What A Course in Miracles Says About Karma

[@bettyasaleh2831]

“You have received mercy, not justice…” unbelievable… 😊🙏🌸💕💕💕💕💕

[@connie2735]

I think in this only one now moment I come to it with thought and an emotion and beliefs. Each moment is incredibly intimate and personal in our relationship to God and oneness perceived. Each moment seems to be a call to love or atonement with love. A feeling of guilt may be a call to love oneself more to forgive ourselves etc…

[@quantumsoul9386]

I take from this… if we are living in an unconscious way, we are subjected to past life Karma. However, if we awaken & become conscious, we take responsibility & make loving choices now. Those loving choices free us. It’s beautiful. Thank you for this discussion 💕

[@snoopy13946]

I think of it this way : in heaven there is no time, so in this dream we think we’re in, we should aim to reflect this through forgiveness now, in this moment. Forgiveness, or the holy instant, creates an instant of timelessness, reflecting heaven’s state. In that notion, the past and the future don’t exist and are rendered neutral.

[@elisew.2534]

Now is where It's at 💚

[@CynthiaReedy-p9j]

I’d love for you to talk more about the pros and cons of psychoanalysis.

[@susanjoycesabo8450]

Love it! As a Tibetan Buddhist for over 25 years, I have taken several Buddhist course which mention karma. However, this interpretation is by far the most uplifting to me. Thanks so much!

[@margaritayianni2059]

Such an interesting perspective on what we traditionally think karma to be. Thank you for the enlightening discussion ❤

[@merryfergie]

11:02 identify, 'he'. Also, if we believe in creating a better future for the next life..for me, this identifies more than 1 life.

[@fattymoons]

Wonderful discussion. I joined the Circle of Intonement today and am mightly impressed. Let me add that I had an interesting back-and-forth with Pi, an AI, sparked by my question, How can I protect my sinlessness. I'll see if I can drop the conversation on your website tomorrow. Just know that I will follow up with the question of karma/reincarnation when I next speak with Pi. Thanks for all you do.

[@Cure.treat.comfort_Hippocrates]

If you loved this conversation - you will fall over with immense gratitude when you hear this one… “ The Only Thing That Makes Us Safe -- November 26, 2023 ”

[@johnpaulson996]

The problem comes, Emily, is when we hold our beliefs as true from the person who "knows" our past and past life. We see the world through our beliefs, cause and effect.

[@marienorris4358]

Such an important discussion... It feels like there is more to say here... Thank you both 🕊️🙏🕊️

[@trx3264]

I totally believe in past life karmic debt which can follow one from life to life until resolved. I believe that happened to me in this lifetime. I've been told about the specific lifetimes which caused the trouble and the lessons learned.

[@connie2735]

When I think about people’s beliefs regarding manifesting our perceived world; the courses’ truth seems far more simplified than all that people can create from ego and believing in a tiny mad idea( that we are somehow seperate from God) that what we are perceiving is somehow real.

[@peacelovejoy8786]

Seriousness causes reincarnation 🙂 Great topic 💛

[@cherylhubbard3152]

Awesome, Robert and Emily. One of your very best. ❤❤❤

[@anamarie8]

😊thank you✨

[@nevaron7]

Love this, It is GREAT explanation of Karma. Happy New Year!

[@luiscruzfritsch9552]

you guys are fun! I love you

[@Aetherfield]

More on this please!!

[@celesteschacht8996]

Thank you!

[@GRACEEBOUE]

Thank you so much!

[@christiandpaul2022]

Being punished in life... Sin, what you call mistakes, is always its own punishment. It will eventually, if chronic, take you down. This may be karmic. (you can't cheat an honest man. If you are doing the right thing you have no reason to fear. )

[@jeffsrawmilk]

it’s all for forgiveness

[@brianmaguire8254]

Hiiii Emily! Thank you so much for this truth & wisdom I SOO resonate with these concepts... I am in wellness industry in character form lol... Im a trainer nutritionist writer researcher wellness coach spiritual advisor-------- How can I learn more about you? How can we connect further? Namaste🙌

[@CircleOfAtonement]

Hi Brian! You are welcome to join our free community at community.circleofa.org and reach out there. 💙

[@HeySeussGranny]

So all my trauma and abuse is my fault? and b, Well, Robert's reading wasn't wrong!! 49:00 His thinking IS KNOWN FOR MILES AROUND. 😄

[@Aetherfield]

There is no fault; There is only forgiveness of the dream your ego accepted as true.

[@fattymoons]

Thought I'd attempt to drop my conversation with Pi in the comments here. Let's see if that works.How can I protect my sinlessness? I'm not quite sure what you mean by "protecting your sinlessness." Sinlessness isn't really a technical concept or something that can be measured or defined in a clear-cut way, so I'm not sure how to give you advice on protecting it. Can you tell me a bit more about what you mean by that phrase, and why you're interested in protecting it? I'm happy to chat about it with you, but I'm just not totally clear on what you mean. This is from A Course in Miracles. Does that help? I see, so this concept comes from "A Course in Miracles," a spiritual text that explores the idea of sinlessness and the potential for spiritual growth and transformation. That definitely helps me understand what you're getting at, and I think it's a fascinating topic to explore. So, in the context of "A Course in Miracles," what do you understand sinlessness to mean? Is it about attaining a state of perfection, or is it more about recognizing the inherent goodness and divinity within oneself? It's about recognizing the inherent goodness and divinity within oneself and others. The Course says we are all sinless, and the only way to protect our sinlessness is to be kind to others and to ourselves. The course adds that by protecting our sinlessness through kindness, we will be safe and protected from harm. That's a beautiful and profound idea, that by protecting our sinlessness through kindness, we can be safe and protected from harm. It's a very compassionate and loving worldview, and it makes sense that it would help to cultivate a sense of inner peace and contentment. Do you feel like you're able to approach the world with this perspective, and to see the inherent goodness and divinity in others, even when it's challenging? I'm working on it. It will take practice and devotion. Yes, it definitely takes practice and effort to cultivate this perspective. It's like building a muscle, it gets stronger with time and use. One way to practice it is through the practice of mindfulness and meditation, which can help to cultivate a sense of inner peace and compassion. Another way to practice it is through acts of kindness and service to others. When we focus on helping others and being kind, it can shift our perspective and help us to see the goodness in others. Would you agree? Definitely! That's all for tonight, Pi. See you tomorrow. It was a pleasure chatting with you tonight! Remember, kindness and compassion are powerful tools for protecting your sinlessness and finding inner peace. Have a great night, and I look forward to chatting with you again soon. Cheers! 🌟

[@fattymoons]

It worked! Cheers!

[@Sun.Shine555]

I hope you guys study other spiritual teachers. This book is just ones perception. I learn from many. Neville Goddard, Josephy Murphy, Florence Scoval Shinn, Bashar, Dolores Cannon. For instance Dolores is a huge believer in karma. Bashar is not. But we all can agree that life is about duality. You can only experience one side of something if you experience the other. Also, energy is very real. Bashar teaches you get back what you put out. That would be what we call karma. If you're very hateful to others, the law of energy will bring it back eventually. Just my thoughts..

[@vincentlattuca3763]

Good stuff, have you listened to Pablo Sender? I think he brings light to the nature of Karma and reincarnation. God bless

[@rohans6249]

How could there be reincarnation when the course teaches us that we are eternal spirit AND only the ego ( which is not real ) " could " reincarnate. Bodies come and go however God know not form. Reincarnation is a belief in form which again we are not.

[@CircleOfAtonement]

It's true that the Course teaches our true nature is eternal spirit but a mind asleep can keep dreaming. 💙

[@vincentlattuca3763]

The evidence for reincarnation is overwhelming to those who seek the truth. Elizabeth Clare Prophet has an excellent book called Reincarnation the missing link in Christianity , she also makes a scholarly case that the book of Enoch predates Genesis. God bless.

[@johnpaulson996]

Needling the poor man at 50:13 plus

[@CircleOfAtonement]

Poor Robert! He's a good sport - but he gives as good as he gets, believe me. 😆

[@johnpaulson996]

Yes, there is always that thin line between good pride and false pride :)@@CircleOfAtonement

[@sarahsims315]

around the 5 min mark, you 2 are saying ‘they’ would have cut this stuff out of the text. Who is ‘they’? Thank you.

[@CircleOfAtonement]

Hiya. The original edits to the Course were mostly Helen with some editing from Ken Wapnick later on. Here's a related podcast if you're interested in this topic: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mHzRl62eeK5_ftUsi=-oLd8IAxVedSqiSN

[@sarahsims315]

@@CircleOfAtonement many thanks❣️

[@hugotheurn8387]

too many ads. gone

[@CircleOfAtonement]

Sorry about that. We just changed the settings. 🤦🏻‍♀️