What is the difference between the objectives resolutions of India and Pakistan?

[@ShakilChaudhary]

Dear Friends, If you like my find my videos worthwhile, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel. I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. Uncivil langue does not make you convincing in any way. There is no problem if you want to disagree with me the guest but please do so without being disagreeable. If you wish to give the opposing view, please send me your contact details. If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them. kzbin.info/www/bejne/noitppqYntGEmpo kzbin.info/www/bejne/noOnmnibbpWtbLs kzbin.info/www/bejne/qaKreICef9CsncU You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter. facebook.com/shakil.chaudary twitter.com/ShakChaudhary

[@Darkings]

Shakil saab, I would like to be part of your show someday. Hoping to hear from you 🙏🙏

[@vimalpandey6122]

Jnab Pt Mahendrpal Aary ko bulaye

[@jitendivgi2761]

Whatever we might feel about Pakistan, we from India have to commend people like Shakil Chaudhary and Dr Ishtiaq Ahmad who stand up and openly challenge the ideology of the establishment which is viciously vindictive.

[@RaviRJoshi]

Dear Shakil, while you're interviewing Dr. Ahmad, you should also please promote his books. His research is enormous.

[@attorneyumarghazalli]

It's really nice to know that Shakil sahib is one of founders of Human Rights Commission of Pakistan. I have more respect for him now.

[@subratachakraborty7405]

Is it possible in pakistan ? After knowing Hamid Mir , MJ Sir , Amir Mir , Imran safqat condition , maybe some other cause behind it ? If you see debate of Shakil Chowdhury before 6 months or one years ago ...

[@attorneyumarghazalli]

@@subratachakraborty7405 Good and bad things go on everywhere

[@subratachakraborty7405]

Yes sir , I also agree with you but most of them are one sided then problem start from this point ....

[@atulkumar-pr4yo]

Gandhi ji always went on hunger strike ,against violence against Muslims, but never against Hindus. Jinnah never condemned killing of Hindus.

[@asadaziz8633]

Sir you are absolutely right. Mr. Ghandi always support indian muslims and at any riots between hindus and muslims he only condemned hindus without knowing the situation. Mr. Ghandi presents his nonsense narrative of non violence which is given him by British empire and his this narrative demoralizing hindu nation. I can not understand mr.ghandi was always save the interst of muslims over the hindu nation. Why indian hindus respect him and some hindus are called him father.

[@AbhishekMishraTakshila]

Shakeel Sir, you are a hero, your work is for generations to come

[@prabhakarkarve7297]

Ishtiaqji, Discuss In Details Logic Of Muslims Staying In India After Partitions....Don't Just Quote RSS & HINDU MAHASABHA. It Because Atitude Of Muslim League & Muslim Religious Leaders & Muslim In General That, RSS & HINDU MAHASABHA Was Establish. This To Safe Guard The Hindu Interest. Because Congress Was Sacrificing Hindus & Hindu Interest Regularly Before Independence Regularly In The Name Of Freedom Struggle...... Mopallah Revoult Of Kerala Is Testimony To It. Were Thousands Of Hindus Were Forcefully Converted & Ruthlessly Massacred & Women's Were Raped. This Revoult Had Nothing To Do With India & Freedom Movement. It Was Because, Defeat Of Ottanman Calaphite Empire By West. The Mopallaha Of Kerala Made This An Cause To Massacre Hindus. But The Left Historians, Dalal Of Nehru, Gave A Twist By Giving Different Colour, That It Was Of Landlords Vs Landless..... Now Coming To Point Of People Converted To Muslims Were From Lower Caste, Because Of Caste System. What About Pakistanis, Who Majority Are Muslims Including YOU, Were YOU From Arab Or Were From Lower Caste???? What About The Afghans, The Zorastrians Of Persia ( Iran), Who Were Completi Converted Within Few Years, Few Excaped From The Islamic Invaders Landed In India. What About The Kashmir Brahmins ???? Most Of Kashmiri Muslim Ancestors Were Brahamins......Can You Throw Some Lights???... Hindu/ Santan History & Civilization Is Many Many Thousands Years Old. The Concept Of Religion Came From West....The Religion Itself Is Based Completely On Imperialism, Rather Than Spiritual Values. The Set Of Rules Applicable Once Becomes Follower Are Different & For Non Followers Are, Completely Hostile & Ruthless, Unlike Sanatan Dharma....... There Was No Caste System In It. The Profession, But Slowly Over The Centuries Turned Into Caste. In West There Were The Royals, The Priests, The Nobles & Ordinary Working Class. Who Were Different Set Of Laws Were Applicable, It Slowly Vanished. But Due To Invasions, Political Disturbance & Other Factors All Over India, It Took Long Time For Reforms. Now This Caste System Is Slowly Vanishing. But The So Called Secular Parties, Like Congress, Left Orhers Along With Media Want To Divide Hindus On Caste & Appease Muslims As A Political Strategy For Votes. But From Last One Decade, This Plot By Congress & Other So Called Secular Parties Are Exposed & Hindus Who Were Divided On Caste, Language & Regions Have Realised & Voting Against This Fake Secular Parties. This Divide & Rule Hindus Started By Congress Few Years Since Pre & Post Independence........ Unlike Muslims In Pakistan & Other Islamic Countries Where Shias Sunnis & Other Sects Of Islam Are At Constant War & Each Others Blood Till Date. Hindus Don't Kill People In The Name Religion. All The 4 Religions Of India, The Hindu Buddhist, Jain & Sikh, Though Slightly Vary In The Religious Following With Different Scriptures, Respect, Mix, Visit, Even Sometimes & Some Place Pray Together & Celebrate Religious Functions, Without Little Bit Of Any Type Of Differences.... Where's It Is Not The Case With Different Sects Of Muslims & Even In Christians. Different Churches Of Roman Catholic, Different Churches Among Different Sections Protestants, Different For Syrian Catholic, There Too Different Sects, The Jehovas & So On. Though All Muslims Follow Koran & All Christians Follow Bible. But All Hindus Don't Follow Same Scriptures Or Has One Holy Book, But All Hindus Visit Same Temple.

[@dilipbari8765]

In India ,M K Gandhi and J M Neharu also failed.

[@jayantakumarsharma4121]

Prof Ishtiaque Ahmed is a scholar par excellence

[@kshitijsharma749]

Though he's a anti Modi but still

[@MalayKumar98]

It is people like you why India is still reeling under colonial rule. There were a lot of things on which he is clearly misinformed. For e. g: Read the entire constitutional debates from Arun Shourie there was no pitching from C Rajgopali Or any such based on Hindu concepts, Gandhi alone was responsible for these riots. He completely absolved Islamic community for establishing MPLB after Shah Bano case and congress supporting it.

[@moderndemocracychannel4699]

Prof ishtiak shahab your scholarly explanation is very very correct but in Indonesia Muslims say that we have changed our religion not ancestors so culture of the land is ours . Are Muslims of India and Pakistan can discuss over it

[@asadaziz6429]

Obviously. It is reality that muslims of India Pakistan and Bangladesh were converted muslims from Hindu religion . The muslims of India from Hindu race . From Pakistan.

[@ssrinivas3236]

Mr Shakil brings in another honest blunt Pakistani, brutal and unflinching with truth

[@skipper09pepper]

Dr. Ahmed, Amazing to listen to you. You are a very honest intellectual. Wish there were more like you on both sides. A big fan!

[@siquendarfirondanapuri9926]

What! A intellectual discussion🙏

[@faheemansari3702]

Indian muslims ne secularism ko kaise Misuse kiya , is pe kabhi baat kare.

[@bhanumungali6000]

He did an interesting program with Prakhar Srivastava

[@atulkumar-pr4yo]

Correct. There is an urgent need in present day

[@sarvathavicharsheel7487]

@@bhanumungali6000 can you share the link

[@bhanumungali6000]

@@sarvathavicharsheel7487 kzbin.info/www/bejne/j5jWgmp8g9pgp7c

[@singhukwala3135]

Agreed

[@azeem_lahori-punjabi]

Dr. Ahmed is a genuine intellectual and an honest scholar from Lahore - Punjab.

[@PS-ej2xn]

Dr Ahmed is like one of the old gurus, a true knowledge-seeking researcher who gets so excited with his work that he doesn't even wait for his research to get published before talking about his findings. In the competitive domain of academic publishing, this is mostly a strict no-no for most self-interested researchers. :)

[@mahipalsinghji7612]

Sir you are back on air after an interval of 5 days precisely. Glad to see your programme.

[@Darkings]

Terrific discussion Shakil saab 🙏🙏 Prof Ahmed is a treasure house of knowledge

[@bhanumungali6000]

By the way I am reading “Garrison State”

[@ghalib9]

This is no less than a paying lecture from a world class Prof, in debt of your insight and wisdom and knowledge and ability to deliver so plainly. Thanks Prof, Thanks Shakeel

[@hn3051]

Jinnah was not only sharp but also most dishonest .

[@bivashchowdhury9589]

Yes prof sahab Wright ly said every thing except some points as per my knowledge After all he is the most respectful person

[@sandeep.sharma.]

Shakil Ji, aapke gyan chakshu toh lagbhag khul gaye hein. Tuhanoon lakh lakh vadhayiaan. Now you're faced with enormous task of opening the minds of your 220M fellow citizens. I salute your mission.

[@tushar1618]

Why does he defame RSS? Does he know anything about hindu dharm?

[@NishantSingh-qe7vv]

kathni aur krni dono ko padh aao

[@stylequotient4921]

Woh defame nahin kar rahein hain wo bata rahein ki Gandhi sab utha ke de rahe the use khilaf rss uthi thi

[@moderndemocracychannel4699]

Prof ishtiak shahab the lack of deep knowledge of Mr.jinnah was the cause of confusion with Gandhi and Nehru. Only knowledge of law is not sufficient for making of modern nation.

[@shidharbhagwat5866]

Those Muslims who were told to.stsy back and destroy India are working hard to destroy India

[@mayankindian3750]

Jinnah confuse the 🤣😂 ki wo kya bna rahe hai 😅😂😆 unka ego tha Congress ke khilaf is wajah se itne log marwa diye pta nahi kya soch rahe the pakistan banate time 😂🤣

[@girishkochewad2033]

*Jinnah thought that he sitting in bar and British are bartender They will serve him power of India as drink *

[@sudeepkumarsanyal]

SHOW US CONDITION OF HINDUS LIVES IN PAKISTAN.

[@aryanhacker5820]

Shakil ji We hindus don't care where Modi and Hindutva was good or bad for us. But during riots only RSS and BJP come to save hindus. We loyal to their kindness help.

[@amolkhobaragade]

BJP/RSS itself is responsible for riots against Muslims. Be it Gujarat, be it Delhi riots.

[@Prat2023]

@@amolkhobaragade Yea so muslims can start the riots and Hindus should basically give themselves up. #Godhra #Shaheenbagh #Gandhi

[@girishkochewad2033]

*Jinnah was lawyer of Lokmanya Tilak he lost the case He is only good in dealing wakf cases*

[@sb9060]

Very enlightening...

[@dhananjaysingh3574]

There are 04 days holiday on the festival of hindu And muslim, 02 days for Christian, one day each for Sikh, Baudh and Jain. Apart from this 03 National holiday And 02 days holiday for regional festivals in India.

[@prabhakarkarve7297]

4 Days Holidays, Ramzan, Bakra Eid, Birthday Of Mohammed & Moharum & 2 Days For Christian, Christmas & Good Friday.

[@rajuvanra2739]

Happy makarsankranti & lohri festival shakil choudhary sir &ishtiaq ahmad sir🙏🙏🙏 I LIKE IT your program sir 🙏🙏🙏 from ahmedabad Gujarat🇮🇳

[@keerthisureshseelam]

Ishtiaq Ahmed’s books need to be taught to children included in Indian school syllabus

[@mwaqeel9868]

Sovereignty. Political and legal. Difference Between the two

[@venkyr182]

I love the way Mr. Shakil listens patiently. He is a student of history and has a desire to learn.

[@utopian1402]

The biggest irony of pakistan is that the man who was the most non-Muslim in his behaviour and lifestyle is revered as a God-like, messianic figure in the so-called liberation of a country which was strictly on the basis of religion.

[@PS-ej2xn]

You two are the pride of both India and Pakistan.

[@shivsharma883]

Brilliant analysis by Sakhil sir and Dr Ahmed. A great learning experience 👌.

[@rahulsinghvi9104]

Akbar waa the greatest ruler and symbol of hindu muslim unity, then why jinnhah out of his personal grudge divided india....when he himself didnt knew even a,b,c,d of islam

[@guleriab]

Dont mislead. Read why Akbar killed civilian

[@rahulsinghvi9104]

@@guleriab Akbar was a v good politician, he just tried to control his political opponents both internal & external, he started his own religion Din en elahi which was anyway a flop.

[@arjunwadhwani3974]

As a sindhi hindu, i am of the opinion that others of my community, cannot explicitly help each other. But are inclined to come together with the 'other' in order to protect their own interest and also to avoid the wrath of the "OTHER"

[@MalayKumar98]

Someone please tell this prof. there was no RSS at that time and Gandhi lost his life because he asked Hindus to accept Muslims attack. Prof. cunningly escaped the role of Jinah in Direct Action Day, Mopla riots etc. etc. Though I must commend him for showing the face of Jinah as it was.

[@serotonin0527]

Ultimately he is pakistani hypocrite... Fundamentals remain intact.

[@suhailssssskhan2129]

Akhand bharat again very soon. Jai hind jai bharat.

[@ishworprasadkoirala5712]

From Nepal Please revert back to your ancestral hindu religion and be human.

[@PS-ej2xn]

That's okay, koirala ji. These two gentlemen are among the best of the best. Whatever religion they follow is at this stage not affecting their work.

[@mikeisrite]

Greetings from belgium I appreciate your knowledge and l like your channel thanks

[@Chenducp]

Mr. Chaudhary, can you please consider to use the dates in English in the future postings

[@prabhakarkarve7297]

Karma Plays The Role, Without Doubt About. History Is Proof To It.

[@rajatmajumdar392]

Indian National holidays- for Muslims 2 Eid, Maharram, Milad un nabi, sikh- Guru Nanak birthday, Buddhist- Buddha purnima, For jain - Mahavir jayanti, for Christians Ester, Christmas, Good Friday, for Congress- Gandhi birthday, for Nehru

[@rajatmajumdar392]

For Neheru children day, Gandhi jayanti etc

[@twinklestar8275]

Aur thode saal inki sarkar chale to phir Indira, Rajiv, and so on 😂

[@ritesharora6032]

Pls invite Venkat Dhulipala if you can. he wrote book named "Creating a new medina"

[@AjeetKumar-xi1tk]

Wonderful discussion 👍👍

[@chaudharyrahulkumar]

I thought all Pakistani are like Zaid Hamid. There are sensible people as well there. 🙏 Chaudhary Sahab.

[@dharithrinarakesari3744]

Do you mean in west punjab no hindu or Sikhs were killed .. come on sir don't be so biased

[@सत्यान्वेषी-न1न]

Glad to see You Shakil Sahab again.

[@bivashchowdhury9589]

Prof sahab due respect can you say why muslim league born before hindu mhasbha ?? As per my knowledge hindu mha sbha born after muslim league to protect from MUSLIM aggressin neither HINDU MHASBHA would not born So I contradict you on the point that hindu mhasabha was aggressive 1st Thank you

[@murarisingh1140]

very good doctor sir speaks very well the bridge of information is blind thank you shakil chaudhary sahab

[@PS-ej2xn]

To my Indian friends. Sure, we are not fans of Mr Jinnah. But please, let's not spam this board, just out of respect for these two rare gentlemen who are doing work that most other scholars and journalists never bothered to do.

[@dkhan9456]

हार्दिक आभार

[@anandsinghkol]

Shakil sir is brilliant

[@Harishkryadav1]

Happy New year 🙏🙏🙏

[@arjunwadhwani3974]

I can only think of jinnah, a gujerati mussalman. An opportunistic disruptor of the sindh province and responsible for separating the sindhi hindus and muslims

[@myvariedvlogs2276]

👍👍👍🙏, thanks #nature_and_sandwiches

[@arjunwadhwani3974]

We are left with the concept of the deprived ones. I in particular cannot understand where i belong.

[@mrnayak1406]

Gandhi and Nehru have done very much injustice with all Hindus and all real lover of India and Indianness to allow all these Muslim leaders to stay back in India after break our country. So we Indians I'll never accept these two business men our true leader.

[@bivashchowdhury9589]

If islamic jihad takes place in ksmir then where will go indian muslims In which side indian muslim will support ?? All are contradictory as per islamic law

[@criticalpatriot3839]

Jinha was ordinary tactician and horrible strategist but he was lucky, as he had to deal with mainly Gandhi and Nehru clan.

[@suhasawasthi3434]

Shakil choudhury sahab namashkar 🙏

[@SukhwinderSingh-hc8ge]

Very nice sir😍🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@anoop2238]

Please professor sir ,your book translated in hindi

[@amolkadam6330]

Sir pls arvind saharan prof ishtiaq need tareq fatah Achha khasa program karo sir 5 to 6 hrs bhi kam padega par maza aa jayega All rational at 1 place pls make it happen

[@shiwajiraopatil4600]

I request Modi govt to give BHARATRATNA award to Br Jinha. Warm regards to both of you.

[@bupinderzutshi1842]

I must admit ur analysis of August 11 is absolutely honest.in view of this how does one accept the assertion of todays muslims that they preferred to stay in india and did not go to pakistan

[@KailashSharma-qn5hu]

Dr Ahmed nu Hindu fobiy hi jo galat hi oh Hindu ne keta hi jab kise Desh da batwara mahjab de Naam te Hoya hi aaj be ta ah gall ho rahi hi bus Muslim kol victim card hi?? RSS hindta ek he gall hi Pakistanie kol Tusi ki kar rahe Pakistan Vich????

[@imranyousaf5389]

Dr ishtaiq. Love. Hindus he is. Disagree from. Divided. India

[@teamxgstarboy7432]

🙏🙏🙏

[@sanjaykalra876]

Prof. Sir,- Do a programme on RSS? Let us know the truth.

[@ravishingravi]

You should read the books written on subject.

[@ranjanbarma9201]

Simply super.

[@arjunwadhwani3974]

Sindhi hindus and muslims ought to have gotten together, against the concept of two nation theory and against the punjabi muslims in particular

[@mylord3003]

Mere words. India has seen many such statements from paxtan. Words never get translated into action by paxtan. Many anti-terrorism bills never became laws.

[@PankajSharma-ir7fb]

He was very shrewed lawyer. That's all abt jinnah..

[@atulkumar-pr4yo]

Foundation of muslim league laid the foundation of Pakistan. I don't how Hindu Mahasabha is is responsible for creation of Pakistan.

[@manishsaini9360]

Creation of Pakistan was a good development in India's history otherwise the #filth that had gone to Pakistan would have been in india.

[@sumitkraggarwal5483]

प्रोफेसर इश्तियाक अहमद इज ट्रू लर्नईड पर्सन

[@rakeshtakyar5041]

👍

[@harisadu8998]

It was Henry VIII not Henry VII.

[@subratachakraborty7405]

Pakistan history , itself U turn specialist...

[@ushabhende4040]

He knew his days were numbered. You must also read his will and the list of his wife's jewellery.

[@somn2425]

Bidesh me Baith kar Sab Resercher Banke Baith Gye or Batt batt me Booklikhna! sab ke sab Hipicrit!Matter BHadd Me Jai Paxtan!!! Jab Westrn Punjab Sindh Katal Suru kia Tab Pta nahi Tha India me Rahen Wale Muslim kaha jaiyenge 🤔Ab to Samaj agya🧐 Ye log Chahate punjabi ke liye ak Muslim area! Magar Baki ke India se koi Muslim Na aye! Or Inke Liye Lucknow wale Pagal ho gye the!!! Jada Chowdhury Mat bano!!!🤡

[@nandkishordeodhar5741]

Nandkishor Deodhar No doubt ishtiaqji is brilliant thoughts presenter but about Hindus and RSS he should correct himself Hindus are by birth are secular four veda are not related to religion but for value in the ruling state of BJP Muslim are safe than Congress and even RSS never thought muslims what ishitiji thinking hidus will never fanatic but Muslim should accept their originality look Indonesians Malaysians I think istiakj should explain about originality you may be muslims but your origana culture is hindu it is not religion but way of life

[@sandeepsaxena8266]

Inspite of these realities which you present Pakistani people don't learn and keep on living in a false bubble.

[@pareshdave8800]

thats way gandhi...nehru...hate here...in india...

[@ritesharora6032]

Shakil ji jo soveriegnity ka chakkar hai wo to doctrines se atta hai. ISIS, Bokoharam etc say same thing that they all earth belongs to allah and islam should be imposed on them. shouldnot doctrines be questioned ?

[@aryanhacker5820]

Then Ahmed deserve what they got ?

[@mohankishan9392]

Dr Sahab Hindu Mahasabha and RSS only doing reaction.

[@arjunwadhwani3974]

Jinnah's house in bambai should be rightfully handed over to the displaced persons of pak .. sindhi hindus

[@moko8870]

Professor’s statements show Jinnah in very poor light

[@SunilSharma-cw4qp]

My knowledge is zero.

[@zeeshan5483]

He looks as left - Nehruvian - Political Historian ... And propogated by penguin published .

[@hitesharora5120]

Black list pakistan fatf remove GSP status india tasks good 👍💯

[@zeeshan5483]

The person only defame - Jinnah ... It is his interpretation but not proper one .

[@singhukwala3135]

Prove it

[@njaveri37]

So called Jinha house was built by .Mr. David Sasun letter he sold to Mr.Patit after some time mr. jinha got the house as dowry from mr. Patit. As per Parsi Law Jinhas marriage was illegal so was dowry illegal.

[@sahilmishra6529]

Dalar. Chini. Arbi. Ameriki.. डालर. Ajami. Arjal. Garib. Lasho. Par. 47 Mahnga. Bharat. Kashmir. Ke. Kamunist ko. Padhna. 75..साल. मे करोड़ो. Jane. Dalar. Ke. Lalchi

[@mithulaghari257]

Khuda ka shukr ha k hamen EST: ne IMRAN KHAN ki shikil mn JINNAH SAHAB ka part 2 dhonda kar diya . Ye bhi CONTRADICTION hi CONTRADICTION ha, Jesa k, Haqani Tribe, Men Janta Hoon, Germany aur Japan Border aur to aur Hamari Economy India se Bari ha,........SUBHANALLAH.