Watch What Happens When a “Trans” Man Confronts Habib Umar bin Hafiz in Malaysia

Learn two years of university-level Arabic in six months by joining the 6-Month Arabic Intensive starting July 2024.
Visit themadinanway.org/arabicintensive to learn more.

[@ibnawesome]

Learn two years of university-level Arabic in six months by joining the 6-Month Arabic Intensive starting July 2024. Visit themadinanway.org/arabicintensive to learn more.

[@BelalHakim1]

The most beautiful response. May Allah preserve Habib 'Umar! Notice also the adab of the questioner, not seeking to justify their actions but seeking to draw closer to Allah. May Allah grant us all His mercy and allow our inner and outer actions to be in accordance with His Law. Amin!

[@morkoan70]

I noticed both these things. Well noticed, Belal.

[@morkoan70]

Amen amen. May God give the blessing.

[@makkawaru.]

Most beautiful response in manipultion and swaying of opinions??? Is this habib is actually the next saibaba? Blasphemily accepted and conveyed lgbt as a mere sin as stealing or even robbery under Islamic laws???

[@qamarkandoth6963]

Sk Habib neither said LGBT is a small sin,nor a major sin... He advised to hold the rope of connection with the Almighty Allah..We have make them optimistic and help them to be in the circle of Islam.. any major sin is small, comparing with getting murthad

[@EnnAye]

You have no wisdom or humility. @@makkawaru.

[@OneTheBlue]

If there was more of this kindness and humility towards sinners, more people would come to Islam. (I'm not a Muslim, but I respect the way this message was delivered.)

[@OneTheBlue]

@Lo-lq2cw That is true. But the numbers could be higher, AND the number of Western reverts who leave Islam could be reduced.

[@neohybridkai]

Some things in Islam can't be compromised, which for some non Muslim people it would seems like heartless, because shariah law must be put before feeling. For example if we feel sad to kill animal how would we slaughter qurban during Ied al Adha. Same with LGBT, the feeling of love must be put aside. Having said that Islam also has thing called adab, the way to deliver message. You have to show humility, kindness, respect, compassion, and if it doesn't work despite all the effort, you can't force them. Unfortunately some Muslims doesn't learn about adab. This only makes the delivery of message backfires, people becomes annoyed or even hate Islam. Muslims are obligated to rely the message but whether it changes the person or not, it is beyond our capabilities.

[@zaenqureshi5032]

Lol the funny thing is that it’s the most merciful religion. Your relationship is with god and that’s it. Don’t need a priest or rabbi to forgive u ur sins

[@OneTheBlue]

What is the connection between these two thoughts? They seem to be unrelated.@@zaenqureshi5032

[@saifulazzamags2666]

​@@OneTheBlue Islam means someone who submits to the will of One God (Allah), and Allah is the specislist of Merciful, people leaving other faith especially christians are way more higher than Islam, they became atheist, while Islam on the other hand is the fastest growing religion in the world right now.

[@user-he4ln6yh1z]

U can see the experience and wisdom displayed . Beautiful way of asking the question...and the response made me cry.

[@EnnAye]

Both the one who asked the question and the one who answered did so with absolute good manners and with humility.

[@nassertaliep8166]

maybe they on the same level. this transgender is unhappy with his Creator.

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

​@nassertaliep8166 trust me. This Habib people are so obsessed with is a mushrik. He's worshipping people in a grave and committing many other bidaah in our ummah. We shouldn't take his word as anything but a foolishness

[@avrm8030]

​@@nassertaliep8166No, they aren't. The person who asked felt confused/lost and knows him as respected Habib. The Habib answers him with high knowledge, inspire everyone including him without breaking anyone's feeling

[@mohammadnurfiqri2831]

​@@nassertaliep8166 any sinner is unhappy with the Creator to an extent. Otherwise they would've obeyed. Don't try to see the sins of others as bigger. Yes homosexual acts are a huge sin but there is always hope for them to come back to Allāh as long as they're alive.

[@FLURTOVE]

Beautiful way of asking the question...and the response made me cry

[@busha8922]

A wise response! He did not sugarcoat and called a sin a sin but gently told them to maintain a connection with Allah n reminded the rest of us that we do not have a right to condemn anyone to hellfire. Judgement belongs to Allah alone.

[@PeterBLaurence]

A sage response by someone who clearly embodies all the wisdom of our beautiful deen

[@ahans1792]

He is truly a blessed soul who leads with wisdom beyond measure! This was an absolutely amazing and beautiful response! I'm absolutely blow away by his grace, gentleness, and piety with that one response!! Subhanallah! May Allah extend his life and continue to bless the Ummah! Aameen

[@torontoyes]

All wisdom?

[@muhammadtaha2332]

​@@torontoyesI think he said religion

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

​@ahans1792 he should've condemned the act. Like prophet Lut AS did. It's a major sin, therefore treat it like a major sin. Before it spread further. And send that qawm Lut to oversea.

[@asma-mushtaq]

​​@@UsamahMohdSabriYou will find that the condemnation of sinning and redirection of attention is embedded in the advice. By advising the questioner to start engaging in the recommended acts, the individual opens the door for repentance and all that is deemed 'Godly' and good. Without these specific direction, there are no levers to hold for a person seeking redemption.

[@altGoolam]

That this person could ask the question in safety and peace, and be answered respectfully and safely, is a true gift.

[@tplez1659]

Subhanallah. This beautiful response brought me to tears for so many reasons. I pray that I can one day respond to everyone around me in this way, so reminiscent of the way of our BELOVED Prophet, salallahu aleihi wa salaam. (And clearly there was no need to use the word "confront" in the title at all.)

[@indipacifician3693]

surely beloved prophet had problems with homosexuals but not with BELOVED MERCIFUL HIGH ACTS OF KINDNESS like a 56 year old grandfather marrying a 6 year old child and then marrying his sons wife and then the list goes on

[@maqboolusman2914]

@tplez 100% ❤️😊

[@yoservs]

Subhanallah, what a beautiful reply. Truly a magnanimous human being, Sayyid Habib Umar. He didn't back down that it is a sin, but he also gave them advice never to lose hope in the mercy of Allah.

[@tauhiradalwai1069]

Superb!!!

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

But he never affirm it as a major sin(at least in this video) which is a big problem

[@yoservs]

everyone knows it's a major sin. fact is no sin is too big forAllah to forgive, there is hope for Allah's mercy always, no matter how deep we may be in sin.@@UsamahMohdSabri

[@CR-og5ho]

​​@@UsamahMohdSabriwhy should it be considered a major sin and not a minor sin? What is the distinction?

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

@CR-og5ho Homosexuality is inherently bad. It destroys the individual, family, society and children. That should be enough

[@Qwikree]

I don't know this man but at the first second I heard him i wanted to listen to him, may Allah help us to show the real islam and not make people run away from islam

[@enlightenment00]

This is what we like to hear an uncompromising loving and compassionate answer.

[@faka7981]

beautiful „ Oh Allah make them as happy in the hereafter as they are happy in this world“

[@arcticbliss2330]

Ameen

[@hidayaali7299]

Alhamdulillah his answer was amazing,let’s pray for our children,Saitan is with us let us avoid bad and catch the rope to Allah as sheikh said

[@greeniscoollol]

The meaning of repentance: "The literal meaning of the Arabic word repentance is "to return" and is repeated in the Qur'an and hadith (sayings of the Islamic prophet Muhammad). In the context of Islam, it means to turn or to retreat from past sinful and evil activities, and to firmly resolve to abstain from them in future." Sheik Habib Umar was in no way telling the questioner to continue, he specifically used the word "repentance". He has not encouraged them to carry on sinning, like some of these comments suggest.

[@mib5116]

Thank you for the translation. I think everyone can benefit from this

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

No, we can't. Homosexuality act is inherently bad and should be seen as bad. We can't keep committing major sin and rub it just because we're still do good deeds. Repent and don't repeat it. As for everybody else, forbid evil

[@sifat_biswas]

That my friend is a real scholar. May Allah preserve this beautiful man.

[@arcticbliss2330]

Ameen

[@tauhiradalwai1069]

Subhaanallah!!!!!❤ beautifully said! We should not judge we should be making dua for mercy on all mankind! Ya RABB🥹🤲🏻❤️ ALLAH is the Judge🤲🏻

[@shahidachoudhary9258]

Masha Allah tabarak Allah The questioner was beautiful in ther approach The ustadh response was on another level May Allah swt bless and preserve our scholars n may Allah swt guide us n keep us guided ameen

[@aBBB321]

He answered the question like a real Sufi.

[@andydufresne4444]

This is islam, not sufisim.

[@beenie1111]

​@@andydufresne4444Sufism is Islam, not the Najdi Wahhabi ideology "created" with support from the west 100 odd years ago

[@bloodlure844]

My friend,habib Umar is one of the realist sufi today

[@user-mh7mv1rf2k]

ماشاء الله الاحتزافية في الترجمة لايصال علم شيوخنا الاجلاء اكثر الله من امثالكم شكرا

[@shabaan.m]

Beautiful response. The wisdom conveyed through humility, words and actions. Indeed, a powerful message.

[@mimonahendricks1161]

May Almighty Allah SWT gùde all our hearts. Ameen. It took a lot of encourage for the questioner in a gathering of such nature. and he was beautifully responded to with Hikmah and compassion SUBHAANALLAH !! JAZAAKALLAH GHAIR Sheik. We cannot close doors on others. You inspire. BAARAKALLAH FEEK.

[@UnderBaseBeatz]

Simply beautiful and unrivalled response, may Allah preserve Habib Umar, his family, and all those who assist him in the dawah, ameen!

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

He's not an authority of islam. He contributed nothing for our ummah except misguidance. He's not upon Alquran and sunnah and in support of shirk and bid'ah. We should not take him seriously

[@UnderBaseBeatz]

@@UsamahMohdSabri who are you?

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

@UnderBaseBeatz somebody upon quran and sunnah. Who are you?

[@UnderBaseBeatz]

@UsamahMohdSabri ah I see.. so the religion of Allah is guess work to you. 'Upon Quran and Sunnah' according to whose authority?

[@UsamahMohdSabri]

@@UnderBaseBeatz According to a majority of scholars, sahabi, and prophet SAW

[@niche9878]

MashaAllah, I was one of those who watched the livestream and was surprised by the turn of events and how Sayyidil Habib answered with eloquence and subtlety. Truly an answer aided by and approached with hikmah much like what Sayyidil Habib was doing, it would’ve touched a questioner’s heart and soul.

[@ahans1792]

He is truly a blessed soul who leads with wisdom beyond measure! This was an absolutely amazing and beautiful response! I'm absolutely blow away by his grace, gentleness, and piety with that one response!! Subhanallah! May Allah extend his life and continue to bless the Ummah! Aameen

[@barbaroslar2235]

you have done great Job, i hope you can translate more content like this.

[@MadyLa]

Jazakallah khair for translating this 👍🏻

[@alikhfurniturerepairsalikh7132]

Very beautifully answered by the Shayk,this is the essence of wisdom.

[@jtb229]

The blessed blood flows through his body, permeates the soul and soothes the heart with his speech. Allahumma Salī 3laa Sayidduna Muhammad

[@ahmedparker1079]

Did you see the blood?

[@lantern7736]

@@ahmedparker1079 Have you seen ur brain?

[@ahans1792]

​@@ahmedparker1079 Did you see the prophet?

[@ahans1792]

He is truly a blessed soul who leads with wisdom beyond measure! This was an absolutely amazing and beautiful response! I'm absolutely blow away by his grace, gentleness, and piety! May Allah extend his life and continue to bless the Ummah! Aameen

[@ahans1792]

@@HassiYahaya Evolution proved!?? 😅🤣

[@dynamicforce8051]

Great message from Shaykh Habib Umar. If a person wants to find their way home and not be an inhabitant of hell, they need to repent and come onto the correct path. It’s the ones who keep going back to their sinful ways that are in trouble. The people who repented from the boat genuinely did realize their faults and genuinely did change their ways going forward. They took Master Karkhi as their example. These days you get the ones who understand the magnitude of their offenses to Allah Almighty and just don’t care, so they return back to their sinful places. Common sense is unfortunately gone from people. Having Habib Umar as an example should be the only thing needed to find your way home❤️

[@UltimateMegaMaster]

Mad respect for the LGBTQ gang for having extremely high courae and confidence to be in this event. Had I were in their shoes, there is no guarantee I will have the same qualities. May Allah bless us all.aamiin

[@user-xr6kk7gd1e]

What respect?

[@pickleism253]

@@user-xr6kk7gd1e being able to ask questions and seek the truth rather than be scared and run away fearing they'll be mocked

[@roubaissa6996]

Masha’Allah. I am speechless. What a response.

[@TheOneMuslim]

MashaAllah one of my teachers whom I say with during my time 9n Yemen

[@azbc9303]

Thank you. I cried listening to the response

[@2loco]

Cannot get an answer more clear or precise than this. May Allah swt reward you brother.

[@HotimusPrime]

Both the sheikh and the questioner have special status within Allah. Don't give up...

[@mariaalvi401]

SubhanAllah Syeddi Habib Umar is a true representation of the mercy of Allah & His Messenger SallAllahuAlayhi wa Alihi wasalim.

[@namiraming2846]

Best and wise response, thank you Shiekh

[@DropoutFelon]

U can see the experience and wisdom displayed 🎯

[@carlpostman1623]

Actually the brother has indeed answered the questions but what he had to say is that it is not allowed in ISLAM to committ these sins. These sins are almost unforgivable! Actually he gave that person who was asking the questions that they can go ahead with what they are doing instead of telling the truth.

[@muddassirghoorun4322]

I said the same things but there are those who are busy clapping forgetting about what Allah did to sodom and gomorrah- The people of Lut as.

[@sankofa010]

Everyone is a sinner and there are minor and major sins. Allah is most merciful and most forgiving, but in order for someone to be forgiving; he/she must genuinely repent, that's stop/terminate committing the sins he or she is doing and shows remorse. Continue indulging in the act of homosexuality/LGBTQ and being proud of it is not the way of repentance.

[@carlpostman1623]

@@nsibtrap8094 the one who mentioned hell is the muslima .She knows the punishment for these acts.

[@carlpostman1623]

@@sankofa010 in other words the brother had to insist of the punishment of horrendous crime.

[@carlpostman1623]

@@HassiYahaya yahaya from the abyss, are you on any kind of medication? Acting if you are an atheist makes you like a monkey flying an airplane.

[@prayforpeacenow]

Beautiful discussion. MA.

[@mohamedessop2113]

Mashallah sheikh Allah s.w.t give u long healthy life to give us more knowledge

[@Saif-vu8gq]

SubhanAllah, very impressive

[@frommuddywaters]

What a beautiful answer

[@sadiqakhan4795]

Such wisdom, SubhanAllah. Beautiful response given in a calm and respectful manner masha Allah. May Allah preserve Habib Umer and bless him with a long and healthy life, Aameen.🤲 May we take heed and never be judgemental, Aameen.🤲

[@thesoulmechanic256]

Masha Allah very beautiful reply

[@mesta4314]

This is Islam. Jazakallah Brother.

[@bungamentari]

Masya Allah Habib Umar. How soothing, full of wisdom your answer is. I'm crying

[@ohihassan693]

What a beautiful reply. May Allah(swt) increase him in rank. And to my fellow brothers and sisters, please do not judge others about hell and heaven, as Allah(swt) is the only one who can do so. Be kind with your words. Stay away from sin like lgbt etc. If you have feeling like lgbt etc then you are not sinner asking as you do not act upon your desires and try to keep yourself away from it. Pray to Allah(swt) to save you, the people you know and care, pray for me and the people i know and care about, to save us from such evil.

[@othmanalmaliki]

Amazing!

[@user-no1ig1er9s]

Quran, 29:45 Recite what has been revealed to you of the Scripture; keep up the prayer: prayer restrains outrageous and unacceptable behaviour. Remembering God is greater: God knows everything you are doing.

[@aminahbergliotrolsdorph7557]

جزاك الله خيرا..سبحان الله العظيم..

[@ameerahmed5876]

Can we not just unanimously nominate Habib Umar to be the Ameer ul Mumineen of our era.... everything I see and hear about him tells me this blessed man is one that can be trusted and will be just and lead us to a better future!

[@yonetmen81besiktasli21]

Well he responded well and gave some examples. But he did not mentioned about prophet Lut and his people and what happened to them. Yes the hope you will not give up but that does not mean that you have to go acting as transgender. He also had to gave the example that Allah swt created man and women. So man has to live like man and woman like woman.

[@bittertruth6575]

The questioner most likely knows all that. You can tell from the humble way in which the the question was asked. The Sheikh then advised them on how to leave the sin and find their way back to Allaah.

[@noushadalihudawime4015]

👍 ما شاء الله دعاء الشيخ معروف الكرخي رحمه الله اللهم كما فرحتهم في الدنيا ففرحهم في الآخرة

[@inusaabubakarahmad2313]

May Allah reward the Sheikh Ameen

[@ILoveMyLittleBoyDog]

Habib Umar's response made me feel humble and he has corrected my thinking, by the grace of Allah. It is true what he says. We ourselves judge and personally, I have taken a very black or white view of the trans and the homosexual communities. Now, after seeing this video, I stand corrected, alhamdulillah. I am not in a position to judge anyone, no one is because we ourselves are not perfect. We may abstain from zina, khamr, ghibah, give zakat, sawm and do our salah on time.......but that does not give us the right to be cruel and consider ourselves better than anyone else. Only Allah (swt) knows what is in our hearts, and it is possible that although a trans person or someone else who has stepped out of the muslim societal norms, may actually be the better person. We are taught by rasul Allah (saw) that the thing that makes us better than others in front of Allah is taqwa, our levels of iman. May Allah forgive us and open our hearts to learn from the guidance of our elders like this wonderful scholar and grant us jannat al firdaus, amin. 🤲🏼🤲🏼

[@documentariesinchd3070]

LoL who's Habib Umar in islam? Nothing what did Allah and his messenger salalahu aleihi wasalam said about this matter? That's what matters my friend don't let this Sufi misguide u he will run away from you yaumul qiyama

[@bittertruth6575]

@@documentariesinchd3070 Actually everyone is running away from the takfeeri and tabdee'i pseudo Salafis who think only they are the saved sect.

[@ShareefusMaximus]

What an incredible man.

[@Qamarun.channel]

Masyallah the translate is correct 👍🏻

[@hafidzahmad4540]

Maa shaa Allah. I'm crying.😭❤

[@hikkato88]

How do you get the translation? Do you have Malaysian friend syeikh ? Btw it was a beautiful answer melted our heart, even this answer was criticized by Wahabis, May Allah raise Maqam of Habib Umar .

[@ibnawesome]

From one of my very close friends who is Malaysian, Alhamdullillah. Yes, it couldn't have been answered any better, Masha'Allah.

[@rizj]

Ameen, summa ameen

[@lifeisreallyshortknowyourr4724]

International shaitan community will lead you to a lizard hole and you will follow them the prophet said{ SA￦}

[@Insaniya.humanity]

Excellent

[@ibrahimriversnoone9767]

The position that a muslim takes on this matter is the position of allah and his prophet..... may allah guide us-amin

[@bittertruth6575]

Which only you and your scholars know of course. Absolutely staggering the amount of arrogance coupled with ignorance.

[@nasreenroper3932]

I would love to listen this

[@harrypotter-rj8ip]

But he didn't reply what was asked,he gave a merry go round answer not clear 😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔😔

[@bittertruth6575]

He did just that and more. watch it a few times and you'll get it. Could it be that what you're really sad about is that he didn't do takfeer, like the scholars you are used to?

[@abdikamil7627]

Islamic rulings on this matters is clear cut - sugarcoatting them will never make it right. In times of fitnah, scholers have greater responsibility to warn people against crossings Allah's boundaries. By Leaving out such ruling in his explanation, the sheekh's take implicitly suggested relaxation of rulings, eventhough he didn't say so. This is bound to create confusion. May Allah forgive and have a mercy on us all

[@irshaadrashid6291]

The Shaykh (may Allah preserve him) referred to the questioner as "him". He also began with speaking about minor and major sins. There was also a general understanding among the room about the related ahkam (rulings). Even the accounts he mentioned were about sinful people. His words were about repentance and maintaining ropes with Allah. This is all very clear. I hope his wise, merciful and encouraging words will have a profound effect upon the questioner and everyone else, in the same way it did for those people he mentioned in the accounts, by the Grace of Allah.

[@AlIslam579]

When you don't won't to take lessons from the Quran and sunna ,tell beautiful story. The man said we are from the LGBT community, Hi is affiliate with them. The LGBT insult Allah openly I don't dare to repeat what they say Auzubillah. Sugarcoating indeed.!! This so call shaik, hi did not give him warning. O advise him to stay away from the sin. That this is the devil who is leading them astray from the natural behavior. And that they should repent to Allah ,and not just stay like that if truly they believe in Allah and the last day Wallahu a'lam Allahummasturna O Allah protect us from the evil

[@muhammadzariff7075]

@@AlIslam579Bro, you are legit confusing western LGBT groups with that of Eastern LGBT groups. I know my fair share of Trans, and they are all polar opposite of western trans in terms of mindset towards religion and whatnot. So pleaee don’t generalise these people, as it will only lead them further from Islam!

[@jiahazahar6607]

Does this video have the long full version, i mean the one with malay translation by the translator?

[@user-ex9lv7dl5j]

السلام عليكم جواب سليم من شيخ حكيم ، لم ينفر السائل من رحمه الله سبحانه وتعالى ، الله يهدي السائل ومن يشوف هذا المقطع ونسأل الله سبحانه وتعالى ان يتبتنا على الاسلام ونسأل الله حسن الخاتمه.

[@haledhajdari1154]

MashaAllah, powerful!

[@witness1000]

Answered like a true politician. Politically correct, and winning the popular vote. 😂

[@undercoverxyz7]

Don't accuse him of something you don't know. He made people think for themself and that's important to let the people think and understand. So being gay isn't the major sin, it's the sin to forfill the sexual act. May Allah swt. protect and guide us all.

[@abihanies]

Being gay means you had succumbed to the sin. If has not then you are not gay.

[@MadyLa]

So what do you expect him to say or act. Act like a true ISIS?

[@indipacifician3693]

atleast he didnt ask others to take up swords and cut her head off

[@indipacifician3693]

@@abihanies no you ignorant ignoramus. Being gay means you are attracted to same gender not succumbing means you are gay but still control your desire and not have any ses.

[@redpersiantv]

Pleasure to watch

[@Amoh29]

Allahuma bareek aleyhi MaashaAllahu laquwata ila biLlah. Ameen allahuma ameen

[@nadzirahfarhah3423]

Subhanallah

[@gondala]

Dunia ini tempat kita berlomba-lomba dalam kebaikan, menjadi orang yang terbaik amalannya. Biarlah Allah, Tuhan YME menjadi hakim bagi kita yang mungkin telah melakukan banyak dosa, namun sekuat tenaga kita berlomba menjadi manusia yang terbaik melalui amal perbuatan. Mudah-mudahan, saat kita meninggalkan dunia ini, kita dikenang dan disebut-sebut sebagai orang yang sangat baik akhlaknya.

[@rur8761]

ALLAHU'AKBAR ALLAHU'AKBAR LAILAHA'ILLALLAH MOHAMMAD'UR RASOOLALLAH

[@hameemhabeeb4455]

Is there a transcript available? It was so fast I missed some of it

[@NC-kk3gn]

Thé prophet ﷺ when asked about Zina, his response was merciful yet direct and calling out munkar a munkar so there is no ambiguity. His response is indeed beautiful, yet was half way without giving a full response between targhib and tahdeed.

[@bittertruth6575]

Because the questioner acknowledged their sin and was not misguided to think that homosexuality is not a sin. They basically asked for advice about how to come home.

[@daudislam4life]

Beautiful answer. The translator was struggling 😂

[@noneofyourbeeswax371]

Allah forgives whoever he want's, may we all be amongst those who he will forgive and save from Jahannam. Say Ameen!

[@frommoroccowithlove]

Abundance of Beauty

[@shiffin_chippe]

Mashaallah❤

[@Harry-bw2xj]

Successful indeed are the Believers.Those who humble themselves in their prayers.Who avoid vain talk.Who are active in giving zakat. Who guard their modesty. Except with those joined to them in the marriage bond, or the captives whom their right hands possess,for in their case they are free from blame.-Holy Quran (23/1-6).

[@vernusoil582]

You see the difference between a Sufi and an ordinary moslem

[@ANomad1]

Sufis are weak and tolerant of almost everything.

[@toasty-toast]

He should have also clearly stated that this is Haram just like cheating on your wife, or taking cocaine as a recreational drug.

[@MrFatboyRuns]

I don't think this Shiekh needs your advice on how to respond to questions. His answer was full of so much wisdom, if you can't see that then the problem is with you.

[@ab00abdullah]

​@@MrFatboyRuns​ no one is above giving, needing, or receiving any advice. Much in Islam mentions this. I imagine the speaker himself will agree.

[@greeniscoollol]

The meaning of repentance: "The literal meaning of the Arabic word tawba is "to return" and is repeated in the Qur'an and hadith (sayings of the Islamic prophet Muhammad). In the context of Islam, it means to turn or to retreat from past sinful and evil activities, and to firmly resolve to abstain from them in future." Sheik Habib Umar was in no way telling the questioner to continue, he specifically used the word "repentance". He has not encouraged them to carry on sinning.

[@soumsoumaya8105]

@@nsibtrap8094 except that bandit is not so much the same thing as trans!!!!!

[@HassanGanari]

​@@nsibtrap8094 The trans said they were trying to find their way to Allah and that they were happy to see the sheikh. Well, the way to Allah is not by commiting a major sin. They wanted to know the sheikh's opinion on this community, it does not matter and the sheikh should not speak of his own opinion, what matters is the religion of Islam. This is very clear, in islam, such things are strictly forbidden, major sins, Allah wiped out the whole world in the great deluge except few with Prophet Lot peace be upon him, why? because of their disbelief first and for the gravity of their sin and corruption. A muslim shall never shy away when stating a clear haram act, a major sin, in this case, the best advise should be : STOP doing what you are doing and repent immediately if you fear Allah, this sin calls for Allah's anger, be sincere.

[@servantofAllah3113]

Jamuan (Al-Mā'idah):7 - Dan ingatlah karunia Allah kepadamu dan perjanjian-Nya yang telah diikat-Nya dengan kamu, ketika kamu mengatakan: "Kami dengar dan kami taati". Dan bertakwalah kepada Allah, sesungguhnya Allah Mengetahui isi hati(mu).Nabi Yunus (Yūnus):23 - Maka tatkala Allah menyelamatkan mereka, tiba-tiba mereka membuat kezaliman di muka bumi tanpa (alasan) yang benar. Hai manusia, sesungguhnya (bencana) kezalimanmu akan menimpa dirimu sendiri; (hasil kezalimanmu) itu hanyalah kenikmatan hidup duniawi, kemudian kepada Kami-lah kembalimu, lalu Kami kabarkan kepadamu apa yang telah kamu kerjakan.

[@supplemarmot1244]

Subhanallah wAllahu akbar. May Allah be pleased with and reward Habib Umar bin Hafiz. It is only in the last year that I learned about him and the Ba'alawiyya tradition. It is truly a guiding light for the ummah.

[@ahmedparker1079]

The prophet and his companions were not ba’alawis. Stick to their guidance not someone who came centuries later and claiming he has blood of rasool Allah saw

[@minskdhaka]

​@@ahmedparker1079: By your logic the four madhhabs shouldn't exist either, as the Prophet and his companions didn't follow them.

[@ahmedparker1079]

@@minskdhaka Firstly, all the madhahibs stuck to the guidance of rasool Allah to the point where each one of them said if my opinion goes against a stronger authentic opinion to rasool Allah then throw my opinion in the trash. So the mashabihs did not follow imam ba’awali they followed Muhammad saw

[@abdulbibi5700]

​​@@ahmedparker1079assalam alayka akhi, you are losing your time in debating with these ignorant sufis, they are plenty of bidaa, superstition & for some of them major shirk. Only Allah can give them guidance

[@supplemarmot1244]

​@@ahmedparker1079 Consider who that statement was directed to (the one regarding "if there is another stronger hadith that contradicts..."). Not a layman who picks up a copy of Bukhari. It's a tired counterpoint that all traditional (i.e. not so-called Salafi, not so-called Ahlul Hadeeth) are aware of already and it does not hold much water because it does not mean what you think it means, and it does not have the same conclusions and consequences that you think it has. The Ba'alawi habibs are mostly Shafi'i scholars anyway, so if I was myself of the Ba'alawiyya tradition (which I'm not), then I'd be following sound fiqh while fully knowing that there are differences of opinions and rulings on fiqhi matters, and I'd be following the sound aqidah of the ahlus sunnah wal jamaah. At the end of the day, you think that your knowledge and your scholars are in the way of the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet ﷺ, and I think the same. This is a debate that has been sadly raging for hundreds of years.

[@roadtohope]

Subhaan Allah

[@jibril25omar82]

Massallah 😢 beautiful responses.

[@nasreenroper3932]

I can’t get the full response ,video stops halfway

[@user-fe7zi6fb4m]

I never read your book. I don't know your language. I don't know your Prayers, except Selah. I long for guidance & I ask for your prayer as I search for purpose in the world left for me that I may help the people & never lose my hope & only add to my faith by reading your book & if God sees a place for me to journey East, perhaps missionary work or shelters. I live in Babylon & there are many lessons & wonders but it feels cruel & without the love I felt all my life. The last time here of religious Strife was during the 1600's-1700's called "Tolousse" & it's been about 400-423 years & it comes again @ the end of a 7000 year plan. Mohammed, a prophet, was sent about 400 years after the death of Christ. That all seems right. I want to go home with my people, with my family, I miss my Father's love. All my heart, Nicole Rhea Poulin, t.

[@abooswalehmosafeer173]

Very tough.Only Allah judges.We Humankind,only worship Allah.The Ultimate Justice of Allah is beyond humankind capacity,too great too high,too sublime for us puny creatures.Hasbunaallahu Wa Nimal Wakil.

[@masbel7709]

MashaAllah a beautiful response👌🏻♥️. May Allah swt guide all the LGBT muslims to the straight path and give them hidaya InshaAllah 🤲🏻🌹

[@noneofyourbeeswax371]

Ameen

[@faizankamal2817]

To be fair, the guy seems quite sincere

[@zaynulabideenkamal1038]

Yeah mashallah the brother did seem sincere. I pray that Allah guides him inshallah

[@utubebeena]

Maa Shaa Allah good question and good answer. However, i wonder, after all the kind and sweet talk of Allah's infinite Mercy, if the Shaykh went on to enlighten of a hadith where RasulAllah s.a.w ordered to distance away from an effeminate men until he reforms. Also hadith about men who dress as women and women who dress as men. In this video clip, it is only apparent the sheikh addressed the attitude of other people towards wrongdoers/sinners, but he did not address the one who is committing the wrong/sin. True, we should make duas for the wrongdoers/sinners. But the wrong doers should also be admonished of Allah's promised punishment which is severe, and that one should repent and correct themselves before death approaches. Perhaps the shaykh was alluding to this through the examples he gave, but for many the message may not be clear....Wallahu'alam

[@bittertruth6575]

Watch it again a few times till you understand the question and the answer.Not every question needs to be answered with 'fire and brimstone'. That's what hikmah is for. The questioner clearly knows they are sinning and was not asking for absolution but rather advise on how to 'come back to Allah'. The examples the Shaykh gave specifically involved sinful people who repented and corrected themselves.

[@siddiquejamali9388]

That is not question of the answer I believe … we muslims should excel of skills and knowledge to confront these type of questions …

[@tasyriq28]

Change the tittle. That transgender man did not confront habib and yet he respect habib ummar from the way he speak to him. Im malaysian and I understand exactly what he said. I dont support lgbt but dont accuse something that they didn’t do. By the way that trans man is a muslim and he have syahadah in his heart.

[@SB-ok1hi]

The translator should have a record and replay thingy cause that answer was maybe too long to remember 🤣Allahumma barik lahum to both.

[@ShareefusMaximus]

The translation into Malay was edited out. He was pausing throughout.

[@SB-ok1hi]

@@ShareefusMaximus Alhamdulillah.

[@Lallateapourer]

❤

[@arianawright4187]

Assalam mualay kom, I am disappointed the response was not clear to read, first thing is in English, and changing fast to one another . Can anybody's translate the responses in malay language pleased..😢