What Each SOULSBORNE Game Did BEST?

[@rakhoo5236]

Bro skipped unnecessary yapping and got to the point

[@TheAshenMage]

@@rakhoo5236 😂😂

[@roboticgentlemen1970]

That's why I subbed

[@BSJINTHEHOUSE420]

0% Nudity 0% Drugs 0% Swearing 100% Straight to the point

[@youngishkarma7387]

Bro missed zero times

[@TheAshenMage]

@@youngishkarma7387 thanks mate 🍀

[@watfunstu9086]

Here's my list: Demon's Souls: Best atmosphere/ambience Dark Souls: Best world design Dark Souls 2: Best hub area Dark Souls 3: Most replayable Bloodborne: Best art direction Sekiro: Best combat system Elden Ring: Everything else basically (bosses, secrets/exploration, build variety, quality of life, lore, music...)

[@TheAshenMage]

@@watfunstu9086 omg majula is so fire 🔥

[@ziadmohamed1128]

Music goes to dark souls 3 and lore goes to dark souls 1 but i agree with everything else honestly and elden ring is my favorite souls game

[@WilliamChiara]

Here’s an alternate version Demon Souls: idk haven’t played DS1: best lore DS2: best NG+ Bloodborne: best weapon design DS3: best PVP Sekiro: best gameplay Elden Ring: best quality of life(ex: no boss rumbacks, no firekeeper to level up you or flasks)

[@TheAshenMage]

@@WilliamChiara oh best pvp is unique because I don’t dabble much but good list 🔥🔥

[@sakupawn3009]

Bro cooked 🔥

[@TheAshenMage]

Thanks mate 🍀

[@senseinuuh]

Ds3 bosses are the best. They are so fucking balanced. Tho one complaint they can be too easy if you have played elden ring for over 300 hours

[@happymonkey6199]

Man said nothing but facts

[@abalfazlhejazi2466]

Ds1: level design - atmosphere - narrative - the fact that everything has a reason (ecept lost izalith lol)-characters DS2: balanced built variety - new game + DS3: bosses BB:weapons -lore -music -npcs Sekiro: not a souls game but a very unique action adventure ER: world design - enemies - exploration - combat + I didn't play demons souls but I realy enjoy atmosphere of the orginal one in videos but I can't say anything else

[@threemeters1425]

DeS: Atmosphere DS1: Level Design DS2: PvP DS3: Bosses BB: Great in everything but best in nothing tbh (but it’s my favorite!) Sekiro: Combat ER: Exploration

[@drfabulous2804]

Bloodborne DLC is the best, by a mile.

[@liszt646]

BB has the best lore and atmospphere lol. Also has best combat along with Sekiro

[@aganbraganca4156]

but bloodborne base game have 90% shit bosses

[@Megidolaon999]

Bloodborne: Everything Jk but it definitely remains fromsofts magnum opus lol. Good video!

[@TheAshenMage]

Thanks mate 🍀

[@threemeters1425]

It’s the most consistent of their games, up there with Sekiro

[@drfabulous2804]

Without doubt. Elden Ring has way too many flaws to be considered a masterpiece like Bloodborne, or even Sekiro and Dark Souls 3. And because of my bias I prefer Dark Souls 2 over Elden Ring

[@andrei-cezarbleaje5519]

@@drfabulous2804 what flaws sekiro has ?

[@youssefessam3164]

​@@drfabulous2804 Elden Ring has flaws but BB doesn't?? Bloodborne has meh base game bosses and little to no build variety and weapon variety. Those are some huge negatives. Sekiro has one flaw in which the exploration and level design are not as interesting as the other games. Elden Ring's only flaw is the repeat mini bosses but i would take that flaw when the game gives me so many build variety and amazing world and dungeons to explore.

[@deazee2288]

Elden Ring's forte for me was the NPCs Specially with the DLC They finally felt like characters and less than dialogue checklists

[@TheAshenMage]

@@deazee2288 that’s a very unique observation, I hadn’t thought about it like that 🍀

[@eog7857]

I wont lie for bloodborne a thing i would like highlight are the npcs they feel like their own bosses and are scary like the kidnappers

[@Ayahuasca98]

Glad to see demon’s souls get some love for once. Also I agree on BB’s atmosphere. One of the few times I felt uneasy playing a game. Especially in the Gaol area.

[@Antisocial_gamr]

Amazing video man I agree with everything you said 🔥🔥🔥

[@justice999]

really liked how he got straight into the video

[@lukasier26]

Demon's Souls Remake - The best graphics Dark Souls 1 - Level Design Dark Souls 2 - This weirdness Dark Souls 3 - Refined combat, mechanics, Bosses and Music Bloodborne - Weapons and Atmosphere Sekiro - Best combat and gameplay overall Elden Ring - Builds and variety

[@hhowdy]

Got strait to the point and had good commentary, great video

[@TheAshenMage]

@@hhowdy thank mate 🔥

[@gamersreactions9267]

Making a Tier List that no one complains about is impossible, yet im pretty sure you just did that. Holy, no misses

[@TheAshenMage]

@@gamersreactions9267 thanks mate 🍀

[@luxnitegd2706]

you deserve more recognition! Earned a sub

[@TheAshenMage]

@@luxnitegd2706 thanks mate 🔥🍀

[@luxnitegd2706]

@@TheAshenMage you're welcome :)

[@BNB-fk8jr]

good video!!

[@TheAshenMage]

@@BNB-fk8jr thanks mate 🍀

[@noahg4083]

Bloodborne-lore/atmosphere/Level Design/soundtrack Sekiro-combat/basic enemies DS3-bosses/art direction Elden Ring-builds/exploration/content Demons Souls-Gimmick bosses DS1-progression

[@liszt646]

Ds1: level design and characters. Solaire and Siegmeyer are unmatched

[@noahg4083]

@@liszt646 You’re probably right.

[@aganbraganca4156]

nah soundtrack goes to ds3 some of the best themes in the game

[@noahg4083]

@@aganbraganca4156 DS3 Soundtrack is a close second.

[@KoolAidNarrator]

Bloodborne: music

[@TheAshenMage]

@@KoolAidNarrator yes 🔥🔥

[@thedarethnator2216]

Short and sweet , good job

[@TheAshenMage]

@@thedarethnator2216 thank you mate 🔥🍀

[@toronto6182]

finally someone who is right about ds3 bosses not the best but good thats an instant like bro

[@jakubletsplays8845]

Video deserves a like because of : not yappin

[@Wasp_Gaming06]

Bro did not miss whatsoever. Couldn't agree more.

[@anukthotawatta982]

good tier list but i think Elden ring legacy dungeons have better level design than all the souls games combined

[@TheAshenMage]

@@anukthotawatta982 that’s an interesting take mate, I get can behind it. I say DS 1 only because it’s the first game in the series to have such an amazing level design, and it was to the point that future games couldn’t replicate until recently 🍀

[@Ringoroadagain6]

Stormveil castle is probably the best legacy dungeon they ever designed.

[@threemeters1425]

This would be true if there werent so many checkpoints as to remove most of their tension

[@anukthotawatta982]

@@Ringoroadagain6 now its shadow keep

[@anukthotawatta982]

@@TheAshenMage yeah, DS1 level design was ahead of its time

[@Khalid_mastoratora]

Bro is spitting facts 🗿

[@thefatking3154]

I think dark souls 2 had the best fashion

[@AlejandroRodriguez-nh8qt]

Great list but I’d probably say bloodborne was the blue print of there future boss design

[@Sponsorbagel]

I think that to this day, I've never had more fun playing a game on my own than when i played Sekiro.

[@TheAshenMage]

@@Sponsorbagel 🔥🔥🍀

[@milk55655]

i feel like ds2 doesn't get enough recognition for trying out a lot of experamental mechanics and i love it for that

[@TheAshenMage]

Agreed 🔥🍀

[@LourdessApekatt]

Agreed, at least with the very few fromsoft games I've played. Sekiro definitely has the best combat with how creative you can be with it. Bloodborne has the aesthetics, weapon designs, monster and enemy designs and personally, no other souls game comes even close the soundtrack in Bloodborne.

[@TheAshenMage]

Bloodbornes OST is fire mate 🔥

[@xcxmafai]

Great video but I think DS3 base game bosses was the best till Elden ring came out the base game bosses there are really consistent imo

[@Disco.starter]

I agree with everything

[@TheAshenMage]

🔥🔥

[@JEUC0]

goated list

[@voidzzlbs3957]

I really like this list. I would say bb has better combat than sekiro and Sekiro has the best storytelling. Also I would give bosses to elden ring but u get what you mean by the blueprint factor of ds3 bosses

[@TheAshenMage]

@@voidzzlbs3957 I can get behind this take as well 🔥🍀

[@gos12345678910]

for me Demon's Souls is the best

[@ilterarikan1888]

Lol he literaly wrote worts 😂

[@TheAshenMage]

@@ilterarikan1888 😂😂

[@guts4902]

factsssss

[@abreu7756]

valid

[@SilverBoy-er4kb]

Dis you rly just gave a point to elden ring for exploration? Rly? Yea its sooo good that you always are either way to overlevel or undrlevel vs bosses. The best example: i on my first playthrou fought margitt, in the begging he absolutely demolished me because of his huge heath and dmg for early game boss. I ignored him for a while, killed 4-5 “optional” punchbag bosses updated my weapon as much as i could, went to margit again and i run him down in less than a min. And not only him, in this game because of open world there is no golden middle, you always are either way to overlevel, or way to underlevel for a boss, which is a bad thing because you have 0 fun getting demolished over and over, or killing bosses in leas than a min (if not faster)

[@TheAshenMage]

@@SilverBoy-er4kb I see what you mean mate, but how does that take away from the exploration? Elden ring is not dark souls both games play differently and are different experiences. The exploration is part of the fun not necessarily to go there and farm but to just find new area explore dungeons and fight new bosses! The point you are making is valid, and I can see what you mean 100% but the two games are not the same. Also the point you made is why the game has such a mass appeal, because people who are not soulsborne players can get into it easier than for example me and you.

[@tsantaratia6980]

let him cook

[@WeirdTroll666]

nice

[@TheAshenMage]

@@WeirdTroll666 🔥🔥🍀

[@BUKUDI]

Elden Ring: best weird pervy bs

[@DarkSoulsssss]

DS2 should've been the NG+, DS3 should've been bosses regardless. Bloodborne is weapons. Everything else is fine.

[@TheAshenMage]

@@DarkSoulsssss that’s a valid take as well brother 🍀🔥

[@tylerhughes4785]

Worts bosses? (Imao)

[@TheAshenMage]

@@tylerhughes4785 omg I just got what the comments meant by “wort” 😂

[@greatfrog2769]

My list will be (people probably disagree): Demon Souls: as you, boss concepts. Dark Souls: best npcs. Dark Souls II: same as you, also I will say... His unique atmosphere and the biggest dlcs. Dark Souls III: bosses design/movesets, balance and level design. Maybe is not as good the map conections of ds1, but I zones of Ds3 are more complex and replayable. Sekiro: combat and progression. Not any other souls felt so good sawing you learning it than Sekiro Bloodborne: atmosphere and lore yeah, but I will say also weapons. I don't get the neccesity of having 20 swords if they are basically the same, only 5 of the 20 have any difference. I prefer less weapons but different and with no janky and recicled movesets. Elden Ring: best piece of shit. Some zones are pretty good if you explore it good but... Most of the time you are on an autistic horse crossing and empty land. A few very good bosses and variarety in builds and opcions. Elden Ring has my favorite magic of all games, in terms on design, visual, possibilities, etc. But come on man, 90% of the enemies are no worth killing it, if they not recicle a thing from other game, they recicle a lot of times the same thing over and over like facing the same boss. Main bosses are in general good (not you Malenia), but some of them looks like the wet dream of the masochist hardcore modder (yes DLC, I am talking about you, also the worst of all dlcs, the camera issues with bosses, the recicle things, the npc with boss health bar and more).

[@TheAshenMage]

@@greatfrog2769 your list is pretty agreeable mate at least to me. 🍀

[@Nrzpokrter]

DS3 is the one with the best bosses? Damn, hard disagree with that one. Did you skip the entire 1st half of the game? Quite a lot of garbage there I fear.

[@cuttchii]

I mean outside of the curse rotten greatwood it's really just flawless

[@Nrzpokrter]

@@cuttchii Vordt, deacons, crystal sage, wolnir, yhorm, aldritch, ancient wyvern and ocerios are flawless bosses? What a standard.

[@cuttchii]

@@Nrzpokrter I mean yes? They are great fights. What game has better bosses than that?

[@Vengeance_I_m]

​@@cuttchiiElden Ring

[@Nrzpokrter]

@@cuttchii Elden Ring and Sekiro. Bloodborne also has highest highs but the average is probably lower than ds3.

[@William-Sunderland]

DS1: Best world building and ambience. DS3: Best Bosses. Bloodborne: Best art maybe sound and lore too. Elden Ring: Biggest, though it sins with quantity over quality, and best build variety. Sekiro: Wont necessarily say best combat but most fresh combat sure. Lore is very interesting in all games in different ways, wouldnt nacessarily point to one as the best, also DS2 and DeS have nothing where they exceed at compared to others, not going to pretend every souls has to be the best at something, thats just not true, both games good though.

[@JDoggPokepixels]

I don’t really care for the idea each souls game did something the best because for my preferences it would be Demon Souls: Nothing still a great game though Dark Souls: Lore, Dlc, Interconnectivity Dark Souls 2: No No No just No Bloodborne: Combat, Areas, Atmosphere, Trench Coats Dark Souls 3: Nothing still a great game though Sekiro: Nothing still a great game though Elden Ring: World, Bosses, Variety And I have proven my point

[@MakioGoHardio]

ER has the best bosses, ds3’s best bosses are just roll 1-3 attacks and then punish simulators which is very boring. Plus half of ds3 bosses are trash, the first half of ds3 is a complete slog because of them and is why I never replay the game anymore.

[@aganbraganca4156]

eldern ring bosses are just reskins bosses with bullshit attacks. ds3 bosses have best design, quality, difficult but they are fair

[@MakioGoHardio]

@@aganbraganca4156 “quality, difficulty” is rng follow ups is what you consider quality lol. If you’re at all challenged by ds3 then I’m sorry to say but I think you’re just bad at video games.

[@Slink21Taken]

@@MakioGoHardio Challenge does NOT equal fun. Souls games need to be challenging AND fun. Elden ring bosses are far too aggressive and fast, Don't get me wrong many of them are great! (8/165 max) The problem is that "bosses" in elden ring feel less special because of how many there are. When you stumble upon a boss in DS3, it's a different feeling yknow? Plus, dark souls 3 has better bosses than elden ring.... but imo sekiro tops

[@MakioGoHardio]

@@Slink21Taken half of ds3 bosses are trash lol, all the remembrance are at the very least decent even EB isn’t pure trash like deacons or crystal sage.

[@Slink21Taken]

@@MakioGoHardio Oh so we gon talk about the bad ones? Whabbout gael? Abbys watchers? Pontiff? Dancer? Namless king? If you wanna go that way.... What about the 50 repetitive dungeon bosses, elden beast, godskin duo and the ancient dragon clones. Not to mention the trash bosses like tibia mariner and cemetery shade