What experts have to say about exploiting the moon and the current space race | DW News

[@kaushikkar1421]

Britain is not even a third tire space power ..

[@Gudha_Ismintis]

but india is a first tier receiver of foreign aid

[@nitinmeena8416]

cry@@Gudha_Ismintis

[@i7xworld702]

​@@Gudha_Ismintis🤡 after 2015 no aid has been given to India by British 😂your own gov

[@irose4066]

Your aid only for NGO for your business investment not for welfare of Indian. Britain only build on theft product and structures that build by slaves. I seen one documentary. It tells 🇬🇧 is very poor and some people can’t even have single meal per day. Soon UK will be poorer than Somalia.

[@jkardez4794]

Millions of Indians are living in Britain , many more are waiting in line - don't insult them .

[@TheWarriorWriter]

ISRO discovered water on moon back in 2009 ever since the south pole became all the more important!

[@suraj.1889]

a mission successfully done by ISRO nevertheless, but hey credit to the NASA for the help@@anshul9462

[@anudevm8638]

you are absolutely correct , "Apollo" as this person @4:05 claims in the discussion kind of blurs the facts by using "since the Apollo we had found out that.." and all is not going to work out. Apollo samples suggested they were created in a completely anhydrous, reducing environment. Its was recently after chandrayan 1 ; that Indian scholars are talking about water on moon, that too by seeing it there during that mission. Any body can check out this article for more info ; in 2021 they made a proper paper on this discovery of water on moon - doi: 10.18520/cs/v121/i3/391-401

[@anksssssssss]

​@@anshul9462so ??? Tomorrow u will say it's Taiwanese microchip that decoded data ??? . Don't be butthurted . It's all ISRO .

[@shansilgurung9324]

Apollo mission found 👽 on moon 😅

[@khan.954]

​@@anudevm8638it was chandrayan1 who found water content on moon

[@stfunub646]

India's space tech has already yielded great results for India by way of multiple satellites launched for weather & earth monitoring - as well as its own GPS systems. ISRO has also placed High tech military satellites into orbit for India & it's Rocket tech has been used to develop India's ballistic Missiles. The new exploratory phase is a good add on - but ISRo has already done a lot for India .

[@khan.954]

Time for Elon Musk to buy ISRO

[@stfunub646]

@@khan.954 it's not a private co. - fully owned by the Government.

[@lmaonoobs3779]

ISRO has never developed a ballistic missile but it has developed air defence systems and an ASAT missile.

[@khan.954]

@@stfunub646 no worry modi is good at selling government sector industries of India.He already sold many PSU of India and even defense sector industries like ordinance factories owned by government. I think Elon Musk would try at least.

[@khan.954]

@@user-wb3fo1sj8m Keep comparing with Pakistan and be happy because that's your value in this entire world.Even poor country like Bangaladesh have better GDP per capita than yours...lol

[@yte549]

Western Hypocrites: India landed as space race..... If western nation landed then these Hypocrites call it as for humanity and mankind😂😂😂

[@maheshrathod5593]

Good point

[@martavdz4972]

It´s "hypocrites", and it´s acknowledging India´s success!

[@yte549]

@@martavdz4972 don't care about language it's just a media for communication.... Anyway thankyou to point out the spelling mistake, I corrected it

[@jamesjackovich5886]

When the first human stepped on the moon Armstrong said ' one small step for man one giant leap for mankind' and sent 5 other manned missions to the moon, India just landed a satellite on the moon, we already have rovers on mars

[@valetudan234]

​​​@@jamesjackovich5886look at where they landed. It's on the lunar south pole, if it was so easy to land there then America or China would've reached that place long time back

[@Marie-cq5td]

Go India! I’m so happy for you ❤️💖❤️

[@AnshuKumar-fi2jy]

Thank you

[@choyung-in6yl9sb7q]

Thanks for support us,, unity in diversity in our country 🇮🇳🇮🇳,,i love my india ❤️❤️

[@jacqueslee2592]

The Ganges River has literally turned into a fecal, choleric waste river. What makes you think that India should have claims to the Moon's ice reservoirs? These are dangerous claims and the world should stifle any Indian intentions.

[@browncandy3750]

3:03Literally India is the first country in the world to put their flag south pole And the first country went to Mars in the first attempt, its cost was 74 million USD And the first country to find water on the moon And the first country made a record by sending 104 satellites Now tell me in which tier Europe spaces agency is

[@Ramiz422]

They have a collaborative space agency called European space agency they don't have a separate space program like ISRO.

[@YuruCampSupermacy]

he already said that India is the leader of the pack when it comes to that tier so he is already placing euro space agencies lower than India, compared to NASA we are still quite small. Obviously given the smaller scale and budget I would say that ISRO's achievements are much more impressive but why are you getting so worked up about what one guy thinks?

[@koteswar009]

@@YuruCampSupermacy I saw in news recently after landing on moon that India will stay to low cost long route to space bodies as they did to Mars and Moon unlike US, Russia that use big rockets to fly quickly but cost more.

[@Matthew-rp3jf]

As an american, I'd tell you good work India and keep the bragging down til you catch up to us hahaha😅

[@jacqueslee2592]

The Ganges River has literally turned into a fecal, choleric waste river. What makes you think that India should have claims to the Moon's ice reservoirs? These are dangerous claims and the world should stifle any Indian intentions.

[@gigachadsitler]

As a man from Europe, i think india should invest in space technology because In future space tourism can increase .

[@1pasupaty]

Mor than space tourism india may remove poverty back on earth using the know how of mining rare earth metals from moons surface in next 2ndecades

[@gigachadsitler]

​@@1pasupatyas a man from Europe ,I think it's one of the biggest challenge to start mining ⛏️ on moon .

[@jyotidaspromax]

True@@gigachadsitler

[@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451]

@@gigachadsitler as a man from Europe 😂😂😂😂😂😭

[@irose4066]

India is developing but Europe is declining. Soon entire EU is poorer than Africa. EU can’t loot anymore in Africa. So they beg for everything in future😂😂

[@amitkriit]

If India is second tier then UK, Japan, Germany arent even worthy of a mention. 😂

[@AwardQueue]

Don't forget the science basic research ability. that's a key.

[@tutorsoar]

India is not at second tier, India is a league apart. India's Chandrayaan 3 cost 70 million, inflation adjusted Nasa's Apollo 11 was 200 billion which is 3000 times more, with that budget India would have explored the entire solar system by now

[@mohannadar8u873]

Entire solar system😂 ye kuch jada bol diya

[@javierderivero9299]

Yes...I don't want to take any credit from India...they deserve it...but to put 25 kg on the moon is a totally different ball game to land tons of material and humans, space station, rovers on Mars, telescopes like Webb etc like NASA/ESA/JAXA/CSA ...India is still far away, maybe in 15 years...but anyway congratulation to India

[@targetfixdreamdoctor8563]

​@@javierderivero9299who says that 25kg ball put on moon, I think first you require a better knowledge about Indias space program chandrayan 3 then give your knowledge

[@HilariousHaveli]

​@@javierderivero9299🤦

[@javierderivero9299]

@@targetfixdreamdoctor8563 I understand the India Lunar Rover is 25 kg. that's why they sent the rocket to the moon...is the payload..just NASA rover in Mars are hundreds of kilos...who lacks knowledge??

[@arcane3464]

The expert literally placed India with Britain in the same tier, while Britain still can't send it's own satellite to the earth orbit. Are you really an expert ?

[@philosopherfrombed]

He is western so obviously he will have a soft corner for UK, by the way this bias makes him exfart and not expert

[@simijose7571]

Whatever happened in the past , India's Chandrayaan 3 is the greatest achievement that i have ever seen in my lifetime , well done team ISRO ,proud to be an Indian

[@ARShanker]

Dear Indian's understand when they say ''WE HAVE BEEN THERE'' INDIA dedicates our Moon Mission to the whole of Humanity

[@jatingodhwani1916]

​​​@@khan.954 bhagwa e Pakistan.

[@siva.m1]

It is not Apollos missions that predicted water ice, it was India's own Chandrayaan 1 that has done that. 4:10

[@ankurantil6137]

Yes

[@thelastofthehitachi972]

and M³ (Moon Mineralogy Mapper - an imaging spectrometer from NASA), that was 'aboard' Chandrayaan - 1 :) and did the first mineralogical map of the moon (water included)

[@ankurantil6137]

@@thelastofthehitachi972 thats the point it was ABOARD Chandrayan hence credit goes to Chandrayan as well..... But Western media carefully omits it

[@thelastofthehitachi972]

@@ankurantil6137 actually it was ISRO that discovered water on the Moon 3 months before NASA's M³ spectrometer with the help of another instrument, an MIP (Moon Impact Probe) developed by ISRO, that also was 'aboard' Chandrayaan - 1 :)

[@abhishekpas]

​@@thelastofthehitachi972Taiwanese chips were onboard mmm which processed the data. Credit goes to Taiwan by your logic.

[@_sayan_roy_]

It should be noted as well that it was India itself which discovered the traces of ice in the South Pole region through its Chandrayan 1 orbiter sent back in 2008 with the help of instruments and analysis of itself(and ISRO) and other space orgs especially NASA. Good coverage, DW, and cheers. From an Indian currently in Germany.

[@Jarod-vg9wq]

Congratulations India 🇮🇳 from Canada ❤❤❤🎉🎉🎉

[@thanosunni]

countries have landed on the moon 1: uk (BBC,sky, the guardian) 🇬🇧 2: russia (Roskosmos) 🇷🇺 3: usa (nasa) 🇺🇸 4: china (cnsa) 🇨🇳 5: india (isro) 🇮🇳 Countries have landed on moon south pole: 1 : uk (BBC, sky, the guardian) 🇬🇧 2 :india (isro) 🇮🇳

[@singh_prince777]

Even uk space director is Indian 16:42

[@tourravi8420]

No, uk has never landed on the moon😂😂😂😅😅

[@ChanduShirwal]

😂😂❤❤

[@ForceX182]

😂😂😂😂

[@nick00176]

British landed on the moon in their dreams

[@diptenduchaudhuri]

Just for the record, India had the potential to send a spacecraft to the Moon way back if the CIA hadn't interfered with ISRO's activities. The United States, not wanting competition, took actions to disrupt ISRO's efforts. Their motivation was primarily financial, as the U.S. would have faced financial losses if India had become a provider of rocket launches for other nations Nambi Narayanan and Sasikumar were two individuals who were involved in a significant espionage case related to ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) and alleged CIA (Central Intelligence Agency) involvement. Nambi Narayanan, a former ISRO scientist, was falsely accused of espionage and arrested in 1994. Later, the charges against him were dropped, and he was cleared of any wrongdoing. His case raised questions about the role of intelligence agencies in the matter. Sasikumar, on the other hand, was another individual associated with the case. He was also accused of being involved in the espionage conspiracy but was eventually acquitted. The case of Nambi Narayanan and Sasikumar highlights a complex and controversial episode in the history of ISRO and alleged intelligence agency interference.

[@sounakchatterjee2694]

Even if that's true, it doesn't matter to be honest! Nobody asked R&AW not to interfere in America's mission. These things are part of any missions of this calibre --- India, Indians, Govt, different bureaus, etc. Rather than crying and giving excuses --- SuAcK it up and deliver! India had the advantage of having a headstart 1000s of years ago by starting one of the oldest civilizations --- It's India's fault not to sustain that.

[@amitmaurya279]

​@@sounakchatterjee2694It means you can do anything you want, according to you instead of sending such missions we should hault other country missions so that we can avoid competitions

[@naughtyboy1500]

US helped China to become economic powerhouse, even if so US has lots of countries they were busy dealing than India. Russia too has bribed many scientists and officials to stop developing indigenous weapons. How about that?

[@sounakchatterjee2694]

@@amitmaurya279 You can proceed with your own mission and choose to halt other country missions ---- So the other country stays back and can never dream about catching on to you. And it's not according to me.... this is how geopolitics is played (since ancient times, those who couldn't keep up, set aside.... India being one).... And if someone is playing it the other way and bringing emotions and prioritizing wellbeing of others (country/countrymen) in action... is making a mistake.

[@sounakchatterjee2694]

@@Amit-oj8oo India getting conquered first by Islam and then by Europe is India's fault.

[@palashgupta8876]

Lowest budget space mission with Limited resources is Commendable , Money saved is Money earned.❤ Great ISRO✌️

[@telx2010]

It showed in the ridiculous CGI

[@aleve.2401]

@@telx2010 does the cgi really matter here? 😂 | We are ahead here from so many big countries which they can't even do with high budget missions..🤣🤣🤣

[@thewonderer9551]

​@@telx2010 Who gonna pay for another camera holder? Your dad?

[@__daddy__]

We lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind 💪

[@exurgemars]

​@@__daddy__no. I hope you're a troll. I don't expect normal people to be this d umb. 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@rishabhsingh6023]

Ty for actually running news channel rather than criticizing other country like BBC , big respect for your journalism ❤❤

[@schnitzel_enjoyer]

Jealousy is some strong drug

[@robrechwithoutzaza7992]

How BBC criticize your country?

[@makunahatata8700]

@@robrechwithoutzaza7992 BBC is the worst, you can google it how they criticize us it is a long list

[@peabase]

Grow a stronger ego.

[@schnitzel_enjoyer]

@@peabase strong jealousy

[@deepakkunar7729]

Indian space 🚀 mission precision of engineering is top notch and this make India can do anything with very very cheap cost ,, india you did itt ❤

[@martavdz4972]

Agreed! Only I wouldn´t emphasize the low cost too much in future. It could lead to top engineers being seriously underpaid, and they deserve good pay.

[@PoojaAxomiya]

​@@martavdz4972The engineers get good pay in india

[@SodiumSyndicate]

SpaceX engineers are underpaid like dogs, India pays its space engineers richly @@martavdz4972

[@asshwina]

@@martavdz4972 underpaid is a very relative term, UK engineers are well paid but all their income is spent on daily expenses, hardly any savings left( my friends live there London is expensive! ). It’s more to do with cost of living and inflation, by that standards Indian engineers are paid well.

[@koteswar009]

True, the ISRO scientists said they traveled to moon and landed exactly as predicted.

[@AlohaKutla]

An interesting aspect is how UK and Europeans are reacting to India successful moon landing. Racist rhetoric and angry tone from UK media, politicians and some European media shows that colonialism might have ended but not in their minds. They are disgusted by the idea how a "colonial subject" can do such a scientific marvel while their country is dying and unable to feed its citizens or provide heat without exploiting another country.

[@yomamasohot6411]

It's just a sign of their insecurity. We shouldn't let that get to our heads. Let's put our heads down and work for a brighter future.

[@AlohaKutla]

@@yomamasohot6411 Na, I think we should highlight it for educating youngsters. teenagers think that Western culture is cool and trendy to follow it. This will shine light on how they treat Indians. I dont want kids to hate western culture but know the fact that US and UK are.a society with deep racist, misogynist and classist society. Even I used to think western culture is cool as a kid till I lived amongst them.

[@graphite282]

The ex colonial imperialists are terrified that the colonies they looted and subjugated for 250 years are going far ahead of them. Now that the UK has no colonies to loot their economy is going downhill fast. UK's white supremacy is turning into white trash and they can't take it.

[@lvjinbin28]

if India grows too fast, would USA contain India's rise like did to Japan in 1980s and China right now?

[@graphite282]

@@lvjinbin28 perhaps they won't contain india but rather collaborate to their benefit. The USA recognises that india is a democracy, it has democratic institutions and written constitution and statutes, rule of law, strong military,, a good education system focused on mathematics etc. And a workforce. USA will do what benefits itself.

[@SKumar-mj6gf]

Our moon mission costed less than a bollywood movie 🤩

[@avivekkr]

Took double the time😊

[@Gyan4more]

Landu bollywood nhi hollywood movie

[@pmx5684]

Did it really?

[@AnkitGupta-nt2ih]

So??? Bura na Maan na agr fail hota toh???

[@sagarb420]

@@avivekkrDouble the time for what? An average movie takes 2-3 months to be shot

[@vjrc2002]

It is India that discovered water on Moon as a part of Chandrayaan - I

[@imaryansoni]

One the guy said India in the same row of Britain and other countries😅😅seriously they didn't have launch a single rocket in outer orbit 😂😂😂

[@Storyblocks6969]

Looted $45 Trillion and now can't even launch a single satellite of its own. 😂

[@SunbathinginAntarctica]

Still hung up about the past aren't you.

[@samratmanna1353]

​@@SunbathinginAntarcticaWe are not but the bbc are. They brought it up

[@arunpp]

Wester countries why is India wasting 650cr on Moon mission as if ₹650cr will wipe out poverty. Western world still living in 19th century mindset 😂

[@maheshrathod5593]

Exactly. But ii could in the near future help us get space resources just like Portugal ans d Spain in 16th century

[@martavdz4972]

I´m from EU and nobody in my country´s media or online discussions has said that.

[@MahiMahi-yu5jo]

Meanwhile, Disney in US wasted 500 million USD on a movie no one wanted to watch. And they even refused to pay their actors and writers a decent salary.

[@AnshuKumar-fi2jy]

​@@martavdz4972 but UK media said so bro 😢

[@zetch3179]

​@@AnshuKumar-fi2jynow they'll admit that they didnt said...u kno na european mindset ..

[@tfhmobil]

They hope to find water, in substantial amount, what to me seems very unlikely. We must appreciate the perseverance of India 🇮🇳 achieving the science, whatever the outcome 👍

[@niks660097]

Those craters on moons are formed by big BIG asteroids/meteors, if even a single of those impacted asteroids had water, you would have trillion liters of water, so unless our theory about asteroids bringing water to earth in past is wrong, then there is a chance..

[@henrystevens3993]

They have already found water in 2008 so please get some knowledge before saying this

[@StoryForKids111]

You are wrong. Moon hold enough water at poles trapped for eternity. No way for it to get out naturally. This is acknowledged by ISRO first fb NASA when chandrayan 1 discovered water as ice on poles. The water is enough that can be extracted once we settle a permanent base nearby it. It's a matter of when (time). It's not impossible to do it , certainly difficult.

[@tfhmobil]

@@henrystevens3993 Read what I wrote before trolling. I don’t believe that it’s possible to extract enough, if any, water.

[@kunalsingh4418]

​@@tfhmobilbased on what though, Any reason or just emotion? Fact is, we won't know until we try. Which is why we are going to try. Unless there is any reason, I would rather be optimistic about it. And as u said, progress in science is regardless going to be a good thing.

[@MrBothandNether]

I think it’s important to remember these accomplishments as things done for the entire species not just one nation.

[@khan.954]

Yeah I hope all humanity stop war and start searching for resources at space together so we can have plenty for everyone

[@__daddy__]

We lndia is 10 years ahead of USA in space technology. Jai Hind 💪

[@__daddy__]

@@greenweed3253 American bot

[@nareshkumar840]

Of course since it's not the USA it should be an entire species. But if it's the USA we all know who'll get the credit lol. Anyways, although it should be remembered as an accomplishment done for the entire species, so should the nation that did it as well. 😊

[@TheWarriorWriter]

That's what the Indian Prime minister said right at the time of Touch Down. World is India's family.

[@PalashKundu-i9f]

It seems like india will be more powerfull in terms of space mission in the near future❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@jeevas8794]

India's PM said, This is victory of all humanitys ,we work together to lead world on moon.. He uttered abt unity is remarkable..

[@AJITHTHOMAS-xp6cm]

What nonsense The fellow cannot make his own country men to love each other Spreading hatred We just saw what happened in UP - Muzzafarnagar His party has destroyed Manipur Where all this will end This Spreading hatred God only knows

[@telx2010]

Then he laughed at you gullible mugs

[@himanshusirohi2403]

Indians should understand that these discussions are happening around India's success. I think it was ok for them until it was just US and Europe. But suddenly its an issue of exploitation. We should control the narrative around our stories not Western hypocrites.

[@longerodds5077]

India's space missions were delayed for two reasons. 1. Visionless governments for 6 decades that refused to fund ISRO adequately. 2. Systematic elimination of our top scientists by enemy nations. Else India would have conquered the Space much earlier

[@gopalray9553]

those visionless governments paid more money per GDP percentage

[@martavdz4972]

The main thing is, it has done it! Congratulations! 🙂

[@longerodds5077]

@@gopalray9553 Amazing how you people come up with a narrative to protect the family

[@satishimca]

@@gopalray9553GDP was so less back then

[@ayusharudraanand1726]

​@@longerodds5077that is in correct. Mangalyaan chandrayaan 1 etc were launched before 2014. Note we were suffering from sanctions during the 1990s. PSLV Was developed much before Modi. The congress credited the family for everything and it was wrong. So is what you are doing. Please desist from "All credit to Modi and Modi alone". In case you didn't know ISRO still operates on a shoestring budget and the pay is low.

[@MichaleJohn-iz8dg]

Baise and racist video failed even to acknowledge that many countries went to the Moon, but it was India that proved world water availability in the moon, when you can give results better than others, even if the early or late comer don't make any sense.

[@JanetManjombe-k9u]

Congratulations INDIA , you deserve it 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@manju4ever222]

India should reserve all the rights of using the resources ob the south pole of the moon. Otherwise the west will start imposing laws and policies to fair usage. As an indian, i want india to lead the space age.

[@AwardQueue]

No Chance, India led by Artemis Accords.

[@aleenaprasannan2146]

There is no such thing. There are long established international treaties that ensures no one country can claim sovereignty over any part of moon

[@tluangasailo3663]

There's no sovereignty like that on moon, they abolished it already 😅

[@exurgemars]

It doesn't work like that, my guy.

[@Shri_Hegde]

When India landed , going to moon became exploiting moon 🤣🤣.. Wow DW Wow

[@ayurtoday]

Countries may feel a sense of rivalry or jealousy when another nation achieves significant milestones in space exploration, such as a successful moon mission. This sentiment can be driven by geopolitical considerations, their in capability, national pride, or the perception that space capabilities signify technological and scientific prowess.

[@penanghill1812]

When earth going 2 destroy 'reach people pretend of moon ''

[@penanghill1812]

So many millionaire 'wants 2 live 'till end of the world '

[@ashleysilver5594]

I thought water was discovered by Chandrayaan 1 when it dropped a moon impact probe in 2008. I dont understand why Alan Duffy says it was the Apollo mission that discovered it. He needs to do a fact check.

[@VG-bf9cy]

NASA themselves said it was Chandrayaan mission that discovered water on moon although they sent their payload on it to detect water

[@TL-fv5xg]

Apollo 14. 1971.

[@ansumannanda8289]

It's not Nasa it's ISRO which discovered water on moon

[@martin96991]

Where's Europe in that second tier???

[@siddharthdas5812]

The Indian space mission is primarily about finding water on the moon. Just think, if water was found imagine the impact it would create for humankind and human settlement on the moon in the near future. India is doing it for humanity, not for itself alone.

[@jacqueslee2592]

First clean the fecal, wastewater of the Ganges river before seeking to defile exoplanetary water.

[@sharabhshukla6670]

@@jacqueslee2592 I think you should clean your consciousness first, looters and haters

[@VG-bf9cy]

@@jacqueslee2592we are leaving that for you to eat and clean there by

[@lastChang]

China🇨🇳 is declining. - India🇮🇳, a Quad member, has the potential to be the next *only Asia superpower.*

[@tourravi8420]

Not only Asia all over the world😅😂😂😂🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳✊✊✊💪🏻

[@TheStefanRadovanovic]

with avreage iq of 70? hardly.

[@Rav01508]

Countries that lead the world in 44 critical technology* sectors: 1. China = 37 2. USA = 7 3. UK = 0 4. Germany = 0 5. Japan = 0 *In fields like defence, space, robotics, energy, the environment, biotechnology, artificial intelligence (AI), advanced materials and key quantum technology areas Source: Australian Strategic Policy Institute (ASPI) **India leads the world in the field of cow husbandry, which is neither a technology nor critical

[@Rav01508]

▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2021 that China's doomed property market would bring down the Chinese economy and India would surpass China by 2030? ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2021 that by 2025, there would be no Japanese factories left in China? This is after the Japanese government's announcement of a scheme to financially assist Japanese firms to shift production from China to India ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2021 that the Evergrande crisis would spell the end of China's economic miracle? ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2021 that India has a $1.2 trillion dollar master plan to grab factories from China. It's called the "Gati Shakti" or "Strength of Speed" initiative to attract multinational companies and enhance India's image as the manufacturing hub of the world ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2020 that India's unofficial "Boycott China Campaign" after Galwan incident would see a substantial reduction of imports from China and thus pave the way for Self-reliant India? ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2020 that 20,000 foreign owned factories will move from China to India due to Covid? ▪︎Didn't indians say back in 2021 that Modi's $10 billion dollar plan to attract semiconductor manufacturers would turn India into semiconductor and electronics giant by 2025? What happened to the Foxconn and Vedanta deal? ▪︎Last week, the Indian gov't suddenly announced a total ban on the import of laptops, servers and tablets. However, the GOI announced a postponement of the ban for 3 months. Only an amateur and indecisive gov't would do such a thing. Which would impact severely on foreign investors' trust and confidence in the Indian government. ▪︎A failing grade(india) worries about the top grader(china) in the class. . . this is india: China🇨🇳 = $19.91 trillion India🇮🇳 = $3.45 trillion International trade: China🇨🇳 = $3.7 trillion India🇮🇳 = $740 billion External trade to GDP: China🇨🇳 = 18% India🇮🇳 = 22% India's exports are also falling due to global recession and worse, India's economy is more reliant on foreign trade than China "Farmers' income would double by 2022, this is a promise I would assure our Indian farmers.." - Modi, 2019 "China has bullet trains, so are we Indians too, very soon. Our 508 km Sabarmati-Mumbai bullet train, would be a reality before August 15, 2022.." -Modi, 2018 "Make in India would end China's era as the factory 🏭 of the world 🌎.." -Modi, 2015 "I will create at least 20 million jobs a year until there are not enough workers if elected as the PM of India.." - Modi, 2014 "When we Indians celebrate our 75th year of independence in 2022, I shall present 🎁 to you all, India's very first bullet train.." - Modi, 2017 "India will send its first astronauts to space before independence day 2022, this is not a promise but a guarantee.." - Modi, 2018 "Give me 5 years as the PM of India and people won't even remember there was once something called pollution in India.." - Modi, 2014 "If I'm the PM of India, Pakistan and China would be so scared of India's power, they would think twice before attempting any funny moves on India.." - Modi, 2014 "Give me 6 years and corruption would be a thing of the past in India.." - Modi, 2014 "We will build 100 smart cities within 5 years in India to the point where Americans, Japanese, Europeans and even Chinese would want to come and study our smart city concept.." - Modi, 2015 "Atmanirbhar Bharat Self-Reliant India will end our imports from China, instead, China will even have to import stuffs from us after that.." - Modi, 2018 "Give me 6 years as the PM of India and everyone in the world would want to come to India to study our achievements.." - Modi, 2014

[@Rav01508]

▪︎Chang'e 3 was launched on 1 December 2013 and successfully soft-landed on the Moon on 14 December 2013. ▪︎Chang'e 4 was launched on 7 December 2018 and landed on 3 January 2019 on the South Pole-Aitken Basin, on the far side of the Moon. ▪︎Chang'e 5 which launched on 23 November 2020 and returned on 16 December in the same year, brought 1,731 g of lunar samples back to Earth ▪︎Chang'e 6 expected to launch in 2024 and perform China's second sample return mission ■The Chinese Lunar Exploration Program is designed to be conducted in four phases of incremental technological advancement: ▪︎The first is reaching lunar orbit, completed by Chang'e 1 in 2007 and Chang'e 2 in 2010. ▪︎The second is landing and roving on the Moon, as Chang'e 3 did in 2013 and Chang'e 4 did in 2019. ▪︎The third is collecting lunar samples from the near-side and sending them to Earth, completed by Chang'e 5 in 2020 and planned for the Chang'e 6 mission in 2024. ▪︎The fourth phase consists of development of a robotic research station near the Moon's south pole.The program aims to facilitate a crewed lunar landing in 2030 and possibly build an outpost near the lunar south pole.

[@shyme6953]

It's the German newspaper that mocked India's growing population, now this German public broadcast having conversations about India's success. As people say, the more you push someone down the more they will rise. It's a slap on their face who looked down on India.

[@neerajr4894]

Britain, does Britain have a space agency. What was there last mission, opening coke bottle 😂

[@TheWarriorWriter]

The world could see the telemetry being sent to earth. Who ever had the antenna could see and track the trajectory of vikram lander chandrayaan 3

[@rickgolder6818]

Also ISRO's GSLV mk3 which is the current heviest rocket in ISROs inventory, can carry upto 4-6 tons in outer space and 8-10 tons in LEO (lower earth orbit), i am talking about the most recent version not the older mk2 ones. But theres a catch, ISRO is in advance stages to complete yet another milestone which is there NGLV, for which ISRO have already successfully tested there mega Cryo-genic engine. NGLV will be able to take payloads from 5tons to 16 tons to outer space, and over 22 tons to LEO. And it will be tested in the next 2-3 years. Now coming to why this is important, its because India have some v ry big plans. India plans to send humans to space by 2025 with there Gaganyan missions (note, NGLV will not be used in this, the current GSLV mk3 will be used for Gaganyan). And by 2030 india plans to start building its own space station, for which a huge amount of payload have to be sent to LEO, and this is where NGLV will come. In the nest 5-7 years, you will be abel to witness history being made. Oh what a time to be alive ! Some upcoming missions of ISRO:- 1. Aditya-L1:- indias first probe to suns L-1 orbit, more like NASA's Parker solar probe. Will be launched next month September first week. 2. LUPEX:- joint venture by Japanese and india to send yet another rover to moon 3. Sukhrayan:- indias mission to venus, will be launched next year around September or December 4. Gaganyan:- indians to space by 2025 5. Mangalyan 2:- another mission to mars 6. Indias own space station, construction starting from 2028-30.

[@checkmate2625]

Whaatt?? UK space agency??? Never heard this term till date😂😂

[@Typhoon-fo9zt]

Some countries have moon in their flag and India reached on the moon. ❤😊

[@imakesense4456]

Germany , Uk and France i.e ESA is certainly a third rung space power if India is a 2nd rung space power😂😂😂

[@21stcenturyentertainment14]

We Indians are not here for a moon race. Our aim is pure Science. Its not a political/ superpower missions which had happened years ago.Speciality of this mission is that, its on the south pole of the moon, since it has got all adverse conditions & possiblities out there. Can u believe such a missiat a budget below 400cr? Our next aim is Sun, Venus, Mars and much more...

[@KarthikSoun]

You are German but you say "We went to moon half a century ago". Are you referring to a Racial achievement??? What a joke.. 😂😂😂

[@itchyballs3129]

Refering to the species .

[@manas3492]

water discovered by isro not nasa in moon. correct ur research

[@koteswar009]

13:04 Yes thats why India has advantage of being close to equator and big ocean on east of country. The launch pad is in an island town in my state in southern India.

[@DavinderEvolution]

the director of the UK space agency is of indian decent himself😂😂

[@kingofdevils]

So Russia has fallen behind India in 21st century space race

[@zetch3179]

nope... they're running along with india .

[@Maverick-zo4kc]

India is a global space power 🇮🇳 ISRO - Pride of India 🇮🇳 Proud to be an Indian 🇮🇳

[@Freethinker-vj4ut]

India should send mining projects to moon and asteroids.

[@peterclarke7240]

Can't wait for humanity to do some mining on the moon, destabilise it, and destroy the earth's fragile tidal system and throw our own orbit out, all because of greed 🤣

[@scratchy996]

@@peterclarke7240 Yeah, but think about the jobs it will create.

[@maxpayne4118]

​@@peterclarke7240It's better then drilling ocean bed anywhere and everywhere in order to get lucky with little gasoline 😂

[@scratchy996]

@lucyinthesky444 What good are jobs ? They can be used to gain political advantage. It also means increased on consumption and more money for corporations.

[@peterclarke7240]

@lucyinthesky444 I have a feeling they're not native English-speakers, or they're just not very bright. The fact the pair of them don't seem to understand the significant risk to the earth's orbit and ecosystem that mining on the moon poses is alarming. Not that it matters, of course. By the time it happens, we'll probably all be dead anyway. Maybe some of their children will get to watch the Earth become a planet of extreme heat and cold, as our orbit shifts without the counter-balance the moon creates, and their last thought before their blood boils or freezes solid will be "gosh, I'm so glad those poor corporations got lots of money at our expense!"

[@yogi_4099]

At this moment, the two leading space research organizations in the world are NASA of America and ISRO of India. The difference between them is that 36% Indian scientists work in NASA, and not a single American scientist works in ISRO. This is the success of BHARAT.

[@sps6]

Indias moon mission is for whole humanity

[@AyushShukla-ns3uy]

The moment India which represents global south beat rest of the world to lunar South Pole , they started talking about “exploitation” of the moon while NASA missions are for research 🤨

[@rajgop-vn9fi]

India was denied access to GPS during the Kargil war by the west. Later we developed satellites capable of doing that. West always allied with countries supporting terrorism. ISRO returned roughly 5 times returns to the amount spend on the organization. Around 500 television channels broadcast through our satellites, Our ATM transactions happen though the satellites Our stock trading happens through the satellites Fisherman get information about the availability of fish in the sea We launch foreign satellites through our rockets and earn money out of it.

[@aayushprakhar1711]

3:02 did he say britain is in 2nd tier??

[@Starlink502]

Britain have No shame 😂 When they can't even lunch a satellite

[@devamjani8041]

How did he make china a first tier power and India a second tier power ? He probably doesn't know that India is the first Asian country, 3rd country overall and the only country ever to reach Mars in their first attempt. So India is ahead of china in many ways. Ofcourse china has a lot more money so it can pursue really expensive missions like space station and etc over and over again. But India even with its tight budget has achieved so much and many things before china did. Also, he filled the second tier with every country😂. Britain for example has lost its space launch capability and can't put anything in orbit. In reality, the second tier should be occupied by France, Japan, Italy, Korea, Israel.

[@AwardQueue]

Also, stop talking about budgets（Indian excuses）, because getting a budget is an ability in itself.

[@jason34007]

it seems you don't know china took mine from the moon to the earth and land on the mars and own its delf space station several years ago. it is your right to be proud of your achivement, but please don't deny others.

[@jatingodhwani1916]

​​​@@jason34007 true. I agree.

[@vidhanchandrasahu1185]

A great victory for humanity 🎉

[@telx2010]

The gullible one's anyway

[@vtp157]

@@telx2010 cry

[@soumikadhikary7495]

When west does it… it’s marvelous, significant to all humanity When India does it… they are debating on Moon exploitation Hypocrisy

[@Gaardul666]

DON'T WORRY GERMANS WE WILL SURPRISE YOU SOON 😏

[@martavdz4972]

I think Germans are OK with that, they respect technical innovation and acknowledge technical successes, whether they´re done by EU or any other country. They actually run a lot of news on African technical innovations in their live stream.

[@Gaardul666]

@@martavdz4972 SO WHAT* SHOULD I CLAP FOR THAT OR. GIVE THEM NOBEL PRIZE OHH THANK-YOU YOU *CUTE* *GERMANSHPERDS* IF YOU HADnot ACKNOWLEDGE OUR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY IT' WOULD NEVER HAVE COME INTO. *EXISTENCE*

[@anuragpatil4073]

​@@martavdz4972Don't take him seriously. I think many Indians are angry about the racist comments made by British media anchors

[@Gaardul666]

@@anuragpatil4073 tu Indian nahi hai kya

[@anuragpatil4073]

@ZELAHALETAP666 I am an Indian bro and a modi supporter. But targeting unnecessarily. Target those racist who are claiming that UK provides aid to India

[@madhuri4355]

India had successful mars mission 7-8 yrs before china.

[@Doyen_balak]

Where is Lord Charu? 😂

[@amritsharma9181]

Water was first founded by our(India's) luner satellite 4:04

[@explorernikita]

Two words always compete with each other, exploitation and exploration. It depends on your viewpoint, Which one do you see first?

[@Maolana_ModiG]

Both are same words for west.

[@killvish5111]

if white people does that its exploration but.....

[@DD-kr8dm]

Thank you DW. We will knock your elite space club door again and again. We never forget the negative comments made about our space ambition. Still many of you reluctant to digest the fact that India reached to Moon. But one thing we will let you know that these innovations are not only for us but for the whole world even.

[@user__100]

Westerners should stick to topics they understand, like the Kardashians

[@Indian_Made]

These channels are being discussed after the successful landing of Chandrayaan 3. If America, China, Russia or even North Korea did it, this discussion wouldn't happen. But I'm surprised there wasn't so much discussion when India got to the moon.

[@nick00176]

North Korea on moon?

[@sandeepkant1815]

because it's the first time any nation has landed on south region of the moon

[@shivam_nagar69]

if NK does it, it will surely be same reaction as they are giving on ISRO

[@hunkmaximus]

Did he just called Britain a space power 🤦‍♂️😂😂 And over that he put UK in same tier with india ?🤣 U.K has done total 2 satellite lauches in 4 attempt 🤡 Let compare that to isro 🇮🇳💪

[@sarathnair3433]

Britain 😂 doesn't even come close to india 🇮🇳 in terms of space achievements

[@kn.5761]

How is UK second tier when It's space agency doesn't even have a proper launching vehicle today?

[@bigboss.800]

Main reason is USA ,UK , Russia and EU can't digest the fact that india has space technology and india became first country to land spacecraft on south pole of moon 🌝🌙 ,

[@martavdz4972]

Russia can´t digest it, but the West acknowledges it. Why shouldn´t we digest it? I live in EU and my country´s media ran praising articles about India being the first country to land on Moon´s South Pole. And in my game group, we created in-game decorations in celebration of India´s Moon langing. It´s a great technological success. You´re forgetting that the West values TECHNICAL SKILLS, INTELLIGENCE and KNOWLEDGE, whoever has them. So when a country shows exceptional skills, we appreciate it. Also, Europe is troubled by the war in Ukraine so we´re delighted by every piece of positive news. And this definitely was positive news 🙂 We resent China´s technological successes because some of them were achieved by stealing Western technologies, and we laugh at Russia´s failed mission because Russian science and politics have been a combination of corruption, incompetence and cruelty towards us for the last 10 years or so. When someone threatens to obliterate your cities with nuclear weapons if you stop buying their gas (yeah, Russia has threatened that to several European countries), you don´t feel inclined to praise their technical projects. But India´s project was fair and square, done with incredible dedication, team spirit, knowledge, and passion. That´s something we very much respect! 🙂

[@bigboss.800]

​@@martavdz4972🇨🇿🤝🇮🇳

[@zetch3179]

ur media spreading wrong info ..

[@anuragpatil4073]

​@martavdz4972 Many Indians are angry about the racist comments made by anchors of GB News and BBC. Honestly, we don't know what the people of EU and USA are thinking right now about us.

[@endoferagoat2393]

Africa is proud of India 🇮🇳 and we will soon be neighbours

[@dj_AD_mix]

Correction, some one from the speakers said that Neil Armstrong, was the one who found that there’s water on the moon, but he was or the USA was not the one who found that there is water on the moon. It was India’s Chandrayaan, the first mission to moon, which was launched in 2008 They discovered that there’s water on the moon.

[@prabhashankarpandey9790]

ISRO,s budget if NASA equivalent then India surprise world

[@_kartik_chauhan]

Director of UK space agency is also ethinic Indian hahha

[@superhit5678]

😂 UK space agency can't send a rocket into space 😂 Even their country is still running on looted 45 trillion dollar from India

[@bhushanraut9392]

I was surprised to hear the UK has a space organisation 😮😮😮😮, I thought as playing as a second fiddle to USA they must be not interested in it as they would be spoon fed By US some day 😂😂😂😂😂

[@annehersey9895]

I am so happy for India! This was more of an achievement for India because it IS a new player in Space. And I’m REALLY glad it was India and NOT Russia!!!

[@vijaybhaskar7034]

The Definition of a Developed nation today is obsolete. A Developed nation is one that works for the benefit of humankind.

[@martavdz4972]

I´m European and I very much agree. There have been talks about changing the definition for some time.

[@praveenpandey1176]

Water discover in 2008 moon by India

[@experimentnation3612]

Britain is not even in the third tear in space 😂😂😂

[@PrajwalChandangole-ur4bg]

cmon britian in second tier it's not even in a third tier 😂😂

[@satishacharya5544]

Not cheap. Fact of the matter is ISRO is the most cost effective, technology way advanced and strategically way ahead of so called elite powers.

[@cnvramamoorthy8358]

India Chandrayaan-3 mission will help to built all weather base station in moon sothern pole . After getting moon soil test , moon soil temperature , moon quake etc.., water can be used for fuel & soil can be used insulation , building & heat batteries . Minerals addition benefit

[@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451]

Then why we don't use warter as fule here😂

[@cnvramamoorthy8358]

@@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451 breaking water into hydrogen & oxygen used as fuel in here too . Indiia & many countries producing green hydrogen .

[@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451]

@@cnvramamoorthy8358 breaking hydrogen from water itself requires lots of energy it's not economical

[@_kartik_chauhan]

@@sawantvaibhavsanjay4451 solar energy and rocket fuel is actually HYDROGEN and Oxygen

[@Itsme_sukunaa]

16:45 even the director of UK's space agency is Indian or may be from Bihar/UP ojha ji😂

[@koteswar009]

This is peaceful space race unllike cold war. India's next Moon mission, the Indian Space Research Agency (ISRO) is collaborating with the Japanese space agency, JAXA. This joint mission LUPEX, short for Lunar Polar Exploration Mission, is slated for a 2025 launch with Indian GSLV MkIII rocket, moon rover and Japanese moon Lander. This Chandrayan 3 mission was to test the technology of the lander and rover and also other scientific data collection for human colony including USA Artemis human moon mission soon. This is not for one nation but for all humanity as Indian PM Modi said after the moon landing.

[@jaihind6675]

The difference is that, INDIA is able to do it genuinely and positive. USA and its allies are unable to digest the fact that INDIA succeeded in this venture.

[@tluangasailo3663]

Bruh, US helps every Indian mission since 2000s ....ur to pessimistic

[@ArabicReja973]

Thanks to NASA 🇺🇲 for the space cooperation agreement with India that China can't have.

[@tourravi8420]

Western is already worried about what is going to happen in the coming few year😅😂😂😁🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳✊✊✊💪🏻

[@Canthandlewithoutyou]

Yeah yeah thanks 😂

[@browncandy3750]

nasa is not a role except to track😂😂😂

[@lulla_tala_katilulli_vala]

Winnie the pooh got hurt😢

[@lipun7568]

​@@tourravi8420 Chinese bot

[@sk-is5sw]

Germanys fate is always on the hands of USA...they can't do anything in this world without permission from their .masters ..we really appreciate France for atleast they coming out from that position ❤️

[@jayavarapuchandrasekhar3497]

India discovered water on moon...chandrayaan-1...I think 🤔

[@SHKUMARAMAN]

100%

[@nps7742]

I don't see British or Germany in any space tech

[@Robert_austia]

Kindly DW news add subtitles as many are not natives English speaking 🗣️ 🔊

[@adghat7819]

Switch on you tube subtitles. Cc.

[@Robert_austia]

​@@adghat7819it's unavailable

[@Subscribe-please9]

Ask your Gomatha

[@Robert_austia]

@@Subscribe-please9 ask your pullah photo 😂🤣...oh yes Charlie herdo cartoon 😂🤣🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕✌️😝 Ask photo of kullah suck 😂🤣

[@ChiSa123]

India's launch sites are also nearest to the magnetic equator of Earth and it has a large body of water next to it i.e. The Indian ocean. This means it is an ideal place to launch fuel efficient rockets! This is why rockets are also launched from French Guyana... because it is also near the magnetic equator and next to a large body of water i.e. the atlantic ocean. Also, India is a country that can provide proper security and in a non-aggressive democratic country which is not trying to attack everyone like China. When it comes to defence and space India always maintains security in these areas regardless of politics! Other countries on the magnetic equator may not have the resources, political stability, or talent! Indian space scientists work for almost every space agency other than the Chinese... so, India has a remarkably high talent pool for space science!

[@pradyumnanayak9844]

Har Har Shambhu 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳