What are Classes?

[@ssingha2071]

Wah, gave me clarity, keep it coming 👍👍👍

[@ghazanhussain2070]

You have truly raised the intellectual level of this nation. Love you sir ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@afaq216]

I've many ideological differences with this man, but I've also learned a lot from him۔

[@AkNeedMoreWisdom.]

Respected comrade free of cost you are giving such a knowledge to everyone bundle of thanks for increasing our knowledge. From Balochistan ❤

[@AliButt-xj9kp]

So much good Dr sb

[@VYDEO]

Marvelous video ❤

[@Taimur_Laal]

Thanks 🤗

[@shoutforit]

Zabardest

[@funwithlipi1144]

आपने बहुत से लोगों का घमंड दूर कर दिया यहाँ भारत में अब भी बहुत सारे लोग अपने को बड़ी जात वच्छोटी जाति में बांटे हैं और घमंड में भूले हैं इस लिए यहाँ कहावत है नंगे नबाव किले पर झंडा

[@sajjadashraf324]

Dr. Sahib your view of migration of indus Valley people towards South India is true but now it has been established that they were not forced by Arian for migration, rather it was drought which forced them to abandon the cities.

[@shahidbaloch4987]

Good 👍

[@SaifAli-ng7xh]

Very basic lecture. 😊

[@sajjadashraf324]

Dr. Sahib as per a High Court decision announced around 1938 Jats are also Shudras. Hence your views that Shudras cannot own land needs to be reviewed.

[@Taimur_Laal]

Glad to hear of this decision but it is in 1938, whereas I am talking about earlier periods.

[@alvinrock7190]

❤❤❤

[@shoaibned]

why you delete part 2 video related to pakistan class system? are you afraid from someone?

[@MuhammadIlyas-eg9is]

Sir wealth waqii theek thak hai😂😂?

[@SaifAli-ng7xh]

What an argument, uk has the same division of wealth. It automatically comes into being over centuries.

[@Bilal-qy2sb]

Dr sb a Gift of God for Pakistan

[@SaifAli-ng7xh]

Lol

[@yasirism4953]

Mein phatti hoi dhoti pehenta hon !!

[@muhammadahmedshakeel7297]

Urdu mai Darjabandi kehtay hain, itna kyon ghuma raha hai

[@fidahussain-qd3ol]

Cast system main reson h poverty ke pakistan me kam krny waly ko kami hari mean neach zat or jo badmash chor ha wo chudary wadera bana hua h pakistan me 95% bri poston pe yh wadery chudarg he kabiz hn jo yh kabi ni chaean gy k dusara banda b uper ay jab tak yh cast system khtam ni hota mulk taraqi ni kr sakta

[@ibratnak]

Btw Abrar-ul-Haq, Ataullah Esakhelvi et al. are mascots of PTI, the biggest burger party of Pakistan.

[@shoutforit]

So it means 70% Pakistanis are burger class? I must be really misinformed

[@ibratnak]

@@shoutforit 93.76% of Pakistanis are PTI supporters. Please don't misquote percentages like a bootlicker.

[@shoutforit]

@ibratnak 93.76!!! Where the f-u-c-k you got this figure from?? BTW, us overseas Pakistanis don't lick the boot. It's otherway round, actually. We make the boot, and the feudal Lords beg for remittance.

[@ibratnak]

​@@shoutforiti was being sarcastic. 8% Pakistanis voted for PTI in 2018. Most Pakistanis don't even care about politics.

[@shoutforit]

@ibratnak Sorry, my bad, I didn't get it earlier. 😅

[@ibratnak]

From what I understand, Vaishyas/Baniyas are the biggest owners of tangible wealth, not Brahmins: 1. Brahmins (Fazlur Rehman): This is the highest varna, traditionally associated with priests, scholars, and teachers. Brahmins are believed to have originated from the head of the deity and are considered responsible for the spiritual and intellectual guidance of society. 2. Kshatriyas (Imran Khan): The Kshatriyas are the warrior and ruling class. They are associated with governance, administration, and defense. Kshatriyas are believed to have originated from the arms of the deity and are responsible for protecting society. 3. Vaishyas (Malik Riaz): Vaishyas are associated with business, trade, and agriculture. They are traditionally engaged in farming, commerce, and entrepreneurship. Vaishyas are believed to have originated from the thighs of the deity and are responsible for economic activities. 4.Shudras (us): The Shudras are the laboring class and are associated with manual labor and service occupations. They are believed to have originated from the feet of the deity and provide services to the other varnas.

[@Taimur_Laal]

Can you provide evidence for this claim: "Vaishyas/Baniyas are the biggest owners of tangible wealth, not Brahmins"

[@ibratnak]

​@@Taimur_Laal Priests are theoretically less wealthy than traders/landowners. ChatGPT agrees, but on a cursory Google search I found mixed evidence.

[@ibratnak]

@@Taimur_Laal Damodaran, H. (2008). Banias and Beyond: The Dynamics of Caste and Big Business in Modern India (No. 08-04). CASI Working Paper Series.

[@ibratnak]

@@Taimur_Laal Can't paste link but google economist article "Why Brahmins lead Western firms but rarely Indian ones"

[@ibratnak]

@@Taimur_Laal Ambani & Adani, richest Indians, are baniyas (vaishya).

[@SaifAli-ng7xh]

Entirely bakwas argument

[@mohammadharisfahim6614]

Why you deleted the video on rich businessmen of Pakistan?

[@bananaclub69]

Class is determined by a person's relationship to the means of production I.e owner of the means of production being the capitalist.