We rank every ice cream flavor (it's going to make you mad)

[@Wardaddy701]

I like to imagine they're in an ice cream store with a line out the door just yelling and arguing about what flavor to get

[@548Shen]

That's my new favorite thought image.

[@bronsongilbert9820]

I see great minds think alike :3

[@Chazbc]

Someone make a 42-minute Game Grumps animated of this.

[@PracticallyBlind]

This better get an animated version

[@shubs9532]

game grumps animated? 👀

[@GolfDudeGaming]

I love every time Arin gets too excited, Dan has to talk him down like he's robbing him "Just take it easy!"

[@irishurbadlmao]

We could probably get a take it easy compilation by now and I'm all for it

[@MoonShadowWolfe]

I think I could find one (or more) that could have a comic of Arin waving weapons at Dan, or straining at a leash like a big dog at Dan, and Dan throws him money or meat to quiet him and the tone is fine.

[@lexierosevideos]

“Woah just take it easy man”

[@Puvwilmo00]

@@lexierosevideos “ITS THE THEATER THUG”

[@Dandylion567]

​@MoonShadowWolfe I could even imagine Arin with one of those little kid backpacks with the leash and ADHD at full force, and Dan is the one trying to restrain him.

[@VoidySan]

28:10 Dan says "I don't really like coconut" and Arin takes a combat stance.

[@The_Ninja_Tree]

Waaaàaaaaaaã

[@EmperorSeth]

I'm with Dan. I got sick on coconut when I was six and spent most of my life convinced I was allergic to coconut. I'm probably not, but I still hate it.

[@commie_dog_boy]

i hate the texture its like biting an mx brown. the flavour is okay but the thought of the texture ruins the flavour for me.

[@LeCowzen]

I read this before I got to that moment so it was exactly what I pictured 😂

[@houdini9739]

i never liked coconut ice cream until i tried tender coconut ice cream in India and WOW. the flavor is so different, and the tiny chunks of coconut are so mildly sweet. idk if its available in the US but i could fuck up an entire pint of that ice cream.@@EmperorSeth

[@luckypenni1233]

Arin ending the episode with “oh i’m SUPER lactose intolerant” had me dead

[@Charok1]

That's why Dan has to say to him "For the love of GOD, please stop farting!" haha

[@Happy_Nacho_Mystery]

Ur profile pic radiates “nuts or nothin’” from chainsaw man.

[@erbrownlee]

8:43 new favorite arin moment dan: i just had eggnog for the first time arin: FIRST TIME?! dan: OK take it easy ARIN: whatwasithowdidyou do ?

[@AlistairAi]

He’s SO excited

[@cheezyatease5223]

As a Midwesterner, listening to them try and describe Blue Moon was hilarious. It just tastes like blue. I don’t know what else to tell ya. It’s blue.

[@DeesVlogs]

Exactly, but it's delicious and they need to try it lol

[@karlierutkowski7195]

Best I can describe it is a mix between almond extract and citrus. The almond taste is very strong in every one I've had. Although blue moon flavor is very scarce here in my state tho

[@hannahyeet8270]

And it is soooo good. They are truly missing out, I didn’t realize it was only a midwest thing.

[@DemonicNightmare]

I'd like to see them try Superman, too. (though based on their other fruit-flavored rankings, they.... probably will not like it that much ^^; )

[@logans1265]

@@karlierutkowski7195 that’s what almond tastes like????? i’m allergic to almond so that’s interesting to know. i feel like i’ve obtained forbidden knowledge

[@mrmajesticburro]

Arin: “NO STORE BOUGHT ICE CREAM!1!1” Also Arin: names exclusively store bought brands lmfao

[@burnin8able]

also "STORE BRANDS HAVE A BUNCHA CHEMICALS N SHIT" Arin, literally all things are made of chemicals. everything. LITERALLY EVERYTHING.

[@marxman6896]

Names exclusively the *bad* store-bought brands lol. Breyers and Blue Bunny are awful. Gimme Kroger brand over those any day of the week.

[@Cheshieruu]

@@burnin8able im not i dont exist

[@thebeavpercabethftw9604]

I love when Arin acts like he knows something.

[@Kelarys]

Breyers doesn't even make ice cream anymore. They make "frozen dessert" and it's disgusting

[@D3ADM0N5T3RC4T]

Arins reaction to Danny having Eggnog for the first time is like Danny losing his virginity

[@Vffhndsercchi]

Just wait until they actually try Superman! But it's made by Kemp's and usually here in the Midwest

[@FacelessDeviant]

Well, I'm sure we'll get Arins reaction to the virginity thing eventually also. I mean they were close with the stripper story.

[@Mr.Meowgical]

@@Vffhndsercchi Baskin-Robbins definitely has the Superman flavor, at least over here in Florida. Haven't had it since I was a wee lad, though.

[@ShesAaRebel]

@@Vffhndsercchi I remember it being called "Superkid", cause they didn't have the licencing to the name from DC. Unless at some point that changed. Or it depends on the location.

[@Ronald_Ruck]

That's a reference to what (episode) exactly?

[@687grayfox]

Dan: *Sweet, poignant story* "So get out there and have yourself an ice cream, unless you're lactose intolerant" Arin: "I'm lactose intolerant, just endure the fart"

[@followerofchrist520]

Yk the stomach aches may be bad but their worth (also why do the pills cost so much 😢)

[@YoutubePizzer]

arin has terrible stomach problems anyways so like

[@uskidsknow19]

aw man lol, Arin's excitement for Dan enjoying eggnog for the first time was such a sweet moment :,)

[@rainbowterra]

Gosh, Arin is so passionate, nuanced, and well-spoken when it comes to food. Any time he talks about it I can feel his adrenaline and rising heart rate through the screen.

[@Baby-Blue-102]

: )

[@analogicparadox]

SUSHI FILLS ME UP LIKE A MOFO

[@hvymtllion5231]

and it's almost exclusively about food! he doesn't really get too rialed up about things like he does food. a national treasure, he is

[@spacesquid95force25]

There should be a comp for all his food rants. All the way back to his subway rant.

[@lc360]

M O R E O N I O N P L E A S E

[@3ExtraLives]

Based on Arin's energy I'm guessing this was recorded right after the Kit Kat 10MPH

[@JChimmy]

He sounds like he may be a bit "hydrated" in this episode

[@TheSpektrum1989]

there's definitely something adding to his energy here

[@TbdPonchoBillionaire]

There’s no way that Kit Kat episode didn’t take them out for like a full day.

[@TheAmorable]

Arin’s incredible horniness for raisins was so sudden-

[@Midnight-Starfish]

Pretty sure Arin has fully displayed that his horniness knows no bounds

[@Suko120]

I'm with him there. Tho, I never even heard of rum raisins ice cream. But I LOVE chocolate with rum and raisins in it. It's so good.

[@kiro9291]

a bicon

[@YoutubePizzer]

@@Midnight-Starfish “any port in a storm” hanson is what they call him

[@nwag17]

36:31 Arin: “I’m not a big fan of Birthday Cake Ice Cream”. Ally: 🙂 *So you have chosen DEATH*

[@tagwaggin]

After getting into matcha ice cream through Japanese restaurants that offer it as a nice after-dinner treat, I gotta agree it's weird that it's not on this list, really good stuff.

[@TbdPonchoBillionaire]

Matcha is actually top-tier. Not overly sweet or in your face, just a relaxing green tea flavor that coats your taste buds and doesn’t overstay. EASY A+ or S tier.

[@tjeulink]

Ever had black sesame icecream? Tastes great too!

[@ephemeraIl]

Definitely an S tier ice cream

[@juanferrer5924]

@@ephemeraIlwhat in the world is going on with your profile image it’s horrifying

[@ephemeraIl]

@@juanferrer5924 were you high writing this its an actor of ocean from ride the cyclone, its a musical

[@chrismanuel9768]

Dan: Life is short. Enjoy the little things. You never know when will be the last. Arin: Ice cream makes me fart.

[@pervyturtle2673]

To be fair Arin does enjoy farting

[@mushymush6902]

28:06 Dan: Coconut would be my first D Arin: *Karate noises*

[@nateeverett1646]

Underrated comment 😂

[@Serpentsons]

"WUUUUUAHHHH"

[@qdawgjr98]

Could we get a compilation of Dan telling Arin to “take it easy” PLEASE?

[@eyes_espresso4803]

I second this!!!

[@casualfoodenjoyer7951]

I third this!

[@ThomasQuist]

Everytime is already a complication

[@Gender_Ascender]

@@ThomasQuist what are you talking about

[@C0D3R_MX]

@@Gender_Ascender I believe the OP meant "compilation" and not "complication"

[@SSmotzer]

Now there's gotta be a Power Hour for ice cream taste tests of these flavors, to see if their tier list holds up.

[@FarawayBrawlHacks]

28:10 Dan disliking coconut really turned Arin into Liu Kang

[@EpicAwesomesauce]

Grumps: *gets to Cookies and Cream* Me: *slowly draws knife* Grumps: *Puts not only Cookies and Cream in S tier, but Chocolate Chip and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough as well* Me: *re-sheaths knife immediately*

[@briangruenewald7536]

I like vanilla ice cream. I like Oreos. But I don’t like them together; it’s just too much… unsheathe your knife. I’m ready…

[@konnichi1wa]

Cookie Dough is gross, the other two are good

[@LordPichuPal]

All 3 are S-tier flavours, I am glad they agreed. Though there's plenty on there I can't stand, but that's more because I'm super finicky on foods.

[@PuppyPawsGamingYT]

like.. the most disgusting flavors get S tier always.

[@theflare9557]

DRAW YOUR WEAPON FORTH FOR THOU HATH DISPLAYED OPINION

[@jillianGillespie819]

I can't describe how much I want them to make a tier list ranking all their tier list videos, as a grand finale one day

[@halffruit9245]

Get yourself a girl that takes you as seriously as Arin takes food and you’ll be set for life.

[@erikkornfeld785]

Arin debates about Ice Cream the way some people debate shipping characters.

[@kaseypoden4226]

Might I say watching the both Dan and Arin try ice cream for a power hour would be super entertaining

[@connortremblay1259]

Especially to watch Arin drink the melted ice cream soup at the end

[@dragontamerpennie3273]

@@connortremblay1259 Yeeees. This has to be the finale. Lol

[@blake6015]

Maybe we should have two charts side by side, so we can see how distinct their tastebuds are 🤔

[@derekhasabrain]

Yeah but that would eliminate the arguing and bargaining that everyone loves so much 🙄 /s I actually agree with you. That would be nice

[@pokey3344]

dan eats nothing so

[@ItBePatYo]

@@pokey3344 He barely eats air... D:

[@MitoseNorikoFan]

@@ItBePatYo But he has to separate the oxygen and nitrogen so that he can experience each component.

[@ShotgunLlama]

"I'm not talking about store bought ice cream! I'm talking about Breyers..." has the same energy as "it's not a chicken, it's a rooster"

[@BinToss._.]

I'm thinking he meant store-brand ice cream e.g. Kroger's Deluxe.

[@bradoliver9324]

Breyers is garbo. I think he also missed the point that it's made with cream, not milk. Bunch of those low tier store brands aren't made with cream, that's the reason they ain't top tier shit.

[@bradoliver9324]

@@miguelnewmexico8641 In response to a video about a food product that is named after the fundamental parts of the process of making it? Yes.

[@housequay]

Arins first natural "oh no" sounded more like Knuckles than his second attempt to do it when he realised he could.

[@daleblanquita]

I always hesitate to watch these tier list videos because there’s always one point where one of their rankings makes me go “… I don’t know if I can watch game grumps anymore 😔”

[@Tuff_Genius]

It was the cheesecake for me ☹️

[@briansydnor4331]

@@Tuff_Genius RIGHT?? 😱💀

[@dammitqirong]

me when arin said coffee ice cream was d tier

[@tjeulink]

Coffee and peanut butter did it for me, shit slaps

[@smilesfordays]

Not having spamoni on the list at all for me: 😞

[@angelasfixations]

Sometimes I worry if they’ve gotten too mature to still want to do this much longer, then Arin opens an episode like this.

[@smilesfordays]

He won’t stop until it stops making money lol.

[@princesstoni8116]

@@smilesfordays LMAO I don't blame him, it's a pretty fire job

[@angelasfixations]

@@princesstoni8116 Right? Like God forbid he make money at his job! People are so bitter.

[@chrisstevens2037]

I feel like there needs to be a second edition of this. These all seemed like fun times, I need the "I'm depressed and eating an entire box" edition

[@WulfyFang3]

I'll second that motion lmao

[@TheLazyShell]

"PEOPLE NEED TO SHUT THE FUCK UP!" - Arin Hanson discussing Coconut Ice Cream (2023)

[@AsianEyes007]

*Anytime Arin gets loud, excited, or defensive** Dan: _Chotto Matte_

[@martingarricks6209]

gonzo calma- calma…..

[@CocktailsConsoles]

Bubblegum ice cream is absolutely the personification of the Matrix -- it has the color that draws you in but it can't calculate what bubblegum is supposed to taste like

[@piperformerlycassette]

"bubblegum" has always meant "sweet cream with bubblegum mixed in"

[@blackhood9441]

Hearing Ally laughing in the background of videos always brings me joy

[@narsheguard6417]

Why? It's intrusive and annoying.

[@windybuttsniff]

@@narsheguard6417 it's fun, and she's got such a cute laugh !!

[@Nowolf]

@@narsheguard6417 "I know you are but what am I?"

[@Kiwikun883]

I love ally so much

[@TheHomerowKeys]

@@narsheguard6417 You're the same type of person that would bully Suzy whenever she would show up. Ugh just leave.

[@cherishheathart]

Blue Moon has an almond extract kind of flavor. Or like...whispers of fruitloops or fruity pebbles kind of. It's light and awesome. Really difficult to describe which made that part even more hilarious.

[@KairuHakubi]

i think it's mainly almond and your mind creates the rest because it's blue. I dunno why their result told them it's raspberry.

[@casual_gamer58]

Nice to find another person who likes blue moon

[@alexhead2645]

My nurse friend told me a story about a lady who gained a 0.05 BAC lvl (or thereabouts) from solely drinking vanilla extract

[@oisinmurphy8242]

Arins love for vanilla has reaffirmed his status as slim boy thick and boy does he have me quaking

[@leiathrix]

I wish they did two separate lists cuz even though they try to compromise it's sometimes simply impossible lol

[@XerxesTexasToast]

"You don't put the vanilla in the mango ice cream!" I dunno buddy every cookie recipe I've ever made called for a tablespoon-ish of vanilla, I wouldn't be surprised if ice cream was the same way

[@bdhkstudios7600]

These pre recorded in advance videos make me think that Dan and arin have actually retired long ago and are living on their own private island right now

[@dbagette]

ChatGPT Presents 10MPH

[@TbdPonchoBillionaire]

I could listen to Arin’s food passion for hours on end. They should do more food related content.

[@zacharykim295]

I go back and watch their miracle berry power hour all the time! Arin should start another channel for cooking, would definitely watch that

[@entr3_nou5]

Aaaand weeeee’re the food grumps!

[@CrazeeAdam]

LOL it sounded like he was threatening Dan based on his Ice Cream choices XD he was so into it, especially the speech about Vanilla ice cream not being the base and then the Butter Pecan almost straight afterwards

[@TbdPonchoBillionaire]

@@CrazeeAdam “VANILLA ISNT A BASE, MILK WOULD BE THE BASE FLAVOR” my boy milk flavor is not on the list… 🤣

[@SarahDaisy98]

Take a shot every time arin passionately says “ACROSS THE BOARD”

[@Noctali_Volkova]

Already on it! 🤣

[@xiphiasoffishwell4781]

It's all I hear now. Thanks.

[@Little_Nutmeg_Hen56]

As a baker, vanilla goes in everything. Its like salt. Its a flavor enhancer.

[@iaminpain9458]

I almost stood up and cheered when they both said they love mint chip. Almost everyone I know says it’s gross but it’s my favorite.

[@robosexxxual]

Anyone who says mint chip is gross has bad taste. Mint chip is the bomb

[@Jeff.S.]

@@robosexxxual Based take.

[@smilesfordays]

It really depends on the type and quality of mint for me. I also prefer dark chocolate too… if it is cheap it’s possibly some of the worst ice cream, but if a good quality and balanced flavors, it’s some of the best on a summers day… it makes sense to me it’s so divisive.

[@KeeperOfUntoldDreams]

It's literally one of my top three favorite Ice Cream flavors.

[@mizumafusotrue]

Mint chip ice cream tastes so fucking good.

[@tacticalgunner3615]

the energy in this was making me cry laughing with all the unhinged passion with arin LEANING AWAY from the mic screaming about ice cream

[@F_rogg_y]

Blue moon was my absolute favorite ice cream as a kid, and I still love it now. Can’t describe the flavor, it’s just blue.

[@xjiden]

it tastes like fruity pebbles to me. idk if anyone else can relate

[@flapjackpancake5486]

@@xjiden I am just imagining it tasting like the milk of soggy fruity pebbles

[@ATiredTripleA]

Blue is a delicious flavor. The industry out here making us taste colors and wanting more.

[@Mithriya]

@@xjiden YES YES exactly fruity pebbles

[@jaybird7997]

What I’ve noticed in these recent food related tier list episodes is that these boys don’t like super sweet things anymore lol

[@zeebo30]

yeah from what i've seen from many older adults when you get into your late 30's to your 40's your tolerance for sweets starts to go down. idk if there's anything to back it up, just something i've observed on my own

[@alissaconant7995]

I think it all depends from person to person. I'm 33 and these past few years my tolerance for sweet things has gone down. Its fine for a few bites but after awhile I can't do it. My husband on the other hand is 36 and is a sweet fiend.

[@averyjohnston9997]

@@zeebo30 probably more concerned about blood sugar levels (and other body health things)

[@zeebo30]

@@averyjohnston9997 that has nothing to do with not liking something that tastes sweet. Even diabetics like sweet things. They're litterally doing an ice cream tier list right after having just done a 10mph where they ate like 50 kitkats. Blood sugar is not in the equation

[@Scrofar]

Can't blame them, Arin cooks and is pretty observant of his own diet while he was training for fights, and Dan's as brittle as a stick since the age of the dinosaurs

[@kristopherdawne]

As someone with a vanilla allergy, it's in almost fuckin every single ice cream and they legally don't have to tell me. It's not even named in the ingredients list on "VANILLA ICE CREAM". Shout out to Benjamin Gerald ice cream for being the only internationally accessible ice cream company that reliably lists it.

[@dragonman011]

This hits different now knowing Arin was tipsy the whole time lmao

[@Alabaster1223]

Was he really??? That's awesome

[@guilhermecastro9893]

@@Alabaster1223 i didnt even know he drinks alcohol

[@nathanvertil7355]

@@guilhermecastro9893 He's a whiskey guy. Specifically Japanese Whiskey.

[@guilhermecastro9893]

@@nathanvertil7355 thats amazing, i didnt even notice arin was wasted

[@charleshultgren7804]

@@guilhermecastro9893 drunk arin and arin are one in the same

[@darak229]

Can't wait for "This is too sugary, gross! Oh a grandpa flavor, S tier!"

[@Ronald_Ruck]

I just love how Danny pronounced "Schlumpf" with a note of total disbelief.

[@djgoku7774]

For those who are new to the Grumps on food. Dan: Eh.... It's ok. Arin: I have to explain this shit in great detail!

[@GetToThePointAlready]

When are you guys making a "Dan says Take it easy!" Compilation?! Every time Dan says that it has me in tears lmao

[@ironicugandan5826]

I hope they do a "Weird ice cream flavors" power hour.

[@RedCloude]

Active charcoal ice cream.

[@ironicugandan5826]

@@RedCloude there is like macaroni and cheese flavor and hidden valley just released a ranch flavored ice cream

[@RedCloude]

@@ironicugandan5826 ranch flavored ice cream. 🤢

[@MusicalMethuselah]

Blue bunny and breyers have the most "frozen dairy desserts" (aka not ice cream) out of all the brands he could have named 😂

[@briangruenewald7536]

@@miguelnewmexico8641 (via Wikipedia): Ice cream is a sweetened frozen food typically eaten as a snack or dessert. It may be made from milk or cream and is flavoured with a sweetener, either sugar or an alternative, and a spice, such as cocoa or vanilla, or with fruit such as strawberries or peaches. It can also be made by whisking a flavored cream base and liquid nitrogen together. Food coloring is sometimes added, in addition to stabilizers. The mixture is cooled below the freezing point of water and stirred to incorporate air spaces and to prevent detectable ice crystals from forming. The result is a smooth, semi-solid foam that is solid at very low temperatures (below 2 °C or 35 °F). It becomes more malleable as its temperature increases.

[@georgeharrisonfricklas7927]

@@miguelnewmexico8641 so "frozen dessert" means that they don't have enough milk fat content to be called "ice cream" on the label according to the FDA. the milk fat can be replaced with vegetable oil, coconut oil, olive oil, or even margarine fat sometimes! it's basically still ice cream, and it won't hurt you, but the FDA has strict naming conventions about what can and cannot have a certain word on the label based on its ingredients

[@Ortisan_Official]

Was about to say this, glad I scrolled down cause somebody had to

[@ronjones-6977]

@@georgeharrisonfricklas7927 It's the cousin of "cheese food."

[@Sybato]

@@briangruenewald7536 That definition makes me wonder if oregano ice cream is a thing

[@dirkguliker1847]

I can't believe they did cheesecake dirty like that!

[@redfury3153]

Right exactly what I was thinking. Cheesecake ice cream is in my top three.

[@redfury3153]

Right exactly what I was thinking. Cheesecake ice cream is in my top three.

[@tastymedleys]

I think the problem with cheesecake ice cream is first of all that some people don't like cheesecake that much in general, and secondarily, that some people who like cheesecake want it in its original form. I fall in the latter category, a good cheesecake is delicious, but fake vaguely cheesecakey ice cream is meh.

[@WulfyFang3]

Everything cheesecake is in my top 3. I am an absolute sl*t for cheesecake and I'm not ashamed.

[@atomic2968]

Green tea ice cream is my favorite as well! Shout out to Dan for being the only other person I’ve come across who calls it their favorite 🍨

[@chuckporter9526]

We're out there. Story time! I work at a Japanese restaurant. Up until a few months ago, the green tea ice cream we had was homemade -- it wasn't that lovely green color, and it tasted like Captain Crunch, strangely enough. I HATED it; the rest of the staff loved it. We got what you and I know as green tea ice cream, and when I told them this was what it was always supposed to taste like, they got SUPER excited... until they actually ate it. I'm not big on the suffering of others, but... that moment was delectable. So here's one: one scoop green one scoop red bean, or nah?

[@SS-fq3xt]

I only like it when it is wrapped in mochi

[@chuckporter9526]

@@SS-fq3xt Don't tempt me.

[@Dorian_Scott]

(34:10) Arin getting so passionate about butter pecan ice cream is fucking hilarious.

[@dramasbomin]

An ice cream joint in my town actually does sell the "milk flavored" ice cream base. They call it sweet cream. It's delicious and I like it more than vanilla

[@sleepyote]

Arin: "It's Game Grumps, not Hamster Grumps" Also Arin: *tier lists every week*

[@captionhere19]

ITS WHAT THE PEOPLE WANT

[@bobtheboneboy6531]

@@captionhere19 nuh uh

[@beanbagman2194]

@@captionhere19 yes I agree

[@jessicalandrey8421]

And we love it

[@tigerwolfftw]

They do one every two weeks, surely you will survive.

[@squidwardshouse5431]

Arin's justification of vanilla flavour gave me a big celery eating smile on my face. Vanilla is OG.

[@CrazeeAdam]

LOL Dan being scared of Arin when talking about Vanilla ice cream was so funny. Arin had to be going at it in the booth

[@SanitysTheif]

@37:50 as Dan said this I had a bowl of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream in the microwave set to 5 seconds lmao I thought I was the only weirdo

[@redruby2318]

Coffee is like one of my FAVORITE ice creams and Arin wanted it in D 😭

[@General12th]

Coffee is SSS tier for me and I still want Arin's D.

[@martingarricks6209]

see, you said ONE OF

[@IlIlIlIlIlIlIllIlIII]

28:08 Arin is so offended by Dan's coconut opinion he resorted to kung-fu.

[@linksora7120]

He turned into lui kang from mortal kombat 😂😂😂

[@frequentsongs3394]

Superman ice cream is an awesome creation that mixes already good flavors to make an even better flavor. The mix of them all together is just amazing, albeit unexplainable

[@Centraxio]

Agreed! Where I’m from, though, it’s blueberry, strawberry, and banana flavour which is why I like it so much (I especially love banana flavoured stuff)

[@reddiamond6524]

It made ma poo green. But i didnt care, still loved it.

[@blueberryjacket]

​@@reddiamond6524 gdi, really? there's gotta be a kryptonite joke in there somewhere 😂😂😂

[@dadeamatic3772]

24:49 What’s funny about this is that if they tried Blue Moon, they’d be saying the same thing to their brain. First time I tried it, I was like “It’s good! But what’s that flavor?” Then I tried it again a year later and had the same reaction. Low and behold, a ton of people had the same reaction and everyone describes the flavor slightly differently. But it’s just so good😍

[@Arke_PG]

I've never thought of knuckles in that way but I can imagine him being a devoted caring partner

[@fuojeda137]

@@miguelnewmexico8641 picking tails over knuckles is crazy

[@doom_coolfist4224]

In Germany that neopolitan ice cream is called "fürst-pückler-eis" and you can buy 2.5 liters for a bit more than 2 euros in "Rewe" which is standard supermarket in Germany. I have no idea why it's apparently so expensive in the US.

[@len5329]

I just yelled the loudest WHAT alongside Arin when Dan said he's not into Butter Pecan

[@daydreamer9076]

Is it good? I never had it ao I wouldn't know

[@tomb6576]

@@daydreamer9076 real good! It's basically butterscotch! Not a fan of nuts in ice cream here but I'll always make an exception for butter pecan :P

[@andrewjenkins9965]

@@tomb6576 I don't know if I'd call it "basically butterscotch." And yet, as I'm trying to describe how they're different, I keep giving descriptions that match both flavors. I swear they taste different to me though! 😅

[@tomb6576]

@@andrewjenkins9965 that's more than fair! Frankly I've only had it a couple times in my life and only Kroger brand stuff so don't exactly have too much experience haha ^^ I'd be curious to try more of it again!

[@TheFinalFarewell]

The vanilla one is interesting cuz I feel like it REALLY depends. A good vanilla ice cream is fantastic, but lots of them are the weakest of the bunch. I feel like it really varies by brand

[@artemiwilson3702]

True

[@ronjones-6977]

Homemade vanilla ice cream is the best. Otherwise, it's an add-on to other yummy desserts or something to put toppings on.

[@zeebo30]

i don't care what brand it is or even if it's homemade, vanilla is litterally the most bland flavor of ice cream there is. i will take litterally anything else over vanilla (the exception is if i'm going for like a sundae, sundaes are best with vanilla ice cream)

[@TheFinalFarewell]

@@ronjones-6977 On that I can agree. Homemade always hits the spot. It's a wonder that with all the companies whose sole purpose is to make and sell ice cream, not one has come close to making a vanilla as good as what you can make at home in a plastic bag

[@Scrofar]

I'm so picky about vanilla flavors lol. the typical ice cream consumer and store brands are far from great, but once you find a really good vanilla flavor in like a local area or homemade, you cling onto that for life!

[@LycanLink]

Game Grumps became a ranking channel so gradually, I didn't even notice.

[@The_Real_Goodboy_Link]

i'ma send you some RAM

[@burnin8able]

every time they make a tier list video I always think back to some of the early tier list videos where Dan would just keep saying "I swear we're not becoming a tier list channel, but we're doing another one."

[@789syrus789]

@@surblechev278 no it’s still hot. Game Grumps isn’t always late to the game. Edit: They’re mostly late to the game…like years.

[@hrodga]

How good of a ranking channel? Where would you rate them.. on a list from S to D, per se...

[@JaySay]

@@hrodga They're in their own tier, maybe call it G. The debate will be if it should be placed above S, or below D.

[@khernon4590]

I love knowing that at some point in the future I get to enjoy the delicious masterpiece that Sbassbear molds out of the pristine quality clay that is 1:02

[@Arke_PG]

Since the adventures you guys have had running your own restaurant, this sort of thing always makes me imagine you guys, as the old couple that you truly are, running a business together, openly arguing in front of the customers, but also delivering the sweetest service 😂

[@xenapryor8480]

Aren't they kind of already running a business together and openly arguing in front of the customers?

[@0zzkat]

Okay but... grape ice cream is my new aesthetic, what the fuck I can't stop looking at it lmfao. BUT ALSO! Dan's little story at the end literally made me tear up, wow. It really is simple shit. I hope everyone gets to experience at least one more of those moments of bliss chowing on some ice cream.

[@taylor_jane23]

Superman icecream is so underrated, it’s not just fun colored vanilla

[@mastergamermike166]

Agreed, but never get super moo,it is not the same ,it's like the bad hiar day of superman!

[@RickWithaW]

@@mastergamermike166 100% agreed!

[@mastergamermike166]

@@RickWithaW have you had the nightmare that is super moo?!

[@awsomewolfman124]

@@mastergamermike166 I made the mistake of buying it and the terrible yellow snot they have instead of vanilla/lemon ice cream is a crime.

[@DragonReaver]

​@@awsomewolfman124 My favorite is Hershey Creamery Company yellow is banana vanilla mix, the blue is blueberry, and the red is strawberry.

[@NinjaPopeXue]

28:11 Probably just me, but my first thought upon hearing Arin's reaction to Dan's rating for coconut was the Gorman Brothers from the N64 Zelda games.

[@heartpalette]

That reaction to butter pecan is the ONLY one I would accept.

[@KappoJK]

“It’d be eggnog, with piss in it!” Had me hyperventilating. After I stopped laughing and choking, then I had to explain to my wife, “What’s so funny?” That made me start giggling again. Thanks, I needed that!

[@Poillip]

I was ready to throw hands, but Arin immediately put vanilla in S tier and that's all I needed

[@julieneff9408]

Bananas Foster ice cream in particular.

[@victoriagann6570]

same. i feel seen

[@spacesquid95force25]

I was honestly not expecting Arin to like Mango ice cream. I really appreciate that

[@CydneSaysRawrX3]

The whole time he was talking about vanilla I was nodding my head so hard

[@sikka6440]

I always got hate for always choosing vanilla ice cream (it was a classmate). She said "why did you always choose vanilla ice cream, it's so bland and boring, basic bitch" i just said "I like vanilla ice cream, yeah I'm a basic bitch, so what. I have always liked vanilla ice cream, i hope that's not a crime".

[@Dipwad_Omega]

For the record, Blue Moon is DEFINITELY NOT blue raspberry or whatever that website Dan found said it was. I always thought of it as a sort of marshmallow-like flavor, which is backed up by the fact that i've seen a ton of places sell Blue Moon with mini marshmallows as a topping. It's like a less sweet, more subtle version of Cotton Candy ice cream. It really is awesome, so you should try it sometime if you see it somewhere. (Just be warned that it tastes different depending on where you get it from, since there's not really a definitive list of ingredients.)

[@baydiac]

Maybe in the places it tastes different in, that's when they try to make it blue raspberry. I've only ever had superman and not blue moon alone, but I'd agree with you that blue moon's just generic sweet like marshmallow and doesn't have the blue raspberry tang. Context is everything I guess though. Like when they said with mango ice cream they'd rather eat a real mango, I'm the opposite. The flavor of a mango is top tier but the texture bothers me so as an ice cream I'll take it over the fruit every time. (And I'm lactose intolerant)

[@Kennybea]

Yay, someone who knows what blue moon is, my favorite ice cream flavor

[@asleepeep]

The blue moon ice cream I've had tasted similar to fruit loops (which also have a marshmallow-esque flavor). I would put it in S tier, personally.

[@agentofashcroft]

The base is almond extract for sure, it's amazing, definitely not gross blue raspberry

[@lisahintz250]

I thought it tasted like almonds

[@TheBlueBlazes_]

They should have made a 10 Minute Power Hour out of this

[@Ronald_Ruck]

As much funny 10mph is, they are already wasting enough food.

[@oscarsegoviano5349]

Treat it the same way as the Kit Kats.

[@jamesembrey3100]

Dan would have actually died

[@Serpentsons]

@@Ronald_Ruck ice cream it´s not food.

[@TiiVTime]

PLeAS

[@a_stupid_kokichi_simp]

34:15 The image of arin slapping Dan every time he talked because he didn't like butter beecan was very clear and it had me crying 😭

[@ashleyspencer5736]

One of my favorite things (out of many) about these videos is when you hear Alli (sorry might have spelled it wrong) giggle/laugh.

[@daniellocklear5908]

As an ice cream maker, I’d lose my literal shit if Dan and Arin were fighting and arguing over flavors while at our store 🤣

[@dubblejinx]

This whole episode I was like “dude, it’s DREYER’S not BREYER’S” then I looked it up and apparently they both exist and it feels…mandela-y.

[@matthewbankey5547]

My dad thinks vanilla is objectively the best ice cream flavor. I bet he’d be glad to hear Arin put it at S-tier. Also, I loved hearing Arin physically restrain himself upon remembering he can’t swear the first minute into a video. 😂

[@vitonuma]

arin's opinion on chocolate and vanilla flavour are something i've literally *_never_* seen someone have and people always judged me for it, i am *so* glad i'm not alone

[@LordofEmbers]

*cough* Vanilla is S-tier, and chocolate is D-tier. You might not be alone, but hey! You found that guy that doesn’t exist!

[@vitonuma]

@@LordofEmbers i swear i read this sentence 3 times and couldn't understand a single thing! also yeah i think chocolate is even lower, because arin said it was like C for him, idk its just really bitter? it makes me thirsty and if you have water after it, there's an awful after taste

[@spookyschnoop]

my husband is right with you! he’s the first person i met that prefers vanilla and i found it SO weird because i’d only ever really had shitty vanilla ice cream, he showed me the good kinds lol

[@ronjones-6977]

Who's gonna be the one to tell Arin that chocolate has vanilla IN IT.

[@vitonuma]

@@spookyschnoop yeah! i also feel like i'm missing out on the good chocolate flavor because so many people like it and i feel left out lmao

[@nobody_5982]

24:00 it's vanilla raspberry. there's this obsession with making raspberry 'blue;' i didn't realize Blue Moon was a mostly Midwest USA flavor, as i've lived in the midwest my whole life and not seen many (local) ice cream stores without it.

[@killerklown94]

Vanilla is a distinct flavor but it is also the default. It's like nacho cheese doritos. There are plain doritos, but nacho cheese flavored are so ubiquitous they've become the default.

[@giraffelord666]

Creamsicle is S+ tier for me! My childhood revolved around getting those with my mom and just wanting to eat the whole box in one go!

[@SonicSlicer]

Vanilla Ice Cream is like Guile's Theme, it goes with everything.

[@lightningg252]

Before they discontinued it and switched their recipe to skim milk, Blue Bell Pineapples and Homemade Vanilla was amazing! It had the perfect mix with creamy, subtle sweetness of the vanilla and the tiny chucks of frozen pineapple added pleasant kicks of acidity and sweet that wasn't overpowering.

[@tailedgates9]

My new favorite thing is Dan's "Take it easy" everytime Arin goes haywire. XD

[@animeveteran]

If ever I have the chance to meet these two in person, I'm treating them both to Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ice cream, because I am SO into that flavor!

[@samlevine1753]

They should definitely just do 2 separate tier lists at the same time. Would be interesting to see how different they would be.

[@funx24X7]

I like how Arin incorporates the outrage from the comments directly into the episode for our convenience

[@mermaidpill]

"store bought ice cream has chemicals and shit" arin, everything has chemicals :)

[@TBustah]

Dairy Queen had a grape Kool-Aid Blizzard in the early aughts that I was crazy for. I’ve recreated it in the blender a few times at home. Just mix a really thick vanilla milkshake, and then add Kool-Aid powder to taste. The real thing also had grape popping candy in it, which was fine, but I don’t bother with it.

[@JayTorin]

The ending of the dessert episode gives this one a lot of context lol