Was it a MISTAKE to Get 2023 BMW X3 M40i After We Finally Test Drove 2023 Lexus RX 350?

[@dezrok1]

I looked at both but ended up with the X3 m40i in Brooklyn Grey. It's a beautiful car. I preferred the bmw drive and looks. It's super fun.

[@100miledrive]

Oh yes Brooklyn Grey is very beautiful color. Congrats on your car

[@kevinb6745]

Likewise!

[@njbloke]

Great content. Well done!

[@100miledrive]

Thank you. Thanks for stopping by

[@ZERO_SVN]

I went with a GV70 but just helped my uncle get an RX350 (which I'm really impressed with). I also looked at the m340i but felt it was a bit too much for a daily driver. The GV70 is comfortable and luxurious in eco/comfort mode, but put it in Sports and it's like a different car. Not M340i level but enough to put a smile on my face. Didn't even consider the NX.

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for the comment and the feedback. I actually reviewed GV 70 last week and my review is out. You can watch to see how i compared it to X3 M40i. Thanks for stopping by

[@paulstewart3010]

I at present own a 2022 UK spec Lexus RX 450h, Premium Sport which will be getting changed next year (2025) Looking already at the brand new Lexus RX 450h+ in Premium Plus trim level (as it's now called) plus it's now a plug-in hybrid) thinking also of the BMW X3/X5 but to be honest, feeling completely lost!! In my time with the Lexus brand, I honestly CAN'T fault it nor my Lexus Dealership in anyway!! The fuel economy has also been superb for such a large car with a 3.5 v6 petrol engine!! and yes, the comfort it gives is truely superb!! Do I stay with the Lexus brand, or do I give BMW a try? Even though BMW reliability is ranked 15th, compaired to Lexus at No.1!! A really hard choice tbh, and which BMW trim level would be near the same as my current car?? Please someone help/give me some good advice here!! x

[@100miledrive]

Responding a little late here. From what I am reading in your comment here it is probably better to stay within Lexus family to enjoy the ride comfort and reliability that BMW still cannot match. I encourage you to watch my video where I discuss all RX trims, specifically their suspension, I suggest you also consider RX 500h. X5 offers different I would say a bit more premium experience in terms of driving dynamics. If ride comfort is your number 1 priority then stay with Lexus. If you want to have more dynamically sound car then I recommend X5 (not X3) as it offers a good blend of comfort and sport. Hope this helps.

[@Wisdom7I]

I have enjoyed your reviews because you bring a different perspective. You like fast performance cars with an emphasis on looks over comfort. Money is not a concern for you. The RX350 is definitely not for you, but the Honda CRV might have met most of your needs based on your impression of that car and saved your family lots of money. But I get it, I love BMW too.

[@100miledrive]

Thanks a lot for your kind words and feedback. In my reviews I put myself in the shoes of what it would be like if I were to own many of these cars that I review. Starting this channel was derived from my mere curiosity about all these cars from economy to exotic ones. And I am happy to share my thoughts and real world experience driving and comparing these cars.

[@d3j051]

I have a similar dilemma with my spouse, I like luxury but need performance and she leans towards luxury, solution is the X5 with this engine. That's what we bought, 2023 X5 and we both love it. Yes, a little more expensive so that will be a deal breaker for some but what a car.

[@100miledrive]

Yep, yep, thanks for sharing. We actually loved X5, we rented it once to drive from California to Texas and back. It's a great car, but for some reason even with same MSRP as X3 M40i it was few hundred dollars more in Lease payment. So I was fine with X3 M40i knowing it's B58 engine and how fun to drive it, but wife wanted X5 :). So we'll see. I think once, soon I bring new X5 on the channel she will reassure me that this is the car she wants :)

[@tonyantonuccio4748]

I've had a couple of BMWs in the past. Their level of parts and workmanship failure is unacceptable, especially at their price point. They're OK if you lease them, dumping them every 3 years, or so, passing on their troubles to the next sucker. Presently, I'm on my second RX (350h Premium+, in copper). The ride and handling are much improved. The handling is, of course, not in BMW's class but I'm fine with that because what it does deliver, comfort with quiet precision, is simply superb. It doesn't float or wallow, like the old ones did. The seats are firmer but still comfy. The room inside is exceptional, high quality, and beautiful.

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for your feedback. I was quite impressed with the new RX350 as it’s chassis is far more refined compare to the older model. Interior quality is top notch. BMW’s reliability improved over the years, I have now seen my friends drive their BMWs close to 100K miles without major issues, but of course no comparison to Lexus. I think it’s nice to have both cars: a fun one and a reliable comfortable cruiser.

[@midiman5045]

i looked at a 2024 RX350 and a X3. I didn't like the RX350 4 cylinder turbo it is too small for that car. It's great for the NX but not the RX. I got a RX 2022 CPO. X3 well maintenance after 3 years is a killer. Now for the > It doesn't float or wallow like the older ones. I don't feel that at all in the 2022. Maybe you can explain in more detail.

[@JohnReis-t5o]

Great review. I just subscribed to your channel as a result. Do you know where I could rent and M40i for a couple of days in the Tampa/Ft. Myers area? Before committing to something like this, I need more than just a test drive around the block.

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for subscribing. I checked Turo in that area and only see X3 30i. If you are not in rush you can keep on checking on Turo, maybe one will pop up in your area. Also, checked Orlando, FL they also have only X3 30i but many more cars. Maybe 1 will show up there sometime soon. This is far but not as far as Miami. Otherwise Miami has X3 M40i for sure and maybe if you are visiting Miami anytime soon then you could plan on renting one there from Turo. Another thing you can do is check inventory of used 2022-2023 models in BMW dealerships and if you see one - email them and ask for more extended test drive where you could drive it for up to 50 miles. 1 local dealer in CA offered here such an option. Just let them know you are a serious buyer and may consider that used one or even a new one. Other option would be to hit people in forums on Facebook. There are many BMW forums and see if you can arrange maybe to pay someone to rent for 1 day or few hours. Hope this helps

[@Zwikster]

What about the day to day use with that wierd Lexus touch screen? The BMW dash and actual buttons are so much more practical and better layout. Changing radio, GPS, climate control looks annoying on Lexus plus all that gloss black will be covered in gross fingerprints

[@100miledrive]

Oh, yes certainly not liking this new idea of putting everything in 1 screen and my X3 M40i feels so much better with actual buttons, however would like to disappoint you that BMW went the same route with new iDrive 8. No more memory buttons, no climate control buttons and BMW menu all converted into apps, everything is an App now, even heated steering on some new BMW is in the screen. I am looking at new X5 and not liking this at all. All auto makers having Tesla’s influence

[@kuopei626]

Nice comparison but i would take M40i for the performance since its different league

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for the feedback. So far most comments are for BMW. Yes X3 M40i certainly has more character.

[@HasanQazi]

Love your content! Also looking for an x3m40i as well so it's very helpful. Can I ask what dealer you got your car from? I'm in LA and I've hit up a few dealers so far, some willing to negotiate, some not at all. Appreciate it!

[@100miledrive]

Hi Hasan. Sure. I got mine from Buena Park BMW from Tai Khuram. Another place I negotiated with before was Rusnak BMW in Thousand Oaks. It also depends how many they have in the inventory and how motivated they are to move the car. I usually first go to dealer’s website, check inventory and then start hitting them up. It is certainly harder to negotiate now than before, but at least possible with BMW unlike many others like Lexus.

[@HasanQazi]

@@100miledrive thank you so much this is really helpful!! Did you consider ordering one? My wife and are trying to find one with ventilated seats but a few dealers said I would have to order that. We're in no rush so that could work and two dealers were happy to do it. Just not sure if they'll negotiate off MSRP...

[@100miledrive]

Initially I did preorder at Rusnak BMW and they even gave some off on the incoming car, then we decided we wanted other options and decided to preorder where they also honored discount but not the coupon that I had from Ultimate Driving Experience. But then I found a much better deal at Buena Park BMW on the car in stock. Basically they could give you some off on pre-order but not much, they are more likely to give better discount on the car in the inventory or at least a car in transit.

[@Wisdom7I]

@@100miledrive X3 will be a complete redesign for 2025, so can likely get a great deal on 2024 if want to save the most money. I bought a 330I 2023 in November after 2024 came out and I got a great deal - same car design.

[@100miledrive]

@@Wisdom7I Nice, congrats on your BMW. Yep with BMW I usually go to their Ultimate Drive Event around August here in LA, get $1000 off coupon and around November, December they would have really good Winter specials, plus you can negotiate even further to lower the price. It just sucks that just 4 years ago an average BMW was around $5-6K less. This inflation really affected car market, plus high interest rates.

[@saikrishnan8277]

Could you please post a video on why you didn’t like the NX. I own one and love driving it , but I am also a noob car owner and maybe missing out on a lot of things. So am really curious

[@100miledrive]

Overall NX is a good car. The main thing is that you like driving it. In my review I was hoping new NX absorbs bumps in more refined way. Also expected slightly better sound insulation which is in part due to run flat tires. Also suspension in cornering is reluctant to slice corners. New Lexus RX on the other hand has mprovements in these areas. But again many people don’t care too much about driving dynamics and are looking for Luxury and reliability, this is where NX scores good points. And it’s fairly comfortable with good seats. I hope this explains a bit. If you want to expand your understating on driving dynamics I highly recommend renting cars from different competitors especially Europeans and see how they perform. I hope this explains a bit

[@timhuynh6164]

Hey Brother, if you are enjoying the NX just enjoy it. I love youtube but watching too much of it fks everything up. Just drive and enjoy it until it is the right time to change it up.

[@donaldbanner2185]

Yep apparently it was too small........His wife chimed in and said she was fed up with SMALL Things...Hmmmmmmmmmmm?

[@timhuynh6164]

@@donaldbanner2185 If your wife is being a problem, gotta get rid of the problem bro.

[@plusforce]

You cannt get spare tire with NX.

[@jbpasion071]

Loving my 500h super smooth ride no complaints here.

[@plusforce]

Is it plug-in hybrid?

[@mannygomez154]

Lexus is for old people with a vanilla personality. It’s not even a comparison. BMW all day.

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for your feedback :)

[@donaldbanner2185]

BMW = Bring More Wallets..................................Ego stupid insecure owners that aspiet to idiot purchases

[@jonwear9791]

You are so right :) Lexus, for older folks.

[@Blackandwhitecat-u9v]

@@donaldbanner2185👈🤡

[@brunobredicean835]

At the end of the day the Lexus is going to start in the morning. The bmw always had a high chance of not starting lol. I rather drive off in my old person car than to be stranded at a parking waiting for the tow truck to come get my bmw 😂

[@Jameshhl]

Any chance you test the RX 500h F Sport 366hp hybrid 27mpg, similar pricing to a X3 M40i. I'm shopping between these 2 cars, having just paid off my Golf R, I wanted something a little bigger but just as fast (enter M40i), but I'm also really sick of having a harsh suspension over the last 5 years (enter RX 500h with softer suspension/ride quality but not as fast for a daily)

[@100miledrive]

I am keeping an eye on RX 500h F Sport. As soon as I can I will bring it on the channel. Make sure to subscribe.

[@gestebu]

That Lexus grill - no.

[@100miledrive]

:) yeah it's subjective. I am ok with it. What I don't like is new BMWs design language. New 7 series is the ugliest BMW i have ever seen

[@clbernier2]

These two SUVs are not even in the same class, plus BMWs are cars for drivers…the ultimate driving machine. The X5 is RX’s rival along with two absolute masters of ride excellence…Cadillac XT6 and Lincoln Aviator. The NX goes head to head with the X3 along with the Audi Q5, Infiniti QX50, Acura RDX, MB GLC, Genesis GX70, Volvo XC60, Cadillac CT5 and Lincoln Nautilus. Apples to Apples

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for the feedback, yes certainly this is not head to head comparison. I did briefly mention this in the video, but this was rather a choice between something more fun and something more calm but yet surprisingly balanced.

[@clbernier2]

@@100miledrive 👍🏼

[@peterlkwan8316]

if you look at the aged BMW and Lexus cars on the street, you will see the BMW is the winner and they last longer.

[@100miledrive]

As far as the looks maybe, but probably not in terms of reliability. Lexus has been #1 in terms of reliability for many years. It’s just Lexus is not a car for enthusiasts like BMW is

[@steverogers7211]

What? Lol no one has ever said this

[@Kwaminho]

I think you & your wife should test drive a base X5.

[@100miledrive]

Yes we did drive X5 many tines. We even had a road trip in X5 from CA to Texas and we did like it, but in configuration that we like with current rates it is far more expensive than X3. I personally love X3 M40i. I will bring new x5 on the channel once it comes out. Make sure to subscribe!

[@carreraenzo90]

I am absolutely torn on a similar decision and would tremendously value your feedback. X3 m30i versus a Genesis GV70 3.5. idk if you tried to the Genesis with the 3.5. Genesis interior is twice as good as anything BMW makes and better than Lexus by a mile. It's so luxurious, and probably has the quietest cabin in the segment. It has way more luxury and tech features than the BMW except for a few small exceptions (adaptive headlights, wireless AA). The power is decent, maybe 85-90% as good as the BMW drivetrain. Fuel economy is atrocious. But the ride is not as jittery.... Idk what to pick. Thoughts?

[@donaldbanner2185]

*~*~*~ Must use FREAK'n Premium gas on both and @ 18 miles per gallon flooring it with the beeemer' & beeemers Check Your Engine light Nightmare ad Korean Horrific transmissions.......Should have bought the LEXUS 450h+ F Sport!... See below: *~*~*~ Read entire below: Exact same Vehicle is the 2022 model & 2023 model.....Why change a GREAT great vehicle you found impossible to get! Was only available in Smog compliant states i.e. Calif & Florida....and then VERY very Limited, so econ 101 makes this car go up in price (if you can find one!, especially the "F" Sport 450h+). All wheel drive woth adaptive suspension: Unlike 98% of vehicles where you loose your Proverbial when you drive them off the lot. So, " ~*~*~*RUN Do-Not walk to the NX 450h+ "F" Sport! ... . I own the Lexus 2022 450h+ F sport. Elegant and refined!.....Note the Heads Up display on the windshield W/8” & 14” Info on Dash board with Crystal Clear display on both, alone makes the Lexus better........Mine is In Atomic Silver Glows in the Sun Light with Lil" grey / Gold metal flake" and same Circut Red interior.. but with Electric battery...Has 306 Horse power 0 to 60 in 5.6 sec (Via Road and track at drag strip!.) ** BIG NOTE: This model DOES- NOT have a TURBO...But rather, a Naturally aspirated / Carb...........(important because it is well known that TURBOS stress engines)...SEE: kzbin.info/www/bejne/lam8n4uIps2Ypas ...ON Turbo issues = Very Bad!..... I use Electricity exclusively non combustion! Simply said: see euro cars shop time & inevitable “ Check Engine Light CONTINUALLY!!....this car combines the Elec Batt and engine to achieve 89 miles per Gallon ( Uses 87% octane / Regular gas according to user manual) in Hybred mode with HIGH torq, And VERY quick out of the hole....*Jus' blew the doors off a 735i beeemer...albeit for only a block ...( I am no dummy, a V8 will eventually pass many cars in the long dist. (in all fairness) ......However, who cares the thrill is initial take off and tickets are for high speed & SPEED...Kill's! My car has Red Calipers against Powder coated Gloss spoke Black mags and All red "F" Sport Badges. Has ALL Nice Carbon Fiber on ALL interior some have Piano Black i.e. Center Consul arm rests dash board & rear center heater consul between seats. ** Don't mind at all making these kind of upgrades as when you drive off the lot and your * Car, Note: As this particular vehicle goes UP IN VALUE: do you know of ANY other vehicle that will Go UP IN Value today??? MY 450h+ has gone up in value $17K at this writing!. FAR better built than Euro's (mine built in Japan) sadly, new releases are now being made in Canada! Canada is Union Shop, Like USA Union shops...no one gets fired.... for a hang over and bad work??? maybe)..... However, Lexus is Far more reliable...Far better Re-Sale that Euro beemers or mercedes (Check Engine Light Gucci headache) .!... IF YOU CAN FIND ONE ANYWHERE do grab it!......"econ 101 / Supply & Demand" .....Has (3) elec. motors gett'n 0 to 60 in 5.6 sec (road and track) HIGH torque QUICK out of Hole!......~*~*Never EVER have I used gas * but highly comforting to have the option..... gett'n 47+ miles per 120 Volt charge (real world driving my experience.)....Almost Silent operation in elec....So do your research, PLEASE......as this is Far better than any European beemer, mercedes and korean etc. All those are depreciating the moment you drive off the lot & simple oil change / maintenance are extremely costly. The aforementioned Euros …....And are UNRELIABLE and get BAD Gas Mileage to say nothing of the: GAS HOG unproven G 70, & RDX not worth mentioning. Z Best of the BEST F Sport 450h+ ! ….One more thing, Jus' a heads up!......My wife drives the RX 2020 model...Consider putting Michelin's at $1000.00 0n / @ ebay deal is out the door and balanced......... on your NX 450h+ F Sport............ replace the Idiot Run Flats that the dealer wants a $1200.00 extra for warr because like me, You WILL eventually get a flat and the Run your WALLET Flats are required to replace??? are you freak'n kidding????....Michelin's primacy same size &......Far and away EVEN a much smoother ride, Shissh, Do Not tell my wife ...even smoother than her 2020 RX 350....because My "F" Sport has the added "Adaptive Suspension" along with lower center of gravity because of Large battery centered Low...+ Soft no roll stabil ride, Much better ride than the HARD Run Flat Bridgestones that come stock. I Carry a Batt. quality inflator ( DeWalt 20V MAX Corded/Cordless Air Inflator ) and string tar impregnated rope insert-er and Do-Not wait for AAA. Consider Use in Only Plug -in and a Hybred NOT a All electric Automobile!.........Using All electric YOU MUST consider YOUR Consider all the above insight, using a Credit Card to Open doors, start the car and monitor via phone app... & and You WILL Have the Best of the Best in the Lexus 450h+ “F” Sport and reflect having a Sophisticated, Elegant & classy platform as well! This vehicle has gone up in price approx. &17K+ at this writing, since I bought it! @ that increase in value what is the downside? ...Additionally the Korean CRAP!...Genesis,...... Has and is plegged with Transmission PROBLEMS i.e. the Torque Converter ...the Clutch & Solinoid issues cause cross contamination of fluids....basically Korean Crap!// .So Guys!...let's Jus' get real leave our egos parked till the weekend, we all know these EURO headache's are just for EGO!.* (SHOW OFF)../ insecure people for the most part?.....* Crash test on BMW x3 & Lexus clearly shows LEXUS NX the best results / winner kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZy5Y3mqo7abkLc. *~*~*~Intelligent people drive a LEXUS...when we go to work / appointment and or KNOW we MUST be somewhere, i.e. an emergency I drive my Lexus….I have been fortunate to own 5 Ferrari's of various configurations to exercise my Ego as well, So lets leave our Gucci cars for the weekend Polo Pony events. One more thing, D0-Not Lease your car and get ripped off! Jus' to turn it in every 3 years @ maybe 1800.00+ per month...Oh! sure we say it is a write off!.... but you still need to Feed and Cloth the beast and NEVER EVEN OWN IT....i.e. RIPPPPP Off! by the by you still get a write off if you buy this & Jus' consider this: DEPRECIATION Of other vehicles: kzbin.info/www/bejne/hIGtn3Wgm81papY End of story! *The aforementioned is purely my opinion and meant entirely to hopefully give others some insight from a hands on user of this Fine Automobile! "

[@100miledrive]

Yeah I know sometimes it is not easy to make a choice. I briefly test drove GV70 2.0T before we got X3 and it was OK, I didn't get much feedback and this is exactly why I advocate to rent a car on sites like Turo and spend a day with it. I will bring GV70 on my channel, maybe even 3.5 to match against my X3 M40i. I am also curious about the ride quality. In southern CA at one point all Genesis vehicles had $4-5K markups due to inventory shortage, so we dropped it even from consideration. So to answer your question: I would rent both cars 1 after another. Spend a day with each car and also decide what is your primary decision making metric: Is it power, interior quality, cabin quietness, engagement. I personally like the engagement and how dramatic my X3 is, but that is X3 M40i but then it has jittery drive which is not for everyone. X3 30i feels just normal with nothing crazy but offering good confidence. I will be able to answer your question better when I spend a day with GV70. I hope this gives you some clue. Make sure to Subscribe.

[@joeg766]

I’ve had to give this some thought as well. I felt that the BMW interior captures a more austere and refined look (not showy or Uber-gadget); whereas the Genesis is more of a refined family living room, with an abundant bells & whistles, which has a lot of merit but not my taste. Aside from this, Genesis handled like an improved Lexus. So bottom line, depending on your preference, both are great cars with different purpose. Settle on the purpose than your choice is clear.

[@nicolasgalileo7209]

Man! I fell asleep with this video...

[@mannygomez154]

The RX is nothing but a Highlander for upper middle class.

[@100miledrive]

Surprisingly New 2023 RX feels more capable with better balance and ride quality over previous model. it just lacks engagement and excitement that european rivals have

[@donaldbanner2185]

Yep and Toyota and Lexus are FAR AND AWAY the most reliable and highest resale value than ANY vehicle produced...END OF STORY!

[@mannygomez154]

@@donaldbanner2185 nah. The story is as follows: BMW climbed two spots to place first in Consumer Reports' annual ranking of the top automotive brands for performance, safety and reliability. Subaru, which was No. 1 in 2022, finished second this year.Feb 16, 2023. Mini was third (made by BMW). Now the story is ended! Bam! Go frantically scour the internet for an article favoring Lexus. (Try searching the year 2010).

[@sophaman9193]

No matter what RX is still the best selling premium SUV in America No German or European cars companies can beat lexus RX why you guys care how fast you can go you should care about smooth ride comfortable quiet reliability save your money the RX is not a slow car you know where i live in Toronto Canada The RX is the most stolen cars in Canada do you know where do they ship to Africa African people love lexus and toyota not European cars they use to like European cars but not anymore because is not reliable car go for lexus my friend take care bye from milton Ontario Canada

[@100miledrive]

Thanks for your feedback. Well gone are the days when RX was affordable. While you can still bargain on BMW X3 and X5 Lexus is very short on inventory and sells at best at MSRP. I do agree that it’s a good value proposition on RX. Very reliable and offers smooth ride, however many people are looking for engaged driving and more luxury and this is where European Rivals come in. European cars maybe not about long term reliability but have distinct personalities that are very fun to experience. Lots of power, cripsp shifts, sporty experience etc… At the end of the day it’s all about your priorities and what car caters to your personality, and Lexus is also a good choice.

[@mrjoe9460]

what a bad taste

[@100miledrive]

For BMW or Lexus? What is your favourite car