Vocal Coach REACTS to SHALLOW- LADY GAGA, BRADLEY COOPER

Hello beautiful vocal athletes, how are you?
Ok I needed one more fix.....so here it is. What's your favourite song from the album. Can't wait for the 7th!
GO TO Patreon! (The green tea lounge) for VOCAL EVALUATIONS/ANALYSIS/MERCH/FREEBIES AND MORE SHIZZLE; / rebeccavocalathlete
Website rebeccavocalath... for SKYPE coaching lessons!
Email: [e-mail]
#Neverstopsinging #RVA #shallow #ladygagabradleycooper
Original video; • Lady Gaga, Bradley Coo...
ABOUT:
Rebecca is a passionate Singer-Songwriter/Vocal coach/mentor /impressionist/photographer/creative junkie /self- development lover not a hater.
“I want to motivate and inspire others to follow their dreams…corny? Well, maybe but it’s true. So what’s motivating me?? I had a huge tumour removed summer 2016. However, despite not being able to walk for a few weeks, and feeling generally awful…. It has made me create and do what I love! It wasn’t an easy time but I won’t let fear dictate my life. I didn’t think ‘why me’, there are plenty of horrific issues people have to deal with…it’s not always smooth sailing. It’s true when you hear, ‘Life is short’, the crazy thing is, I am glad it happened…I appreciate life even more and try to practice gratitude everyday…It’s so easy to get caught up with the little things…and I do sometimes, but look at the bigger picture, will it matter in a year or two…we are all specks of dust…Also, thank you for all your support. It means a lot. I have suffered from anxiety from the past and self-confidence, (yeah hard to see now right) didn’t think I was ‘good, or worthy enough’ but I feel I have a new lease of life, don’t really care as much and want to show you guys what I have! : ) You are all awesome and without you, there would be no channel.

[@MindsetMastery75]

When Gaga comes in with "I'm off the deep end, watch as i dive in, i'll never meet the ground" her voice penetrates through the entire body and into your bones. She has that powerful of a voice. Truly gifted she is.

[@cocogomez2278]

Great way to put it! Yes her voice vibrates and penetrates into my bones and soul. I get choked up every time, it's so powerful. Gaga has never been so beautiful.

[@heejinators7342]

her voice permeates my veins and crawls through my cells

[@Steroid1363]

I agree, are you kevin? ?????

[@weareplastic6754]

Space Alien Not as powerful as the trailer version... sadly

[@SquirrelTheater]

She just DESTROYS me with that vocal in this song....because that’s my LIFE.

[@lucyroberts8104]

*All vocals in the film were recorded LIVE*

[@rva]

That's awesome

[@lucyroberts8104]

Rebecca Vocal Athlete ikr it makes the whole video even more impressive!

[@rva]

7th November!!! 💓

[@edwuave]

@@rva you have not seen the movie?

[@franziskaa.4898]

Yes it was Gagas wish to do it like that and Bradley luckily trusted her with that 💕

[@debsw4518]

It's weird but I've never really looked at Lady Gaga before this film..... she is so so naturally pretty. I'm a little bit in love 🙌

[@rva]

Straight up me Debs. Me too

[@ragazzopigro97]

"Naturally" lmfao she is full of filler

[@inka9321]

Debs W she actually made hundreds of surgerys.

[@misscoolgirl7166]

Debs W she aint naturally beautiful tho.. lol

[@Nazaba09]

Lorenzo she doesn’t have fillers, she has fibromyalgia and gets Botox for it.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

This is a corny thing to say, but part of me wishes I could see it again for the first time.

[@rva]

🧡💛

[@daisybuchanan8205]

It's actually very sweet and genuine.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

@@daisybuchanan8205 Tonight will be the third and last time to watch. I'll then buy the DVD on its release date of 12/31/2018. I hardly buy DVDs anymore, so I hope it has a lot of extras bloopers and bonus stuff.

[@clarad4288]

i feel you

[@daisybuchanan8205]

@@moomoopuppy5810 you seem to love this movie, much like everybody who saw it, I bet I will love it too, can't wait to see it.

[@EmmaTheCowie]

A Star Is Born freaking destroyed me. But it was worth it. Always Remember Us This Way is hugely underrated from the album. Hope you enjoyed it when you saw it x

[@rva]

Thanks sweet pea

[@claudiaemme1219]

Emma McNeil Cowie so true! I loved that song so much!

[@kalen3719]

That’s my fav song on the soundtrack

[@joshuahale6249]

I like that song, but I love “Is That Alright?” even more. I feel that it’s so under appreciated.

[@gilangrzkp]

Is That Alright & Before I Cry are way more underrated

[@breakmykneespaps7721]

All the singing in the movie was requested by gaga herself to be live signing, as she dislikes the idea of lyp sync through a movie, so Bradley had to take musical classes for over a year, so he could achieve the voice that he has now

[@g2growcya]

Joao Santos also the concert parts throughout were filmed at Gagas actual concerts

[@sheidee3551]

They apparently went to music festivals and asked for slots, but for the purpose of secrecy of the film, the volume of speakers were turned down.

[@amazonwarlord]

They did the same in Les Miz as well if I recall correctly. I love that dedication to the craft.

[@chasenichols9372]

I’m the 666th like 👿

[@rva]

Ok oops it was all recorded live. Holy shmokes. Sounds purrrrfffeecct 💓😍 Pps. I am totally obsessed with this song and film. 3 times at the cinema...and counting

[@hugurkids9528]

Amen sister to your reaction. I haven’t been this excited about a movie in years. Sooooooo good!

[@truelovetrueblood]

I feel the exact same way! It was amaaaazing

[@Wiley_Coyote]

I could see doubting Cooper was live. But you can definitely tell Gaga was live. If that was studio recorded and dubbed, the engineer would have to be hella genius to get that mix of background noise, echo and breathing. I'm sure there was plenty of post recording sweetening though. Even Gaga doesn't turn that down.

[@Chrizzy77]

..and now the Davina Michelle cover. :)

[@fleur8886]

What??!! They recorded it live?!!! Just.. wow!!!

[@eugenegrewing2587]

These vocals were not done in a studio. Lady Gaga insisted that they recorded it live during filming. She refuses to lip-sync if she doesn’t have to. There’s no lip syncing here. Bradly Cooper also does all of his own guitar playing in the movie.

[@AndrewJSimpson]

Just come from the Movie and the version in the film and the version on KZbin is different. There's no violin or heavy accompaniment that you hear here @ 3:10 in the film. Definitely sounded better in the studio.

[@m2772]

not

[@ThatsSoKatie44]

The movie was all live but the music videos were from the studio!

[@PantsuMaster]

Andrew Simpson That’s not a foking violin.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

Shes does a great job of portraying a stage-frightened person even though she's far from being one in real life.

[@crash406]

That was probably because she may have been just a bit outside of her comfort zone. Of that's the case, it was to her advantage

[@SunflowerSpotlight]

I agree! I thought “man she looks like she’s trying not to barf.” 😂 Such a good job! It made it easier to empathize and think, “Oh man I’d be freaking out too!” In fact, I covered my eyes a second before she did, and I still have that instinct every time I watch it, lol! There’s a certain kind of coping mechanism where you do the hard thing (don’t freeze or run) but then after, you do freak out, lol. Like if your car is starting to spin, you correct and get safe, and only then, you FREAK OUT. I feel like it’s a mini-episode of “Oh my gosh I got through that! I have to keep it together for this next bit. You can do it, just sing!!” Those little subtle details of how she played it were really very useful in getting into her character.

[@stevetimman]

As a singer/performer, yes, she is in her absolute comfort zone. But remember this. They had MINIMAL stage time to do these shots with "Shallow", and she is....Acting also. So there is an element of stress and unfamiliarity for her that comes through on camera. Not to mention the fact that she and Ally had that trepidation factor with her "looks" and Gaga went absolute minimal makeup through most of the move....my interpretation.

[@MrHws5mp]

Yeah, the first time I saw this footage I thought "okay, there you have it: she CAN act". That look at the end, like "WTF just happened?" is golden.

[@padacia]

Hi. Just to fill you in about a fact in the production of the film. All the singing in the film was recorded live, not "studio generated".

[@rva]

Wow superb!

[@garywtyler]

@@rva AND not only that, he took on the rasp in his speaking voice because it would be more like Sam Elliott's voice, who played his older brother in the film.

[@katherineclairesantos7739]

Always loved Lady Gaga, great reactions... lavit!

[@darkphoenix474]

These music videos, apart from The Shallow, are the studio versions though

[@shelly49]

darkphoenix474 no they’re not. Have you not seen the movie?

[@andreacollins3204]

I cried so much to this song!!! And then I saw the film and I’m still crying. And it’s weeks later. The story touches my soul and my family. Much love from Ireland 🇮🇪🇮🇪❤️

[@rva]

💜🧡🙌

[@wes8798]

The reason why they do not harmonize well is that in the movie she does not rehearse before the time.

[@garywtyler]

Yes, he caught her totally flat footed! She sings this to him in a parking lot the night after they met, and he has his 'people' bring her back stage at his concert, he starts singing the song, introduces her, and they push her in front of this huge crowd for the first time, and a star is born.

[@ayvidyan]

Nooo don't spoil her the movie!! 😂

[@jasdancer20]

@@garywtyler if you listen to interviews w lady gaga and bradley, "a star is born" actually in the *end* scene, and lady gaga/ Allie looks at the camera for the first time in the whole film! interesting

[@Jakerski]

I went to see this movie three times, because I loved the acoustics and how loud the music was, apart from the storyline. I got huge shivers which brought up,tears because of Gaga’s vocals. This movie‘s going to be timeless

[@bebebubut6869]

Crazy epic chemistry. Their performance is so lit, it's burning me. Can't get enough of these two. 🔥🔥🔥

[@urqueenari]

I still can't believe Clint Eastwood questioned her placement in the film. Lady Gaga is such a raw talent.

[@ScarlettRaven666]

I get chills when gaga sings the chorus.

[@hopeworldd_7]

This movie broke me , i love how she hides herself but then she get's on stage and enjoys the whole thing and let's those vocals fly out ,i cried and that's not even the sad part of the movie lol , her voice is just amazing and shows emotion (':

[@PantsuMaster]

BRADLEY TOOK VOCAL TRAINING JUST FOR THIS MOVIE! I'M PRETTY SURE HE SANG LIVE.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

I like the moment she punches through spontaneously hits the one note @ starting with "I'm on the deep end..."

[@charis1516]

Gaga acutally told him some time ago that she will make that film with him if he takes vocal classes and actually will be able to sing that live :). I think knowing that makes it much more touching and authentic... I love it!

[@victoriaa2218]

You were absolutely spot on about their connection, they got on so well and they would constantly say that in the interviews. I look forward to your cover, I hope you do Shallow because of that belting part, I can't do it so I live vicariously through her.

[@rva]

💓😊🎵🎵🎧

[@mishmila0167]

Just want to mention, it's hard not to notice Bradley's sparkly eyes every time he looks at her. Either great acting but there was some feeling behind it. A love story either in friendship or otherwise I don't know..hard for me not to notice.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

Bradley Cooper said that his voice performance was a tribute to Kris Kristofferson and Sam Elliot as he was aiming for a voice like the both of them.

[@christiansabeliever]

He drew inspiration from Eddie Vedder for this role too.

[@kaseybryant_]

Her reaction + facial expressions are so pure, especially during Gaga's parts. I felt the same way!!

[@Lara-ox8uk]

i love when you randomly hit high notes

[@rva]

Bing! 💜

[@rivaldoroberts9966]

Saaame😍😍

[@nataliajimenez3227]

In the movie the vocals where all live. Bradley can really sing, it’s not “studio generated”. He took vocal lessons, but in an interview they said that the first time he sang with Gaga she was really impressed. Thank you for reacting, have a lovely day!

[@carruthers97jc]

Yeah, they sang live and just mastered for individual song releases afterwards. Not actually studio generated 😀 Gaga insisted 😂

[@Steroid1363]

Since your name is Jake, I know youre not kevin. Are you kevin?

[@carruthers97jc]

@@Steroid1363 No I'm not Kevin 😂

[@troyp9485]

Jake C Gaga knew what they needed to do to make this music work.

[@irocksixx]

Every man cringing because their girlfriends are attempting this song.....LOL....but yeah this is the new royal couple and most perfect. My boyfriend and I are singers and I have to convince him to attempt this duet together haha

[@renaway549]

Sooo... how'd it go? Did he agree yet?

[@jeffbrown5934]

Here's my opinion after watching this movie last night, Bradley Cooper is like a modern day Johnny Cash, Lady GaGa is his June Carter. Although this movie to me ends on a sad note, she is the reason he tries to change his life. This is an amazing movie, and to me, a modern day Cash/Carter love song.

[@hayleydunne8938]

Been to see it three times at the cinema and this scene made me blub like a baby. Easily went straight to my top 5 films of all time. It really hasn't received what is should have done so far in awards season but we all love it and that's what matters. I liked watching this because I wish wish wish I could have the feeling of watching it for the first time again. ❤

[@spacewinter]

This album has such well written and emotional songs. Even love songs from major artists aren't that compelling.

[@girldownunder9043]

I agree. It's a fantastic album the songs are incredible. I'm totally addicted

[@SusieQinNewOrleansLA504]

I'm a singer and I can't control myself from singing...no way I ever listen to this song without the urge to belt it out with them.

[@CatherineGrace101]

Can you react to “Always Remember Us This Way?” Lady Gaga just posted the music video on her channel.

[@moomoopuppy5810]

The first time I saw it, I totally wished they were married IRL.

[@nisrine3362]

Lol sameee💔💔💔

[@TRMoura1]

Loved your reactions! Those shivers and emotions got me on the exact same parts 😂

[@mchotsie4723]

This film was FANTASTIC 😳😳😳

[@Zoidd_Bergg]

Bradley is such an amazing guy, he learned to play guitar and piano and took singing lessons just to play a character in his own film

[@lexid9681]

Its not studio generated at all. They recorded it live. I love this though.

[@klayers1555]

Bradley spent a year working with Willy Nelson’s son on his vocal, learning the guitar and general stagecraft and performance. He actually worked to drop both his speaking and singing voice about an octave from his “normal” voice and it just kills as a result. And Gaga’s performance is so natural it’s just incredible.

[@bardockofalecido]

Loved the way she smiled/reacted at 4:04

[@desiraevang]

I just love the song so much. Makes me cry every time. Their voices ugh just so good 😭😭😭 Gaga is iconic! And Bradley’s voice just so good

[@JG.Artistry]

she even went makeup free the whole movie!

[@scifigeek6515]

It was her own idea to do that, and to go back to her natural hair color. I think she's gorgeous like that. ☺️

[@florenciamarie9758]

Scifi Geek it was actually Bradley’s idea if you watch the interviews. She had a bit of makeup on but Bradley insisted that it was that way as he wanted the movie to be as raw as possible.

[@TYBFP]

In my opinion the finest vocalist/showman (woman) in the world today.

[@shannonshuck8667]

Yes, I love Gaga and I love Bradley but your vocals are amazing!!! I would love to learn from you!

[@hailey-jr9pq]

You bring me genuine laughs every video!! Just by you and your realness!!

[@rva]

♥️☺

[@allenmaxerscalata6401]

Congrats for having a 200k subscribers ((: Please react to Demi's "Father Live" thanks

[@andreacollins3204]

Allen Maxers Calata oh god noooooo that song destroys my soul 😭😭😭😭

[@JuzSayWooo]

Please watch the full movie 😍😍😍 It is really good

[@cholo.olalia]

*The Intro Was💜👌😍*

[@juliusmostajo3918]

I didn't watch that movie for now but when I saw the music video of shallow I felt that the movie was so fuckng good and I want to watch it!! 😭😭

[@WoncoTheSane]

Oscars Oscars Oscars… did I miss that video? lol Love Rebecca anyway! Always amazing!

[@Nazaba09]

I didn’t like this song when I first heard it but when I saw the movie it made sense and now I can’t listen to it without crying.

[@princesspippy7]

This just makes me want to see the movie again. So good!

[@gebusan3548]

Cried again...regardless of how many times I’ve heard and seen this❤️

[@BryannaHitchcock]

I hope you really enjoy the movie. It will rip your heart out in the best way, based on your reactions to the songs. My favorite from the album is Is That Alright.

[@mariac231075]

The movie is AMAZING, I hope you watched it since this.

[@mirat8485]

AAH CAN YOU REACT TO MARINA AND THE DIAMONDS' NEW SONG WITH LOUIS FONSI?? It's really good!!!

[@projecteyecandy4057]

YES

[@dianahernandez8688]

*Luis Fonsi

[@hannahbridges1708]

Have you heard Lady Gaga's Julie Andrews tribute!? If not you should react to that if you haven't, because wow

[@MsCammy17]

Good lorddddddd this soundtrack is beyond perfect !!!! 😩😩😩

[@cybertelevision]

Hi! ..... I almost did not watch your review of this event, this happening, this SONG, SHALLOW,, because I thought it would upset me too much if you didn't appreciate all of the wonderfulness of each nuance, breath and all that is embodied with it. You have indeed 'GOT IT' ,, your perception of the song going by so fast, because you love it so much, was such a wonderful thing to be cognizant of and share with your audience. What an excellent job you did here, more like just letting your head and heart free here! 💞

[@rva]

Thanks my sweet. Seen it three times. Such an extraordinary song.!!💜🎅💟

[@cybertelevision]

@@rva 'I hear you'; thank you my sweet for your lovely reply.

[@mychell75]

Listen to I'll Never Love Again from the soundtrack. It brought me to tears.

[@magneticnena8766]

I've become a fan of you since I saw this video, seriously. You're amazing! should post more reacts to Lady Gaga at different genres.Regards from Argentina 💓

[@RG-hf4et]

They weren't on par because the characters Jack and Ally never sang together before. The vocals should NOT have been perfect for the song...Ally was caught off guard and did not want to perform.

[@Defensewinsall]

play at .50% if you wanna laugh your ass off so damn funny i cant breathe

[@danhuff8446]

I have always been a fan of GaGa's vibrato when when she holds on to notes. Just like a talented guitar player who knows how to get just a tad more emotion out of the instrument with vibrato, GaGa does the same.... It is always so good!!!

[@lohrestorms6687]

I get shivers every time I watch the video for this, and the one for always remember us this way. Gaga is amazing and so underrated. I haven’t watched the film yet but I’m certainly gonna check it out once it’s on the internet. Have you ever heard achy breaky heart by Billy Ray Cyrus and Miley Cyrus? It’s amazing you should defo go listen to it.

[@davepowell3001]

So enjoyed your reactions to Lady Gaga scenes from “A Star Is Born”. Now, for one more, entirely different side of Lady Gaga please react to her performance at the 2015 Super Bowl where she, and the entire performance absolutely KILLS it singing our National Anthem! Thank you!

[@yuuko6993]

React to more Panic! At the disco plssss

[@emelsvik]

DezzeR Mine yessss

[@fortniteclips7635]

the vocals on that aren’t amazing tho she should be reacting to stuff like this and my heart will go on

[@MinaF99]

Yes, thank you for this one. I guess I’m the star is born fact parade, but all the singing in the movie is done live btw

[@MinaF99]

And remember to wear waterproof mascara in the cinema

[@rva]

Hahahahahaha omg. Haloween is over

[@portalkey5283]

Woohoo! You did it! I love your reaction! I now wish you can do a video after you watch A Star is Born but that'll mean going into the realm of film review. (But if you do, please do one for Bohemian Rhapsody.)

[@rva]

Ok sure will do 😊🧡💜

[@sluggosloan]

The movie and the music was so powerful to me. I was in a funk for weeks. I still am! lol It's just magical stuff. I don't know any other way to describe it. = )

[@DaveRucci]

RVA. CONGRATS ON 200000 subs! ♥️

[@rva]

Thanks Dave son sub to this man!

[@DaveRucci]

Rebecca Vocal Athlete yes please! 😂😉👍🏻

[@devikajoseph7660]

Yes! Just what I asked for! Thank you so much :) I didn't watch the movie but this song and I'll Never Love Again makes me tear up.. Always. And congratulations on the 200 k :) Edit: oh yes... His interview in French had me swooning. 😍 And please do a cover on Shallow :)

[@rva]

Yeah I drooled a little haha

[@girldownunder9043]

OMG you have to go and see this movie. It is so good, but it will devastate you. Best movie I've seen in a long time

[@chloelenpilapil55]

I died. Their voices really are distinct and have their unique harmony to them. Gaga ❤

[@Shavinism]

Play button!!! I believe lady Gaga insisted that all songs are recorded live btw, not studio, but maybe I'm wrong. He's a handsome man, Bradley.

[@rva]

He's a stallion

[@Klempner]

Your reactions are the cutest and sweetest thing I've seen. ever.

[@SnarkierThan-U-R]

I saw the movie and it was absolutely incredible.

[@stoovn4368]

I have been LOVING your reactions to this movie! Please react to the full ASIB SOUNDTRACK!!! You can find a (Without Dialogue) Soundtrack Version on spotify or you can just skip the dialogue! Thanks!

[@stoovn4368]

You should also react to LADY GAGA BEST LIVE VOCALS video or maybe even her CARPOOL KARAOKE video with James Corden :333 Love ur video

[@rva]

Thanks lovely 💓😊

[@HoraDeJugarJueguitos]

You now a singer is really unique when he/she makes you cry at least once in their lifetime, awesome movie guys Bradly and Steph really had a masterfull performance.

[@nickels4682]

Did you see her win her academy award for the song?

[@peattiff2334]

Your amazing Rebecca first video ive seen of yours. Brilliant x

[@rva]

💓🧡💛

[@sarasamehfci]

Wooooow I fell in love with song a time ago I wished you could listen to it too

[@wldnemesis]

Music to my eyes

[@krisztinagermanotta7142]

Gaga is the new queen of pop❤️❤️

[@Mischa16178]

That song is pure sex. I love the build up and emotions put in. But that’s probably the effect from seeing the movie. Anyway. One of my favourite songs at the moment.

[@stylecollective-qt9um]

LOVE watching the analysis from an actual singer ! Just as an aside, after seeing the film, we come to know that she sang the bare bones melody of this song to him 1-2 nights before , and he pulled her onto the stage to sing it in entirety impromptu. So in essence, her character is feeling her way through his arrangement. It makes the chorus so much more impactful: it's as if they are reaching out to each other in a dimly lit room, and eventually they not only connect but fall into lockstep. Powerful stuff, indeed ❤️

[@rva]

💓😊

[@nickels4682]

Am I spending too much time with you? I don’t know.....Who cares....😂

[@w.b.t.127]

Love your "R" reactions and smile.

[@LyamNeal-VESPER]

This song is clearly a goosebumps machine. Incredibly beautiful... And that vocals... ! By the way, I've made a FRENCH VERSION of this song, it would be great if you come take a look! Thank you so much! ✨

[@minonadam1077]

can you please react to "Kelly Clarkson - Shallow (Lady Gaga, Bradley Cooper Cover)" ?She did really a great job

[@yuuko6993]

React to more Panic! At the disco plssss

[@AnnaliseRaquel]

I would love to see your cover of “shallow”. You have such a beautiful voice!

[@rva]

Ahhh thanks darling 💓

[@Bruce1983]

you're the vocal coach? really after that performance. who are you kidding

[@babiekoala7643]

Congrats on 200K . May u reach millions

[@rva]

Awww maybe one day lol

[@babiekoala7643]

@@rva no it's for real as long as you give ur best😊

[@The_Raff_G]

Thanks so much for doing these :) I haven’t seen the film yet but I really hope to soon. Enjoy watching it on the 7th November!! Let us know if you enjoy it I’m sure you will :)

[@zavremym1172]

Gaga's awesome, and her live performance are worth watching. Maybe you could do one, it's nice (at least for me) to see you trying her vocals because of Gaga's flexible vocals and techniques. Thanks for another nice video!

[@mariellarung9207]

Please react to Gagas Superball Halftime and her karaoke Carpool please

[@salsaucedo]

I totally love this song more the other one "I'll never love again" but they are both awesome songs. Lady Gaga does a wonderful job on this song beautiful voice and she looks amazing all natural looking and not all flamboyant as she always appears.

[@rva]

Agree 💓😁🎶

[@inmyReputation-Era]

I honestly think she's at her most beautiful this way.

[@salsaucedo]

@@inmyReputation-Era totally agree

[@uptries]

You can’t judge Gaga in a bad way

[@e116ene]

Rebecca i love the way that you show your emotions to everyone watching these clips, it feels like we get to see into your very soul its so beautiful 😘

[@alphasxsignal]

Yep it is a game changer for the both of them and I hope they hold on to each other for the ride. The need each other at this point i think.

[@sallydeb]

Yes. There are multiple film partnerships in history - remember Spenser Tracy and Katherine Hepburn? And they were not romantically involved if I'm not mistaken.