What Explains Israel Rejoicing Of Palestinians Deaths? | Nathan Thrall | Dawn News English

[@suzanneharris8339]

This book needs to get into thousands of American & British public libraries.

[@kristiblack4789]

"Those that can make you believe in absurdities, can make you also committ atrocities!"

[@nadinayebdadash7441]

What an evil society.

[@williammohan9784]

Yep, Hamas is really evil,

[@MR-dm1gx]

Well they have been doing despicable things to the Palestinians for over 75 years.

[@pdst3]

And the terrorists have been doing the same to the Israelis

[@nataliedoyle4701]

Israel lobby. Look up the book which Professor Mearsheimer wrote about 10 years ago.The hold of the lobby over American political culture has only become tighter, because of the need of political parties for funding. Of course there is also an ideological component to Israel's influence.

[@ruthokelley5833]

This Israeli/Palestinian issue has revealed what happens when a social order has been left unchecked over many years. But, it is innocent Palestinian civilians that will pay the heaviest price for this depravity.

[@talksmoke1190]

Nakba was self inflicted

[@KlausJLinke]

@@talksmoke1190 Read about the massacres, and tell me how they were self inflicted. Say Deir Yassin, which had cooperated with (what later became) Israelis, and refused Arab militias acess to their town. Irgun attacked the defenseless town anyway, and threw hand grenades into the buildings where the civilians cowered. Menachem Begin defended his decision to do the massacre later, since it had terrorized all Palestinians so sucessfully, causing thousands of them to flee.

[@talksmoke1190]

@@KlausJLinke hardly defenseless, when arab troops in he village attacked the road bellow, forcing a battle. Perhaps you should blame the arabs for drawing fire on innocent villagers

[@KlausJLinke]

@@talksmoke1190 Do you have a source? From Begin's statements on the massacre, it seemed like a planned terrorist attack on civilians, with the intent to cause other villages to flee. And lobbing hand grenades into buildings with civilians seems pretty inexcusable ... At least Israelis didn't excuse it when it happened at the Nova music festival, although the Palestinians involved had been in firefights with the IDF..

[@desireedebellis6766]

@@talksmoke1190 psychopathy mind think ,,you need help

[@jawedumerani3393]

The crime of occupation should not be acceptable.

[@Stephen.in.Virginia]

The separate and shared crimes of political corruption of Netanyahu and Biden help enable occupation, and make them unfriendly accomplices running from justice like an old movie with stars handcuffed together and bi*ching every step of the way !!

[@samfore2644]

Jews were present in Jerusalem before Muslims.

[@katong1953]

How could Israelis rejoice at the Palestinians' suffering, especially when the suffering is caused by the Israelis themselves?Everything falls into place when you understand that the rejoicing comes from.pure evil.

[@IB4UUB4ME]

Because Satan is running rampant through the world right now because he knows his time is short and is wreaking havoc on the human population, he hates God and loves to see his creations in pain and turmoil, however the time has come for his removal and then a thousand years of peace on this earth. Psalms 37:10,11,29. ☮️ peace to every God fearing human. ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

[@michelemoneywell8765]

​​@@katong1953Excellent comment you made-- How can Israel rejoice at the suffering of others, especially when they cause the suffering? It's pure evil. -- and I agree.

[@rantube369.]

Thank you Nathan 🇵🇸🕊

[@JuliusGalacki]

Nathan Thrall's book won the 2024 Pulitzer Prize for non-fiction. When I bought the book (before the award), it was not very available... took well over a month via Amazon. Fortunately, the award seems to have made the book much easier to get a hold of.

[@BrianQuinn-ms7iy]

God have mercy on every Palestinian soul 🙏 its truly heartbreaking 💔 😢 🇮🇪🇵🇸🙏🇮🇪🇵🇸🙏

[@Ilyaz3207]

It's sad 😢

[@ENA214]

@@Ilyaz3207 En beschamend.

[@penelopelucas4973]

Stop blaming israel and take a good long look at the atrocities hamas has done and is still doing to it people.

[@Ilyaz3207]

@penelopelucas4973 they have doing it thousand fold worse for over 75yrs now

[@saidat98]

​@@penelopelucas4973Gaza international airport was destroyed by Iszr....in 2001, which was 5 years before hamas' election in Gaza.

[@melodymzoubi4140]

Israeli rejoicing of the palestinian genocide is disgusting. They seem to forget that what goes around comes around. Justice will come to palestine and they will surely pay the price for what they have done

[@RichardPepperman-kk9yb]

And, it's coming around again.

[@williammohan9784]

@@RichardPepperman-kk9yb Oh yeah, and how is it coming round again boy, come on tell us about how you are going to do it

[@williammohan9784]

any comments on October 7th boy, i bet not, you probably were as hard as a rock when you watched the go pro footage of October 7th and God knows what you got up to when you heard about the rapes

[@lorenam8028]

Sick society. Freedom and justice for Palestinians 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@naijaman6639]

Very sick, indeed. Yet, some Christians blindly support them as the chosen ones. Isn't this sheer lunacy?

[@xoxamyyyx]

I think you mean Hypocrisy

[@shulamay]

You're such a hypocrite

[@pdst3]

There is no Palestine. It’s made us in your head

[@Ashmooni]

@@naijaman6639 They were chosen in the past but not anymore.

[@ajledbetter3899]

The Palestinians deserve our support and sympathy after 75 years of apartheid rule under a mentality of arrogant superiority, torture and deprivation.

[@eyedownload]

As Nathan said the status quo will continue without a revolution so we need to step up and revolt.

[@honestyfirst3994]

and depravation!

[@evacorpus]

💯 Yes! 🙌🏼

[@talksmoke1190]

All their own fault

[@skontheroad]

Can you provide an example of it, please? Can they only sit on certain benches, drink from sperate water fountains, must they sit at the back of the bus?? My Friend from SA is SO offended, after having grown up LIVING with real Apartheid! And she is 100% correct! It IS offensive to her and anyone else who grew up living with that!

[@yvonnebloomfield577]

Plain evil

[@ghana312]

Wonderful interview. Enjoyed Mr. Thrall’s prospective so much. Thank you for having him.

[@tobiashardy1620]

The occupation must end. 🇵🇸🕊️🇵🇸

[@arlenelewetzow2937]

The Jews left the West Bank in 2005!

[@jga1001]

Stop the occupation! (Of the Holy Land by arab squatters)

[@philomenaoconnor2211]

In order to dehumanise an other person, one has to be inhumane himself/ herself

[@silkee1922]

Because it is generally agreed that the efforts of Hitler required the consent of the German public, the capacity for any Jew to even mention the Holocaust in the future grows more and more hypocritical by the day. Blaming Netanyahu alone will not be a thing in 5 years and beyond.

[@Cnichal]

Facts

[@georgestavri4474]

@@CnichalJust listen to your own like Gideon Levy a tru juu with spine as well as Norman F, Avi Shleim, Daniel Levy, Gabor Mate and others. Oh wait I forgot these are self hating jews right ? 🙄

[@ENA214]

Gelijk heb je, De Duitser er nog steeds op aan spreken En nog terug betalen voor,,en aan hun . Dan is het niet meer te bevatten wat daar nu gebeurt . Dat is niet meer te pruimen, of ergens mee te vergelijken. Dat is onderhoud aan de staat van ellende .

[@RKS454]

The most moral people on earth. Despicable.

[@theseustoo]

You mis-spelled 'immoral'... There! Fixed it for you! Don't mention it! 😉

[@katong1953]

@theseuestoo. "Most moral" was used in sarcasm, as that's what Israelis say about the IDF. So don't overrate yourself.

[@jga1001]

I agree with you about your definition of palestinians

[@gunnarrundblad6846]

Did you come in your pants while writing this?

[@leoninocat5070]

How can anybody can support Israel ?

[@NasreenBhana]

Thank you, sir, for your honesty.

[@rashadabdulazeem5387]

Remind me again how these people could be remotely associated with Gd or be Gds chosen, such a claim is absurd

[@paulathomson-m2y]

They have had a starvation policy since 1948

[@talksmoke1190]

Nakba was self inflicted

[@MichaelSmith-ph5oe]

@@talksmoke1190 They rounded themselves up at gunpoint and shot resisters in their own family s themselves, then they stole their own land and homes, then they forced their own family's to march away with only what they could carry, and kept themselves out for 76 years. Is that what you believe happened?

[@paulathomson-m2y]

@@talksmoke1190 what are you smoking

[@nukleartaro490]

​@@talksmoke1190like your empty head

[@talksmoke1190]

@@MichaelSmith-ph5oe they started a war, lost and fled the land.

[@Rastaferrari829]

They rejoice Palestinian deaths prior to October 7th, so to say this is about Hamas is a tired out talking point 🥱

[@orechchristopher18]

This is a fool who doesn't understand what happened on oct 7 th

[@Rastaferrari829]

@@orechchristopher18 keep ASSuming based on nothing.

[@stephaniejaboh8929]

​@@orechchristopher18October 7th is not the only history there is. The Jews are not the only people with trauma. Why is it okay to do it to other people many times before but cry about it and call for deaths when it is done to you? That is what many zionists dont understand why support for them are shifting around the world. Not to be insensitive towards victims of Israeli hostages but why do we call them hostages but refuse to call many Palestinian children in Israeli prison who were detained for years without being charged or even given any trial or legal representative, the same label?

[@richardroma536]

@@stephaniejaboh8929 "Palestinian children"? You mean 16 and 17-year-old hamas fighters? Those children? Stop with the taqiyya. You're embarrassing yourself.

[@wonderwinder1]

They are evil.

[@lauramurray1482]

Thank you for your book and your honesty ❤

[@Maj-cy6iq]

Thank you Nathan and Shahzeb

[@rifaatj]

Thank u. A very good interview on an excruciatingly painful n unjust situation. A Holocaust of current times.

[@crystalgarry5873]

Thank you, Nathan, for shining a light on this ongoing apartheid oppression by writing such an enlightening beautiful story.

[@HaasibFFGAMEING]

Fair, humanist, unbiased analysis of the on ground situation.

[@coffee6783]

You have got to be joking - Israelis are on video rejoicing in Israeli streets, dancing and singing, on 9/11. Of course, they claimedd it was Palestinians and of course they were believed by msm, etc.

[@ManGolden786]

And I just wrote about it a few minutes ago drinking partying big morning celebration in New Jersey over the river waiting for 9-11 to Begin, wearing Palestinian Flags over their shoulders⁉️ They were being recorded, before and after the First Strike on Tower 1, It was unusually Odd to the Residence and they called the Police. The So Called Drinking Palestinians were indeed Moosad who did just a few months: Republican or Democratic 😢SAD😢9-11 and they were Freed!

[@ENA214]

Hoog moet komt ten val .

[@KaileyB616]

Yup. The "dancing Israelis".

[@quent94181]

I’m from Israel like Nathan and I thank him for his courage of seeing the things as they are and for telling the truth despite the danger of repercussions.

[@aujax1]

these are nazis in our time.

[@zafar0132]

I can partially understand the atrocities committed in the wake of 1948, being driven half mad by Hitler. But what is the excuse for the current generation?

[@romanahowe67]

Thanks! Free Palestine!

[@marleneplasencia3656]

Yes, free Palestine from Hamas

[@Sony-mu7ol]

It’s not ONLY IsraHell The US government is also responsable

[@TheAscensionHasBegun]

Thank you Nathan!

[@rashedala-uddin8157]

When you encounter racism, Z1onism, or Fascism, you have a moral duty to challenge it.

[@Funkme67]

Warning signs of a cult. 1- The leader is always right. 2- Criticism of the leader or questioning the leader is considered persecution. 3- Anything the leader does is justified. 4- The leader is the only source of truth, everybody else is lying. 5- Followers must be blindly devoted to the leader and never question them. 6- The members won't recognise they belong to a cult.

[@georgestavri4474]

Thank you ! So well said 👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉

[@raufjaleel8317]

What is the purpose of your comment?

[@Funkme67]

@@raufjaleel8317 ask yourself the same stupid question.

[@Funkme67]

@@raufjaleel8317 you certainly are not the smartest one , of the litter.😂

[@treasureobasuyi894]

​@@raufjaleel8317islam = cult. It really isn't. People are just scared. That's like saying hinduism = cult.

[@marrisa17]

Excellent interview. I am about to read his book.

[@infiniti28160]

Megalomania is starting to manifest on social media. It is truly disturbing.

[@IanBlease-y5b]

The Thuggery continues on a daily basis.

[@xs3282]

Good on ya Nathan, you are a true human being.

[@Geewiz363]

Sickness

[@lorrainevlambert]

Thank you for clarifying this very obvious fact.

[@EdwardNathanSchwarz]

- ONE STATE SOLUTION. Hello, I'm the Moschiach. As Davidic king over the nation of Israel I'm willing to declare all Palestinians descendants of Jacob/Israel and his twelve sons/tribes and are thereby as legitimate inheritors of the Holy Land equal rights as Israel citizens. One State Solution.

[@TheAscensionHasBegun]

Those who are most righteous and on truth shall rule.

[@That_Freedom_Guy]

You are right that that's what all the different rulers of the same territory have said throughout history. 😅

[@fireh3211]

Sorry but billionaires disagree, and they are very powerful and influential, they are invested and having their own ideal final result.

[@EdwardNathanSchwarz]

@@TheAscensionHasBegun where did you get that? Only one ruler. No such thing as a state with multiple kings.

[@ghst4487]

​@@EdwardNathanSchwarzthe land belongs to the indigenous Palestinians and not to those Europeans who came in 1948. I don't support Palestinians sharing their land with colonizers

[@middleeastgirl8926]

thank you Nathan! i think ppl who moved to israel and israelis who have been born there, have a right wing nationalism mindset fed by the narrative of israel. for me its a conundrum how such an amount of ppl can think by refusing equal rights to another oppressed enitre population can bring peace and safety. i am just astonished by that stupidity. this is why i think, the problem is gried. they want all for themselves - going over lives. i believe every power of a country fall down one day. afterwards karma comes into place. this is law by nature.

[@MiMiiViVi]

Thank you! I really appreciate hearing compassionate, intelligent and humanitarian Jewish voices .

[@jamilabagash149]

Do you remember the Israelis dancing and rejoicing on 9/11 as the twin towers burnt?

[@danajacobs9097]

Yes

[@desireedebellis6766]

one word,,Pyschopathy.

[@bebopkirby]

Who have Jews ever liked? Watch the ‘American’ entertainment media, not exactly a love letter to the American people.

[@hbicolenna6745]

Jews and Israelis are not the same thing. Trafficking in antisemetic tropes does NOTHING to help Palestinians, it just makes the movement look bad.

[@bebopkirby]

@@hbicolenna6745 Take your point, but it is all the more ironic that in practice it is virtually impossible to be critical of Israel without being branded as anti-Semitic. It’s the old catch-22.

[@nataliesnooke]

Thank you for sharing Nathan’s wise and realistic perspectives, and respect to both of you for your invaluable work. In solidarity from Australia. 🇦🇺🇵🇸

[@paulnejtek6588]

Let them go right ahead. Better to advertise to the world who they really are. Fortunately, their support among young American Jews keeps going further and further down.

[@lorascelsi8102]

Would bB been able to carry out this carnage if it wasn't for Evangelical mega churches financial support?

[@desireedebellis6766]

spot on.. one of my so called christian friends,,(now ex friend) had on her social media ,that she supported the occupiers and to kill the babies and their mothers... the emptiest vessels hide behind religion

[@har3036]

Don't forget the US support.

[@lorascelsi8102]

@@har3036 agree 👍

[@lolazal1]

Yes. Because he had the support of US/UK abd many European governments.

[@lorascelsi8102]

3/4 casualties women and children

[@richardbrown9760]

Lies

[@lorascelsi8102]

@@richardbrown9760 Armenian Christians being displaced in the West Bank by settlers and IDF

[@lolazal1]

They've been doing this since 1948. It's not new...

[@mjdia2543]

Guys..they’re being the most careful about civilian deaths ok. Netenyahu said so.

[@dinoOvranic]

Thank you!

[@daisychainsmusicpublishing4789]

Racism

[@Jerusalem-u4k]

Free America from AIPAC

[@MarkWinterrowd]

Because they're sadistic little creeps. Not complicated.

[@mollyneoline9701]

Talk about the "ROOT OF THE TREE" Not the bark & leaves. Palastine is a State, Majority is Arab Muslims.

[@colinsbane]

I found the repetitive background 'music' (actually mere noise, if I'm honest) to be intrusive, irritating and totally pointless. Please will you sort out this defect for future videos. It was only because of the quality of interviewee Nathan Thrall that I put up with the nuisance this time around.

[@historiaeresistencia832]

I want to read Thrall ' s book.What is the name?

[@middleeastgirl8926]

its called: A Day in the Life of Abed Salama: A Palestine Story.

[@dawoodbatozai]

I am surprised that Dawn is doing such good work. 👍

[@Naturedrawn]

I think we also see the mainstreaming of Israeli sadism

[@kathismatastic]

There's a long history of child sacifice there.

[@barefoot6745]

Please do tell.

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

​@@barefoot6745 You can see video of the IDF passing children through the fire

[@barefoot6745]

@@RogerLewis-ey2tt OMG! This happened recently or in the pass?

[@mydogsbutler]

Not that this excuses the behavior but to be fair there are a lot of Palestinians that celebrated Jewish deaths back in Oct too. And a large number of Palestinians continue to support Hamas.

[@oanapopescu6176]

Palestinians have this right. They were opressed not isreals.

[@mydogsbutler]

@@oanapopescu6176 Hamas is a terrorist organization. Let's not pretend it wasn't also found guilty of war crimes by the ICC. For actual moral people, the world isn't about one group being all bad and another group all good. There are extremists in all groups.

[@SnNvee2936]

❤❤❤❤❤

[@donnavorce8856]

Answer to your headline question: Expropriation. Always the plan. Never a secret. Herzl wrote about this plan as early as 1895.

[@amgguy4319]

They've been doing this right from the beginning... 6-Year-Old Hind Rajab they cheered. 2 elderly women inside the Gaza Catholic Church - they rejoiced. Why do you think no country wants them around?

[@dorothyleeuw8774]

DawnNews English. The Muslim Metaphysician had a video early on showing what they teach in schools. It is a must see if you want to understand where the hatred has started. And not just their neighbours, but other religions too. It is disturbing.

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

So similar to N@zi education

[@SYHEHE]

THAT'S TOTALLY UNTRUE, YOU SHOULD BE ASHAME FOR WHAT YOU ARE SAYING, SHAME, SHAME, SHAME ON YOU...

[@tubeEseen]

This is very disturbing

[@allenlopez9731]

Demonic possession?

[@desireedebellis6766]

indoctrinated from cradle to grave to believe they are the chosen ones and everyone else has no rights as human beings

[@jakepistolero]

if you want an answer to this question, look at nazi germany, early america, and the inquisition

[@KateBates22zabu]

Maybe he'll do an LBJ & refuse a 2nd term.🤞🏻

[@iamjanedoe4real]

He's too petty for that. That's been the most consistent thing about Joe, he's super petty.

[@QUINTUSMAXIMUS]

Joe is very stubborn. He is very unpopular among voters, but the DNC and Biden insist on him. Bad idea.

[@RogerLewis-ey2tt]

Fat chance. Biden is incapable of admitting he,,'s wrong

[@Method9]

☮☮☮☮☮

[@TruthSeekerAll]

Wow. Who would have thought that kidnapping and holding innocent civilians as hostages can be this deadly in consequences? 🤔

[@darlenedowie2926]

Not surprised nor shocked

[@abys242]

Sick, psychopath society. Just unbelievable...

[@theseustoo]

"What Explains Israel Rejoicing Of Palestinians Deaths?" Sadism? Barbarism? Psychopathy? Sociopathy? Narcissism? Or a combination of all of the above which I refer to as 'Bibi-ism'... Take your pick!

[@Gerardo_Molina]

Fortunately we have people with the will to tell the truth. Free Palestine!

[@rashidhussain5977]

They were always like that, only rest of the world started paying attention after this genocide started ..

[@randydoak6638]

It’s the kind of evil that ‘s the inevitable outcome of fanatical religion.

[@saiqhai9968]

You lose me when you call it a conflict and war, instead of occupation, oppression and g€no©id€

[@dhibba52]

They lack any sense of morality.

[@josephineng7086]

Just saw a video of the supermarket in central Gaza that it is actually full of goods. Am really baffled by the report about salvation of the children there.

[@oanapopescu6176]

Supermarket full of goods like north korea's supermarket?😂😂😂

[@kennychristensen4290]

the explanation is: They are pure evil

[@GinaRams]

Americans are too. And im America. Its horrible.

[@Chloe12875]

Lessons!

[@End_Zionism]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@iaa9874]

Sick

[@Rachid-cg2qy]

EVERY ACCUSATION IS A CONFESSION!!

[@keithm257]

cut the music man!

[@lindawilkins9296]

Do you truly believe he, Biden, is capable of thinking that deeply nowadays?🤦🏼‍♀️

[@Jesus-Jesse]

Do any of my answers even have an effect?

[@pam7500]

What explains the Palestinians cheering in the streets when they found out what hamas had done to the Israelis???

[@NP1066]

What explains Palestinians rejoicing of Israeli deaths? Are you interested in that question as well? Or is it non of your concern? I bet it's justified in your eyes.

[@cristinasala4143]

@NP1066 If you are no longer able to see yourself in the position of someone oppressed, if even the simple idea makes you sick, you cannot understand what it means that the oppressed can strike back at the oppressors, that they can stand up and fight. This is what the Palestinians celebrate and not the deaths of civilians (which by the way, and some of you know well, were in many cases the work of the IDF itself)

[@treasureobasuyi894]

​@@cristinasala4143people are people. Murder is murder. The israelites probably think the same thing. Try to be mature. You are an adult. Geez.

[@NP1066]

@@cristinasala4143 I find it a bit rich that a Westerner by the name Cristina is trying to lecture me, an Israeli Jew (of Iraqi descent), who lives in Israel, works, lives and befriends Palestinians and Arabs, what is truly in their hearts when they rejoice after 7/10 and all other civilians-targeting attacks. Everything you know about them is through curated social media with an agenda to extract as much global & Western sympathy, regardless of actual sentiment in the ground. And btw. I'm not painting rosy pictures here of either side. On both sides genocidal sentiments are prevalent. Among Israelis & Palestinians alike.

[@djdoolittle1315]

Satanic

[@luball416]

There is a lot of misunderstanding here. In the Torah, it is prohibited to rejoice the suffering of your enemy thus it is Meditating during Passover. Not all Israelis are Jewish, not all Jews are perfect . But in Judaism, it is highly prohibited to celebrate the suffering of your enemy, it is actually commandment that one has to help their enemy . Stop spreading lies