What facial recognition steals from us

There's a massive bait-and-switch at the center of facial recognition technology.
Join the Open Sourced Reporting Network: www.vox.com/ope...
Human faces evolved to be highly distinctive; it’s helpful to be able to recognize individual members of one’s social group and quickly identify strangers, and that hasn’t changed for hundreds of thousands of years. Then in just the past five years, the meaning of the human face has quietly but seismically shifted. That’s because researchers at Facebook, Google, and other institutions have nearly perfected techniques for automated facial recognition.
The result of that research is that your face isn’t just a unique part of your body anymore, it’s biometric data that can be copied an infinite number of times and stored forever. In this video, we explain how facial recognition technology works, where it came from, and what’s at stake.
Open Sourced is a year-long reporting project from Recode by Vox that goes deep into the closed ecosystems of data, privacy, algorithms, and artificial intelligence. Learn more at www.vox.com/ope...
This project is made possible by the Omidyar Network. All Open Sourced content is editorially independent and produced by our journalists.
Watch all episodes of Open Sourced right here on KZbin: bit.ly/2tIHftD
Become a part of the Open Sourced Reporting Network and help our reporting. Join here: www.vox.com/ope...
Sources:
"Obscurity and Privacy" papers.ssrn.co...
"Modern Face Recognition with Deep Learning" / machine-learning-is-fu...
"Face Recognition and Privacy in the Age of Augmented Reality" papers.ssrn.co...
Megapixels megapixels.cc/...
"FBI, ICE find state driver’s license photos are a gold mine for facial-recognition searches" www.washington...
"Are Stores You Shop at Secretly Using Face Recognition on You?" www.aclu.org/b...
"Due to weak oversight, we don’t really know how tech companies are using facial recognition data" www.fastcompan...
"Facial Recognition Service Becomes a Weapon Against Russian Porn Actresses" advox.globalvo...
"Creeped out by Facebook’s algorithms? Just wait until you see this new facial recognition tool released by anonymous Russian programmers." meduza.io/en/f...
"How it works and why they created SearchFace - a service for searching VKontakte users by photo" tjournal.ru/te...
Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com.
Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE
Follow Vox on Facebook: goo.gl/U2g06o
Or Twitter: goo.gl/XFrZ5H

[@Vox]

Open Sourced is a new project from Recode by Vox, which includes lots of reporting and writing on our website in addition to videos: www.vox.com/open-sourced. We'd love to hear your questions about tech, data, AI, and privacy. Here's an easy form for you to submit questions for our journalists or contribute your own expertise: www.vox.com/opensourcednetwork

[@Cloroqx]

More content like this, please!

[@thanos4959]

Vox ok

[@samson136]

Thank you for being objective. Its a good change

[@CanuckMonkey13]

I was excited to see the Recode imprint at the start of the video and was not disappointed! Open Sourced sounds like an exciting new project, and I'll take some time to see if I can come up with anything to submit. I look forward to seeing what you folks produce!

[@TAVideos786]

What App did Aric Toler use at 5:50 to scan and pull more photos and personal information of that Russian guy in red t-shirt?

[@blahblahchachable]

I tried doing my face on Yandex, and couldn’t get back any results of my actual other photos online. But at least now I know my Russian doppelgänger

[@Northern_Sea]

Mavrokattou h Prwti Well, now Yandex has a photo of you that you've uploaded for a search. Soon enough it will find real you. 😓

[@jgabt]

@@Northern_Sea How did you know that Yandex will store your photo? And why did you think that yandex will store that.. Does Yandex have tens of thousands of petabytes of server to store your photos?

[@Minebilding]

Yes just like google

[@Northern_Sea]

@@jgabt I doubt it stores a photo. Just a data matrix of it. A pattern that is used to search and compare, a "fingerprint" of your face. It's only several kilobytes of data I presume.

[@drakedoragon3026]

@@Northern_Sea lol... Right on, that's the first thing that came to my mind 🤔.

[@ianrayflora3593]

Technology is a double edge sword.

[@wellesradio]

excuse me A double edged sword is technology.

[@tm_cloudfire4804]

A double sworded technology is an edge

[@yodoodler5951]

Technology sword edge double a

[@joseregalado7539]

And I am it's master wielder

[@TPerm-hj4sf]

I enjoy my iPad as oppose to whatever 13th century King used. People who thinks it’s double edge sword are short sighted obstructionists.

[@swaggy123swaggy]

day by day we’re losing our privacy and it’s actually vey scary

[@taekwondotime]

There's really only two things people have in a free society: Freedom of speech and the freedom to go about their daily lives without being watched (privacy). Once you take those away, you're living in a prison essentially.

[@sword_of_damocle5]

Read up on panopticism and societies of control. Very relevant to the times we live in.

[@taekwondotime]

​@@sword_of_damocle5 Well said. We've got a societal structure now where government can watch you pretty much everywhere, but where they lack, the public makes up for it by essentially watching each other and playing the role of "cop". Sort of like a 24/7 snitch service. People with cell phones, dash cams, etc... can record everything that goes on. So it's a case of having the prison guards and the inmates watching the inmates.

[@itswhatis018]

You havent heard about China's social credit system?

[@ikigai999]

So true

[@amitkain4055]

Not far are the days when our lives turn into a grim episode of black mirror

[@zhuleikhaosman2322]

Ezio Auditore how did that come up?

[@pax4370]

Ezio i am not a fan of isis either, but its not relevent!

[@TeslasSecret]

@Jane Doe 1

[@IamINERT]

@Ezio Auditore I like your thinking 👍🏽

[@NMiller_]

Today is yesterday's dark future. Tomorrow could yet still become today's salvation.

[@bundubashing2591]

Vox constantly reminds me how ignorant I am to some of the most important things happening around me today.

[@JeffDeWitt]

Watch the infamous Vox video on how to build a computer and you will see how ignorant Vox is.

[@bundubashing2591]

@@JeffDeWitt Wasn't that the verge?

[@snaeshaads8203]

@@bundubashing2591 the verge is owned by vox

[@bundubashing2591]

@@snaeshaads8203 where did you find this info that no one else has!?

[@FakhrulFaris]

@@bundubashing2591 Both Vox and The Verge are part of the same parent company, Vox Media. It's like your brother do something bad but because you have the same parent, you were accused of doing something bad too.

[@Falicity345]

The guy who was found through Russian web search engine: "Why am I getting recognized on the street by complete strangers?" Stranger: "We loved you in Vox" Him: "Fox? What's that?"

[@J_dizzle.]

Annie Lanier this made me laugh 😭😭😭

[@gazaalley3862]

Very underated comment

[@chrono-glitchwaterlily8776]

Was that a typo or intentional

[@Klrfl101]

@@chrono-glitchwaterlily8776 maybe intentional

[@multiplebees]

me: “omg that’s seriously terrifying” me also: immediately searches my own face on yandex

[@Sam-gl6fu]

nerv dog what happened did u find ur twin

[@Rallosz]

I literally paused the video to do exactly that. Lol

[@h7672]

bad idea

[@honeywasp7839]

You just gave the Russian goverment there first photo of you

[@jasonk7675]

useless debatable who's to say they don't already have photos of you uploaded by your friends / uncles / cousins to their Facebook Instagram Twitter. case in point, look at Geraldine above.

[@FF-ch9nr]

no wonder yandex has an almost 100% accuracy rate for reverse image search lol

[@film_bauer]

I tried yandex and it is soooo creepy. There were pictures of me online I didn't even know about. Who uploaded them, who put them there.... Goosebumps!

[@KaikalaMoon]

Niklas Bauer Dang you just made it real for me. I was in popular box store when I saw it activated on my face. I feel totally violated.

[@tribesail1336]

Rlly?

[@yes-ge4nm]

Thanks for having your face as a pfp! I will search it now!

[@randomdude9135]

*Imagine Chinese officials using this tech to identify HK protestors.........*

[@randomdude9135]

@@merrillgeorge1838 😨

[@krystalphan8871]

very possible, they've already done this in other cities

[@1nmess]

@@merrillgeorge1838 Theory is theory after all XD

[@shaanm.8778]

They actively have been. That's why the protesters have been using masks to obscure their faces.

[@CataciousAmogusevic]

Just imagine

[@thefilmfrontier6822]

When the guy was taking a picture of her, I was like, “Stoooop.”

[@luigialvarezproductions3563]

persons probably acting loool

[@narata1541]

@@luigialvarezproductions3563 *Is acting.

[@luigialvarezproductions3563]

@@narata1541 Okay.

[@superjoeyman1]

Imagine getting on the subway hoping to get a creepshot of a guy taking a creepshot

[@luigialvarezproductions3563]

@@superjoeyman1 Hm that's creepy but all I am saying, for sure the person is just acting taking creepy photos of her and that for sure she's just pretending she's not seeing it so we can all get what the video is trying to talk about because it would be surprising of how the camera man will be able to see the creepy man taking photos of her without the boy catching the camera man but I get everyone's point hahaha

[@hamzamahmood9565]

Only if Light found the death note in 2019......

[@lIlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlI]

Tru

[@JaszLcookie]

Nikola Tesla thanks tesla.. now i all need to do is find a deathnote

[@LightYagami-wt1jw]

If only...

[@tet8236]

Deathnote can be bought on a comic store hahahah, waiting for my shinigami to show up.

[@mercce6750]

Welp, time to learn hacking so I can delete my face from the internet.

[@sisbrawny]

Once it's there you can't take it back.

[@brendonsforehead4961]

sisbrawny exactly, that’s kinda scary tbh

[@plapin3538]

That means deleting your backup photos from Google Drive and ICloud... good luck . 👍

[@gogl0l386]

The problem isn't that it's on the internet, the problem is that if it was on the internet anyone could have downloaded the data.

[@ajinkyamehere5365]

Oh yeah, and how are you planning to delete it from your government issued IDs?

[@adeebr6639]

Moral of the story: Anime profile pic, anime name, anime mask

[@cityuser]

The weebs will outlive us all

[@EJionix]

@@cityuser We already are

[@_adheeb.]

Hey we have same names :)

[@AxeKick80]

I was born in 1980. I can’t believe how much life has changed in my short lifetime. Life is really truly becoming something out of weird science fiction.

[@user-rm4yd2cl2k]

This is basically like what celebrities have to go through. You’re famous, or in the regular-people case, searchable, and people will judge based on that.

[@bunny.thebest9103]

Yandex: exists Stalkers: my spirit search engine

[@toolittletoolate3917]

In his novel “Fall”, Neal Stephenson writes of an FR-cancelling technology called the Veil. Can we crowd-fund this ASAP?

[@phoebexxlouise]

You could wear a real life veil

[@DOPEBEATZBOYS]

Can't crowdfund things that won't exist

[@alconvin2334]

It would be outlawed and everyone associated with it it would be placed on a watchlist "You have nothing to fear if you have nothing to hide"

[@forte609]

There probably would be something like this to be developed by the government agencies. Its kind interesting on how espionage might work now considering spies might become obsolete or very hard to produce

[@LowestofheDead]

There are stickers that disrupt image-recognition programs. Put one on your face and Yandex will think you're a toaster or a banana

[@davidpeters6536]

What you are explaining to social media users is exactly the reason I don't use it and don't use it. You are doing a good job telling the unaware what they are getting into and how they are open to exploitation.

[@nm7965]

Black Mirror episode Nosedive comes into my mind

[@HelgaCavoli]

"Brazil" feelings. A pixel in the wrong place and a regular person could become a "wanted" one.

[@randomdude9135]

*Vox giving ideas to stalkers*

[@sujathastanley9791]

Or teaching us how to be safe

[@artsyavede]

This is so well put together!

[@patromo]

This concept always scares me. And often when I try to articulate my fears im left speechless. The things that we assume are traditional right are often the hardest to defend; we've never had too

[@TX51]

Best Yandex ad I've ever seen.

[@RickStLouis-xh4zh]

Absolutely love this series. Y'all are tackling a very important topic and I can't wait to see the next video!

[@Safe-and-effective]

Most mainstream media will not report because they are in on it...the plan is for the technotyranny to be rolled out quietly and seemlessly to an uninformed populace that is far too busy with tiktok and netflix so that they only realize the gravity of it when the digital fist is shoved in their face and right up their youknowwhat.

[@bspradiomusic]

"Oh be careful who you share your data with... But don't forget to tell us your opinion in this link so we can also have your data"

[@HappinessinaDishHD]

privacy is nearly non-existent these days. 🤔

[@kingofflames455]

Technology has always been a double edge sword.. Now more so than ever.

[@spamnstuff6060]

Google already give the option to face recognise your pictures on your drive photos, its really powerfull and it's been possible for few years now

[@jamonzonv]

Well done VOX... while doing this video, you just encouraged and opened the pandora Box for the western world which had no idea about this. Well played!

[@dimsodenso6839]

I swear I only use this when my friends gave me a "manga" without source

[@rolfs2165]

saucenao ;)

[@notbnw6744]

@@rolfs2165 this man gets it

[@avariceseven9443]

One of the ethical way of using reverse image search

[@ksonsouchou]

@@rolfs2165 SauceNaono is not enough. Use Google, Yandex, Saucenano, Iqdb and Tineye.

[@jon...5324]

@@ksonsouchou ok 4chanX

[@1ctnichols]

Joss, i love your work and it has opened my mind to the potential danger of upcoming tech, but also the beauty it can hold if used/regulated the right way! Thank you!

[@jjc5475]

i had one teacher who i suspected of not having the right papers to be a teacher. i reverse image searched him and found his complete journey from a turkish university, to an student exchange project to the USA, to his eventual study in the Netherlands. together with 5 different social media accounts. one of which was an anonymous one on which i uploaded only his photo and on which i assume one of his kids shared mobile game stuff. i don't upload selfies anymore..

[@lostandthrown3137]

What

[@blck21]

Y?! Ur teacher will be freaked out if he ever finds out...

[@jeffreym68]

Why on earth would you think your teacher didn't have credentials?

[@rootchino]

This is the kind of content that brought me to Vox, excited for what you and Joss will do with Open Sourced.

[@ciel983]

This already happened in China and clearly will eventually come to our counties if not today then tomorrow, this is how the future looks like

[@adamender9092]

It's scary

[@Masbro-ie2jz]

Genshin Impact

[@pimeto]

I dunno what Facial Recognition steals from me, but i know that Joss Fong stole my heart!

[@Shamol]

I clicked immediately on this video because I recognized Joss‘ face 😊

[@edmund8954]

totally not a creepy comment.

[@wellesradio]

Edmund Ng whooooosh

[@ayushmanthapa_onion]

@@wellesradio Okay redditor

[@daluven]

Thats creepy

[@comradechenkov6210]

Yup! Joss has a (creepy) following.

[@JammyBandStudios]

Digital privacy is the single biggest moral and ethical issue facing modern society, and we need to protect it.

[@risingsun8609]

That was the most effective ad for the Yandex.

[@bidaubadeadieu]

So excited for Open Sourced during this next year. Technology policy issues are some of the central policy issues of our time!

[@rafallamas1245]

i'm here because facebook started finding my face in photos i wasnt tagged and i'm scared

[@RP_Williams]

With her voice, her poise, and her beauty, Joss could be a major network news anchor.

[@doomdoktor]

Protip: Yandex is where you go to find sauce that google or bing won't. Y'know... for research.

[@BestofCalcioIT]

for the science

[@jamesrussellangeles4054]

I will remember this knowledge

[@ksonsouchou]

@Mr Doggo its just a meme. No one wants to use an inferior product just for privacy. If you didnt get my point - DuckDuckGo is useless outside US.

[@rustyjames1819]

Truth

[@renxiongmao]

A man of culture

[@neil340]

The narration of this video is very pleasing

[@eustache_dauger]

Gotta start wearing IR led above my shoulder. Glasses frame, baseball cap etc.

[@PrograError]

not much use if it's just normal camera...

[@Government_Username]

Almost all modern cameras have ir filters.

[@TheFeldhamster]

@@Government_Username yes, but only for scattered, naturally occuring IR (like, by-product of sunlight), not for a beam of IR from an IR LED. Try it yourself - take any camera you have, point an IR remote at it and see the beam of IR in white. If you buy a couple of high-powered IR LEDs and fix them to your eyeglasses, you should still be able to overexpose your face on surveillance cameras.

[@Government_Username]

@@TheFeldhamster thanks I'm going to try this 👍

[@hendrikdependrik1891]

You can better wear a chain mail burqa instead.

[@socialtech7882]

The indusrty has done a amazing job of popularizing voluntary data thief. Brillant!

[@user-cz7ct8oi1g]

I just tried my own picture... Lol I found my doppleganger

[@exoticme4760]

Me seeing this video when it was uploaded : "omg I better be careful when posting pics" Me Now doing projects on face recognition : *I need more data*

[@AuthenTech]

Great vid!

[@amorales1069]

O

[@_adheeb.]

Yes Indeed

[@hulqen]

The level of arts and craft skills that went into making this video is epic!

[@TheHatedOne]

The Internet was a mistake.

[@COVID--kf3tx]

is not, but ok

[@the-engneer]

@@COVID--kf3tx You're a fool, and you will realize it when you're a prisoner under surveillance every waking hour of your life

[@the-engneer]

In the future they will give history lessons on how the internet could have been used for good, but instead was the downfall of mankind

[@koruki]

Then get off of it lol why are you still here

[@the-engneer]

@@koruki meth

[@offplanet740]

i’ve never been so happy to have deleted facebook five years ago in a bout of depression. now, i value data privacy so much while i watch friends shrug it as they post away, citing facebook invites as the reason to remain on the platform. our world is madness right now, and we need better privacy laws more than ever.

[@harryzain]

Yeah this just made me more paranoid then I already was.

[@brunogoncalves2947]

It's great to see you back, Joss! Excellent video.

[@BBTeZeT]

Technology makes me to not want any children.

[@sm1522]

BBTeZeT why?

[@AmadeuShinChan]

[ Me too, then on the other side, when looking at Joss Stone, that makes me want to have children. ]

[@Marklee-lx7cd]

I don't wanna have them anyway

[@eddiewiggles9398]

@@sm1522 Social Norms and Society are shifting too rapidly, I don't know what's gonna happen but I feel bad for young kids today and whatever their future holds- especially when it comes to having legit jobs or good social skills in person..... not over using technology to communicate with friends

[@accordiongordon]

:Amadeus-Josef :Moisl. You mean Joss Fong?

[@abolmiamenx4]

wow! I always look forward to Joss's videos, they are incredibly insightful and they do help me as someone who video edits and do motion graphics as a job! Thank you Joss and Vox

[@knowledgeiskey1319]

Vox: This is Yandex ME: _Inputs Liam Hemsworth..._ Finds look-alike... *I have found my tru luv* THE POWER I HOLD!

[@DarthVaderin]

I'm faceblind and it's already like magic that normal people can recognize faces, and now even algorithms are better than me?

[@JackMediaComments]

I do not agree with the statement at 8:20 I certainly do wish I could be equally honest with everyone in each social realm. I'm not sure the fact that most people act completely different around family, coworkers and loved ones means it's good.

[@javeriat497]

its not necessarily about honesty. its more about behaviour expectations. Would you want to have to act the same way you do with your spouse as you do with your boss?

[@ValLovesBatmanAndTR]

Man this woman Joss makes some of the best videos on Vox. what a pro.

[@ДжоДжон-и6г]

Vox just accidentally informed potential stalkers to use Yandex instead of Google. Welp

[@Sjalabais]

Beautifully made video, and I especially like the positive note you end on. It is very easy to lose hope with massive data and AI developments - but we want to use the positive sides of what the internet offers, too.

[@Coniferou5]

Thank you, this is terrifying.

[@disobediancevideogames7183]

Just gonna say this for everyone watching. I love Vox and all their efforts they put into their videos in regards to educating many people on a broad, plethora of topics. Thank you Vox🙏🏻

[@samwalrus]

There is also gait recognition (how you walk and hold yourself), hand recognition etc.. so a mask or make up, wont help you for long..

[@os2171]

Hey joss. I’ve always loved your videos. The topics, research design and creativity. But mostly, seen your beautiful face, keep the beat work!

[@marlonmoncrieffe0728]

This is like the futuristic NetFlix thriller, 'Anon,' by Andrew Niccol.

[@carmendelgadopr]

Thanks for this kind of content and congratulations for your new project, well needed for the general public!

[@Philippoable]

Context collapse: a George divided against itself cannot stand

[@jonsprivatelife]

Was hoping to find this. Thank you for posting it, obscure internet person!

[@lucasng9617]

This video is amazingly done. Very nice perspective. Vox content is amazing.

[@chrisklugh]

Well, I'm growing a beard...

[@sebastianholmnielsen8924]

Can't wait for Open-sourced to start!

[@MuhammadNurbasit]

wow! Today I learned how to stalk someone quicker

[@leavemychannelaloneiquit840]

Abe E i think it’s because his profile says his name

[@frankwhite6490]

Joss you are the best.. Your videos have a deep meaning

[@easternwind4435]

I actually like that, now people will think more before posting stuff on the inet

[@DoctaM364]

Doubtful

[@antonallen8972]

I always knew Yandex was better, I’m Russian, and they’ve literally become such a conglomerate in Russia which provides you with everything. They’re a search engine, an Uber, an UberEats, a Netflix type of thing, and so much more. Also, never mess with Russian IT guys. They have the value Swiss Guards used to have back in the 1300’s.

[@stefanleo8963]

soon you'll need a face camouflage to go to the mall...

[@dongysakura418]

Leave your phone at home. Google tracks you too and will send you ads for you to spend more money

[@dongysakura418]

Or airplane mode

[@fiend821]

Love the "Mr. Robot" vibe music in the intro

[@intern1020]

Finally. Some good information to store on Database

[@Papeeshka]

Well I hope I can FINALLY get the photos from all the modeling I did. I never saw my commercials, music videos, commercials, print, catalogue work etc..

[@desu38]

I put in some AI generated faces from artbreeder and found their real life doppelgangers.

[@bryantlicious3590]

Love the new series! Great work y’all.

[@AyubuKK]

This is some scary stuff.

[@rmgrmg2488]

If you have a driver's license you're probably in the system

[@melchizedekpsj]

This is a brilliant and... terrifying video. My thanks, nonetheless.

[@ravikumaryadav1276]

Great research and documentation u guys do to aware us .....great work guys ...salute to u all 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍 Love from Delhi(India)

[@StevieDamnit]

I uploaded a picture of a toad and Trump came up in the results.

[@KneeJerkReactor]

Ya sure it's just Trump? My search results found Boris Johnson, Putin, Kim Jong Un and Xi Jin Ping.

[@ConvictedFelon2024]

Try a turtle next. You'll probably get a photo of Mitch.

[@NatureShy]

@Paul Boobier There's a civil war in the democratic party between the elite establishment crowd (Bill, Hillary, Obama, Nancy Pelosi, Tom Perez, socially left & economic right billionaires, CNN and other mainstream media, etc.), and the progressive wing (Bernie Sanders, Warren, AOC, and most of the democratic voting base, especially among younger people who want bigger, more drastic change than what the establishment elite want). Most dems (the progressive base) will openly criticize the establishment wing of the party.

[@didi-ud2tg]

I tried searching my face on Yandex. It's unbelievably amazing that I really find one picture of me there, even though I myself didn't really see the similarity between both of the pictures since usually my face looks kinda different on photos.

[@omnipotentp0tato]

I hope you asked that random guy whether you could use his likeness

[@dennis9052]

While you are watching this video, there's a camera in front of you (if you have your phone).

[@ZiRR0]

Me: **Sees this video** Also me: **A stalker**

[@cjthibeau4843]

Super excited to see more from Recode!

[@Spirit532]

"Posting anonymous photos online" is an oxymoron. If you want anonymity, you shouldn't share your life on the internet, especially publicly.

[@noname-zp1yh]

That's like saying "if you don't want to get stalked don't go outside". Technically true but it's basically blaming the victim.

[@Spirit532]

​@@noname-zp1yh No, it's pretty sane advice. If you don't want to get stalked, don't give the stalker a complete set of present-wrapped and hand-labelled tools to do it.

[@crazydragy4233]

Spirit I politely disagree. Also “if u dont want to get food poisoning, dont eat” has the same energy imo lol. The internet isnt just a public space as well, it can be at least partially private. It is accesable to the public, just like any other public space, for instance a hospital or a library, the only real difference is its digital. We choose the amount of things we share with certain people and social circles both in real life and internet. Taking that away will have consequences. But i am running off arent I, we know China isnt that bad.

[@DeanRendar]

in a simulated/blended reality the demand for the designer classics of time faces will fetch everyone's fancy, and then after in world tendencies play out through repeated stressors, the really bold will create the hybrid, and hybrid of hybrids, and intentionally obscure. All facets indicating that the path used by most has been done and something fresh is required for the fresh mindset they seek to curate/let live out.

[@randomdude9135]

Yandex: *exists* China: STEAL THAT TECH!!!!

[@k4nd17r33]

they already have it

[@akshatpunia]

China literally uses face recognition across each one of its cities.

[@rondarvin472]

Thanks to the Vox team for all your hard work to educate people all over the world. I use your videos for the courses I teach on digital literacies. I'd be very interested in more videos about the design and sociotechnical structures of different platforms, their algorithmic processes, and how these shape different cultures-of-use, identities, online interactions and modes of exclusion.

[@CountSessine]

Joss Fong ... so cute, so smart ❤️❤️❤️

[@koyot_inozemez]

3:08 refined 8:44 bait and switch. 4:00 сonsent 5:34 eviscerating