Were the Steelers right in extending Mike Tomlin’s contract?

Joe returns to discuss the new three-year extension for Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin.
The positives of Mike Tomlin as the Steelers head coach far outweigh the negatives, no matter what some fans might say.
Joe also digs into the myths of "inheriting Cowher's players" and how playoff success, or failure, should not be the only benchmark by which the future Hall of Famer is defined.
Questions or Comments?
Call the Steel City Underground Fan Line and have your question played on our podcast! The best questions will be answered in a future episode.
- Dial (203) 900-4SCU (4728) from any number, and leave your name, location, and a question on our automated attendant.
- Text (203) 900-4SCU with your question OR
- Email [e-mail]
Connect:
Facebook - / steelcityunderground
Twitter - / steelcityundrgr
KZbin - / steelcityunderground
Instagram - / steelcityunderground
TikTok - / steelcityunderground
Web - www.steelcityunderground.com/
Shop and Support SCU:
Amazon Prime Store - amzn.to/30owltC
TeePublic Store - www.teepublic.com/stores/stee...
PayPal Donation - bit.ly/3FfGJmn
Subscribe to our podcasts:
Apple Podcasts/iTunes - itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/s...
KZbin Music - • Pittsburgh Steelers Po...
KZbin - / steelcityunderground
TuneIn - tunein.com/radio/Steel-City-Un...
Spreaker - www.spreaker.com/show/2600913
iHeartRadio - www.iheart.com/podcast/steel-...
Spotify - open.spotify.com/show/4Yacx1u...
Deezer - www.deezer.com/show/1439702
Amazon Music - music.amazon.com/podcasts/f22...
Pandora - www.pandora.com/podcast/pitts...

[@krenck61]

Thd good of Mike Tomlin far outweighs the few bad things.

[@RVRTYGRarts]

It's continually entertaining to read comments where fans only know and experienced the "Tomlin years" yet insist the Steelers would be better off without him. The NFL isn't a lottery scratch ticket... there's very little instant gratification. And people today seem to only want what makes them feel satisfaction right flippin now. Extending Tomlin was an intelligent move. The team is transitioning with a new offensive coordinator this year and players have stated they came to play in Pittsburgh because they want to play under Tomlin. 53 men on the roster and all they do is Tomlin's fault would be a great podcast topic for the people complaining about the Steelers coaching.

[@Steelcityunderground]

It's the same thing with trades. "Trade Player X because he sucks and we don't need him, and get a first-round pick." But Team B will give up a first-round pick for the same guy? LOL. What? - Joe

[@SteelersNationAustralia]

Yep Great move so happy for Coach Tomlin

[@thechocolatewriter8680]

Yes Joe

[@jameslee8519]

Joe kuzma for president 😎😎 you are the truth

[@HP3TV]

It was a good decision. Ending a relationship due to feelings usually ends poorly.

[@steelerspittsburgh875]

Steelers are going to the Superbowl 👍

[@StephenFinski-en5pz]

All on board unless one of those new offense guru’s. Now I use to be a big Tomlin hater then I learned more about Steeler team dynamics. For example is OC hirings but I’ve learned some HC don’t have any say he might but idk. Also positions coaches seemed even worse than below avg. I changed my mind when I found out good coaches don’t wanna come to pix cause cheap pay, also always have the least amount of coaches. When we do get great coaches they won’t promote or raise salary can’t rem name right now but I heard everyone in the NFL say he was the best OL coach. My big problem is and same for Cower power is the lack of game planning and adjustments,”predictable offense, coaching for dummies” then hear them say we do what we do. Also same as Cower always play down to competition.

[@bofnation2126]

it tells me we are going to get a deal done with JF, and this is tomlins project, to develop him into a winner.. if he fails they are both gone unfortunately, but this almost guarantees JF will stay and have a stable environment

[@jamy8575]

If a Rooney... I would have waited to see if this QB Shuffle panned out. BEFORE giving Mikey this extension.

[@berniemccluskey8186]

hi mark no comment on tomlin

[@berniemccluskey8186]

sorry heh heh said no comment on tomlin oops I will give you the injury bugs tho

[@berniemccluskey8186]

those teams arent mediocre their just bad jets look good this year tho

[@Steelcityunderground]

How do we know the Jets look good? Rodgers left Green Bay and they went right into the playoffs. I'm not convinced Robert Saleh is a good coach either - yet. If he struggles this year, no doubt he's gone. - Joe

[@berniemccluskey8186]

@@Steelcityunderground I agree about saleh I could be wrong but I thought they had a good free agency/draft maybe shoulda said on paper thanks joe go steelers

[@jamy8575]

Listening to you describe your differentiation of PIT vs "mediocre" others... I applaud your resilience. But; back to brass tacks.... I cannot keep thinking Ben this & that.. I saw a winner (#2) & the franchise opted else wise.. When a franchise does that.... Well -I see rip van winkle time coming. I just see ZERO excuse for this QB swap out.. Mason Rudolph survived the '22 Preseason end around; WAITED all season to get his opportunity to SHINE out... HE does SO & this franchise SHIT down his throat AGAIN... You are riding this ship down into Brownsville with BLIND optimism..

[@Steelcityunderground]

You certainly are putting a lot of words in my mouth. Please tune in more often because you'll realize how much of a Mason Rudolph supporter I am. He's going to ball out in Tennessee when Levis doesn't workout. - Joe

[@berniemccluskey8186]

I dont think they would fire tomlin just dont renew

[@berniemccluskey8186]

before you say anything I was in masons corner from the get go always was I will never forgive tomlin for throwing away 3 games with boobisky then he gets shamed into playing him dont tell he didnt know about mason had him for 6 freakin years he screwed up big time with the Qb situation sorry not a fan never was

[@berniemccluskey8186]

ya raiders ha ha couldnt happen to a nicer team

[@slyke3445]

Only if you're happy with zero playoff wins the last 7 years and only 3 playoff wins in the last 13 years. When we signed Brian Flores I wanted him to take over as head coach the next year, and when that didn't happen I wanted Klint Kubiak from the 49ers

[@RVRTYGRarts]

Flores left of his own accord. He wasn't forced out. And why would Kubiak leave when the Niners are hot?

[@slyke3445]

@@RVRTYGRarts Are you kidding me where did I say Flores was forced out? and your wrong Kubiak already left the hot 49ers to be the Saints O.C. this year, and if the Steelers would have offered him our head coaching job he would have left the 49ers in a second to be a head coach for us or anyone else that offered and make a lot more money

[@Steelcityunderground]

If you've followed the show for a while, I was campaigning for Flores to be Tomlin's replacement. Who's to say that won't happen still? He's only a coordinator, not a head coach elsewhere, and can be poached if need be. - Joe

[@jamy8575]

"Cohones" Would have been resigning Mason Rudolph as QB #1 & NOT another QB #3 card Monti Calling what Tomlin does "Cahones" wielding ....Nah

[@berniemccluskey8186]

ya the cowgirls suck

[@JamesJones-bl3fo]

There's no use everyone bitching about Tomlin getting extended not a damn thing any of you can do about it except find another team

[@stevepickering9697]

He'll no but all you Podcaster are scared to say it.

[@thechocolatewriter8680]

Have you ever considered that maybe all the podcasters just don’t see it the way you do?

[@jameslee8519]

😎💯❤​@@thechocolatewriter8680

[@stevepickering9697]

@thechocolatewriter8680 reality is the guy hasn't even won one playoff game in 8 years. Longest streak in the history of the steelers. That's reality they play those games to get to the superbowl that's everyone's goal. It matters or don't bother playing the games. Maybe not keep score for tomlin.

[@RVRTYGRarts]

​@@stevepickering9697not even close to the longest streak. The Steelers were founded in 1933. And they didn't get anywhere near the playoffs prowess people seem to keep complaining about under Tomlin. Seriously, man. Know facts before starting a debate based on your feelings.

[@jameslee8519]

​@@RVRTYGRartsyep

[@stevepickering9697]

You just went bla bla bla over playoff wins. Lmao like their not playing to get to the superbowl. That may be the most clownish defense of tomlin I have ever seen. Nobody can ever take you seriously that's fanboy stuff on steroids.

[@thechocolatewriter8680]

And yet here you are watching Joe Kuzma on HIS podcast.

[@RVRTYGRarts]

Joe living rent free