Way Too Little & Way Too Late Spoils Qissa Meharbano Ka | Sang-e-Mah | Sinf-e-Aahan | Mere Humsafar

[@niharikamishra_]

Sang-e-Mah Maintains a record of atleast one twist per week. I stand corrected that Mastaan was not sentenced but voluntarily accepted Zarghuna's servitude as he realized he had inadvertently caused her to miscarry. Haji Marjaan keeps revealing new shades with his new conspiracy of killing Hilmand. This track is now completely on a Hamlet path, and Hilmand's monologue was somewhat, if not totally derived from "To Be or Not To Be". What blew my mind was the chemistry between Hilmand and Sheherzaad. So deep, impeccable and long lasting. We didn't get a feel before that Sheherzaad was an underconfident woman due to her past trauma of sexual abuse, except a slight hint where Hilmand asks her to print her own picture in the article, but it's being well-projected that Hilmand's words are making her stronger to face exploitation.

[@hopeq1322]

The chemistry between kubra and Atif Aslam was sizzling. She seemed to be mesmerized by his personality, his voice, his overall aura as was anyone watching. You didn’t want to blink so you don’t miss anything! Just amazing performances 👌👍

[@tabinda460]

I think it's more kubra talent that she made us feel this way...

[@hopeq1322]

@@tabinda460 I know, her face said it all even though Atif was the one talking.

[@tabinda460]

@@hopeq1322 plus love atif ..only thing pathan accent is missing in him

[@quratumar4538]

Absolutely right. It was such a beautiful scene

[@hiranajmi93]

Hilmand and sheherzad are meant to connect this way. Loved their scene. I second you.

[@hashhina7324]

I think hasan has it wrong. What haji marjan said to his servant was to kill hilmand not sheherzad when the opportunity strikes. According to him, when sheherzad would keep on pressing him to ask for forgiveness, he would lose temper and the servant would kill him on the pretext that hilmand got out of control and he killed him to protect the girl. If he was supposed to kill sheherzad than why did he not?? He had the opportunity to but he did not so what hasan is saying doesn't make sense.

[@sonia7123]

Completely agreed

[@meeow4392]

I know … I wonder how aamna just gave up ..

[@muhinibegum2644]

👍

[@teeh5121]

Exactly

[@teeh5121]

Came in the comment section for this Maybe Hasan watched it on 2x because of his busy schedule :p

[@mahadfraaz218]

The most objectionable thing about ishq e laa this week was Azkas character. Why on earth would Yumna choose such a character? She has no feelings and is written as a very surface level character. There is no depth to Azka as she’s just selfish and emotionless in simple terms. Yeah she cried at her brother’s death and felt bad when Shanaya died but why is she so unbelievably numb? Regardless, the biggest issue I found was that the moment she begins going to med school she loses the chaddar and dupatta and begins to talk to boys. This is what we complain about when we talk about misrepresentation of Islam in international content. Whenever there’s a Muslim girl in a Netflix show, they always show her losing her hijab at some point as if it’s a moment of liberation for her. I remember watching some shows where they glorify a girl for taking off her hijab for her boyfriend as a symbol of empowerment. This isn’t any different. Instead of showing someone who remains true to her roots and continues to show modesty regardless of her current position, they have once again associated education with liberalism. We ALWAYS see this in dramas where the rich and powerful are never shown to be religious and the poor and helpless are. They were a bit unconventional with Shanaya but Azka fits the stereotype like usual. Super disappointed in the writing

[@hercatalogue1323]

True! The drama literally lacks depth and the content two of the powerhouse of performances aka sajal and yumna would sign. The hype about Amin Iqbal's direction feels lackluster!

[@aziza000]

I never quite got the idea Azka is/was a very religious character though. She wore a simple duputta on her head more so as a cultural thing, hardly hijab now is it. Had they shown her very religious like Dua from AMEK at least and then changing as soon as she joined uni I would’ve agreed with you on that point but she’s not really shown to be religious or saying anything remotely religious like Dua who touched on the na mehram issue a bit, in fact in Ishq e Laa even Shanaya was shown more religious than her! Lol 😂 but I agree with everything else you said.

[@mehreenmisbah9556]

You're so right. Azka is such a shallow character. About the hijab bit, unfortunately in our 'liberal' circle, hijab is not considered a tenet of faith. As in piety has nothing to do with hijaab as far as liberals are concerned. As for Azka, she is not at all shown to be someone close to her Creator. Allah se bhi uski closeness isliye shuru hui kyunke usay medical university mein admission chahiye tha......she lacks depth......and i hate the way she is shown to be so masoom and the way her mother and bhabi go gaga over her as if she is a baby.....itna tou Aliha ko bhi baby nahin karte jitna Azka ko karte hain.....i am not a fan of that ex-fiance of hers but the way she so casually told him to bring his mother and then later on backed off was clearly unethical. There are so many things wrong with Azka. That guy in her class is also very annoying. 2 mulaqaton mein mohabbat hogayi.....so ridiculous! Can't believe someone like Yumna agreed to play that character.

[@mehreenmisbah9556]

@@sabazaidi9022 hahahaha

[@mahadfraaz218]

@@sabazaidi9022 yes I agree and I liked that about this drama. They finally showed a religious yet rich girl who knows her faith. The issue I have with Azka losing her chaddar/dupatta is that it paints the picture that she was oppressed and uneducated before. It tells the viewers that now that she goes to college and learned about whatever she doesn’t need to cover up because she’s educated and “free”. It’s just like what I mentioned about a lot of Netflix shows. They always have to show the Muslim girl taking off her hijab or veil at some point as a form of liberation and that’s exactly what happened here.

[@myramalik208]

Of course one can’t help but admire the beautiful frames and the meticulously shot scenes of Jo Bichar Gai ; from the very first episode it magically takes you back to the early 70’s ka Pakistan and having grown up in cantonements I can vouch how real and authentic everything seemed , right from the uniforms , to the Anwar residence ♥️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 It won’t be wrong to say that I partly watch the drama because it transcends you back in time ….. just like Dastaan did …. Bravo Haisam 👏🏻👏🏻♥️ Thank you for making us relive a piece of history that so many of us had either forgotten or were ignorant of . Thank you ♥️

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

Sang e mah: This was the most impactful episode which set the momentum of the drama as we now fully understand the characters and their back stories. Two scenes showing women empowerment and resolute, left lasting impression: a). Zarghuna riding a horse taking Mastaan Singh as a ghulam, although Haji Marjaan tried to save the son of his partner in crime. It seemed a scene from a parallel world, as we live in a world where no man can accept to be subservient to a woman. In our society even a rape victim is handed over to her rapist to be married to him for life long punishment. b). Shererzad coming out of the office and draping Hilmand’s shawl around herself, depicting exactly what and who she wanted. A girl molested by a close relative, facing workplace harassment is overwhelmed by the respect given to her by a stranger. Haji Marjaan’s camouflaged negativity, innocence of his wife Zasanga , the vengeance of Hilmand and Zarghuna, combined with past and present love stories would make this drama a very interesting watch in the coming episodes.

[@navdeepkaur_3]

U need to correct the names... Haji marzaan Khan not Haji Mastan...... Also it's Mastaan Singh not khan

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

@@navdeepkaur_3 Thank you for correcting. I am really bad at remembering names. Always confuse them.😌

[@AbdulRehman-nm6bb]

Good englsh

[@shrawaniverma4454]

@Mahnoor Qureshi as always aptly articulated.

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

Haji Marjaan's character is quite dubious and complex, especially after what he did in this episode, so I fail to understand him completely; probably because his backstory is not yet disclosed, like how did he marry Hilmand's mother? And did he kill Nasrullah khan? And if not then who killed him, and did he play a part in his killing?

[@Sonal.09]

Kubra's British accent is required for her to play Mahjabeen, because it is mentioned that her mom is a British Kashmiri and that she has studied law from London. So, her accent is justifiable and important for this role. Yes, but when in comes to Mashal in HKKST, I don't remember her having an accent and for Sang e Mah, I'll notice more from now. But I like her accent.

[@uzmab6399]

She is in real life British born n raised

[@Sonal.09]

@@uzmab6399 I know she is, that is why they are telling her to work on loosing the accent in her roles. I was just saying that her accent is required for her to play Mahjabeen.

[@ambreensiddique6882]

But I love her British accent no matter in what character she is

[@maheenqutab]

Amna, please know that when we see or discuss a woman who is a “shaheed ki bewa”, and has a child as well, and we see that another army officer has married the widow, we actually celebrate and encourage the couple. No one, absolutely just no one in the Army “gossips” about it. It’s a thing to be encouraged and honored. We take it extremely extremely seriously, since we have so many women who loose their husbands.

[@shanazhussain718]

Very well said

[@recollections-may-vary9328]

Exactly

[@abd33163]

Perfectly said🙏

[@288amna]

Yes! It’s celebrated in Army that’s why it seemed so stupid that Major Usama’s wife was evading her friend and kept lying to her in the beginning

[@maheenqutab]

@@288amna I agree. It’s weird the way she’s a tying. Usually there’s no need to act that way with such an information, especially when you know that everyone knows the story. I agree that she’s taking time to heal, and that’s fine. But she’s acting so weird in public it’s unbecoming.

[@hihello6009]

I now really want kubra to do a solo drama I mean she has done enough multi starer dramas from alif to hum kaha ke sachay the , sinfe ahan ,sangemah even her film was multistarer her choices are good but now I want to see her in a solo drama

[@sania.s3472]

Warch Muqabil

[@hihello6009]

@@sania.s3472 ya but that was many years before main abh latest kisi drama main dekhna chahta hu where all focus is on her acting

[@sania.s3472]

@@hihello6009 yes i agree. In a role like shehrzad. She has done lots of bratty spoiled girl characters.

[@hihello6009]

@@sania.s3472 ya I agree 👍 now it's time she should take a solo script l mean she should think herself she has done enough multistarer

[@humerahameed1624]

Totally agree

[@shauli3110]

Want to appreciate Badam Gul for is consistent accent in Sang e Mah. None of the veteran and mainstream actors could do the same in the play.

[@s.s.m9936]

Thank you for saying this. I was observing the same

[@hercatalogue1323]

This one is for Something Haute viewers and reviewers of the comment section. You guys watch every content with such a observant eyes, and a different and beautiful perspective. I like how everyone is coming up with their theories and novel ideas about the storyline. Always a positive space for discussions. XD

[@hk4943]

Army wives do gossip about everything under the sun but they never gossip about a martyr’s widow remarrying because its an extremely sensitive topic.

[@ayeshakanwalkhalid6082]

Hassan, you are wrong Marjan asked his man to kill Hilmand not sheherzad. the scene between Hilmand and sheherzad is amazing love, their chemistry is on fire, the way she seemed completely smitten by Hilmand's aura is so beautiful and cute at the same time.

[@thevibe2316]

Yes he wanted his right hand man to kill Hilmand and then say that he did it cuz he misbehaved with the gurl but Hilmand didn’t and that’s y that guy said to Marjan that Hilmand ne mauqa hi nhi dia.

[@saniak5262]

I thought so too but i think Hasan is right. If the girl is killed, there is no witness that Hilmand didnt kill her. But if hilmand is killed, the girl will provide witness that haji's man killed hilmand as there was no one present there except him. So Hasan is right :)

[@rafiamirza1]

@@saniak5262 aap samajh nahee raheyn...the issue here is that the person before killed a guy who misbehaved with the foreign grl n the witness was only the killer n thwt foreign grl...even here if u notice is the hilmand (who is basically the main issue) n tgag grl n that gunman ..so if the gunman kills hilmand if hilmand misbehaves; then theyve witnesses that hilmand was misbehaving with that grl thats y the gunman killed him....well if u see theost ; hes gonna get shot later n kubra khan gonna do teemardarey n all, its then when this love shuv gonna get start officially 😉

[@narcissistichealingforempaths]

Yes, I think Hassan has misunderstood Hajji's intention. They wanted to pressure Sheherzade to irritate Hilmand and expect him to lose it.

[@MiraasbyMariyamDawood]

@@rafiamirza1 yes plus the gun man even assured her before entering that if anything happens, he will come to her rescue. they expected Hilmand to misbehave so that the gun man can shoot and Shehrezaad would be the perfect witness.

[@juhigupta4574]

Sang e Mah: I think Aamna is on the right track regarding what Haaji was scheming... He was hoping that Hilmand misbehaves with Shehrzaad, and the right hand man then shoots Hilmand and tells everyone that he did this to protect the honour of Shehrzaad, like in the Dadaji ki story... Hassan wali interpretation sahi nahi lag rahi....

[@samsamar2000]

I thought same about it

[@shaniaadeez8498]

Same 😒

[@Fatima_ali14]

Right

[@maryamlove2443]

Right

[@sundusabubakar9359]

Right

[@wardahhussain8513]

Until Ehde Wafa, I also thought that the armed forces are over glorified. However, after my recent visit to Islambad I beg to differ with my own opinion. I was hosted by a PAF pilot a trip to Murree and no words would be enough to describe what an an honourable, humble, and hospitable man he was. In fact, not only him, but a lot of his platoon mates were extremely nice, caring and friendly. He was not someone very close to us yet treated us with delicious food in his officer's mess, and showed us around the place despite his tight, hectic schedule. These people are truly heroes inside out. They have super human qualities indeed. Their love for the country and its people is well reflected in their personality. May Allah always bless them. Aameen!

[@MariamAliRaza]

Ameen

[@aemmaenn5048]

JBG: The twin sisters came to distract Sonia so that the other lady could get maps for the bridges. In the earlier scene she had asked Sonia to ask Anwaarul haq to give locations of those bridges which can easily be recreated sso that they can bomb now to create chaos and then later rebuild them. Also Rumi now works for Mukti Bahini because he believes army killed Haroon. If you remember tht was an army operation in university which eventually killed Haroon. Sange Mah: Haji Marjan wanted Awal Khan tto kill Hilmand as he thought that he would misbehave with Shehrezaad. The Christian girls story was the same. This way they would also have had Shehrezaads testimony that Awal Khan killed Hilmand to save her.

[@sabahatmazhar6056]

Jo Bichar Gaye: goosebump moments: scene between Rumi and Shabnam, scene between Sonia and Farrukh, The Shining twins doppelgängers that appear at Sonia’s house and that whole sequence of them singing, Captain Fakhuruddin’s speech at the end as he says Allahu Akbar and as Rumi sets off the explosion…it’s hard to pinpoint any one moment…this is a complete cinematic experience per se…

[@aashiidrisi7239]

So true...it definitely is a complete cinematic experience. Loved every bit of it❣

[@nausheenabdulla2587]

JO BICHAR GAYE EP#12…………A round of applause 👏👏👏👏for each and every actor for delivering the best work of their lives. We have no words for Wahaj Ali’s performance to be honest, he will forever be RUMI for us now on. He delivered few dialogues in this episode but wow to his face expressions and body language specially his scene with Nadia Jameel.He is one of the most successful young actors in the entertainment industry with back to back hit projects proving he is one gifted actor. Though JBG is Talha Chahour’s debut in the TV industry, but definitely one of those roles that will be remembered for a long time. He as a Captain Farrukh, gave a remarkable performance, and made us live through the character’s pain and suffering. His chemistry with Sonia is praise-worthy and we would love to see him more on the screen. Maya Ali as Sonia has left an everlasting impression, whether it’s her looks, her voice or the way she expressed herself, her concern for Rumi and her connection with Captain keeps the viewer confused ,she never fails to impress her audience at any moment and how can I forget her big expressive eyes and gorgeous hairs, OMG! She is one of the few actresses who can sport any hairstyle and look terrific This play is a complete package…A MASTER PIECE

[@sabahatmazhar6056]

Completely agree…I can’t imagine Talha Chahour doing anything mediocre going forward…he’s set the bar pretty high for himself…

[@Nidhi-ll3yq]

@@sabahatmazhar6056 absolutely my sentiments !

[@hiranajmi93]

Actually Hilmand has 2 personalities. One is a sensitive person who love his mother, brother and also Haji Marjan(because he was a good father to him until he came to know that Haji was the one who killed Nasarullah) and on other side his revenge side kicks in and he wants to overcome all the things over his agony.

[@saimaiftikhar4473]

No words for Jo bichar gaye . It reminds me of my childhood , living in Malir cantt , going to trenches , sirens etc . I remember how the units moved out from cantt to borders , it was almost empty . Sadness in the air . My father used to talk about all the situation . How bhutto refused to accept mujeebb’s success and than everything goes into spirals leading to fall of Dhaka . This drama is doing justice and taking us back to history with sad memories . Thanks to the team of jo bichar gaye 👏👏👏👏👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@hercatalogue1323]

Been having a crush on Atif Aslam since my childhood and now watching him play Hilmand- The Hamlet is like a fan-fiction dream come true. Man, his acting is class apart. Tailor-made role just for him. Also, from his interviews, it is evident that he is into Urdu literature, poetry and Sufism which shows when he is delivering his performance and uttering those dialogues with such beauty.

[@AnonymousOnlyy]

The chaddar that hilmand put around shehrzad was symbolism for protection and 'izat ka muhafiz', and that is what sets him different in the eyes of shehrzad in the light of her past trauma aur jo akhri scene mein office ka boss ussay harass krta

[@onestopacademyenglish]

Jo bicher gaye: Those women came to Maya's house to look for the bridge's information. PTV personnel asked her for this when she called Shonya in her office. She asked her to get information from Anwar ul Haq

[@intensenotcrazy]

Yes, they wanted information about the bridges that they were planning to blow up from Anwar-ul-Haq, but Sonya didn't help them so they got it this other way. What I was then unsure about- was the PTV lady really in contact with Rumi and giving messages from him, or was she lying to Sonya so that she would cooperate with them?

[@babitapradhan7903]

In our indian history textbooks,we still read about taxashila and indus valley civilization,very happy to see it.love from india

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@ENBSamiaSiddiqui]

No Hassan I think you've misunderstood that Haji sahab's plan. Because the right-hand-man only took up the gun when Hilnand draws closer, and puts it down when he doesn't do anything. Like, if he planned to murder Shaharzaad anyway why would he wait for Hilmand to get agitated or something? I believe Haji just wanted to kill Hilmand and She was only an excuse like their grandfather backstory. I love these rewies btw, it's like having discussions with friends.

[@pakistandiaries90]

I think the same, Haji wanted to kill Hilmand and the accusations would be on shehrzad or may be on his right hand man ,and he would forgive his man becoz he would take oath and he will be forgiven for the murder ,,,,,but at the same time Hassan's story is also relatable,,,, confusing

[@cricommentarybyfia1827]

Yes, what he intended was to have an excuse to kill hilmand. So he could prove later that since hilmand disrespected shehrzaad, marjan's man killed him.

[@seemikhalid9252]

Yes totally agreed. Hajj wanted to kill Hilmand and use Sheherzad as an excuse

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

Hassan's narrative of this scene is incorrect. The henchman was instructed to kill Hilmand!

[@mehsoonawaqar1243]

Amna this is a fact, the family of the martyrs are shown the utmost respect. Every where they are given perferential treatment. The senior officer wives take special care of them.

[@Amwaseem3624]

I'm so moved by Atif Aslam's acting.His screen presence makes me smile and ofcourse how Shahzad gave a befitting response to her jerk boss was really good... Sang e Mah my favorite drama ❤

[@Bh70399]

Why ? He’s acting terrible, he can hardly say dialogues with any sort of emotions. Also he seems like a pakka Urdu speaking rather than Pathan. He couldn’t have acted worse

[@eo7200]

We take your duo as a reliable source of drama criticism but it is so disappointing to see that none of you actually pay attention to the plot details. Hassan bhai, your interpretation and understanding of the entire situation of Haji Marjan's plan to get rid of Hilmand is absolutely wrong. Haji Marjan's dad's brother was killed by a villager because he misbehaved with a foreigner woman, a mehmaan passing by their village. He instructs his right-hand man to take Sheherezad to Hilmand in order to ask him to apologise. The plan was that that Hilmand will get irritated and misbehave with Sheherezad, which will give haji's accomplice a reason to shoot Hilmand. Therefore, repeating the entire scenario all over again expecting Sheherezad to be a witness that he was killed because of his misbehaviour with a guest woman. The plan didn't work out obviously because Sheherezad was so awestruck that she didn't mention anything to Hilmand and there was no conflict. Ye thi ap ki story. Please program karnay se pehlay apni research ker liya kareyn. Your audience respects your opinion which puts a lot of responsibility on you guys. 🙏 shukriya

[@wonderwoman6933]

Before this discussion he was remembering Hilmand's dialogue in the previous episode ( that chess wala scene) ke ab agr tm aur aur tmhre paltu ko zuban se yeh lafz nikla tu maafi ki meem munh se niklne se pehle uska sar na phora tu Hilmand ko nasrullah ka khoon na smjhna. Haaji ne awal khan ko bola ke shehrzaad ko bolna k Hilmand ko maafi k liye force kry.. us ne socha wo maafi ka dabao dhaly ge tu Hilmand ko ghussa aye ga aur wo misbehave kry ga shehrzaad se aur awwal khan usko maar dy ga... pr aisa ni hua q k wo phle mil chukay the😁😁😁

[@javeriasiddiqui6242]

I was just gonna say that but thank God I read your comment...😀

[@eo7200]

@@wonderwoman6933 exactly! Thank you for beautifully connecting the dots.

[@ayeshak4996]

Exactly. Thoroughly disappointed in Hassan and Aamna. We always say that our dramas are not good, but the fact is that on and off we have good dramas; however, our drama critics are definitely not very good. First, they are the people who actually love Netflix stuff and watch these dramas just to make money through their channels. Second, their Urdu is not good, they don't even know the meaning of many words used in the dramas or the meaning of many drama's titles. Lastly, they don't do the research they MUST do before reviewing a drama. Hence, at most, they are just two drama viewers who have made a channel to share their views after watching a drama but in no way they can be considered a reliable source of drama criticism.

[@afiraqahar8130]

Reviews these days are rushed and missed out on details

[@ImxMeeka]

I literally laughed on aamna’s review about army person’s wives, thats the thing that actually comes in my mind that why they always show even civilised modern educated women gossiping and saying such horrible things and not these wives... and also why the mother in law of major samia says me kiyun na khiyaal rakhun apni bahu ka woh officer he army me but i think its a wrong approach, every mother in law whose bahu doing job (any kind of job) should be respectful and caring towards her.

[@asmaabbasi1104]

yea...i mean we also live with normal people but i have never seen women gossiping like so openly

[@mooey87]

I don’t think they were really gossiping though, they didn’t say anything bad, they were just acknowledging what happened. I think it’s odd that Kiran wanted to hide it though. I mean everyone hangs out together there so obviously it would come out eventually 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@asmaabbasi1104]

@@mooey87 i was talking about dramas in generally not about sinf e ahan

[@nausheenabdulla2587]

JO BICHAR GAYE……… it’s an extremely powerful play and giving a balanced view of both sides and as u said We can see human emotions on both sides…. Thanks to the entire TEAM for making this narrative so believable and close to the viewers hearts This play is teaching us Our world needs: Bridges, not divisions Friends , not enemies Hope, not fear Love, not hate Non-violence, not violence Peace, not chaos Pens, not guns We need humanity Right now Tomorrow Forever

[@recollections-may-vary9328]

I don't know why our critics are always so reluctant to criticize an actor's performance and find it much easier to blame the writer. Let's be honest, Ishq-e-laa suffers on all counts. Not only is the writing unimpressive, the direction is mediocre and the performances lacklustre. Yumna is not performing half as well as she did in her previous 2 dramas nor as well as her other drama on air currently. For me her OTT expressions (acting), her weird reactions (direction) and silly dialogues (writing) all are the problem. I wish someone would just come.out and say that no, this time this actor didn't perform well, this time he/she wasn't as good as drama X, this time they could've been better. I'm sure a little apt criticism won't kill anyone or their egos.

[@sarahkhalid1869]

Regarding jo bichar gaye - the reason that lady comes to Sonia’s house is to get the info on the bridges across Dhaka that helps or connects the pak army to each other as in different bases or enables goods to reach them. I believe what Rumi is blowing up are those bridges that have been identified and pinpointed by the the PTV lady. Because she tells Sonia that we need to mark them so that they can be repaired after liberation…

[@vanitanazir8401]

And Mr. Anwar ul haq had the info but he wouldn’t give it to the rogue elements so the ptv lady barges in Mr.Haq’s house and brings those girls to keep Sonia busy while she fishes for those maps.

[@mehsoonawaqar1243]

After listening to your reviews i have started taking note of the technical aspects like shots, lighting etc. And can now appreciate the scenes of Jo bichar gaey more.

[@nausheenabdulla2587]

Yes I’m loving the shots of JBG and the cinematography.. it looks as we r in Dhaka

[@zahrasukhera]

Salam. I am a big fan of Something Haute, but I would disagree with the gossip part I'm Sinf e Ahan. An army personnel's family ( or any other security force for that matter ) spends their lives in constant fear and praying for the safety of their guardian, especially when they get posted to operational areas. And if an officer gets Shaheed, its a matter of extreme agony for the family for the years to come. We would never question his bewaa's actions in any way. She had a young daughter and a fellow coursemate offered to marry her to take care of her. I find it extremely uplifting. Salute to that officer for taking care of the his friend's family like that. Its indeed a thing to celebrate, not gossip.

[@65RUMA]

I love to watch Hassan's youthfulness but learn and enjoy more of Amna's knowhow through her narration. So balanced and never frightened of what people will say. Amna's knowledge and Hassan's boisterous and liveliness. Always stay blessed.

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@sadiachoudhry6415]

Amna you nailed it ....."Asims character is not so complicated....." Hasan Bhai balance, Haath hola rakhain tareef wich Same was done with Danyal in taana baana, Hasan Bhai said "he is a fantastic actor"...but Amna corrected that the role was easy going... But new roles and characters like captain Farrukh played by Mr Chatoor , yes is demading, challenging needed mature acting approach etc definetely needs hinest great praises 👍👍❤️

[@SajidAli-gw7df]

The scene between farukh and sonia outside ptv was such a classical scene, in jo bichar gaye

[@saniahameed667]

Ok so i think both of you got the Christian girl story wrong in Sang-e-Mah. I think Awal khan wanted to kill Hilmand as if he misbehaves with Shehrzad than Awal khan will save her. So basically Hilmand will be killed for misbehaving with the girl ,same as how the Grand Father of Haji was killed. Isi liay Awal khan ny jaky kaha k Hilmand ny to usko behn bna lia q k wo soch rhy thy Hilmand apny state of mind ki waja sy is journalist k sath kuch ulta seedha behave kryga.

[@shaniaadeez8498]

I think ye review k chakr mn jldi jldi episodes dakhty is liay Sahi ni smjh ske..

[@sarahshaykh04]

Agreed. Hilmund was to be shot. Not Sheherzade. The henchman came back and tells Marjan that Hilmund didn't do anything malicious towards Sheherzade so I couldn't shoot him

[@kausarhassaan7995]

Yes. Right. I saw the whole episode again because Hassan said he was about to kill Shehrzaad. But no he was sent to kill Hilmand. They asked Shehrzaad to pressurize hilmand for maafi. Jisko sun k ussay ghussa aata In the last episode he told Marjaan khan that maafi ka meem nikalne se phele uska gala ghont dunga agar maafi ka dobaara kaha to...

[@sanailyas1024]

Spot on. Exactly what I understood.

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

SeM: Finally they met, the moment that we've all been waiting for since their last encounter. And my goodness the wait was worth it, such beautifully shot & acted romantic scene. And Kubra Khan - what range of emotions she has displayed in that scene, my eyes were glued on her the whole time. "Kaampte jism pe koi chaadar daalne wala ho" final dialogue, followed by the OST - which further elevated our emotions!!! Pure brilliance in acting, writing and direction 👏👏👏

[@aashiidrisi7239]

JBG: This episode has some very powerful moments...first, when shabnam curses rumi my goddd that scene was so impeccably done...the way she was cursing him and the way rumi reacted. Nadia Jameel and wahaj ali both nailed it, wahaj's expressions were outstanding I could actually feel his pain...no dialogues only expressions wahaj is mindblowing. That scene was bone chilling. 2. The meeting of Sonia and Captain farrukh. Their conversation was so impactful. Talha and Maya have amazing chemistry...I so want farrukh and sonia to end up together but I know it's not gonna happen. Haisam has given us a gem...JBG is a masterpiece is true sense. Direction, writing, cinematography and performances everything is top notch. Talha, Wahaj and Maya are outstanding.

[@fatimanasir5697]

Really l dont have words to describe the character of rumi his skills are exceptional jitni bhi tareef karo kam hai iss drama ki kam hai JBG💕❤❤❤💔💔lots of love for this drama 💔

[@amanpreetsuman3992]

Last episode of sange mah was the best one. I couldnt get Atif's dialogues out of my mind. Atif and kubra's performances were surreal . Totally worth watching.

[@zauqTV]

Keep them in your mind then, I guess space should not be the problem.

[@Itzz_Inaaya]

@@zauqTV 🤣

[@zauqTV]

@@Itzz_Inaaya , does this fall under trolling? 😀

[@Itzz_Inaaya]

@@zauqTV just a joke😛

[@sania.s3472]

Jbg: i dont want this show to end but it is also getting heavy on hearts. 💔💔💔 Career best performance by Wahaj Maya Talha and also the crew. Bsss sonia itni pathar dil kyun ha wo b farrukh jesy pyary cute sy lrky k samny😍😍😂 Nadia J one second of screen presence makes you cry for a monther who lost his child .

[@maheen8869]

i think watching jo bichad gaye's latest episode was so amazing because it made me realize that good writing is when you have two characters (like shabnam and rumi) who are on opposite sides of a conflict and both have caused each other pain but you understand and empathize with both of them and their pain. the acting this episode was just superb. that scene with rumi, shabnam and sonia was heartbreaking and beautiful and sonia and farrukh's conversation was so well written with such a nuanced back and forth. even anwar as a side character is so important. in the episode previous to the last one, when rumi wants to go out and smoke, he tells him to stay and smoke inside because atleast wo usski ki aankhon ke saamne toh rahay ga...when sonia asks rumi if he wants to eat and the look on his face. he's a husk of what he used to be. he's tired, starved and guilt has eaten away at him. with dramas like these it's like hazaron saal nargis apni benoori ko roti hai barri mushkil se hota hai deedawar paida.

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@maheenqutab]

Amna, your frame is so beautiful today. The background the lighting…. excellent 😍

[@shahneelmehmood951]

I think Atif Aslam performance isn't something to talk about... He has that aura that hilmand character requires,,, and writing is so powerful u barely notice the performance,, if he was just saying "m office s Agya, chay ly ao "😂to bnda note krta h,,, story is so powerful that little bit lapse don't matter

[@sobhak123]

For Amna: Army officers ke wives gossip kerty hey but we leave shuhada’s wives. 😬

[@cupidinthecage]

Army officers wives are like that because they live in uncertainty between life n death . If not with them but with someone they know in that 10 , 20 ppl ,students or friends get martyrdom in training or some in field and that is true so they become sensitive to these situations . It’s not glorifying it’s reality

[@sidrakafeel9160]

JBG..two narratives and two stuggle of two ideology are very well shown by rumi and capt.farrukh...acting by wahaaj and talha is beyond words..both deserves award for that..infact the whole team..

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@akankhyamohanty6693]

I am in love with Hilmand and sheherzad's chemistry damn ♥♥🔥🔥😭😭

[@ayshcandy7155]

Sinf e ahan... amna is me mahjabeen k British accent ki khair hai kiun k is me start me btaya tha k mahjabeen ne apni adhi zindagi bahr e guzari hai. jb wo Shaista ko kehti hai k mujy pashto kesy a skti hai urdu itni mushkil se ati hai mujy. or uske father b shaista k abu ko btaty hain k wo bahr settled thy phr kafi time wahan guzarny k bad Pakistan aye thy.. Sang e mah me I agree accent itna solid nh hona chahye but I really like kubra 😊

[@whiteorchids3811]

Hassan and amna aapki waja sa hi mujha jo bichar gya dakhna ka moka mila es drama ka to mujha pata bhi nae tha aap logo na esk bara ma baat ki pahli dafa or mujha lga dakhna chahea and I'm so happy I watched or jitna hum sb essa admire kr raha han esma aap dono ki makhnat bhi ha aapka review dakh dill khush ho jata ha ya drama or eska whole crew tareef k kabil ha

[@nausheenabdulla2587]

Amna and Hassan…for JBG…the PTV media ladies reaching at Anwar Ul Haq residence was to get the maps for the bridges that needed to b blast by Mukhti baini ppl and to repair later after the independence, they needed the bridges details from his cabinet that they took it hiding it under the saree ( this was Rum’s msg to Sonia…(GIVE THEM WHAT THEY WANT)

[@mindfulexpedition5735]

With Sinf e Ahan I feel it's nice to see them show Army officers wives converse the way they did, and in earlier episodes showing Shaista's father being congratulated by the neighbours as well as a few other scenes. I see it as them showing how it should be done rather than how it is which is what we normally see and often criticise.

[@asiyamuqaddas3795]

AOA Aamna and Hassan. I am a retired Army officer's wife. Considering I didn't grow up in Pakistan and neither has my husband graduated from AM College, the environment was new to us both. Neither of us knew dependence on the so called 'household' staff provided. Ladies (ladywives) always have enough time to gossip, backbite and compete with each other's monetary background. Mostly those who chose to stay home instead of pursue any job or career. News travels faster than wildfire. Especially when there is a martyrdom. Only another Army officer will be brave enough to marry his widow. For all other officers, it is highly respected. For the character of Kiran I think, her feeling ashamed of the situation is unrealistic. Martyrdom is a huge honor, both in this life and the hereafter

[@kumudchadha6683]

Totally agree with Hassan this was my favorite episode of Sange mah and that scene btw Kubra n Atif was so romantic, watched it twice😀 then Atif s song oh God it was amazing.

[@seemikhalid9252]

Kubra looked totally smitten

[@divyaramavat2641]

Biggest problem in QMK - nobody ever mentioned that Murad being married to Mehrbano, did second marriage with Fari without asking her. This is a felony i think, nobody mentioned in court case against Murad. This episode defied all logics and all connections.

[@LoveYourself.....]

I am 100% agree with Aamna about azkaas character in Ishq e la.

[@mahnoorkhan6006]

Ishqelaa: They have shown a very few medical students in the class but actually Pakistan k hr medical college mai atleast 100 students aik class mai hoty hain aur King Edward mai tou 350 tou ishqelaa mai konsa medical college dikhaya hai jahan sirf 15-20 students hoty!!

[@Fatima-pn5fq]

JBG: Just wanted to clarify that Roomi is a freedom fighter now fighting against the West Pakistanis. The governor he killed in the last episode was a west pakistani sympathiser. And the women came to steal the maps for the bridges for which kokab had asked soniya to convince Anwaar sahab.

[@arslanashrafbutt5062]

Hassan is wrong about the reference , what haji marjan wanted was that shehrzad would provoke him to apologize to jirga and then hilmand would get rude or handsy with shehrzad and then haji marjaz man would shoot him and kubra would say infront of jjrga that yes he became rude with him and thats why he was shot. That is why there was so much emphasis on kubra to convince Hilmand to apologize, because hilmand made it very clear in the last episode that the idea of apologizing makes him angry. And thats why marjans gun man told him that he didn't get a chance to shoot him because hilmand didn't do anything instead he gave her his shawl.

[@mominaamjad2345]

Sange Mah: why are you guys not taking about hilmand’s appearance? His carefully gelled and blow dried hair don’t make him look like he lives in a graveyard, not to mention his crisp shalwar kameez.

[@feeblePeeble]

and perfect cut of beard

[@mariumkhalid5629]

Shout out to Shahrukh for editing this video and releasing it on Monday!! Thank you Shahrukh!! And Hassan got haji plan wrong. Awal Khan would have killed Hillmand and justify his act by saying that he misbehaved with mehmaan.

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@sadafkhan2509]

Being an army officers wife i can bet you, no other institution can be this much disciplined. Hassan and amna i wish i could tell you that how much gossip creators army officers wives are as normal wives but the only difference is they do only in their friend zone.else like an army officer senior, the wife is also treated as senior by the wives. The house hold and the workers at our home have been trained to respect the ladies at their best!

[@srijitaroy-pathfinderhazra8037]

Azka has to be the most irritating female lead we have rn. She is so so seflish. Usske aas paas log mar rahe hain aur usse kuch farak hi nahi padta kya?Nahi usse to sirf doctor hi banna hain. Chaahe uski puri family mar jaaye bas usse doctor banado she is happy. Shanaya mar gayi her reaction was so bland. She doesnt even realise till now that Shanaya died because she told her about the abduction. And what is with that irritating expression she has on her face 24/7? Why would Yumna take up such a selfish two dimensional character?

[@SA-ui8if]

sang e mah: what i understood from haji marjans back story in this episode was that he wanted sher e zaat to insist on an apology from hilmand and since he won't give in hilmand would misbehave and thus giving agha a chance to shoot hilmand on the same pretext as haji marjans pardada was shot, also the person swearing on the cross was the female that was harrassed by the par dada, this kind of made more sense as than they would recreate the whole scenario of yesteryears with sherzad being there as a witness. I was'nt trying to correct your interpretation but this angle shows haji marjan as an even more evil person that he would malign his step son and than have him killed rather than getting a girl he barely knows killed.

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@wajeehazarrar995]

@53:06…. Soniya’s father is a civil engineer. He has the prints of the bridges. So they come to the house to get the prints for the bridges….t

[@fakhirasaba2857]

آج کا پروگرام مجھے بہت اچھا لگا اور سب سے زیادہ تبصرہ مجھے قصہ مہربانو کا پر اچھا لگا کیونکہ وہ بالکل سچ اور کھڑا تھا کیونکہ یہ ایک ایک قسط کا ناول تھا جس کا اختتام ڈرامے کی طرح ہی بے تکا تھا بلکہ ڈرامے میں تو پھر بھی عدالت کے ذریعے اس معاشرتی مسئلے کو حل کرنے کی کوشش کی گئی اصلی ناول میں تو کوئ کوشش ہی نہیں کی گئ تھی یا تو مسائل نہ چھیڑا کریں چھیڑیں تو انجام تک اللہ کے واسطے لے جایا کریں اور دوسرے اور جیسے سنگ ماہ ہے اس میں سب عورتیں مضبوط صنف آہن کا مقصد ہی عورتوں کو لوہے کی طرح مضبوط بنانا ہے تو عورتیں مضبوط ہیں زیادہ تعداد میں تو ان کی کہانی سنائیں بے تکی بے مقصد مظلومیت والے ڈرامے اب برداشت نہیں ہوتے باقی سنگ ماہ اور صنف آہن جو بچھڑ گئے پر بہت اعلی تبصرہ کیا

[@AhmedKhan-yb1bn]

Great review. Sinf e Ahan , Sang e Mah and JBG continue to be top 3. Really nice to see Sajal n Nathmy get screen time. Arzoo stole the show for me. JBG and Sang e Mah, top notch every way

[@wardaakhtar8375]

Pleasantly surprised 🤗 Drama is a 'visual' medium hence, it cannot be pulled off without technical perspectives. Which is why, the cinematography, editing, background score are essential to be discussed.

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@sarahashfaq9980]

It was a pleasant surprise to watch today's review cuz it was unexpected. I appreciate both of you for taking time in your busy schedule for it. I can understand that's why you especially, Hassan couldn't understand Haji Marjan 's plan. He didn't want to kill Sheherzad he wanted to kill Hilmund. Hassan was telling totally a different story.

[@alishbahasad6676]

In love with JO BICHAR GYE!!! WHAT A MASTERPIECE!

[@AudioNovelLovers]

Omg guys thank u so much for the review today... I love uuu ... I wanna thank Shahrukh especially for editing and publishing the episode today instead of tomorrow ❤❤thanks buddy.

[@saniyashaukat9486]

Bad lightening affect a drama. Can't recall name but there was probably one of Fawad Khan's which a lot of us didn't watch bcz of bad lightening. You guys notice and discuss as well aestethic and natural beauty and cinematography whenever done well, like JO BICHAR GAYE that Talha's hidding behind tree scene with light. Or ishq e laa initial shots. Talking about SANG E MAA : I cried at Badam sing scene where he told how Asadullah used to say Bahi hai bhai mera. That was very well performed. . Need to appreciate this actor. .They also cleared why Hania doesn't detest Mastan singh. Apart from that of course that kubra's scenes with Atif and afterwards were quite strong and emotional. Her eyes also make you feel what she's going through. Haji ne shak me daal diya hai. Kafi grey character hai. Need to know if he actually loves Hikmat or not. And how did he marry Hikmat's mom. Want to know if Mastan (Omer Rana) himself said sari zindagi ka gulam ban jata ya did Zargona say it. Appreciating thay he took stand to get proper punishment and realized that he had murdered 2 lives.

[@anna-yh9mc]

Jo bicher gae now sooooo thrilling......💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪💚🇦🇪

[@iamnaziz]

I agree with Hassan, Shehre Zad and Hilmand scene was so romantic and well performed. ❤️

[@aishamahmood4678]

Amna if you well aware with Army you should know Army’s widows are very respectable ,this is very sensitive and emotional area in Army . yes they do gossip but they can never make fun of remarrying martyred wife and They gives special respect to them

[@sammyann70]

Never thought I’d say this but I agree with #Hasan that I now prefer ‘Mere Humsafar’ over ‘Ishq E Laa’ 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@mahnoorkhan6006]

The biggest problem with ishqelaa is k yumna aik fsc ya 1st year mbbs ki student nhi lgti !!! Plzz share your opinion on this.. btw 1st year mbbs student is 18-19 years old

[@mominaahmad8570]

why any one is not talking about that

[@NotTheGoddess]

Shout Out to Shahrukh for the Monday Episode!

[@mooey87]

I think as Mahjabeen the British twinge works because her character also spent time in the UK (maybe that’s why they chose her for the role) but agreed in other dramas where it’s not relevant it shouldn’t show.

[@starlsma2000]

You can't just get rid of your accent that easily

[@mooey87]

@@starlsma2000 You can. British actors play American roles all the time and vice versa. Regular ppl can’t but that’s what acting is.

[@gulsaanga4533]

It's encouraged in army to marry the widows of fallen soldiers. It's army's tradition and it's celebrated. They are groomed into this tradition. I wish I could explain it better.

[@salaamletstalk]

Sang e Mah: A lot of people have already pointed out that Haji Marjaan had sent Awwal Khan to kill Hilmand on pretext of him trying to misbehave with Sheherzaad with that background story. Hassan, you misread the whole point there. Zargoona's connection with the trauma of her miscarriage and her husband's death so many years ago and that softer side of Badaam Gul when he converses with Gulmina was great. Finally the scene between Sheherzaad and Hilmand was truly magical. ❣❣

[@ayshcandy7155]

Absolutely 100 agree with amna on Ishq e Laa.. it's just sooo boring nd I watched it within 5 mins... every thing you said about azka is so true..

[@Tigrealmainonly]

Mind-blowing episode of sang e mah...the chemistry between shehzaad and hilmand was too good

[@crazybird786]

What is it with Maya Alis obsession with such dark eyeshadows. No matter what the situationc/circumstance/character, she has this over the top eye makeup, its distracting from her otherwise good performances.

[@nehacreations8669]

Wahaj ali performance jbg👏👏👏

[@samreen-rizvi]

Special shout out to Shahrukh for managing to put this up in Monday only!!!

[@samraz6958]

JBG The ladies were looking for a map of tge bridges they want to blow.up.

[@javeriazafar970]

Jab jo bichar gye shuru hua tha tw mainy shuru k 4 episodes nai dekhy thy but all thanks to something haute and hasan or amna aap logo k reviews ne mujhy jo bichar gye ignore krny nai diya or ab mai every sunday jo bichar gye dekhti hun koi episode nai miss krti or enjoy bhi krti hun bohot❤️

[@zauqTV]

Harpalgeo is equally thankful!😀

[@saimajalil8044]

Sinfe ahan- awesome 👍🏻 i like the fact that they chose to show kind & sensitive women as army wives who show concern towards each other. They could have shown typical women gossiping and harassing each other but they did not. Sange mah- zaberdast. Atif scene & the last scene was amazing. Haji marjaan is so clever. He sent his guy to shoot himland

[@NASH_U]

Kia baat hai Shahrukh ki..we are watching it on Monday 👌

[@tipuhome]

Sang e Mah is really Intresting. That chadar scene OMG 🤩❤ QMK was also good..

[@Anonymous-v5f]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp_Fp6CdZqaJbZY

[@pavshinde]

Kudos to Sharukh as it is Monday here in uk !!!

[@aleezasana5010]

Hats off to shahrukh for putting this up on monday

[@humazarar2093]

Amna is right! yes Mehru's gestures to Mahir are very ' motherly'

[@umbreenusman9854]

For sang e mah , I also understood what Amna understand.

[@sarahkhalid1869]

This is for Hassan. Regarding Sang e Mah. The person who held the cross and vowed to tell the truth was the gori Ma’am. There were only two Men there, the one who died and the one who shot him.

[@sevgilimjk]

hassan completely misinterpreted haji marjan's plan 😬 in the beginning of the episode, haji marjan was thinking about what hilmand said to him "ab agar tum ya tumhre paltu ke zuban pe ye lafz (maafi) aya tou khuda ki qasam....blah blah blah At the same moment, awal khan arrives and tell him about shehrzad who wanted to meet hilmand. Haji marjan thought about getting rid of both of his sar dard i.e shehrzad & hilmand. He came up with this shrewd plan that if shehrzad asks hilmand to apologize infront of jirga, hilmand will get furious and he might misbehave with her too. It will give awal khan an opportunity to shoot hilmand on the pretext of saving the honour of a woman who is also their guest.

[@mariammasood1313]

True.. and at the end after so much support of mehran she said she can't marry... I can't understand... That why they show this ..