Walther PDP vs Beretta APX in a 15+1 9mm Showdown

[@damize]

I do own both. I have modified both as well. Both have been fitted with a Sprinco recoil management system. Both have Ameriglo tritium night sights. They also have the same baldr combo lights installed. I have improved the trigger on the Beretta, but the Walther has been untouched. Both pistols are a blast to shoot. As in the review I have made the Walther my main carry gun. You would not go in the wrong direction with either pistol. I feel like the Walther is more refined. I have just recently added a Holosun 507C X2 to the Walther and it has greatly improved its accuracy, plus made me a better shooter than I really am. The same Holosun will be mounted on top of the Beretta, so testing will continue on. At this point, if you have the money Walther all day long. That being said, the Beretta is often the over looked underdog. You will be happy with either choice, I know I am. Take care everyone and keep one in the chamber.

[@Neverknight2]

Get the walther dynamic trigger, it is wonderful. I bought the dpm recoil spring instead of springco How much to u think it helped pdp? I felt the dpm was at least 25% recoil decrease. Was the sprinco about same?

[@tobiasfunke3357]

PDP FTW

[@gemneyetwin6248]

Where you find sights for APX??

[@a.d.c7941]

Great post brother.

[@damize]

@@a.d.c7941 Thank you my friend. Take care.

[@nelsons48]

I own a full size Beretta APX 9mn for about 2 years and love it accuracy and handling, plus having 17 rounds magazine is Awesome. Outstanding video you shared with us, thank you.

[@chadf2169]

I had a 40S&W Beretta APX, but I returned it after a day. Because it had really bad trigger slap. I liked it other than that. Did you experience any trigger slap with your APX? Curious if it was just a issue with the 40

[@nelsons48]

@@chadf2169 no my trigger is OK but I did put in some new upgrade springs inside by Galloway.

[@gemneyetwin6248]

😎😎

[@SwaybackJack]

My APX Centurion doesn't have an Instagram account, so I don't consider its looks relative to other guns. I know that when I shot the APX at my range along side a Glock 19, Walther PPQ and Sig 320, the APX felt best and was $250-375 less expensive. Its an absolute steal in every way.

[@fishfood8719]

True, but if you want optics ready, you would have to buy the Beretta APX RDO. MSRP $550( 500 average online price) and a separate optics plate ($70-$82)Walther gives you 1 free. So equally equipped pistols prices are almost equal. I moving towards optics on my new pistols (over 55yrs eyes), but your right, they are a steal. I have talked myself out of buying one 3 times, even when they were $325. But if I can get an FDE for $350 again, I'll have to buy it.

[@MurderBallad]

@@fishfood8719 new APX A1 looks like it covers all the bases!

[@idonz21]

Agreed. I have both and the APX is my bed side. I think my APX was like $350 only. I was shocked to learn I could've gotten two for the price of one PDP.. Prices have increased now for the APX though.

[@Jamie-pn2xj]

I have both of these pistols and they are both awesome! My son turned 18 and I gave him his pick out of all my pistols and he chose the Beretta APX my loss his gain lol but the good thing is the APX can be bought at a steal it’s hard to believe it’s selling as cheap as it is cuz it’s worth much more!

[@toddparsons2980]

Would like to see a comparison video of the PDP and the new APX A1 Full Size.

[@STF34]

Obviously this is an older video but it would be a better comparison with the new Beretta APX A1 FS vs a Walther PDP FS. The slide serrations now are even more comparable, and both are optics ready from the factory!

[@m1k3_flo]

Original Apx is about the same gun as A1 just with different slide serrations.

[@scottclaiborne5123]

The APX is actually a sweet shooter. Shot one at a range. Very soft recoil and a nice trigger. Plus, it’s truly modular. She’s just a dog. If Beretta goes back to the drawing board for a Gen 2 APX, I’d buy one.

[@gemneyetwin6248]

She's a keeper 😎😎

[@mestevens5756]

There is a new gen 2,

[@gutWrench9mm]

Pdp much better

[@SuperJahJr]

Please do the APX A1 in comparison to the pdp

[@richardoliver1468]

Thank you for your review. When you look at the APX model, I believe it has a few advantages over the PDP. As you mentioned, not only can you change out the grip frames, you can also change out the grips. Beretta has optic mounting plates so that you can add an RDO to their none RDO ready slides. With that I will continue to love my APX.

[@v.german11b]

Initially, I bought the Walther PDP full size 5" barrel (18+1) just about a month after it was released. I was so impressed with its reliability and accuracy after 300 rounds I shot through it, that later on I ended up getting me a PDP 4" (15+1) LE Edition with XS sights from the factory. Both of them are superb! I have nothing but praises, no issues, no complains. I only changed the sights on the full size for AmeriGlo Trooper night sights, and attached to both pistols tactical gun lights, which with the added weight under the barrel it keeps the gun flatter when shooting. With that said, I am impressed with the Beretta APX and have toyed the idea to get me one. Excellent comparison review 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@jordanjoestar8839]

For $329 the APX is a world beater. Absolutely over-built unit. Look at the slide rails, they are massive and run nearly the entire chassis. A Glock or other similar firearms have small tabs that make me feel uneasy, especially considering how much most of its competition costs. Say what you will about "legacy" but Beretta is the longest operating privately owned company on earth. 500 years strong baby, long live the king of guns.

[@bigmike716]

I love the PDP! Perfect for me, having really big hands, I have the full size frame with the 4" slide. Perfect with the Holosun 507C.

[@garycooper1644]

Why did you choose the Holosun 507C ? I'm considering the same setup and would like your opinion on the Holosun vs. the other options.

[@Neverknight2]

I know for me, it is more clear for my astigmatism and I also like the dot or circle option.

[@garycooper1644]

@@Neverknight2 I have the same vision problem... I think I'll give the Holosun a shot....Thanks

[@alpha2957]

Holosun all day, everyday for me. 💯💯🙂🙂👍👍

[@christophereger1053]

The serrations on the APX are just so...Toblerone. However, I do like how it shoots.

[@spades512]

lol I knew they reminded me of something

[@venomfang8560]

😅

[@cbo9090]

The serrations are awesome

[@raymondbiohackergonzalez9927]

When comes the comparison of PDP vs S&W Performance center m2.0 ported.

[@80sDon]

Love the APX

[@r.parker8299]

Great comparison video 👍. You can't lose with either of these great firearms. 🗽🦅🇺🇸

[@falconator3419]

How’s the grip on the Walther PDP 15 rounder? Does your pinkie sticks out? For large hands at least.

[@jaytay7989]

I have medium hands and the pinky fits fully on the grip.

[@Mr_Santo5]

I'm the owner of a PDP but I think this review is a bit unfair in that a red dot is installed on the Walther. Would have been a more honest comparison without it.

[@chaff5]

Can you do an updated one of this w/ the new PDP Pro and APX A1?

[@jdscoco]

I carry the PDP compact. I shelved the modified Glock 19 5 gen that I carried for a couple years. The PDP is a great tool. I opted for a custom holster with LAG tactile, still waiting for it. However, a Glock 21 holster works perfectly.

[@luckman-zz2sm]

I was able to rent a PDP at a range and I've owned a Glock 19 and 17. When I had a chance to fire an APX, loved it, bought one and now the Glocks haven't seen the light of day in quite a while.

[@stevenkendell1134]

How is the Walther modular, again?!?!?!

[@chuckb6256]

I own the compact 5inch pdp and it's my favorite striker fired pistol ever owned. It is my daily carry

[@psuave1210]

Love my Centurion.

[@tylerhaskiell1338]

I own the pdp, fn509, m&p 2.0, glocks, hk. And imo the 509 has the best serrations.

[@l337l0gan]

To be such a big name, FN is under appreciated in the handgun realm! Every FN pistol I have ever owned or shot was absolutely amazing!

[@whiterangerrr]

I love my full size 509! Trying to determine whether or not to get the Compact 509 or APX.

[@tylerhaskiell1338]

I would go with the fn. But the apx imo is THE BEST gun for the money!

[@joecader]

@@tylerhaskiell1338 you spelled PDP wrong. 🤣

[@bigbass421]

I own both. I carry the PDP. I just went to the range, and as much as I really want to like the APX Centurion, I cannot shoot it nearly as well as the PDP compact. I think there is something off with the sights on my APX. I also shot my Canik TP9 SF Elite SC. I like that gun a lot, but I'm carrying the right gun for me. The Walther PDP compact.

[@terryoliver1410]

I have both and I would give up neither. PDP is number one for the reasons you described . As you mentioned though if budget is a concern the Beretta would definitely be your choice.Used PD peas are nearly impossible to find but you can get excellent excellent value on the Beretta’s as used firearm

[@JacksonWalter735]

Honestly I don't think you can go wrong with either guns and it just depends on what you're looking for. To me I'd get the APX if I was tight on money or buying a first gun. It's $300 less than the Walther PDP, you can switch between different grip modules (if you want to go to an APX Compact to make it easier to conceal), to me it feels softer shooting with the lower bore axis (if you shoot Glocks or M&Ps the APX kind of shoots like that), the trigger undercut is nicer, and it looks like a pistol inspired by Jurassic Park/dinosaurs with the slide serrations, grip texture, and jagged trigger. The trigger is above average, but it's not comparable to the Walther PDP at all. You can always add the $15 Competition Firing Pin Spring Assembly from Beretta to make the trigger much nicer, but I'd still take the PDP's trigger. Plus the RDO APX (optics ready) and the APX Combat (optics ready with a threaded barrel) are still cheaper than the Walther PDP. If money wasn't a factor I'd go with the Walther PDP. I am biased though because the Walther PPQ was the first gun I bought when I was old enough and the PDP is just an overall improvement over that. I got a chance to shoot a Walther PDP Compact back in May and fell in love. The trigger was even better than the PPQ's trigger and the pistol wasn't broken in yet with only 60 rounds through it when I shot it. To me this would be the primary reason to get a PDP. Ergonomically, the grip just feels a lot better in my hands than the full size APX or the APX Centurion. The grip swells out and curves in all the right places to really fill out your hands. The grip texture is one of the best, if not the best, out there by allowing you to really lock in your grip while not chafing your skin while you conceal carry. The Walther PDP comes optics ready by default which is nice if you want to future proof your pistol. Back in the day I had to send my PPQ slide to C&H Precision to make it optics ready. Might as well get it done straight from the factory and not have to pay extra. The slide serrations on the Walther PDP looks better in my opinion as well. It looks thick on video, but it's not that much wider than what you get on something like a Glock 19. Shooting wise I do feel like there is slightly more felt recoil while I'm shooting fast, follow up shots, but with a proper grip the sights snap right back into place. The Walther PDP Compact also feels like a much bigger gun than it really is. It's still a great conceal carry option while feeling like a full size pistol if that makes any sense. For many people who never shot the PPQ or PDP, I notice many of them ride the slide release while shooting. On their last shot the slide doesn't lock back because they're engaging the slide safety. This isn't a problem with the gun and a little bit of training will fix it. The Walther PDP also looks better to me.

[@Justadude7]

Where can I find a Centurion new or used at a reasonable price?

[@920WASHBURN]

His face is symmetrical AF. I think I'm gonna buy the pdp

[@jacobberman4616]

You ok bro?

[@920WASHBURN]

@@jacobberman4616 ha ha yeah. Just kinda scatter brained

[@FrankDAmico-dr5dl]

I don't own a Walther but their guns are known for quality and accuracy. I do own the APX and for the bang for the buck, I love it. Accurate and reliable. So it comes down to personal preference and how much you want to spend. Try both before buying and then make your decision.

[@Dante-tk7gb]

What red dot do y'all recommend for the PDP?? Something affordable and well made.

[@ThunderFalcon333]

Got the Walther PDP FS 2 18 round mags awesome tiger and accurate and reliable. Well worth the money.

[@RobnPhx1]

I was attracted to the APX due to the unusual slide serrations. Although I really like Walther products, I find that the Beretta just has a better shooters feel to it. Both the Walther PPQ and PPD have better triggers, but the Beretta APX feels more like a duty pistol to me. Maybe my Beretta bias is showing, but I like what I like.

[@ironsights.2a913]

Great video, thanks

[@automandan]

Both are great guns and for the price they're hard to beat.

[@mattf5630]

I have to say, I had the PDP, and while it is very accurate and has an excellent trigger, I couldn’t get past the excessive slide rattle, and general “cheap” build. There is a lot of hype around it right now, but I suspect it will fade. It’s a good gun and I had zero malfunctions out of it. I just can’t say that I trusted the quality and durability.

[@oceaser6977]

I love my PDP but that rattle comment is very valid. When I hear something rattle like that I just think inferior quality. I’ve heard ppl say Walther justifies this citing play on the slide for accuracy and durability

[@alpha2957]

I want the Walther PDP 4.5 inch with the 18 Mag capacity. Enough said! 💯💯🙂🙂👍👍

[@RammaJamma3]

What iwb holster u useing with pdp?

[@papatorr3669]

I called Beretta directly and asked them about switching out from my full size apx to the compact centurion and they said it wouldn't work. There may be a video where someone went from a sub compact to a compact frame. Open to feedback.

[@JacksonWalter735]

Yeah switching over from a full size APX to a Compact or Centurion model isn't really realistic nor is it feasible. While theoretically possible to do so, Beretta doesn't sell all the parts necessary for you to convert your full size APX over to a smaller version or vice versa (like how Sig lets you buy every single part for their P320/P365 lineups). You can't even buy different size slides from Beretta (or an optics ready slide if you wanted and optic now) to make this possible. Converting your full size APX from a 9mm to .40 S&W or changing out the grip frames is probably the most you can do. Just buying the parts alone would cost more than straight up buying a new APX Compact/Centurion IF Beretta sold all the parts to make those pistols when you already own the APX FCU.

[@68gomat]

I have a full size APX and it stays full size. Nothing can change that. I also have a Compact APX that can change to a Centurion by charging the $38.00 frame to color of your choice. Simpler and easier choice is to just add a Centurion mag and spacer to the Compact. Same difference. Either of the Carry models are all by themselves. Some day I'll get a PDP .

[@jackdavidrussell797]

Like the 411 very informitive

[@sinistar426]

APX's dovetail cut in the slide is proprietary to Beretta making after market sight choices limited to what Beretta puts out "which isnt much".

[@gunsandcars3648]

simple buy both, either one is awesome.

[@jimmysmith3255]

Huge fan of beretta, they dont make a bad firearm, that said pdp on a whole different level the only thing keeping the pdp from perfection is the take down. Put vp9 takedown on pdp and you have the best striker on the market

[@oceaser6977]

I agree. I have a full size PDP and love it. How it feels, shoots and how it looks even (although I sort of wanted the compact but bought the larger for home defense) The take down is a but “funky” but aside from that great gun

[@joecader]

The takedown on the PDP is Glock-ish. The takedown that threw me for a loop was the HK P30. It didn't tell me that the lever isn't removed. 🤣

[@jimmysmith3255]

@@joecader any you tube video will

[@scottmason7654]

Stoeger ST9 slide serrations are also as aggressive or more than these two pistols.

[@videosilikemedina4872]

Beretta owns stoeger 😊

[@enderdavila2910]

hi, y love your video, thanks for shering,, i got my apx from you 2 days ago

[@videosilikemedina4872]

Yes the PDP RATTLE BUT THATS THE REASON WHY THE SLIDE NEVER JAMS,clean or DURTY and without oil,very well tough

[@derrickbrewster7223]

What kind of red dot on your PDP?

[@robertosanchez4117]

Why a red dot on an edc that makes no sense.

[@marksmith1535]

@@robertosanchez4117 it’s just preference of sight picture. Maybe someone would use the dot if their vision isn’t the best. Or getting different iron sights would fix it. Either way if you train with one or the other, it doesn’t really matter.

[@jamesharrelson713]

This is a great gun .beretta name alone speaçks for itself after making guns for 500 years...

[@aaronholmes8568]

The Walther has the trigger by which all other striker fired pistols should be judged. I have a 5" Full Size PDP for shooting Production class Action Pistol and it is a better gun than I am a shooter. The trigger is like a glass rod breaking, clichéd I know but it's true. I also carry a PPS M2 for CCW and I might trade to the 4" Compact PDP. Before anyone starts, I'm 6' 225lbs and could conceal pretty easily under any of my clothes. I also prefer OWB in a leather holster, just my preference.

[@AlaskanBallistics]

I like my APX but I've had a jam or two.

[@blackticalmayhem8461]

i cant decide between the APX or CZ P10C . your thoughts?

[@AlaskanBallistics]

@@blackticalmayhem8461 glock 19 gen5 better than both at handling hotter +p+ loads and i shoot them better than both... the APX is nicer grip than all three

[@blackticalmayhem8461]

@@AlaskanBallistics lol, thanks but i have several glocks already

[@videosilikemedina4872]

P10c all the way,but can’t go wrong with neither

[@nasirmahmood6452]

Fine work good

[@MrRasaan77]

This is the luckiest man on the planet right now

[@repentnow1720]

FYI - costs = Walther PDP $600 / Beretta APX $380 (both via Cabela's)

[@fredq6543]

Thank you sir I was just about to look for that information appreciate it very much

[@fishfood8719]

FYI. Walther is optics ready, choice of one optic plate free. Beretta RDO ( optics ready) MSRP $549, online cheapest was $480 pre covid a while ago sold out., but usually $500 to $525 +. Plus have to buy optic plate, going for $82 on Beretta website.

[@fn6266]

Great guns in market absolutely flooded with equally competent Glock 19 alternatives.

[@matthunter9562]

Team Walther PDP ✌🏻😀

[@PRAETORYANN]

both are awesome but APX for me.

[@kylerumsey8942]

Good video

[@eddieperez5079]

I do own both of these pistols! I dO agree with most of your review but the beretta shoots better than the pdp!!! Pdp is a little to snappy!

[@billswanson1251]

Adjustable rear sight on the PDP.

[@jasonfranciosa]

Real comparison is the P10c vs PDP

[@MurderBallad]

Pdp trigger is nice and lite but feels like cheap plastic.. would definitely upgrade to a metal one.

[@jackhammer0101]

PDP all day.. Every day.. Hands down

[@pigpaul]

PDP vs the P365

[@bayard0157]

PDP vs P320 maybe. P365 is WAY smaller.

[@darkpassenger65]

I don't see the comparison.

[@Montblanc1986]

PDP slide rattles, otherwise its great.

[@jimhovater8755]

Red dot v NO red dot? Wow...

[@WendzDarKnight08]

I’ve notice a lot of Instagramers and gun bunnies love the PDP. Totally overrated

[@thetacticalape8852]

How is the PDP overrated? It is a very ergonomic, accurate, and reliable pistol. The trigger is outstanding, even more so on the Pro version. My only complaint is that it is a little thick.

[@jamesstubbs4978]

Your right you are biass

[@tarrelljones7259]

Overwatch Precision makes a trigger for both of them very affordable thank me later

[@tobiasfunke3357]

PDP is the best pistol in the world IMO.

[@JDowPCs]

I'm not sure why, but I'm really inaccurate with my APX. As reliable as it is, I can't get to shooting it right. I shoot my compact and subcompact pistols much better. I have big hands and I'm using the Large backstrap, maybe I should try the medium?

[@janirajaquessjaques1680]

Tiago Jaques Sabino Araruama Rio

[@janirajaquessjaques1680]

Tiago 123

[@MajorC202]

You should do an apology video….toWalther. The APX is NO PDP. 😉

[@MajorC202]

The APX makes a good tire chock.😬

[@waterhead1359]

For me and others when shooting our thumb rides the slide stop so doesn't lock back on last round which I dislike on the pdp

[@robertosanchez4117]

My pdp locks back on last round all the time and very very very accurate

[@venomgt7299]

So basically you switched from a sub compact to a full size gun.If you wanted more rounds, just go fn 509.24>15

[@jefflyons7]

Full size? This Walther is compact sized...

[@venomgt7299]

@@jefflyons7 to me the pdp is like a desert eagle my friend.The shield 3.1" is micro compact.I recently shot my buddies walther pdp.Great shooter, just hard for me to conceal carry.Enjoy the gun though

[@jefflyons7]

@@venomgt7299 the PDP I own is the size of a glock 19. Not sure if you classify that with a desert eagle or not? Maybe our body type is different, pretty easy for me to conceal most compact guns with normal attire...

[@ahood893]

What own holster do you use?

[@ahood893]

OWB

[@dbones8795]

1312

[@WendzDarKnight08]

Such a biased review

[@Osprey1994]

I have shot the APX and I honestly can't stand it. The trigger is kinda gross and fat, but maybe the rental was just bleh?

[@gutWrench9mm]

Slow talker

[@lubnaatari9009]

first comant

[@Berserkable]

I’m sure it’s a great gun but the APX is one of the ugliest guns I’ve seen imo. Just a bit better than XDs lol

[@blackticalmayhem8461]

it really is LOL they could have done better

[@keithmccready3158]

Why are you picking on the XDS? After all, that was the first 45 caliber compact handgun to come on the market. A real powerhouse in a small package. A true Pocket Gun.

[@ramoncunningham6660]

Beretta has absolutely no aftermarket for the APX. Don’t buy it.

[@frontlinepfknr]

You’re crazy! Tell me what aftermarket support it needs? The Apx is a beast out of the box. I don’t understand buying a gun and spending just as much on aftermarket shit. The only thing I did to my Apx was buy extra mags and hella ammo to TRAIN. That’s all I’m not saying the pdp is not a good firearm. Again another firearm that doesn’t need aftermarket support because they’re good right out of the box

[@ramoncunningham6660]

It’s suppose to be a modular system. I’m not saying it’s not a great gun. It’s got a great trigger and ergonomics . But the lack of aftermarket beretta has provided for it is horrible. They did not market this well. But it would be nice to have slides, internals and kits available similar to how sig has it for the p320. Mine also has a hard time cycling steel case ammo. Lots of FTF’s. For the price it is great. Just expected more aftermarket support

[@frontlinepfknr]

@@ramoncunningham6660 you are correct about beretta missing out on the accessories part. I just feel it was misleading for you to say that is has no aftermarket so don’t buy it.

[@frontlinepfknr]

@@ramoncunningham6660 your cycling issues call beretta and get them to send you a née recoil spring. If you have one of the ones that first came out they were designed for nato loads

[@80sDon]

The APX has night sights from Trijicon, Ameriglo, and XS Big Dot available. Leather, kydex, and hydrid IWB and OWB for any carry position is available. Beretta offers threaded barrels, optic cuts, steel plates for every major optic manufacturer, manuextended magazines, extended mag sleeves, heavy recoil spring assemblies, grip modules in several colors, extended mag release, and slide stop on their website. Beretta and Galloway Precision both offer competition striker springs that will bring the 6lb trigger down to 4-4.5lb.

[@seth3000gt]

The serrations are absolute junk on the APX. That's why only the APX ever had any like it. Watch Military Arms channels test of the APX. And they are cut backwards too 🤣 You need more traction at the base of the slide Beretta, not the top.. No wonder why it didn't stand a chance at the military trials...🤣 Then that stupid trigger Beretta put on it.... horrible weak trigger return spring that can barely pull itself back to reset, it's crunchy, and most of all Beretta then decided to build the frame around the trigger so that it bites the living crap outta your finger!!! Multiple reports online about this, including mine. Takes a doctor to swap frames on the APX too...what a pile! Oh, and on top of that, it's FAT!!!! And I mean, FAT! I compared mine to all my guns and it seriously looked unfinished, like they forgot to slim it down and just decided it was too late to actually shape the gun. The APX is terrible, That's why Beretta dropped the price of them down to 300.00 bucks before the China Virus. They suck, and Beretta knows it. When I saw this video, APX vs PDP I was like, well that's not fair to Beretta. But then you made it sound like it was actually a close comparison!!!?? No, no no my friend, stop being nice to Beretta..be honest with us and yourself. Anyways, there's a rant for ya to smile about. ☺️🤘

[@seth3000gt]

@silent sir Well then if we use your theory, I guess everyone has small fingers and hands. Including Tim from Military Arms channel! Haha, someone should let him know, because he thinks he has large hands. The slide release on the PDP is a Gem. Even the all mighty H&K uses the same one it's so beautiful! Haha and also why Walther hasn't changed it since the original design of the PPQ. Oh, and Canik who copied the PPQ kept that slide stop design. The APX?? Uh, nothing. It's no comparison. I am willing to be that Beretta comes out with a new poly wonder 9 that is nothing like the craptastic APX. And soon too.

[@spades512]

The fat thing does kinda ring true, but those front serrations don't take anything away imo. It allows you to rack it from there, or stop someone else from racking it in cqc

[@Arrozconchopsticks]

The serrations are just fine, and that video by military arms was garbage.

[@sweetcostarica]

WHAT THE... Did he say he switched from the smaller S&W Shield (7 & 8 rd magazine) to the big butt & chunky Walther PDP (15 rd magazines)?? Saying *_Gunscom,_* he wanted *more capacity* & a more *"capable"* carry gun?? Bias is correct - IMO: CAPACITY - for concealed carry the FBI street data shows the average shots fired in personal self-defense is 2 to 4 shots. You don't need 15 shots for CCW/concealed carry. If you shot 15 shots in a CCW/concealed carry incident, 1. You are a poor shot. 2. You will be going to jail to for overkill. 3. If you shoot the wrong color i.e. you are white, "bad" guy/gal is black/brown/yellow *_15 times_* you are racist according to USA current culture. Just saying. CAPABILITY - I thought the S&W Shield was/is very capable. I have no idea what *Gunscom* want *_more_* the Walther PDP has that the S&W Shield does not have?? _I Think_ (tell if I wrong *Gunscom)* Because the Walther PDP is the new shiny object every gun industry person & their mama wants to use it in some form or another to _promote it._ The are better carry pistols out there that are already known. I.e. HK VP series, or the World Standard the Glock can & does beat the PDP. THE TRUTH The Walther PDP is a good gun maybe a great OWB duty gun _BUT_ it is a *_bad carry gun_* cause it is fat, bulky, & heavy at 24.4 oz for the compact 4 inch barrel - heaver than the Shield which weights 18.3 oz & is smaller. I have no idea why anyone who is not fat like the PDP would carry it?? NOTE: Guys/Gals do not use handguns for home defense USE LONG GUNS to have the power advantage & be much more effective. The best long gun to use for home protection is the *_shotgun_* or trench sweeper as my grandfather would say. God bless