What Do Indonesians REALLY Think of Malaysia?

[@benfishermin]

⚠WATCH NEXT: What Do Foreigners REALLY Think of Malaysia? kzbin.info/www/bejne/pomym2eeeZWenKc

[@cutakecare2020]

@@benfishermin should ask what foreigners think of indonesia or thailand in Malaysia … you’ll be amazed by their responses.

[@zanzillahsaruji9966]

They are many illegal Indonesian working in Malaysia but they are ashamed to admit and talk about it. Culture not belong to a country but belong to races living in that country...

[@tundewasakti4624]

India,pakistan,bangladesh have same food also "briyani"🤷‍♂️

[@littlegarden1304]

@@tundewasakti4624 in fact the pakistani people said biryani is original from pakistani muslim but india stole that.

[@tundewasakti4624]

@@littlegarden1304 padahal briyani wujud sebelum pakistan,india,atau bangladesh menjadi sebuah negara🤷‍♂️

[@Kartalaksana]

Malaysia never said batik started from Malaysia. We just said we have our own batik and it is our culture as well

[@endrajayajaya1826]

Tapi ramai orang korang cakap batik dari malaysia, macam dalam video i soo speed,tu yg buat kami marah

[@cutakecare2020]

@@endrajayajaya1826betul lah tu … fahami erti dalam bahasa malaysia … “dari Malaysia” bereti ianya di imaginasi, dicorak dan dicetak olih pereka anak tempatan mengikut cita rasa tempatan … tiada isu claim itu ini .. dalam erti kata lain batik Malaysia di buat di Malaysia dan Batik Indonesia di buat di Indonesia … as simple as that!!

[@muhammadabdulwahab123]

batik bukan dari indon tapi asal nya tidak diketahui. Bahkan kata nya batik dibawa dari india.

[@hanxhaykidsdiaries8044]

@@cutakecare2020 bro susah bercakap dengan orang yang tak mahu paham ni. Dah berkali2 cakap pun tak masuk dalam otaknya. 😅

[@cutakecare2020]

@@muhammadabdulwahab123 kemudian tersebar luas penggunaannya di Malay Archipelago (keseleruhan Nusantara) dan rakyat tempatan mula mencipta corak mereka tersendiri mengikut budaya mereka ketika itu hingga kini. Itu saja … buat apa nak repot2 macam lah mrk pakai batek hari2!last2 pakai T-shirt dan celana pendek jer 🤣🤣

[@GoodjobSkill]

To All Malaysian.. please ignore and skip this video. Useless and meaningless. Nothing to do with this video. we have done with the topic. Just focus how to develope our beloved country. As educated person, we refer to the history, we believe the territory is one, we got similar culture , same race (DNA) , and then we are devided to two different countries. That’s why we have same culture. To the youtuber, don’t take advantage as to reach your view engagement. TQ

[@keangwooichoo6138]

I did

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

@@GoodjobSkill yup!! I skip the whole dumb video by just reading some of the stupid comments from the indon netizens. Utter nonsense

[@kiplingkoliak]

Sorry Ben, .. this video has little meaning and the answers given by them all were not new and got no substance.

[@aabmbsa]

Totally agree with you 👍

[@kirk3056]

Kecoh, pasal batik pun nak claim2, rasa bodoh dan goblok pun ada, banyak pekara kami perlu fikir..

[@gundam4596]

Ben, this malay archipelago has a very long history. From Thailand to Vietnam to Phillipines, Indonesia are all the same root as malay world. During the ancient times, there are many established kingdoms and Malacca was the centre point for trading from all around the world. That is why malay language was used as a lingua franca in those ancient days be it in Borneo, java, Mindanao, or even trader from Arabs, Persian, India, China are communicate in malay when the come to Malacca to do trade and exchange. So on those days, people from all over the neighbouring area, from java, Sumatra, Sulawesi, Mindanao, champa, Hainan, India, come migrate to malay peninsular which bring along their culture, language, and then living in what we known as Malaysia nowadays for generations. Those time we no need passport but after colonial era, this whole area of malay archipelago got separated by the western imperialist. Then the westerner try to rewrote all the history. This culture claiming topic is just a childish issue for most of us which many Malaysian not even bother and just making fun of it. There are certain things that you should know about the topic before you go through it. First of all Malaysia has never made any claim that batik, rendang originated from Malaysia. What Malaysia is trying to promote is "Batik Malaysia". For many, they may not able to distinguish batik and think it is all the same. Batik is not only in Indonesia, Malaysia but all over the globe, the China, India, Hawaii, even European has their own batik culture. In Malaysia we have 2 type of batik; the drawing method and the stamp method. What known as Malaysia batik is the motive, colour, size of motive. Malaysian batik usually has bigger motive and we only use floral and some creature like butterfly as motive because of Islamic culture. Unlike Indonesia batik, they can draw any animal or mystic things as an art but not us. There are many other things to distinguish and most people will know whether the piece of batik is from Malaysia or Indonesia just by first look. The one who made claim is Indonesia when they try submit to UNESCO claiming batik belongs to them but got backfired as UNESCO only approved "batik Indonesia" same as what Malaysia saying to "batik Malaysia". Then about rendang. Yes rendang is a well-known dish from minang tribe in Sumatra. There are also many descendant of minang in state of negeri sembilan of Malaysia even we still have the king of minangkabau still rule of the state. In Malaysia, rendang is a normal daily dish nowadays and you can find anywhere but unlike in Indonesia you will only have it in Sumatra on special occasion day such as Eid but it is not norm in java and other parts of Indonesia. Because of that, Indonesian only knows that rendang came from padang, minang and not other place. Unlike Malaysia, we have several.type of rendang, the minang rendang which kind same like rendang Indonesia, then we have several other rendang like rendang tok only in the state of perak, then there are many fusion style rendang by nyonya baba culture, indian rendang and many others. Malaysian rendang is not base only from one base tribe/culture but blend enough in all part of Malaysia with their own version. But we never claim rendang belongs to us,it is just a normal daily dish for us but if you think it came from minang, Indonesia, we also will not opposed as minang is also part of our malay culture.

[@syeikhamd]

Tanah Melayu (Malaysia) The earliest written record of the existence of rendang is found in a Malay manuscript, Hikayat Amir Hamzah which was read to Malacca soldiers during the night before the Portuguese attack. From Hikayat Amir Hamzah: "Then Khoja Buzurjumhur Hakim also went to the shop of the rendang goat meat seller. Then he said: "Give me this lump of rendang goat meat" We need to know that this manuscript of Hikayat Amir Hamzah was read on the night of the War of 1511 by the Malay warriors at that time, in order to raise their spirits. So, this means rendang cuisine has existed in the Malay Civilization since the 15th century AD.

[@razalihusain]

@@syeikhamdRendang is only Style of cooking meat until it is dry.

[@endrajayajaya1826]

Bro dah dari dulu2 di nusantara ni ada negara tersendiri, kat jawa ada mataram, di sumatra ada sriwijaya, dan dah dari dulu2 juga salinh berperang berebut kekuasaan , jadi salah betul yg cakap "alam melayu adalah 1" iti pembodohan

[@ZainiZaudi]

​@@endrajayajaya1826aku ada mix 3 negara bermaksud gen anda kena faham, sejarah peradaban manusia sentiasa berpindah randah. Indonesia,Malaysia,Filipina,brunei,Vietnam, Myanmar,Laos Dan negara lainnya semua baru lagi.

[@cutakecare2020]

Yes!! Agree it is a silly and childish topic to gain viewing and likes … that’s pathetic to me … sorry no offence intended 😃

[@kiplingkoliak]

Indonesian had been taught/indoctrinated from their school-days that they are a superior nation than anybody else .. and that reflects in their overall mentality and thinking today.

[@suhaimiabdan3403]

Bukan super power. But more to supertitious! Belief in chance or magic. Pasal tu terasa diri hebat.😂😂😂

[@Bilbilaul]

Funny cause Malaysian literally has superiority more than anyone. Not to mention you all have superiority among other races in Malaysia 😂

[@mirao1782]

@@kiplingkoliak and that's like almost every country too

[@Ali_art]

​@@Bilbilaul kau kena barang apa ni? Mcm on je

[@defiasri4595]

Apakah kamu orang Indonesia? Kami memang diajarkan bahwa bangsa Indonesia ini adalah bangsa yang besar dan memiliki sejarah luar biasa. Kami memang bangsa yang hebat, coba kau bayangkan sebuah bangsa yang bisa membangun candi Prambanan dan Borobudur pastilah bangsa yang hebat. Tapi, kami tidak diajarkan bahwa kami bangsa yang terhebat. Masih banyak bangsa-bangsa lain yang hebat. Dan kami menghargai setiap keunikan dari masing-masing budaya dan kehebatan bangsa lain.

[@gangstercats641]

Damn! this country mindset never change since Soekarno era. Their government should increase the budget for their country's education for the future...

[@Bilbilaul]

What mindset? Typical confused Malaysian who think Javanese, Bugis, Minang,etflc as Malay 😂

[@christianng7609]

They're proud of their military and "they always say it doesn't matter to be poor and underdeveloped as long as military are strong so that our neighboring countries are scared"😂😂😂😂

[@Asif-mondal-01]

​@@christianng7609omg indonesia seems similar to Pakistan. Pakistanis also think highly of their army and don't care about the economy. 😂😂😂

[@EfriadisFamily]

What?? 😂😅

[@one97three]

Batik as mentioned by UNESCO, BATIK do not originated from JAWA Island. The recognised Batik Indonesah and they also recognised Batik Malaysia...on equal terms. PERIOD

[@MatDas329]

Riwayat obrolan  Buka bar samping ChatGPT Anda bilang: Hi chatgpt jelaskan Dimanakah asal usul batik ChatGPT bilang: ChatGPT Batik adalah seni kain yang berasal dari Indonesia, terutama dari pulau Jawa. Asal usul batik diperkirakan sudah ada sejak ribuan tahun yang lalu, dengan bukti peninggalan berupa kain batik yang ditemukan di situs-situs purbakala. Batik memiliki akar budaya yang kuat dan berhubungan erat dengan tradisi dan ritual masyarakat Indonesia. Secara historis, batik mulai berkembang pada masa Kerajaan Majapahit (abad ke-13 hingga ke-16) dan menjadi lebih populer pada masa Kesultanan Mataram. Teknik pembuatan batik melibatkan penggunaan lilin untuk menahan pewarnaan pada kain, menciptakan pola yang rumit dan indah. Batik tidak hanya berfungsi sebagai pakaian, tetapi juga sebagai simbol status, identitas, dan kekayaan budaya. Saat ini, batik telah diakui sebagai warisan budaya dunia oleh UNESCO, dan teknik serta desainnya telah berkembang, menginspirasi banyak seniman dan perancang di seluruh dunia.

[@basedbutler]

One more important thing which everyone missed about this Batik Drama is that BATIK was founded before Malaysia or Indonesia was even a country. so how can it be claimed by either?

[@MatDas329]

@@basedbutler dulu sebelum india merdeka banyak yang pergi ke Malaysia, kenapa sari india tidak diakui milik Malaysia?

[@joharimamat1522]

​@@MatDas329 Haha thats so stupid.

[@Kartalaksana]

Indonesia & India TIDAK sama. Atau anda merasa sama?​@@MatDas329

[@SongsMalaysia]

Indonesian who easily accused Malaysia claiming their culture obviously never had experience travelling to other Asean countries or live in Malaysia. If you asked Indonesians who have travelled experiences or studied or work in Malaysia, most of them would say Malaysian batik or rendang or cendol is totally different from theirs. They acknowledge also the names are similar but thing is different. They also know batik, and other similar foods exist in Thailand and other Asean countries.

[@cindilgamingg]

With that concept, you can also make malaysian pizza, malaysian barongsai, and also all bangla things you can also make it on malaysia version. Is it correct ? Then you can claim whatever in this world..

[@PakChikMirol]

@@cindilgamingg There will another version for everything you darm carnt... Hamburger was originally in German but popularize by American. Kebab, Doner, Shawarma are the same thing, but does people in Middle East argue where it come from, Turkey, Saudi, Oman? NO. Thats why now Kebab shop is everywhere in the whole world! Can you think for second! FOR REAL FOR REAL INDONESIAN! Please! I don't want see you on the lowest IQ in South East Asia! PLEASE! Why you keep doing that to yourself!?

[@anialawiyahalawiyah3819]

Culture is the same as where you were born, you will definitely answer from your mother's womb, and likewise culture is born from its oldest original source.

[@user617a6d6]

@@cindilgaminggWhat is the meaning of the word 'Indonesia'?

[@decTac]

Only the educated Indonesians understand and know how to differentiate their cultures and Malaysian's.. No one claims without proof and history.. Btw, that lady described cable cars in Genting Highlands.

[@Bilbilaul]

Only educated Malaysian would know Javanese, Bugis, Minang, and Banjars aren't MELAYU. so how come their culture belong to Malaysia when they aren't ethnically Malay?

[@decTac]

@@Bilbilaul those Indonesian descendants have their own cultures and so on here only those who are blind can't see them.. 🤣

[@Bilbilaul]

@@decTac those Indonesians descendents literally considered as MALAY in Malaysia constitution 😂 that's why Malay Malaysians claim their culture belong to them . Cause they classify everyone as Malay and got confused where and what their original cultures actually are 😂

[@decTac]

@@Bilbilaul absolutely gibberish 🤣😂

[@Bilbilaul]

@@decTac facts doesn't care about feeling 😂

[@hafizzjohari2567]

thing is, I have not yet see any Malaysia claiming certain cultures belong or originate from Malaysia, we accept the fact that the cultures among these 2 countries are almost identical. It is hard to make Indonesian understand that the culture exists long before the country of Malaysia and Indonesia were created, it really does not belong to certain country hence the culture and foods are a lot similar among the SEA countries because huge part of SEA were used to be under one empire. simple example there is Batik and Wayang Kulit in Thailand's culture , and Kebaya in Philippine but you don't see Indonesian attacking them for practicing and embrace the culture. Big reason is because Thai and other SEA countries they don't use Bahasa like we Malaysia and Indonesia, hence the name of the cultures are different although the concept are similar. I think that is the big issue, the name of the certain culture are exactly the same. If we are talking about Indonesia people migrate to Malaysia and bring the culture so Malaysia has no right to be proud of their culture, let take a look wayyy back, indonesia is an island country while Malaysia is connected to mainland, logically we migrate to your land. but that is not a wise argument, but also that is the logic they have been using "we migrate along with our culture"

[@JakaIskandar]

But you have to know that Indonesia is got independence earlier than Malaysia, so we have the right to claim... And the facts is that things are originally come from Nusantara (Indonesia)

[@hafizzjohari2567]

@@JakaIskandar your logic is invalid because Thailand has never been colonized, so technically it is older than Indonesia's independence . So can Thailand claim all the similarity of culture among SEA Countries? So yea, think of logic when you're talking about this similarity of culture.

[@JakaIskandar]

@@hafizzjohari2567 I never mention Thailand in this conversation, why you mention Thailand, they have nothing to do with batik, and Indonesia don't have problem with Thailand... Don't bring other country in this debate... Stupid... Do you need Thailand help?

[@gangstercats641]

​@@JakaIskandar What a clown mindset...

[@kirk3056]

​​@@JakaIskandarYou got your Independence from who? The Dutch? In fact, when Indonesians pay their debt to Dutch Government in order to settle the Independence? Pernah dengar tali barut Jepang? Siapa tokohmu merupakan barua tali barut Jepang?? Lu pikir la sendiri...

[@mohdzaki1089]

2:13 Haiya....she was talking about Genting Highlands bro ..how come you didn't know....😅😅😅😅...

[@MohdFadliAbdullah]

Yes, what she meant was Genting Highlands, Skyway is the Cable Car, the way she described maybe confused Ben more, btw it's in Pahang not KL.

[@Ghostbuster80]

Sound like Uncle Roger there... Haiyyyaaa...

[@kakalakiakka4545]

Because he just cares about the viewer count

[@eeta291]

Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, Philippines and Singapore originally before conquest by the West was united under Malay archipelago. that is why most of the culture, food and language are almost similar.. during those time, Indonesia or malaysia does not exist yet... there is no issue batik or certain culture belong to Indonesia or malaysia..we even have batik Indonesia, batik Malaysia, batik Philippines, batik Brunei... but based on their own local design...

[@dadiguntara3937]

@@eeta291 korban pengajaran Profesor halu Malaysia.. 😁

[@JakaIskandar]

Don't bring your your Malay archipelago concept made British to Indonesia, we don't recognize it... We have different concept and teaching

[@shahrumalong2362]

Ras tiada...suku ada bangsa nama negara 😮.. jatidiri tiada.. makanan milik tiongkok..tukar nama.. orang tiongkok jadi cindo😊

[@noefvon]

Batik is javanese, just use different name bro.. if its different batik why u didnt even create the word other than "batik"

[@sun_wukong90]

@@dadiguntara3937 betul la apa dia cakap kalau tak mcm mana selat melaka jadi pusat perdagangan dunia seketika dahulu antara 2 benua (eropah dan asia) macam mana islam tersebar di malaysia dan hubungan diplomatik dengan cina ketika itu dalam sejarah buku teks malaysia ada tak taulah kalau buku teks sejarah indonesiaa macam mana...ini bukan klaim budaya sewaktu indonesia dan malaysia wujud mmg dahulu budaya itu berkongsian maklum jarak indonesia dan maalaysia tak jauh lain la budaya barat mau diklaim maalaysia

[@fuadarif4056]

Malaysia and Indonesia are Nusantara people. it’s after colonialism it has becoming a ‘claiming’ game. This should not be the case anymore.. time to move on and make the region better.

[@AnasSuhaimi]

I don't buy the "Nusantara" thing. Sriwijaya yes. Not Nusantara. Even some Indonesians don't believe the Nusantara claim.

[@endrajayajaya1826]

Dah dri abad ke 7, di nusantara di dah ada kerajaan masing2, dan dah dari dulu2 juga saling berperang, salah betul mengatakan alam melayu satu

[@AnasSuhaimi]

@@endrajayajaya1826 "Nusantara" adalah istilah ciptaan Majapahit, merujuk pada wilayah jajahan mereka (kononnya) padahal tidak ada bukti pun mereka telah menjajah seluas itu. Paling-paling cuma selatan Sumatera dan selatan Kalimantan (kawasan Banjar). Tidak ada bukti langsung mereka sudah berkuasa sehingga ke Semenanjung dan Filipina.

[@endrajayajaya1826]

@@AnasSuhaimi pointnya adalah "alam melayu itu tak wujud" kan??? Sebab dari dulu2 pun dah ada kerajaan sendiri2 di kepulaun ini, so sangat salah prof korang yg mengatakan melayu dahulu satu

[@endrajayajaya1826]

@@AnasSuhaimi sekarang aku tanya, kenapa jawa minang banjar bugis dan lain2 di malaysia disebut melayu?? Padahal jawa dan minang tu lain suku ,melayu juga lain suku tetapi kenapa korang samakan dgn melayu?? , tetapi juga kenapa orang sarwak dan sabah tak disebut melayu?

[@mohdzamrimohamed7030]

Malaysian batik is from Malaysia. Indonesian batik is from Indonesia. Same name " Batik" but totally 2 different batik either the quality or material or pattern or colour or equipment used. UNESCO already highlighted the matter except only some ignorant person who like to talk silly matter.

[@TaRunaX]

Agreed period.. Distinct different between the two. For the ocds read more😂

[@JakaIskandar]

I wanna ask you batik word originally come from?

[@JakaIskandar]

Once upon a time medini peninsula (Malaya) was a colony of Majapahit empire from Java, so there are many Javanese descent mostly in negeri Terengganu and Kelantan and they bring their cultures like batik and wayang kulit to Malaysia... So you know the story why there is batik in Malaysia... In opposite there is no Malay empires like Melaka or Johor ever invade Sumatera or Java.. That's why there is no Malay descent or heritage here

[@aeoe4999]

Indo 🇮🇩 = BATIK Malay🇲🇾 = Baju Lukis

[@Indo_Musik-e9p]

begini manusia memilihara kebodohan dangkal sekali pola pikirnya. hampir di negara asean ada semua batik tetapi mereka tidak berani meng klem batik berasalk dari negara mereka karena batik itu BRAN MILIK INDONESIA. ... dan sama piza indonesia juga bisa buat dan banyak modelnya tapi kami tidak berani meng klem piza berasal dari indonesia.. jadi bodoh jangan di pelihara Peak...

[@avunik]

Indonesians don't know their own history. They only know about Indonesia after 17 August 1947. They claimed many Malaysian malay originated from Indonesia but Indonesia only exists in 1947. They are so proud of the Indonesian language and their Indonesian people... Just ask them what their great grandmother/ grandfather called them self?? Cannot be Indonesia because the words Indonesia did not exist yet. No countries can claim any tribe culture as their. Many Javanese people migrate to the peninsula of Malaysia. They continue to practice their Javanese culture. Malaysia cannot claim that it is Malaysia culture so does Indonesia. It's Javanese culture. So does batik or any food cannot be claimed as belonging to any country. All that is Nusantara people culture (Malaysia, Indonesia, Brunei, Singapore, southern Thailand and southern Philippines). Before colonial times, there were no state borders.. all areas in Nusantara are governed by kings and Sultan. People didn't ask you, 'which countries are you from ' people will ask you ' who is your Sultan'

[@fabianicoles]

And why didnt you claim SARI Indian tobe sari malaysian...? India malaysia also malaysian kan... 😅 Why u just claims. Yang Indonesia punya u also want...

[@username-nomad]

The idea of nations has been the greatest hoax of human history. Before French Revolution, there were no such thing as a nation, just landlords that collect taxes and tenants that pay taxes, people did not identify themselves with the landlords (kings, emperors). All these Malaysia, Indonesia, Canada, China are all recent inventions 😂

[@dadiguntara3937]

@@avunik ini salah satu contohnya.. Kena ajaran Profesor halu dari Malaysia. 😁 Coba tunjukkan dimana terdapat prasasti prasasti kerajaan Melayu??? Di Malaysia?? Ga ada tuh... Adanya di Indonesia .. Di riau, di Kalimantan, di pulau Sumatera, di pulau Jawa... Ada di Malaysia???

[@SongsMalaysia]

@@fabianicoles the Indonesians who always say Malaysia like to claim this and that never actually investigated or learn their history. Those who travel alot knows many countries share similar food, clothes etc but have slightly different taste or design but never get emotional and claim their neighbouring steal their culture. I have many educated Indonesian friends who lived overseas and in Malaysia. They acknowledged that Malaysian has own batik, rendang satay cendol taste different and etc. Just because the name sounds the same, it doesn’t mean the same thing.

[@xshiro83]

@@dadiguntara3937 prasasti ligor dan grahi..

[@sariahlimat1315]

Technically 🇲🇾 Malaysia 30 years advanced than Indonesia 🇮🇩.

[@priaberharga]

@@sariahlimat1315 in your dream haha

[@Tuan.multituli]

So what?

[@daddykarl3312]

While Malaysia is to be a HIGH INCOME COUNTRY nxt year 2025...technically YES!...😊😊😊

[@shevaroesdy]

Cuma Kuala lumpur yg advanced... Itu pun mayoritas penduduknya cina India dan Bangladesh 🤣🤣🤣

[@Bilbilaul]

And yet Malaysians lost their culture 😂

[@cutakecare2020]

Lots of comments from Malaysia make more sense. Wonder what’s it’s like asking a Mexican about Ameican or a French Canadian about British Canadian??

[@abdulrazaksulaiman2211]

Indonesia = Indian Archipelago Rupiah = Rupee Jakarta = Dhakar Garuda = Garud/Garuda Bali Sundaram = India Sundaram Reog/Pendet dance = Peacock dance (India)

[@littlegarden1304]

Mengarang indah

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

Like 👍

[@shahrumalong2362]

😂😂😂😂😂😂... tiada jati diri..ras tiada.. suku ada.. bangsa...nama negara

[@kangrmc9986]

Malaydes 😂😂😂 in kl 😂

[@YarisGr-ir5rz]

@@littlegarden1304ya ga ngarang itu bang indonesia itu ya kepulauan india

[@HappyGolfCart-uz3ft]

Both Indonesia n Malaysia have strong brotherhood relationships ...Nobody should be allowed to instigate n break us apart.. both Malaysian n Indonesian brothers should not argue about little petty things which could be capitalized by ' outsiders ' ... Probably Malaysians speak slightly better English while our brothers and sisters in Indonesian may not be as fluent making them having slight difficulty expressing their true n honest opinion about Malaysia Indonesia relationship.. . stay calm n lets love each other more...

[@Kartalaksana]

Well said ❤

[@kelawarman]

Totally agree

[@Red_Mask_1]

I don't get some of the comments here bashing Indonesians in the video. As a Malaysian myself seeing this video, I only see well mannered individuals expressing their thoughts on the topic. No foul language whatsoever, not even derogatory in the slightest sense. Please be respectful of one another

[@noordinbeldenlex1620]

The claim made by Malaysians that batik originated there is blatantly false. It was never claimed by Malaysians. However, some Malaysians made and sold batik in Malaysia especially those originated from Indonesia, and therefore we have to tell our customers that the batik is made in Malaysia because of the quality differences. For instance, Indonesian Batik Solo is far better quality. Therefore, as batik is an Indonesian product, we cannot and should not deceive our clients, especially foreign visitors. Can they claim that their Batik is from Indonesia if they print some Batik motives even in Hawaii? The same is true of rendang; we Malaysians have never asserted that it originated in Malaysia. Naturally, since the rendang was not prepared in Indonesia, we must state that it originated in our kitchen in our country. Could you be upset with an English chef serving you a burger that came from his kitchen back home if you were eating burgers in the United Kingdom? I believe you should avoid from posing delicate and controversial topics because not all of the people you interview will be able to provide you with insightful replies that won't enrage netizens in both nations.

[@7sevenfish27]

Well said!

[@endrajayajaya1826]

Aku dah sering jumpa orang2 jawa ,banjar dan minang kat malaysia , diorang tahu budaya yang mereka gunakan itu berasal dari indonesia macam batik, rendang, pakasam, tapi yang aku hairan kenapa pula melayu yang mengklaim itu budaya melayu??? Padahal melayu dan jawa tu lain, melayu dan minang tu lain

[@endrajayajaya1826]

Aku pernah juga bawa orang2 banjar malaysia pergi ke tanah leluhur mereka kat banjarmasin kalimantan selatan, menangis diorang ketika sampai mengingat pedihnya sejarah dulu2 hinga terpaksa berhijrah ke malaysia, jd selama ni yg klaim budaya itu ialah orang2 melayu yg tak paham sejarah

[@bkansapa2323]

​@@endrajayajaya1826😅😅😅😅sok2 tau. Betul tak bererti benar.

[@safuwanfauzi5014]

batik malong is good, i buy at shopee i love Filipino batik. and also filipino rendang maranao also good. keris bangsamoro Philippine also unique. (it smua asal indonesiaaaa, klaim klaim klam king of klaim)

[@ahmadjohanahmadtajuddin4791]

This is a good approach interviewing Indonesia what they thought of Malaysia. Great job Ben.

[@SafaNadia-v9f]

Been few times to Malaysia, so far all of them left good impression and memories for me! People are so nice and it's easy for me to interact with the locals. Tho i've only been to around KL, someday I rlly wanted to visit Langkawi, Penang, and Kota Kinabalu the most for more adventures.. the food also can never go wrong, even when i'm on a budget but when it comes to food i should not hold back LOL! Will have a quick visit again in November & stay in Sepang for the first time~ can't wait!

[@xshiro83]

I think she meant Genting Highland. There is a cable car called skyway

[@kayellai5278]

1:20 That is correct Skyway cable car in Genting Highlands. One of the fastest cable car in this region.

[@hplagt6880]

We Malaysians NEVER claim other countries' culture. And we never claim to be a developed country except those experts who say so.

[@kureed79]

Batik is not from Indonesia. It is from the Khmer-Champa period where nowadays Malaysia part off.

[@jackjamara7099]

Apakah di khmer-champa namanya BATIK!! OTAK kalo bodoh jangan di pelihara

[@Bilbilaul]

Semua dari Malaysia. Native Malaya is Melayu but all southeast Asians ethnics groups from Malaya?😁

[@MohddaudSalleh-e4b]

Dahulu kala sblum wujudkan Indonesia dan Malaysia mmg suda terkait persaudaraan keluarga mmg suda wujud sbb tu selepas kemerdekaan dan pembahagian di lakukan penjajah baru wujudnya Indonesia dn Malaysia, sbb tu Indonesia dan Malaysia berkongsi pelbagai tradisi, bahasa, budaya dll.

[@mrj475]

No they are not, its totally nonsense..

[@mawarberduri2865]

Where does the term 'wayang kulit' come from? 'Wayang kulit' is a Malay word. We also have the origin of the word 'batik', which is 'baris and titik' meaning lines and dots, or the word 'bacik', which means tattoo. Remember, the Indonesian language originates from the Malay language. UNESCO has never said that batik comes from Java, Indonesia.

[@noehahanji]

What does wayang means in Malay word? "Wayang" is Javanese word which means "shadow" or "bayang"

[@noehahanji]

And Batik was actually from two Javanese words: Amba and Titik (ambatik)

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@noehahanjistop stealing bahasa Melayu kak 🤭🤣 please use your bahasuck cacingan javad0g okeh kak 🤭🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️💩

[@noefvon]

​@@noehahanjithey are halu lol, even its written there in wikipedia that it is javanese

[@mawarberduri2865]

@@noehahanji In Malaysia, "wayang" has many meanings: it refers to puppets and performances. In Javanese, "wayang" means "puppet," but in Indonesian, "wayang" refers to "shadows." Is 'bayang' in Javanese 'wewayangan'? In Javanese, 'wayang' and 'wewayangan' are different. Wayang means puppet, while wewayangan means shadow.

[@asyraffrahim8303]

Aku doa supaya Aceh bebas, Riau bebas, Palembang, Jambi dan Sumatera bebas dari pegangan Jawanesia. Bebaskan Orang Papua, orang Kalimantan pun harus bebas. Biar indonesia jadi hanya negara jawa dan sunda. Biar suku2 lain bebas, negara korup dan rasis

[@mazlinarazelan3805]

korup, tindas eknik lain dan ikut tradisi bodoh toksik dan pemikiran kuno dlm dunia pasca moden. ya

[@afgandarudin4338]

😂 Apa urusan Anda. Ocehan anda lebih mirip seperti ocehan bocah ingusan.😂 Sejak dulu yang salah bukan karena Jawa. Tapi karena pondasi Adab leluhur yang tidak dibangun.

[@goldenrain5151]

setuju

[@halfease96]

Itulah impian Rakyat di Kepulauan Riau, Aceh dan Sumatra

[@m.salmanalfarisi4932]

🤓

[@Dee_Perspextve]

Actually, the history in both countries is clear, but what makes them different is how they understand the story behind it. According to my friend who are Indonesian himself, In Indonesia, most of the history they learn in school is about how their ancestors fought to build a country called Indonesia. If they wanna know more than that, such as relation between countries in this region, they have to learn about these archipelago from their old folks or other third party sources. And of course, when they learn history from their elders, different tribes will tell different stories and interpretations. Meanwhile in Malaysia, we are not only taught about how our country was built, but we also being taught about the Malay Achiepelago in our History class since high school, most of us were taught well to understand what happened in this archipelago back in the past, since 600AD until now. I think it's the same with our Singaporean and Bruneian brother and sisters. That is why Malaysian never had any problem with Singaporean and Bruneian when it comes to historical knowledge. But, it's just a little different with Indonesians because they don't have standard knowledge when it comes to human civilization in this region. However, all the disagreements that happen between us are like a conflict between brothers and sisters.

[@kelawarman]

Spot On!!

[@agunglaksono421]

Our Differences are the influence of colonialism, even when the British colonized Indonesia, Thomas Raffles wrote a book about Java and never gave credit.

[@agunglaksono421]

The way to be independent is also different. Maybe that's the reason Soekarno confronted you guys, you still have a colonial mentality.

[@agunglaksono421]

Talking about Indonesian history. Our history is completely stored by the Dutch. And the Netherlands is a country that is famous for often recording history.

[@daddykarl3312]

Thats a wide different of Education between Malaysia and Indonesia...no wonder there are five Universities of Malaysia in the TOP 10 Best University in South East Asia...Rank 3,4,5,6 and 7 placed...😅😅😅

[@amirijaz894]

Ben, you don’t “live” in Malaysia…you’re a tourist. Technically, not even on a digital nomad visa….so excessive content creation in Malaysia for YT money may be a violation of your tourist visa terms.

[@natrahmohammad8979]

Biar supaya dia tahu. Let him be. If things go south later on, he knows what he did and the consequences.

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

Yup don't take for granted just to make some quick bucks not worth a penny bro

[@InvestingWithAdamK]

I would highly doubt that is a violation. I work on a computer and when I travel continue to work. My job is still in the US. Ben just works remotely when he travels

[@hhhmedia]

i guess everything on earth belongs to indonesia 🤡

[@kelawarman]

😂😂😂

[@JakaIskandar]

Indeed

[@hhhmedia]

@@JakaIskandar yea that’s why indonesia are 20 years behind, bcs you guys are delusional hehe 😣

[@hhhmedia]

⁠@@JakaIskandar indonesia are just a clown in SEA you know 😂 always see their neighbour countries as a threat. even when the big companies like apple, tesla, microsoft & many more big companies don’t want to invest in indonesia, they gon start blaming their neighbour countries 😂

[@royanjunior9782]

nope, Indonesian never said that, indonesian just defend their culture and food from malaysian claims!!

[@arinarin7464]

Malaysia owned 70% of palm oil in indonesia...several Malaysian banks are top 7 financial institutions...basically indonesian ecomomy is controlled by Malaysia

[@cloudddd381]

whopper. .. keep dreaming😂😂

[@simmbachtiar663]

@@cloudddd381 real

[@hanxhaykidsdiaries8044]

@@cloudddd381 1) IOI Corp punya 21 lebih hektar ladang sawit di indonesia, juga kilang dan pusat penyelidikan di indonesia. 2) KLK punya 54% ladang sawit di indonesia ( pulau belitung, kalimantan & sumatera) 3) united plantation punya 20% ladang sawit di indonesia. 4) Felda Global Venture punya 5 estet ladang sawit di kalimantan tengah dan kalbat. Jadi, majoriti ladang sawit di indonesia kepunyaan Syarikat Sawit gergasi malaysia.

[@cloudddd381]

@@hanxhaykidsdiaries8044 🤣... Di indonesia ada banyak perusahaan besar... Ini beberapa perusahaan penguasa sawit di indonesia..mereka punya lahan jutaan hektar 1.PT Sinar Mas Agro Resources and Technology Tbk.... 2. PT Astra Agro Lestari Tbk 3. PT Salim ivomas pratama Tbk 4. PT Dharma Satya Nusantara Tbk 5. PT Triputra Agro Persada Tbk

[@cloudddd381]

@@hanxhaykidsdiaries8044 Di indonesia ada banyak perusahaan besar... Ini beberapa perusahaan penguasa sawit di indonesia..mereka punya lahan jutaan hektar 1. PT Sinar Mas Agro Resources and Technology Tbk.... 2. PT Astra Agro Lestari Tbk 3. PT Salim ivomas pratama Tbk 4. PT Dharma Satya Nusantara Tbk 5. PT Triputra Agro Persada Tbk

[@sharilsamad9727]

You lost weight. A little something to treat yourself, eat something nice.

[@benfishermin]

Thanks a lot!

[@diazjulianms]

As Indonesian I always feel embarassed everytime Indonesians bring up this cultures claiming topic, I really hate it because we are one people we are cousins we are family but we only divided by countries, if more Indonesian can acknowledge the fact that CULTURAL EXCHANGED HAPPENED WAY BEFORE INDONESIA AND MALAYSIA EVEN EXIST, there will be no need to claim or be mad, I mean I’d bet not all cultures from Indonesia that Indonesian would recognize and not all Indonesian also know that some cultures we have actually originated outside from Indonesia, so please stop bring culture claiming topic because it’s literally useless instead why don’t we focus to be a better country, developing each other countries together, most Malaysians are always the one with this attitude while some or even most Indonesians stuck with the ‘claiming cultures’ attitude 🙃

[@muhd7144]

9:10 This lady, as with practically all Indonesians, seemed to assume that "Melayu" (the Malays) in Indonesia are about the same as "Melayu" (the Malays) in Malaysia. This is not entirely correct. To start with, the Malays in Indonesia are one of several ethnic groups, each with distinct language and culture. It's a very small ethnic group comprising less than 3% of Indonesia's 280 million population. The most predominant ethnic groups being Javanese (about 40%) and Sundanese (about 15%). In contrast, the Malays in Malaysia are not entirely defined by ethnicity as in Indonesia but by a legal provision, specifically by Article 160(2) of the Malaysian Constitution - Malaysia's highest law. Basically under that provision a "Malay" is someone who follows the religion of Islam, who habitually speaks the Malay language and practices the Malay culture. But in effect any person from Indonesia - be that person a Javanese or Sundanese or whatever but so long as he/she a Muslim - upon becoming a Malaysian citizen (through marriage or naturalisation) will be considered a Malay.

[@Northman46]

There are both sides of citizens who are very toxic on the internet, they like to criticize other countries and they feel nationalis, maybe lack of education makes someone be like that because in Malaysia also many people are unable to get higher education because the economy is still not balanced to the whole country I think that is the reason if they are well educated they will know the history and all this will not happen

[@salonnouveaunouveau3882]

Most Malays are from Jawa and Padang (Minangkabau) so they brought their culture along Long before this Archipelago was known as Nusantara. Borderless.

[@mawarberduri2865]

Not many, really. There are more locals in Malaysia.

[@bashed1000]

Sorry nope. Malay in the north not Jawa or Minangkabau. What the heck!

[@abdmanafali2975]

12:12 - Ben, i have to remind you on shaking hands with Muslims... please do not use your left hand to handshake someone offering their right hand. The left hand, although clean as it is... should not be used for shaking hands with a Muslim. Muslims use their left hand to clean after themselves after defecating. Its rather rude to shake hands using the left hand instead of the right. I hope this advise is useful for you.

[@minnaihatsu]

I remember that moment too, and I read from Ben's gestures that he knew that. But at that moment - since the situation came up so quickly (as they sometimes do even though we try or should be prepared) he "kind of" shook with his left hand. With his smile he apologized, in a way.

[@iskhrm1688]

The first wave of Javanese immigrants came to Malaysia around 700+ years ago during the Malacca Sultanate, the nation of Indonesia came only into existence in 1945. 😂 - Bahasa Indonesia = Malay + English vocabularies & claimed as Bahasa Indonesia. The only "language" in the world with birth date, i.e. 1928.😆 The American never rename English as American Language, so as the Brazillian never rename Portuguese as Lingua Brassileira 🤣

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

There you go!!

[@JakaIskandar]

Lah terserah kita donk, kok lu ngatur... Ga Terima?

[@iskhrm1688]

@@JakaIskandar sebab itu susah maju nya

[@Bilbilaul]

Indonesia existence in 1945? What about Malaysia existence? 1948?😂

[@iskhrm1688]

@@Bilbilaul existence date is irrelevant, cultures created & possesed by the people/tribes, thats uncontested fact.

[@Tahyetahtidak]

Malaysia,indonesia,brunei,singapore, even southenr thai we are one, we share a lot of similarities, but after colonialism we shit separate by them. And the important thing is “Bahasa melayu” still relevant become our “root”

[@fuadarif4056]

Ben can I suggest that your interview zoom on to understand the region - maybe about you understanding the region. The interview about beautiful woman etc2 don’t feel contextually relevant to where you are. You are hundreds thousands miles from home. Maybe it could be about language, or cultural norms. Or maybe asked people about being being Asian.. what is their aspirations with the region

[@ballcollector70]

Indonesia is jealous of Malaysia's success in various fields that is why Indonesia wants to claim everything while it is all a cultural similarity.

[@JakaIskandar]

Why do we have to be jealous to small and weak country... No reason... It just only in your megalomaniac thinking

[@royanjunior9782]

jealous? we have rich culture than Malaysia, Malaysia always claim everythings from Indonesia

[@daddykarl3312]

The main thing is...we hv similarity in culture​@@royanjunior9782....Historically..and a long long time ago...peoples around the Malays nusantara migrates to the lands...to Malaya..and bring their culture along...Unless if Malaysia is in Middle east or europe...then i wud considered!....Amd Malaysia is more advanced on INFRASTRUCTURE, EDUCATION, HEALTH and SDM is lot higher...2025 Malaysia will be a High Income Country and move to be advance country...😊😊😊

[@Rafi14022]

Ngimpi 😂 Jealous apa sama negara Malaydesh? 😂😂😂

[@suhaimiabdan3403]

@@royanjunior9782rich culture with low income.

[@10000years]

The first girl, if she’s still single and wanted to meet a Malaysian guy, I’m available

[@VictorPeter]

1:50 i think she meant Genting Highland cable car

[@kayellai5278]

That is correct Skyway cable car in Genting Highlands. One of the fastest cable car in this region.

[@RajeshRavindranathan]

Asking whether Batik comes from Malaysia or Indonesia is like asking where did Latin come from, England or France?

[@kelawarman]

👍😂😂

[@7imbu]

Lalu budaya India di Malaysia apakah bisa dikatakan budaya Malaysia..atau budaya etnis India di malaysia😂

[@RajeshRavindranathan]

​@@7imbu There is no such thing as a pure culture. Whether in Malaysia, Indonesia or even India, those who think that are generally racists.

[@7imbu]

@@RajeshRavindranathan Pizza berasal dari Italia, meskipun di Amerika ada pizza tp Amerika tidak pernah mengklaim pizza asli dari Amerika 😂

[@Bilbilaul]

Since there are lot of indians in Malaysia that's mean indian cultures and cuisine from Malaysia?😂

[@sadiqsalihoddin1087]

Saya dari Malaysia. Saya menyeru orang Malaysia yang menonton video ini abaikan sahaja isinya. Ini perbincangan akal rendah. Kita perlu melepaskan diri daripada membincangkan batik dari mana, makanan itu dari mana dan sebagainya. Kalau semua itu milik Indonesia, biarkanlah. Tak penting pun. Kita fokus pada membangunkan negara kita, jom!

[@azidinzidin9234]

Batik actually from India, but Malaysia with it's own design & different than Indonesian's style.. so, no need to argue that small matter cause it dosen't bring progress to anyone's mind..

[@suhaimiabdan3403]

You’re right. Indian didn’t claim and why they obsess claiming that they are theirs.

[@abzonearth]

Batik itu teknik nya ya bukan coraknya, coraknya banyak versi china, india, belanda, malaysia kita mengakui itu versi corak jadi kalau teknik membatik itu jelas dari Jawa, bahkan di negara Afrika batik sudah banyak dijadikan kreativitas tapi mereka mengakui original batik berasal dari Indonesia

[@azidinzidin9234]

@@suhaimiabdan3403 because their mentality are very poor😅

[@adhityanurrohman9115]

Menurut Museum Sejarah Budaya Oslo, diketahui secara pasti bahwa orang Jawa memengaruhi pembuatan batik Melayu secara teknis maupun dalam pengembangan desain. Pada tahap awal, orang Malaysia menggunakan balok kayu untuk menghasilkan tekstil yang menyerupai batik. Hingga akhir tahun 1920-an, para pembatik Jawa memperkenalkan penggunaan balok lilin dan tembaga di pantai timur Malaysia. Produksi komersial dimulai pada tahun 1960-an. Kerajinan ini telah mengembangkan estetika dan desainnya sendiri, khususnya di Malaysia. Batik Malaysia yang baru jelas berbeda dari batik khas Jawa yang dilukis dengan tangan.[4] Batik Malaysia dapat ditemukan di pantai timur Malaysia seperti Kelantan, Terengganu, dan Pahang. Batik di Johor jelas menunjukkan pengaruh Jawa dan Sumatera karena populasi Jawa dan Sumatera yang besar di Malaysia selatan.

[@Tipe-M.a.l.a.s]

Dari India.? Serius banget membela serumpun nya.😅😅

[@alifahmadi6094]

Nasi goreng China, Lumpia China, bakso makanan khas China yang ditukar nama, soto China, mi ayam China, siomay China kak indoNECIA claim again 🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️

[@Benygarage]

Yg komen naturalisasi dari bangla ini 😂😂😂

[@shahrumalong2362]

😂😂😂 ..cindo .. China tiongkok. China Indonesia.

[@Benygarage]

@@shahrumalong2362 ini orang bangla koment lagi😂🤣

[@shahrumalong2362]

@@Benygarage tau itu teori Darwin??cocok buat kamu 😆.. warga 62+ dari rata rata IQ78 sudah turun kelas..62

[@deyeezchanel2763]

Wkwk... Coba luh cek di China daratan apakah ada baso. Soto. Siomay. Nasi goreng. Mie ayam. Dan coba luh search di google. Chat gpt. Wikipedia dari mana makanan itu berasal.. Kalau negara luh satupun tak punya makanan. Nasi lemak itu nasi uduk brasal dari Indonesia yg di ganti namanya. Nasi kandar makanan khas india. Bakuteh sop babi makanan dari China. Cuman makanan itu yg malay punya itupun hasil klaim kasian ssekali negara luh minum budaya. Tradisi. Kuliner sejarah seni. Semuanya ada di malay semua di curi dari Indonesia orang luar negri yg bilang dunia pun sudah tahu negara luh negara tukang klaim tukang curi. Kasian negara luh di kenal dunia cuman di kenal sebagai negara tukang klaim dan paling Rasis di dunia. Apa hebatnya negara luh. Ngaku islam perjunuan. Penjualan arak di legalkan negara malay adalah negara paling aneh dan paling bodoh paling tak kreative di dunia. Negara halu tukang klaim dari nabi Adam sampe nabu muhammad istri nabi muhammmad sahabat nabi semua di klaim dari Malaysia. Luh pikir negara yg ada di dunia itu cuman Malaysia wkwkw.. Dunia lagi menertawakan negara anda apa anda tidak punya rasa malu..

[@penukulbesi4006]

Songket from Malaysia as well as Indonesia says Malaysia claims when it is Malay clothing and until now it is used for Aidilfitri celebration.

[@JakaIskandar]

Please learn history first before comment

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@JakaIskandarsongket is from Malaysia kak UNESCO already approve 🤭🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️💩

[@hailakmal4683]

​@@JakaIskandarterpaling history lak indon ni😂

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@JakaIskandarinoNECIA stop copy India culture and chinese food and stealing bahasa Melayu kak 🤭🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️💩

[@ritathem4726]

Real joke ..at 9.10 that lady & the guy spoke in bahasa Indonesia and our anchor is nodding his head as though he understands their language ..ha ha .I guess after this interview Ben would appreciate the level of English in Malaysia

[@JakaIskandar]

Ye lah kan kalian budak British... We agree with you

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@JakaIskandaryuk aarr beyy ceyyy bahasuck cacingan javad0g+belanda kak 🤭🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️💩

[@dearrylh8924]

do they welcome us with our language if we go to their country?

[@新炒饭]

​@@JakaIskandarbudak belanda

[@muzakkir64]

Most Indonesian wish they were born in Malaysia but not the other way around 😂

[@Bilbilaul]

Lmao nope. Malaysia doesn't have any identity and very segregated country😂😂

[@amirijaz894]

Ben, to be honest, I don’t like the path these new style videos are taking. Many of them are about comparing one culture against another, who started this first, what do you think about that culture, etc. it’s a bit childish actually. It would be more interesting to be more intellectual and focus mainly on their own culture, what it has to offer, etc.

[@safuwanfauzi5014]

indonesia started first everthing from nasi goreng(fried rice), sumatran tiger, arowana fish, batik, reog, wayang kulit/shadow puppet, lumpia, onde-onde, everthing belong to them, Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei and Philippine cannot used or list as country heritage. very sad mentality, i never saw UK bash US and Australia or China bash chinese diaspora about culture.

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

​@@safuwanfauzi5014 true. Goes to show how low thier... Nevermind Ben knows betger 🤣🤣

[@TalabJhon]

​@@safuwanfauzi5014Haha .itulah keragaman indonesia dari makanan sampai adat istiadat.bahasa .Indonesia paling beragam bro

[@JakaIskandar]

​​@@safuwanfauzi5014off course because it's belong to Indonesia, Malaysia only imitate...please create your own culture😂😂

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@JakaIskandarinoNECIA stop copy India culture and chinese food and stealing bahasa Melayu kak 🤭🤣☠️🇮🇩☠️💩🤣

[@justrk3980]

One simple question they dare not answer is that where does their ancestors came from thousands of years ago after the creation of ship 😂😂😂..its weird with same body features they tends to believe they are separate race

[@Bilbilaul]

From Taiwan, and they migrated to Philippines, then to Indonesian 😂 alam Melayu has been debunked

[@WorldIsNotCruel]

Batik exist since majapahit empire that is java empire. The malaysia included in majapahit land, even singapore and brunei now also can claim the batik theirs because they also include in majapahit empire

[@pawehbsam5872]

what most of Indonesian doesn't know is that Malaysia also have Javanese people, Banjarese people, Bugis people, Minang people even before the existence of Malaysia and Indonesia..when Indonesian think that Malaysia is hold only by the Malay people but not the other races/ethnics that is why we always fighting to claiming culture things in social media..

[@新炒饭]

Indonesian only know malays 🙄

[@pawehbsam5872]

@@新炒饭 so what??

[@silanong]

I think this channel has quite a unique content compared to other channels. I hope it continues to develop better and better, more and more interesting. Perhaps you could do an interview of Malaysian who married expat.

[@benfishermin]

Thanks a lot, I really appreciate you supporting by becoming a member 🙏

[@Ron_Lombok]

Malaysia and Indonesia historically one nation and one race. Indonesians are welcome migrate to Malaysia.

[@JakaIskandar]

Actually Malaysia is Indonesian diaspora country except Chinese and Indian... Also Bangla don't forget😂😂

[@izdnghz]

You've touched on a very sensitive topic, especially between these two countries. Coming from an outsider or expat, it's important to recognize that you may have limited understanding of the cultural nuances involved

[@axelanamwatever7408]

Before colonization part of Malaysia and part of Indonesia are one empire,so u could say both share same culture but the real question is who claim it faster😂

[@hailakmal4683]

Its jawa supremacy who always barbar when it comes to malay 😂

[@daddykarl3312]

Yea!...unforrunately they understand Malaysia is somewhere in Europe or Middle east!...😂😂😂

[@AV4U2]

Excellent work there, brother! Keep'em coming! So, it seems that both countries claim the same cultural heritage. It sounds like they are both correct, in that, they are the same people, just migrating from one island to another and keeping their traditions. We should do a DNA test to confirm that. PS: That handshake using your left hand was priceless! I couldn't stop laughing for the reasons that you know of and that most Americans have no clue of what I'm talking about right now... too funny, bro... Let's gooooo! Cheers

[@given_mill7]

Real life people and online people are 100% different..

[@abangjek9350]

it is thought to be over 1000 years old, with historical evidence pointing to its use in parts of Africa, Asia, and the Middle East. Although the actual origins of batik are unknown, it is believed to have been transported to Asia by way of the Indian subcontinent. “Batik” is derived from an Indonesian-malay word, which is now often used as a generic term referring to the process of dyeing fabric.

[@tazzznphilly]

I loved watching this. Indonesians seem to be so kind and friendly. Thanks for showing that to me..a USA guy. ~ Tazzz ~

[@benfishermin]

Jakarta really had some of the nicest people, it was easy to make friends there. I'd say I stuck out a lot more than in Kuala Lumpur, there were barely any western people at all, I saw very few in my whole 4 days there.

[@andytulubay7682]

Keep it up ben.. this is great content..🎉

[@Dasa22222]

In unesco page itself stated that batik name origin is indonesian-malay. Obviously it is malay language and not Javanese language. So javanese please stop claiming batik

[@TalabJhon]

Batik dari Jawa guys ..kota saya di juluki kota batik di Jawa tengah .sejak ratusan tahun lalu

[@mawarberduri2865]

@@TalabJhon pergi baca unesco tulis. batik bukan dari jawa

[@TalabJhon]

@@mawarberduri2865 dari Jawa guys .saya sudah baca

[@noefvon]

U are spreading hoax lol, its written in wikipedia batik is mbatik (javanese)

[@Dasa22222]

@@noefvon wikipedia edited by indon for indon

[@eddylee7786]

Great job! This is the first video I ever watched about how Indonesians think about Malaysia 👍

[@almas806]

Genting Highlands lah (1.58). Nasi goreng, batik, etc were around way before there was a country called Indonesia or Malaysia. It belongs to the Nusantara.

[@penjahatbandung]

Not Batik, Batik is from Java. Specifically Java. I'm Indonesian Sundanese, we don't even claim Batik from us. Batik is belong to them the Javanese. Even the word Mbatik, Ambatik is from them meaning making dots or writing dots. But the traditional clothes like Songket or Pencak Silat, you might say it belongs to the Nusantara

[@gingerteddy618]

​@@penjahatbandungYou are talking about Indonesian batik. BATIK in Malaysia is a Malay word. Batik refers to natural patterns found in plants and animals. Batik adalah istilah Melayu. Batik adalah corak alamiah yang terdapat pada tumbuhan seperti Keladi Batik, Buluh Batik dan corak haiwan seperti Ular Sawa Batik dan Ayam Bulu Batik. Batek adalah suku kaum di Semenanjung tetapi dieja menggunakan e untuk memudahkan pemahaman apabila ditulis Batek. Teluk Batik adalah nama tempat di Semenanjung. Batik adalah perkataan dan budaya Melayu.

[@gingerteddy618]

Dalam website unesco menyatakan asal-usul batik TAK DIKETAHUI. Dan yang didaftar di Unesco adalah batik dari indonesia didaftar sebagai warisan indonesia. Batik negara lain tidak didaftarkan sebagai budaya indonesia. Masalah sebab indonesia tak reti baca. Yang indonesia lebih lebih klaim sampai Batik negara lain pun dia klaim.

[@maunglodaya]

@@penjahatbandung As sundanese myself, do you know that we have old batik tradition, share with central java batik culture, the original batik as identifiction where you come from, what is your social class, and if you have royal blood, who is your main royal blood or your ancestor. This is what original batik is about, from java island regardless the tribe, sundanese, or javansese. Sundanese has older culture, even older story that already a legend in tarumanegara era, the kingdom of sunda, it is where sunda word come from, the ancient kingdom that already achieved gemah ripah repeh rapih, prosper for everyone. This is why other culture or countries who claim batik would never know let alone understand the secret information of batik patern and colour, let alone have they own identification for occupation, social class, royal blood etc, even for javanese and sundanese this knowledge is almost gone if not already. Regardless pencak silat, do you know even some expert dont really know what pencak silat mean, and the differences between pencak silat and silat. Do you know that pencak mean dance, come from your own tribe language that not many people used it anymore. Just like sundanese hardly used kumeli rather than use kentang for potatoe.

[@JakaIskandar]

Indonesia is Nusantara not Malaysia weei.... Don't bring Nusantara (Indonesian term) into yours😂😂

[@Lady.Lynn.Z]

The age old argument. Never ending. Money can never buy experience so I hope you've acquired the experience. I can't say for the others but for most of the Malaysians I know including myself, we just don't care what originated from where, who invented what. We normally don't start a fire but if we're burned you'll definitely see/hear us 😂

[@biancaaprilia-l1q]

no one says Malaysia is a developed and great country........try asking about Japan...they will definitely answer that it is a developed country

[@Bongkodok]

Bro,please review back the video.Got or not the Admin asking about the developed Country.?He just asking about the culture and what the different and similar bittwen Malaysia and lndonesia.lm never hear the admin asking about the Developed from both Cuontry.Are you sleeping while you watching the video..?😂😂😂

[@biancaaprilia-l1q]

@@Bongkodok Malaysia negara paling maju sedonia 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@yunytotoro7184]

​@@Bongkodokitulah tiber, aku rasa dia macm penyakit lah tak tonton habis tapi terus judge bila ada perkataan terkait dengan Malaysia Indonesia

[@biancaaprilia-l1q]

​@@Bongkodok...malaysia negara paling hebat mendonia😅

[@SouthernCrossGO]

Learn bahasa malay bro Indonesian same language with a few dutch words added

[@mrarie930]

Indonesia claim Batik 😂 (ini kata penyataan dari unesco) (Statement from Unesco website) "Although the actual origins of batik are unknown, it is believed to have been transported to Asia by way of the Indian subcontinent. “Batik” is derived from an Indonesian-malay word" - sumber dari Unesco website "Meskipun asal usul batik yang sebenarnya tidak diketahui, diyakini telah diangkut ke Asia melalui anak benua India. "Batik" berasal dari kata Indonesia-Melayu" - Unesco. Unesco tidak pernah bilang "origins batik from indonesia". Tidak pernah dia bilang begitu. Unesco juga tidak mengakui batik dari indonesia. Indonesia malah ngaku2 sendiri😂

[@rokakaro3157]

mat saleh ni kalau interview touris d malaysia dia akan compare dgn thailand , d indo cuba melagakan indo msia tentang budaya , bangang agaknya kalau moyang2 beratus/ beribu tahun budaya dan adat nya lebih kurang samza, mau d bilang apa? nobody claim cuma lestari budaya atok nenek...itu oun jadi isu.

[@ajixslayergaming5359]

Buat mcm mana..dah mmg dari zaman penjajahan..kita orang asia ni masih bodoh..masih nak bergaduh..sedangkan bangsa eropah rilex je..yang nak bergaduh lagi tu lantak korangla..nak berjuang utk perang akhir zaman? Jangan harap..merdeka kan diri dahulu ..zahir dan batin..kalau tak sampai kiamat la duk bergaduh benda yang sia sia

[@Emo_Girl-]

indonesia meaning is indian islands. Nobody start from the island ‼️

[@douglaswilliams4274]

The cable car at Genting Highlands

[@simonlow0210]

She was talking about Genting Highland, which is not in Kuala Lumpur. It is located in Pahang state.

[@kayellai5278]

If PAS wins Pahang state, there will be no more casino. PAS just announced their intention.

[@rosdibujang4769]

Malaysian batik is softer with a flora & fauna theme than Indonesian batik is more violent with an animal theme😅.Malaysians are more multicultural and can accept various races & religions from all over the world. Indonesian workers have many problems in Malaysia.😮Ringgi lebih tinggi berbanding Rupiah sangat rendah😢. apapun terima kasih Indonesia sudi membangunkan ekonomi M'sia juga ya.

[@rosdibujang4769]

Thank you Indonesian people who work in Asia who develop the Asian economy as well..😊

[@dhnitatau]

According to history, the similarity between Indonesian and Malaysian cuisine is due to the large migration of the Malay Minangkabau people from Indonesia to Malaysia, which began in the 15th century, around the 1400s. This migration process continued until the 19th century, particularly to the region of Negeri Sembilan, leading to a significant influence on Minangkabau culture and cuisine in Malaysia. Minangkabau/Padang is a province located in West Sumatra, Indonesia. Indonesians from Java who migrated in the 19th century played a role in bringing the batik tradition to Malaysia. Over time, though, Malaysian batik developed its own style and techniques, different from Javanese batik but still keeping its cultural roots.

[@junaiditimbang8497]

Ben,Now u in Indonesia and better u topic also about Indonesia.Help them to promote Indonesia through ur channel.

[@Kartalaksana]

Kesimpulan saya....org Indonesia tetap org2 yg baik & santun. Semoga dua2 netizen terus berantam ....namun dihati masing2 netizen tetap ada rasa hormat & menyayangi antara satu sama lain..😅

[@BrayenChen-v7e]

This person is only looking for subscribers for his channel and his own profit.

[@kelawarman]

Yup agree bro and very immature in my opinion

[@alonewithalones]

Such an important topic, Ben. It is nice to listen to each other to understand. I think you are doing us a great favour here 🙏 The problem is they don’t realise they are all one people. I mean, just use your eyes and look? Don’t they look the same?? The artificial divisions are the cause of this. They look at their different artificial flags, different artificial country names and think they are different from each other. Nature doesn’t have segregations like that. We need to go back to nature and learn from it instead of learning from compartmentalisation of flawed man/mind. There is a reason why colonials/sectarians have divided the world. Division makes a people weak. Peace.

[@nazli_ss]

Genting highlands. You should go there and take the skyway cable car, Ben.

[@Shariffudin-d7n]

No money bro 🤣🤣

[@Theperson1998]

🫲HAPPY INTERNASIONAL BATIK DAY🫱 🇲🇨 🇹🇭 🇵🇭 🇲🇾 🇱🇦 🇰🇭 🇧🇳 🇨🇳 🇻🇳 🇲🇲 🇹🇼

[@pangitko3142]

kaming mga pilipino wag niyo kami isali sa inyo dahil mga Austronesian kami, hindi nga kami naka intindi kung ano ang batik words sa inyo.

[@ditabahari5295]

Malaysia mostly malay or melayu, while indonesia is so diverse. You can see that western indonesia and eastern Indonesia are so different culturally. Indonesia also has malay people, mostly in west part. While in the capital jakarta mostly javanese. That's why official indonesia motto is unity in diversity..

[@SuhaimiAmir]

1:50 it's Genting Highland, She's explaining about the cable car Genting SkyWay or Awana Skyway

[@megstlimlim3386]

Malaysia was under British influence whereas Indonesia was under Dutch rule

[@Benygarage]

Pengaruh apa di bawah kekuasaan iya,merdeka aja di kasih sampai buat patung pahlawan inggris😂😂

[@sayfolman7752]

​@@BenygarageSekurangnya Gratis Bukan Bayar Udah Habis Bayar Utang Sama Belanda PayAway

[@Benygarage]

@@sayfolman7752 gratis apa bayarnya harus tunduk pada bayang2 inggris sampai di buat patung pahlawan dari inggris😂🤣😂

[@Indo_Musik-e9p]

@@sayfolman7752 gratis... mana ada penjajah memberi malaey ke melayu palsu gratis loe tetap bayar upeti selama 999 tahun goblok di pelihara🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@alifahmadi6094]

​@@Indo_Musik-e9ppay away Belanda giveaway jepang kak 9999 bilion gulden meja bundar ☠️🇮🇩☠️💩🤣

[@kratos8873]

I think that 1st Indonesian lady was trying to describe Genting Highlands. The 2 things that make me think that is 1. Sounds like she’s trying to describe the cable car going up to Genting Highlands and 2. She sad it’s in KL, maybe what she meant was she was driven from KL to Genting Highlands which takes like 45 mins to 1 hour. Genting is actually in Pahang

[@infinitecbs186]

Batik does exist since pharaoh regime in egypt decades ago. And does exist in china, india, africa 6000 years ago! Then after that going through the east india sea indonesia and so on. Malaysia batik motive was more towards floral and ISLAMIC CULTURE. Indonesia Batik motive was more towards animals and more to HINDUISM CULTURE. The javanese, minang, malays migrated to Malaya before Indonesia exist!

[@kelawarman]

Ben maybe you should ask indonesian what they think of Timor Leste or Papua New Guinea or Australia... Those are their closest neighbors too 😂😂

[@macTiger8711]

Ask about their beloved close neighbour. Which is Island Of Komodo...

[@noefvon]

​@@macTiger8711 what are u talking about lol

[@zawawiyahya1512]

Thanks you Ben for the video. That’s real life Indonesia people

[@bakarmadiasin3806]

Bro Ben..u really have to learn bhasa Malaysia...once y know Ba has Malaysia..would be freely move around in Indonsia Because Bhasa Indonesia Bhasa Malaysia has slight different.....this is similar to the British English n American English Both are understandable....the different is just the Slang

[@arisirawan9832]

If you want to know what year batik is, where can you learn batik? What year is it in Malaysia and what year is Indonesia? It can be explained using history.

[@infinitecbs186]

THE FACT IS INDONESIA LANGUAGE IS TAKEN FROM MALAY LANGUAGE (MALAYSIA NATIONAL LANGUAGE) BECAUSE OF JAVANESE LANGUAGE WAS TOO COMPLICATED TO BE LEARN BY MANY TRIBES IN INDONESIA. THEN THEYVE ADJUSTED OUR MALAY LANGUAGE TO BE INDONESIA LANGUAGE AND THE FUN FACT IS SOME OF THE WORDS AND SPELLING THEYD PRONOUNCE LIKE NETHERLANDS LANGUAGE THAT IS WHY INDONESIA LANGUAGE BECOME LIKE NOWADAYS.

[@setyawanherus5405]

Much issue kurang baik hubungan Indonesia-Malaysia, tetapi kenyataan dilapangan banyak WNI kerja di Malaysai begitu juga sebaliknya Kami WNI Indonesia mempunyai hubungan baik baik saja dengan warga malaysia di Qatar Salam Damai Indonesia Malaysia

[@GAJELAScc]

First Lady sounds like Filipino to me from the accents

[@lynharun4695]

I noticed that too, her English more to Filipino accents

[@pangitko3142]

😂😂😂 pilipino accent daw.😂😂😂😂

[@ylzaf77]

I think the first lady was trying to describe Genting Highlands' cable car or perhaps the Skyworld theme park

[@carolineross6474]

KLCc n Genting highlands should be the answer

[@kayellai5278]

It is about Skyway cable car in Genting Highlands. One of the fastest cable car in this region.

[@vister6757]

I think most Southeast Asian countries share very similar cultures because people have been trading and migrating within the regions for a long time.

[@razalihusain]

Genting Highlands Skyway