Was Abigail Marston REALLY Unfaithful to John in Red Dead Redemption 2?

Join us as we dive deep into the complex character of Abigail Marston in Red Dead Redemption 1 & 2, unraveling the myths and misconceptions surrounding her alleged romantic involvements within the gang. We'll dissect the evidence, timeline, and in-game dialogues to provide a compelling case against the theory that she slept with everyone in the gang.
Furthermore, we'll explore the intricacies of John's paternity and debunk common assumptions about his relationship with Abigail. Our video sheds light on the nuanced storytelling and character development in the Red Dead series, offering a fresh perspective on Abigail's role in the gang and her bond with John Marston.
Don't miss this deep dive into the world of Red Dead Redemption, where we challenge stereotypes and reveal the hidden truths about Abigail Marston's character. Subscribe, like, and share to join the discussion and help set the record straight!

[@SpeedDemon55]

I think Abigail is a misunderstood character. She just wants to look out for John and Jack and for John to stop living like an outlaw and settle down and become a good honest man. She may be a bit whiny or angry but everything she says and does it out of love for John and Jack.

[@kyledeguzman165]

And that’s the problem,had John been complaining as much as Abigail did about protecting family, people would have a problem,but Abigail being a whore and a woman who can’t protect herself unless she has help from the people she treats like shit apparently makes her some misunderstood woman who is supposed to get everything she wants in life for free whereas John had no choice but to live his life as an outlaw and only chose to work shoveling shit for her

[@thomasmartin4281]

And she was right that he shouldn’t have gone after Micah, it led Ross to John.

[@ItsMrs.Marston]

I agree with this so much. She's such a great, loyal woman. Uncle was truly right about her

[@cursedweaponkenjaku888]

@@thomasmartin4281but if he didn’t everything arthur did would be for nothing.

[@minervacatter]

@@cursedweaponkenjaku888 i think rockstar was trying to hint that it was a mistake throughout the game with the "revenge is a fools game" "vengeance is an idiots game" but also micah deserved to die so

[@lynette50]

In those days 17 wasn't treated as underage. Girls were being married at 14.... Abigail definitely was a prostitute. Uncle was the Pimp. Even Arthur says he was the worst Pimp ever... And its Uncle that says in Chapter 2 of RDR2 when he and Arthur go to town with the girls, that he is going to "Put the women to work" and Karen replies "With pleasure ".. Abigail gave it up after she got pregnant because she was in love with John

[@implicitmintjulep]

Agreed. Thinking a gang of outlaws in 19th century America would actually adhere to modern day ethics and societal norms is always laughable

[@Ashley-bw9ns]

Yea, but it makes sense for John not to want to look after her and Jack in the beginning. John himself wasn't sure whether Jack was his son, and rightly so.... who the hell would settle down with a working girl at first(albeit a former one)

[@urdarkruler2223]

I assumed "put the women to work" was their usual schtick. The thing they do, gathering intel and stealing stuff from people. Like in Valentine, I believe that one of the girls was about to knock a guy out to rob him, after making him 'think' she was going to sleep with him.

[@shadowcobra69]

What are you on? Married at 14 was not allowed some people did it of course just like they do now.

[@YishmaelBenElisha]

17 is still legal age and 14 Actually 16 is legal age in my state

[@Truekingr6]

It was so odd seeing John as a dead beat father who wanted nothing to do with her and Jack but then he slowly becomes who he is in rdr 1 thanks to Arthur

[@liebeasta3332]

makes sense. He was not even sure the child was his

[@daahorse1652]

That’s what makes his redemption even more powerful to me, turn from wanting nothing to do with his family to literally sacrificing himself for it.

[@Miltypooh2001]

In my opinion i don't hate Abigail sure she loves to whine at john for showing off his gun skills, but you gotta remember she just wants john to be a regular dad for the sake of jack.

[@kyledeguzman165]

And that’s the problem, he protects his ranch and his family and the people in the ranch yet Abigail complains like a bitch when John doesn’t just sit back and let tons of people get shot at or killed

[@yaboyreflex1919]

@@kyledeguzman165yeah everyone leaves out this context it’s so annoying. What is he supposed to do literally act like a coward and let people get robbed/killed?!

[@sharpweaponcatcher]

@@yaboyreflex1919 the thing is abigail was tired of always having to move so she wanted a place to settle down. john could’ve handled the situation with the police but because of his lifestyle, he resorted to his usual habits which is why abigail was upset. she knew it was john’s pride as well. sometimes he didn’t shoot because he HAD to, she shot because he CAN, and that was the issue that abigail didn’t want to involve jack in.

[@MrRAGE-md5rj]

When a team of armed burglars comes to burn your house down, you don’t have time to wait on the police.

[@sharpweaponcatcher]

true but that doesn’t mean john had to resort to his old habits- which abigail was trying to keep him from doing

[@BlitheDragon]

I always felt that Arthur wanted to marry Abigail mostly because of the guilt he felt after his own son and mother of his child were killed by outlaws. And also the anger and self hatred reflected by John's actions of leaving her when Jack was a baby.

[@legopussy2363]

Arthur didn’t have a son, or wife

[@ConservativeCalifornian1032]

@@legopussy2363he never said wife but yes he did have a child. His name was isaac and him and his mother were killed over $10. Look it up.

[@assbutt6969]

@@legopussy2363he did

[@renaldoseraphin792]

@@legopussy2363lol yes he did he repeatedly mentioned this

[@evanwest4927]

@@legopussy2363He had a son, he talks about him in one of the Rains Falls missions

[@torinsnotmyname827]

Her being 17 really doesn’t mean much. The age or consent in certain modern day US states is 16. So 17 in 1899 wouldn’t have stopped anyone, even moral heavy

[@cheefqueef6494]

so you'd bang a 17 year old? 💀

[@BallBatteryReligion]

Thank you. I don't know why dude in the video is making such a hard stance on her being 17 like it would have changed anything. Not to mention, John is what, 3 or 4 years older than her? So 17-18 year old girl meets a 20-21 year old guy. That's... really not that weird even for today.

[@theoutsiderjess4869]

Your right but I can't see Arthur, Dutch or Hosea sleeping with her. Dutch is most likely too out of the lot but she isn't Dutch's type she isn't rich or sophisticated or someone who likes literature.

[@Lamedvavnik]

@@BallBatteryReligionI’m not sure he’s even played the game. His pronunciation of Javier and Hosea are proof as much.

[@almalone3282]

​@theoutsiderjess4869 Intellectual people like sex too. And ironically they aren't really that picky

[@olliecrayford]

Why did Uncle have the hammer and sickle on his forehead💀😂

[@jamiemcmullen4767]

I thought I was seeing things lol

[@eyaljanssen4164]

based uncle?

[@chancellor1055]

Comrade uncle

[@AdamEhsan777]

Uncle was a Bolshevik

[@amrinhouston8395]

I was just thinking the same shit lol

[@nihaalsandim9986]

Abigail is a fine woman , even with her past . She pushed John to follow an honest living , and wanted him to be responsible and good . She also wanted jack to learn and become a decent man , she was also hardworking at the camps and always kind to people , even to molly ,who supposedly the rest of the gang disliked . She had morals , and was a good wife , mother and woman .

[@DavisJ-ln6fw]

Here here

[@MarkelMathurin]

this is thinking is how men screw over themselves

[@LQC13]

I like how ambiguous a lot of back stories and end stories are in the rdr universe. It gives an extra flavor to the story.

[@cah8533]

Im glad someone is FINALLY giving her justice!!! Everyone calls her annoying but lets be for real, she just wanted a decent life, and never had the chance to do so before. I always knew it was unlikely she slept with everyone, since in RDR2 you can clearly see no woman in the camp sleeps with multiple members at the same time. Like, even Karen, drunk all the time, only flirted with Sean from all i could see. So i mean, the women in the camp joined the gang for working and protection, never for just sleeping around.

[@kyledeguzman165]

She was annoying and a whore that cared about nobody except herself and her son,and when her life and her husbands life becomes in danger she ends up complaining as if her “strong and independent” ass couldn’t defend herself on her own yet she has a problem when John kills to save her and his som

[@Based_Gigachad_001]

Sadie > Abigail. Sadie is badass.

[@cah8533]

@@Based_Gigachad_001 bro I love Sadie but what does she has to do with the topic in hand?? You can talk about a character without needing to compare it to another one :) I do prefer Sadie but Abigail needs to be appreciated too!!

[@nemesis27]

She slept with the gang members, dutch says it in the 1st game ( English is not my 1st language)

[@cah8533]

@@nemesis27 it's ok bro! English is not my first language as well. And I know, he said that. But like the video said, Dutch could have lied or manipulated the real situation to get into John's nerves. And it wouldn't be the first time he lies, we know that. So yeah, not a very reliable source I would say

[@yungozXXX]

She wasn’t for the streets, she was for the haystack in the barn lol

[@user-mu8dm4rk7g]

You made me snort my snot out lmao

[@Mrmonkey19888]

3:40 did any body see the hammer and sickle on uncle or am I hallucinating

[@danthonygregory4157]

Yes it is. The footage was modded for uncle to have this.

[@codeinecowboy8607]

Uncle is actually Karl Marx

[@vagabondquerier9375]

underage is your reason ?!? Serious? She was 17 when joined the gang. The age of consent was 13 to be married ... Criminal Law Amendment Act of 1885 moved it to 16 ... yet it was not heavy enforced to many years after.

[@Carlo775]

Legality =/ morality. Just cause it was legal back then doesnt make it morally correct

[@vagabondquerier9375]

@@Carlo775 I guess you speak on drawing moral views from Christianity, Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism , Judaism, Sikhism, Taoism, the Baháʼí Faith, Jainism, Confucianism, Shinto and even Zoroastrianism to name few of the mostr popular collectives of morals ... which of these are are morally correct? I will stay with the legal and what was enforced 13 to 16 to marry

[@KC.45]

Josiah Blackwater's first wife was a native American "woman" of twelve years of age.

[@Logan_TheLegend]

Holy🤓🤓🤓 this was the cowboy days,you think they cared

[@kurtcometa4818]

​@@Carlo775its the 19th century. They don't practice those morals especially outlaws

[@alexmccart2566]

6:50 looking at my friends family cemetary I can tell you that people born in the late 1800's were not opposed to a a 25 year old man marrying a 15 year old girl.

[@AlexanderLegium]

I think in RDR 2 is implied that she used to be a thief, remember that she's the one to discover the location of Dutch's stash, and give Arthur the key to open it, they even have dialogue along those lines. To explain the Susan scene I think fits well, Abigail refuses to going back to stealing the same way she wants John to end his outlaw life, cause she don't want to get caught or killed, again because of Jack, the gang needs money, that's probably why Grimshaw was asking her to return to her "old" habits, never is said to sell herself, which probably weren't as profitable as stealing.

[@UncleTonyK]

Considering that "cat houses" were a legal trade at the time, I don't imagine that Abigail would have continued to prostitute after joining the gang. It wouldn't make good business since for the proprietor of an establishment to hire on new talent who had come into town with a gang of outlaws who'd likely bring unwanted attention to their place of business. Instead, I suspect that she (like Karen, Mary Beth, and Tilly) would go into town and grift unsuspecting drunks for leads or whatever was in their marks' pockets. But, (as you stated) having Jack changed her both physically and mentally.

[@alfredmamba]

If you have Arthur make negative comments to Abigail or Jack, Arthur states that anyone in gang could be Jack's dad. Yes, he's being an ass but he's verifying the obvious. Abigail was a 304.

[@shamanllama]

As much as I love John, he was kind of a pathetic man for most of his life. He definitely Redeemed himself, but I don't blame Abigail. I woulda married her too. Abigail is a beautiful and incredibly strong woman and mother. I dont know why people hate on her, really. She pissed me off sometimes, but she really only yelled at John because she was worried for them all (including John)

[@WeBothAreMonkeys]

Ehh that’s only cos rockstar wanted to shit on him so Arthur had a chance of seeming cool

[@Louis13XIII]

Cuz she dum af

[@rowenjohnson]

@@WeBothAreMonkeys nah, they began John's story in rdr2 as a deadbeat. but after the events of Chapter 4 and Angelo Bronte, he turned his act around and became a good man

[@tateoctober814]

​@@WeBothAreMonkeys Google "Character Arc".

[@Jason.cbr1000rr]

Shes hot fir a gane character..

[@Wolf-bz6kq]

Remember that age of consent wasnt a thing in those times, when a girl get her period they are considered an adult so Abigail growing up poor in those times it would make sense for her to be a prostitute until jack was born then stopped knowing the gang more or less adopted her as somebody more than a prostitute

[@internetkurator9256]

"We all had her. But Marston married her."

[@BiA-hg7qr]

They all did mating press on her. 🥲

[@The90sKid518]

„We all had her”- Dutch 😂

[@cuckertarlson3329]

Bill said some shit too in rdr lol

[@The90sKid518]

@@cuckertarlson3329 😅😅 yes i know and still funny

[@MyCarlos311]

I think most of the hate on Abigail comes from RDR and the fact that Romantic interest is shown from Bonney McFarlen. You play the whole game to save Abigail and she has major attitude. Bonnie is shown as beautiful and an extraordinary woman. (Which is why I think they they redesigned Abigail to make her more beautiful in RDR2) That being said. Like others have said, she’s looking to protect her son. There’s no reason to dislike her. I love that Arthur even says to himself that he should have probably married her cause she’s a good woman.

[@lonestarbuckeye6889]

She was a great character right up to the epilogue when she told John to stop being a man making decisions (or something like that) then leaving John because he stood up to the thugs, but I realize they had to make up some reason for her to leave John just so they could have their heart felt reunion after they built the house on beechers hope

[@DayGrin_]

​@@lonestarbuckeye6889In the 7 years after Arthur's death, it was implied that they had to move constantly because of John's recklessness. Of course she left

[@notyourdaddude1957]

The epilogue really portrayed her very unlikeable though, the reason why John managed to have his own farm is because he knew how to use a gun and that earned him friends and connections for doing noble acts like helping Pronghorn Ranch when needed. But i didn't see Abigail complain about it, she took it and she was fine with it even though she was giving him such a hard time for not being able to change and even left him too for a time. Also her mother instincts became a priority pretty much after Jack was taken by Bronte, that's when she realized what really means to be a mother and how much Jack actually meant for her, that's when she started to put Jack needs before her own. There is a conversation at campfire in chapter 2 where she says how awful it is to be a mother and how she wanted to have a different life and all that, she even says herself she wasn't much of a mother and didn't knew what that means until that point in the story.

[@trippie.bleu_]

2:13 bro starves arthur

[@Fireflamez317]

He said we all had her but he married her yo I’m rolling LMAOOO 🤣🤣🤣

[@chester9718]

Ikr that guy is a menace 😂

[@julidee_]

How is that funny

[@BiA-hg7qr]

@@julidee_ They all did mating press on her. 😮‍💨

[@skipsamson]

Your channel is going to get big I can see it:) I hope I can try and make videos as good as this one day

[@shoretroopercaptaintarras1876]

Anyone else notice the hammer and sickle on uncle's head about one third of the way through the video?

[@Obst111]

Great video!

[@TheThirdMeteorite]

Thank you!

[@Srenitystreezx]

I believe more and more that dutch must have always been a piece of work because in both the two games , the Pinkerton's during the fishing trip Arthur does with Jack they mention to Arthur how Dutch had a forked tongue and then in the mission where we save Sean, Trelawny is basically trying to tell us how dutch shot and k***ed that young woman in blackwater.

[@ajsalcove1762]

When Bill is caught he says “we all f*cked Abigail!!” He only says this when he’s pinned down and about to die or get captured so it’s obviously just to get a jab at John before he dies. You don’t have to be too bright to understand that John is sensitive about Abigail previously being a prostitute, was in his actions, mannerisms and he’d said it directly. Even if Bill didn’t realize it at the time he probably pieced it together from memory or someone just told him. Back before RDR2 Bill wasn’t seen as the idiot he is in RDR1 (correct me if I’m wrong) Having known John for almost his entire life Dutch knows his insecurities like the back of his hand so he elaborates on his ‘spin’ of reality in camp in front of the government workers to try and embarrass John and probably make him do something rash, or just show he’s the one with the power. Dutch is nothing if not manipulative. Only John’s matured so he just grits his teeth and bares it, probably realizing what Dutch is trying to do. (Like a child gray-rocking an irate manipulative parent.) It is important to discern the truth from the context of the situation it was delivered in.

[@faridagasiyev7042]

But Bill actually slept with her, so as Dutch, Javier, and Arthur. She was a prostitute whom Uncle brought to camp when she was 17-18. She slept with many gang members until she fell in love with John. Arthur's line to Jack (antagonize): "Youndon't look much like John. More like Williamson, or Escuela".

[@EmperorFreezaSama]

Exactly thank you I always thought it was strange everyone takes Dutch and Bill’s word, two chronic liars who are clearly trying to rile John up

[@charliejamz.]

Micah had some words about Abigail during the American Venom mission.

[@hussainali1340]

What was it? I can't remember.

[@chokomaru5465]

@@hussainali1340 "how is that WHORE of yours" if i remember right

[@RyanRFC]

@@hussainali1340 he called her a whore and remarks that after he kills John he’ll go pay her a call

[@mainG588]

quoting a famous 21st century poet: "She belongs to the streets!"

[@marcplatapus8676]

3:40 who put the hammer and sickle on uncles head?

[@RoenAccurate]

I’m the 600th subscriber! Congrats on 600!

[@Cbart23]

Abigail’s a little whoo-aah!

[@xGitzabrar]

😂

[@Pekile69]

I love you're videos but at 3:43 why does uncle have that logo on his head(also u misspelled abigail in the thumbnail)

[@evanjuniorfluffy]

Bro was a communist before it was cool

[@ghost3337]

The games says she was a working girl, Dutch's comment to John wouldn't mean shit if it weren't based in truth.

[@whitex3898]

Okay so maybe I’m dumb for not knowing this, but why is there a hammer and sickle on Uncle’s head at 3:40?

[@BlueWoodStudios]

I feel like this is weird, what is so wrong with Abigail being a former sex worker who left sex work to be a mother? I think it speaks to both John and Abigail's characters that they put all of the pointless things behind and just accept that they loved eachother.

[@Vibrantly_Monochromatic]

Some people like to put women on a higher moral ground than men and if her past revolves sex work, she is past "redemption" Which is interesting because both Abagail and John are symbols of people who want to live a better life and become better people especially for their son and try to lead a healthy sane life

[@BlueWoodStudios]

@@Vibrantly_Monochromatic Exactly, it literally is her character to have been a sex worker who overcame that. I don't even think sex-work is bad, it just wasn't what she wanted, she wanted to be a mother and a family.

[@tnyte89]

It’s disgusting for one . I know I’d never marry a former hoe

[@Whitebeard_28]

Simp

[@godloveszaza]

​@@Vibrantly_Monochromatictheres a little truth to your assertion although you exaggerated and peoples hate towards her is just projection and its understandable. People dislike her because of her big mouth. Some of her provocation is valid but mostly it's uncalled for and just pure ridiculing of john it's not a surprise why people dislike her. So that higher ground stuff is just nonexistent it's simply not that deep.

[@buildingglocks5797]

Why did uncle have a hammer and cycle branded on his head

[@CheezDoodlezz]

Wait so u stop uploading for 4 years then suddenly return wow! Cool

[@octavianrusu923]

Wait but if Abigail had a client try to leave without paying 10 years before the events of rdr2 that means she's been a whore at 15-16 years old 😧

[@Wolf-bz6kq]

Not uncommon for those times, up until the 1900s a girl was considered an adult as soon as she has a period Remeber historical context

[@Spider-Rat77]

If I'm remembering correctly, Abigail was orphaned at a very young age and she grew up in brothels and bars. Being raised in an environment like that would not only make a kid percieve sexual acts as normal, but she was allowed a way to make money at such a young age and no adults had the morals to prevent her. Of course she'd work at the brothels as soon as they deemed her sexually mature enough. That's why I think it's sad and hypocritical how players will consider characters like John and Arthur victims of circumstance because they were orphaned young, but Abigail, who also had no choice in how she was raised, is treated like filth.

[@dee8171]

Lmao Micah: How's that uhh, whooore of yours? 😂

[@joynelbonet194]

Adult Jack doesn't look like Javier, he looks like a young Dutch

[@Sparkle420]

i think bill and dutch in rdr1 were saying that abigail was a whore just to demorilize john

[@thegamingglove238]

Why at 3:44 does uncle have a hammer and sickle on his head

[@TBOR101]

Abigail was what everyone thinks she was, there is enough factual clues to the truth about her. Questions are Why did John actually leave for that year and Why is he not certain about Jack. Since an older Jack favors Dutch more than John, we are left to speculate about what really should have been written. After another fight, Dutch comforted Abigail and with her own needs to feel loved adding in the lack of respect for anyone Dutch took advantage of the situation. John couldn't put the timeline together in his own mind, so he left to sort out his feelings. Upon his return against gang code Dutch took him back into the gang. Arthur was confused by this, Hosea and Dutch throughout the game try to convince John of his fatherhood of Jack. Through the disloyalty and treachery of Dutch, Abigail loved John and he her and Arthur loved them both and together they found their way to Redemption.

[@paupau8246]

Dutch in RDR1 always tries to get into John's head

[@ghost3337]

Also her conflict with grimshaw stems from her no longer 'working' for the gang. She definitely did.

[@alushakatz2828]

AYO WHY UNCLE GOT SOVIET THING ON HIS HEAD AT 3:40

[@gilbertnavarrette4806]

The short answer: yes

[@matt-cu4kf]

3:43 whats up with the hammer and sickle on uncle?

[@DrDurango]

Jack is clearly Dutch's kid

[@travismeta3727]

Not sure how it doesn’t make stuff awkward when you know the whole camp slept with her

[@RaffehNaseer]

I never understood why people compare Abigail to characters like Sadie or Bonnie Abigail is a completely different character with different goals, a different personality and a different life and for some reason people think that Abigail should just get a gun and become "badass" when she has a son to raise and not the smartest husband to take care of. Unrelated but "John Marston x Bonnie" is a bad ship

[@cabuscus]

Developed a bit of a crush for abigail after rdr2

[@eigelgregossweisse9563]

Anyone can say anything, true. But what they say, we take at face value in the first few seconds of initial impressions.

[@jayceegenocide4402]

Jack does look like Javier as does John in RDR 2 who also looks related to Javier from RDR 2. However, RDR1 Javier doesn't resemble John nor Jack.

[@Shak2k11]

lets be honest, its clearly a retcon that has caused a continuity mistake or at least story flaw.

[@djkreed1999]

Abigail kinda didn’t really change from number 1 would have been good to see her change from younger years to the one we know like we did with the other characters then again it wasn’t the at the very start of their run

[@brdg00d1ng]

Why did uncle have a hammer and sickle on his forehead at 3:41 ??

[@allainangcao28]

I think it was funny to find out that when Abigail mentions that she is working at the Doctor's Office, if you went to the Doctor's, there would be a sign on the door saying the classic "Gone Fishing" 😂

[@Matt561]

She wasn't unfaithful, she was working. John happened to knock her up.

[@Unpainted_Huffhines]

"These comments were clearly intended to provoke an antagonize, not to provide factual information." Those two motivations are not mutually exclusive. Jack could've been any one of the gang's kid. Not Javier, as you've pointed out, which follows, because the only resemblance between adult Jack and Javier is tje mustache. But adult Jack looks exactly like Dutch, so that kind of narrows it down a lot.

[@RedusDeadus]

This is the moment Abigail became Whoresenberg.

[@geminfly]

😐😐😐

[@xxintixx4638]

Womp womp

[@user-ww4oc5cp2n]

Instead of cooking up meth she cooked up in the bedroom

[@a6hawk]

I almost spat out my water when I saw the title.

[@deakindavis4814]

why

[@a6hawk]

@@deakindavis4814 i don’t remember, probably a misread or something

[@arthurmyboy]

hold up i did not notice that uncle has the hammer and sickle on his forehead

[@BLET_55artem55]

3:39 is that an editing joke or does Uncle really have that mark on his head!?

[@I_Should_Have_Died]

Why is uncle still talking about this?😅

[@bobicrni1284]

1:20 what a lucky man John is 🤣🤣🤣🤣 no wonder he treats her that way.

[@amarettopunsch1496]

People HATE Abigail??? She is easily one of my favorite characters of rdr franchise. She cared so much for the people and not just for her family but for the whole gang. She was everyone's sister, and those woman who needed advice always went up to her to get guidance.

[@xaviervega468]

Honestly the ones that seem to hate her the most are the Micah simps who have convinced themselves that Micah was not the rat. They blame Abigail instead

[@nexor7809]

@@xaviervega468 i hate micah, but i dont like having to play as john being a simp for an ex-whore.

[@xxGeorgeWKush]

I don’t blame John I woulda married her too

[@Scar207]

Title is wild bruh 💀

[@luisdj86]

Ok let's understand Abgail situation so we can place her in the right place she was. She was a prostitute before joining the gang. We don't know for how it took from the moment she met the gang and became a member. It is possible that some of the gang members, including John laid with her while she was a prostitute, and that he got her pregnant. When she joined the gang, of course she stops being a prostitute. Still, John is not sure whether he was the father or not of the Kid. That changes over the course of the story, but thats another topic. When you see Grimshaw nudging her to go back to work, here is what you need to understand what the camp girls are. They are thieves. Conn artists. They do scam other men to steal their money. You can see that happening in the chapter 2 mission Polite Society, Valentine Style. You see Karen in the Motel with a man, already taking her clothes off. What Abgail refuses to do is go back to that life. Since she became a mother, she doesn't want to do that anymore. That is what she refuses to do that Grimshaw was demanding her to, because Grimshaw oversees the camp and ensure that everyone is "contributing", if someone doesn't she snitches them to Dutch.

[@KaiW22]

I’m still lost how both John and Abigail have black hair but jack has blonde/brown

[@ItsMrs.Marston]

John has brown hair lol

[@caucaxican86]

jack's hair starts out light and actually gets darker as he ages. the same thing happened with my mom! she had blond/light brown hair as a little kid, and ended up with brown hair in her teens and on. it does happen!

[@lonestarbuckeye6889]

By the end of RDR1 Jack has dark hair, when he's grown.

[@brianpass]

4:49 nah that was just uncalled for

[@SG-qx9ko]

3:33 we aren't gonna talk about what's on uncle's forehead?

[@yeeyee6723]

I have a recorded clip of aurtjor antagonizeing abigail and saying she made the most money while whoreing (something along those lines) then john comes and knocks out Arthur i thought my game just crashed but I was just knocked out for a long time before waking up lol

[@Gfre12334fdc]

Abigail was like in here early twenties in rdr2

[@thegamergabe150]

Why tf does Uncle have the Hammer And Sickle symbols on his forehead 💀 3:39

[@wolfy9549]

3:43 why Uncle got that Soviet brand lol?

[@jaymackyt2416]

Title is crazy 😂

[@levirogers8186]

Why the fuck at 3:40 does uncle have a scar in the shape of a fucking hammer and sickle

[@DEViL_X1612]

her past was bad but her character was not bad i like her after meeting john falling for him she didnt cheated or something she was faithful

[@bobmigarski283]

Jack is obviously Uncle's son thats why Uncle lingers because he wants to watch his son grow up without seeming suspect so he just plays the role of the lazy mooch with terminal lumbago.

[@rackum44]

I wish they would do a story mode DLC. The best game ever and they just quit on us because of gta6. Well they have enough workers that can make a DLC for RDR2, DAMMIT!!!

[@lonestarbuckeye6889]

That would be great, or even give the story mode some of the little upgrades like the online has, being able to cook multiple meats, picking herbs from on your horse, etc.

[@mr.dome.gaming7103]

Twisted His Balls 😮

[@AuthorMorgan7436]

Every time I see rdr1 Dutch I get so scared he is Horrifying

[@Attentatten]

WHAT DOES UNCLE HAVE ON HIS HEAD 3:42

[@brandonwhite142]

The short answer is she used to be

[@usershadto]

we all had hair even your dad

[@Artur-tg6bq]

3:41 there’s is no way 😭😂

[@hadoo-ken583]

“That’s tuff”

[@restant8845]

3:40 why does uncle have a hammer and sickle face tat?

[@saintdave4943]

What about her cleaning at the doctor’s office in the epilogue?

[@mlmii1933]

And if you go check the doctor is closed. 😅

[@Funnyusername69420]

I don’t know why so many people think Javier is Jacks dad. NPC’s in rdr1 will literally confuse Jack with John

[@average__height8033]

yes.

[@jakubciesielski5169]

Yes.

[@bigstoner42069]

the title had me dead

[@edwardecl]

"We all had her, but he married her."

[@notyourdaddude1957]

What really annoys me when comes to Abigail as a character is her insufferable attitude towards John during the Epilogue, i mean the man tried to so hard live a normal life but she is always complaining about it. She can't understand that it's not so easy for him to simply give up his old way of life and adopt a new one, he can't simply magically change into a different person just because she's asking him to, the man was grown to be an outlaw just cut him some slack once in a while. Even so, his noble actions earned him connections and friends which helped him settle down with his own farm even though he had to use his gun for that, thank god she becomes more understanding and supportive in RDR1. I just can't bring myself to like Abigail in RDR2, her ignorance makes her very irritating and unlikeable.