Was THE LAST OF US a Good ADAPTATION?

[@DoktorSkipper]

Yo nice vid!

[@Chunklechuck]

I felt like the show was decent but very forgettable. It suffered from oversimplifying some themes and did not give us the same connection to Ellie or Joel like in the game. The last Episode was extremely rushed and felt something out of a comic book when he started killing the fireflies. It did not take it's time to expand the world unfortunately. The best episode was the gay episode with Nick Offerman because it took it's time to explain and explore a simple story. I think it would have benefited more if they took 2 seasons for the first game. I felt nothing for these characters. While Pedro Pascal is a decent actor I did not feel like he was very good as Joel nor that his acting was particularly great or that he even gave a shit. Great video tho.

[@iMmunashe]

Great summary

[@ManuelD1206]

It’s a good day when Typoh uploads

[@sadpluslonely2775]

NGL, I loved this video, it was really nice

[@willfanofmanyii3751]

Bella Ramsey proving the cast not being allowed to research the game was a bad idea with that stupid comment of hers about how Ellie is just a violent girl with a violent heart, lol.

[@tmm4195]

That's not completely wrong though. Even the director of the game says this. Ellie does have violence in her. Not just violence, but in general she is a violent girl

[@JackycakesV2]

She literally is though lmao what

[@brotherbrod]

@@tmm4195oh you don't know that Bruce Straley is the reason the first game is as good as it is and that Neil took all the credit and forced Bruce and Amy Hennig out of Naughty Dawg after getting promoted to studio head. the guy is a total narcissist who surrounds himself with yes men. if you asked him how much a pile of his shit would be you'd ask if there were gold nuggets in his colon.

[@kwk111]

Woah, I couldn't disagree more about the winter segment. The infected were there for a story/character reason, it made the distrustful Ellie bond slightly with David through fighting together for survival. She didn't fully drop her guard, but she got comfortable enough not to hold her gun around him which says a lot. And no, it wouldn't have been too videogamey for them to fight off some infected. It probably would've been a lot less videogamey than episode 5. On my first playthrough even I considered David might be an ally. That's what made the reveal of his true nature so good. In the show Ellie's and David's thing wasn't nearly as compelling. Ellie meets him, she basically points her gun at him the whole time and David almost instantly spills his guts. The connection just isn't there. I also think David's design in the game was better, for a specific reason. The dark/gray hair, scruffy beard, sunken eyes: his appearance had an abstract resemblance to Joel. It added to why David was initially so disarming, and after the reveal it made him all the more creepier. It's like a subconscious effect.

[@therealplanetmars]

Arcane is its own story, you might like it. It didn't make me want to delete myself which can't be said about most of the new content being out out.

[@literallylaw]

It's so weird hearing myself in someone else's video. Good weird. This was so worth the work tho man, this and Skippers vid are probs the best two I've seen about the show. Amazing job

[@AidenLampitt]

I was on your side the second i saw the thumbnail I haven’t even started watching the video yet

[@Typoh_YT]

Lol

[@SketchyTinkerer]

"Most people can read" Eh, ain't so sure about that one, chief

[@rebelz926]

For criticism of your video, maybe slow down a bit and less frequent edits. moving too fast even for my brain to keep up. Great video man and keep up the good work.

[@Jimmydean33]

Agreed! The editing at times took away from the points he made for the sake of an off topic joke and it’s extreme fast pace made it so everything was surface level coverage

[@Typoh_YT]

@@Jimmydean33 absolutely tbf, I'm a big watch time worry-er, and i want everything to maintain a good pace and keep the audience invested. But the result is I go by topics way too quick just to move onto the next point, that the whole thing just feels like an annoying stream of consciousness

[@MAMULA.]

LETS GOOOOOOOOOOO YEAAAAA

[@philipdarmawan6252]

the only thing I see this show has in common with the game is its aggresive fanbase.

[@willfanofmanyii3751]

The show was relying too much of the attention of the game to put effort into Joel and Ellie's connection besides the bare-minimum.

[@themustardcat1415]

I did make 2 part video of the last of us of how it was very different from the game aka what made the game such a good story telling

[@SixerMason]

I think you give Druckman waaaaay too much credit for the merits of the first game's narrative. Considering his future input into the story it's clear he didn't understand the characters or the themes and twisted them to fit his vision. Now that has seeped into this adaptation due to the fact that he has more control, that's why Joel specifically is so different until Druckman has no choice but to replicate a game scene where you can see a real glimpse of the character delivered poorly by Pedro.

[@gusterwarawara7305]

I think you right, all the narrative, script and historia structure was done by a team and (I think) Neil just make the decision to go or no.

[@PeachesandCream225]

Last of us part 2 is a great game

[@kingpinavatar]

The hubris here is insane. "I'm not wrong, everyone else is"

[@brotherbrod]

@@kingpinavatarhahaha what do you even mean by this

[@kingpinavatar]

@@brotherbrod what are you struggling to understand?

[@Rubric.]

Another banger video typo

[@magpineapple]

great video, i think you should adopt less of a constant attention grabbing stance on editing with the transition sounds and frequent unrelated cutaways

[@Typoh_YT]

Definitely going to be playing around a lot with format with smaller more frequent uploads. Playing for watch time is fun, but time consuming and end of the day isn’t as essential as I make out. Need to play around and experiment with all that :)

[@chaosmirco]

This was great!

[@practiceyourart]

Joel was atrocious in the TV show. He was a completely different character outside of what you see on the surface. Show was much better than I thought. It wasn't amazing or great but very good for a video game adaptation.

[@tinalarsen1585]

You're awesome you'll go places fr

[@Typoh_YT]

🤞

[@redliteyt]

Yay. New upload

[@McMingus]

LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOO

[@klaryon]

How the hell you have so little subscribers?! Your videos are golden

[@Jimmydean33]

Taking 5 years between videos to then be boring will do that

[@rubenabajyan4126]

Finally,someone said it

[@giveitalltoloseitall]

Love your videos

[@ZiGABlaze]

How does this not have more views.. Incredible video essay friend.

[@ZiGABlaze]

I feel like a more eye catching thumbnail will grab people more.

[@brotherbrod]

Visual storytelling is damn near nonexistent in the show.

[@SoggyCereal]

You're like Doctor Skipper but British

[@Typoh_YT]

That POS?

[@TheNumber]

Neat

[@Typoh_YT]

Nice

[@HeathsHobbyLobby]

the tv show sucked

[@Hman191]

You made an ugly joke about 14 year old girl. I stopped caring at that point