Can China and India end western dominance? | DW Business

[@makunahatata8700]

As an Indian i think we need both West and the East, I like both sunset and sunrise, I am a sunflower.

[@nicksonpinto2074]

Like a 🌻 poem.

[@cashcash5995]

We need both West and East , we just do not want to be vassals of the West , India still is ?

[@syrhusprod]

as an american, I hope our countries form a strong alliance to thwart China. I feel as though our countries are kindred in many ways

[@deanbarnett8538]

I believe that North Korea should join as an example of political direction. And Afghanistan for it's Theocratic example. Apart from India, most of the BRICKS countries are shades of North Korea and Afghanistan! A real rogues gallery! Putin should be the figurehead!

[@AbhinavBadagouni]

​@@syrhusprodthere is an alliance called QUAD

[@WalknTalkVlogs]

Correction: CIPS is quite small compared to UPI in terms of volume. Today 4% of global Internet payment transactions are conducted via UPI. UPI has recently been adopted in Singapore, Thailand, UAE, and 10 other countries. It's interesting to explore CIPS vs. UPI vs. SWIFT (Basically China vs. India vs. West) SWIFT is slower and more expensive for transactions. On the other hand, UPI is faster and less expensive than CIPS and SWIFT. At the end of the day, BRICS+ should adopt a cross-border payment system that offers lower cost of transactions, higher speed, more reliable infrastructure, and data security. UPI wins over SWIFT and CIPS.

[@LpG88]

SWiFT is slow because the western bankers want it so, they earn a lot of money from interest every extra day the money need to stay in their bank between transfer from account A to B.

[@aumvachhani1402]

​@@LpG88but the fact that i saw a german minister in india pay through UPI at a roadside vendor in less than 20secs😧

[@aburetik4866]

Source: Banglore scam call center

[@WalknTalkVlogs]

@@aburetik4866 Brother, mention your country and I will list down all the scams going on in your country. I have traveled all over Europe and lived in 4 European countries. Are you having a difficult time handling facts?

[@Liboch]

​@@aburetik4866correction : Bengaluru

[@louisa9617]

India and AU (African Union) think it will be fair that they are invited to be part of the Security Council

[@TL-fv5xg]

India should be included. US has been pushing for India to have a permanent seat on the UNSC since 1950.

[@AbhinavBadagouni]

India, AU, South America

[@PlaYer-sn5or]

The fact is the big five all Veto India as permanent member of UNSC : UK : Once France : Once Russia : Once China : Once US : Twice

[@buravan1512]

This time the SECURITY COUNCIL is meaningless...😂 Today we need another organization that could rival the UN.

[@YuruCampSupermacy]

That would never happen china will always veto India's inclusion

[@abrahamsneo7783]

Its really surprising how the people from the west and global north have problem with developing countries uniting together to improve their economic status. Economic agreements are necessary to uplift the global south out of poverty

[@surtrpicks]

It’s not the economies that bother the “west”, it’s the values and treatment of people that worries them. Not financial, moral.

[@abrahamsneo7783]

​@@surtrpicks politics divides people. Young people in the global south are interested in development not the politics of cold war, us vs them mentality is not working . When china visits africa, they leave infrastructure in form of roads, hospitals and more. When the westerners come to africa, they lectur africans how bad the Chinese are

[@KO.....]

@@surtrpicks which values or treatment of people? Are you suggesting they have values like colonising entire nations? Starting wars and balkanising nations? Killing leaders of nations and exporting terror groups they created like ISIS into other regions? Those moral reasons?

[@swarnavabanerjee4112]

​@@surtrpicksIndia doesn't agree with china iran and other nation but they are in Brics for joint improvement and reducing global poverty.

[@Funkywallot]

Look at China and Russia. Long tradition of mass murdering their own . And still, there have been non to take to court or even admitting any crimes against humanity. Values ? There is more. Dictatorships like Ethiopia, brutal theocraties like Iran and Saudi. Its like a club for the worst of the worst LOL. Some of the members are even enemys . So, naturally it raises som questions in the north. If somebody tells me that BRICS brings freedom and prosperity to the world. I would just laugh in their faces@@swarnavabanerjee4112

[@kumarkumar-ro1hz]

As a Indian i know our country mindset we believe in universal Brotherhood and by seeing the current generation kids i can say 100% India have the bright future in this planet .

[@TL-fv5xg]

you should start by trying to get along with your neighbors...

[@ishowsports008]

​@@TL-fv5xg well which major world power was ever at peace? We'll manage you should rather work on determining your genders.

[@cashcash5995]

The neighbor China is having a very bright present , when india will have his bright future?

[@4swaroop]

"current generation kids" / Religious f%%kwit.

[@freespiritable]

​@@ishowsports008it's scary that this jokes comes from a citizen of a country that discriminates on every reason they can get. Ypu aren't even able to treat your citizens equally, how can you think of becoming a global power without achieving that? It will break you from within.

[@IndiaTides]

China and India had a share of 25%-25% of global trade from 1 to 1800 AD. Western dominance is new in the world. You have the advantage of the scientific revolution. We will definitely bridge that gap. It will take time but by the end of the century, definitely.

[@TRAZ4004]

Congratulations on the successful moon landing.

[@ssr7301]

​@@TRAZ4004 thank u

[@optimisticoutreach1236]

and the T-Rex ruled the land at one point as well.

[@joexavier4070]

Can show me those 25% global trade of china and india First ad to 1800 ad One thing i know about india is they were enormous rich under Mughal

[@mr2981]

@@TRAZ4004 Yay, welcome to 1969, India.

[@God-is-my-protector]

India is sitting both in Brics and quad so it's actions clearly suggest that they want multipolar world...India perhaps is solution to this complex world order.

[@branbran9129]

Complex wrld order caused by the west

[@thegreatdane3627]

nope, India is the future battleground for a proxy war between the east and the west...

[@linkme2dnet]

Hah....India should just mind uplifting its countless population to a middle income standard of living (like Thailand/Malaysia/Chile level) and focus on investing in its own country first before throwing in huge sums to that NDB thing.

[@sahilrajput5746]

​​@@linkme2dnetyou are done?? India lifted 415 million people out of poverty, according to un report in 10 years, Bigger than your population, multidimensional poverty is just 14% in india now , and We are fast growing economy in the World,

[@sahilrajput5746]

​@@linkme2dnetindia already working on developing infrastructure, like bullet train corridors, 30k - 40k km expressways , metros in 50 cities 20 metro are operational now , rrts corridors faster than USA train , DFC corridors for Cargo, train like vande Bharat also being introduced, 11 industrial corridors, indian government is spending 1.5 trillion dollar, I guess bigger than your country GDP

[@rikagg1]

Elisha is on point to say that India is the only one standing for multi polar world, we’ll never let china dominate Asia or the world for that matter, no matter how much we trash USA, at the end of the day; it’s a democracy and best bet for leading the world; if not USA then only multipolar world is what we’ll accept

[@Western_Decline]

mentally colonized Indians, kneel before your masters

[@jaibholenath6900]

We Don't Accept the Demonratic Liberal Jihadi Evangelical Terrorism of US either.

[@thedelanyo]

Democracy is just a surface story, underneath that story is a different story.

[@jvs9797]

well said 😊

[@learn-2-earnn]

One things for sure..india won't accept American hegemony now ....

[@offred6013]

West has already pushed Russia in China camp. Dont loose India too

[@ASH9366]

India not going anywhere 😌

[@andrewelphick2304]

Lose not loose. FFS.

[@prabhakar0076]

India has its own side, sphere and so on.

[@matt-eu-poland]

Russia push itself into an absyss. It will be a gas station of China. Not bad for the West at all

[@烟雨听]

@kjgd-ck4wh 那上北约下场打倒俄罗斯好了。

[@IndiaTides]

Removing western dominance is not anti-west. The world deserves their due place in the global governance.

[@mr2981]

What is their "due place"?

[@IndiaTides]

@@mr2981 UNSC P5 should have seats based on the region. They should correspond to the current economic, and military realities. IMF and World bank needs to expand share of the developing countries.

[@JoseSantos-xh9mp]

The world needs peace! not war! And the occident Loves WAR!

[@Santanibalak1]

​@@mr2981why UK France and Russia is still part of UNSC permanent seat I think at today UNSC need reforms and create another 5 members 1 USA 2 China 3 EU 4 India 5 AU 6 Brazil 7 ASEAN they are deserving candidates

[@thegreatdane3627]

the security council should rather just be disbanded. It is completely pointless, and hasn't actually prevented any wars.

[@aresdan]

Can't imagine a cooperation between India-China and Iran-Saudi Arabia (future BRICS members). They are even more rivals between each other than "West" and "East"

[@Robert_austia]

Ohh 😯 In before ww was france and uk not fighting 😅😂

[@heartofsteel7821]

Cant wait to see the west disappointed. The west has leaves in bubble for too long that they have fail to see reality. The countries will worl together.

[@raviguptaboards]

Accurate comment

[@Adarshkumar-te8dw]

As a Indian l fully agree Because of CCP it is impossible

[@goldenG978]

well as an Indian let me explain to u there is a brics bank which is quite profitable for us we are their for just economic reasons whereas china wants to use brics as to challenge the West Difficult dilemma for us

[@sonu337337]

The whole world is family no rivalry just peace and love from INDIA to the world 🌎

[@esteemedyams]

Right, that's what russia and China are all about; peace and love.

[@sonu337337]

@@esteemedyamsmy dear brother hate just spread hate u know KARMA what goes around comes around peace and love to u ❣️

[@Ashwinkumar.]

Yeah i agree 👍

[@cashcash5995]

The whole world is a colony , India still likes it .

[@gaurav-hn5zd]

Bhai ye India ki taraf se self made spokesperson banna band Karo. World politics complex hai aur tum log har jagah peace love, world is a family .... Wahi bakwas shuru kar dete ho. These comments in thousands of numbers suck.

[@ASH9366]

21:30 very happy to see she understanding India Europe's eyes are opening 🙄 Very early to say Or she is expert of Asia Pacific 🧐watching Indian media 😎

[@ronneyismael605]

India follows the concept of vasudhaiva kutumbakam which means The world is One Family. As an Indian I know my country very well.

[@seanbrennan9188]

How's that working out in Manipur? If that's how you define family you need to go to family therapy.

[@adityarai5568]

@@seanbrennan9188 there are problems not only in manipur but in nuh in rajasthan in west bengal elections, there are lots of problem but these problems will be solved very strictly and these situations won't change our values and morale

[@pelandolickasshole8715]

@@seanbrennan9188 we Indians don't need therapy and mental support stuff, you need them

[@Anshex.e]

Nah no West 💀 100 million people died , 45 trillion and destroyed our business and people

[@Anshex.e]

​@@seanbrennan9188Less than holocaust and colonial era 🤡

[@pineapplesareyummy6352]

Either India or China alone has more people than the entire West! Your days are numbered. The world can now be divided neatly into two camps: a US-dominated Western camp who DO NOT believe in sovereignty, who thinks they have the right to meddle in the internal affairs of all other states, and decide what values, political systems and economic systems other nations are allowed to practice. On the other side stand the 7 billion people of the rest of the world who DO believe in sovereignty as the cornerstone of international relations. These 7 billion people accept that we are diverse civilisations, with diverse values, religions, methods of governance, and that no country has any right to impose anything on anyone else. In this global struggle, we will win and you will lose! There are more of us than there are of you. There may indeed be disagreement between India and China, just as there are disagreement between any two countries. But where India and China both stand in lock step is the non-negotiability of sovereignty and multipolarity. Neither India nor China will EVER allow the West to tell them how they should be governed, what their foreign policy posture should be, who they should trade with, who they should be in alliance with. Western intervenionism is just late-stage Western IMPERIALISM, where the West still hasn't yet accepted that you no longer have any say in the internal affairs of the rest of the world. Western "dominance" is going to end (assuming that it hasn't already ended). Multipolarity, and the return of NATIONAL SOVEREIGNTY and NON-INTERFERENCE (rather than Western interventionism) as the cornerstone of international relations is NON-NEGOTIABLE.

[@thegreatdane3627]

that is just a return to the cold war. But the eastern bloc will be dominated by china instead of russia this time.

[@pineapplesareyummy6352]

@@thegreatdane3627 China does not want to dominate, nor does it have the ability of dominate. China has no ideology to spread to the rest of the world. It is NOT China who is spreading and enforcing Communism on the rest of the world - it is the West that is imposing and forcing liberal "democracy" and capitalism on the rest of the world (Note: by "democracy", it means acceptance of Western domination and subordination to Western preferences in values system). Well, nobody outside the Western bloc believe that. The rest of the world are a diverse bloc with completely different values, religions. But Western aggression has awoken the ENTIRE WORLD that it must unite to counter Western domination, or else we will all be Westernised to the detriment of our civilisation values and our national interests.

[@jetli740]

@@thegreatdane3627 brics is about trade not dominated , all party have equal power

[@thegreatdane3627]

@@jetli740 Brics: "we are all equal". China: "but some are more equal than others."...

[@jetli740]

@@thegreatdane3627 that is your opinion, trade all equal none one dictate anything all go throught voting system

[@VishalT_Finance]

21:25 She forgot INDIA don’t need to beg for mercy from USA remember they Import from India. She need to do little more home work.

[@manimalworks7424]

We don’t want to end western dominance, we just don’t want to be dominated

[@jetli740]

cant have both. you have to choose

[@NCJ-Innov]

The latter bud

[@lipun7568]

​@@jetli740If West like domination then they should be dominated

[@bb9a]

understand their comment

[@modernpronationalistharshg8647]

Doesn't know about Others But a wise Indian diplomat say We need Both west as well as East.

[@prabhakar0076]

Yes UK and USA for Janitors. Bcos we r new in Toilet building 😂

[@Bradymcbridhe8304]

​@@prabhakar0076ignorant.

[@aa-hb3tg]

USA doesn’t think like That For them it’s only slaves or enemies

[@mhlengidlamini994]

The US is 50 countries masquerading as one, the don't agree on literally anything and yet we don't doubt their ability to get things done. The EU, a group of countries masquerading as one, don't agree on a lot of things and yet we don't doubt their ability to get things done.

[@lastChang]

Countries now are smart enough to know about China 🇨🇳. It can't fool others anymore.

[@ashifabedin]

taiwan not a country ,,,china number 1

[@heartofsteel7821]

China is great democracy. Everybody wants to be associated with China, India, Russia, SA and Brazil.

[@aslampervez2294]

Biggest fool is usa having around 800 billion dollars trade with china

[@aj3314]

İs that why another 6 nations joined in an organisation where China is 1 of main powers?

[@calvinblue894]

Yes..now they know China is not a Warmonger like USA.. That's why 6 new countries join BRICS..and many more will too..

[@Parth_k92]

As a indian person, I have a sense of respect for Chinese and other east Asian people. I wish a better synergy and trust in entire of Asia.

[@archibaldsamu5873]

India must understand now that it will be treated just like China when it becomes the 3rd largest economy in a few years time.

[@kiannaples7867]

ASEAN people hate china.. we stand with Taiwan.

[@Neyobe]

Likewise!

[@weewillywonga]

The Chinese do not have a mutual feeling like that towards India.

[@caomilo1031]

@@weewillywonga Most Chinese do not have any hostility towards India, unlike India where politicians and media are talking about China bad all day long.

[@davidcoldstar6333]

Unlike India, The Chinese economy has completely collapsed. The bubble economy had already ended two years ago. And China will never have a boom again. China will suffer an unprecedented recession for at least 20 years.

[@Percival5]

China is doing very great unlikely like Europe in recession

[@TRAZ4004]

China has a serious demographic issue with an aging population and a massive real estate bubble. China has the benefit of a world leading industrial infrastructure

[@AnzorAzhiev95]

🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@justinwolf7490]

This is true. India is very happy they did not go in on China’s belt and road debt trap. India will continue to work with everyone east to west but China is in huge trouble right now because of ccp policies.

[@ARIA-In]

But china is still growing with 5.9 % after india with 6.5%

[@raghavsingh.]

India wants multipolar world which is good for entire world.

[@Sahil32854]

Common Indians , you guys not need to spam everywhere how good you are. Gaining sympathy is nice but also strengthen yourself so you need not to depend on US , EU or China. Be like king Ashoka to have longer reign than being crushed by external politics. US , EU are equally racist and won't let India take Multipolar order.

[@escorel89]

Europeans and Americans be like crazy when anyone says they had enough of centuries of them telling others what to do and how to do with and with what money to pay

[@dimitridshaw]

The u.s hasn't been around for centuries

[@porkNbenz]

its not wrong to dream, $$$ is still king

[@yomamasohot6411]

​@@dimitridshawreally? I thought they got independence in 1760-70s, whatever it was.

[@uromvictor]

@@porkNbenzthere was a time the pound was king too. For you to say it out indicates the dollar is in decline

[@porkNbenz]

@@uromvictor like i said you can dream. Good luck with brics but i wont bet on it.

[@josealexander1674]

India will work with BRICS and it is called Global South needs to be prosperous.

[@larissamello374]

In Brazil people do not see BRICS as rivalry to G7. President Lula is reflecting the vision of a country. It is a 15 years old institution and the only time we heard we were anti west was after Russia invaded Ukraine. Which does not make any sense because we cannot be against what we are. One does not need geopolitical reasons to not use the dollar. If the US did not make such a mess with it harming latin america or if our interest rate wasn’t so much higher or even if WTO hadn’t been working since forever we would not be so supportive of BRICS. But we see these issues as essential for our economical development. Is G7 anti global south or only when we come together we have to be anti something??

[@AdamBuccaschie]

When Putin and Xi publically address that Brics should be "Anti-west" I think we should take Brics as anti-West and we should treat these countries accordingly. If Brazil really want to be anti-west and to be in the same group of punch of anti-west dictators then Yes, Brazil yes indeed in the other side, already.

[@larissamello374]

@@AdamBuccaschie This is China and Russia vision for the BRICS. The other members do not agree with it. The only new anti - west member is Iran. It’s very good for business and economy. If the west want to believe that BRICS institutions are against them, it will be a very lonely future.

[@Kiki123-k5r]

​@@AdamBuccaschie Great !it doesn't matter what the west thinks its aways been the enemy of the Global South,Bye Bye Colonizers!

[@larissamello3262]

@@AdamBuccaschie there are 3 anti west countries in the group: China, Russia and Iran. The others like Ethiopia, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Argentina, India are not. The European Union is not anti - US because Macron is vocal against it.

[@buravan1512]

Wake up...

[@waheex]

No. China needs to surpass the US in the next 5 years or it never will, there is no sign this will happen. Quite the opposite. India is becoming very strong, but my guess is that they will pivot westwards against China's imperialistic expansion

[@freaksuyash]

India just needs to kick Modi out of power, and then we sale west wards. That might actually happen in the next elections.

[@Robert_austia]

😂😂 Again communist will increase 😂😂 Better would be free india than communist china😂

[@heartofsteel7821]

China is a great democracy. Everybody wants to associate with them ex ept the evil west.

[@firefly4907]

Indians won't pivot anywhere, judging by their history, they'll remained non aligned.

[@joexavier4070]

​@@firefly4907nah,this time they openly choosen eastern bloc They never condemned Ukraine war that it self shows they in eastern bloc,they for a anti western world order Most probably end of globalisation is coming

[@jasonmonge9969]

What about the G7!?? Where the USA is the one who benefits the most!! Is that good? So then why if China is the biggest player in the BRICS is a bad thing?? Can somebody please explain?! Thank you

[@jeromeanthony-t1c]

Maybe the other countries in G7 don't mind the US being on top, but in the bricks, India wouldn't want to see China benefiting the most.

[@svanimation8969]

​@@jeromeanthony-t1cas per Indian population size ! And Chinese aggression on border ! India not gonna give China upper hand

[@shoeexpress3601]

@@jeromeanthony-t1c exactly China's growth is slowly getting down India should have 7% average growth rate to end the gap snd beat USA to become second largest economy by 2045

[@brian.z6592]

China probably can, but not India, because India is still following America in many international affairs.

[@Ati-Maharathi]

India doesn't want to end western dominance. India wants to create its own dominance.😎

[@prabhakar0076]

Side effect is western dominance ends😂

[@memrman8331]

Mate India cant be the sole dominant power without China. Thats just going back to the old times anyway

[@descent2023]

Even if India become world leader one day, you will never see another China or USA. India is based out of love and care to the world, to too the needed ones.. Like we support African nations to come to the front.. There are no wars and captures, but seeing them equals in terms of humanity.. Modi is greatest leader of our times❤❤❤

[@SoulTheMagnificent]

No country has a God-given right to be at the top of anything. However, if you think carefully about the monetary stability and fiscal history of some of these countries then you suddenly think that the dollar is VERY SAFE.

[@ArthurShotgun]

Yeah very safe lol. You just freezed 300 billion dollar reserves of Russia. That's why every country is rethinking if they will be next on the list. USA has weaponized the dollar for geopolitical advantages.

[@kunjukunjunil1481]

Lol

[@36G]

Their instability is directly related to the dollars dominance. That's why so many are joining

[@alanssshh]

the sanctioned countries laughing at your stupidity

[@yomamasohot6411]

2008 destroyed many countries' economy around the world. No, thank you!

[@nebiatyessuwork7139]

FYI, Ethiopia is rich in natural resources, you name it, Ethiopia got it. Ethiopia is endowed with tracts of virgin and fertile land. With a 125 million plus population a country twice the size of Germany is surely very attractive to anyone.

[@s9ka972]

*India* 🇮🇳 : We are in *QUAD* politically against China and in *BRICS* economically against West

[@xyz-iz2kf]

Chad

[@svanimation8969]

Gotcha 🎉

[@nightowl1435]

Checkmate

[@farthurf.5221]

🗿 unthinkable mission

[@mikelundberg6550]

BRICS will not affect the US Economy right now! But BRICS will have a massive affect on the US Economy by 2032! ✅

[@blackphoenix114]

The western media is now running out of arguments😂

[@peteck007]

China can, and it's very much doing it. Meanwhile India would definitely reach to certain level where it could become a big economy, but largely it wouldn't show the power dominance and more likely to stay aloof.

[@ArthurShotgun]

Yeah India, we just want to stay neutral & chill between this west vs east( US vs China coldwar). Both of them can fight, India just wants to develop itself & it's citizen & take whatever benefit we can from both sides lol.

[@MartinMenge]

@@ArthurShotgunWell, if BRICS doesn't deliver a multipolar world, India always has the option of joining the west, slowly take over the batten from the USA. A move the US will likely support as interests are calibrated.

[@pineapplesareyummy6352]

India would NOT be able to stay aloof. Trust me. China would LOVE to be aloof, and just quietly develop, like it did in the 2000s. It still tries to be aloof, stay out of everyone else's business whenever possible and not comment on what happens in the rest of the world that's obviously not China's business. But this is an impossible dream when you have a Western bloc (orchestrated by the US) that constantly interferes in everyone else's internal affairs. Every few years, the US finds a new country to invade, sanction, crush, because it didn't like its political system or social values or economic policies. The other countries in the US mafia piles in. China had tried to ignore what happened to Afghanistan, Iraq, etc. But this only allows the West to expand its power and influence, at the expense of China's or Russia's or the rest of the world's. Thus, China could no longer be quiet. Hence, SCO and BRICS have taken on new meaning and new importance, China solidified its alliance with Russia, in order to counter the West.

[@anuragrawat391]

@@MartinMenge US will never tolerate any regional or global power. Doesn't matter if it's india, china, russia, iran or any other country.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

@@pineapplesareyummy6352 : Disputed islands anyone ? Fishing rights abuse ? etc ? etc ?

[@nitinkumar29]

India supported and still supports non-alignment movement, the non-alignment can be best materialized by multi-polar world, and that will create not only harmony among countries around the world but also balance of power which will eradicate the oppression of smaller nation by bigger and powerful countries, once this is done, the countries can trade with each other without feeling exploited. So in nutshell, India has not left the ideology that it has championed since its independence since 1947. Also, I think, no two countries are same and they need multiple groups to locate themselves keeping their identity, cultural, religious etc. understanding which may not addressed in a group with big powers which may have their own priority and may choice to ignore the above-mentioned concerns of the weaker country of the group.

[@judyl.7811]

1:30 credible 1:35 complementary region

[@currentzone8160]

India is 3 largest country... Most populist country but we are not in security Council... Is it not hypocrisy of west... We have not any option but to make a another world order❤❤❤

[@lipun7568]

China also do not want to have Veto power in UN by India. They every country West and Russia support India but China didn't. I know when China will support others will oppose. So your decision is good.

[@yomamasohot6411]

China doesn't want India in the security council. Evryone except china is in favour.

[@DalitShiv_Nagwanshi]

West wants to give India 🇮🇳 a seat in security council But it's CHINA which is Bl0cking it

[@SuperSksmanian]

Excellent analysis by Alicia , mainly because hardly we have rational discussion in DW , and this was a pleasant surprise ..

[@Oceansta]

Pretty much every discussion is level and balanced in DW. They're even critical of their own government - something that's probably an alien concept to you. Perhaps what they say doesn't suit your agenda?

[@user-littleoldbrother]

​@@Oceansta中国人都觉得DW是美国的口舌！

[@PeepalPawan]

Great analysis by the lady! 👍🏽

[@ASH9366]

She's watching Arnab 😎😁😅

[@rrrajlive]

Finally someone makes sense and not random hate for India for no reason.

[@tlp3482]

The best thing about BRICS is it's ability to keep you guessing. Thinking that China and India will always be at loggerheads will be your downfall. The world is moving on without the garden

[@YOUNGDOCGH]

Corruption and avarice are exerting significant influence in Africa rather than the Western countries.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

Iran, Saudi Arabia, UAE and Egypt are all close friends and they get along really well. Ethiopia and Argentina are politically cohesive and such strong economies. [sarcasm]

[@pineapplesareyummy6352]

@@thinkingcitizen That is ending. You may find the Middle East is becoming woke to the divide-and-conquer of the West. This is why China was able to broker a peace between Saudi Arabia and Iran, because that is what both sides want anyway. They found an excuse to settle their dispute (an invitation to join BRICS), and they have much more to gain working together against Western imperialism.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

@@thinkingcitizen : Iran's relationship with India is somewhat strained. A quick search of "does Iran get along with India" will show those tensions. Cheers.

[@juancubojamez8843]

Hahaha, I hope Argentina joins soon ... because if this continues like this... it won't be Argentina next year

[@highplatform1649]

Iran and Saudi friends is a news for me

[@blackbrute2504]

Russia and USA fought together in world war 2. Just saying.

[@inderpalsingh713]

As an Indian, I'm damn sure that all other comments that starts with "As an Indian" are written by paid trolls

[@currentzone8160]

Good analysis by lisa love from 🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@DutchFR1908]

The west won't forget lets see how happy you will be with china or russia

[@liang8255]

Nobody intends to alter Western countries. Non-western countries have right to do things their way amongst themselves, it’s an alternative not dominance. The BRICS are at equal foot, whereas G7 is one boss and six servants (no one in G7 is at the same power position as US, only closer servant such as Japan in comparison to South Korea, UK to Germany). The only problem is West losing its reign on developing countries, much more difficult to exploit developing countries.

[@alanssshh]

well said

[@alanssshh]

nobody is richer than America as a country. Japan was hit in 1990 because it was close to American as a country. @suriyasparx

[@jboreal7982]

Simply stated, if the BRICS-plus objective is to broaden their member nations global influence by trade agreements then I see no reason why that would fail - if member nations are truly invested. The question that has been whispered about in the West is whether or not the BRICS will establish a shared gold backed currency to compete with the U.S dollar dominance. The early answer to that is no. That being the case, The BRICS is just another trade agreement that joins major economies to emerging economies.

[@omgsam2263]

obviously as an european, she and DW are worried. she put a high hope for brics failure by keep highlighting the issue betw china and india. she will be disappointed. those issue is not do or die, most important is economy. how to derisk from US dollar.

[@rudicarlosmurga5217]

Screenshots shout should work as far as notifications go 16:05

[@rudicarlosmurga5217]

Show they r proof

[@escorel89]

What about Alicia saying Brazil is the only country that is in the Western Hemisphere? Almost all of Europe sit is in the Eastern hemisphere... We are not talking about geography here lady, it is about geopolitics

[@buravan1512]

Exactly, in politics you have to read between the lines 😂 the WEST means something else, the competition is not geographical... For example: AUSTRALIA and NEW ZEALAND are in the WEST, could you believe that?

[@RightWing-i9c]

We've sent India in there as The Great Western Empire to ensure that organization run in endless circles forever

[@cinpeace353]

It is not just China and India, the whole global south wants a multipolar world. 😅

[@AnubhavSingh-nb3bt]

We are not friends of china we are democracy not communists. So plz dont take our name with Chinese bateaters

[@atlrr8366]

You guys in Europe are starting to get the message....The majority of the world is moving forward! You have committed enough attrocities and United Nations of the Global South has had enough......

[@frederikpedersen689]

russia is commiting attrocities right now

[@atlrr8366]

@@frederikpedersen689 Long Live Russia... Africa stands 💯% with Russia!

[@WHS_reviews]

​@@atlrr8366: GTFOOH war criminal helper! Just ESAD!

[@WHS_reviews]

​@@atlrr8366: You guys are NOT moving forward. And talking about atricities is a laugh, go look at your own history, you war criminal helper!

[@sparks1792]

@@atlrr8366this kinda of hurts your point lmao

[@Avaricumstudios]

Surprisingly no one talks of the EAC ...DRC,Rwanda, Burundi, Kenya,Tanzania, Uganda ,South Sudan and soon Somalia...these countries are rapidly integrating and have similar ethnicities and shared cultures....

[@joybandopadhyay2557]

Somehow if india and china can sort out their differences and as russia has brotherly and friendly relations with both, things can get extremeleyyyyyy interesting 🤔

[@jaibholenath6900]

That SOMEHOW means Xina has to withdraw unconditionally.

[@shoeexpress3601]

It Only Help China's desd economy India should corporate with both economicaly we must have 8 T economy by the end of 2030

[@antrondon3654]

23:07 strange how the commentator here failed to connect Lula's speech about the G7 with her previous point about a multi-polar word. Brazil's interest is the same as India on this matter. But it seems that she still thinks of Brazil as a lesser nation that has to get a call from Washington before it's speeches. Lula's previous speeches criticized the dollar and the USA hegemony. Acting as if those comments are an attack on the entire G7 exposed she still sees European countries as vassal states to the US.

[@shubodas499]

We Indians are the future🇮🇳🙏

[@nanthakumarrr]

Energy -Rare Metal-Trade and Transport binds them together.

[@JigilJigil]

The problem with BRICKS is that all BRICKS members are pursuing their own interests and almost every member interests contradict with one or two other members interests, BRICKS is going to be a big failure as its members will oppose each other all the time.

[@JessicaSunlight]

they are not democracies, they cannot cooperate, they don't even grasp what is humanity which is basis for respecting other people and cooperation. They are together because they see democratic countries as a threat to their autocratic position and they know democracy is the future and it grows around the world gradually. they are together to form some kind of alliance of axis against west so that they can do something about west together. For example China dreams to get Taiwan but they know USA will defend Taiwan with military, they hope if they grow BRICKS there will be collective force to fight west. Same with India who has territorial disputes and wants to get Pakistan back into India. They do not like that West did not allow Putin to get away with invading Ukraine.

[@sweetienkd3670]

its BRICS not BRICKS .....

[@JessicaSunlight]

you did not get it @@sweetienkd3670

[@MartinMenge]

The conflicting interests is not necessarily an Achilles' heel. In recognition that the world is moving towards being more multipolar where there will be growing contradicting interests they could construct a new global governance architecture. Such a rules based order may have much fewer and watered down rules compared to the current one. However, this depends on not a single country seeing itself as plausibly being able to become the single superpower in a new unipolar world.

[@senomaganu2723]

Wishful thinking

[@gmock9427]

Is it Argentina or Brazil?

[@semanadelherrero]

A multi-polar world is the common aspiration of all BRICS countries. Ending the dominance of the West is also in line with the trend of the world. It is wrong for the Western media to blame it on a world dominated by China, because everyone is based on the foundation of peaceful development. In order to provide a broader road for more developing countries in the world, the Western world led by the United States is committed to restricting the development of developing countries and blocking technology so that they can better harvest the world. Most people in the world have seen I know what the West is doing, so don’t use this as a reason to deal with the BRICS countries. If you want to fight against the BRICS countries, you are not afraid at all. Will the countries that control more than half of the world’s resources and population be afraid of the West? The answer is no, because These countries are all developing countries, and the strongest representatives are basically big countries.

[@escorel89]

again, the main thing in discussion is not a common currency for all these countries. it is about using their own currencies to trade between each other. why should they use American dollars for trade?

[@minzhang1640]

The idea of one against another is so old fashioned. Why it has to be always like that? Why someone has to dominate others?

[@xieccs]

If one looks G7’s reaction to BRICS and its expansion, comparing with the rest of world, you know this is something that G7 countries hate to happen, as it threatens their privileges as a exclusive club. For that alone shows the value of the BRICS

[@CedarHunt]

The G7 hasn't made any statements about BRICS beyond some completely justified skepticism that the group can hold together. Nobody is afraid of an alliance of losers.

[@TL-fv5xg]

I think the IMF/World Bank have reached out a hand to the New Development Bank to work together on infrastructure projects. The NDB is the only tangible aspect of BRICS. So don't see much merit in your statement

[@NotSomethingIsNothing]

@@CedarHunt If that's the case, I wonder why the mouth pieces of western nations (western media) is trying so hard to downplay the value of BRICS as an organisation with all these anti-BRICS videos last few days.

[@Pointi69]

Sure, we don t thrust autocrats. Why should we want them to become stronger? Wouldn't make sense for us. In Western history there were no autocrats which were good for anybody nor in russia or china.

[@highplatform1649]

Mistaking BRICS with just China is a big mistake. The other voices are loud and clear.

[@enriquesouza5296]

I'm brasilian and I think that's a UE and EUA problem, nations don't want to be dependent anymore, and rule by our own interests

[@tut2tut2]

Bem colocado amigo.

[@outerspace8158]

Create latin currency dude

[@Nicolasmlago]

Surreal o olhar deles mal falam do Brasil ela falando q não tem ideia por que dos outros países

[@no.1spectator39]

I don't think G7 is a thing anymore

[@hemalbhatt4055]

India will focus on sny multi lateral ageeements which will serve the interests of the international community and ehich serves the national interests without creating obstacles for any Nation.

[@notjohnnyrico]

And then China trolling India by showing new map which claims India's territory as China's

[@BaljinderSingh-xy4ik]

Brics rival itself more than others

[@kushsingh9088]

Nicely said..😂😂

[@intothespace.....9442]

Well done Allicia, I foresee India as a more powerful nation due to its genericity towards the world and democracy!

[@birjusharma8104]

West will use indian's democracy for its advantage to weaken india but they can't do the same with china cuz china have a internet firewall

[@tim_peaky]

India's officials just went to a summit in Taiwan. so no, they won't threaten the western economy. I do hope that India's influence on the world increases. they have a beautiful and positive mindset.

[@aa-hb3tg]

India wants multipolar world and that requires ending of western dominance

[@CristianPrecoma]

Remember that Brazil is the first food productor of the world.

[@Lekechimwanderemw]

Variety is good, in the end humanity wins.

[@brawales]

Go BRICS.

[@casualsuede]

This is what I see. If BRICS is trying to grow each others economies like ASEAN, then hopefully it will work. If it's to give the middle finger to the west and for each country to support it's own interests, it will fail and if it is to create something other than an economic partnership, like trying to creating a military or political bloc, it will fail BADLY.

[@yurimorgan7460]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@yte549]

Its your dream😂😂😂

[@jeromeanthony-t1c]

True, they should have their own vision, not try to destroy the west.

[@yomamasohot6411]

China and India together in a military partnership when they are rivals doesnt make sense.

[@yte549]

@@yomamasohot6411 Saudi and Iran can resolve it then India and China too

[@maftab3818]

BOYCOTT Dollar BOYCOTT Dollar

[@MilesBellas]

BRICKS : authoritarianism destined to infighting ?

[@yomamasohot6411]

You think India, Brazil and Argentina are authoritarian?

[@MilesBellas]

@@yomamasohot6411 The Norwegian newspaper Aftenposten commented that the BRICS group has "become a global club for authoritarian and reactionary leaders, with China and Russia at their head."

[@Stekopo]

Being dominated by western hegemony is authoritarianism while BRICS surpassing and becoming immune to western sanctions and meddling is democratic in a real sense.

[@WallaseyanTube]

It is a shame that O'Neill's contribution was so brief. The rest of the video has hardly taken a look at what the members of BRICS might have in common or at what they might be able to achieve as a group on a practical level.

[@nishantb80]

All the trouble in the world right now is a result of dominance and war plus crony capitalism and religious extremism. It's high time that leaders work towards renewable energy, peace, uplifting living standards of people and stop wasting public money on weapons. We have indeed not overcome the barbaric mindset, only change is that we make more and more destructive weapons with technology.

[@larrythao1414]

How? Both of them dont even get along due to border disputes and skirmishes.

[@currentzone8160]

India needs east and west.. And also india wants to stop expansionist 🇨🇳.... It's tough but it is need of hour

[@alanssshh]

MSM and CIA working pretty well

[@SeeLasSee]

Greater say and dominance comes with greater responsibility. The USA should ask China to match its humanitarian and development aid at 50%. China gives almost Nothing.

[@samip3124]

She has really good study of geopolitics commendable 🎉

[@fearlessswiftie6458]

i want to to my masters in geo politics as i have very deep interest in geo politics

[@samip3124]

@@fearlessswiftie6458 good for you

[@DalitShiv_Nagwanshi]

​@@fearlessswiftie6458where are u from?

[@fearlessswiftie6458]

@@samip3124 thanks.

[@fearlessswiftie6458]

@@DalitShiv_Nagwanshi i am an indian living in Slovenia.

[@gurvirsingh7877]

India will be last superpower of this planet and in space also u can't stop that . Only way west can save themselves from china don't let china and india get together.

[@A_Patriot_Bengali]

Germany must fuel India to become a real military hardware & semiconductor production house. Because trust me 🙏 A superpower India will never blackmail anyone. Will never attack or invade anyone! A weapon industrialisation will decrease India's dependency on the Russians too.

[@rogerma7831]

Please give independence back to the kingdom of Sikkim

[@AbhishekSingh-zv2tn]

@@rogerma7831 search war nathula 1967 sikkim

[@lipun7568]

​@@rogerma7831Did we force them to join with India like China did with Tibbet.

[@calvinblue894]

@@alu-du5st Tibet is fine..what nuclear program you talking about?

[@A_Patriot_Bengali]

@@rogerma7831 FREE TAIWAN

[@baibhabjitdas1056]

Let the panelist talk in her native language and provide subtitles(captions) in english. Why so stress on english?

[@revolutionarydefeatism]

Can Brazil and India have a half-veto on the UN Security Council? :-D If both are vetoed, then it will be in effect. 😀

[@buravan1512]

UN should be dissolved,

[@deborahhebblethwaite1865]

Please explain to me how each country evaluates their currency. Against what? I thought BRICS would have one currency. What you are really getting at is Free Trade. No such thing I know I am 🇨🇦

[@AB-mn5re]

whoa , india is in position of make a kingmaker ! west need to take india on his side at any cost . india's position matters the most . wherever india leans that side feel weightage . come on WEST shower money , technology transfer ,and respect for india on global stage .

[@aj3314]

İndia gdp is about 3 trillion And with accepting the new 6 members that make more than 3 trillion İndia has lost any advantage that they had against China and Russia

[@s9ka972]

@@aj3314 Which is country in group other than China and India more than 3 TN $ economy.

[@aj3314]

@@s9ka972 collect the new 6 members that just joined

[@s9ka972]

@@aj3314 come on Egypt vs Ethiopia and Saudi vs Iran , do you think they are to be taken as a single unit. India very well knows that Brics is not going to work politically . For them Brics is like economically benefiting by less interest loans from New Development bank in Indian currency and to show US that we need more technology transfers .

[@AB-mn5re]

@@aj3314 india's GDP is 3.75 trillions ; close to 4 trillion .

[@cybourne5910]

Is Germany or US more important for the G7? Just wondering if the lady would talk about "balance" in the same way?

[@moali8434]

things r moving very fast , hopefully by 2025 we can start using GOLD as money , no more hard fiat currency BS

[@notyourtypical4915]

India and china should resolve there problem,and com together to be two great country's, both economically and militarily,they need to work together,they are neighbors,and Russia as well

[@yp77738yp77739]

US intransigence has forced them to do this. I hope they succeed, not least because I have interests there too!

[@MartinMenge]

Indeed. Intransigence leads to stagnate. Stagnation leads to decline.

[@yp77738yp77739]

@@MartinMenge It’s the Straussian elements within the US government that have got themselves into this mess post 1960s. They have accelerated the decline of their Empire, by military interventionism and made the classic mistake of spreading themselves too thinly. No one country or empire can control the world for more than a few decades, it can’t work. Sometime soon that huge debt is going to crash all the fiat currencies, which I assume is why the global south are working on a gold backed currency again.

[@Jouantiese]

Ignorance leads to failure.@@MartinMenge