Red Dead Redemption Stories: Bonnie MacFarlane. All Cut Scenes.

Bonnie is the daughter of Drew MacFarlane, the owner of MacFarlane's Ranch and has spent her whole life working on the ranch with her father. When she was young, her father hired a "French" governess (who Bonnie suspected of not truly being French, due to the fact she spoke Russian) to teach her and keep her civilized. She had six brothers, but five of them died from either illness or foolish choices. Her sole surviving brother, Patrick MacFarlane, moved to New York, where he supposedly works as a banker in Manhattan. With the majority of her generation deceased and the only other surviving male child leaving the family, Bonnie feels it is up to her to become the "man" of their family's ranch.

[@Chinchilla2310]

I love their chemistry and how realistic it is. They would’ve made a fantastic couple, but that’s not how it works.Right person, wrong time.

[@daermani]

The fact that stuff like this happens literally all the time for people in real life makes it so perfectly executed man

[@Youtube_Rakudaman]

Damn you're RIGHT. What a Realism is it.

[@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1]

BMA A Man is allowed by "The God" to have more then one wive,i.e, upto four if he can do justice b/w them or else only one!!!

[@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1]

@chandllerburse737 BMA That is what you will say to "Angel of Death" he does nothing but fulfills command of "The God"!! And starts beating immediately (coming) low honoured soul (&Body with his weapon)!! "Every Soul has to taste Death"

[@JanitaJones-nx9fc]

​@@ENTERTAININGVIDEOS1 Cult leader talk brother brother

[@thezodiac8973]

33:42 you can see bonnie was jealous, man this was an amazing game

[@anthonyspitery6332]

I literally jumped off my wagon and ran back for Bonnie. I wanted to ship them so much

[@joshuahenry3191]

I noticed that the first time I played that Mission

[@joynelbonetdelgado4952]

Aye, Abigail was jealous too. That's why she hopped on the wagon to accompany John to Bonnie's ranch in the first place.

[@eviemorgan1360]

Not jealous, just a little heartbroken

[@Gwynarth]

I don't think she was jealous...nor heartbroken. It looked like she just wanted to say more to John, regarding his kindness and willingness to help her on desperate times. She had plenty of opportunities to be jealous before and didn't. She knew John had a wife...why just act like that due jealousy now? For me, she just wanted thank him more and was touched by his gesture. Edit: Misspelling.

[@Raidxn96]

Bonnie was such a good character

[@DatMentalGamer]

indeed batman *someone had to do it*

[@eddieezcobar]

Indeed I like her more than abigail

[@dannylou95]

you can see John, so subtly, seems more literate here in his words -- maybe something he picked up from Jack through the years after RD2!

[@prosimian]

Yeah. He seemed like an idiot in Red Dead 2.

[@Miguel_morales99]

Well rdr2 epilogue takes place 3 years before rdr1 so maybe those stories jack read weren't as much of a waste as john thought lol

[@fuckingfuck1972]

@@prosimian Well, he was. He was young and dumb. He gained more wisdom as he aged, and experienced more.

[@Watcher-hh4mu]

I'm pretty sure those ideals come from Dutch. He was the idealistic proto-socialist that taught people to read and how to think like him. That's why John knows him so well in RDR1, especially when he explains his ideals to the Mexican revolutionary in Mexico.

[@thecowboy9698]

@@fuckingfuck1972 - As does everyone.

[@freemanduder]

5:47 Holy shit I've never noticed this till now. Look at John, how when he is woken up from his sleep by a third party does he reach for his gun as a first reaction? Truly a display of his outlaw background, one we did not see until the prequel. Read that in Snake Oils Man's voice if my drunk English isn't good enough for you.

[@nood1le]

Nice catching

[@drewzoobulandes4184]

Damn I hadn't noticed he was drawing nice eye for detail my man.

[@Bithe_Get]

Yeah, very wild background. *John calmly sleeping in the camp* (Literally never never gets out to do anything if it isnt a main mission there isnt even side camp activities with him like going out to rob a place or smth like that)

[@imarealone_0076]

​@@Bithe_Getrdr2 had to ruin john bc he would've easily overshadowed arthur

[@ShimSladyBrand]

@@imarealone_0076it’s called character progression

[@annetteespinoza842]

They flirt a lot for simply being friends

[@bigfootwithinternetconnect2330]

Well it did look like she fell for him

[@yaro42]

@@bigfootwithinternetconnect2330 she did 100%, if not for Abigail, John would probably went for it

[@joynelbonetdelgado4952]

Yeah well that happens

[@barackyobama6139]

What kind of friends would anyone be if they didn't flirt with eachother?

[@mari-wf2jx]

She had a crush on him sooo

[@Halopen94]

Can't herd, can't swim.

[@dylana.9057]

That dialogue had me rolling . Arthur my man is much better than john

[@Halopen94]

@@dylana.9057 I'd say his character is a bit more complex than Johns but I love them both. But yeah Arthur is 1% above John at everything, exept for swimming and herding lol

[@dylana.9057]

Halopen94 Yeah John is so good . But Arthur is more " relatable " for the player ( especially when you start reading his journal and what he thinks about life and human condition ) . I think Arthur is more interesting , hence why the character development is better . But John is the classic cowboy , handsome guy that everyone loves . And a tragic character too . However these 2 are some of the best protagonists in any game ever ! That's for sure

[@Halopen94]

@@dylana.9057 Fully agreed. I prefer Arthur as well but its pretty close

[@dylana.9057]

Halopen94 Do you own a PS4 ??

[@realdude6145]

I’ve noticed that they call John and Arthur dumb but marston has a good vocabulary and Arthur is damn near a poet/artist

[@cedfiaenthusiast4240]

We just can't have a normal rdr game without people linking rdr 2..

[@Master_Udon]

@@DeadX2 nah, i'd call it a good writing. RDR 2 overshadowed RDR but props to rockstar's writing, both are masterpiece in storyline.

[@jim8571]

They gave all of John's qualities to Arthur...

[@Mitchisable]

​@@Master_UdonExcept when the writers in RDR2 forgot about John's daughter

[@aggserp4340]

​@@MitchisableMaybe she was born between RDR2 and 1. It was pretty common for children to die young back then.

[@Betterhose]

11:05 "Ugh. Call me Bonnie you fool! Call me Bonnie." "MISS MCFARLANE. I'm married. I have a son." 😄😄😄

[@nameless6923]

oof

[@thatguy8777]

Bro really hit her with the "I have a girlfriend" 💀

[@karadanianoI]

TBH she was getting real close and "friendly "to him, keep in mind that in this time you would only call someone by their first name if you were very close to them, if you didnt know somebody too well it would seem rude and out of place. he needed to put that boundary before things escalated

[@RickJoystick]

@@karadanianoIBonnie is better than Abigail. I would have divorced her for Bonnie.

[@Eliteshot135]

@@karadanianoI in Bonnie’s defense she had no idea John was married until he spoke up at 11:17

[@julianm9932]

It sucks Bonnie just keeps getting fucked over by everything. I loved her man but she was always getting dealt bad cards

[@reservoirfrogs2177]

@Benny Fair fax Yeah, but if he went with Bonnie he would have been hunted and killed at her ranch in front of her and then her life would have been even worse

[@prosimian]

@Mad Max Rockatansky Jack is like 20 years younger than Bonnie

[@megaavonaco9954]

Really tho, the guy who wanted to marry bonnie died in rdr2. Hell, because we can’t see Bonnie due being able to play as John marston later, so she never found out what happened to him.

[@smileysatanson3404]

yeah i mean in the second game you can find a letter from her dead lover

[@oldarthurmorgan6319]

Loved John more lol

[@TwiggyArmstrong]

32:22 and 33:44 was heartbreaking. She just felt a bit disappointed hearing that John was married even though John told her that he was many times. As he leaves, she feels lost and heartbroken.

[@r011ing_thunder6]

He spoke a bit slow when he saw Bonnie lien he was unsure 😐

[@saputro2552]

I agree

[@salvadorenoify]

I quess its more like saying I have a family and I can’t let them leave behind I have to take care of them

[@greedyanimal3148]

When I played saw that cutscene for the first time i genuinely felt bad for Bonnie because I could tell that she really did have a thing for him.

[@spacecowboy1438]

"Baby Rabies"

[@Everik-ct6pg]

1:39 can we just appreciate how great that line and delivery was?

[@Obscurum]

yes we can

[@ijustwantmyphonecall6947]

@@swimsanta3132 You had time to think about that. Probably the only 3 you could name.

[@EddieFreak]

I just want my phone call dawg wtf that is a very common thing are you drunk? Literally fucking Incredibles had it, Spider-Man far from home had it, that shit game anthem had it. It’s common. Don’t make it bad necessarily, but it’s common

[@breezetha27]

Swim Santa doesn't make sense considering the fact that both john and bill were equally threaten like shit in the Dutch van der linde gang, bill being called a fool and a drunk and john always needing to be saved him saying "now I'm in charge" isn't him surpassing john it's him gladly expenses in the fact that the old leader and fellow gang members are no longer banded and or dead

[@stevenuribe7346]

Swim Santa I can tell no one likes you and people don’t enjoy your company

[@DreKC]

16:44 Love the way Mr. MacFarlane leans in a little bit as he delivers the line. It looks so realistic.

[@jaytee1766]

mocap or waterver it’s real acting

[@suleim4n]

Motion capture

[@darryldraven9093]

Bill was an alright guy in Red dead redemption 2

[@sethprestenback8617]

Darryl Draven Well he is considered “a wolf in sheeps clothing,” by Arthur and Hosea. Bill simply became fully realized when there was no one to stop him from doing what he pleased.

[@bradydavis5791]

Nah, he wasn't. He was dumb, though.

[@WackRusDud]

@@bradydavis5791 better than Micah, that's for sure.

[@donovanwilliams1378]

bill: you always thought I was an idiot

[@simplelife88393]

He got shit on a lot by Dutch.

[@lrc2k8]

33:38 This almost brought tears to my eyes😢 This is the last time Bonnie saw John. So ominous

[@qwertyki9367]

whats ominous

[@lrc2k8]

@@qwertyki9367 Ominous means, giving the impression that something bad is about to happen

[@channeljohnnyYT]

john and bonnie, arthur and sadie DAMMIT ROCKSTAR LET ME DO WHAT I WANT

[@eddieezcobar]

IKR?

[@joynelbonetdelgado4952]

Red and Annie from Red Dead Revolver too. It's like they keep making the same characters with a few differences lol

[@enriquepowers]

​@83rdox I think he's comparing their relationship, not exactly their character

[@milesupshur4179]

Bonnie was cool but I liked Abigail too Bonnie was like the school girl who had a crush on a hero of hers

[@machosadness8821]

John has a wife and Arthur is in love with his ex-girlfriend, so no.

[@ITzAhhMehMardio]

rdr2 makes me appreciate the characterization of john in rdr a lot more. you can really tell how much wiser and older he is in this game when compared to rdr2.

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

Yeah but they could have achieved that without making him a complete moron in rdr2

[@TimedRevolver]

@@Pedro_Le_Chef Sometimes people become wise elders because they were young idiots.

[@rxge1]

@@DeadX2 he didn't get downgraded, he was young and inexperienced, after Jack's kidnapping you can see how he started to be more hardworking and stopped taking BS

[@Bithe_Get]

He's just straight up downgraded to make room for arthur lol seems rockstar didnt trusted the new protagonist enough so they nerfed the og

[@Bithe_Get]

@@rxge1 "younger' "sttoped taking bs" my man john wasnt half the tough guy sadie was during rdr2 they just straight downgraded him

[@MetRighteousTV]

Not one useless character in the game. All side characters had their own personality

[@smileysatanson3404]

so sad seeing her kick the dust around, wishing she was Mrs. Marston instead, this game was truly amazing

[@freebird264]

The MacFarlanes are such honest genuine people. John rode back into their lives after helping them as much as they needed and they didn't hesitate to sell him cattle in gratitude.

[@stevej71393]

Bonnie is how a female character should be done. She's smart, witty, capable, down-to-earth, but most importantly, she's realistic and has limits. I was disappointed that she did not appear in RDR2.

[@rrazelp833]

She is in rdr2

[@ventexovakon2178]

..and pretty to boot

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

I am disapointed she was replaced by Sadie

[@cakeblade6954]

She is a free roam mission lady in rdr2 online

[@aelius3805]

I agree, John would have died without her help, and she would have been in worse shape or died without his. If RDR was made today she would have probably freed herself from that noose and killed all of the outlaws alone.

[@Neo-lp3vb]

25:45 that shrug John does is hilarious

[@DatMentalGamer]

indeed

[@ZealepYT]

It even looks like he's looking at the camera, pulling a Jim. lmao

[@H.K.5]

John and Arthur's sense of humour are almost the same.

[@unknownassailant157]

"Hello audience... ...you're probably wondering how I got here..."

[@samjackson9560]

32:00

[@anzhehuang2921]

That ain’t fair Bill! I pressed Greet every time I saw you as Arthur!

[@unkindledasha7309]

13:51 Bonnie: Listen, can you help me? John: Well I can try. What do you need? Money? I have a riverboat full of gold and cash.

[@alexdeghost2729]

*had

[@Bithe_Get]

He paid his bank loans with that

[@_NoodlesMedia_]

In the 20+ times I've beat this game, I never noticed John was barefoot in the scene at 4:27

[@deadgambler879]

Holy shit.......its so minimal but i never saw it Impressive

[@nicklynch216]

Bruh, I must have replayed this game 100 times and never noticed

[@thefreshprincer5587]

Mmmhhh... feet 🤤🤤🤤🤤🤤

[@Joedoeem]

Bruh ive beaten this game a year ago and played it 5 times without beating it

[@lightningmcqueef743]

@@thefreshprincer5587 🤨

[@0dot9]

13:32 the look she gave him after he called her bonnie…

[@hercul4n0]

33:48 This scene cut my heart

[@lrc2k8]

Me too. This was the last time she saw John. John was murdered after this scene.

[@Joedoeem]

@@lrc2k8 well he was betrayed by edgar for no reason and the whole pinkertons (or the fbi)

[@lrc2k8]

@@Joedoeem I know, thats why i left many holes in him as Jack Marston😅

[@community_elbow]

@@Joedoeem i still think its interesting about what Dutch said before he died. "When I'm gone, they'll just find another monster to kill to justify their wages." And that's what they did, they needed another target to kill to keep getting paid and John was an easy one.

[@dmalak4509]

@@lrc2k8 And it’s funny that Amos who she thinks is another “countrified” man walks by her. Although it’s not implied who she married, when playing poker with Amos at the ranch he will mention how much he wants to marry her.

[@jordy1682]

The dialogue is so realistic sometimes and makes u feel like you’re there

[@cristianskahan2157]

I love that John is still wearing Arthur’s satchel.

[@DHCNetwork06]

At the ending. Wasn't Jack wearing Arthur's jacket? Looks a lot like it.

[@Vanerov]

@@DHCNetwork06 No. The Jackets are different.

[@nicklynch216]

@@Vanerov maybe it is, but R* used a new engine and textured it more different

[@Vanerov]

@@nicklynch216 Its different...

[@alan370z4]

It’s not the same imo cause there are a « john’s satchel » and a « arthur’s satchel » in the epilogue of rdr 2

[@mal_3157]

3:34 $15 is about $416 in today’s money.

[@Bithe_Get]

So why a aplle its 2 dollars

[@harambe1331]

@@Bithe_Get purchasing power and value over dollar amount

[@Ghost-qo5of]

1$ is x30 the $ today so

[@julianramirez580]

Inflation is killing us

[@mycycleminorities]

Me playing RDR with $5,757: stonks

[@MrJinglejanglejingle]

Poor Drew. He's gone through so much shit. You can hear the desperation and fear in his voice at 24:15

[@skxlter5747]

Well yeah alot of his kids had died and Bonnie is the only daughter he ever had and felt proud of and loved her and if he lost her he wouldn't know what to do

[@TurkishBread_]

and then he gets his head shot clean off by marston in undead nightmare 😊

[@smoker5989]

@@TurkishBread_ yeah but undead nightmare ain't cannon

[@JohnFortniteKennedy_]

@@smoker5989 yeah, but idk it just seems- hard to not think its not canon for some reason help!6!6

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

Definately one of the best performances in the series

[@theonlyplain]

John saved ranches. In 1907 and 1911. John saved gaming industries to push further. In 2011 till today.

[@Okk030]

John The Don John El Don

[@Henchman.24]

Tbh if I was Bonnie McFarlane I'd be so fucking relieved to hear the stranger and potential insane person I spent money saving could speak intelligently and thoughtfully after days of unconsciousness.

[@aaronyandell2929]

Even in his nightmares, Bonnie exists. Oh, that came out wrong.

[@gzs98]

Amazing how the facial expressions still hold up to this year. Great game!

[@noah_body_cares]

37:56 he doesn't even offer if she wants to tag along with him💀 Poor Bonnie can't get a break

[@BOMBON187]

21:20 "White trash can be pretty frightening" The Skinners and Murfree Brood agree. Hell that statement stands true even to this day.

[@lol-un6nl]

The stinners were majority navites

[@kino9521]

That quote at 12:24 is great Theres a feeling in the original game that simply is not on the second. Also the soundtrack and the story telling is better in my opinion

[@hunnerboi8561]

70% of the story in this game is just doing favors for people so they can give you information about where Bill and Javier are.

[@kino9521]

Jimmy Dean I’m aware of that, and i still like it more than RDR2’s story, but that’s just my opinion.

[@legendgamer676]

I agree, I feel like this games story is more introspective and personal than RDR2. Not taking anything away from RDR2 though because it’s a goddamn masterpiece

[@Outrigger200]

Soncho John says it to Hosea in a random camp dialogue in rdr2

[@JasonToddEatsCrowbars]

@@Outrigger200 John also says it in Chapter 6 when you're sitting at the camp fire

[@placenitis]

Damn. Abigail can run!

[@josephkerr5018]

11:07 John: Miss MacFarlane

[@DatMentalGamer]

you gotta love John's respect ;)

[@zaybans23]

-Dat Mental Gamer- *OUTTA THE DAMN WAY*

[@thecowboy9698]

Hard to believe this man is the same John Marston we met in RDR2. He did grow and mature during the 12 years since 1899.

[@larsongame4120]

“You know Bill Williamson?” “Knew him. Long time ago,” “Well, what was he like?” “Dumb,” 🤣🤣🤣

[@kennymccormick9628]

Accurate

[@Kyrious]

The conversations in this game sound so natural.

[@Sergio8HD]

We can all agree Rockstar always has the best dialogues, didn't remeber how perfect this game was, just like rdr2

[@EdouardPicard0224]

Yes it does. Unfortunately, RDR2 fans likes to shit on this game.

[@nonnolucamatteo]

True

[@kirbyisdonewithyourbs2810]

The shooting was also less shaky in this game which makes you FEEL like a gunslinger.

[@danwordgod2017]

@@EdouardPicard0224 Lol, which do that fans exactly? I haven't seen anyone, real RDR fans love both games.

[@memecliparchives2254]

@@danwordgod2017 The new fans who just played 2.

[@darth_yeet3487]

“Well you know I can’t read” had me dying 😂😂

[@lewisjohnston7077]

Abigail is dyslexic

[@thatquietasianguy9582]

The voice acting in this game is legit scaring me out it’s too good…

[@MeganS-rd7dg]

It was performance capture

[@ethan8804]

They learned a lot from each other, the chemistry between the two was powerful.

[@OGvibes-tq6zl]

33:52 she really wanted him so bad😩😥😭

[@despacitodaniel801]

As a friend

[@asc8194]

@@despacitodaniel801 who knows?

[@lightningmcqueef743]

@@despacitodaniel801 yeah a friend with privileges

[@TwiggyArmstrong]

@@despacitodaniel801 she wanted him. Seeing her arm drop when John told her to meet his wife just shattered her. She knew he was married but seeing his wife was like rubbing it in her face that she can’t have him. .

[@r011ing_thunder6]

@@lightningmcqueef743 black privilege or white privilege?

[@othelliusmaximus]

33:44 knowing what happens to the Marstons next makes this so much sadder.

[@Jaguadarte__]

So happy she's in Red Dead Online. Unfortunately the Online part of the game is shit right now.

[@ibra84him]

Still shit

[@aegirgabriel2399]

Still shit

[@RandalfElVikingo]

Shit still, boah.

[@oneshotf301]

Still shit

[@ek7404]

Good now in my opinion, lots more stuff to do. Only annoying thing is the disappearing camp bug

[@lucaskcvc3480]

Isnt there a letter to Bonnie MacFarlane that you get from a drowned guy in RDR2??

[@carolynegeng9675]

Yep!

[@Kelly14UK]

Yeah. Found it across from Great Plains on the sands.

[@mailboxavenger644]

Maybe they could include that to red dead redemption remastered Since it was rumored that it's will be a dlc for rdr2

[@Joedoeem]

@@mailboxavenger644 i do too and i hope john, javier, uncle, bill and dutch and i wish the last misfits would say like "You wouldn't be here without arthur you bastard!"

[@Raidxn96]

Yooo Bonnie’s actually in red dead 2 online just did a stranger mission for her last nite lmao shit was crazy to see her at the farm seeing as you cant find her in story mode

[@unlightings]

I believe the reason why she isn't in story mode is because of this, pulled straight from the wiki: "Events of Red Dead Redemption 2: Bonnie is mentioned along with her father, Drew, as having to get out of New Austin temporarily due to a cholera outbreak afflicting the populace in the territory."

[@thedeathstar420]

man rdr1 became such a special game after rdr 2. I hope they make a prequel to rdr2 showing the origins of the van der linde gang and make rdr2 even more special that what it already is

[@ella1774]

32:10 I am speed

[@Joedoeem]

Lol never knew a woman could match the speed of usain bolt

[@ReaverVandal]

I prefer the way he talks in here. On RDR 2 he sounds like uhh.. How do you say it -raspy?

[@DoctorMikeYT]

SevenFriday Well newer equipments and the time gap, can make a difference.

[@goodkill8335]

Well the voice actor was about 8 years younger here

[@AvatarJian]

@dayum son source for this? For some reason I noticed that he sounded younger to me even though his voice sounded raspy and different from RDR1.

[@AvatarJian]

@Eoghan That other user still hasn't provided a source for Rockstar specifically making the voice sound that way. I'm sure it's more because Rob Weitoff, the voice actor for John Marston smokes combining that with his voice changing over the years. It happens to many voice actors.

[@anthonyspitery6332]

WELL THE ACTOR DID AGE LIKE 10 YEARS and probably smokes

[@Winabagel23]

Bonnie and John definitely have way more chemistry than John and Abigail

[@cocob0l0]

After RDR2, fuck no

[@supremedreams6789]

I use to agree with this back when RDR1 first came out. But RDR2 really expanded on Abigail and John’s relationship.

[@Orophile_303]

Nope. They're my favorite couple. Wouldn't change them.

[@laydenkingery8268]

Imagine if a Arthur hadn’t have passed away and him and John both showed up at bills.

[@chasevids14]

John: Bill Bill I’ve come for you Bill: Go away now John Arthur: Dammit Boah get down here Bill: Yes sir! On the way!

[@laydenkingery8268]

@@chasevids14 lol that’s how it would be.

[@laydenkingery8268]

@DMRS: Servus Christi I doubt he would actually do it tho.

[@laydenkingery8268]

@DMRS: Servus Christi Yea to save his family or at least fake Arthur’s death.

[@ChonkedCat]

@DMRS: Servus Christi no he wouldn’t, Arthur saved his life and put him on the right path

[@mikaeldahlqvist399]

The MacFarlane family were really good to John, hard to come by such people in those days.. And in ways, hard to come by even today.

[@Misty8097]

I'd argue it's even harder today.

[@MrBossFML]

I feel bad for what Bonnie must of felt like once she heard John died

[@lsr444]

I really love how John ang Abigail talks to each other..

[@boden_gamerboy6139]

4:22 makes me smile evry time

[@joynelbonetdelgado4952]

30:17 what is Jack doing? lol

[@thatquietasianguy9582]

Nae nae

[@albertoocampo35]

Jack's a little different lol

[@Gazpacho834]

I really wish there was a funeral scene for John where everyone he’s helped payed their respects.

[@JKF10210]

that would've been the most amazing thing to see

[@Nixonforprez68]

Find a woman who looks at you the way Bonnie looks at John lmao

[@donvalve2257]

I'm probably the only one here, but i'm happy she married Amos in the end. He was always loyal to her and her father, he maybe not an adventurer like John but in the end is a nice guy and he always liked her, after all they grew up together.

[@MrKiron12]

Bonnie>>>>Sadie Fite me

[@CellJr.]

Nahhh

[@2literoverlord482]

Yeah Bonnie didn’t fuck up every mission like Sadie

[@pelucheCR7]

I prefer sadie, she was more interesting.

[@Obscurum]

Bonnie is better of course

[@justinguyton6400]

Gtfo

[@mari-wf2jx]

“Just don’t be two people at once that’s all I’m saying”

[@guarded_sheriff1934]

They need a remasterd

[@yaro42]

Inside rdr2

[@volnisobrinho4465]

Retro..

[@josephconti4265]

Just port Red Dead Redemption in to Red Dead Redemption 2 and add Mexico and price it at $30 - $40 as story DLC.

[@ulises.-.5455]

@@josephconti4265 well, since they made rdr2 in 8 years that would be done like in 3 years making Mexico,doing the other characters and new voicelines etc. And it would have to have a 60 price and sold as a separate game

[@marcowulliampopirers2216]

seeing how the xbox one x performs rdr i dont think we rlly need a remaster yet,maybe a remake that adds some things,and upgrades the game in other ways aside from the tecnical ones

[@Kelly14UK]

Cholera free Armadillo. 1911.

[@Goji938]

That conversation with her dad is so good. That shit still relevant today.

[@kiefermcginty6189]

There's nothing more intense than saving Bonnie MacFarlane

[@YTrap.Outlaw]

*Wakes up* Strange woman: “Well you’re alive”

[@DatMentalGamer]

part of me wishes John and Bonnie settled down (in undead nightmare anyway, due to his family being zombies)

[@tinanikkillz8570]

They turn back at the end of the campaign (not the free roam after the end of the story)

[@VictorTorres-rg9lp]

Tinanik Killz during the campaign if you go back to the house. John stop at the door due to his wife or son talking to him or hearing a echo of them.

[@tinanikkillz8570]

@@VictorTorres-rg9lp while their still zombies?

[@VictorTorres-rg9lp]

Tinanik Killz yeah John was probably just losing his mind a bit considering everything happening around him.

[@Balkancuga]

I playes rdr1 a few days ago and i was at sheriffs office at macfarlanes ranch with Jack (i beat the game) and a sheriff said "Miss Macfarlane saves Johns life but John didnt save hers".

[@Balkancuga]

@Somber& Gold Im 100% sure.In Sheriffs Office, i was doing the Nightime job and i came for reward and some guy or sheriff said that before i cracked the safe lol.

[@unofficial-rights2022]

this is some story. very interesting. Bonnie was always nice and helpful to John. I visited this ranch as John in RDR2 but it was somewhat abandoned. just a few folks. and nearby a nasty gang called Los LOBOS . had my encounter with them. thanks for this video. very very cool. have a good one.

[@Tevi_L7151]

The developers should have made sure that none of them met earlier than indicated in the plot

[@rooster5228]

I love the beginning of undead nightmare it’s like those old scary movies

[@dannylou95]

i love the dialogue in both this and RD2

[@stefonsomers2963]

“Hold your excuses until you figure out which one to use” 🥶😂

[@milesmarimbire1640]

Bonnie like John lol

[@Obscurum]

she does like him

[@Official_Zy388]

Can we admit how funny red dead redemption is 😂😂😂the accents are perfect

[@mspionage1743]

Ironic to consider that if John ended up staying with Bonnie he probably would have survived as the Pinkertons would have been way... way more hesitant to attack him then considering the wealth of the ranch owner.

[@TimedRevolver]

Her dad was in debt, and didn't have much power. He was also anti-government, so they would have been more willing to shoot than anything. Remember, they were being led by a traitorous bastard.

[@braden2206]

Take a shot every time she says "Mr. Marston".

[@everlels7608]

Take another shot whenever John says "Miss Macfarlane"

[@diva1675]

John or jack should teach Abigail to read.

[@tinanikkillz8570]

Kind of too late......

[@redpractition]

about 106 years too late

[@Okk030]

@@redpractition 107

[@babykrul]

I lost it at 7:51 when you sped up the video and the whistle sounds like a meme 😂 the chipmunk voices why did you do that I’m laughing so hard 😂😂😂

[@jeromywong6041]

My controversial opinion is that RDR 1 soundtrack is much MUCH better than RDR 2

[@coreycasciano3255]

Jeromy Wong I'd say they are both great but RDR 1 was a bit better

[@kirbyisdonewithyourbs2810]

I think the ambience of rdr1 is better and the music feels like something you expect from a game set in the west.

[@ElNiNjA246]

the dialogue is even better

[@joaoguilhermeesteves4531]

well rdr1 has Dead man's gun so I see your point they are close tho

[@lockandreload]

Everything about RDR1 is better than 2, except graphics (obviously). But for some reason RDR2 has an army of zoomers/Redditors fanboys who think it's the greatest game ever made.

[@albertvonmollendorf5621]

John looks like a true cowboy in RDR1 😆

[@eggy6815]

31:01 I like how John actually read it a little first just to make sure it wasn’t a love letter XD

[@user-ug4yo5ep2x]

That violin 🎻 in the last encounter ❤ The composer and the violinist got me!! Any information about them?

[@timhughes7653]

The characters in RDR1 were so much more memorable than in rdr2.... I miss this game

[@brigs247__8]

I disagree. Sadie and Charles are equally as engaging as characters like bonnie and Landon, and the camp characters are also very engaging. And Arthur is one of the greatest video game protagonists, like John.

[@alexdeghost2729]

Then u hardly played RDR2

[@lockandreload]

Big facts. Seth, Nigel West Dickens, Irish, Bonnie, Marshal, the deputies, Landon Ricketts, Allende, De Santa, Reyes, Luisa, Ross and Ford, all much more entertaining than Dutch's boring ass gang of nobodies. Arthur and Sadie are the only new characters that stood out to me.

@@lockandreload Sadie is crap character (the worst). how is this gritty realistic western story justify a woody's round up feminist? let's be real here women are not men and should not be written like that. the way Sadie steals john's light in the end of rd2 is unforgivable. the man could of went bounty hunting himself why does he need this political correct trope to show him how to be a real man? it is cringe. bad enough john is wrote terribly in rd2 a goofy fool that has to be rescued all the time. not once throughout the whole story of rd2 did john come on like the man we see in rd1. the end with the mountain in rd2 comes out of nowhere and seems off considering throughout the whole game john is played like a joke. having Sadie down talk him makes it even worse f her character.

[@jacksongibbs8998]

She’s a firecracker, she is.

[@The_Honcho]

Thanks Rockstar, thanks for activating my crippling tomboy obsession

[@ivanivanow4642]

So Jack never visits the MacFarlanes after John's death? That's a bummer.

[@Stormertheboy]

Reasons why Bonnie is better for John than Abigail 1. She’s better looking (imo) 2. She doesn’t complain every second 3. She actually knows how to cook, read and do ranch work. 4. She saved Johns life...

[@redlobster1143]

Well, without abigail's complaining john would probably be dead even before he left the van der linde gang.

[@graysonguinn1943]

Abigail is a straight waifu in rdr2 though

[@penthos9783]

Why not both?

[@doctorlove3536]

Omar reasons why abigail is better for john 1. Jack 2. Jack 3. Jack 4. Uncle 5. Jack

[@josephstalin2606]

If anybody were John I think most would’ve hooked up with Bonnie but we gotta respect John for remaining loyal to Abigail even if she’s in some ways inferior to Bonnie. John is a good man

[@danielmcgravie2929]

6:06 this is a fine weapon. Proceeds to never use it again after getting any other repeater or rifle

[@CharlesSmooth1]

Also is one of the weakest longarms in the game haha

[@dmalak4509]

@@CharlesSmooth1 That’s why the 2nd game does a good job with the weapons. Every weapon is viable and useable. In this one you immediately dropped the carbine repeater once your able to purchase a Springfield rifle and pickup a Winchester from one of the missions. Same as the cattleman revolver once Rickets gives you a Schofield.

[@CharlesSmooth1]

@@dmalak4509 weirdly for me, after doing a play through of RDR2 and then going back to play RDR1, the guns in 1 feel more powerful, especially the pistols. Comparing the Cattleman in both, I’d say it sounds and feels more powerful in 1 than 2, but that’s just me

[@onemetro7987]

This is the greatest release in history

[@juanjosemendivil1626]

Who here like the background when it rains in a cutscene?

[@jib1823]

33:14 that line fucking killed me lmfao

[@shane-vc9qq]

11:23. Why did rockstar forget this and completely abandon the idea ?

[@august8696]

it probably happened between games

[@Doctor_Yodel]

Augustus IV yeah I think so

[@trilobite2500]

But there is no grave of this mysterious daughter.

[@stxrmbreak]

Alzog ad be Manda'yaim Söldner der NWO there was like 8 years between the main game and epilogue- her grave could be anywhere in America. they even go to Canada at one point

[@josephstalin2606]

stxrmbreak If you capture Javier alive he says “I hope your wife and children rot in hell” so that would suggest he knew about Johns daughter despite not seeing John since the gang fell apart 12 years prior. I think rockstar just messed up and forgot about it

[@Gongasoso]

That doctor seriously buffed John up. After that he only dropped after 5-6 bullets

[@linhza501]

I love Bonnie's character. She has a great sense of humour.

[@MS-sv1tr]

She's lesbian

[@batonusio]

1 no she aint 2 what would that change@@MS-sv1tr