Welcome To Our Shorts React to - BTS Black Swan (MV)

[@jilll1287]

Jimin was the one that sprouted wings. He represents the black swan in this video. Notice when he’s in white suit he’s dancing differently than he is when he’s wearing the black. He is dying his first death (Martha Graham) throughout the whole video until he collapses at the end. He’s the only member that’s trained in contemporary so a lot of the time when you see him dancing he’s off the one that singing his part. Edited to add: Blood Sweat and Tears come close when it comes Black Swan. Also Fake Love. Spring Day. Jimin’s Lie is incredible. Suga’s Shadow too. Even Anpanman has a deeper meaning!

[@imajinallthepurple]

Fun facts... - BTS has actually covered Every Breath You Take but in the Puff Daddy version. They even changed some of the rap parts to Korean. -The shadow/fear in Black Swan starts out really big and over-powering. Midways, when they confront it, reach out for it, they become equals. In the end they accept the fear as a part of who they are as artists and the shadow is absorbed back into them. 💜

[@srishtikar2964]

It was funny that you mentioned "Every breath you take", as they have actually done a live cover of it, and it's incredible

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

Serious!?! Yep. We're doing that!

[@Solny_army]

@@BeardsBoozeBandsBS yep! Check BBC Radio 1 Live Lounge 😁 (it's more correct to say the cover is of "I'll be missing you")

[@itsbonniefay2417]

Yes I love their harmonies, they did that song well

[@tinalim6782]

@@BeardsBoozeBandsBS here you go. kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3-YeJRshLKqnqM

[@marinal.]

@@BeardsBoozeBandsBS pls

[@YukariBromfield]

This song is truly a special song. And you guys are right in that this song can apply to non-artistic endeavors. I’m a high school teacher and I love it but earlier this year, something happened personally and for awhile I lost my passion for teaching and I felt empty. And this song certainly hit me totally. You were talking about going back to their earlier discography… yesterday, I listened to their Dark & Wild album thinking that I wouldn’t like it but I found so many songs I loved. So you may be surprised to go back. The boys are incredible writers, especially the rap line. For me the song that made me a fan is Spring Day. And yes, the music video has a connection to an actual tragedy, the song itself is helping go through the process of grief. I’m not really a rap fan but I love all the rap line songs. Some of their songs are anti-establishment that could have led to being blacklisted by the Korean government. I’m sure you will get tons of recommendations but you really should go through the discography because you will find your own BTS playlist that means a lot for you. Before BTS, I only listed to classical piano, so I know Bach really well. 😊 And I grew up in the 80’s so I remember the Police MV of that song and I thought that was creepy. I thought I had read that Sting wrote this for an ex after a divorce? Lol.

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

I hope you found passion someplace else. Teaching is one of the toughest professions. It's not appreciated and many teachers are leaving because they feel that they do what they do for the children and yet so many non-teachers in positions of power are telling them what they can and cannot teach.

[@YukariBromfield]

@@BeardsBoozeBandsBS I had a very special group of seniors this year and they pulled me through the tough times. Thank you.

[@Isilyal]

💜

[@jessicapierce3027]

Dark and Wild is an excellent album, Skoool Luv Affair is also worth listening to. Who am I kidding? Their entire discography is worth it.

[@YukariBromfield]

@@jessicapierce3027 When I first saw the MV for Boy in Luv, I was taken back and just didn’t listen to the early albums. And the fact that I’m old, I didn’t think I could relate to the whole young love stuff. Lol. But I will listen to the trilogy! 😊

[@deniseannlange4519]

A well-known Martha Graham quote opens the piece, which is apparently a personal reflection on art by the band itself: “A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing, and this first death is the more painful.” BT Martha Graham revolutionized Contemporary and Modern dance . Jimin actually specialized in that type of dance...

[@deniseannlange4519]

She lived 1894-1991.

[@jocelyn6318]

🤍

[@ching-yaolo8242]

Martha Graham left an official modern dance technique, the Graham Technique. Classes are given all throughout the world as one of a few modern dance techniques. There exists the Martha Graham Dance Company and The Martha Graham School of Contemporary Dance, founded in 1926 and still growing strong. Classes are always given in very good dance schools, because it builds the body like ballet.

[@jocelyn6318]

@@ching-yaolo8242 I'm a dance major and you're correct Martha has left an enormous technique in modern dance that helps a lot to understand the use of our body through dance (for sure, we also use this technique in contemporary dance).

[@AlineNigelski]

When you talked about the somber sound and deep meaning I instantly remembered Jimin's solo song "Lie" (also one of my favorite solo live performances because his dancing conveys the meaning as well as the song) and Suga's solo song "Shadow"

[@wendydubbelyou]

There is so much symbolism going on here, like the fact that they started out on stage facing the crowd to ending it with their back turned to the crowd on the stage. there are a lot of things like that

[@soeunpark6935]

The entire Wings area is definitely on par artistically with the Map of the Soul: 7 era - the Wings shorts/MVs and depth of the songs are some of BTS's best. It's really BTS's "art album" era. It's a bit overwhelming, but if you take it solo song by song/relevant short by short, it's probably the most personal solos the members have had, as well as the most creative musically. I think it's a great way to learn about each of the members and their own individual styles as well! It starts with Jungkook's solo, Begin (#1): kzbin.info/www/bejne/r4OaZHxmr5qgqZI (Note, none of the solo songs have music videos, but there are a bunch of lyric videos out there...there are music videos for Boy Meets Evil, the intro, & Blood, Sweat, and Tears, the lead single)

[@carlycchapman]

If we're gonna send them through WINGS, we might as well send them through the whole BU, since WINGS is part of that. XD I'd love to see their perspective on the entire BU, but that would need to be another series for sure.

[@linneajoette]

BTS have so many songs with deeper meanings that it is hard to just pick one, Whalien 52 and 134340 are two that pop into my head immediately. Even songs that sound like they are a straight up play/party songs can surprise you with deeper meanings like GO GO, Anpanman, or Baepsae. They are great for making us think as well as enjoy the music and I love them for that. They even poked fun at ARMY's obsession with them in Pied Piper. My recommendation is to just pick a song that sounds interesting to you and have fun seeing that it is more than you thought. Great reaction and glad your better Kyle. 💜💜💜💜

[@quewilliams6884]

Jimin sprouted wings he is also the one doing the contemporary dancing

[@marinal.]

yep yep

[@lillianbarbieri7771]

Yoongi (Suga) solo song in Map of the Soul 7 is Interlude: Shadow which dwells on the shadow concept of Carl Jung (with Persona from RM and Ego from Hobi). Shadow comes right before Black Swan in the album.

[@reneezemlock7880]

There are a couple behind the scene making-of videos for this. One has all of them and one is just how Jimin filmed his dance sequences. Even if you don't react to them, you should check them out. This is one of my favorite songs from them. You should also check out a couple of their live performances of this. Their first live performance was on James Corden in 2020 and they did a pre-recorded live version for BTS week on Jimmy Fallon. ALSO... one of their live performances from their Permission to Dance concerts @_@ You should check out "Still With You". It's a JK solo he wrote and his super Jazzy and has that kind of fuzzy echo-y sound in the beginning.

[@deniseannlange4519]

BTS did a live version of "I'll be Missing You" which is Sean Combs & Faith Evans's song they did. Ther version was based on Sting's "I'll be watching you" and "I'll Fly Away".... the rappers in BTS added in solo rap lines.

[@icantjimout4298]

The one who did the shadow behind Suga’s part and Jk’s part is jimin, and also he is the one doing the contemporary dance.

[@soop5414]

Black Swan ballet: changing from white to black swan - growing up, losing innocence. Black Swan movie - sacrificing mental and physical health to reach the top. Shadow/mirror images - self reflection. Ocean - something for you to look out for in various BTS songs.

[@Ariel-iz9hv]

As people already mentioned in the comments it was Jimin who sprouted the wings haha. He's also the one doing all the solo dance parts and playing the shadow dancing behind the members. A little fun fact that aligns with the entire theme of Black Swan and the choreography itself is that Jimin is actually a trained contemporary dancer from a top art school in Korea and contemporary dance was actually branched off as a rebellion against the rigidity and perfection required by ballet that can sometimes stifle the dancers and kill their passion for their art. Contemporary dance is supposed to be more emotive and expressive and Jimin kind of exposes that transition in the video. He's much more graceful and soft when in the whole outfit (aligning with ballet) and then breaks out from the rigidity when he sprouts wings and tries to reclaim his love and passion (the movements get far more intense and chaotic in the black outfit) until finally he collapses and dies his first death like in Black swan

[@MsKaz1000]

this is just for fact reasons because Jimin is an amazing dance but the shadow behind RM was J Hope not Jimin they are both amazing dancers and I love this MV

[@el-dawn]

Black Swan has a special place in my (and I believe a lot of other people) heart. It *is* very relatable. As someone who also passionate about something. About creating... it's absolutely terrifying to think of the day when I won't be able to do what I love and passionate about anymore. Depression did that to me for a few years and I did blame myself for losing touch with what I love. Deep down that passion is still inside, but I couldn't physically and mentally fulfill that passion. :") As the members have multiple times said, they're well aware that everything won't last forever. So I hope they as an artist could make music and perform for as long as they can and want to; and I'll be there to witness it. As always great reaction and discussion, guys

[@Isilyal]

💜

[@JeonJungkook-wr4yr]

You guys gotta see this live it's beyond incredible in there concert they did this song and truly so amazing.

[@lilithlove7]

Nice to have you back, Kyle! The small orchestra arraignment for the dance video is also great. Please react to the mv for Interlude Shadow while you’re here on the dark side 😉

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

I'll check it out!

[@marinal.]

@@BeardsBoozeBandsBS sweet, ty

[@KW-tc6rk]

I really enjoy y’all’s reactions! I’m looking forward to more! Also, glad Kyle is back to normal!

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

Yay! Thank you!

[@baharbts2549]

performances of this song is amazing

[@ThaisLima-kh7kp]

I’m SO invested in your guys channel, such a fresh take for me inside of this reaction format of content, the comments and conversations are so rich and interesting! Lots of love from a brazilian army 🇧🇷💜

[@BSYBang]

This song says, “The dancer dies twice. The first death is when the dancer stops dancing. And this death is much more painful,” the legendary contemporary dancer Martha Graham made its motif. Just as a dancer faces his first death when he quits dancing, it contains the fear of the moment when he will no longer be able to stand on the stage as an artist. "The more I do music, the more I fear that music will no longer give me a lot of emotion or trembling, but the moment I face my inner 'Black Swan' from the depths of my heart, I paradoxically realize that there is only music." Suga also said that if he is flying now with the wings that ARMY gave him, he wants to land slowly rather than fall. [Suga] Ayy, they say my heart is not beating no more listening to music Tryna pull up Time seems to have stopped Oh that would be my first death I been always afraid of [RM] If this makes me cry no more If you can't make my heart tremble more How could I ever die like this But what if that moment’s right now right now Ps:Black Swan is my favorite song. When I had to end my 25-year career as a contemporary dancer, I felt the same way, and this song comforted me.

[@janelle3681]

I’m glad he is back! I like to see both of you in this channel

[@LEE-zh6us]

BTS has a lot of songs with deeper meanings that often get overlooked by the fact that they are a boyband and the stereotype that comes with that. They have many songs like this, some about them confronting their own shadows and fears like this one Black Swan, and Suga's solo Shadow where he talks about being afraid of being famous, because as the lights on him become brighter, his shadows grows bigger; they talk about their personas in songs like Idol where they embrace the title "Idol" which is often talked down by many people who say "Idol/Kpop music isn't good or authentic" by saying they don't care anymore because they know who they are and chant that nobody can stop them from loving themselves, as well as in RM's solo Persona where he talks about who he is, his persona and what he wants to be and all the things that come with that; one of their first more daring songs is actually a single from secong album O!RUL8,2?, the song is called N.O and it seems to be a sequel to their debut song No More Dream where talk about feeling so pressured by people to study hard and get into a good university that they're left with no space to dream about what they really want to do or be, in N.O they take it a step further and directly criticize the insane schedules that korean students have to go through asking "Who are the ones the made us into studying machines? The ones that categorized us into numbers and stragglers and locked us in a trap" and urge the people to say no to these ideals and to not let themselves be trapped living in someone else's dream; Spine Breaker is another one where they openly talk down on teenagers wanting to have only the good expensive things in life because all of their other (richer) friends in school have them, essentially "breaking their parents spines" in order to get those useless things just to gain status; in Baepsae which to a regular listener that doesn't understand what they're saying can easily be overlooked as just a fun hype song to dance to actually criticizes the older generation for fucking up the economy to the point where young people can't even afford housing and when they get jobs they're often underpayed or not payed at all because it's an "experience job", and talk down on the older generation for calling the younger generation "lazy" and "not hard working" when in fact they are the ones to blame for the environment the youngsters have to survive through nowadays. They also have some very personal songs as well, often solos, where they talk about their own struggles and stories. Some that come to mind is Suga's Nevermind and his solo from the Wing's album called First Love where he talks about his deep love for the piano and growing up alongside the instrument changing his flow in a sort of conversational way where he speaks as the piano and as himself, and Jin's solo Epiphany which might be one of their most beautiful songs talking about self-love emphasizing that he is the one he should love, following the group's continuous message that loving oneself is the most important love people should have in their lives. And it would be a crime to not mention Spring Day when finishing this essay of a comment. Spring Day has been charting on the Top 50 section of Gaon's Digital Charts for 5 CONSECUTIVE YEARS, making it one of, if not the most, streamed/bought/listened to BTS song, also considered by most Armys BTS most iconic and beautiful song, telling the story of losing someone you deeply loved and cared for, be it a friend, a partner, a family member, somebody who has passed away, literally anybody who had a big part in your life and are no longer there and all the feelings that come with that, the longing for the person to come back, it's opening lines being "I miss you, saying this out loud makes me miss you more", and the anger about this person leaving/growing apart but still not being able to forget them because they meant so much. They compare the longing to meet with this person again to being a snowflake in a snowing day saying "If I were a fluttering snowflake I would be able to reach you a little faster", comparing these sad times to winter and waiting for the spring to come so they can be together/happy again. It's also important to mention that although this has never been confirmed by the members, a lot of people have theorized that this song is about, or makes reference to the Sewol Ferry Tragedy which killed 304 of the 476 people on board, being that more than 300 passengers were young students of the Danwon High School who were going on an organized trip, only 75 students were able to survive the tragedy. The references people have noted are mostly in the music video, scenes of Jimin by the ocean retrieving a pair of shoes from the water, shots filmed from inside a laundry machine which many have said resemble the windows of a ferry/ship, scenes of Suga on top of a big pile of clothes which could represent the people lost in the tragedy (the pile of clothes is actually an art piece so you can interpret it in many ways). In the music video they also reference the fictional town of Omelas from the fantasy book called "The Ones Who Walk Away From Omelas". The story is a utopia where in the town of Omelas everything is perfect and everyone is happy, but in order for that to be one child has to be the kept in complete darkness and misery. When people learn about the child most of them decide to ignore it since that is the reason why they are able to live such happy lives, but some decide to escape, not necessarily knowing where to go but going anyway, them being the ones that walk away from Omelas. The boys in the music video seem to represent the people of Omelas, in many scenes they are seen having fun, looking happy and in peace, then in others they seem to start to realize that something is wrong, leading them to run away and take a train to anywhere, essentially leaving Omelas. In one of the final scenes we can see that Jimin hung the shoes he retrieved from the ocean in a tree which to many is a tribute to the students who lost their lives in the ferry accident or could also be seen as them paying tribute to the fictional child of Omelas. In the end we can see all the boys finally together in a deserted place by the tree where the shoes are hanging from as the winter turns into spring. It's beautifully written song and a beautifully made music video so I highly recommend reacting to it. So in conclusion: REACT TO SPRING DAY! 💜

[@Siennaflower]

Loved your essay!!!

[@LEE-zh6us]

@@Siennaflower Thank you! I really tried my best to include some of their most thought challenging songs but there's so many I really feel like I could write pages about it 😅

[@Siennaflower]

@@LEE-zh6us Absolutely!! There's so much to say about their songs, and I'm here for it!! I think RM's philosophical vibe inspires those of us who are thinkers or writers to wax eloquent about them and their songs! I also think the fact that Bang SiHyuk got a degree in aesthetics is revealed in everything BigHit produces! 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@ulhakwiliyanah7006]

💜💜💜

[@anamaria-azula]

14:08 I can feel you tumbling down the rabbit hole with every word you say 😌💅👀

[@mcald17]

The rap line songs have a lot of deeper meaning/raw lyrics. OUTRO: TEAR is a very powerful song that suga wrote at a time when BTS was struggling mentally/physically and thought about disbanding. The live version is incredible and you can really feel their emotion. As people have said, map of the soul is based on carl jung's philosophy of ego and the album parallels that and journeys through the realization of self. There are good explanation videos to pair with music videos if you evere wanted to do a dive

[@miraclesumalpong2635]

I love it when I stayed after you reacted to the full MV. Most of the time in some reactors I quit immediately after they've finished the MV or video, but with your channel, I love staying after for the wisdom you're sharing. Thank you for this.

[@Fairy_jjks]

I’m watching this after the Yet To Come teaser I’m shaking oml 😭

[@jayiti2262]

Spring Day is a great song with a lot of deep meaning to it. Many would say it is one of their best songs. While the lyrics of the song can be related to many different feelings and circumstances, the MV has lots of references and imagery of an incident that happened in Korea called the Sewol Ferry Disaster/Tragedy. There is a great analysis video on it from Italian ARMY. Fair warning though, it is pretty sad and devastating.

[@carolinesch.]

Every breath you Take, there are people who Play that at weddings!? People Dont know its about a Stalker?! Like the Lyrics are soooo obvious about that

[@imajinallthepurple]

It's like how people think Last Christmas by Wham is a beautiful christmas song... 🤦‍♀️

[@minsugamaxsalt]

I love hearing your thoughtful discussions after the music. Thank you so much. I would definitely recommend to start from the beginning (2013) -> 2021 just to see how they’ve grown up. Or, you can go from 2021 -> 2013 since you’ve watched all their recent music vids already.

[@bobbimayer4563]

Something I love the most about BTS is how deep a lot of their music is. The further you get into their discography you’ll discover so many songs with deep and meaningful lyrics. Even if they’re known as a pop/hiphop boy group and those songs go the biggest commercially, a lot of their work, I’d even venture to say the majority of it, is much deeper. I’m still learning and going down rabbit holes to this day three years in 😂 one of my personal favorite songs is called the truth untold. That one has a lot of back story as well and I hope you’ll get to it. Love the reactions 😁

[@kimschuler2906]

This is one of my top 5 favorite songs by them. I love this song. Also love Kyle's taste in music. Love A Perfect Circle and Nine Inch Nails. I would recommend the song Lie by Jimin. It has some really deep meaning. There is no official music video for it but there is a lyrical video. It seems to me that the most deep songs that BTS has are either the individual somgs or the line songs. I think that is just because individually you can sing something that is really important to you or really affecting you better than with a group sometimes. I would also recommend the song outro: tear. It was done by the rapline around the time period when they thought about breaking up as a group.

[@ishratjahan2999]

There's a quote in the artfilm version and it's "a dancer dies twice, once when she stops dancing and this first death is more painful". The song resonates this quote.

[@Random-qi3vv]

Love that we have regular Kyle again!

[@AngelaSealana]

Regular Kyle: *slaps Sick Kyle* Me: Yep, this is what I signed up for.

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

He stomped on his face after the video. lol

[@TassianeBernardideJesus]

When the video started, I was worried that Kyle wouldn't react to this MV, so I was really happy when you showed up. Once again I want to thank you for the videos you make, I really believe it's a good use of my time to see and listen to you smart people analyzing lyrics and MV's instead of just reacting to gain views and subscribers. Thanks.

[@jee2325]

what you said about them referencing death in the lyrics is absolutely accurate. In the black swan art film they also released, they included a quote that references this too - "A dancer dies twice - once when they stop dancing and this first death is more painful" - Martha Graham

[@jessicapierce3027]

I think one of the things that does some deserves to BTS' music is how some people only want to stick to the literal meaning of the song based on how the artist wrote it. But what makes the best songs and the best lyricist, or poets or writers is that their work can be relatable to a wider audience. 1000 people don't live the same life so they may hear the same song and hear a different song from the person next to them. I can't relate to losing a passion for music or dancing, but I can relate to losing passion, in my case my career or hobbies, they aren't things that define me but they are parts of my life that kept me moving forward. And what's great about BTS lyrics is that the depressing things don't linger, they give you a sense of hope that it can get better. On a lighter note from beginning to end of this song I am also reminded of Jack Skellington, because it's basically what he went through on Nightmare Before Christmas.

[@gailkeren]

Your comment about "Black Swan" being mature is very spot on. I'm glad that you guys appreciate that side of BTS and that you analyze the song lyrics. That is what makes BTS' discography appealing to so many different age groups. Their themes range from young love, self-love, rebellion, artistic pursuits, mental health, etc, so there's a lot of stuff to discover.

[@meriAnne3376]

For me blackswan is about their lives as idols . While on stage, the spotlight is all on them, the media covers their every move, finding faults to every little mistakes that they are afraid to make even a little mistake that haters blow up. They are seen by fans as perfect and so if they make a mistake, its the end of their careers. If their passion is lost and they cant give what fans expect then its their death.

[@rosat8877]

There other mv of black swan is also a different version of the song. I recommend watch it anyway because it hits differently. For me is a better version. I you want to check even deeper songs I'd recommend: Tomorrow. This song made me stan bts and made me realized they were different. It's also an old one and there's no mv, but live performance. Paradise. From love yourself tear Blue&grey. From BE album Whailen 52. From the most beautiful moment in life, part 2 Answer: love myself. From love yourself: answer album

[@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971]

Next please checkout Magic Shop live performance with subtitles.

[@BleachBrownie]

i think the song speaks to not just the inability to practice your craft but also the possibility of no longer finding enjoyment or satisfaction from it next week marks 9 years since their debut. that's a long time to be doing what your doing, and not have those concerns, to look at how much you've achieved in some areas of your life yet still feel like you're in stasus or lacking in others

[@KassandraTheCleric]

I've seen many people discuss this song and how it helped them in their depression. That line about the ocean one to mine because I describe my depression like that. Like you're in the water standing and suddenly a wave picks you up, sand slipping under your feet. Then bam the water is over your head and it's dark and heavy and you move so slow. It all seems to difficult to find your way back to the light. So this song speaks to so, so much.

[@shelby1053]

Glad to see you're feeling better kyle! I just got a stomach bug and I'm recovering rn too so I feel your pain. This is definitely BTS' most artistic album next to wings, which i think someone already mentioned in another comment. I believe MOTS7 was actually suppose to have a coordinating art exhibit. I know they had a few put out but I believe it got cut short because of the pandemic. Such a shame, I'm sure it would've been really cool.

[@angeliesy1021]

Welcome back Kyle, glad to see you're feeling better 😊 thanks yiu guys for checking out Black Swan, it is one of my faves, and i love the meaning of the song. I completely relate to it, i would feel dead inside if i could no longer feel my passion for things i love to do.

[@tarisindanarie34]

guys please react to Spring Day, it is considered as the Queen of all BTS songs. it has never left the Top 50 Gaon chart since its release in 2017. the song in itself has a deep meaning about missing someone you've lost but the inspiration for the music video is more heartbreaking. there's an explanation video about that, watch the video first and take note of a few details so you can relate it when you watch the explanation video. other BTS songs that has a deep meaning are Blood, Sweat and Tears and some of their catchy songs which seem light and fun but actually tackles social issues like N.O., Baepsae, Go Go and Anpanman for some. More power to your channel!

[@DA-sf3vs]

Welcome back Kyle! So glad to see u healthy! Please stay healthy and safe. Same for Cory 💜

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

Thank you! It's good to be back. - Kyle

[@raya6532]

As a huge fan of Aronofsky films, especially Black Swan, and of BTS I freaked out when this music video and the lyrics came out. There are variations of the story in all the different adaptations since the original ballet. BTS relating to it from their own perspective as artists and the fears they have is so well done lyrically, choreography-wise, and visually. I think people who are in any artistic field that have spent their whole lives doing the one thing they love would be lost if they stopped loving what they are doing and the passion is gone. If you haven’t watched the “Black Swan Art Film” video that they dropped during promo for this song I highly recommend it. It’s an actual modern dance group that performs to the orchestral version of this song. Love your BTS reactions KEEP EM COMING

[@lesliecaudill725]

Like your reactions, in depth, thought out. "Fake Love" speaks to a lot of fans.

[@organiccookie1306]

I think it's safe to say that most BTS songs have a deep meaning. Sometimes understanding the whole meaning takes quite a bit of research because there is so much context involved (cultural references, Korean language meaning, references to BTS' journey and the relationship with ARMY). Alao, they create concept albums with narratives/story arcs. SUGA once explained theat the meaning might only become clear when listening to all the songs on one album. I recommend SUGA's beautiful 2016 solos track First Love next. It shows his outstanding ability to create images and a whole story with his lyrics.

[@lauren0047]

Hi guys! Taylor Nakamoto just pisted her updated version of the guide to bts! Please watch that 💜 Edit: here's the link kzbin.info/www/bejne/nqa5kKx_md2Nhrs

[@lisacsarmiento5627]

Welcome back Kyle .. glad you're well now 💜. Thank you for sharing your insights to this song guys.

[@deniseannlange4519]

The doll is from the Idoll songs/MV

[@nirvana6172]

The one who got the wings was Jimin, For you to recognize each BTS member just listen to their voices, the way they sing they got different tones. Vocal line Jin, Jungkook, Jimin & V have distinct voices also the rapline, RM, Suga & J-Hope got their own flow when rapping, that way you will remember them.

[@amimom2837]

If you want to check out a video that's similar to Black Swan or Fake Love then you should check out Blood, Sweat and Tears. That video is full of symbolism.

[@sushmo7100]

I’m loving your reaction, breakdown and your perspectives on BTS songs. Thank you!

[@a2g2u2s.t.d]

the lyrics for this song are so poetic. they still impress me every time I watch the video. also I was huge into BSB when I was younger and I can tell you there is nothing even close to this in their catalog (at least up until 2003ish). maybe now that they're older, they'll have something along these lines. but never ever could I imagine 20-something BSB or Nsync doing anything close to this lyrically.

[@chelssays]

Blue & Grey during the pandemic, The Truth Untold, Answer: Love Myself, 00:00 Zero O’Clock, Jungkook’s My Time, First Love, Tear…the list goes on and on guys.

[@bangtannoah]

There are some songs from their Love Yourself era/albums that get pretty introspective & deep (“Answer: Love Myself” & “Epiphany” are two songs that come to mind), but MOTS:7 has quite a number of deep songs. You gotta dig into some songs off some of their earlier albums: Tomorrow, Am I Wrong, Epilogue: Young Forever are a few that come to mind. Someone else said it, but their solo tracks from their WINGS album are really excellent. I don’t remember if y’all have looked into Spring Day or not yet, but that’s a great song.

[@Catalina-fq1kq]

this mv hits different when you see their festa video and all makes sense now, I mean they were telling us what they were feeling since 2/3 years ago, I just want them to be happy and healthy 💜

[@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971]

If possible do the behind the scenes of BSwan where Jimin shows us his talent in contemporary dancing. RM is main songwriter of BSwan and he cried while writing it. Pdogg produced it

[@bonchaemanchae]

why you lying pdogg is still the main songwriter of black swan

[@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971]

@@bonchaemanchae RM himself said and in credits RM is main songwriter.Pdogg is mainly a producer not a songwriter tho he co writes. RM is known in kpop for songwriting and has 189 credits, most credited idol after Ravi. Do some research kid. Kids from other fandoms these days🤦🏻. Even Pdogg would laugh at your comment lmao. Everyone knows BTS members(the rapline) are main songwriters and Pdogg is main producer. RM,Suga were taken into BTS for writing and producing songs and rapping. Checkout the Mots7 press conference RM clearly says he wrote BlackSwan and he cried while writing it

[@rikhmjustsomeguywithmousta4971]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/maG9e3hvedOXoas

[@psychokitty71]

Honestly, most of their songs have multiple meanings. They have songs that have one meaning for the members of BTS, another meaning for the listener and yet another meaning/message that the boys are trying to convey. And then you throw in a music video and get a fourth meaning. Especially when you deal with the BTS Universe story line. Their first albums deal mainly with issues that people in high school typically relate to, because that was their age when they wrote the songs. Even then, however, you have songs lik No More Dream, where they tell people to stop following the dream that someone else has for them and to follow their own dreams. They have songs like N.O, which is a criticism of the Korean school system. I've seen people mention Sprig Day. The song itself is about losing someone, either to time and distance or to death. The video, however, is a tribute to the Sewol Ferry tragedy. Around 250 high school students drowned when a ferry sank. Government corruption and greed caused the accident but the actions of the Coast Guard, press, and government officials caused so many deaths. They then tried to cover up the truth. The MV references all of that. There are two explanation videos for Spring Day that ARMY always recommends. One is by Bulletproof Vibes and the other one is by Italian ARMY. The first one is more about the visuals in the video than anything else. The second one, however, discusses the imagery, but mainly focuses on the actual tragedy and what happened to the ferry and the victims and their families. That one is absolutely gut-wrenching, so be aware of that before you watch it. It includes footage of the parents on shore, begging the uncaring coast guard to rescue their dying children. Many people aren't able to watch the whole thing. It's an excellent video, but the subject matter makes it difficult viewing.

[@antoinettefinner3488]

Welcome back Kyle! Good to see you are feeling better.

[@m_artinez]

You guys should definitely watch a live performance of this song. It’s so beautiful and it incorporates a lot of back up dancers and is truly stunning. I watched it live at a concert and I couldn’t believe it😭

[@janetaskin2150]

Thanks for another thoughtful & enjoyable BTS reactions. Glad to see that Kyle is recovered! You may enjoy reacting to the vocal line's live performance of 'House of Cards.' (live) It is soulful & the band (though off stage) is beautiful w/synphonic elements. Alsi, they do a beautiful job vocally of the newer Japanese song - "Film out' the Music Blood version has the best audio/mix. Look forward to more BTS reactions! Take good care. :)

[@DA-sf3vs]

Oh God I was so sad Kyle was not there again! So awesome! 👍 you got me there !!!

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

I was so hoping we would trick someone. LOL - Kyle

[@elena4695]

personally, i believe Black Swan is so widely relatable because it doesn't have just one meaning, but rather different layers of it superimposing to create some big image. bts have been weaving a story throughout their content for years, in which they've depicted the process of growing up and knowing oneself; they have acted as children, as young boys who've gone and done so much, as young men who struggle with their identity and what part of us is real (as in, this saying of "a person's true colors"; is it just the ugly, dark colors which are true? or rather is it the pretty, vibrant colors we show to the outside? that's pretty much what maps: persona is telling.) in the BU, black swan is referring to the moment where we fight or unite with our shadows, leaving it to break us or make us (something which is very visible in the alternative black swan mv, with a crew of dancers). they tell that story while that telling itself is representing who they are as people (artists, performers) and that they've struggled when it comes to separating the stage persona to their real self (which, again, is visible in Shadow). it's complicated to point-blank explain because it goes in circles, but if anything, i'd recommend searching for a guideline to watch the BU in order. have a nice day, and thank you for your time!

[@cynthiaperez2232]

Kyle, what you said touched me (re: the stages of grief/frustration). If you haven't already, I hope you check out First Love by Suga.

[@1obsessionafteranother794]

I’m gonna watch this reaction later but did you know that prior to this official MV, there was another MV before it? It’s titled Black Swan Art Film, it features the Martha Graham quote about the “first death”, and was choreographed and performed by MN Dance Company. I mention it because I feel that it now often gets overlooked.

[@sybalandra7544]

BTS songs with deeper meanings? Actually, there's a lot to remember but these first come to mind: 1. 134340 (a Pluto reference - you'll know about it from the lyrics) 2. Whalien 52 (the world's loneliest whale, and why the whale is a very significant symbol for BTS and ARMY) 3. Lie (vulnerability and escaping temptation, musically-rich and very sultry) 4. Interlude: Shadow (the underlying meaning behind one's shadow, the struggles that come along with success) Always love your reactions! And YAYY to regular kyle welcome back!!

[@msmichellewinchester]

YAY, Kyle is back! I literally squeeled when he came through the door 😄

[@CP_LUVS]

Thanks for your reaction to this. Cannot wait for the next BTS reaction. They have a ton of equally as deep songs and MVs, some seem like they could just be talking about young love or such but when you really look in to it you realize they are talking about their own views/emotion on themselves or ARMY or life in general. Hope you check out more soon. Cannot wait. Glad you are feeling better Kyle!!!

[@taetaetrash9728]

I'm gonna recommend you guys a song you probably don't get recommended often, which is: BAEPSAE aka Silver Spoon. This song is a song in which BTS calls out boomers and the generation gap. Before BTS I had NEVER seen anyone write songs on these kinda subjects. (Am I Wrong, Spinebreaker, GoGo are a few other satirical songs that touch on social / political subjects). To really understand Baepsae, please react to "DKDKTV explaining Baepsae". It's a famous video of 2 Korean guys explaining the song's meaning. It will give you a true insight and blow you away. And will also give you a really good insight in what sets apart BTS from other groups and makes them special. (ps Baepsae doesn't have an MV, but does have a dance practice). So yeaaah DEFINITELY watch both Baepsae with lyrics and then the explanation to understand 1 of the reasons why BTS's music is special.

[@NaBi_1307]

I don't think that there is a person alive who won't relate to the fear of losing passion unless they already lose theirs. I personally happen to experience this (still experiencing), after years of loving doing research and working on my field of study, I lost all motivation and passion to finish my phd and abandoned everything I loved doing, everything collapsed but the problem is I didn't feel anything but void, still to this day trying to find myself, find another passion to give myself a reason to keep moving otherwise I really don't know what to do with my life.. It's been almost a year since I took "a time off" from everything to rediscover myself and hopefully one day I'll find the missing piece.

[@Mark-vj7zd]

Just in case no-one else has mentioned it, the ocean symbolism is something they’ve returned to several times over the years and there’s a specific phenomenon in k-pop which is relevant here. Ordinarily in their concerts they (and other idols) swim in an ocean of light and sound provided by the fans through their lightsticks, cheers, applause, singalongs and chants. In k-pop there is something called a ‘black ocean’ where the audience will deliberately turn off their lightsticks and be silent to express their disinterest and/or disapproval. So, in addition to being about the fear of losing their own love for their art it’s also evoking the terror of losing their audience. For BTS that would be utterly devastating. The lyrical and conceptual depth isn’t new. Their songs have always had heft and intent and they’ve retained the elements of social, political and personal commentary which made them distinctive from the get go. Even back in 2015 at the beginning of the HYYH era they were starting to explore some very deep and dark ideas, especially through the imagery of the BU (Bangtan Universe) contrasting and interplaying with the songs. The Wings era (2016/17) is the flowering of the explorations which lead directly through Love Yourself:* to Map of the Soul. If anything, Wings itself is even more intricately constructed than MotS, particularly if you incorporate watching the short films and mvs.

[@sruticranjith5194]

Blackswan also has connections to the movie, and its not the first time they have pulled inspiration from Blackswan, blood sweat and tears yet another mv of theirs have direct interpretations from Blackswan. Blackswan is from the album Map of the soul 7 which is derived from carl jungs teachings, the archetypes of human personality and achievement of individualization Black swan movie also has those themes of Persona and her hidden repressed shadow, which is a huge part of this album concept You can also watch the instrumental version of Blackswan which is performed by an art company. It is called Blackswan art film. Its beautiful, and very meaningful and deep

[@crushedflora2696]

Glad to have Normal Kyle back. The other was was really quiet

[@imajinallthepurple]

Why does "regular Kyle" low-key sound like someone from a laxative commercial?! 🤔😅😂

[@BeardsBoozeBandsBS]

You may have something... ;)

[@Reign14forever]

Spring day is one of the deepest most heart breaking songs bts have ever done read the lyrics then read the story behind it

[@blueminnie13]

In my Opinion: This is the one that should have won a Grammy. The idea of loss of love/interest/ability of your art should have been a message that most artists can relate to (especially since Grammy reps keep saying it's not a popularity contest.....?). Having the subtitles reinforce the concept but the tone and imagery are there. Spring Day is also excellent regarding message and imagery. I can't get through Butterfly without tearing up. As an older ARMY, I've seen many groups come and go, (including the Beatles, Bee Gees, Jackson Five, The Monkees - These are the ones where I knew the names of the members) but none have captivated my interest like BTS. Good review! THX

[@yoshikiyoshikioyama4191]

Really happy both of u are backs sir thanks for the reaction and black swan is Fcking insane.

[@lilith7334]

I consider this song my introduction to the boys. A year ago, i was following Jimin videos when arrive to this song and became one of my favorites ❤️

[@taylortoodles]

I really enjoy that you guys take the time to dissect these songs and that you share how you can personally relate to the lyrics. I'd definitely recommend some of BTS' more political/social commentary songs like Baepsae, Am I Wrong, N.O, or UGH!. Not only are they incredibly insightful and deep, they're also all certified bops 😆

[@erivera9313]

99% of their music is extremely deep and meaningful. Dynamite and Butter are feel good songs. Permission to Dance is semi deep for discussing the pandemic.

[@salinasahrom6364]

If you ask me for another song that has a deeper meaning...to me its Magic Shop, the song is made for Army. Pls do a reaction to Magic Shop. 💞 Borahea 💜

[@chichaya7608]

all of their songs have deep deep meanings especially in their early days. if you want you might want to check Am I Wrong. This song is abt political views and such. also, check their Dark & Wild Album, as well as Wings. Love Yourself series album (This is a trilogy) Btw, thankyou for always appreciating BTS artistry and musicality. :) Yet To Come MV Teaser it out now, might want to check it out. ;)

[@donitapolk9413]

KYLE'S back! Yaaay, I'm glad you're feeling better.

[@elizar8863]

Welcome back Kyle! Love both you guys together. Please watch Blood,Sweat and Tears MV. Besides being visually stunning it is packed with deeper meanings. It is also helpful to watch one of the explanation videos to understand what is going on💜I guarantee you will like it♥️

[@titanium3xp]

i loved this reaction video. I love how you guys go more deep into the music itself and its sound and meaning. I def loved the intro to this video it was hilarious. Love you both. Stay safe, healthy, and happy. HuGGieS

[@phoenixtearz1]

One song that stands out to me as having a deeper meaning is NO. Its not in and of itself deeper, but for an "idol group" it hits hard at societal norms and expectations of youth. I'm almost 42, and a lot of the boy bands and idols of my youth NEVER touched on any important topics, it was all about having fun and "love". That's one of the things I love about BTS, while they do have their poppy catchy songs, the majority of their music touches on real life.

[@Launibu]

and yes, a lot of their older stuff is "mature" in subject matter.

[@Launibu]

suga and the guys always say....the bigger your success or light, the bigger the shadows. I think this ties in a lot with Sugas "shadow" from Mots7. It also makes me think of depression and then getting out of it.

[@amyoconnell3936]

This song is related to the "shadow" part of Jung's Map of the Soul. A soul decends into the underworld/subconscious to face one's darker, hidden side. After integratng the shadow into one's consciousness, one is reborn as a more complete person. Being swallowed and drowning are often symbols of death and rebirth. The first few songs in MOTS:7 (following the ones from Persona) are about the dark side of being a performer. The MOTS series is based on Murray Stein book by the same name.

[@reiang9637]

Another great thing about them is their lyrics are meaningful. They blew up in popularity in America thanks to English pop tracks like Dynamite and Butter but those are just fun songs, “shallow” compared to their usual lyrics that hold messages.

[@debhouckscraftycottage]

Black Swan was my introduction to BTS a little over a year ago. It will always have a special place in my heart. Beautiful and meaningful song, for sure, especially for any creative type. Glad Kyle is feeling better now. For more meaningful type songs: Spring Day MV and the Spring Day explanation video by Italian Army, Idol MV and Idol explained by a Korean (DKDKTV)...there are more but I'll just start with those. Thanks for the reaction.

[@iamtd298]

Appreciate you guys taking the time to share your thoughts abt the song. A lot of their older releases (ie, before butter or dynamite) do touch on pretty serious themes. Interlude: Shadow - by Suga is another interesting song methinks. It's in the Map of the Soul: 7 album~ Worth diving into the lyrics to.

[@vanmiddletonphotography]

BTS is known for being deep and meaningful, as you go through the Rise of Bangtan series, you will really see that, HYYH ( Most Beautiful moment in Life) and Wings era plus the Love Yourself era will blow your mind, the artistry and depth and going throught the Bangtan Universe - Their work which reflects their life, struggles and growth - Checkout the HYYH series and Wings Short Films!