Vocal Coach reacts to Metallica The Outlaw Torn (Live)

[@BethRoars]

Hey Everyone! I have started a new channel called "Roar!" where I take on challenges and push myself out of my comfort zone. You can check it out here: kzbin.info

[@johnlengar8331]

Please react to metallica of wolf and man with s&m newsted camera how brilliant Jason as a backing vocal,thank you

[@MrRabiddogg]

the conductor of the San Francisco Symphony invited Metallica to come there to do the concert. Not sure of who paid who for it.

[@jason42080]

You have to understand that every hard beating of the drums is a Reciprotation of the mental stae and emotions of character at that moment in the song so there are no mistakes whatsoever every hard or fast beating of the drums is 100% designed for not just all of their songs but the characters in the songs...that is why Metallica is the GOAT of a Symphony Metal Band...they literally are their own Symphony already by their self 😎 🤘

[@BastiXIII]

OUTLAW TORN!!!! Whoever suggested this you're the hero of the day!!!

[@ryanw6074]

I see whatcha did there.🤣

[@drshreddinger9115]

You're right, sir. MAMA THEY TRY AND BREAK ME!

[@drock55551]

He's no Disposable Hero!!!

[@outlaw_math]

He's the MASTER! Like no ONE else!

[@mestrealmeidascreativeworkshop]

True, and nothing else matters.

[@GleepgorpOfficial]

2:11 Correction, you know you've really made it as an orchestra when you're able to play with Metallica

[@SharbelFadul]

LOL!!! Win!!

[@kalebbooher8092]

Yesssssss

[@mariobandov6638]

Correctly. Very great comment.

[@mike28003]

Yes yes yes

[@eyematrak]

Nice point of view man :)

[@glcorreia]

8:15 "I love these growls behind in the back vocals" Jason was the best

[@yupsure]

We love them, and miss them too!!!☹️

[@Pirustae]

She hasn't heard him performing during the Justice and Black Album tours. An absolute beast! A demon

[@chrisautry9479]

Newstead for all time!

[@larryreno8293]

Jason’s vocals are missed.

[@NotZahidatall]

@@chrisautry9479 you are the one who comment on d gibbby's outlaw torn reaction for not liking the vocals of Jason 😅 am I right???

[@jovanco]

You probably won't see this but I think "Bleeding Me" from the same concert is amazing!! Gives me goosebumps!!

[@apoenaferraz3512]

It has been my favorit song for ten years!!

[@FluffyFractalshard]

its so cool to see people here pointing out the same songs that are still my favourites from that album to this day! :)

[@mmmmn8033]

especially when it comes to kirk's solo...wow

[@dishanknayal6118]

It's a fuckin master piece

[@felipeguedes2462]

Concordo totalmente! Me dá arrepios também. Tive de ler seu comentário com um tradutor, faça o mesmo, não sei escrever em inglês kkkkkkkkkkkkk

[@75190255508]

Anyone else stoked for S&M2 in September this year?

[@furrom152]

What? WHATWHATWHATWHATWHATWHAT? How the hell did I miss this?

[@75190255508]

@@furrom152 check their official Facebook page :)

[@bradderzpartridge]

Mate, its gonna be epic. I've been thinking about what Metallica standards along with new stuff they'd play that they hadn't already done on S&M 1. They've got 'Sanitarium', 'Creeping Death', 'Harvester of Sorrow', 'Fade to Black', 'Orion', 'Blackened', 'The Four Horsemen', 'The Unforgiven' just to name a few! Proper exciting.

[@75190255508]

@@bradderzpartridge I really really wanted creeping death in their firs S&M. Since they have released hardwired we should expect at least one song from that album. Spit out the bone with an orchestra... That would be epic!

[@christopherdavila9605]

Gavin_152 exactly the words that i just spit out!!! Word for word man!

[@antoniosivric7206]

8:17 I almost teared up when she said she loves those growls in the back If only she knew how much we miss those growls..

[@NamitComedy]

James still brings them back sometimes, but yes, I almost cry seeing him struggle sometimes!

[@JPMongeS]

The Outlaw Torn is such a masterpiece and the S&M version took it even further. Love it!.

[@Blackstock123]

Hetfield is an interesting singer, and a reluctant one, he never really wanted be a vocalist at the beginning of Metallica but has developed and improved his singing ability from just yelling and screaming to what you see now, he may not the best technical singer but hes a very expressive one. I think his true genius lies in his song writing ability and how he comes up with guitar riffs/arrangements and lyrics/ vocal lines.

[@astro2691]

James ONLY wanted to sing when metallica started. Get your facts straight!

[@Blackstock123]

as far as I am aware they were looking for a vocalist but never really found one so James took it upon himself, he has even joked about it, but by all means correct me if I am wrong. :) I cant remember every little fact or detail on the fly, cheers.

[@esteban280889]

Howard should check this facts before trying to correct others.

[@IwieIch123]

Kurturmis true.. up to MOP they tryed to find a singer.. after that James embraced it.. thanks for that tbh

[@kevinlemaster8958]

they almost got Joey belladonna ( anthrax) as a vocalist so James could focus more on guitar. thank God they did not work out and James kept both spots

[@freetobewhoibe]

Such an underratted song from Metallica. Great video :)

[@Schivi086]

100% true

[@linkinaball]

I think that it is my favorite Metallica song. So much feel and emotion to it. They grew as musicians. I really respected that. And defended them back in the 90's because of it. But the so called fans just wanted the old stuff. They went back to the older style. And now they sound like a cover band of their former (and old school) self.

[@GanjaLibre]

This whole album is underrated, it has great classics and balads, I understand though why people critize it, is the less thrash metal album and is far from the noisy dirty Metallica we all love, but still is a beautifull album

[@jackking8027]

Agree, everything from Load and Reload are very underrated.

[@VacantSpirit]

@@linkinaball i love the build up for solo coming slow chill then BIG BANG also other song with same type of is on Unforgiven 3 has the build up and similar Solo begin with BANG!

[@Dewitt-b8n]

Shows you how good James is as a songwriter. They are a perfect fit for an entire orchestra

[@thebigv8644]

This concert shows exactly why Jason was so perfect for the band, his growl and energy on stage was phenomenal!!

[@StonyBlazestation]

Load got so much hate because it wasn't like the older albums. If you separate the preconceptions about Metallica from this album and just listen to it for what it is, it's actually quite good. There's some really good songs on Load and, to a lesser extent, Reload.

[@jw11432]

Absolutely agree that Load/Reload got hate due to its departure from their signature sound. I was fortunate enough to have been introduced to Metallica shortly after Reload came out, specifically with the song Fuel. I gorged on Reload, as it was my first Metallica album, listening to it over and over, loving each track (with exception to Low Mans Lyric, at the time). So I would say each are synonymous in terms of song quality, but that's just my opinion.

[@mitchmenken9264]

If you were to take the best songs off load and reload, that would be one fucking amazing album

[@Matt_H_26]

Love them both. Was a big change for Metallica, but still amazing music.

[@Metalhead52771]

Load is half of a really good record. ReLoad is Memory Remains and a whole lot of (King) Nothing. St Anger I listened to once and threw it in the garbage. 3,000 cds and that’s the only one I straight trashed. Bought Master of Puppets on the day of release after discovering RtL and subsequently Kill em All. Went to all 5 SoCal headline shows on the Justice tour. I go almost all the way back with them. Gods

[@nonameslb]

Load and reload are garbage albums by Metallica standarts.Kill,Ride,Master and Justice are better by a fucking mile.EET FUK \.../

[@glyrtv]

I'm a simple man. I see Metallica, I press like.

[@Thnielsen85]

the reason that classical instrumelts and metal goes so well together, is that classical music is basically metal without electricity.

[@derekfletcher8934]

Yep. Fight Fire With Fire from the Ride The Lightning album comes to mind immediately, or Battery from Master Of Puppets.

[@Alexander-gj9ms]

NO... Metal is just classical with electricity.

[@claus9112]

I would have to agree and I'm sure Apocalyptica would too.

[@gr8old136]

Motzart and others original metalheads

[@stevenmathis5003]

I feel like ...and justice is very classically influenced

[@TheMasonator777]

Jason Newstead is the bassist/backup vocalist. He is a metal vocal giant in his own right.

[@insufferablethrashelitist9305]

He released his own album in 2013 under the name Newsted. Has some pretty good tracks on it. His voice takes a little getting used to, but once you do it's pretty cool.

[@BC08]

Lol, what?

[@Trainwheel_Time]

@@khaledjouma Bwwaaaahhaaaaaahaaaaa!!! Good one man!

[@lonewanderer2894]

@@khaledjouma , naw. Metallica's awesome songs and the three guys who wrote em are what made and still make Metallica shows awesome. They still kill it live.

[@jason.h.zager88]

@@lonewanderer2894 typical idiot who gets into metallica a year or two

[@ashleebenedict6523]

Wow, I think this was the best Metallica reaction I've ever seen. Professional, open minded, informative. I loved it. This song has always had a special place in my heart (along with all of the othe Metallica songs) and I'm glad that you enjoyed it.

[@DavidGomez-ph4yn]

Now we need to know what do you think about the angry James Hetfield in the early 90's and the 80's

[@8tonystark8]

*Fade to Black Seattle* or "James Hetfield YEAH compilation"

[@MetalKillsRap2]

Tony Stark The Thing that Should Not Be in Seattle 89. His voice was brutal on that one!

[@CHAOSMOVEMENT]

Yes lol, please do a segment on Jump In The Fire or Four Horsemen ;)

[@rytterl]

Would be interesting to see the love version of spit out the bone too. Well, not Robs part, but yeah. A little more grizzled and aggressive.

[@Randall_Kildare]

*"DICKRASH!"*

[@curlem76]

Wow...1) Metallica 2) Outlaw Torn and 3) S& M Live!!! As co-incidence would have it, this year is the 20th Anniversary of this gig and the band has just announced an anniversary performance (S&M²) with the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra this coming September (although sadly it will be without the original conductor and composer of the orchestral arrangement Michael Kamen who died in 2003).

[@metalfan4863]

Yeah. And the tickets sold out in not even minutes after the pre sale went up. It was the work of bots. Everyone is beyond pissed. Including me

[@FluffyFractalshard]

@@metalfan4863 omg this is so sad! how do they just let this happen?

[@overnightgrowth]

Great pick! I love bleeding me from the same concert as well.

[@JBjopa8]

Agreed!!

[@brandonbailey8318]

Old school Metallica fan and I think this is probably my fav

[@VacantSpirit]

Bleeding Me is best and underrated song of Load i guess people rate King Nothing as best but as ive listened that album so much i just think no other song wins Bleeding Me ofc King Nothing, The Outlaw Torn and Until it sleeps are on top 4 behind trying to fight for the place behind :D

[@Christian-vq8rd]

@@VacantSpirit Outlaw Torn and Bleeding Me are by far the two best songs on Load. Both very emotional

[@madulazat]

U should pick "Bleeding Me"..the arrangement..the melody..so dramatic!

[@gcm747]

One of my most favourite songs from this epic performance. James’ talent as a vocalist is really on display here. Thanks for the review.

[@Kipex]

Excellent request and reaction. Good timing too considering it's the 20 year anniversary of this show. James' vocals on this entire S&M show are some of his best ever. Outlaw Torn is definitely an underrated song and the S&M version is brilliant. RIP Michael Kamen!

[@RolandDeschain1]

Michael Kamen did one of the most beautiful scores ever with THE DEAD ZONE. Also, his theme for BAND OF BROTHERS can bring me to tears. He was brilliant and seemed like such a nice man. He is missed.

[@iSanctum]

They are doing another S&M show later this year and I’m really excited which songs they are gonna play this time!

[@Ozzy_2014]

I recognized the name Michael Kamen from What dreams may come with the late Robin Williams. Another loss.

[@jmgmusic1979]

They performed it again for S & M 2 and it was better than it was 20 years ago

[@oldmanuserphan]

I like that even Beth recognizes Jason's perfect backing vocals. I will always miss Jason in the band.

[@Hadjo373]

A reaction to James Hetfield, something I think I never saw on youtube. Great reacion, it's been a while since I listened to this, time to give S&M a spin!

[@juusokovala45]

S&M has autotune so it's not the "reality" of james voice

[@StephenChapman]

This song and "Bleeding Me" are both fantastic on this album.

[@battoosh]

Well get ready for S&M2 later this year! September can't come soon enough! 🤘🏻

[@KARLDOOM]

I wanna see her react to to seattle 89 lol

[@derekfletcher8934]

@@juusokovala45 what proof do you have for this claim?

[@slicedpie]

This came out of NOWHERE! Love this song, especially in this live performance (one of Metallica's most underrated songs imo). Great video as always!

[@turnnburn9008]

I haven't seen any reaction to James, this is a good one, thx

[@TwistedMind86Chern]

James is one of a kind. Consider that he plays amazing and difficult guitar riffs and singing at the same time. 😁

[@MrScrofulous]

NOt to take away form James talent, but you do realise that Kirk plays all of the super hard riffs live like Muppets while James is singing, hey ? James tends to lay back on the power chords then. That does not get recognised much.

[@TwistedMind86Chern]

@@MrScrofulous i think you're totally confused. Do you play guitar or have you seen Metallica live? James plays all the rhythm guitars in studio as he does in the live performances. Kirk plays only the solo parts in the studio versions of the songs and in live concerts he is following Jame's rhythm guitar. You need to do some research before you say your opinions. James play's guitar riffs not guitar chords.

[@TwistedMind86Chern]

@@MrScrofulous especially this main riff of master of puppets. The whole band doesn't play and James plays it by hitting all notes with downpicking. Search more about music and Metallica.It feels that you don't know much about music,i guess its not your thing at all. Cheers.

[@williamskellyl1]

You HAVE to check out Metallica’s S + M album. An entire album live with an orchestra! I recommend No Leaf Clover.

[@thontor]

seconded. That is my favorite Metallica album.

[@louisjamin7195]

No Leaf Clover is definitly the best.

[@tn-luna6915]

I love Of wolf and man. Jason's howls are amazing!

[@Matt_H_26]

Such an amazing album, totally agree!

[@jamesgarrett4653]

Master of Puppets was my first album I bought with my own money. They are my favorite band, and S&M will always be my favorite album of all time.

[@asia-27]

Alice In Chains - Love, hate, love LIVE AT MOORE - one of the best vocal performance ever!

[@FxsX24]

I'm tempted to the spend money on the Patrion just to make this happen

[@drshreddinger9115]

I was about to suggest this one too!

[@ronniegarcia213]

PLEASE

[@OneRealOG]

Layne Staley *sounded amazing live and yeh love hate love is one his best performances

[@bertramallgood9921]

Yes, or Would? or Junkhead....plz

[@supernicko123]

Yay!!!! Thanks for reacting to my request! It is really cool to hear what you think about James Hetfield as a singer, because he has really never considered himself a singer. He has referred to himself as a guitar player who sings because they needed a singer. As other people in the comments have mentioned, he blew out his vocal cords while recording the Black Album in the early 90's, and ended up getting a vocal coach and a warm up routine that he still uses before shows. The conductor, Michael Kamen (RIP), provided some strings for a Metallica song called Nothing Else Matters and then they approached him about doing a whole show with the San Francisco Symphony. They are actually repeating this concert this year on September 5th to celebrate 20 years since the original S&M concert. This concert is incredible, I think there are a lot of other songs from it that you would enjoy, if you ever have the time.

[@basxV96]

Thanks :')

[@smittycal]

Later this year Mettalica is celebrating the 20 year anniversary of this concert by doing another one with this orchestra. To say I’m excited is an understatement

[@VacantSpirit]

i really hope they would livestream it but i guess no xd

[@smittycal]

MetrislicA they might! There doing it at the Chase center in September. There website has a live stream so who knows. Plus they released a DVD from the original concert so that may happen again. Fingers crossed. Oh and there doing two shows with the orchestra this time due to high demand for tickets. I can’t wait!

[@cdc3337]

It makes my heart very happy to see someone else love this just as much as I do! Haha, can't wait to see more of your reactions!

[@cleitonbelitzki9965]

20 years of S&M! Time flies! R.I.P. Michael Kamen. My sugestion: Type O Negative - Love You to Death

[@Randall_Kildare]

This is one of the best, most unusual, emotionally powerful, & vocally interesting songs in all their copious discography. The 'wolf howl' onomatopoeia in the chorus pronunciation of 'Tooooooorn' is just awesome to me. Not to mention Hetfield's volume-swell solo & the general cleverness of the lyrics. An absolute classic. As an aside, this is the first time I've ever watched anyone inspect Metallica & not discuss Het's singular right hand technique. This is also one of the few songs he's written where he's not downstroking at 250 bpm! \m/

[@robinjansen8522]

I'm a fan for over more than 25 years, and still can't get over how good of a song this is

[@robreynolds9349]

Dear Beth I am sure that Metallica didn't have to pay the Symphony . Micheal Kamen R.I.P approached them and he arranged every note. This was my Mom's favorite Metallica concert but she watched all of them with me. She really loved them.

[@samvisser9408]

I never knew Michael Kamen had died! R.I.P

[@robreynolds9349]

He died of a heart attack @@samvisser9408

[@samvisser9408]

@@robreynolds9349 Thanks for the info. I'm sure it's old news for everyone else, but I'm still kind of shocked. Seemed like a great guy.

[@robreynolds9349]

@@samvisser9408 He was very cool. They had a making of or behind the scenes extra tape that came with the S&M concert.

[@samvisser9408]

@@robreynolds9349 I know! I still own that DVD - he seemed so humble

[@a.t.3192]

James is obviously magneficent here, but Jason's backing vocals around 7:58 onwards always bring a smile to my face. You can hear the passion in the dude's voice, and you can see it on his face.

[@davidsthubbins176]

I really like Rob as a bass player. But I I don't think Metallica will ever sound as good without Jason's vocals.

[@charlieparra3103]

The Outlaw torn is probably the best song from Load/Reload era! Thank you! :D

[@guigow2004]

And Fixxxer as well.. Maybe my favorite. :P

[@nathanparry8315]

And maybe bleeding me too.

[@charlieparra3103]

Fixxer and Bleeding are definitely top 5 yes.

[@Crono1000]

It's impossible to not get chills when listening to this version of this song. It will never get old.

[@beautifulbearinatutu4455]

Uh, interesting. Don't think I've ever seen anyone react to James Hetfield before. He's actually matured a lot as a vocalist throughout the years and even though he's not as aggressive now as he used to be, I quite enjoy his live performances. Gonna be interesting to take a look at this :D

[@netrioter]

this is over 20 years old. Newsted is still in the band

[@beautifulbearinatutu4455]

@@netrioter Yeah, the comment was made before I actually dived in and watched the video. Point about him not being as aggressive kinda still stands, given the late 90s and 2000s feel like the period where he sorta switched off his trashy style, though, at least based on what I've seen of them.

[@tommacmillan8831]

his recent live performances are good, but yeah it's much less aggressive. his clean singing it's excellent lately.

[@davidfuller581]

He's actually a good deal more aggressive than this now. He's figured out how to do it without hurting himself.

[@crustyskellington4056]

I wouldn't judge his aggressiveness based on this concert though as he was particularly melodic around this period of time. If you listen to him post-Death Magnetic he's got some of that snarl back.

[@anthawks9374]

When I listen to this song it grabs me by my senses and makes me realize that I'm grateful for everything I have have. Thank you..for this jewel.

[@Lost_n_Found_1]

You know you've made it as an orchestra, when you're playing next to Metallica...

[@stevenlornie1261]

The Load era is quite underrated. They really matured and peaked as musicians/song writers here. Shame they never kept it up.

[@googlewantstoknowyourlocat1115]

What does "underrated" even mean?

[@penoyer79]

Lars has always been quite pointed and adamant that the Load era was never a conscious effort to change. it was simply them being in a different place as a band - relaxed and at peace with where and who they were - and the music simply reflected that. the black album tour drove the ultra aggro diva rockstar right out of them. the exception being jason who probably would have preferred something... heavier.

[@googlewantstoknowyourlocat1115]

@@penoyer79 stfu

[@monsteritoco]

Load its an amazing album

[@freakystyley4000]

I'm still waiting for ReReLoad.

[@kagankalayli]

PLEASE KEEP COMING WITH THESE METAL REACTION VIDEOS ESPECIALLY METALLICA

[@D-Day-fb3pw]

This whole concert was epic. There are many standouts but Outlaw Torn, Bleeding me, and For Whom the Bell Tolls are mind blowingly good.

[@kevonicus]

One of the most underrated rock songs ever.

[@larryreno8293]

Totally underrated.

[@Awonnuriel]

That feeling when someone says a song that was released when you were 20 is classic. That said, I have to agree that having the whole orchestra behind the band really brought something special to the songs.

[@WolfestoneManor]

Michael Kamen wasn't appreciated for the genius he was.

[@arryospeedwagon]

So many Metallica songs to pick, so many classics, and they go with this deep cut/hidden gem of a song. Absolutely epic and interesting choice. This song proves that Metallica didn't fall off after the 80s. They just grew as artists.

[@sharavanaraj]

Classical music is just metal before electricity!

[@TheLynneee]

Sharavana Raj Maruthiah Great comment👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻🎸🎸🎸🎸

[@nachocheez9690]

Ugh k

[@glassprison03]

Wow, you are on fire lately! Kamelot, Tesseract...The Outlaw Torn?!

[@MrGmoney48]

This is my most favorite concert. My wife hates it because I push the limits on my entertainment system.

[@doggiedoter]

The only way to listen to 'tallicA... yes, SIR!!!

[@aestheticbrah2097]

React to Metallica - creeping death Seattle 89 live Master of puppets is also VERY good from the same concert.

[@NeOVidas]

you might want to switch out creeping death with the thing that should not be from the same show, rewatch it and pay attention to how he sang it

[@ork_oz]

Creeping death moscow 1991 better

[@sanketdhembre5525]

This is a vocal coach reacts. What's the point if u can barely hear the vocals!

[@ork_oz]

@@sanketdhembre5525 she can clearly hear vocals on Moscow and Seattle 89 is remastered too.

[@sanketdhembre5525]

@@ork_oz Yeah, but she is a vocal coach. Not sure what her insights on that song would be.

[@LelynMac]

this was my favorite song on the album by far and this album means so much to me.

[@thekoochy6347]

One singer that i don't see many people talk about is Warrel Dane (R.I.P) from Sanctuary and Nevermore my biggest influence. Suggest you checking him out from "The year of the voyager" show

[@randominc.2251]

The Learning...Wally is in my top 5 of all time ....mostly because my voice changed exactly like his through the years ...

[@andreja9119]

True true

[@lepermessiah1433]

Classical is just metal without electricity! Prove me wrong! Love this channel!

[@cebadillae]

Leprous - Slave or The Flood (both from Live at Rockefeller Music Hall) please! ❤️ I love your videos and I can't wait to see your reactions to Einar awesome performance!

[@Bethrezen78]

Yes please

[@salamanteri_]

Leprous! Einar's style is really unique.

[@ckokomo808]

I’d be interested in her watching “The Last Milestone”. Not a showcase of their overall style and synergy, but it’s such an emotional piece... SO DANG GOOD!

[@cebadillae]

@@ckokomo808 That would be awesome!

[@Severindk87]

I have also suggested that! Definitely unique!

[@ChucksPullingVideos]

When you talked about how this just makes you feel the music.. that is literally spot on with what Metallica does. They want you (everyone) to feel their music and be a part of it, be one with it. I personally love this song, it's one of my favorites of theirs, and you definitely nailed it on this video. Excellent work. I'm gonna check out some of your other stuff and subscribe. Hope you're having a fantastic day!

[@FrenzyWolf]

I miss Jason´s vocals so much. No offense to Robert - but i think that jasons the only true guy for that job.

[@justjones4148]

For vocals, sure. But Rob is a better bassist. Though neither are Cliff...

[@robertw9978]

@@justjones4148 no, neither are cliff. But, it cannot be understated the stage presence of Jason. He was live Metallica. When he left, it diminished the band. Just my opinion, but Jason was the best thing to happen to the band..

[@Quakezilla69]

I have this thought weekly. Wish Jason was still there. I think he was a great back up vocally with James

[@pdegan2814]

Yeah Rob's a monster of a bass player but his vocals can't hold a candle to Jason.

[@Bestwick1983]

I'd rather have a slightly less capable bassist in Jason with his backing vocals than Rob and his complete lack of backing vocals.

[@Vagmansexy]

Fantastic video and the Metallica song that I return to the most after all these years listening to them. James on this particular performance is outstanding. The symphony orchestra just adds so much extra sensitivity to the wounded calls and the way it builds and builds with Kirk's shooting star-esque guitar solo really increasing the sheer magnitude and scale of the song. Really stands by itself outside of the genre, I feel. It's that good.

[@BarryChapman]

always loved this song. been a fan of theirs since before beth was born! (87-88 that is!) This is a massively underrated song from a more... experimental period.. of their time. But this period yielded some great songs, carpe diem baby is another great one. Cue the haters and the people who consider themselves real fans while only liking a fraction of their discography. You can all go stick it. they aren't real fans, they are people that like a couple of songs of a band. this review was on point and an excellent choice for a song of metallicas that did cover a significant breadth of their repertoire. Thanks!

[@boxerdog5979]

I simply adore how you break stuff down. You make it easy to understand.

[@537Aleks]

We wait Fixxxer on S&M 2. Similar and underrated as Outlaw Torn.

[@penoyer79]

That would be a surprise.

[@MrZer066627]

I want The Day That Never Comes

[@FluffyFractalshard]

fixxer would be so awesome!!

[@lostitoto298]

@@MrZer066627 They did it!! They played The Day That Never Comes on S&M 2!!

[@VocalCitizen]

The late Maestro Michael Kamen conceived this pairing of MetallicA and the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra and he composed the entire orchestra’s accompaniment. And - a DEFINITE FIRST for MetallicA fans - it was a sit-down venue. Fun mix of conservative rich classical music folks with headbangers. It was such a great crowd and they came together on the musical fusion . 💕

[@x666xIronMaiden]

Fun fact! They did a 4 song encore after this song. I think the rest was an encore anyway. Been awhile since I listened to the full album.

[@tomharris5649]

Battery was the encore song iirc.

[@Wolfoe-ex2jj]

James has probably been the most influential musician in my life. He inspired me to pick up guitar, I learned his stuff, and his incredibly diverse vocals ended up teaching me more methods and control over my voice than I ever expected.

[@daveruda]

I think this was James best effort on S&M. Really emotional powerful performance. Maybe his vocal peak in terms of "singing".

[@hawaii2k]

This was one big suprise to come home from work to! It's fun to see how you comment on all aspects of the music, not just the vocals, event hough you're a vocal coach. Instruments enhance the vocals and vice versa. Plus you don't use fancy terms for everything. It's easy to understad what you mean.

[@esteban280889]

If you like Jason Newsteads backing vocals should watch live performance of seek and destroy where he takes the lead

[@QuasiELVIS]

He's a lot less nuanced than James.

[@ElBrunno12]

Whiplash, Four Horsemen or Creeping Death too

[@cursedchest6469]

James: "Seeeaaaarchiiiiing..." Jason: "Aauuuughhhhh!!!"

[@TheTruth-pl3mk]

The first time I saw them, in '99 at the old Wembley Stadium, they played this song. It was an epic moment, for sure. I'm old-school Metallica fan (first 4 albums) and not really into Load or Reload, but The Outlaw Torn is certainly a highlight of either album and was a live favorite for many.

[@ork_oz]

He's not just vocalist .He is the greatest rhythm guitarist ever. He has a metronom in his brain

[@DeBedschbacher]

Yeah, sorry Mate. He is good -he is really good-, but he isn't Malcolm Young...

[@ork_oz]

@@DeBedschbacher fair enough.I respect that comment but my fav James and I love Malcolm too

[@DeBedschbacher]

@@ork_oz Personal preferences ftw!! In all fairness, James sings too, which Mal doesn't. So that adds another level to it. Can't be easy to sing that good AND be that great in your instrument at the same time...

[@williamskellyl1]

He’d have to be good at keeping time. Lars is crap at it.

[@andrewlaw]

@@DeBedschbacher Gary Moore did it superbly.

[@elkardona]

What a lovely english accent you have😍 I like so much the way you analize from the soul, from feelings the tones, the growls, the whispers, everything the singer does. Greetings from Medellín-Colombia

[@andrewlaw]

It's a Scottish accent, the Scots take offence at being called English! 😂

[@RolandDeschain1]

No-one is ever going to call Hetfield a technically great singer, but he has charisma and a unique delivery that a lot of vocalists still try to imitate, but can never match.

[@emperoring112]

YES! THANK YOU! I love orchestra with rock music! It’s one of the most epic things for me!

[@alexeyyakovich7464]

Should have better done "No Leaf Clover" from the same live. Much more vocal there.

[@VacantSpirit]

i know people been wondering why they didnt release it on studio album but i just think thank god they didnt! becouse its such a masterpiece already when they played live Studio version just would've made it sound weird :D

[@CalgaryDynastar]

Good day to be alive he said!!!!! One of my favs off the album

[@kreush7329]

Bleeding Me

[@gabrieledomingosjardim5358]

In Human, the vocal is heavier

[@bm669]

I saw an interview with one of the orchestra musicians talking about being on tour with Metallica. The way he talked about the crowd and the reciprocating energy being something he never felt before was really cool.

[@vitalsteell]

An epic concert! They will do a 2.0 version this year!!!

[@chrishowell199]

I love how you understand. It's rare for me to relate with most other people. Thank you.

[@avav6204]

Metallica has done s&m 2 and YOU NEED to DO new reaction to this song. Want to know what you think about James vocals now, 20 years later!

[@LeperxMessiah]

I don't know if anybody's commented this but this song is very personal to James it doesn't get played live much nowadays but when it does it's amazing every time and it's so powerful. he put so much passion into this song because it has meaning behind it for him because it's a personal song.... great reaction to this and this is one of my favorite Metallica songs the bass lines in the song are just so good if you listen to this again listen to studio version and just listen to the bass... Metallica Now, Then and Forever a Fan

[@DeBedschbacher]

Hey Beth! Thank you for choosing the S&M version of the song! 🐅

[@MetalPersonJ]

It's the only live version of this song.

[@DeBedschbacher]

@@MetalPersonJ Oh, I did not know... It is the only live Metallica I listen to. The whole double album has been continously in my playlist since '99. What an epic EPIC concert...

[@eighteen-naked-cowboys]

@@MetalPersonJ not true they have played it with rob trujillo at least once. its on youtube. edit: i googled it its actually been played quite a few times.

[@MetalPersonJ]

@@eighteen-naked-cowboys The only live purchasable, official version of the song, though youtube clips are fair game here last time I checked.

[@jasonstinebaugh8447]

In addition to your always spot on review, I love the fact that you got a little metal snarl on your face as the music built and almost started banging your head! Love your metal/rock reactions!

[@jonathanblaine4121]

I never thought I would see a vocal coach get so excited about a James Hetfield performance while breaking it down and explaining it so thoughtfully. Consider me impressed, Beth.

[@Fixxer315]

IMO, the most underrated song of the Metallica catalog. This was a true masterpiece, and it's a shame that it doesn't get more attention, perhaps because it was during a transitional period of the band, which the fans didn't quite accept. But the song itself is amazing, particularly the bridge and the guitar solo, both of which give me chills.

[@davesmith8341]

React to Skid Row 18 and Life live from Moscow!!!

[@jasonx4008]

Loooooove skid row (Bach era)

[@DiamondDustVIII]

I've never heard anyone actually pick apart...not just just the music, but the idea of metal itself. You nailed together what I've been trying to argue for the last 20+ years. Killer video, Beth!

[@akenawell]

I call what he does “Hetfield Magic”

[@CodOverloadNoob]

First heard this as a young kid and I have yet to hear a more perfect combination, this song is absolutely everything in 1, great video.

[@manguy2000]

Call of Ktulu from the same show please.....oh wait....

[@kondrashovoleg]

This song will kill me sometime. That buildup... My heart races each time, and then, the noize explosion - a mini heart attack of happiness. I am so happy right now I almost cry..

[@angelinasecatero7507]

Great choice. Especially with S&M. Keep rocking Beth. 🤘😎 Can you please react to Queensryche- Take Hold of the Flame (Live in Tokyo). Thanks.

[@IguanoTwix6942]

This specific live cover of this song is one of my favorite Metallica songs. You don't know how glad I am that you're doing this song!

[@Valdagast]

I wonder what you think about Ozzy Osbourne. He sure has a unique voice.

[@BethRoars]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d2GVlYWnfMhqqqM :)

[@riphopfer5816]

What you were discussing about his using open notes, then closing them off rapidly- When I was a lad I wanted to sing like a combination of Jim Morrison an James Hetfield, and I used to describe that style as ‘biting’.

[@RocketCr_YT]

Out law torn? Great f******* song!!! 🤟😁❤

[@Dave19812506]

Michael Kaman was the SFO director at the time and he has one of the most iconic scores of the 80s and 90s films

[@danielskar7783]

SPIT OUT THE BONE!!!!! Please ❤️❤️

[@clairepaulkayam]

This popped up as a suggestion and it's absolutely fascinating! Thank you!

[@shapeshifter7676]

Blind Guardian - Valhalla (Live Imaginations Through The Looking Glass)

[@sanketdhembre5525]

^This

[@flatini]

Valhalla! Deliverance! Why've you ever forgotten me!

[@oneclipleft]

I love the advice you give about thinking what your voice would naturally do in response to an emotion. I never really thought about it that way, and it seems it can give a vocal performance a very emotional impact without the singer feeling the emotion at the time. Almost like how an actor or actress does it with facial expressions. Very cool.