滿有趣的😂

[@henrycheong3083]

JJ❤🚶🏻‍♂️📀的独一无二声线，唱功及技巧。无论唱🎤什么歌🎼，都超级赞\(≧▽≦)/呗。他所有的华/英语歌，都非常好听❣🙏🏻☝🏻🥰👍🏻

[@bingyuanlu2825]

行了 抖音捧捧就行了！这样说话方式真恶心

[@athomenotavailable]

Rozette 想太多了，亚洲的演唱会的服装千奇百怪。JJ的算是很正常了。

[@isaaccruel3994]

Rozette is so good she could imitate whatever language was sang in and sound like she speaks it.

[@nina747]

我很喜歡李榮浩模特那張專輯，但這首歌真的是因為JJ才喜歡的，除了JJ的音色好聽，另外在這首歌中難得可以聽到JJ的低音，太有磁性太有魅力了

[@hongyutu]

喜好真的是很主觀的！ 但可以聽到聲樂老師專業的意見，真的覺得很棒！

[@普通-p4e]

李荣浩就是出了名的小眼睛😂😂😂

[@就是喜歡吃薯片]

這首歌還是喜歡李榮浩😂❤ 這首歌的質感配榮浩的聲音比較配 而且榮浩的歌真的不適宜技巧太滿 聲音很smooth的❤不過音樂的確每個人喜好不一^^

[@dor6612]

Rosette complimented JJ on his harmonising ability when doing a duet with his singing partner. I totally agree with her and would like to recommend a duet that he did with Karen Mok in her 2018 concert. The song is called Xin Ling Shen Hui (Heartfelt) which JJ composed for her. You can find the live video from Karen Mok's KZbin channel. JJ's harmonising ability is superb and Karen Mok also showed why she's a diva. Appreciate if you could show it to Rosette for her review. Thanks.

[@qingchu6880]

喜欢老师在片尾的演唱。❤

[@ivychow7687]

Oh, jj tmea 2023 also very good to react to

[@ltteo2036]

JJ❤❤❤

[@ivychow7687]

Stage spotlights are strong so that the audience can see the performing artistes clearly

[@ivytran2945]

If I’m not mistaken, JJ is the producer of his concert 😂😂😂

[@ivychow7687]

Yeah disney medley 🎉🎉🎉🎉 can react to jj tribute to david bowie, prince n george michael too pls pls

[@tekyonglim1130]

Yeah, JKai & Rozette, please react to jj tribute to david bowie, prince n george michael, the link below:- kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKLEd2mYmt6hZtksi=f_1kzsCjSoXq2HVP

[@rurulin4228]

好喜歡老師對於不管是音樂，還是生活的觀察，聽了都會不禁思考好多小細節

[@libyide]

是因為黃種人如果常曬太陽，是會黑黃黑黃的，而且會顯老，跟白種人曬黑後的那種淺棕膚色不太一樣。😂

[@wengroger3847]

可能因為不懂中文歌詞的緣故，所以老師偏愛周深或是JJ可以理解，畢竟這兩位的歌唱技巧實在是太好了....

[@lingling-gh6pw]

多re点林俊杰的live现场呀（TMEA，红白歌会，2019年跨年，KKBOX好多呢）。 好像迪士尼是个MV来的，音画分开录的，但是是好听的啦！

[@huangvictoria6688]

I’m obsessed with this channel！The topics and cultural differences you guys discussed about is exactly what I have always felt over the years about western pop music. There are less and less singers or albums like back in the good old days when Beyoncé sang something like “halo”. It’s such a pity because there are still tons of brilliant ‘singing technicians’ in the market, but they just don’t make songs like that anymore.

[@qiangxu9513]

太有趣了你们的对话

[@jill55jill]

💜💜JJ 暖男~

[@sammygogo1659]

音樂頻道在討論時尚嗎！太有趣了

[@ivychien3097]

俊傑粉簽

[@snoope.snoope]

老師穿這件很好看耶！

[@henrycheong3083]

Today 22042024, Jj❤ have composer 🎼& chorus🎤 a new song"俯冲灵魂". With his idol "Power Station", super nice❣🙏🏻✌🏻🥰👍🏻

[@smellybeans_8817]

Can you re to JJ's performance at 34th golden melody awards?

[@A3142]

that is quite an excellent performance for jj

[@TSENG666]

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

[@ErinLee-rh9mu]

歌唱的是年少有為，老師顯然不知道，但是話題最後卻閒聊到人生的選擇，也太巧合地契合了！😂

[@黃家羚-i6u]

中文歌有些時候歌詞重於技巧 歌聲 尤其敘事講故事這種歌 個人很喜歡JJ 可是這首年少有為，個人覺得JJ並沒有唱出那個畫面感

[@huanglilian5911]

因為JJ一直很有為，不止年少有為，畫面感唱不出來也是正常，他沒那種高低差太多的心境。

[@jameslin5584]

In early 2000, When JJ was still young he joined Hailuo music, he was sent to be trained by one of Micheal Jackson's vocal coachs, that is why his singing techniques are similar to MK.

[@misserene9]

Please do a reaction for JJ and Lala duet . 不为谁而作的歌

[@peggy4374]

離題一下 亞洲包含日本韓國台灣等，都很流行寬鬆的褲子XD 而且多數真的最愛的就是黑白灰穿搭 當然有時也會繽紛色，但多數時候喜歡素色 尤其韓國冬天路上真的清一色的黑XD

[@bigchief1210]

JJ 一進歌就不同了

[@stevechang600]

Oh, my Godness, when you will visit here in Asia? espacially in China to let every one knowing about you and your singing talent! we all love you here!!

[@silv3ry0ru]

终于re了迪士尼那场么？😲 那是不是可以蹲一个跟Jason mraz还有hito致敬巨星经典的🙈 林JJ在合唱上的禮儀部分 真的120%的認同~💜

[@吳牛牛-q5l]

我想妳是專業的，懂的發聲，但妳不懂文化，妳看的是中國的歌手

[@silv3ry0ru]

@@吳牛牛-q5l 能不能不要在我留言下面耍白目（摳鼻）

[@DWLEE-un3on]

服裝風格是這幾年很流行的韓式風格

[@liang6748]

No, quite a lot of my friends wear that kind of cloths including me 😂

[@zzzzzzzz3412]

I agree on all the comments about the singers and I love JJ. But when I hear Li Ronghao singing this song, for some reason I would cry

[@lance279]

any chance to review jj and mayday's performance in kkbox that pays tribute to David Bowie, Prince and George Michael?

[@UserCw76120]

Yes, please review this. One of my favorites which I listened to many times.

[@nina747]

那場太震撼！👍

[@missmickery]

Actually surprised that she hasn’t reviewed Diamond Zhang yet……

[@家家-b8m]

榮浩聲音 我喜歡

[@李孟倫-d4n]

老師的外套顏色 亞洲人也會穿的 我就會喜歡😁

[@abc092158]

老師說她偏愛JJ多一些、因為JJ唱的比較美聲啊！其實我也是比較喜歡JJ的歌聲，但李榮浩的歌曲很能打動人心，他是娓娓道來歌曲的意境，所以他很多歌我也很喜歡…

[@ahchinsoh4825]

没错，每个人的意境不一样

[@guayihchang]

那褲子以前我們叫"哈台褲",(勞萊與哈台的哈台,和哈台族沒關係XD),有分打一折和打兩折的,在90年代真的蠻流行的

[@foundx8426]

李荣浩声线可怜， 失败感，听了同情❤️‍🩹。JJ‘s voice is naturally brighter.

[@SummerBosch]

可能每个人的感触不一样，我觉得李荣浩的情感更深一些，有融入到歌词里面

[@kikarul]

林俊傑唱就是很順的林俊傑在唱歌，但李榮浩的聲音唱起來就有點滄桑的故事感。

[@geyoung-hp1vs]

快点去歌手2024

[@SandyWong42]

JJ已是世界級歌唱家，李榮浩還不是，在音色上自然是JJ處理得較好，而且聽得比較舒服💁🏻‍♀️

[@SummerBosch]

我两个都喜欢，但是这首歌我喜欢李荣浩的，他的声色也unique ❤

[@Cheerchoice]

Please react to JJ's 鳯凰于飛😊😊

[@UserCw76120]

I really like this song and enjoy the performance. Very interesting changes to the tone and pitch.❤❤❤❤❤

[@FT-od4xv]

Finally Disney!!!!🎉🎉🎉

[@楊雅玲-n3p]

太棒了👏🎉🎉，真的等不及了😍

[@jenyojenyo3316]

Really💜💜💜

[@janiceleong3602]

I guess Rozette will be very happy as most of the Disney songs by JJ is in English.

[@ClaudiaWoo]

Where is Disney songs reaction?

[@emily1723009]

JJ演唱迪士尼組曲的影片什麼時候會上呢🥹🥹❤️

[@HarryHo02]

老师应该听一听（像我这样的人）jj版的 这首歌很多人说jj 想听老师的对于这首歌的看法

[@linnealinberg251]

Can you try to do one video with Yoga Lin? People say he is very skilled as well!

[@howardwu7457]

I know this song sounds like murmuring, however, for this song, the interesting part is the story in the lyric, and, don't miss the music video.

[@吳牛牛-q5l]

懂的發聲或其他技巧不代表妳是主流，懂的尊重別人是重點

[@ming-fenli3207]

希望也可以做一集老師聽動力火車的🙏

[@dxxx.n]

李荣浩太好听了😭❤🐳

[@李榮浩-r5o]

单纯技术处理上同意您的看法，但是这首歌还是感觉李荣浩的演唱更加贴合这首歌。更成立…😂

[@pheiszeong2310]

I agree with preference. Like Rosette prefers JJ's voice because it sounded more pleasing to her and tug her heart strings more. I get he's also the more popular all rounded one. But I am somehow much more attracted to Li Rong hao's as his voice feels darker and magnetic for me. I mean I love Li Rong hao so.. 😂

[@amyg1073]

👍👍👍

[@davec8153]

Harry Styles wears that kinda pants.

[@amyg1073]

JC keep sending people to JJ channel to accuse him of his private life. JJ is getting famous n he is afraid someone overshadowed him. Pls watch out for hate speech here whenever there is JJ around. So sorry that JJ is facing the same accusations as Taylor Swift

[@喵星-m5h]

这首歌还是更喜欢李荣浩的诠释，更符合歌的内容

[@sctan]

各有各的意境吧，毕竟每个人的内心不一样。一个是原唱，当然符合，一个是照自己的感触去唱

[@HanYu0414]

（眼睛太小？）😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@外星人-d6g]

一比見高下,和JJ差太多了根本沒得比

[@la-fc5tp]

很喜歡老師的專業講評跟風格～～～～這首歌建議老師可以看MV跟了解這首歌的中文意思！！

[@la-fc5tp]

JJ很會唱毫無意外，不過這首歌還是李榮浩詮釋的好

[@CoffeeWho_TW]

我也好希望能看到動力火車❤

[@Angelsonearth-l3m]

这位老师真的是专业，她其实听出来乐李荣浩不是中国人。李荣浩的发音是韩国人的发音。

[@不动不静]

太可爱了这个Lady的性格。 ❤

[@LivYang]

哈😂的確，亞洲人真的覺得一白遮三醜，台日韓中的確都是喜歡白一點，現在最流行的就是冷白皮😊

[@xingzuowang]

如果让老师看着《年少有为》的MV再听，代入感会更强

[@viviland620]

太多林俊傑了~我知道老師欣賞他，但~~~太多了!!!! 想看評更多歌手，還有很多非常厲害的歌手，例如: 動力火車. 小宇. TANK. 蕭煌奇. 蔡健雅. 戴佩妮. 很多超棒的創作歌手

[@葉秋萾]

這些言論是多餘的，他們是主廚，他們出什麼菜，你就吃什麼菜（當然你可以選擇要不要吃），何況你們是免付費的

[@FT-od4xv]

数一数JJ也不是最多😂，去其他的留言区说说？

[@HiroSakuma-s3u]

喜欢李荣浩的音色😂😂😂

[@scottylau929]

Lee and JJ 那些美夢 part, Lee is singing the original version in his wrote. But JJ is singing a new ver. by his style. But if you know the full meaning of the song, Lee one is getting more mood and feel matching the whole song. This is not a joyful song. This song should be flat like that.

[@allen5690]

老師林俊傑給李榮浩在日常生活穿塔是不會這樣穿的😂

[@吳牛牛-q5l]

中文歌着重感情

[@ahchinsoh4825]

但JJ更着重真诚，唱的是自己的故事，如果他没有这样的经历，你们硬要他唱这样的意境，可能他会对自己说，太对不起自己了😂

[@黃家羚-i6u]

太對了！！！

[@m70327]

想聽老師分析曹格🙏🙏🙏