What Did Medieval People Think Of The Pyramids?

[@WaterShowsProd]

Very interesting. I love the idea that they even thought it would have been practical to haul the grain up to the top of the pyramids and pour it in through the top. Also: I never knew about the pyramids of Romulus and Remus before.

[@studiumhistoriae]

It certainly would have been quite the task!

[@laserspear22]

Great video! Loved the John Osborne insight and Al Muqaddimah shout out. Subscribed

[@VulnerableBede1]

Fantastic video

[@studiumhistoriae]

Thank you!

[@jaanth314]

Ben Carson confirmed civilization player.

[@ghostpasha9076]

Specifically, Civ 2

[@jaanth314]

@@ghostpasha9076 I wish one of the candidates would run on a platform of building a spaceship to Alpha Centauri.

[@ghostpasha9076]

LOL hell yes@@jaanth314

[@laurisafine7932]

Nicely put together, thanks.

[@roundninja]

But has anyone ever checked if maybe the pyramids used to be full of grains before it all got eaten by one really hungry guy?

[@studiumhistoriae]

Shhhh... don't tell anyone... I'm the hungry guy

[@Jimmylad.]

Why was the pyramid in the Vatican dismantled?

[@studiumhistoriae]

To make way for new constructions. Specifically I believe they were building a new bridge across the Tiber river. This is around the same time that they were building the new (current) Saint Peter's basilica, so there was a lot of new construction projects going on in that area at the time.

[@studiumhistoriae]

Modern archeologists have actually found the old foundations of the pyramid so they know exactly where it used to be

[@JaelaOrdo]

Great video 👍🏾

[@kenyonmoon3272]

This is not a common belief in the church. For doctrinal purposes the story of Israel in Egypt is assumed to be literal, or at least an amalgamation of experiences, but the graineries are not thought to be identified on our end of the timeline - either we simply haven't recognized them or they've been lost to time. Carson's position on the matter is not unheard of, but it is not one you should expect to encounter regularly within the denomination.

[@studiumhistoriae]

Thanks for the insight!

[@kenyonmoon3272]

@@studiumhistoriae of course!

[@laub847]

Such an interesting subject

[@jammysmears4077]

I reckon the pyramids simply reminded people of piles of grain and the various legends grew up separately from similar ideas.

[@vickibamman8333]

Babylon was the name the ancient Romans had for Old Cairo? First time I heard that - what is your source?

[@MatthewTheWanderer]

Yeah, no kidding, that makes no sense at all! The Romans knew where Old Babylon in Mesopotamia was! And they ruled all of Egypt, too. It wasn't technically a foreign place that only pilgrims went to.

[@studiumhistoriae]

For one, that's the name used in the pilgrim's letters that I mentioned in the video, and several of the later sources call it Babylon even after the official foundation of Cairo in the 10th century. The sources I have included in the video's description also mention this if you want to take a look at them. The Romans built a fort near Memphis called Babylon (obviously named after Mesopotamian Babylon, with which they were familiar) and over time this fort would become the center for several towns which would eventually become Cairo. Pilgrims often sailed down to Babylon and noted that the pyramids were right across the Nile from it. I hope that clears up any confusion. I glossed over it quickly in the video, but maybe I should have said a little more about it.

[@johnoparinde2682]

I would also recommend “The Great Arab Conquests” by Hugh Kennedy. It’s okay if you’re surprised, I was confused by it at first too.

[@f23as]

Governor, the city granary is now empty...

[@TriBgarage]

Very interesting, really the scary thing is, how many people blindly assept false truths, just because who said them. You can say actual facts no longer matter in public opinion in some groups. And how each group say it's the other one that is lying, it can't be their side. I like how you say both opinions, and how they come to them, rather then just say your opinion, and that the other guy is wacky.

[@Dowlphin]

This is primitive psychology that has always been a part of humankind. Tribalist mind.

[@florinivan6907]

The assumption of granaries has some logic to it. In an era when famine was always a possibility that's the immediate thing you would think. 'Why would they build something that big taking up so many resources?Food of course.'

[@hypokratesthehypocrite3513]

Do you ever plan on doing a video about the Moors?

[@studiumhistoriae]

I will certainly get to talking about them eventually!

[@100crisps]

You ask some wonderful questions in your titles

[@SaltyChickenDip]

Ben Carson is interesting dude was a genius in neurosurgery. But it seem like he did whst a lot of smsrt hyper specialized people do and assume thier intelligence means they know a lot about everything else.

[@fuzzyhair321]

Heres something interesting, when the old testament was put together on paper. Already the pyramids of giza were ancient. These structures are so damn old

[@ethanator4051]

The peasants trying not to die from plagues, wars and poor harvests: I beg your pardon, What on gods green middle-earth is a pyramid?

[@Toksyuryel]

Would that much grain even remain edible for seven years if stored like that? There are so many holes in this story XD

[@chombus2602]

Well, logically, 4000 years ago, they were not as they are today. Today, all we have are their "structural skeletons", so to speak

[@apocolypse11]

Pyramids were all over the world until Egypt got the monopoly by historians. 😊

[@nevetstrevel4711]

Duh they got the idea from civilizations 2

[@Siegbert85]

So... what you're saying is... Aliens?

[@jasemamen2522]

Roman name for old Cairo ⁉️⁉️⁉️ . Cairo wasn’t existed at that time time ⁉️

[@thiagolourenco4020]

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Babylon_Fortress

[@thiagolourenco4020]

I think he meant that. It's not a city tho

[@studiumhistoriae]

Cairo originated out of a Roman fort called Babylon. Over time the fort would become a town and that town would eventually become Cairo, but it continued to be called Babylon for a while

[@veronicatash777]

A bit of a correction needs to be made. A claim that the pyramids were granaries is a claim made at least as late as 2015, when Ben Carson claimed such and stood by his claim.

[@elfarlaur]

You may want to rewatch the first 30 seconds of the video. I'm not really sure how you missed that

[@drdca8263]

@@elfarlaurI think the “correction” comment is a joke?

[@CartoonHero1986]

Rationalist: Modern science shows us the Pyramids at Giza were built around 2500 BCE and the time of Joseph in Egypt is set around 1875 BCE so this claim of them being Joseph's Granaries is something made up by people from a time without the facts, education, and technology to make this connection. Literalist: Nuh-uh! Because the Bible says this, and a Biblical Scholar while reading the Bible and attempting to link it to real world events and locations says they HAVE to be the Granaries! Rationalist: You do see the flaw in that logic right? Literalist: What flaw, I see no flaw!

[@stephfoxwell4620]

Not a lot. The vast majority never travelled and were not educated. There were no books.

[@Angie2343]

@studiumhistorian Interesting! I'm trying to subscribe but it won't let me!