What are Pakistan's successes and failures? Is it on a course of self-destruction?

Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed is a well-known Swedish scholar of Pakistani background. He laments that Pakistan is on a course of self-destruction. Its education system has no room for critical thinking. Instead of enlightenment, it is geared towards indoctrination. It neglects science and technology, placing too much emphasis on religion. Its social sciences and in particular historiography are based on self-righteousness. For example, Jinnah is portrayed as an infallible leaders who could not do anything wrong.
You cannot achieve anything without the ability to think critically. The Pakistani mind has been put in prison. Pakistani social scientists and historians have an infantile attitude towards knowledge. He says that the creation of Pakistan benefited landowners and that it was meant to be a military state. Pakistan can become a prosperous country by changing the course of its foreign policy. It needs to have good relations with all its neighbors.
Born in Lahore on February 24, 1947, he holds a PhD in political science from Stockholm University. He is Professor Emeritus of Political Science at Stockholm University. He is also Honorary Senior Fellow of the Institute of South Asian Studies at the National University of Singapore. He was a Visiting Research Professor at the Institute of South Asian Studies (ISAS), National University of Singapore, one of the finest universities in the world, and at the South Asian Studies Program, National University of Singapore from June 2007 to June 2010. He is member of the editorial advisory boards of "Asian Ethnicity"; "Journal of Punjab Studies"; "IPRI Journal, Islamabad"; and "PIPS Research Journal of Conflict and Peace Studies, Islamabad".
He received his doctorate from the University of Stockholm in 1986, where he taught a range of courses from the basic to the doctoral levels. Besides teaching mainstream subjects such as political theory he also lectured and wrote on the politics of South Asia (mainly Pakistan and India, but also Bangladesh and Sri Lanka), political Islam in various contexts and in world politics, human rights, multiculturalism and on ethnicity, identity and nationalism.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The host, Shakil Chaudhary, is an alumnus of Government College, Lahore. Subsequently, he studied international relations in Islamabad and media in London. He has has worked for several English-language newspapers. He has written a critically acclaimed book, Handbook of Functional English (Ferozsons), to help those who wish to improve their English skills. If you want to see his most popular videos, here are the links to them.
• Shahid Siddiqui: The p...
• Muslims started the 19...
You are welcome to follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
/ shakil.chaudary
/ shakchaudhary

[@ShakilChaudhary]

Dear Friends, I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. If you like my videos, share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel. If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them. kzbin.info/www/bejne/noOnmnibbpWtbLs kzbin.info/www/bejne/qaKreICef9CsncU You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter. facebook.com/shakil.chaudary twitter.com/ShakChaudhary

[@shreyanshgupta7648]

🙏what is hidutava forceses ??? Please jara bataya.aapky program may isko baar baar kaha jata. 🙏

[@shreyanshgupta7648]

@beautiful Woman Bilkul Sahi. 👍

[@harshbhartia5052]

yes TIFR and IISC banglore along with 1st generation IIT and IISER are really good in science and technology.

[@thebharat6118]

U r really concerned for Pakistan, Sir. But u may be called as gaddar because truth is unacapatable there.

[@AmitKumar-kr1jz]

What are islamic force?? Well Shakil's full name says about it , itself .

[@mohsinafzaal7550]

Excellent conversation…..we must face the facts, take responsibility of our mistakes and learn from them and move on….it is always a pleasure to listen to both of you….❤️

[@nileshnarkhede3004]

Mohsin but will Pakistanis implement what you say?

[@shivakaramadi9444]

Shakil Sir, I want make one correction about # Indian PhDs. There are even more number of Indians who do PhD in USA. Indians who do PhDs in USA are not US citizens before PhD but most of them take USA citizenship after successfully completing their PhD.

[@surudog4929]

Prof Ahmed is one of the few Pakistani who has clarity of thought and explains things with data. I wish Pakistani leaders listen to him and fix the country’s issues. When will the people like him be listened.

[@humanityfirst3012]

The illiterate love to listen the romantic stories by Tariq jamil and Mufty Tariq Masoud,the rich mullas .It is no use casting pearls before a swine.

[@sanjeevsood531]

When Dr Ahmed talks of problems being faced by Pakistan, particularly in the field of education; he should also consider another aspect. Problems being faced by Pakistan in the field of education are also being faced by nearly all the Islamic countries. The Islamic countries having oil wealth have been able to surmount them (in a manner of speaking) using the money that they have. Dr Ahmed has done a very objective analysis. He should consider doing another program with the same anchor and critically examine the larger question that why are Islamic countries facing problems in the field of education. Mr Shakil Chaudhary could expand the scope of the discussion by including a suitable person from India and also examine the fact as to why are the Muslims in India not doing as well in the field of Education as rest of the Indians. The appeal to use civilized language is appreciated and endorsed.

[@shahryarkhan159]

A very nice, informatory interview.I must praise the knowledge of the interviewer also.

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

Modi Govt has launched New Education policy with inputs from stake holders and experts, policy reforms and assistance to key sectors to promote manufacturing and 1.3 trillion USD investment in infrastructure development and digitization of country are key factors to push India to become 3rd largest economy in 2030. People of India are aware of preserving of secular values to maintain a normal and progressive nation. Thanks both for nice discussion. We learn a lot from both of you.

[@dipakpatnaik6662]

Thanks for inviting Prof. Istiaq, a true intellectual and researcher, as it is always a pleasure to listen to him. Hindutva forces and their anti muslim activities as normally referred to, does not exist on ground. Modiji never discriminates citizens on the basis of caste, religion and treats everyone equal. Propandists raise these issues for political mileage. Being a common indian , I have never seen any muslim being discriminated in the society. Rather, some muslim politicians create false narratives and are biased.

[@satyendrapandey7672]

True, you are right Mr. Deepak.

[@mirmir7869]

Al you need to do is look at the state of kashmir and the freedom and free will there so stop tring to pain a picture perfect india and yes I am a Kashmeeri who is absolutely fed up with two bully boys on both side and let’s look at what Punjab is going through and what you lot did there also let’s look at babaerie masjid there I spouse it was the love that destroyed a building no hatred there towards Muslims so stop talking a load - - - -

[@donboscow9291]

@@mirmir7869 Before talking about Babri Masjid, remember what you peacefuls have done in India for 1000 years, how many Hindu and Buddhist temples you have destroyed, what you did to Nalanda, Vikramashila and Odantapuri, what you did to Somenath 17 times, what you did to Guru Teg Bahadur and Guru Arjan Dev. And remember what you did to Kashmiri Pandits - who were totally innocent an dharmless. Babri is just the beginning. Boshut hissab chukana baki hai. Sab ka badla liya jayega...

[@XoPlanetI]

@@mirmir7869 where were you when your brothers expelled Pandits from the Kashmir valley

[@XoPlanetI]

Any Bangladeshis watching this,the freedom that you got in 1971 is the reason why you are doing well.. keep it up

[@dhruvnarayan8169]

India started with Mahatma Gandhi's twin principles of Truth and Non Violence. This is the basic difference between India and Pakistan.

[@vamsikrishna3855]

And it was our undoing

[@shubhendhujyotishi1782]

Leave talim sahab now taliban will come..they will teach you science very well...

[@sureshrai1248]

Agreed !

[@whiteholeeducationcenter]

Yeah, just like they teach lndian a lesson in Afghanistan

[@baleshwarnathsharma]

@@whiteholeeducationcenter Game has just started bhai, just wait and watch.

[@sureshrai1248]

@@whiteholeeducationcenter India has won the Goodwill of Afghan people. Rest see for yourself as days unfold.

[@ashishpradhan4029]

Bro these intelltual are good not bad

[@MunawarAzaad2025]

Sir this is very much incredible and it must be repeated always the important revelations about Kashmir and all the issues regarding state policies so that the new generation knows about these truths whenever they watch any of your programs. Hats off Sir

[@subratamallick9353]

Mr Shakil Chaudhary, thanks for inviting a great intellectual Prof Ishtiaq Ahmed. I always love to hear from him.

[@maniras6634]

Good analysis, just keep on touching current issues in your programs, will increase your viewership.

[@virendraSingh-je3sx]

Thank you Chaudhary Sahib for inviting Prof. Ahmed and enlightening us with his knowledge and truth about history and politics in the region.

[@ramakrishnagorty9165]

IISC Bangalore has been ranked as world no 1 in research institutions..beating even the US institutions like MIT.

[@whiteholeeducationcenter]

🤣🤣🤣

[@pradyumnakumarnayak9384]

Future of Pakistan is very bleak.

[@rajendragujjar3045]

Shakil Sir... You are doing a great job... and Ishtiaq Ahmed is a great learned person... I have not seen any indian intelectual who possess the intelligence/knowledge of political science as much as that of Ishtiaq Ahmed.

[@sandeepsaxena8266]

Bhai Saab, its good that you like dr. Ishtiaq and appreciate his work but being an Indian you should read Chanakya and you'll learn quite a lot and if you want I can give you names of quite many brilliant Indian political scientists.

[@rajendragujjar3045]

@@sandeepsaxena8266 noted dear.....i have appreciate him too much.... Will not repeat in future......

[@piyushdas079]

You haven't seen much 😂

[@sarakumari3179]

@@rajendragujjar3045 better

[@prakashtanjore3038]

Prof.Ahmad is very clear an unbiased.

[@ramanand7639]

Your commentaries and interviews are truly informative. Thank you.

[@arjj5232]

Research capabilities of Ishtiaq sb is no doubt marvelous.

[@infinitewisdom6065]

A pleasure to listen to a good interview.

[@MuhammadKhalid-jv4qr]

The response of half of the society over Minar-e-Pakistan incident is an indication that how successfully the goal of making the society JAHIL AND BACKWORD has been achieved.

[@saeeddeen7304]

Thank you Doctor sahib, For your thought provoking conversation.

[@pratapgadhvi7091]

Indian civilization started from what is now Pakistan but to admit that Pakistanis will have to accept that this civilization happened when Pakistanis were hindus. So we can safely say it was Hindu civilization.

[@suryanarayanajagarlapudi8672]

Assuming that your reference is to Indus Valley Civilization, then I must point out the there was no religion called Hinduism then. But all those living in the Valley accepted a common Belief System. Most of the people now occupying the region abandoned the common belief system only in the 7th Century AD and accepted a System which Originated in Arabian Country.

[@pratapgadhvi7091]

@@suryanarayanajagarlapudi8672 originated in Arabia is laughable. Its Pakistanis wishful thinking that their ancestors were Arabs and not HINDUS. The civilization in Indus Valley was in full fledge by at least five thousand years before 7th century. Arabs were wondering around in desert at the time.

[@pratapgadhvi7091]

@@suryanarayanajagarlapudi8672 Your comments are hilarious. A belief that is practiced by millions today, was abandoned in 7th century? 😂😂😂😢. By whom? Followers of a peadophile?

[@pratapgadhvi7091]

@@suryanarayanajagarlapudi8672 What we now call religion was practiced by Indigenous of Indus Valley. HENCE called Hinduism. Please reply I'm humoured by your comments.

[@piyushdas079]

Nope...there is no evidence of that

[@arshaddurrani3885]

Thankyou for educating us.

[@janealamkhaki3716]

Truly admirable discussion on key issues facing Pakistan - or more appropriately, elite of Pakistan thrusting on its people. The mix of a political ideology as a tool for domination, and a superficial loyalty to "Zindabadism" (of all sorts) have both played havoc to its fabric not just education. The hypocrisy, which we otherwise demonize when it comes to our faith, has characterized our society at all levels. Professor Sahib, and you, Shakil Sahib, with your perceptive questions and comments have done a marvelous service to both the culture and the country. Professor sahib is a human asset and people of Pakistan and India should particularly benefit from his wisdom and scholarship. Shakil Sahib, your reading and critical interjections/interpretations are so insightful. Jan e Alam Khaki "JanealamkhakiTV"

[@sanirudha]

Baloch never came to Sindh, they never annexed another culture, it was a peaceful area. Tell me of a war in Gandhar or Madra before western attacks happened? Talk sense, just don’t vomit nonsense. what a confused guy. He forgets Gandhara, Madra nations, he does not know anything about Jana padas of nation states and a United Arya Varta which was called Bharat Varsha, at the time of Krishna which is proven around 5000BC. Even Saraswati river was dried much later, Rig Veda was written atleast 12000 years before that, astronomical dating and carbon dating has proven. Nothing will help us in proving anything, these guys or anyone else, they live in Disneyland.

[@sandeep.sharma.]

12:45 to 12:57 Shakil sahib espousing critical thinking for Pakistanis, not realizing that first questions for any critical thinker are 'who am i, what is my origin, where am i located, what is my purpose and what is my destination?'. You got the wrong person to answer these questions. 30:30 to 30:45 the master of half-truths, Prof IA, gallantly and derisively refers to 2.7% industrial growth rate as 'Hindu rate of growth' but shies away from referring to 5.3% industrial growth rate as 'Muslim rate of growth'. I speak on your side, Shakil sahib. Beware of academic charlatans.

[@rajivgupta7973]

Better to refer as 'Socialism Rate of Growth'...

[@shreyanshgupta7648]

Bilkul Sahi. 👍👍👍

[@MrNitKap]

Talking about Benazir Bhutto… at that time her govt had started a population control campaign with ‘Hum do Hamarey Do’ poster all over Pakistan … all those posters had to be pulled down once Benazir got pregnant and delivered her 3rd child 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@whiteholeeducationcenter]

🤣🤣🤣.

[@Harishkryadav1]

namaste shakil sir 🙏 one of the best KZbin channel 🔥🔥🔥

[@srinivaskini4704]

Very very hard to believe that Sardar Vallabhai Patel offered Kashmir on a platter in to Pakistan, in lieu of Nizam's Hyderabad. He was the one who had despatched troops to Kashmir to counter Pakistani insurgents much against the wishes of Nehru, who apparently was resorting to delaying tactics to allow the insurgents enough time to swallow the whole of Kashmir.

[@realhulk7034]

Dr saab is right….I heard some have got their PHD on phones…..shocking…. Actually no shock- Imran khan says he is 3 times PHD……😜😜😔😔😔

[@vijaypothukuchi5694]

People like these are the true patriots of Pakistan.

[@ashishnehra5481]

Shakil bhai you need to interview Chacha Abdul Shakoor who has the channel called Chacha The Commando

[@vijaypothukuchi5694]

Chaudhary saab, we desire to have a sanguine, prosperous Pakistan as our brothers and neighbours. Please do your part to make your own mark to change the mindset in Pakistan

[@minnathkanchar4104]

Sir, You have shown guts to speak logical things.

[@drx.sunilcarpenter8153]

Choudhary Sir good question

[@narayanpatro4588]

Sir..keep working hard...u will have more and more subscribers very soon...

[@nadeemmuhammad7994]

Thanks

[@karolbagh3793]

One I Know 'Tarek Fatah' who excels from Pakistan

[@premkumar9608]

Stand up to speak the truth the nature will always take us in right direction. Few prof from your region is striving hard to bring good education, it's time general like minded pakistan should think of.

[@mr.india..4765]

Shakir shab is good person...

[@thebharat6118]

Istiaq Sahab knows Pakistan than any other intellectual. He should provide a road map to help progress Pakistan.

[@freeman4899]

yeh mein maanne ke liye taiyar nehi hu ki education Pakistan me India se achha tha. Calcutta used to have finest educational institute and some of the finest intellectuals J C Bose, P C Roy, Meghnad Saha, S N Bose jeise finest scientist the . Madras me bhi bahat achhe universities the usse time pe

[@rpforyou]

Sir you always use a term Hindutva force what does this means have you ever heard Modiji speaking about Islamic forces he only says clearly that he will work for all Indians.

[@shivamsinghrawat9910]

Inko nhi pta ki hindutv kitna jruri hai india me abhi.

[@amolkhobaragade]

@@shivamsinghrawat9910 Koi zaruri nahi hai. Congress ke waqt bhi zaruri nahi tha. Hindutva aazadi ke movement mein bhi zaruri nahi tha.

[@worldcitizen3519]

A very good decent discussion keep it up

[@vijaypothukuchi5694]

Please keep up with this intellectual format of your videos

[@b.pdhuriya5382]

🙏🙏

[@sarakumari3179]

I didn't noticed a single Pakistani in comment section, so good their gov is not putting too much efforts on education, they r still not ready to learn 🤣🤣🤣😆😆🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@hirendesai8343]

Wonderful conversation 💐👍 I was surprised to learn about Patel offering Kashmir - that’s really interesting - need to read these books you mentioned - Thank You 🙏🏼

[@amolkhobaragade]

I don't think that was clear offer but an understanding between Patel and Pak leadership.

[@debasishraychawdhuri]

I mean the name 'Hindu is basically how the greeks would call 'Sindhu'. What are they talking about?

[@indiavinod4492]

Before 1947 all were indian. Fictitious line can't divide cultural heritage. NoPakistani culture existing.all you are seeing indus civilization and Aryans cultural society. Maximum converted muslim from Hindu. You can see surname shah,chaudhri Patel Solanki etc. You recognise self pakistani but my indian mindset can't accept this theory. Both are wellwisher of their country. Pakistan should respect like this learned person.

[@balavijayanvenkateshwaran2265]

Am an Indian myself, these scientists criticise their country as they are true patriots who believe in their religion and country and want it to be the best. Perhaps, they were ignored by the military masters of their country- making frustration a factor. Indians should not get fooled by this self flagellation. They are not that behind as Indians like to think they are. India too has a lot to rectify and improve upon else we should be ready for unforeseen shocks and disasters.

[@er.vishnukumaragarwal4354]

Baluchistan and Pakhtoonistan are sure to become independent nations in next 5 years due to emergence and victory of Talibans in Afghanistan. Independent and strong Punjabistan is a buffer state between Afghanistan and India. Because all invasions from Afghanistan passed via Punjabistan to Northern India. Ahmed Shah Abdali (Durrani) unified Afghanistan with capital in Peshawar in 1757. He was highly literature and good Ruler.

[@criticalthinker5764]

Self criticism and introspection is lacking in Pakistan because of lack on honesty

[@EILF7842]

religious supremacy.

[@sureshsharma6293]

Dr istyaq ji very good man

[@sharjeeljawaid]

The key issues in our education system is 'learning by rote' and 'taqleed' (blind following). Unless these obsolete basics are ejected from our thinking there no improvement is foreseen.

[@EILF7842]

blind following is the result of religious fanaticism. Your religion by default promotes only blind faith. islamic fanaticism is responsible to root out scientific thinking, promotes blind faith

[@Clklom]

Today Pakistan is really on self destruction due to what they have done to Afghanistan......#azaditoafghans

[@shivendrasingh8931]

Shakil sir👍👍👍 Thank-you for the shows

[@riazahmed-ir3vm]

Jo qom allama iqbal ki shairi c science tlash krti ho unka kya kehna

[@elknihc]

In 1947 and for a few decades after that, there was a case for comparison between India and Pakistan. Not any more. Sibling jealousy or rivalry may force you to think that way but it is actually delusional and self destructive. Just like an India China comparison can’t be held ( Though there are many areas India is far far ahead ) an India Pak Comparison is ludicrous. And there isn’t one area Pak is completion. To get ahead and make progress let go of this obsession and much as it hurts, third world countries in Africa,Sri Lanka and Nepal May be more appropriate to reflect with. Better to discard the Nuclear bogey too.

[@yogeshtest3602]

Sir a little correction, ISRO chandrayan-1 mission was successful, unsuccessful was chandryan-2 on which pak minister moked.

[@azeem_lahori-punjabi]

ریاست پاکستان نوں لگیاں (کج وڈیاں) بیماریاں : "قومی یعنی فوجی سلامتی" "قومی یعنی فوجی مفاد" "قومی یعنی فوجی حکومت" "قومی یعنی فوجی پالیسی" "قومی یعنی فوجی استحکام" "قومی یعنی فوجی نظریہ" "قومی یعنی فوجی خرچے" "قومی یعنی فوجی عدلیہ" "قومی یعنی فوجی میڈیا" "قومی یعنی فوجی اسلام"

[@AjitJoshi686]

TIFR is more known for atomic and similar high technology. IITs are more for General engineering . Chinese schools run from morning to evening 10 to 12 hrs daily

[@jacinthadias5040]

Yes.. Self distruction

[@mithsindia5150]

Badhiya sir bahut badhiya. Even we want prosperity of this whole region 🙏.. Koi faayda nhi yai ldaai jhagdey ka

[@mirmir7869]

Agreed as do kasmiree people so maybe self choice for us too

[@anilthapa5631]

Good job 👍👍👍.

[@adityamehra4956]

Where are u from Thapa ji ? I also have a friend who shares his name with u..

[@amiriabal9707]

Itezaz ehasn wrote book not to please benazir but establishment he has always secretly supported establishment

[@suryanarayanajagarlapudi8672]

Dr. Ishtiaq is so perceptive.

[@XoPlanetI]

Science based education is the only way to get off poverty, not Madrasa education.

[@SridipParui]

Chandrayan is not a failed mission. It is giving new revelations.

[@User-45xu67]

Very informative and reallistic . Although being Pak channel you are rightly introspecting for failures of muslim nation but the same factors are applicable in India also to indian muslims. Here we have scientific education to all . But unfortunately there is tremendous growth in Madarsas in India particularly in rural and backward areas. Here also ideologically is on rise in India.

[@XoPlanetI]

Agree with you..not just in backward states,it has increased in Kerala as well

[@vinodverma8553]

what a man

[@durgaprasadsingh3755]

I appreciate your discussion with eminent personalities. You are right about Pakistan bosting their possession of Nuclear weapon but Indians never mention it publically.

[@Speak_truth0009]

Dharm Ka Gyan Aapko Aache Karya Aur Sahi Raaste Par Chalne K Liye Prerit Karta Hai & Modern Education Aapko Naye Khoj, Pratispardha Aur Prithvi Par Manav Jeevan Ko Surakshit Aur Aasan Banata Hai.

[@atulkumar-pr4yo]

The main problem with pakistan is that Pakistan always compare with india and has hostility towards India. Pakistan is fighting with India on issues which are useless, perhaps these are necessary for its survival.

[@rpforyou]

I RECOMMEND NOVEL PRICE FOR DR. ISHTLAQ. HE IS FARE IN DISCUSSIONS

[@1aarora]

It’s Nobel prize and fare is something you pay as a bus/train ticket!

[@sarakumari3179]

@@1aarora haha hahaha, #Raju , can't u see he is biased towards Islam, calls indian hindus fanatics

[@1aarora]

Sorry, Pakistan never really had economic growth, even during the supposed golden days of Ayub Khan - the supposed growth was just the US largesse because Pak joined all the possible CENTO, CEATO … against the supposed Soviet communist expansion! All the banter about 5.4% growth etc is a lie for ego building.

[@Byju2869]

It's always a pleasure to listen to Professor Ishtiaq's analysis.

[@mukeshkumarjain5192]

Shakil bhai bahut khoob surat and hard fact discussion.

[@rmnair90]

But, compared to India, Pakistan has a very high AK-47 Literacy rate😎

[@drsubashn4025]

Panelist may be an expert in the affairs of pak. But when it comes to indian affairs , he is just a pakistani armchair expert filled with hatred for india and hindus. He doesn't have anything positive to say about pakistan, so he gets vicarious pleasure in talking negatively about india and hindus. About india and hindus , he depends only on social media and handouts from Pak army/ISI. I do not think he has ever visited India , definitely not in the last 10-15 years. If he has to be in the limelight, he has to portray india and hindus negatively. It can make his masters happy. Pathetic for an "expert ".

[@rajuvanra2739]

Well done shakil choudhary sir & ishtiaq ahmad sir i like it's all program from ahmedabad Gujarat 🇮🇳🙏🙏🙏

[@bhaskarchoumal9222]

Professor Ahmed may be one of the reasons for exansion of islam in Sweden. One may conduct research on this topic.

[@iamyou8994]

Indians recognize the offer Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel had given regarding Kashmir. I don't know which indian Ishtiaq Sir was talking about. Maybe some Indians who didn't study history so only has some basic knowledge of partition because we just mention partition as British divide and rule policy in our school books with little or no explanation beyond.

[@harisadu8998]

Well you have one in this comment section denying it.

[@chetanmehra5326]

Suggestions by Professor Sahab at 39:16 , was also suggestions of Indian PM modi to the peoples of Pakistan.

[@suhasawasthi3434]

Good discussion

[@moderndemocracychannel4699]

Dr Ishtiak Ahmed shaheb your are respectable because your analysis is very fair but if pakistan started restrospect it's fair analysis and opt democracy like india it's boundary of Radcliffe line will be removed.The leadership of Pakistan is on the basis of religion so how you think to be an scientific achievement like india and Israil. India gave world many noble prize winner

[@ashokrai34]

Sakeel sir aap sandar video pes karte hai maja aa jata hai

[@champ1007]

It seems that more Indians watch this program than Pakistanis because in comment section you find more Indians.

[@gauravpandey6181]

Ap Sab Ghar Vapsi kar lo sab apne ap improve ho jayega. Problem is in ideology

[@somanathr7851]

shakil chowdary sir NAMASTHE. lov u lot fm bangaluru india.

[@palash21]

An Arab ancestry beat suits the 2 nation narrative of Pakistan . But I don't understand as why Pakistan should oppose a Hindu India rationally, ethically, morally..... while they themselves made a country based on a religion.

[@kushendramishra5471]

Shakil saheb gud work

[@anabhtechnosoft6797]

What a great comedy when growth rate of india was low..it was called hindu rate of growth and dt time was secular government but now during last 7 years india has average growth of 7 percent..now it is called hindutva government I can just laugh at confusioness and dichotomy by guest scholars 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@automationvesta]

Mr. Shakil, You forgot to mention one major achievement of Pakistan; Development of technology of terrorism.

[@s.knehra5106]

Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed sir apko Hindus se kyo problem h??Hindus yadi India me Hindus ki baat nhi karenge to ap bata sakte ho ki kha kare?? We respect you sir but please change your mind also

[@anujay81]

Doctor saheb is of leftist bent of mind and an atheist.

[@humanityfirst3012]

What is the standard of literacy,Matric FA etc?

[@mylord3003]

India helped in independence off Bangladesh. India did not take over Bangladesh. Bangladesh with some good policy decisions are doing well for themselves.