Westminster Dog Judge Ranks Top 5 Dogs • Top 5 Beatdown

[@galepark1261]

Ok but shane putting mutts as his number one was so endearing holy shit

[@ikratog8933]

An asexual.

[@emmagrace9561]

Spoiler alert

[@MiklPickle]

@@emmagrace9561 well with a show like this spoilers in the comments are expected...

[@Imsomebodywow]

He is the most controversial yet brave person

[@kimberleytso2715]

Awwww i love this *all dogs*

[@gracie3929]

something about shane's proud smile whenever bill agrees with him or finds something he said charming is sending me

[@CaKoMi]

Shane lights up like a kid, it’s adorable

[@kellydao9532]

The proud teacher’s pet in the most charming way ❤️

[@aurora78]

Yess!! It's so adorable.

[@nmgads]

100% agree! I replayed that part like three times 🙈

[@gracie3929]

@@kellydao9532 it is literally so endearing

[@TwinkCookies]

I love the way Bill talks about the dogs, be it on his list or in Shane's and Ryan's. And the appreciative nods or smiles. This man really loves his dogs

[@megib901]

Right ! He was such a nice guest.

[@DarkestEmpress]

Bill really does love dogs. I have shown to him several times and he's a wonderful judge. Sincerely passionate about what he does. :)

[@tdsims1963]

@@DarkestEmpress What breed do you show? and do you still show? I am curious and I love dogs!

[@DarkestEmpress]

@@tdsims1963 Hi Traci! Due to the coronavirus I haven't gone to as many shows as I would like recently. :( My previous breed was Akitas, but I am in Chihuahuas now! Happy to chat to you about showing, it's a wonderful sport and really brings you closer to your dog. :)

[@izmckenna]

@@DarkestEmpress Chihuahuas are my #1 dog breed!!! Long haired or short?

[@mackharrison1861]

I wanna listen to bill explain the history of every single dog breed I loved this

[@deaddumplings5565]

Honestly 😅😂

[@ThatDudeDeven]

Right?? I easily would've listened to every one. You know he did.

[@j171984]

Totally agree!

[@abigailsalmanac]

Seriously! Get this man his own KZbin channel where he just explains dogs 🥺🥺🥺

[@__DY__]

Kinda reminds me of the program Dogs 101 that went over a whole bunch of breeds with guest commentary. I definitely would be down for a reboot of that show with Bill!

[@Imsomebodywow]

This guest star balances his vast knowledge with his calming, affirming demeanor. I kinda want to talk to him about my workplace drama so he can be like, "exactly; sounds like he's just jealous of your success"

[@deaddumplings5565]

😂😂😂

[@jsgracepark]

Haha very specific

[@jenl7094]

You nailed it. He’s that guy you want around

[@jessica_gerbil]

amazing take, i love it.

[@MagisterialVoyager]

LMFAOOO a mood!!!

[@thursdaysdaughter]

Buzzfeed Unsolved: Ryan is precious and Shane is a monster. All of Watcher: Shane is the most wholesome precious creature and Ryan has been possessed by all of the demons they encountered.

[@preetiphotos2051]

I miss them bro. I luv them in Buzzfeed

[@DawnOldham]

I’m guessing they’re free to be themselves now. The same thing happened when the Try Guys went out on their own from Buzzfeed.

[@ayi1891]

🤣 the accuracy!!!!

[@TheJessicahammerly]

🤣

[@aloenuht.1740]

Ryan unleashed

[@alexsterio8258]

Shane: I like this dog Ryan: no, I like this dog Bill: I just love dogs man

[@heidiallen824]

I haven't even finished this ep but this has got to be my favorite. Bill is so chill compared to our two chaotic hosts and you can tell that he loves dogs so much. As someone who grew up taking in dogs that people couldnt care for and now adopting rescues, I also love Shane's list and his number 1 pick.

[@k80_]

Bill is the heart and soul of this show

[@moonbot7613]

I agree, I have a mixed cattle dog and she’s the best! Also a rescue and I just rescued a Blue Heeler

[@zimmakimma7007]

Fax

[@clayhurley1696]

Anyone else love how Bill tucked his earbuds into his shirt? Very sophisticated.

[@bronco7087]

I KNOW I LOVE HIM SM

[@STSGuitar16]

I appreciated that little detail literally every single time they cut to him lmao

[@zenayla9179]

shane's smile at 7:35 after bill said 'you’re so right' has *made my day*

[@babahu15]

he's a little teachers pet

[@Bdkejdkslkf]

The poodle is “America’s darling.” No, no. Bill is America’s darling. Love him!

[@julie717]

im a bill stan

[@jenl7094]

Yes 1000 times over.

[@loofahsswanson559]

Shane picked the Borzoi because it’s the dog version of himself. You can’t convince me otherwise.

[@enviithechange]

Yes! I agree 100%

[@Zlixlriffs]

This is even better because he said that the Borzoi is the dog that his girlfriend would get

[@uniquereviewshacks2121]

yup

[@loofahsswanson559]

@@Zlixlriffs she has a type lol

[@pretzelpatch]

I think Shane's #1 is also a pretty accurate description of him XD

[@VlogDoPajamas]

Thanks for the mixed breed appreciation Shane, I adopted my boy from a shelter and he's the sweetest 🥺 wouldn't trade him for any other breed

[@philipgallagher69420]

One of my dogs was from a shelter and the other was literally left for dead in the woods and I brought him home and they are the most amazing little creatures ever. Wholeheartedly agree

[@SmartStart24]

Aw same my parents have a Chihuahua/ Jack Russell mix from a shelter, he’s adorbs.

[@kellycornell7510]

I totally agreed with his number 1 choice. I'd rather have a rescue than any other dog. And I find mixed breeds are healthier, less timid and easier to train.

[@Moon-ex1yr]

I got mine from a breeder. Good old mutts. Mutts are so cute, their so well- put together.

[@ChristinaCovers]

Yeaaas! I am very big on the adopt don't shop. Most of the dogs in shelters are mutts and they deserve so much love. I have a lab/hound mix and a lab/shepard mix and they are both the sweetest most loving dogs. Very healthy and very happy.

[@lanakinz]

Give this guy a podcast. I love learning about the history behind dogs! He just has a really chill voice/personality, and you can tell he’s really passionate about what he does.

[@FrostedCanid]

Listen to Pure Dog Talk! It's not his podcast (it's run by Laura Reeves, who breeds German Wirehair Pointers, but she talks about dog breeds a lot and Bill's been interviewed by her several times!

[@jadewolf22]

Every podcast episode: Today we’re talking about [insert breed]. We would like you to know they are the bestest boys and girls and 12/10 should be adopted and loved forever. Thanks, see you next time!

[@pedropinheiro9196]

Shane in other episodes: niche, Midwestern, unknown things Shane in this one: America's favourites

[@nayanahedemark5432]

idk one of his picks was “whatever the fuck my grandparents had” which is the Most niche thing hes said so far lmao

[@jenl7094]

@@nayanahedemark5432 except that those dogs turned out to be Shetland Sheepdogs which Bill said were very popular. The only niche typically Shane pick for me was the Borzoi. Even his description of it made me laugh at what an odd choice it was.

[@lilykep]

Shane your grandparent's collies were trying to herd you. lol

[@aliifahbianca5504]

why does this make so much sense :')

[@boopiedinkus]

this comment made my day HAHAHA

[@Bella-Seasons]

@lilykep My smooth border collie did that with me and my cousins when we were toddlers lol she would pretend to nip at our heals and we would run away screaming. She would herd us in circles 😂

[@freya2294]

shane knowing nothing about dogs but desperately trying to relate is how i feel as a brit everytime they do an american based beatdown list

[@Lazyassindigo]

@@englishatheart I bet English is not their first language and even if it was, you have no business correcting minor grammatical mistakes of strangers on the internet in a superior tone, so how about you take it easy, professor?

[@PorpoiseInATent]

@@Lazyassindigo I think you are right about grammar stuff, but they did say they are british.

[@Lazyassindigo]

@@PorpoiseInATent You're right,I missed that part tbh (but my point is still valid I think).

[@ErinKHayes-un5vl]

@@englishatheart it's youtube, not a college course

[@nfh688jfnie]

@@englishatheart So is "grammar nazi".

[@hoibin8317]

"It looks like someone took a bunch of bones and stitched them together with taffy and then rolled it through the hair of a ghost." - Shane Madej on borzoi (2021)

[@fredmachine6039]

ryan listing mostly small "low to the ground" dogs is unintentionally very funny 😭 he really goes for the dogs he relates to huh

[@lydia.rogers]

I love that Bill isn't at all judgemental about anybody's choices (while Ryan is laughing in the corner).

[@heidic5404]

Bill: the expert who compiled a diverse list with fascinating tidbits backing up his choices. Shane: picked popular choices. Ryan: wants a dog version of himself or one that reminds him of his childhood.

[@ximenakokoro9899]

I work at an emergency vet clinic. Let me say this about labradoodles and golden doodles. They eat EVERYTHING. Rat poison, tampons, chocolate, medicine, underwear, socks, anything and everything. Granted, all dogs do that, but doodles are the worst for it. I remember a call I got and the man said, "Yeah, I think I need to bring my dog in. We think he ate a sock, and he vomited up a sock, but it's a different sock than the one we think he ate."

[@rottnk9527]

I think it has more to do with the lack of experience most doodle owners have and the type of person that is attracted to doodles. The majority of doodle owners are first-time dog owners.

[@ximenakokoro9899]

@@rottnk9527 I would think that, too, but even experienced dog owners have the same issue. We once had a doodle come in, and history on the patient clipboard said that it had come to the clinic three times in as many years for eating things. I'm convinced that doodles somehow get all the happy-go-lucky and loving genes but are completely skipped over for brain cells XD

[@LAWL95]

I just listened to a podcast episode talking about obesity (it ties in trust me). First they talked about how its strategic to be able to eat more after being full and then they talked about a hormone that tells the body that its time to stop eating. They mentioned that Labradors have this and (like the guide dogs) its bred into them because a food motivated dog is easier to train! I can imagine that goldens could have the same problem paired with hyper poodles

[@KL-qp6yo]

Grew up with a poodle. In his life he was known to obsessively eat socks and knee high pantyhose, napkins/kleenex. His most interesting choices: a 20$ bill, and a chocolate covered granola bar in its wrapper. Cool dog for sure.

[@nothingtoseehere5678]

Are you in the SoCal area because we had the EXACT same case a couple years ago. I think it's less the -oodle part and more the lab/g ret in them though.

[@tinahan1244]

now they're legally obligated to do top 5 cats next

[@phamiru]

Yaaaaaaas

[@bethmacisaac1300]

I don’t know if Ryan would allow it lol

[@johanvajse8410]

I'd like to see that to learn 5 breeds of cat. I only know tuxedo & siamese

[@KMivaldi]

@@johanvajse8410 I would enjoy that, too. However Tuxedo’s aren’t a breed, but a coat color/design, much like Calico. Tuxedo’s can be found across all different breeds. Although as a proud Tuxedo owner, I find that they all generally have a similar personality!

[@johanvajse8410]

@@KMivaldi so I really need the show - I only know 1 breed LOL

[@afgrliegrl]

Shane’s #1 pick was so unexpected and heartfelt! Literally made the back of my eyes sting with tears. Love these boys and their wonderful content!

[@IImmy_xx]

Ryan saying that his parents had two dogs called Ricky and Lucy just straight up reminded me that, that could be the origin for Ricky and Lucy Goldworth’s names

[@smellyshart442]

Aww:( he loved those doggies i bet

[@sierramolinary]

i just realized ricky and lucy are from “i love lucy”… good names 😊

[@hanaeyoshida5163]

Omg I love this!!! Let the lore continue

[@notyourlioness1625]

The way Shane basically preens in the light of Bill's approval of his choices gives me so much serotonin

[@breannagraham5831]

It's so cute🥺

[@shawnabasallo7515]

I've never seen this man beam this much

[@dlara18x]

“Whatever kind of Collie my grandparents had.” Best quote of the episode

[@lrose1310]

*Collie

[@dlara18x]

@@lrose1310 thanks

[@dlara18x]

^ that’s not sarcasm btw

[@Memow-pk1ng]

I had collies. when I was a kid They are intelligent, affectionate, beauties, I had to brush them every day, as was one of my chores.

[@brynnp.4953]

YES Shane putting mixed breed dogs as number one. Also, to whoever reads this, this is your PSA to adopt shelter dogs whenever possible.

[@FrostedCanid]

*but not indiscriminately! Adopting is important but lots of times shelter puppies end up given up again when they grow up to not fit into their people's lives!! Purebred dogs give people the option to figure out what dog will do best in their home. Adopting is great, but also a very, very mixed bag so I would really only suggest it to people who have very adaptable lives!

[@anacrea3931]

@@FrostedCanid absolutely. We should all do what suits and wants best, adopt or shop responsibly! If you're buying from a breeder ask for proof of health testing (OFA or pennhip, plus any required genetic testing), if you're rescuing make sure the rescue is open about their dogs needs and past and is covering health care for their dogs (desexing, vaccines, vet check). Not all breeders and not all rescues are doing things right which is why we should always do our research before acquiring an animal.

[@jenl7094]

To add to these comments already here I would just say that instead of adopting a puppy, you could visit the shelter several times and try hanging out with a full grown dog to see if they have the right size and temperament you’re looking for. Most shelters actively encourage this and this was how I found my perfect beautiful buddy of a random mixed breed (he was 2 yo when I adopted him). He was so handsome, sweet and up for any adventure. And he grew to love my husband and then became very protective of our son when he was little. I loved that mutt. My son wants a dog now and we’re going through the process of looking now. So excited to find his perfect buddy!

[@k80_]

@@jenl7094 we adopted our second dog when she was relinquished to a shelter at 2 or 3 years old. We just fell in love with her personality right away. 10 years old now and she shows no signs of stopping!

[@nelsaf365]

All my dogs (4 over 20+ years) have been shelter dogs. Never have we been disappointed with them. However, please do research so that when you fall in love with that pair of eyes set in a furry package you know what you are getting into. If you aren't sure, go home to read up on them and sleep on it. My first dog was part coyote, but she looked quite the heeler breed. My point is don't be surprised by anything and be ready to accept everything that dog is bc they will give back ten-fold. Shane, 🤜 on the mixed breed choice. Ryan, 🤛 on being a mushy dog-lover unafraid to admit dogs melt your heart. Great guest, loved the show!

[@rheanathan4189]

Bill was such a charming guest, every dog was the best dog in Bill's eyes, he had a lovely little fact for all of them, the vibes were so wholesome in this episode

[@yanniesays]

I got teary eyed when Shane mentioned MIXED BREEDS!!! It felt really emotional. 😭 Please adopt! And also I love this guest! Bill is calm and approving and very knowledgeable about his field of expertise. I love that he pushes to research first before choosing a dog breed to have. I love that Shane wants his approval 🤣🤣

[@StutleyConstable]

I know yours is an older comment, but I wanted to chime in. I agree with you. All of my dogs were strays that found their way to me. My first cat was a stray. When he died, I waited for another stray to come along. After two months and no stray came along, I decided to go get a pair of kittens from a shelter. I agree with whoever said, "The best way to honor your pet is to adopt a new pet and give them the love your former pet enjoyed."

[@fourleafclover2064]

I'm glad that Shane put mutts at the top of his list, they have less health problems and need the most adoption

[@jadeykg123]

I love mutts so much. At the start of the video I hoped that they'd be put on someone's list. I currently have 5 rescue mutts and have had quite a few others growing up. They are such good dogs and everyone should give them a chance.

[@ashleyduong9108]

That's so like Shane, too Giving those wonderful creatures the appreciation they deserve

[@bernitajenkins3180]

Exactly. I've adopted two Dachshunds over the years, one a mutt and one pure-bred. I never had to take the mixed breed to the vet. The pure-bred has me hemorrhaging money...allergies, anal-gland infections, arthritis, periodontal disease... 🤪🤯

[@00muinamir]

Unless someone needs a specific breed's characteristics for a task or special circumstance, hitting up the local shelter or rescue group first should be the default.

[@emilyfallaw5912]

I also love mutts.

[@elliannart2681]

Shane's number 1 dog bread being mixed dogs made me so happy because it doesn't matter what type of dog you have as long it is happy and healthy. The are so misunderstood and they usually end up being strays which is so sad. With his choice I felt like he said to not buy our pets but adopt them :)

[@elliannart2681]

@@englishatheart I agree with you but if you ask someone if he wants a specific dog or a mixed he'll chooce the specific one. Some of them will talk shit about the mixed ones, refering them as "dirty strays that only bark and bite for no reason" ( I did a project about it asking people from my town about dogs and you have no idea how many people answered like that) Also Pitbulls are really misunderstood dogs, just because one really aggressive Pitbull once ate a human it doesn't mean that they're all the same

[@juicysatsumabeauty]

Christine C. "most people have mixed breeds" is just factually incorrect.

[@jellybeanslash]

Not Shane putting dalmatians on his list after leaning so hard into the Cruellahead aesthetic. This guy, I swear.

[@Whatareevenbirds]

This made laugh so much omg--

[@bluefox99887]

Thank you for recognizing mutts, Shane! I've worked at an animal shelter and there are so many great mutts in need of homes. They have so much love to give!

[@sammyhoku6773]

I can’t believe I missed this episode when it first dropped!! And even more so because Bill is the breeder my husband and I got our corgi from! 🥰 He’s gonna be 4 this year and he’s been an absolute dream dog for us. We are so thankful for Bill and his team and they are the epitome of ethical breeders. I loved this episode so much. And no matter what kind of dog you are planning to get, PLEASE always do your research and be patient. Your future pupper will thank you. 😊

[@horohorosrin]

Guys, you've outdone yourselves with this one. This was a delight to watch every second of the way. I LOVED listening to Bill talk about these dogs, and I could've just listened to hours of him telling us about dogs with you guys offering little comments here and there. Just A+ fuckin work, lads. Also, rottweilers are best dogs

[@JT-hr6dq]

I grew up with rotties and I agree. Such great nanny dogs. We also had a fantastic bull mastiff.

[@violetskies14]

I love big dogs. I actually trust them more than little dogs (despite having a chihuahua with the sweetest temperament myself) and rotties are one that if I see someone out on the street with one I desperately hope they drag their owner over to meet me.

[@laurenwestover6519]

Bill Shelton talks about dogs a lot actually, seminars etc., and a lot of it is online (though a lot of it is more technical than this).

[@FinnickAnnie]

i really would love them to bring bill back on their podcast

[@nataliethomas444]

I was really hoping that rotties would make somebody’s list

[@samueltambunan2888]

Never expected Shane to be mixed breed activist, some King behavior right there

[@jukkes]

I’m the owner who’s like “you know I’m not really sure what breed he is but he is lovely I love my kid” LMAOO

[@Paige-pk8dr]

I love my dog more then most people. Then again I hate most people so that's not saying a lot

[@Wertsir]

That’s how my mom talks about me too.

[@gracereynolds5389]

God, I'm so glad Shane added the Borzoi to his list, I love those slender-snoot doggos, they always look that they have a secret to share

[@DudeWheresMyApple]

I love how Bill's response to everything Shane and Ryan say is "lovely dog". All dogs truly are the best dogs

[@Zlixlriffs]

Bill adds so much more to this video than most experts do in other top 5 beatdowns mostly because Shane and Ryan are so out of their depths in this topic

[@EarthCybebe]

Shane muting Ryan to let Bill talk was the power play of the century

[@tiredhoneybadger1916]

I do genuinely appreciate Shane have mixed breeds as his number one. Mixed breed dogs are wonderful and unique but don't always receive the same adoration as purebreds. Especially since we need more dogs to be rescued from shelters, versus bought.

[@dotdotdot...176]

For a cat person/someone who never owned a dog of his own, Shane has some great insights into dogs breeds and temperaments. I also love that he put mixed breeds as his number one, because I really do think that some of the sweetest memories we have involve those mixed breed dogs pick up at shelters or find on the street or adopt. We can never tell what dog breeds are mixed in but it doesn't matter because the dog is the sweetest thing.

[@Mariana-sy3dc]

I thought Bill was the stock image man who is always smiling but kinda suffering for a sec. They are both amazing, love them both

[@aerocarnie]

Shane: "My girlfriend loves Borzois" I immediately thought of some of Sara Rubin's lovely drawings that have featured Borzois when he said this.

[@vsratoslava]

Same

[@everyoneandnoone3156]

I want Bill to sit me down and teach me about dogs for hours. You can tell he has the patience of a long time dog trainer, which is important if you're going to teach me anything.

[@danielleeriksson7065]

Same 😂

[@theWeaverofTales]

Every time Bill hears a dog mentioned and goes "Oh I love these dogs" 😭 He really appreciates all of them

[@alyssa5604]

Shane’s reaction to Borzoi’s hunting wolves is priceless

[@V.R.CoryArt]

Shane's #2 pick being "Whatever kind of collie my grandparents had" and the exact emphatic delivery sent me!

[@sofiastj]

Bill: *explains why dogs are the way they are* Ryan: "I just think they're neat"

[@msfeverblister]

Also Shane’s No 1 number brings tears to my eyes. Sometimes the amount of heart he shows is overwhelming and refreshingly human.

[@vsratoslava]

YES!!! The whole time I was like “please someone mention that there are also mixed breeds who need families” and there he goes🥺🥺🥺

[@MultiTimetravler]

I would love a show just called ask the expert. where ryan and shane just ask clueless questions to an expert that plays it straight. Like this or the bird ep. they did

[@ssilva2439]

This!!!!!

[@kpeterson9455]

There’s a podcast where a lady does that and it’s called Ologies!! She has a different expert each week :)

[@lilacbombs_5197]

bill was such a wonderful guest, he took all of shane and ryan's enthusiasm and jokes in stride. I think when someone's an expert on something there's a need to take it really seriously, but he was such a good sport

[@Tiff_lifts_alot]

Bill is knowledgeable without being stuck up. He's not judgmental, and it seems like he appreciates all pups equally. You chose a great guest/expert!🎉

[@JeremyPulumbarit]

SPOILER ALERT Shane's number one is Oatmeal.

[@genkikai1]

Haha

[@azizabrown]

😂

[@bbd121]

And everything else are Reese's.

[@s-kim10]

This made me laugh so hard

[@ahorserunning]

im still pissed

[@grimeydanny4214]

"I could tell by the way you spoke that you didnt have a clue" bill's sounding like my professors

[@samanthaa_32]

predictions: Shane puts a cat on his list somehow, Ryan has dachshunds as #1

[@teenujoseph8797]

Your Ryan prediction came out yo be true!

[@JoshuaLasimMusic]

Ryan prediction is on point

[@caseyhaggerty4089]

YOU WERE RIGHT

[@ashleyduong9108]

Haven't gotten to that but WHAT

[@catzalotATJ]

Idk why people think shane's lists are so zany. Ryan puts shit on his lists that only people from LA would put, but he doesn't get reemed in the comments constantly.

[@boxlunches]

Amazing guest, LOVED listening to all his insights on every dog that came up. And can I just say, I love that Ryan and Shane are the sort of hosts who actually let their guests talk at length about what they know and what they're passionate about rather than steamroll over them or cut them off. Very pleasant video.

[@thelegoofawesome]

Honestly I absolutely love these videos where there's a very respectful dialogue going both ways between laymen and experts, it's just delightful seeing Bill enjoy talking about these dogs and responding to Ryan and Shane's insights

[@natattack1235]

shane, the cat person: i guess dogs are okay

[@Lazamattaz]

Most cat people are like that

[@Marzi29]

In my experience most cat people still like dogs or think they're okay. Whilst dog people can be dramatic and think cats are the spawn of satan or something. And if you say you don't like cats, people seem to understand... but if you say you don't like dogs, somehow you're evil. Like lay off, it's all just personal preference. I'd just rather not be around dogs, they scare me.

[@mothy6738]

shane’s wholesome admiration of bill and his excitement when bill recognizes what he says keeps me going

[@coppurrtings]

Wholesome

[@ashleyduong9108]

He truly is an expert, and a professional. He patiently answers questions and validated Shane's number one, he was great!

[@leightaylor6767]

I know the series is "Top 5," but I'd be happy to see part 2 of this episode and get their #6 - 10 dogs! Bill was a delight, I'd love to see him again.

[@nataliethomas444]

^

[@nicolepittman9660]

Growing up I always watched the Westminster Dog Show, everyone else in the house would complain that it was boring, but I really did love watching all these beautiful dogs prancing around looking so regal and proud, and getting to learn about breeds i had never heard of was, to me,exciting! This gave me all those warm fuzzy feelings of my childhood, love it🧡

[@cthulhucult3230]

Dog shows are just about the only thing my dog will watch on TV.

[@lillykeim6741]

Shane’s innocent and American nostalgia list this episode really gave me joy; his smile was so pure.

[@gleekoo8]

bill seems like such a chill dude, he genuinely gives them feedback, laughs with them and is having a great time 100/10

[@alyssabrown5480]

Bill's dog history knowledge was so interesting! I also appreciated his comments about doing research before buying a dog, it's so important and so many people don't do it.

[@rosscalhoun3389]

Unlike every other episode, this one had no arguing or shaming for opinions. This is because all dog breeds are good boys/girls. Edit: I spoke too soon. Ryan shames Shane for liking mutts.

[@danibogle6466]

Agreed! Tbh this was the most wholesome episode yet

[@AngryBerb]

​@@KatarinaTVD Yeah, it's kind of like the "D. All of the above" answer on a multiple choice question. It's valid but still kind of a copout choice. And if we're playing by those rules, I'd argue that rescued dogs are the best dogs.

[@jadewolf22]

Already loved Bill but him appreciating Shane’s top pick of mutts and acknowledging plenty of breeders create unhealthy dogs is lovely to see in such a prominent show/breeding dog person

[@mooklz]

the genuine feedback from bill and the overall wholesomeness has made this ep *chef's kiss*

[@kamilucredic]

This just made me realize that no one used their chef's kiss here 😢

[@alfiefry1769]

"That scrappy dog u see jump off a train" Shane is so classic ha ha

[@andrewmonster9985]

This video could have just been called bill teaches ryan and shane about there favourite dog breeds

[@Jaybee_89]

I feel the boys really had to be on their best behavior for this one bc Bill was just so chill and cordial. What a delight

[@ejune0381]

I love that Shane mentioned the mutt. Because I rescued 2, 6 week old "mutts" and gave one to my aunt and I kept the other. My monkey is my baby and I love her with a passion. A observation I found with Ryan he loves them short dogos.

[@jane.s4052]

My mom wrote a book related to whippets so it brought me so much joy seeing that they were in second with the Westminster judge.

[@otdtyh]

The lion and the marmoset. I’m dying. Ryan’s face. “That’s not a fact.” 😂

[@juliagee8896]

Loved Bill! It's awesome to hear someone talking about ethical breeders and purpose bred dogs. I wish they'd let Bill talk more about what makes a breeder ethical and all the work that goes in to good breeding, because so many people have no idea and lump all breeders together

[@Bxr12]

“Never has the gulf of expertise felt so wide” as they’ve had a renowned LA top Michelin chef and restauranteur on their show - twice.

[@_Moe]

I think Shane meant expertise/knowledge about the topic of debate. With Jon Yao they were talking about fast food and cereal, two things Shane and Ryan know about, not Michelin Star restaurants, cooking techniques, and quality ingredients. This might've been relevant if they were, like, debating about cartoon dog characters (Scooby-Doo, Dodger, Tod, etc.) and not the actual breeds.

[@honestlynotsponsored]

I LOVE this panelist so much! He is so knowledgable and educates about every single breed mentioned. He isn't condescending despite the differences in expertise between him, Ryan, and Shane. He's just a very pleasant man, and seeing him in his element was a really fantastic experience

[@alyssahope8156]

I love when they have really lovely experts on the channel. He sounds so passionate about dogs and was so respectful about all the picks. Go Bill, love him.

[@theWeaverofTales]

The nerve-racking countdown music at the start while he's just pleasantly explaining his dog experience lol

[@vinxy3752]

Bill was easily my most favorite guest they’ve had on this show so far. he is so respectful

[@N0T_.1VA._]

I cant be the only cat person here learning about some dogs

[@danielcasco4124]

of course not, thats exactly what shane is doing this whole video

[@Monkimode]

I'm a dog person learning about some dogs

[@Cove_Blue]

Yep. You're the only one

[@AngryRockMan]

Cats>>>Dogs but this was a fun episode and it was cool learning things about dogs. And Shane's picks are great

[@jdhuh1]

@Shaow_gaming 209, cat person here as well. We do have a dog though, but that's our dad's dog.

[@kookycrypt]

Big respect to Shane for putting the mixed breed dog on there. Mutts were what I've had my whole life until my family rescued a doxie from a puppy mill. After you get a dachshund you never really go back, so I'll probably have doxies the rest of my life but they're always going to be rescues!

[@smellyshart442]

🌭 🥰💕

[@Waskickedfromconspiracyclub]

I love how Shane’s first three were these fancy, weird-ish (but in a good way) big dogs and Ryan’s first three were just average, lovable dogs that everyone knows 😂

[@hypotheticalforest]

Glad to see that we’re continuing to see the trend of the guest having the most educated and experienced list while Shane picks the most unsettling and obscure options and Ryan picks the most basic 😂

[@melissamartinezhernandez278]

Bill is now one of my favorite human being. He truly love dogs, not only the most "sophisticated" like most people in that business

[@Khryztine]

He said, they’re like the lays potato chip of dogs 😂 damn.

[@KaiasDogMom]

Right? I had to cuddle my golden and tell her she’s more special than lays. 😂

[@heyryanisonx3141]

They're the McDonald's of dogs

[@sweetlorikeet]

Bill was such a great guest for this, what a great guy. Really brought a lot of knowledge but also his love for these dogs just shone right on through.

[@hypotheticalforest]

When I was growing up, my neighbors had two poodles. They semi regularly colored their fur (safely of course❤️) a pastel pink and blue. They were named Cotton and Candy respectively.

[@frankensteinlives]

Bill Shelton made this episode for me, his expertise and humor was the perfect contrast to the Ghoul Boys

[@minaraja1977]

Why did i think they were going to list specific famous dogs instead of dog breeds-

[@satinsleeves]

NO BC I LITERALLY THOUGHT THE SAME--

[@maryraja7738]

T Fooled by title

[@johanvajse8410]

Shane did mention Beethoven

[@Travel_with_Gigi]

"Whatever kind of collie my grand parents had" love that for Shane

[@mikaelalucido]

This was my favourite episode of Top 5 Beatdown! Bill really vibed off both of you in tandem and was so genuine and clearly (com)passionate about all the dog breeds. I learned a lot and will now go give my dog a big hug :')

[@meghasinghania1]

What breed is your pup?? How old and is it a girl or a boy??

[@katjawahlberg5634]

Love how Shane is looking stuff up on his phone while the others are talking

[@lillymae5372]

I know Shane is trying to be controversial but I genuinely was starting to get sad bc one of my two boys is a mystery mix and while I love all dogs and appreciate the breeds they were talking about I was sad about the lack of representation for my sweet Mulder as he laid with his head in my lap. Then Shane came to the rescue.

[@victorialobato3652]

Bill is a true PROFESSIONAL, mans really knows what he‘s talking about

[@victoriaschmitz4039]

every episode Shane’s list is PERFECT

[@UltimateKyuubiFox]

Except Pixar. Cars should not be on anyone’s top 5, sorry, lmao.

[@preetiphotos2051]

@@UltimateKyuubiFox I don't like the Cars as much as the others

[@cbjgirl23]

i watched the candy bar episode, his list was almost all one brand

[@ispellitjustg]

Whenever I see dogs in life or on a screen, I always say "hi puppy" kept doing that while watching. It's involutary at this point

[@tiffelou]

I could listen to Bill talk about dogs for hours! What an awesome guy :)