We Fixed Battlefield 1's Historical Inaccuracies (Part 2: Multiplayer)

[@TheFrosty_1]

Join one of the best GTA 5 RP Grand RP servers - gta5grand.com/?ref=4082 (Get a $25,000, prime status, and choose a cool car in the game for registering at this link) Download RP GRAND for Free on Mobile - rpgrand.com/?Frosty Use promo code "FROSTY" in shop for rare rewards in the game *We’re excited to announce that since the making of this video the MARNE private servers are now ready for release following the recent EA Anti Cheat update! Thanks to everyone for your patience. You can now set up and enjoy your own dedicated servers and take advantage of LAN play, modded servers, and more. See more info here:* marne.io/ Part 1 Fixing Battlefield 1's campaign story mode inaccuracies video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/iXfQXouNnsuUoM0 Full Battlefield 1 Inaccuracies analysis video: kzbin.info/www/bejne/a4KwZ5qen7dniKc Massive thanks to mod creators Jay Fuzz and American Hero for their help in making this video possible! If you wish to support Jay Fuzz via donations for his modding work on all the ones shown in this video then find his Ko-fi here: ko-fi.com/jayfuzz42 Jay has asked if a few clarifications regarding his projects, 1918, and future updates could be made for the sake of keeping things clear and understandable. Starting off with wanting to note that the changes made to the pilots and cavalry (Officer) kits in the 1914 and 1916 mods are not made in the 1918 mod, they are exclusive to 1914 and 1916 only. Following that he wanted to clear up that the visual at 17:10 showcasing the Italian Officer actually has a mistake as there should be no cape there. This is a visual bug that occasionally occurs in the games menus. For the 1916 mod Jay actually wants to make the British sniper a white, Brodie wearing Tommy, but still wants to keep the Indian Sikh on the team somehow and have a Tommy wearing a soft SD cap, which currently works best on the Medic where he would likely have the Sikh. This is something he's been trying to figure out for some time and still hasn't come up with a solution that he's satisfied with just yet. He also wanted to say that he currently has unique textures for the Maori New Zealander's uniform that feature a light grey/green khaki wool appearance, and was supposed to be added in the next update alongside the updated Khaki Drill uniforms.

[@jayfuzz1086]

Hello everyone this is Jay! Author of the 1914 and 1916 mods, and collaborator on BF1918. If anyone has any questions, suggestions, clarifications, or corrections for anything featured in my mods please feel free to mention them as I'm always eager to learn and improve where I can! I did my best to be faithful whilst keeping some of the more exaggerated and bombastic tone of the default game, but will always be keen to make changes for the sake of history where I feel it necessary to do so. P.S if anyone can correct me on the Engineer's Kepi colours in the 1914 mod that would be more than appreciated as I have no idea if this is 100% correct or not, was quite difficult to fact check that one haha. Cheers!

[@umisonoda8206]

​@@jayfuzz1086 Hi There is still no solution to avoid the anticheat, right?

[@nicolassaid5979]

@@umisonoda8206 nope, also the game now runs like shit and there's still cheaters around, the anticheat literally made the game worse XD

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@@umisonoda8206 Unfortunately nothing yet :/

[@umisonoda8206]

@@TheFrosty_1 ohh i see, ty i hope we back run the mods

[@Lycan_of_1941]

Fix Battlefield 5 Inaccuracies, this could be a must watch film.

[@TheRedBaron2010]

@@Lycan_of_1941 Battlefield five installed in anti-mod

[@SpecialTungi2006]

Pretty sad that BF5 has installed an anti-cheat system to prevent modding, but the only thing that I'm sad about is that there's no Italian and Soviet forces in the game

[@TheRedBaron2010]

@@SpecialTungi2006 same

[@FIVEBASKET]

Yea.

[@thevladplay4966]

It's 100% inaccurate shit , it has to exist in middle 2000

[@ruffianraffy]

The WW1 uniforms of each nation's army look so gorgeous. It's such a shame the developers kept reusing the same uniforms and equipment models for nations like USA and Austro Hungary...

[@Aureus_]

Real!

[@ryszakowy]

this is austro-hungarian soldier so he will use... french webbing british canteen german ammo pouches american pants russian jacket funny helmet we saw in one historical photo but have no evidence of anything like that being used obviously he'll be black and carry 7 different pouches, we shall throw dice, first for nation second for type of the pouch

[@ElsekBeg]

One thing about older games this channel made me realize is. They may not be %100 historically accurate but they dont scream "Hey I'm something not from this era or fictional" and can be ignored while newer games are...

[@ryszakowy]

there is a reason World at War is considered the best call of duty

[@calopsita4465]

...nicki minaj

[@jlagaviota]

THE TANKER BECOMING A NAVY OFFICER IN THE GALLIPOLI MAP IS SOOOOOO GOOOD HOLY

[@1SilverDollar]

Shame the mods are gone. I remember using them and seeing a "tanker" go 'f it we ball' and charge down after losing his destroyer. Gallipoli becomes much more crazy when you see the naval captain taking his revenge personally.

[@jlagaviota]

@@1SilverDollar yeah its such a shame... aparently the anticheat works well... but the loss is defenetly a shame

[@spaman7716]

@@jlagaviota I've seen plenty of hackers since the update, all it did was screw over the mod community

[@vitmezulianek598]

Where?

[@sethleoric2598]

>replaces pants with army kilt holy shit im gonna download this mod now.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Hi there! This is Jay, author for 1916 and 1914. Unfortunately modding is no longer possible as of last week thanks to the new anti-cheat :( Glad you liked the additions though, thank you!

[@sethleoric2598]

@HarlowLovesGaming aw... that's sad, but it was a great mod while it lasted, thanks mate!

[@PhoenixT70]

@@HarlowLovesGamingTypical. EA is the enemy of fun.

[@TheIshikawaRin]

@@HarlowLovesGaming Hopefully a workaround is found eventually similar to how modders have been able to still mod the FIFA/FC games even in spite of the anti-cheat.

[@spaman7716]

@@TheIshikawaRin I'm sure it will be but that's probably very far down the line at this point

[@flamingrubys11]

0:17 the french a few months after the start of ww1 swapped to that intial darkish blue uniform so both are accurate

[@Mistah_Boombastic_BiggieCheese]

Yeah the french maps are set in Battles from 1916-1918 so no need for the bright red pants uniforms.

[@kingspore5000]

40:10 as a Polish myslef I'd never expect someone to add this to a computer game, especially that this historical fact is often neglected, thank you soo much!

[@SapphireScroll]

I was taken by surprise as well and I really appreciate somebody thought of this. But I'm wondering why only in the German faction. Poles were also present in the Russian and Austro-Hungarian armies. Heck, I'm pretty sure there were other Slavs and Hungarians in the Austro-Hungarian army as well. Nonetheless, great detail

[@Sailorcat98]

Hallers army

[@Sailorcat98]

Though they did commit some awful stuff

[@kingspore5000]

@@SapphireScroll Anti-cheat propably...there were plans about rest of the nations but most propably they didn't make it in thime

[@olekcholewa8171]

@@Sailorcat98 When?

[@E-11-s19]

Finally, some historically accurate models. This brings such relief to me. It's a shame that the community can create more historically accurate content then big developer companies.

[@Pigness7]

I prefer devs spend their time on making the game fun to play rather than worrying about everything being 100% historical accurate. Players changing that if they want is better for the ecosystem, I mean how would videos complaining about historical inaccuracies get any views if games were 100% historically accurate? Also, as a modder for a different game I don't really like it when people put us in competition with companies, it's bad for our mental health.

[@MoeruGoRound]

@@Pigness7 It reminds me of the time when Enlisted went on a sponsor spree. I hate it when people say "historically accurate = good game" to COD players and expect them to understand.

[@JustAGuy-IdkWhatElseUNeed]

​@@MoeruGoRoundLet's be real. Everyone wants to complain as much as possible. You can give them the slightest mistake and they'll immediately become angered rather than looking on the positives

[@MrPikaGammer]

The French here were made inaccurate.

[@qwerty30013]

It’s not their job to jerk off your history fantasy. It’s their job to make a video game playable for as many people as possible. Hope this helps

[@inductivegrunt94]

The changing of the US AEF to the Canadian CEF for the 1914 mod was a brilliant choice by the mod author. Battlefield 1 is such a fun game and I'm really happy to see historical uniforms for the various soldiers from each of the nations.

[@kingspore5000]

I DREAMED about this SINCE 2016...you're finally making my wishes to come true

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Hi there! This is Jay, author for 1916 and 1914. Unfortunately modding is no longer possible as of last week thanks to the new anti-cheat :( Glad you liked the additions though, thank you!

[@kingspore5000]

@@HarlowLovesGaming You did it just in time to fulfill my dreams and not only mine but MILLIONS of other people

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@ is a shame that these mods are unusable thanks to the latest update but I appreciate the kind words nonetheless

[@ScoutTrooperMan]

historical accuracy mods like these and the collection for world at war ngl are mods i cherish dear to my heart as someone with a autistic love and passion for the historical period of the 1910s onwards to the 1960s

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

You just like me frfr - Jay, 1914 and 1916 mod author :)

[@ImThatScotty]

I wonder if they’d be able to make a video on WW1 game series (Verdun, Tannenburg, Isonzo). As far as I know the developers did extensive historical research to make sure everything was accurate so it would be hard

[@kaiserrat70]

If they just merged the 3 games instead of letting two flop and one be small they'd be rich

[@PANCAKEMINEZZ]

​@@kaiserrat70Yeah I don't understand why they didn't treat them as expansions.

[@kaiserrat70]

@@PANCAKEMINEZZ makes no sense, I play ww1 games for trenches not mountains

[@a10goesbrrt28]

​@@kaiserrat70 the engines they're played on are vastly different

[@kaiserrat70]

@a10goesbrrt28 they'd all work the exact same on the current one if not better

[@TheRedBaron2010]

I freaking love your channel man. Keep up your good work.

[@oliverpohlproductions8291]

Wow, I salute you Frosty. Bf1's new anti cheat messing up a lot hurt, but this helps a lot.

[@Lycan_of_1941]

Your Videos are Perfect for History Research. Sometimes History, is a Mystery.

[@tylerstravelsandmore]

What gets me is they not only are more accurate, but look SO much better. Which begs the question why didn't they do this in the first place? Guns are one thing but uniforms are a completely different matter.

[@tsukopara2054]

DICE were under heinous time and budget constraints while making Battlefield 1 through to 2042, alongside both Star Wars Battlefront games. Some of the ex-employees (most of whom walked out after Battlefront 2 was prematurely axed) have said on Twitter that a lot of these inaccuracies were a result of having to rush to meet internal and external EA deadlines, some flimsy research (research trips are expensive), feedback from QA testers and EA higher ups, and multiple arguments between senior staff as to the pendulum between historical accuracy and rule of cool design. They were spinning a lot of plates while being consistently sabotaged.

[@andyfriederichsen]

It's understandable that the Canadians were left out of the unmodded game considering the fact that much of the Geneva Convention exists because of them. EDIT: The Battlefield 1 developers probably could've included them in the game but it would've been a pretty inaccurate portrayal of WW1 Canadians (to avoid having you play as basically a bad guy).

[@LucatheRexcario]

Wat?

[@cheesyfromindonesia9969]

​@@LucatheRexcarioBasically he is saying that the Geneva Convention even happened because of how brutal the Canadian troops were in World War 1. Example of this would be throwing canned food to the German trench who are probably cut off from their supply lines and starving then throwing gernades to their trenches after they threw the canned foods giving them false security

[@BrickyMySticky]

⁠@@cheesyfromindonesia9969Or killing POW’S, such as the officer who placed a live grenade in a german POW’S pocket without him noticing.

[@cheesyfromindonesia9969]

@@BrickyMySticky Real

[@Prizrak131]

What??? How do you even make that conclusion???

[@peacefulfungoloid8624]

SCOTLAND!!!...and... Canada, BUT SCOTLAND 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@MalcolmIIofCaledonia]

ALBA GU BRAGH!!! 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@olekcholewa8171]

**BAGPIPES START PLAYING**

[@devinthierault]

Aye

[@califpreacher]

Forever!!!!!!

[@angusyang5917]

Personally I think the Canadian scout in the 1914 mod could've been a First Nations soldier, since Canadian minister of defence encouraged them to enlist unlike with black and Asian Canadians, because he thought they would make ferocious soldiers on the battlefield. Also, missed an opportunity for the pilot on the Italian faction to be a pig

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

I appreciate the Porco Roso reference :) This is Jay, author for 1916 and 1914, appreciate the suggestion and might look into it! Maybe for the Medic or Assault class, but it also unfortunately has to do with the limitations of facial/character head mods and model optios. I'm fairly good at altering/editing/importing uniforms and equipment, but I could never quite figure out custom head models but definitely something to take a crack at at some point, cheers!

[@BitcrushedMozart]

​@@HarlowLovesGaming Are you able to make different models for the same faction depending on the map, or can you only replace existing models?

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@@BitcrushedMozart I can add new models, including new face models, it's more the fact that I'm bad at getting custom face models to animate and look natural haha, much better with making clothing and gear look believable, but people's faces are a whole other story.

[@GAM3RK1NG.]

@@HarlowLovesGaming i heard anti cheat doesn’t allow mods apparently, is that true? if so it’s probably because they saw this video, they hate fans so much, can you use workarounds

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@@GAM3RK1NG. Unfortunately it is very true :(

[@cleeiii357]

28:06 They feel a slight precipitation. "I think it’s raining," says the man. "No, it’s snowing," replies the woman. "How about we ask this Red Army/Communist officer here? He is always right!" exclaims the man. "Officer Rudolph, is it raining or snowing?" "Definitely raining," Officer Rudolph replies before walking off. The man turns to his wife with a smile. “See? Rudolph the Red knows rain, dear.”

[@saferhere]

what have you done? this pun is so mentally painful that i must pass out and die!

[@ryszakowy]

it was so stupid entire enemy trench started laughing as well

[@niono1587]

One note on the French Uniform, the red kepi would've often been worn with a light blue cover (similar to horizon blue.) This can be seen in paintings and B/W pictures of the time from the unique blank texture of the cap.

[@amazingnoo9935]

Horizon blue mentioned!

[@platypusbaybee7969]

Such a shame this is all unusable now thanks to the new anti-cheat. The modder did a phenomenal job on all of this

[@ryszakowy]

what anti-cheat should do: insta ban those using auto-aim, wallhack, speedhack and anything that gives advantage over others on serverside what anti-cheat does: fucks the game completely for everyone using client side mods

[@spaman7716]

What it doesnt do: Actually stop cheaters/hackers Great work as always EA

[@montero2004]

​@spaman7716i actually got bullied by cheater yesterday and i have video on my phone

[@whyso4ngry639]

They should've put a Stetson hat on at least one of the early war Canadian infantry classes, especially the cavalry. Most of the cavalry troops and a lot of infantry battalions entered the war in Stetsons and other cowboy hats before steel Brodie helmets were introduced partway through the war.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Hello! This is Jay on my alt account at work, I tried looking this up but couldn't really find any evidence for its usage in Europe. Not to suggest that it's not true at all, but could you link me to any photos or articles showcasing that? Cheers!

[@Armageddonsteellegionioneri]

If I remember correctly, some northwest mounted police and mounties went over to fight, but they mainly fought for the white army in the Russian Civil War that where they served as cavalry and mp's

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@@Armageddonsteellegionioneri Don't think that would fit in with the mod in that case but still cool to note, thanks!

[@imbreadth11r5]

@@Armageddonsteellegionioneri The Western intervention in the Russian Civil War seems to be rarely mentioned when it comes to portrayal of WW1/1910s conflicts in pop culture. The only example I can think of is the British war comic Charley's War, where the titular protagonist is sent to fight there after the end of WW1 by a criminally insane officer.

[@m3gawither7734]

I love the assault class being changed to a Harlem Hellfighter, they live up to their name.

[@Xristoforos41493]

The fact that there is a part 2 and it’s 42 minutes long speaks volume for the game’s historical accuracy

[@IQsveen]

The Highlander heavy gunner is so badass, well done! 👍🔥

[@RetroGaming-gp2ef]

It's great the mod adds the Canadian army.

[@Elevator829]

You should have uploaded this BEFORE the EA anti cheat, since NONE OF THESE MODS ARE USEABLE ANYMORE. Its a real shame that EA decided to screw over all the modders in both BFV and BF1

[@Psitau]

While this is nice (undoubtedly), I do like that DICE was going dor "historical authenticity" rather than complete "historical accuracy". It can still get you immersed into the atmosphere of the Great War while still being a fun, fast-paced game.

[@jayfuzz1086]

Well, kinda. They half arsed it tbh, especially for some factions like the US and Austro-Hungarians. Nowhere near as badly as BFV which is riddled with Axis gear on Allied characters, and vice versa, and modern/Cold War equipment littered throughout, but they still messed up here. The point for the 1916 Enhanced MP mod was basically to try and achieve the "historically authentic but still bombastic" approach that I feel like Dice was initially going for, just executed more fully :p

[@fus132]

Buzzwords, buzzwords, buzzwords.

[@Godman545]

​@@fus132what?

[@taistelusammakko5088]

I hate it, if for nothing else, then the helriegel

[@cdgncgn]

@@taistelusammakko5088 Americans live in a time bubble, for them a year ago is 50. And they think somebody else is going to pay for their mistakes. A Huge mistake.

[@Spitfire__1944]

The mod creator did an amazing job, I can't ever go back to the original now! EA And DICE can learn a thing or two from this about game direction

[@cdgncgn]

but they think too much of themselves and historical accuracy is not something they pay any respect to.

[@Spitfire__1944]

@@cdgncgn What a shame that is. Imagine the potential in a competent dev team for a WW1 game

[@jeroenstefan]

I wish I could play these mods, its a shame we can’t anymore

[@jarvy251]

As much as I love the Canadian representation, the tank markings are a bit over the top. The real Canadian Armored Corps tanks I've seen have british markings, but with the old-style maple leaf (it looks like the collar and cap badges) hand painted by the crew on the front plate. The stylized maple leaf used at 3:50 didn't exist until the adoption of the national flag in the 1960s

[@Maurice599]

Thanks Frosty, love your stuff and it sucks about the anti cheat man

[@rauchgranate5648]

Hello from Germany. Frist of all, I'm happy that the German Army is now some what correctly reprecented in BF 1. The only thing that bothers me are the C96 holsters. First of all the C96 was very commen in the German Army, at special in the Stormtrooper Corp (Assult Class), so removing it is not the best joice. How ever it shoud be the Shoulderstock holster like on the tankers. The leather holster was not used by both british, german and austrian forces. Only the Bolo Mauser C96, that was mostly used by the Red Army in the 1920s. The Austrian Army did only use the C96 in small numbers, so a Steyr Pistol Pouch woud be more apropried.

[@plaquer1337]

So happy to see actual Canadian Representation, they were such a significant part of World War One and those servicemen deserve the credit

[@MrB00mbang]

Huge bf fan for over twenty years… no Canadian DLC while we got ANZACs was such a slap in the face. Vimy could’ve been a whole ass DLC.

[@saharayang9312]

Keep up the content!!! You're gonna have a blast with Black Ops 6

[@worldbiggestfan1]

14:31 the existing of the Webley revolver, used in multiplayer, was plan to be added in through mud and blood, friends in high skys and the runner, however the model of the webley is a ww2 model

[@quadpictures]

Great video and an amazing mod as always 😊

[@Rogue_Tiger]

I kinda like bf1s crazy uniforms. We would never have seen them in any other game. Maybe just maybe some game that has a small traction

[@lumbagoboi1649]

Bf1 is the only game I've ever seen where they combined modern "tacticool" with historical drip and made some pretty epic looking dudes.

[@notatimetraveler6444]

As cool and well thought out as this mod is. I’m starting to see what Gabe was talking about when it came to realism in games.

[@Rebelsquadleader]

We needed this lol

[@DualStupidity]

Very satisfying. If you're going with a historical theme, you might as well be as accurate as possible visually.

[@Geg9449]

I hate EA, I have waited for years and years for someone to publish a mod with an alpini cap for the italian faction and now...

[@jayfuzz1086]

EEAC really ruined everything :( But these mods have also been available for a few years now lol...

[@vinecsarabia6807]

HE EVEN GAVE EACH FACTION THEIR APPROPRIATE SOUNDTRACKS I LOVE THE EFFORT

[@lecharlie4847]

I guess due to technical limitations, the Germans in North Sea maps wasn't change to be the Navy.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Unfortunately yes.

[@justwatch7091]

Yeah, I am guessing German skins are universal in the game since German Empire uses the same models in every map. You either change them for all maps or you don't change at all.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@ exactly, unfortunately.

[@angusyang5917]

@@HarlowLovesGaming What about the White Army on the Russian Civil War maps? I know they use the same uniforms as the Imperial Russian Army, but are they technically the same factions? If not, you could edit them to have more ragtag uniforms to reflect their poor industiral base, or even mod them into Japanese soldiers like with the Canadians or Schutztruppe to simulate the Siberian intervention.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@ unfortunately it’s not possible or else I would’ve loved to do some custom stuff, but as you theorise, the white and Imperial Russian army both use the exact same files and faction data, which is unfortunate.

[@mar_k3445]

Cant wait for 2043 so this man makes a video of battlefield 2042 historical innacuaricies

[@Nogh_the_gamer]

Nice video lad

[@Eru-z9z]

I think this mod is absolutely fantastic and I don’t want to seem nit picky or overly critical of it but I would like to share some details that could be added. 11:59 the band around the slouch hat (known as a puggaree) has 7 folds representing the 6 states and 1 for the Australian territories. Historical at the time the puggaree would have been a singular wool hat band with no folds. 12:16 the black boots could be replaced with the unique brown Australian boots that were worn by the soldiers at the time. 12:29 the slouch hat with peaked crown, colloquially called the lemon squeezer, as far as I’m aware by the time of 1914 and the Gallipoli campaign was only worn by the 11th (Taranaki) Company of the Wellington Battalion. This can be confirmed by the cap badge as shown. I don’t know if there would be many Maori in the 11th Company, mostly white New Zealanders, however there would be plenty of Maori in the Maori Contingent and whose uniform would be similar except changing out the lemon squeezer for either a peaked cap or Wolseley pith helmet. 13:46 I can’t help but appreciate the detail the creator put into the uniform here especially the red piping on the epaulettes, It would also be nice to see the detail of red piping on the outer seam of the trousers which would be accurate to the ‘New Zealand Military Forces Dress Regulations 1912’. Although for 1918 the New Zealand army would of had the lemon squeezer as standard issue headdress for all regiments and corps except the mounted rifles, who wore slouch hats, the locally produced New Zealand uniform was phased out and the New Zealand army opted to wear British uniforms. I believe this change was made in 1916 after Gallipoli. It’s been a while since I’ve played BF1 so I don’t remember if there is cavalry on the Gallipoli maps but if there were I would recommend using the Australian Light Horse or New Zealand Mounted Rifles as both were present on the campaign although they were dismounted. One might even say the same suggestion could be made for the Canadian or Indian cavalry for substitution to the British faction. Once again I’m not trying to be critical to the creator I am merely making suggestions going forward on what is already a splendid mod. Keep up the fantastic work.

[@patrickjohnson5245]

12:30 He totally looks like a young Temuera Morrison!

[@suyz9312]

He is trying to make his through the universe

[@nicolassaid5979]

I haven't played since the 22.... Those mods were so good, I miss them.....

[@SpongeBobMeBoyyyyyy]

New video W, also bo6 video when?

[@flaviapunktexe]

I love it when you say "Pickelhaubä". Love your videos!

[@johnarbuckle6583]

5:41 Years of seeing these emblems in killcams and I never realized they were based off real insignias…

[@Jiro-q4c]

FINALLY CANADA IS RECONISED

[@patrickmonahan5272]

i wish that for the Canadian scout they went with a first nation solider, as the deadliest sniper of ww1 was a first nation Canadian

[@MrB00mbang]

Right from where we cottage too. Parry Island First Nation!

[@parsak938]

Thanks buddy doing gods work

[@ace7669]

It looks cooler when it’s realistic

[@TahaKhan-cz1gt]

Hey, can you do video on every historical inaccuracies in black ops 6 (which takes place during the gulf war?). Also can you do a video on weapons inaccuracies in black ops 6 aswell?.

[@HistoryMonarch1999]

Trying to mod battlefield 1 was a nightmare idk how I managed to get it to start for the single player. But it was fun

[@kiryuchansboyfriend]

I love how some of the real versions look outlandish and impractical and Battle Pass-y compared to the in-game versions (France what were you on 😭)

[@LePoilu]

The French engineer kepi bears the wrong piping. The engineers had a dark blue kepi with red piping, this is a chasseur à pied’s kepi. And if the support class represents an engineer he should wear a dark blue trouser with red bands on the side and black collar tabs with red numbers. Apart from this, the uniforms are pretty well done.

[@jayfuzz1086]

Great! Thank you for letting me know! Would the trousers be paired with puttees at that point, or the same leather lace-up gaiters seen on the other classes?

[@LePoilu]

@ it would be the same leather gaiters. Really nice work btw, really nice !

[@jayfuzz1086]

@@LePoilu Great, and thank you! :D

[@BlueJayWaters]

Thank you SO much for doing the multiplayer

[@entropiart]

as a reenactor the bolshevics for early war would use only ex tzarist equipment because later from 8 april 1919. war they standardized the unfiorms introducing also the m1919 Gimnasterka , even repainted adrian and Sohlberg helmets, even repainted adrian with the zarist crest on it with a red star drawn on it. Plus the papakha should have the stripe or the badge, should not have both the budenovka should be greener, and absolutely not red piping that is the tourist shop version of the hat, the farbest thing ever.

[@Aureus_]

I’m chuffed with all the changes with the mods; especially the Sikh having facial hair

[@ZackCrete]

Do every Historical inaccuracy in black ops 6

[@cdgncgn]

You mean, the things they actually did correct ? Would that be a video minute long at all ?

[@cjvoerman5591]

Seeing this makes me wish EA and Dice would go back and update Battlefield 1 with these more historically accurate uniforms. Hell, if they add more Expansion packs focusing on overlooked fronts of the war, it’d be one of the greatest FPS ever. Have Operations for maps based on the African theatre (like German East Africa or Cameroon) with colonial uniforms, the Battle of Tsingdao with the Japanese faction, the Siberian campaigns of several Entente and Central powers against the Bolsheviks during WWI, or even the Easter Uprising of 1916 (or seeing as BF1 already has maps for the Russian Civil War, why not for the Anglo-Irish War of the early 20s?). What actually surprises me is that there’s no maps in Serbia or Bosnia.

[@tictak2121]

Question: did you remove the sound of bullets hitting armor plate after you removed cavalry armor plate? Also I guess developers decided to stick with certain helmets/uniforms to make it distinct when you see them. For example if I see small metal helmet I know it's an assault etc. But I agree with patches and colors.

[@jayfuzz1086]

Hi there! I actually tried to keep distinctive class appearances throughout the 1916 mod, particularly with gear and headgear profiles, as you'll notice the Medics always have a soft cap, the Assault's still keep grenade bundles, etc. They are still of course unique and distinctive from the vanilla appearance, but after playing with the mods for a while you definitely learn the new appearances and recognise them from a distance. As for the armour hitting sound I didn't even know that was a thing for the Cavalry Class, so probably not, but it might also be tied directly to the armour item being applied to them, so may have been removed along with it in the first place. Not sure.

[@tictak2121]

@@jayfuzz1086 I play cavalry a lot and sometimes there is a sound similar to sentry armor when you shoot at it. I think it's related to the armor plate itself (as you said) but I just wanted to clarify. Great mod and video!

[@jayfuzz1086]

@@tictak2121 Good to note if we ever find a workaround for the new EEAC, and thank you!

[@TheLaughingReaper525]

the canadians and the hellfighter look sick

[@PANCAKEMINEZZ]

5:50 In a big fan of this change. I was alright with the French forces having the black assault because i thought it was a nice nod to the Hellfighters fighting alongside them. But i think this change of making the Hellfighters a part of the Americans but with different uniforms is a cool change too. It signifies the fact they are american forces but also shows off the segregation aspect too. Would it be realistic or authentic for them to fight alongisde their fellow white Americans? No, but the mod represents the idea well enough

[@jayfuzz1086]

That's sort of what I was going for tbh, but also the fact that I wouldn't want them speaking French if they were on the French maps, and I wanted to represent the French's own black soldiers as well haha, but thank you!

[@FreyaFjords]

I love these videos, I do like the vanilla Austro-Hungarian assault though

[@TreacherousFennec]

Is there a way to use frosty mod manager now that the anticheat is also released for battlefield 1?

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Unfortunately not :/

[@TreacherousFennec]

@@HarlowLovesGaming that's a damn shame, I guess

[@thestørmcrier2024]

Oh I love the Canadian inclusion. Never knew brody helmets weren’t used till 1916. That Canadian tanker freaks me out lol

[@PushistayaBulka]

Спасибо, что разобрал форму русских солдат :D Твои ролики очень крутые :3

[@jayfuzz1086]

спасибо за добрые слова, я рада, что они вам понравились

[@ninjaamrou3927]

Hey Frosty 1 Can you make a historical inaccuracy video for Black ops 6? That would be cool👍

[@worldbiggestfan1]

13:04 since this mod take place in gallipoli, as an aussie, the eye shield shouldn't be use as it is an American experimental eye shield, plus all support/heavy class soldiers, were not equipped with mg08, only lewis or hotguiss, since they were supplied by British and france

[@TheFrosty_1]

The Willmer eye Shields on the sentry soldiers are innacurace but was added as one of the few decisions made by the mod creator to try to keep some of the games exaggerated "tacticool" aesthetic. As for the weapons, it was mostly random what I gave to the characters in the overview because I didn't have them all unlocked and most of the weapons in game are innacurate anyway

[@worldbiggestfan1]

the Australian armor was not used during the battle of Gallipoli, as fewer on, uniforms like blue shirts and slech hat was shown footage on Gallipoli, as battlefield 1 was released, aussie people were abused to the multiplayer map that have so many inaccurate uniforms, in reality although they were kaki clothes, it was shown there were few blue shirts they wear and no armored anzac were deployed in Gallipoli and there were no tanks in Gallipoli, but regardless of the mod although accurate, we do forgive that April is anzac day

[@danielwilson3472]

Love all the games and content you put out.

[@johntheknight3062]

I never understand why they always invest to much into these games only to make them inaccurate for no reason.

[@cdgncgn]

research and expertise required means investing, meaning, they have to lower production costs. But this is how Americans think. Then quickly forget everything, to be tuned into the next thing rinse and repeat. lol :)

[@johntheknight3062]

@@cdgncgn Nonsense. The only thing they would need is team of maybe 3 or 4 experts that know the real history. Look at this modding community. They do it for free. Do you really think it would be that pricy to get them to work on these games? But yes, you are right, Americans are a sick nation full of greedy morrons with fanatical beliefs.

[@ProLapsRacing]

This is amazing. While I really loved the atmosphere of BF1, I never enjoyed it as much as a lot of other people because I’m too big of a WW1 nerd.

[@toa_cracau4286]

I feel like the German support should get the lobster armour, or at least a stahlhelm brow plate, since both of these were used by machine gunners

[@toa_cracau4286]

Oh and also same could go for the Austrian support, there's a few photos showing Austrians on the alpine front using their brow plates as face shields, tho I guess that might've worked better for the sentry, but either way it'd be a nice detail and reference to historical photos

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

hey there, this is Jay! Fair suggestion but I didn't want Standard soldiers looking too overdone, but the support is also supposed to be a mobile machine gunner, not a static machine gunner so overly heavy equipment would be out of place in that regard as well. Cheers!

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

@@toa_cracau4286 I think I know the photo you're talking about, which is actually a German soldier, not AHU, but still a cool photo nonetheless!

[@toa_cracau4286]

@@HarlowLovesGaming holy I wasn't expecting the actual modder to respond! That's understandable, I mainly suggested it cause it feels like it'd add some nice variations to the looks but it makes total sense! Also let me say I appreciate your work even tho I can't play it (even if the anti cheat hadn't dropped) since im on console You did a great job and I was surprised at how high quality everything looked!

[@toa_cracau4286]

@@HarlowLovesGaming oh I absolutely misremembered, I saw it in a video about the game Isonzo, and that must have confused my memory, thanks for the correction!

[@CanofAnxiety]

I’d love to see a video on how they actually make the new skins and such, it’s a really impressive modding community for a older game.

[@shileetan6040]

Great, now try doing COD Vanguard...

[@L.P.1987]

I hope BF1 gets an update fixing historical uniform inaccuracies for the sake of more beauty and immersion

[@loslingos1232]

Removing the Americans and replacing them with Canadians in the first mod was a surprise and a great choice. Didn't even know BF1 was THIS inaccurate lol

[@FairyNya]

as the video progresses, the more sick he gets lol. at the end he got the full nasal blocked voice

[@tardarsauce1842]

I don't think it's not historically purely accurate, if all the soldiers have mustaches/facial hair in BF1 Because of presence of boy soldiers who were prevalent in both sides that have ages of 16-17, some even go down to 14

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

True but there should still be at least some that do have facial hair. If you look at the 1916 and 14 mods though, you can see younger soldiers still, without much/any facial hair, such as the German Assault.

[@K-Nyne]

About 6% of soldiers in the British army in WW1 were under 18. That's not that many in comparison

[@spaicia1]

Bro fixed everything before people could say “You keep critiquing these games why not you fix it yourself, oh you can’t”

[@MrB00mbang]

Lmao those types are the worst!

[@TheGreatBig]

When the race-swap makes complete and total sense:

[@OnkelMedic]

A great change you didn’t even mention were the WW2 Y-straps on the German forces being replaced by the Tornisterriemen (backpack-strap wich was experimentally used by lots of soldiers to take weight of the belt since only cavalry had Y-straps. Later in the war the Storming Bataillons were also allowed to have Y-straps.

[@jayfuzz1086]

It is actually mentioned at 29:12 that they were updated with the breadbag straps :)

[@thegreatrobin2329]

Hope EA doesn’t attempt to ban these mods, the work that was put into this is impressive and cannot be overstated.

[@oetam8559]

Why is the red army updated in 1914 and 1916 mod if the russian civil war started in 1917?

[@sergeu78]

(1918-1923)

[@TheFrosty_1]

It is just the name of the mods in that regard, it would be more like 1918 and 1922 or so

[@oetam8559]

@@TheFrosty_1 thanks

[@jayfuzz1086]

I actually did want to change the Bolsheviks for the 1914 mod to something else at one pointed but it just felt wrong to do so, same with how 1918 leaves the Gallipoli maps with their early war setup. They're too niche to justify a complete faction swap out. As for 1916, 1916 is just a good tagname as it's the middle of the war and one of the most brutal years for fighting :)

[@superjesse645]

I was grabbing the 1916 mods while this video was going. And then you said the anticheat update killed modding. Nuts.

[@civilprotection3114]

I was pissed that BF1 never included Canada. We were in that war before America, fighting in Vimy Ridge, Somme and Passendale.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

Hi there! This is Jay, author for 1916 and 1914. Glad you like them, thank you!

[@MalcolmIIofCaledonia]

They left us Scots out too! Not even the Black Watch got represented!

[@olekcholewa8171]

There were no Canadians or any other armies than French and German at Verdun.

[@Godman545]

​@@olekcholewa8171thank you I was about to say lol

[@NewYoyo2A]

And they had first added the french as an DLC, we can't expect anything from them

[@MrFirefox]

Great work. 8 years wow

[@IsaiahRowland-jg7sg]

im american, but SCOOOOOOOOOTLAAAAAAAAND

[@Justin-yt7pi]

So basically the mod makes the soldier's uniform more drippy.

[@dantheman627]

Replacing the Americans with Canadians made my day

[@Armageddonsteellegionioneri]

Thank you for adding canada

[@MichalKaczorowski]

Uniform mods won't help when everyone is running around with experimental automatic rifles. It's more like Battlefield Dieselpunk.

[@HarlowLovesGaming]

You'd be surprised.

[@TheFrosty_1]

As Tesco would say "Every Little Helps"

[@wyattdelamare6139]

Due to I believe the Russian army’s cavalry in game meant to represent Cossack troops it would have been nice to see them be revamped to look more like their real world counter parts

[@TheFrosty_1]

The Russian Empires Support soldier in the game is actually already supposed to be a Cossack troop I believe, as he wears a Cossack Cherkeska coat, Cossack dagger and Cossack Papakha hat. The base Imperial Russian uniforms were actually surprisingly well done by DICE, especially in comparison to how bad the other factions uniforms are.