Voice Teacher Reacts to Rose of BLACKPINK - If It Is You

[@mizanorizam8184]

YG, you should hire this guy.

[@crazy.autumn]

Hahahaha. Same thought

[@twicemomo383]

Ahahhahaha

[@memes6587]

why? so he ruin his career too?

[@memes6587]

@Leo Lion ?? yg avrage salary is 35k Per year

[@memes6587]

@Leo Lion and out of the big 3 YG each year have the most percentage of people leaving it

[@cojjiehassiopeia6963]

After watching a couple of your videos, I can't stand any other "vocal coach" who call themselves "coaches" but talk about nothing but shoes, jackets, and the lights lol =)))))

[@annalam1701]

Cojjie Hassiopeia oh god same, i once watched a "vocal coach"'s video, i expected sth more and all he talk abt is the mv, the clothes, the visual

[@Edu_Silver21]

Have you seen Tara Simon Studios? she's kinda new on youtube and in my opinion she's killing it too ^^

[@lunaproductions13]

Wow, I haven't encountered any of those

[@agusttinasol5]

OMG yes.

[@deeznuts4703]

Cojjie Hassiopeia agree. And especially if they react to kpop, they just talk about the language or looks, not the song or voices what is the main point

[@ManitoBittar]

Thank you for such an honest opinion. She’s been criticized for her technique since the day she debuted, and although she‘d be better off making some adjustments as you said, I appreciate the fact that you valued her uniqueness and how important that is for the market she’s in. I’d also like you to check out Rosé’s voice in GDragon’s song “Without You” purely for your analysis (although I’d love to hear even more about this since I know you’ll have way more to talk about once you listen to the difference) She recorded that song before she officially debuted so her technique was a lot different. /end lengthy comment

[@user-xm3tk6iq6t]

Carlos B i wouldn't recommend "without you", it was full of autotune, he should analyze one of their debut songs or just one of their covers

[@oohdiana]

@@user-xm3tk6iq6t but her voice now is different from the trainee days. I really like her voice on without you. Now, for me, it's seems really forced...

[@cupidream9702]

oohdianax yes I agree. I say it’s yg trying to make bom 2.0 when rose’s voice is already good

[@tiaraandham5831]

And also her cover of helsey's eyes closed please

[@Kanon-cg9ts]

lol bom voice has never change don't stop dreaming guys that yg changing their voices lol as they aged ofcourse the voice will change a bit. but still bom and rose voice is unique. stop the blaming that yg changes their voice lol thats their style of singing.

[@taylaroberts]

I feel so happy like hanging out with a friend watching your videos. And seeing you grow 20k in like 4 days is just blowing my mind. So well deserved. I learn so much from you 👌

[@Cancer0202]

Fr, the last time I was on his channel, which was like 2 days ago, he has 61k subscribers but now he has over 70k. He deserves it

[@ttteacupp2920]

And now he has a hundred 💯

[@O0992-s6o]

[King of masked singer] can't miss 'the East invincibility' defensive stage Love never dies 20180408 kzbin.info/www/bejne/bHLSdWiXiNuLj6s

[@angelahale7914]

To me, Rose has what I call a "country music twang" to her voice.

[@hello_teej]

Angela Hale OMG that’s what I’ve been saying, but when I bring it up no one truly understands the message I’m trying to convey. Her stylistic flair really made me gravitate towards her and made me wonder how country is going mainstream as well.

[@angelahale7914]

Yes, it is pretty rare in Kpop. That is what makes her really stand out.

[@inquisitvem6723]

agree and during "Whistle" she sounded like a country music artist during the acoustic guitar sound...loved it.

[@NaNa-ou1sg]

It sounds more Japanese like to me.

[@_H.A.N.N.A_]

Also she is from Australia so she has a accent in her korean

[@stephaniemaranon9805]

I love your constructive criticism. Another reason why her vibrato and the way she sings is weird and hard to you is because that's not the way she regularly sings. She was trained to sing differently(I think she also changed her voice to sound more cutest). I kinda hope she sings in her regular voice cuz it sounds like she would have powerhouse vocals but this style really suits blackpink songs. I also hope you can react to more sohyang in the future.

[@littlejeka]

Her voice was deff modified, there's that one song with gd that is completely different as to how she sounds now

[@qtpr8675]

Jeka it could be the company or it could be Rosé herself that wanted to sing that way. It's a very debatable subject

[@katarzynab2233]

Jeka she recorded that song 6 years ago. It's natural that her voice changed a little. YG is not forcing her to sing with cute voice. Listen to how she talks, she sounds the same as when she sings.

[@qtpr8675]

K Agree also maybe Rosé herself wanted to be that way.

[@ashleecameron3458]

I think it might be the korean language itself effecting it. When Rose speaks in English she sounds a lot more natural and her tone is deeper, this is reflected in her English sung songs as well. When she speaks korean her voice is a lot more cutesy and fluffy, which reflects in her korean sung vocals as well. Of course you’re gonna sound more natural in your most comfortable language and Rose is still mastering Korean, this could be why she sounds more unnatural when singing in korean.

[@katherinerochester1010]

Yeah. Her company may have told her to keep that tone. Before debut, she has a normal tone.

[@unicjjkgg3953]

Katherine Rochester she find her style, more than 4 years have pass since she participated in gd song, she was only 6 month of being a trainee, her voice obviously change and find her style

[@katherinerochester1010]

Unicjjk Gg Precisely what I said. She changed her tone. Most likely with the help of vocal coaches at YG. They want a unique sound. I just hope her voice doesn’t tire out like Britney Spears because it isn’t her natural voice.

[@rosannapark3295]

That's her tone. It's either you like it or hate it. Main vocalists in YG are taught the same and they are encouraged to find their own style, and she found her style and she likes it. She's obviously getting better and better but nobody would want to make a note on that cause the main issue for you guys is she's ruining her voice. News flash: it's still crystal clear and smooth af and even better than last yr

[@JL-lm2vr]

@@rosannapark3295 chill. No one is hating on her voice, people are just worried.

[@rosannapark3295]

@@JL-lm2vr There's nothing to worry about

[@hagralyn]

Rosé sends me chills when she have those vibrato and high notes. Definitely her voice is very unique

[@PrincessGarnetXVII]

This guy is so great at what he does; I’m one of his students now and he helped me so much with just one lesson. So happy you’re getting the support you deserve, Sam!

[@mele3721]

this is one of my favorite covers by her.. I don't know much about voice techniques nor I am a coach but I really like the vibrato in her voice!

[@k-day4243]

She has such an unique voice

[@rid1986]

Rosé is new in the industry but she is doing a great job (that video is just one year after debut )every artist that i know who works on his voice keeps getting better and better. I love how she sounds . Because she has a different voice people keep saying bad technique but it's just she has a unique tone that i enjoy listening to . Thank u for making this Video.

[@shairaivy2507]

this is the most honest vocal reaction video i have ever watched. kudos to you.

[@elnathanchung7379]

I really like Rosé's voice. To all that criticizes (maybe unintentional) Rosé technique or her stability, do some research. A lot of people confirmed that dancing and singing poorly doesn't mean that the singer doesn't have bad vocal technique. Check out BlackPink's encore stage for Ddu du ddu du, she's doing very well and she's 101% stable.

[@Darfaultner]

I love, I love, I love her fast vibrato. I love the harmonics it produces, it is so rich and rings so much. I wish there was more of her. I wish so much. I actually can't stop listening to this. WHY IS IT NOT ON SPOTIFY???

[@aikosinag17]

When she sings you can feel the emotion in her voice. That’s what makes her unique as a fan of her, I know she’s got a wide vocal range. But of course when you are in a group you have position. But when I listen to her sing solo. She makes me cry she can interpret song differently depending on what she felt. She learned the hardest part about singing, putting emotions that not only you can feel but also the audience.

[@keinihc]

It is so fun to watch Reaction Videos of Rosé like yours. It was entertaining to see people from different races and cultures appreciate Rosé’s talent. Please look forward to seeing Rosé’s other performances and support her. Thank you!

[@peekyoin8347]

Rosé really has a very unique voice

[@GaladrielOfLorien]

Here's a non kpop recommendation with impressive vocals: _Female metal singers (expectation vs reality)_ (seriously though, time to react to some metal, those vocalists have impressive set of pipes on them 😁)

[@anbar]

YES

[@ivanacutiepiez5720]

YESS!!

[@inquisitvem6723]

Baby Metal girls!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@aaaaprilj]

Galadriel of Lorien uh-uh

[@praetoriatormont3502]

you can't imagine how happy i am to hear that you don't find her voice or technique odd as a professional because i can't even count the amount of times when i saw people trash talkin her saying that she sounds like a dying duck & everything

[@obsessioninrivulets4769]

“She has a very interesting tone to her voice..I don’t know how to explain it” This is me every day. 😂 I’m definitely not skilled in voice but I felt this way hearing her voice. And most of my fav singers give me this reaction. I love unique tones sooo much! I could tell you were intrigued by her voice from that compilation you I reacted to previously 😊

[@elleaz738]

I love Rosé' voice with unique and very attractive tone.

[@marlondavidbetancururrego8597]

I still remember that around two weeks ago we were around 40k subscribers, now there’s more than 250k and it keeps increasing. Definitely love your videos!!

[@tikarenzhi]

Sam Johnson to 100k subs!

[@keinihc]

I love her voice so much! I love everything about Rosé. She's not just a singer, she's multi-talented.

[@AsianTankPilot]

Everyone seems to love Rosé’s unique voice and I agree with all you are saying. She’s still young and it would awesome to have a teacher like you helping her.

[@usgnik]

Another great video from you. Rosé has a very unique voice but she still has space to improve. Overall it's very good to listen to her. Please react to Yuju from Gfriend, she's one of the best vocalist of this new generation in kpop.

[@lillycamp8892]

Her cover of stand up for love!

[@yerfdys8192]

He did react to Yuju in one of his Kpop videos. I think it was on the best high notes one.

[@ashygfriend6784]

please do a full reaction to Yuju's vocals, she's amazing

[@graceshaw6792]

YES

[@hagralyn]

After watching several reaction videos, yours is one of my fave. No sugarcoating and Trashtalking.. simply a constructive criticism and no biases on Rosé's voice.. hopefully there are more youtbers like you

[@eckee]

After some months I realized your analysis was pretty accurate. She now sings with a more opened voice so to speak, and she sounds even better imo, I was already a fan of her. Thanks for the video, you’re great. Even a non-musician like me could understand everything you said.

[@ghaissanie]

people disagree with her technique while singing but i love it. it sounds unique and she is really charming

[@hagralyn]

I love that Rosé is sending her own version when singing If it is You. As if she's going thru with it in her life

[@yeseniagarcia7539]

I love Rose's voice so much, thank you for reviewing her :)

[@Valentinafr99]

My beautiful Rosie 💙 thank u Sam

[@keinihc]

I am glad and proud to see Rosé doing her best in every performance she did. Please watch more of Rosé related videos.

[@KpopUnniesUwU]

If you watch the lyrics, you may felt hurt and cried!!! It's so emotional! Love Rosé's unique voice omg!!

[@chenashlynx7477]

You are my favourite vocal coach on KZbin, I found out about you last night and I can't stop watching your videos, you're explanations are so detailed

[@jacqui3230]

I was honestly waiting for this so..THANKS

[@JOJi_xcl]

Its like her rookie year... now she way way better

[@emilyvu2757]

Please react to red velvet Wendy’s Halo cover

[@kookieluv9338]

OMG YESSS PLSSS here's the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZoKbp5eJgMZ8bpI

[@chescadelacruz9980]

Or her in this same program too.

[@zharyraizenswift7374]

pleaseee guysss

[@ffupelffuh5230]

Joy's too in this program😭 her voice is just so- yall know

[@keykey8675]

yes , please

[@Silversaku]

Seriously Sam, you deserve to get monetized for your videos! I hope you will get the adds soon. I will rewatch every video again, because; 1. Super interesting! 2. You deserve the money. 3. I learned so much things from your videos! Thanks again for this video. The way you explain something and how you analyze the video is really at a very high level. I enjoy it very much. (I am also sorry, if I wrote something wrong. English is not my first language :c)

[@xiuminist]

please react to jonghyun vocals :(

[@beyondsingularity2243]

Yes:(

[@safiyaturner-khan9249]

yup :((( that would make me cry aswell

[@SamJohnsonVoice]

It's coming soon!

[@animegurl23579]

A lot of people are telling you to react to Y SI Fuera Ellla, but as a huge Jonghyun stan, I would honestly recommend a different song. Jonghyun has a very distinct, unique voice, and hes a singer songwriter as well, and he wrote 99% of his solo music, and I feel like the best way to get a real feel for his voice is to listen to something he actually composed himself. Y Si Fuera Ella is great, but its a cover of a Spanish song that he rewrote the Korean lyrics for, so his unique mannerisms and little vocalizations he always adds into his own music isn't present. If you really want to get a taste for his style, I'd recommend something like live performances of She Is, Deja Boo, Beautiful Tonight, or Playboy. I think this is a great video you could react to: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eIOcZHV6iNGmjqs Hopefully you read this lol

[@StoryBroken]

@@animegurl23579 hallelujah it's a good one to

[@roseforlyfe3033]

Thank you for your reaction! I feel like she was in pain whenevee she sing, she transfrom me all of her broken that got me emotional. That's why I love her voice😍😍

[@rimandriux]

Roseeee ♥️ It'd be really cool if you could react to Jonghyun's "Y si fuera ella" ✨

[@madridenostwinkyb.5259]

Thank you for your reaction on BlackPink Rosé. Her voice is so unique and angelic. It really gets me emotional whenever I hear her sing songs.

[@mandyshe7289]

Your the best coach reactor ever! You explain every detail even a non singer can understand. I love you!

[@buuguss]

Sorry sam johnson i can only hear in your intro: hi i'm renata bliss and i'm your freestyle dance teacher

[@SamJohnsonVoice]

You're hearing me correctly then

[@Pumpkin0_0]

xD

[@visa8803]

Omg same xD

[@kuein]

OMMGGG I just noticed that I’m dead 🤣

[@graceshaw6792]

SKSJEKEKKEKE

[@albumintroduceupleaseu2064]

After watching all of ur vids, I can say that ur the best reactor who gives honest opinions about their singing as a vocal trainer... just wow

[@lisaoppa5784]

Every singer have their flaws and areas to improve on, that includes rosé. But her voice is so unique and distinctive. She’s able to convey the emotions into her singing so well. I really felt the emotions when she sang this song as someone who never studied vocals/singing/music before. That’s what sets her apart from other kpop vocalists. Overall, she has a great voice and I love listening to her sing.😍

[@nada-yy7hx]

I love how sam say what he want and he kept real and honest

[@dx-tu3qt]

I've been TELLING people this forever. She changed her technique, but it's not detrimental to her health. Rose is a good singer because she knows her limits. That's why she never goes up higher. It's hard for her to maintain that voice while going up high because she can really damage herself.

[@hopexiong8582]

Yasss thank you for reacting to her!! I definitely agree with a lot of what you said! Can't wait for more videos!

[@kpopthenewmusicrevolution8354]

Park Bom is coming back please react to her You And I Single please! All blackjacks please support this so that Mr. Sam will notice this. It's been a long time since we've heard about Park Bom. She has also have a very unique voice. Thank you.

[@davividavid]

Her ability to convey the emotion of the song and the beauty of her unique style, including that fast vibrato, are what make her so exceptional. I hope she doesn’t change a thing.

[@tiermax1629]

She does has a very unique voice, and it’s what makes her Rosé

[@yosiee]

I like her very much because of that different tone I think is so beautiful and refreshing, thanks for reacting to Rosé !!

[@blondy2257]

You should check out blackpink covering Miguel’s sure thing! It’s live and really good

[@lizkarisalazar9986]

Si!! x2

[@vivienvn]

I love your reaction, constructive and real, and knowledgeable

[@pinkdagger]

I just binged a bunch of your videos, and I don't know jack about singing, but I love learning this way (as well as *your* old singing videos). Thanks for sharing and keep up the great work. edit; Takeuchi Miyu recently garnered a lot of attention for being a more skilled musician and vocalist than the J/Kpop idol position she was auditioning for (Produce 48). Especially considering the AKB Jpop artists don't receive any vocal training from their agency so they need to seek it out themselves and they have a reputation for being very nasally, I'm curious of what you'd think of her techniques and other Japanese artists too. Miyu has her own KZbin channel.

[@melinafred5788]

You act and kind of sound like a proud but honest dad! And I like that. It’s good that you give advise and compliments.

[@sloangary1995]

She was classically trained. You’re great❤️

[@extrachickenwang8062]

tysm for being honest like the only vocal coach i can stand

[@chaemunkblinkblink1796]

I am a huge fan of Blackpink. Rose has the best voice I’ve ever heard.

[@Feuerkopfilein]

Thanks for reacting to my suggestion, much appreciated :)

[@Brooklynhanse]

Btw can you please react to Jonghyun- Y sí fuera ella

[@mikkiphunglimboo9676]

·B · H· Can u please do it🌼

[@mafercanul1822]

Porfavorrrrrrrrrr

[@hannahk7691]

Please let Sam know Jonghyun has passed away. We don’t want him to get hate posts if he said something not to someone’s liking.

[@bnrfreeonekiss348]

Yassss I waiting for agesss😭

[@ithnkyn]

i have beem requesting it for a while now please react to it..

[@n03liaa_]

I love the simple fact that Sam doesn't care about the language he's listening to, he's just enjoying music. The world should learn about this. Love your work, keep going like this!

[@richardhague801]

it's interesting you say it's almost a character voice because this isn't her natural voice. there are videos of her vocals prior to entering YG Entertainment. Hani from EXID is another exceptional vocalist who has a vocal style within her group but sounds different singing naturally.

[@leenmansour8239]

This is her natural voice

[@anonymous7851]

So refreshing to hear actual feedback and not “reactor” posing as critiques just saying how amazing all Kpop idols are for click bait

[@nasya.x5030]

Can you film a react to Solji-"Maria" cover on King of masked singer? She won this show 2 times and her vocal voice is really amazing

[@lippiesimps8869]

nasya.x OML SOLJI YASS

[@jennyjessieful]

Rosé made me cry 😭 emotional of the song is so amazing 👌

[@micaela1389]

Thank you so much for appreciating our Rose’s voice, it will be perfect if you could react to Gfriend’s “Yuju cover of stand up for love” she sang it when she was 16 and still was a trainee. ❤️

[@lillycamp8892]

THANK YOU OHMYGOD I THINK I MIGHT HAVE REQUESTED THIS 8 TIMES AT THIS POINT. You're doing God's work

[@salouan6494]

Rosé is love

[@mikelimks]

Check out GDragon’s “Without You”, featuring Rosé when she was only 15 years old before she debuted in Blackpink.

[@DBM1234-d1f]

🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹 *ROSÉ* 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹 THE BEST VOICE OF BLACKPINK

[@sanyadevic4622]

Thank you so much I appreciate this so much! Rosé is my favorite vocalist of all time and my friends always talk about how bad she is at singing. Thank you for calling her a great vocalist that really makes me truly happy to see and expert call her that after all the hate she gets.

[@bangtanseonyeondamn6336]

His intros always make me laugh It’s just- he looks so happy then when the video starts he goes from :D to :^ pFFft

[@saisamiakasiakim9417]

Her voice is really pretty cool, interesting and unique... I feel relax!!!

[@jayleec7180]

React to Monsta X please!!!!! Kihyun (main vocalist) has killer range!!!!!!!!

[@DayWatch]

i adore kihyun and i love his singing but i can already hear sam be like ".......he is really pulling chest voice" (in the lost in a dream clip especially) lol it would be interesting to hear an analysis for sure

[@peachy423]

aaaahhh!!! Thank you!!! I was looking forward to this, i love it

[@peachmingyupie]

I love that Rosé has such a unique tone! Because there's a lot of people on the internet who give her crap for that, I'm absolutely glad to hear a professional opinion on it. Turns out she's not really harming her voice, BUT she can improve on her techniques. Haters can leave her alone now 😂 On another note (😉) I'd love to see you react to Joo Byungjin and Kim Jaehwan's cover of If You (Bigbang) on the same show, King of the Masked Singer! > kzbin.info/www/bejne/f5StoXugmtOMrLM

[@susimi8232]

Forever rosé@i really like her and tq for the reaction....she’s my everything 🥰

[@danaibero7118]

Yes, I have seen the same in Rosé. She has a unique tone, but as you have said, she is under pression and tried to push her distictive tone a lot more, it's not bad, but I'm always in pain when I listen to her because I feel that it some time, her voice will crack.

[@Thomas5k]

I've watched all your videos in the past two days after subscribing. Goddamn, you're making me want to learn to sing.

[@JellyFunVloggers]

I think one of the reasons why her voice is like that is possibly because she grew up in New Zealand / Australia so she adapted the accent from there possibly

[@emmanuellieannefernandez595]

I think she use that style but if u are curious of her real style try to eatch rose with gdragon

[@gordowg1wg145]

What I really like about some singers is that it is the 'flaws' in their singing that makes them special, unique, in a market of averageness. In this instance, the restraint, or limit, in the vibrato compared to what others may have used is what distinguishes it - the 'tenseness' showing the emotional tension of the singer.

[@jadonrowe273]

This Rose’s normal voice comfortable and it just sounds better and she seems more comfortable

[@kaeyer]

This song is literally the best

[@mikek1635]

You really need to analyze Song So Hee. She is a traditional korean folk singer who sings pop songs on this this very show.

[@meerabzaidi9445]

Your reaction videos are one of my favs :))

[@meerabzaidi9445]

❤️

[@franzamora7943]

Please react to yuju King of masked singer "I love you"

[@lillycamp8892]

It would be even better if he did her cover stand up for love

[@lucilleann808]

yes 😊😊

[@keinihc]

BlackPink Rosé is a great artist. She’s like owning the song as if it was hers. She creates a whole new feel and vibe. What more if she has her own SOLO SONG! Can’t wait to see your other reaction videos about BlackPink Rosé

[@alexknauff3467]

i love your videos, you’re my favourite reaction channel because you actually know what you’re talking about and you’re so respectful to the artists. if you have time, could you react to CLC Seunghee’s cover of If I Ain’t Got You?

[@kathleenj.l.delossantos3904]

thank you.. like i was so happy to hear from a music / vocal expert to say Rose' voice is interesting... and you keep praising her T__T im so happy as a blink!

[@yohannamanzanares464]

Please react to gfriend yujus vocals

[@lillycamp8892]

HER COVER OF STAND UP FOR LOVE

[@lucilleann808]

yes please💕💕

[@susanaviana5584]

Yeees💖

[@karindeawijaya1989]

YES PLS

[@madridenostwinkyb.5259]

Can’t wait for Rosé to have her SOLO. It has been 2 years and hopefully she will have it this year! Please look forward and anticipate Rosé Solo too. Thank you!

[@salouan6494]

Rosé is my one my favourite girls in kpop or in general because of many things. But this video is soley based on vocals so let's only talk about that. And may i say i love her vocals especially after watching her live vid of her singing in their concert. She has like 2 vid i don't like , 1 is a live performance vid and we shouldn't really judge her while dancing. And the scond one is like a 60 sec vid where too nasally during a cover. But other times and during performances like these , i prefer her over all other "top" vocalists because she makes me something and reaches her audience. and her and blackpink whether bad or good review always bring the views and they're the most popular girl group among international kpop fans so with that does come a lot of unnecessary hate and criticism.

[@lillycamp8892]

Hi I love your reactions and the time you put into discussing the vocalists' technique! I'd love it if you could do the same with Yuju - Stand up for love It's a vocal practice from when she was around 16, I'd love to hear your thoughts on her range, control, and mixed voice

[@aicha602]

I love her voice so much 😍😍😍

[@seattlebrandon]

Please react to Yuju or Eunha from Gfriend on King of Masked Singer! "I love you" and "I have to forget you"

[@TheRzabcia]

I'm watching some of your videos purely because you're so cute at the beginning an at the ending, but throughout the video you are sooo professional and I can actually understand and learn. Also, that little thing you do at the end with your shoulders is the cutest, keep up a good work bro :)!

[@taehyungiebangtan5647]

Her name is pronounced as Roh-sey 😂 Rosè

[@mel7291]

actually its rosé*

[@mel7291]

@Lana Pearl yh and then after that rosè

[@rudiwesli6846]

So much tense. Her voice is really different and attractive