What happened on the 3rd March 1924? Its impact on Muslims - Part 1

Follow: @AbdulWahidHT
Recommended reading:
The Inevitable Caliphate - Reza Pankhurst
How the Khilafah was Destroyed - Shaikh Abdul Qadeem Zalloum -
Al Dawah Al Islamiyyah (‘The Islamic State) - Shaikh Taqiuddin an-Nabhani -
The Fall of the Ottomans - Eugene Rogan
Ottoman Endgame - Sean McMeekin
A Peace to End all Peace - David Fromkin
Longing for the Lost Caliphate - Mona Hassan
Coping with defeat - Sunni islam, Roman Catholicism, and the Modern State - Jonathan Laurence
A Line in the Sand - James Barr
Ataturk - Patrick Kinross
A History of Saudi Arabia - Madawi al Rasheed
Marmaduke Pickthall: British Muslim - Peter Clark
Islam in Victorian Britain - The Life and Times of Abdullah Quilliam - Ron Geaves
Loyal Enemies - Jamie Gilham
The State in Contemporary Islamic Thought - (A Historical Survey of the Major Muslim Thinkers of the Modern Era) - Abdelilah Belkeziz
Islam and Modernism - Maryam Jameelah (formerly Margaret Marcus)
Arabic Thought in the Liberal Age, 1798-1939 - Albert Hourani

[@RRRR09]

I couldn't listen to all of them because my English is not enough. But as a Turk, I can say that while the Ottomans were going through very difficult times, they wanted to bring innovation to a group of Ottomans, they were Muslims and well-intentioned, but a commander who played an effective role in the wars, Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, brought his own western views to the newly established Turkey. Many Muslims even opposed with weapons, but unfortunately they were all killed. There is a civil war in Turkey right now. Secular atheists and Muslims are fighting each other. Muslim Turks do not like Atatürk, but the other side is quite strong, Erdoğan has been victorious in this war for 20 years. There is an election in 2 months, I hope he wins again. As Turkish Muslims, we will do our best to return to our old days and bring the Sharia. May Allah unite the muslims.

[@flykiller]

I thought I was the only Turk following this channel. Well said brother. Btw, if your English isn't enough then whose is :D

[@adam.259]

​@@flykillerHahah tabiiki değil. We are with a lot elhamdulillaah

[@ahmed.aljelali]

Please God, help the turkish people 🥺❤️ Im sick of seeing atheism winning, it's like we're back at the times of Abraham and Moses 😔😔

[@theodorkrafting9716]

How is making hijra to Türkiye?

[@RRRR09]

@@theodorkrafting9716 Whose hijra ?

[@akhtarmehjabeen]

I remember my grandfather telling how his grandfather and other Muslims protested in Indian subcontinent in support of osmania khilafat:: At that time, Muslims gave their life savings to somehow save the khilafat…and I am very proud to be the descendants of those great people…

[@AlOstosman]

Sadly my whole family except for me and my mother are kemalists, me and my mother are the only ones in my Whole family who are anti-"ataturk" and Pro-Khilafat and Pro-Islam

[@AlOstosman]

@@Quran_Alone_Dawah 1. The Arabs Revolted As A Result Of The Incompetent Djemal Pasha Whom After Every Defeat Had Vented His Frustration Out On The Arabs By Terrorising Them And The Leader Of The Arab Revolt Whom Was Also The Sharif Of Mecca Was Deceived By The British To Revolt Against The Ottomans 2. The Ottomans Surrendered Because None Of Their Armys Were Able To Fight The Allies And If The Armys Continued To Fight The Any Of The Allies It Whould've Been A Death Sentence For All The Armys The Ottomans Had And In The Last Few Days Of The War The Allies Had Nearly Reached Anatolia Therefore If He Didnt Surrendered Like The Rest Of The Countrys In The Central Powers, There Would Be Nothing Left Of Us 3. In The War Of Liberation, turkey Only Really Fought Against The Greeks As France And Britain Did Not Want To Fight Anymore As They Were Exhausted With War And There Were Only A Few Border Skirmishes And Battles Against Them, The Armenians Were Handled By The Soviets For Us, Same With The Georgians, There Were A Few Battles Against The Italians And We Didnt Even Fight The Kurds, Infact The Whole Reason The Kurds Dont Like turkey Is Because mustafa kemal Had Promised The Kurds That If They Joined turkey In The War Of Liberation, The Kurds Would Get Their Own State But When The War Ended His Lie Was Uncovered 4. No One Said He Or Any Of Us Worship The Caliph 5. mustafa kemal Was An Enemy Of Islam As He Turned Mosques Into Barns And Pubs, Portrayed The Ulama(Imams, Sheikhs Etc.) As Snakes And Dogs, Slaughtered Tens Of Thousands Of Innocent Muslims Just Because They Didnt Wear Western Clothes, Removed The Shahada From Army Standards, Abolished The Khilafat, Banned Traditional Muslim And Turkish Clothes Etc Etc 6. The Caliph Never Sided With The British 7. Calm Down

[@britishqueen94]

Just a bunch of knobs...time would have been better spent fighting the British than worrying about murtad Turks

[@abdelhakyac7285]

True..... indian muslims were one of the best because they acted upon their responsibilities to defend the prophet’s peace upon him legacy..... may allah give them peace in day of judgement..... and may everyone who willingly chose nationalism, tribalism over the unity of muslims be held responsible

[@drabulhasandasankop3737]

We are from same indian decedent even today we are praying caliphate to return soon so that whole umma will get their rights peace and harmony in muslim umma world over.

[@whatever9506]

My great grandfather fought with the ottomans in WW1. He was a logistics officer responsible for buying and distributing food to his soldiers. When the war ended and the empire was carved up, his family was split btw 3 countries Lebanon Syria and Palestine. So he chose to settle with his relatives in Lebanon. May Allah unit this umma under one banner again. The empire was doomed when foreign ideas like nationalism took hold in the region.

[@kellysam2076]

THE EVIL ZIO.NIST KHAZARIAN EMPIRE SUCEEDED IN THEIR FIRST PLANS OF TAKING OVER THE WORLD BY GETTING THE MUSLIM UMMAH OUT OF THE WAY

[@teukufadel8293]

There is actually a video named as "how did westernization destroy the Ottoman Empire" and a Book regarding the rise and fall of the Ottoman Empire by Ali Muhammad Ash-Shalabi which might explain some additional info regarding how bad the nationalism and westernization affected the empire itself as a whole (even though some Things Such as the reformation of the military system and the abolishment of the Obsolete Janissary as a whole might actually seem necessary on many parts)

[@whatever9506]

@@teukufadel8293 indeed nationalism is a cancer that still plagues our region unfortunately. I'll check out the vid. Thanks for the recommendation.

[@dova238]

Yes nationalism led to shameful mass killings of other religions like Armenian Christians. Many “converted” to Islam just to stay alive.

[@kellysam2076]

@@dova238 And Do u know who was behind this nationalism. The khazarians. They manipulated the whole thing and killed the Armenians. You see I as a shia Muslim am appalled at the manipulation that goes on. And I feel if the Armenian orthodox Christians still had been around as there would have been many in number then the middle east would have been safer. They had lived side by side with Muslims especially shia prior to this western concept of nationalism that created nazism. This nationalism agenda was pushed by the khazarian zion.ists to create is.rael to make Muslims fight Christians. And take over.

[@adam.259]

I am from Turkiye. May Allah preserve president Erdoğan, forgive his sins and bring the shari'ah and khilaafa back to our lands, aamîn 🌹

[@kellysam2076]

THIS ATATURK WAS A FAKE. A DONMEH. A KHAZARIAN J3W WHO WANTED TO DESTROY TURKEY ITS EMPIRE AND MUSLIMS

[@absar4578]

Ameen Beyim

[@thomasthomas6645]

Erdoğan is a shaytan..

[@dova238]

Erdoğan won’t bring sharia brother may Allah forgive his sins cuz he’s done many faulty things that are against Islamic teachings. There can easily be a better Muslim leader But he’s the only one that’s somewhat “ religious” even though he’s not that conservative but it’s better then other parties who are probably worse and anti-Islamic and pro-Ataturk

[@MiekuahProductions]

@@dova238 edrogan seems like part secular and part muslim but the changes he made slowly turns the secular country into muslim country. One step for a day.

[@salmahyunus6267]

Lessons in history which don't make it into our school text books. So blessed that Allah allowed us to gain beneficial knowledge through BT. May Allah bless you Bro Paul and all the scholars on your channel

[@kfie3731]

Our brother Paul with another great video. Just started the video. Am I the only one who gets sad thinking about Khilafah.

[@maymunahsydow6276]

Nope...I feel it! The absence of leadership over the complete Ummah!

[@sairamalik1572]

Asslamalaikum, Alhamdolillah I just start listening and I gathered from the Turk brother’s comment , I’m from Pakistan and my heart goes for all my brothers and sisters in Islam all around the world, I absolutely agree with you, your English is perfectly fine, Islam is the one going to be victorious, that is Allah SWT’s promise to momayneens, that what is says in Qur-an, Alhamdolillah,we have to be patient, Nasrumin Allah wa Fathun Qareeb.

[@taifshams]

Every 100 years there occurs a big change for Muslim World I believe, hopefully in 2024 Insha Allah something good will come about.

[@KingsCrossVIP]

Lesson 7: Don't judge a situation from a Eurocentric perspective... I totally agree - listen up When I arrived in the UK I went to live in Small Health Birmingham I was told all the Muslim areas are called Ghettos - even by Muslims themselves. I was absolutely shocked because I loved living in an area that was all Muslim - the people, the bookshops, the doctors, the businesses, the schools and so many Masjids - to me, an outsider, it was heaven on earth but they considered themselves living in a Ghetto - very strange because they had access to all the necessities in life like everyone else and could make their area as beautiful as they wanted.... but unfortunately they adopted the Eurocentric perspective and looked down on themselves.

[@maymunahsydow6276]

Ye that's a huge problem if the west demonised they believe! They question and doubt themselves as Muslims! When the Kaliphate was dissolved in my humble opinion and I don't know much just that is something inherently wrong the removed the head and the body is floating around like lost to a degree! Still it stands amazing though but how! Perhaps Yemen would not bn allowed to happen for example if we were accountable on earth! Sad!

[@Kuppasy]

They live in Europe for heavens shake! If they don’t want Eurocentric view, shouldn’t they be migrating back to Islamic Emirates?

[@KingsCrossVIP]

Reply to tuktuk eurocentric cultural mind frame not location. If youre not a Muslim you wouldn't understand. We are not like you

[@user-vb6df4sd8d]

@@Kuppasy bro if they live in Europe doesn’t mean they have to think like them. Holy shit some people just love to worship Europeans

[@quitlying1948]

​@@KuppasyEurope like any other part of the world is nothing but a land. You shouldn't change your soul because you are in such and such places.

[@kenkaneki9138]

You were clothed in a shroud on the night of the wedding, and was buried at dawn Minarets and podiums yelled for you, and kingdoms and mourners cried for you India sorely grieved, and Egypt is saddened, crying for you with tears Poem by Ahmed Shawqi

[@IngramSnake]

What does India have to do with this tho?

[@MirAbdulWajid]

@@IngramSnake did you not hear the talk. It mentions the Khilafah movement which was championed by the Indian muslims.

[@Kuppasy]

@@MirAbdulWajid not everyone! Just don’t misappropriate the title Indian Muslim. In fact big chunk of Indian Muslims even rejected a separate state for Indian Muslims. DO NOT ATTEMPT TO ISOLATE US FROM OUR NON MUSLIM INDIANS! We are native Indians accepted Islam for its teaching but definitely not to separate us from our non-Muslim Indians! We are not subservient to arab or Turkish elitism. Not even to Urdu Muslim appropriation of the narrative of Indian Muslims. We don’t exist for you to create caliphate monarchy! We know how sultans, nizams, etc.etc… thrived and made themselves rich and exploited the mass! We reject politicizing Islam

[@teukufadel8293]

Bruh a Muslim that fight for the secular , yea good luck with that

[@Kuppasy]

@@teukufadel8293 is that right ? Muslim world has the some of the remount secular leaders in the world. Read about Kamel Ataturk, Nasser, Enwar Hoxha, Mujibur Rahman, Abul Kalam Azad etc.. many many! As much as Christian or Hindu or Buddhist world has religious fanatic political leaders as well.

[@AbdulMuij08]

What an insightful session, مَا شَاءَ ٱللَّٰهُ May Allah ﷻ bless both of you .

[@mhamed1432]

Thank you Paul and your guest. Very informative talk, May All rewards you immensely.

[@babulsarwar3714]

Unbelievably enlightening and edifying piece. Great great work.

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@atmuji2262]

I'm proud of Caliphate of Islam. It brought the world in to the rightness and prosperous for people all over the world. Allohu Akbad

[@fathimashums4045]

Allahu Akbar * (you've made a typo brother/sister)

[@OneCash]

I think one of the most important, yet nearly unmentioned name in the Empire's downfall is Shabbtai Tzvi. It was his followers, the Donmeh, who posed as Muslims in order to climb the ranks in state and military. Kemal was a Donmeh, too. They brought Freemasonry to Turkey and lured western-minded state officials to join, as they were granted a special kind of acceptance in Europe. But the masons threw Kemal out because he was getting on everybodies nerves with his atheist views. That's why he banned them when he came into power. The Donmeh are still alive today, leading the war on Islam in Turkey. They even have a seperate cemetary in Istanbul called Bülbüldere.

[@user-zy7fs4ho7e]

You are so stupid dude. Mustafa Kemal wasn't a dönme, he was a real turk fed up with arap betrayals

[@4gimmi]

It was so interesting to hear! Loved it for historical purposes and theological aspects that as a Muslim we didn’t know.

[@usmanalikhan6073]

very good timing ما شاء الله , I'm studying abroad in Pleven, Bulgaria, just found out that today is the day they were 'liberated' from 'opression'

[@teukufadel8293]

Pretty much many ex Ottoman Land Such as Bulgaria and Greece celebrated their "liberation/independence day" from the Ottoman Empire

[@axmed2229]

Lool same I’m studying in Plovdiv

[@dova238]

Well they were neither liberated of freed. Although ottomans were a Muslims Khilafa state they did many faulty things which didn’t follow Islamic teaching and the sunnah of prophet Muhammad alaihi Salam. Like the exploitation of non-Muslims by taxing them higher and making them of lesser people by taking their children and making them as slaves which isn’t particularly bad cuz slavery in ottomans was done the way it was like in Islam, having the slave in the house with his own name, same clothing and food and medications as the owner, and u teach the person the society of Islam and Islam itself so that they might convert and can become free from the owner. Who knows how many slaves converted to Islam with right intents or solely to have freedom. Many Europeans did this “converting” to Islam just to get cheaper tax rates. That’s how u got crypto Jews or donmeh which is a term or word in Turkish for people who say are Muslim but in reality still practice their initial belief which is not Islam. They were a group of traitors which Kemal was part of and what caused the Ottoman downfall so part of the downfall of the ottomans was the ottomans itself with its mistakes.

[@thetruth8295]

​@@teukufadel8293 this could be understood while they were Christians but kurds Iranians till India and China and Arabs were suffering and many till now

[@usmanalikhan6073]

@@axmed2229 got a mate in third year called Suhaib Hamad, do you know of him? 😆

[@musasesay8477]

May Allah continue to bless you Paul as always going dip into muslim matters

[@ryojs4286]

ALHAMDULILLAH FOR THIS INFORMATION

[@muhammadhanzala9736]

MashAllah nice 👍 one... Pls arrange other sessions with him on Islamic economic, social, judicial system... MashAllah HT members are well known about khilafah

[@talalberekdar]

What a great conversation about a very interesting and important topic. Thank you both for reinforcing the point that muslims are brothers and should cooperate together regardless of national identity or nationality. That was the core principle of the Ottoman empire.

[@CineRanter]

An incredibly fascinating and informative lecture on a riveting but depressing subject

[@emaadstoys7449]

SubhanAllah! Just 10m in...interesting and intriguing.

[@maazakhan]

JazakAllah khair for doing this.

[@speakerscornerislamicdawah3947]

Alhemdulillah! And another one! Thank you brother Paul for a fascinating and informative discussion on our shared Islamic history. Hope to you see tomorrow if you pass by. Asalamu Alaykum.

[@BloggingTheology]

Wa alaykumu s-salam

[@Kuppasy]

So from here on if anybody accepts Islam don’t just stop by asking them say “la ilaha illallah..muhammadur rasoolallah”..but please also ask them if they accept caliphate also. Otherwise disqualify them to become Muslim.

[@memonm786]

Very insightful, thank you both.

[@BloggingTheology]

Glad it was helpful!

[@shoaibmahaldar2642]

@@BloggingTheology Is islamic caliphate possible ??? Let's look at reality of muslim world. Do muslim countries have good relationship with each other?? Sunni arab countries hate Iran,saudia uae and egypt blocked qatar,Turkey invaded syria,Bangladesh took independence from pakistan due to pak armies atrocities,Muslims are fighting against each other in sudan,sudan has border disputes with egypt,Pakistan and Afghanistan are fighting on border issues etc............... How will you form military alliances??? Nato was formed because all countries have a common democratic ideology and free trade similar culture and tensions with soviet union. Only common thing that can unite Muslim countries is islam.But at this moment islam is not a priority of any Muslim country. Muslim countries cannot make high tech weaponary.All muslim countries are dependent on USA,Russia,China and Europe for weapons. Russia has military bases in every former soviet muslim countries. China has military bases in muslim African nations. Usa has military base in turkiye and other middle eastern countries. Its a shame that Saudi arabia that has the 2 holy muslim cities is protected by 5 american military bases. Even the currency used in mecca and medina and rest of Saudi arabia is pegged to US dollar. Such a shame. If ever we could go back in time and bring prophet Muhammad to the present, he would be terribly unhappy with the Saudis. He had asked for a global caliphate with military domination, especially dominating the Christians. But never ever he would have thought that the heart of his empire is already a puppet state and of no match to the Christian crusaders in military might. What a pity.! We Muslims truly haven't lived upto prophet Muhammad's expectations. Millions of Muslims are starving in yemen syria sudan somalia Afghanistan pakistan and other poor countries and arab nations are busy buying football clubs. Millions of Muslims died due to continous wars waged by America nato and other countries. Uyghars are being killed and tortured and Muslim countries are inviting china to oic and giving china projects and taking loans. I used to be a devout muslim but after studying geopolitics and reality I have lost hope and I don't believe in Gods mercy anymore. The reality literally made me cry for days but now I have embraced Friedrich nitzsche's nihilistic belief. For me God is dead.........

[@SuperTANMAN007]

Salam Pual, Absolutely amazing insight. Really appreciate your work.

[@abbasbeig3943]

As usual an excellent effort to promote true side of Islamic history. There was " Thehreek e Khikafat " in Indian Subcontinent by Muslims of Region, a serious and sincere movement to save Symbolic Islamic Khilafah.

[@snakejuce]

This specific topic, Every. Single. Human. MUST. Know. About. (Especially the Muslims)

[@arsalanmirza3411]

PS: Refer to Surah ar- Ra’d ‘The THUNDER’ Verse 11 👇 “Verily! Allah will not change the good condition of a people as long as they do not change their state of goodness themselves (by committing sins and by being ungrateful and disobedient to Allah). But when Allah wills a people's punishment, there can be no turning back of it, and they will find besides Him no protector”. Quran: 13:11. “Verily! Allah will not change the good condition of a people as long as they do not change their state of goodness themselves (by committing sins and by being ungrateful and disobedient to Allah). But when Allah wills a people's punishment, there can be no turning back of it, and they will find besides Him no protector. Quran: 13:11-11

[@MR-dm1gx]

It was a sad day for the whole humanity let alone for Muslems as evident today as ever!

[@kenkaneki9138]

Its only sad for Muslims, people who helped destroy it are rejoicing.

[@247Slotenmaker]

Great series these talks

[@ilhamdahir9915]

I love history and I enjoyed thank you very much guys

[@husniolama8283]

As always, impressive selectin of topic and discussion by (BT) Mr. Williams. Just thinking, after adulthood, and for the last 50+ years of being an observant Muslim, I couldn't understand two major issues related to the "Khelafah," from the Omayyads to the Ottomans: A Khalifa should be a member of a dynasty!, and A non-observant Muslim -to say the least- be accepted as a Khalifa with religious authority!

[@salihdrerschen2569]

Return of The Khalifat by Shaykh Abdalqadir As-Sufi is a concise piece of history and inspiration for the strength of our Ummah

[@bernardmcavoy1864]

Do you mean that nutcase, Ian Dallas?

[@Repentmuslim]

Alhamdulillah, finally found this topic...

[@sohail216]

abolished Ottoman Caliphate, repercussions of this decision r still felt in Islamic world 2day

[@mahnazbahaji2648]

He has Bern known as Jamaldin al Asabadi. Very knowledgebl man and a fighter.

[@maaziy_ghaziyIYI]

Anyone who's interested in learning about Islam and politics has to read the works of Sayyid Abul Ala Maududi. He's the founder of Jamat Islami of both India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. He's considered to be the founder of "Islamic Fundamentalism" by the United States. He and his works have influenced the Muslim Brotherhood of Egypt and Ayatollah Khomeini's Islamic revolution in Iran as well as the Taliban in Afghanistan. His book Khilafat-o-Mulukiyat (Caliphate and Monarchy) is an absolute must on the subject-matter of Caliphate and Islamic governance and statecraft.

[@wbh623]

none of the examples you mentioned have anything to do with islam. get out of here with your khariji bullshit 😂😂😂

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

His works influenced the infidel khomini wow really and the secular Muslim brotherhood who brought the damn sisi for us now I know how it’s not good to read his books

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@@yottwr6108 do not make me laugh hizb al Nour are not salafi they are murjia just a sect like your precious ikhwan real salafi will never support a taghout i am Egyptian by the way so do not act as you know more about my country just because you are brainwashed by some emotional heretics

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@@yottwr6108 my name is Ahmed and you think that I am a Christian oh my Allah

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@@yottwr6108 wallahi who accuse people with something then it’s his reflection look seems From your IQ that you are Asian ottoman lover wannabe boy alhamdullah I am an Arab and If I was a Nationalist then I would be proud of the Egyptians pagan history just because you are hating Arabs and worshiping the ottomans as any heretic does not mean that you correct so look to what the prophet said about real caliphate and the Arabs and do not be emotional

[@nadeemmagsi2901]

Want more talks about the Khilafah System from Blogging Theology! 👍🏻

[@BloggingTheology]

Another one next week!

[@drabulhasandasankop3737]

Yes please do bring out more video of Osmania caliphate we indian know Turks empire but which we don't know we get acknowledge from you respected Sir.

[@Kuppasy]

Yeah. Take Muslims further backwards so we can create a monarchy in the name of Islam. effindi titles can provide comfortable life.

[@backoffice9957]

@Amal Arab Girl the main reason for the fall of khalifite is the Arab. Especially hashmies and sauds in present ksa. The west had paid a lot of money for the hashmies in mecca and offer then the khalifite. The Arabs are fools. They are are thinking with their spines and not by brain. The west had been Trying 3oo years to over thow the sultan. The ww1 and ww2 was an orchestrated event with somany goals, One of the primary goal of ww1 was the entire elimination of elimination of tsar of Russia and ottomans. The deep state which has very few people with vast wealth afraid of the strong kings at that time. Because these European kings may Unite against and wiped out them. So they want to invent democracy, with this nobody has absolute power and nobody can harm or challenge them They created their new world order with no challenges.

[@shoaibmahaldar2642]

Is islamic caliphate possible ??? Let's look at reality of muslim world. Do muslim countries have good relationship with each other?? Sunni arab countries hate Iran,saudia uae and egypt blocked qatar,Turkey invaded syria,Bangladesh took independence from pakistan due to pak armies atrocities,Muslims are fighting against each other in sudan,sudan has border disputes with egypt,Pakistan and Afghanistan are fighting on border issues etc............... How will you form military alliances??? Nato was formed because all countries have a common democratic ideology and free trade similar culture and tensions with soviet union. Only common thing that can unite Muslim countries is islam.But at this moment islam is not a priority of any Muslim country. Muslim countries cannot make high tech weaponary.All muslim countries are dependent on USA,Russia,China and Europe for weapons. Russia has military bases in every former soviet muslim countries. China has military bases in muslim African nations. Usa has military base in turkiye and other middle eastern countries. Its a shame that Saudi arabia that has the 2 holy muslim cities is protected by 5 american military bases. Even the currency used in mecca and medina and rest of Saudi arabia is pegged to US dollar. Such a shame. If ever we could go back in time and bring prophet Muhammad to the present, he would be terribly unhappy with the Saudis. He had asked for a global caliphate with military domination, especially dominating the Christians. But never ever he would have thought that the heart of his empire is already a puppet state and of no match to the Christian crusaders in military might. What a pity.! We Muslims truly haven't lived upto prophet Muhammad's expectations. Millions of Muslims are starving in yemen syria sudan somalia Afghanistan pakistan and other poor countries and arab nations are busy buying football clubs. Millions of Muslims died due to continous wars waged by America nato and other countries. Uyghars are being killed and tortured and Muslim countries are inviting china to oic and giving china projects and taking loans. I used to be a devout muslim but after studying geopolitics and reality I have lost hope and I don't believe in Gods mercy anymore. The reality literally made me cry for days but now I have embraced Friedrich nitzsche's nihilistic belief. For me God is dead.........

[@masoudissa7744]

Mashaa Allah

[@Abd.Al-Malik]

MashaAllah

[@RA-tc8tr]

Is this talk available on your spotify channel?

[@kfie3731]

Paul you have to do a video on Allama Iqbal the poet and philosopher in India. He is incredible. Believe me you will read him and get shocked.

[@dova238]

I know of him because of sheikh imran hosein

[@unibks4382]

What about Sir Iqbal?

[@unibks4382]

@@dova238 What does the Sheikh say about Sir Iqbal?

[@mariannaser7737]

I'm Muslim and arab too 💗💓💕💞💙🌹🌸☺️♥️🥰🐢🕌

[@ahmedshoaib2791]

SunHanAllah Allah Blessed him after they rejected his body to his homeland He gave him Medina MashAllah

[@fauziajasia2548]

Where's the booklist he talked about in the beginning?

[@shabihhasan1876]

Thanks!

[@BloggingTheology]

Many thanks!

[@kazirakibahmed2965]

Assalamualaikum. I am so WOW by the so informative discussion. It has cleared me up about lot of questions particularly in regard to middle east geo politics, financial gains, and eventually plan of wiping out Palestainians. Thanks a million indeed! There is another very sad and cruel overthrow of a very famous dynasty- the Mughals of India by the English. The last Emperor, 20th in line Bahdur Shah Zafar was exiled to Rangoon and died there. Kindly arrange a program on this where we can really know what really happened in the Red Fort, how his family was captured, members were killed or not and who were exiled with the last Emperor and any updates on their descendents. It is so sad to know that Bahdur Shah's last surviving son was begging on the street - where as a few hundreds years back his great, great great grand father was the creator of the Tajmahal, Emperor Shahjahan! I am sure so many of us will be benefited if you kindly arrange a or two program on this topic. Thanks again and God bless!

[@BloggingTheology]

Wa alaykumu s-salam

[@kfie3731]

Allama Iqbal before leaving for England for higher education also was quite impressed by nationalism. But a stay of few years in England and Germany (where he is Phd) made him see the complete picture. All these individuals travelled to Europe and were influenced in negative ways but not Iqbal. He then said whatever he knew in poetry. His poetry has politics, philosophy, history and of course its Islam and Muslim centered. His work is a treat for Muslims. He even claims in his verse that his work has nothing other then Quran. Paul read his 'Shilwa', 'Jawab e Shikwa' and 'Tallu e Islam'.

[@teukufadel8293]

He also actually prayed in the ex Umayyad Land of Iberia/Modern Spain as well as far as i remember

[@kfie3731]

@@teukufadel8293yes he did

[@britishqueen94]

Tell me why did the British give Iqbal a knighthood.? You are a prime case of idiots choosing other idiots as leaders

[@kfie3731]

@@britishqueen94 you have not read Iqbal as that is evident from this comment. His works criticize the British (European broadly), their doings, ideas, education etc. He was a great poet he deserves all sorts of awards. As I said before you are unaware of his work. Please read him. Your opinions will change. It's nothing but an interpretation of Quran in poetry. Like Rumi's Masnavi is Quran in Persian, Iqbal's work says nothing but Quran. Read 'Shikwa' and 'Jawab e Shikwa' your views will change. Happy reading 😊

[@britishqueen94]

@@kfie3731 Simple question he was knighted,for what? Shikwa was considered Kuffar at the time....the source for a Muslim is Quran/Sunnah and the Islamic edict for the Muslim of that time was Jihad against the British.....did Sir Iqbal declare Jihad?

[@al-hilalgames5708]

The abolishment of the Caliphate is indeed a great achievement of the British people in their unending crusade against Muslims.

[@al-hilalgames5708]

@Amal Arab Girl Well, most Arabs are clear enemies of Islam, so that doesn't matter. tbh

[@user-vb6df4sd8d]

@Amal Arab Girl who said that?? Speak for yourself.

[@user-vb6df4sd8d]

@Amal Arab Girl it was until some traitors decided to rebel against the ottomans

[@user-vb6df4sd8d]

@Amal Arab Girl listen we get that you are a bot there is no need to continue spamming your bullshit

[@cwh5]

It's so sad to see that how we as Muslims have been our worst enemies. People like Attarturk sold out the UMMAH. I shudder to think how these people are going to stand in front of Allah after being instrumental in bringing down the system of Allah in the world as well as the ensuing suffering of the UMMAH in Palestine and the rest of the world. This discussion caused both my heart and eyes to shed tears 😭

[@cwh5]

@@Quran_Alone_Dawah I am not someone who is looking to prop up any nationality. It is a known fact that Theodore Herzl and the Zionist together with the British tried to convince Sultan Abdul Hamid to give Palestine to the Jews. He refused saying He had no right over what belongs to the UMMAH. This was even before World War I They then realised their only way was the dismantling of the Khilaafat and breaking up the Muslim world into nation states. To this end they worked and Atarturk was used to achieve this. He was instrumental in bringing the Islamic Khilaafat to an end. The Islamic Khilaafat was not an Arab or a Turk institution. It was an Islamic one. If Atarturk was not anti Islam why did he change the Adhaan from being called out in Arabic to being called out in the Turkish language in 1932 and this lasted for 18 years? What you cannot deny is that he was very instrumental in bringing down the Khilaafat. I also belive that the Arabs actually began this downfall by giving Arab nationalism preference over Islam which led them to conspire with the British against the Ottoman empire. So it's not a question of nationalism with us. Islam needs to be the criterion. As Umar Bin Khattab (RA) said, 'We are a nation honoured by Islam and should we seek honour by any thing besides Islam we will be disgraced!' This is exactly what happened

[@shifanur8261]

because he is not a muslim to begin with. Atakhafir is hiding as a Türk. but his origin is not...

[@shifanur8261]

@@Quran_Alone_Dawah proof?

[@saranpatel1114]

May Allah swt's curse be on Ataturk and his family and friends and his supporters until the day of judgement and then May Allah swt make them the firewood of Hellfire.

[@britishqueen94]

The Palestinian Muppets have a day when they celebrate liberation from the Ottomans... Shit happens because there is a reason

[@Noraiz2822]

Wa Alaikum As-Salam Wa Rahmatullahi Wa Barakatu

[@behappylivelong]

Thank you for this very informative, facts about my beloved country. May Allah swt protect and bless it and the President Erdoğan long live Türkiye ❤

[@zhuala]

SubahanAllah it will be nearly 100 years on the fall of last Islamic Khalifah. Yes Ottoman empire has it faults but it has deen. Look at the Umah now, fighting for scraps

[@zayn6725]

Very sad day in history indeed

[@MrChelek]

It must be restored, can be restored and will be restored. There are very many issues that need to be addressed by the institution of the Caliphate!!! Urgently.

[@grnzrn]

I like this part at 1:03:40 where Paul criticizes an author for reserving the ideas of "liberty, individualism and freedom" for the "white man" (aka non-muslims). Whereas he clearly opposes those same ideas in everything else he says. Its like the joke with the old lady at the hotel-buffet, who loudly proclaims: "The food here tastes terrible! And also the portions are way to small!"

[@kassema9527]

Amazing video as usual! Was slightly disappointed though that honorable Abdul wahid didn’t mention the atrocities caused to the Kurds by Ata Turk. He killed and oppressed them harshly

[@letstakealook123]

Ata Turks crimes in are many and was a vile and despicable man. He destroyed Muslim unity. The video was about the abolishment of the Khilafah. What Ata Turk did was after that and outside the scope of the discussion.

[@kassema9527]

@@letstakealook123 salam alaykom Brother, yes I am aware of that although I refer to the part where he highlights the wrongdoings of his reign he could of touched on it because he butchered a lot of the ulema of the Kurds and it was relevant for the point

[@letstakealook123]

@@kassema9527. Kurds were strong supporters of the Khilafah and known to have stood upto to the despicable Ata Turk. They paid a big price. No doubt Allah ﷻ will those as shuhada who stood up to the nationalist secular tyrant.

[@saranpatel1114]

May Allah swt grant Jannathul firdaus for the people who stood by Islam

[@zeknoss]

M. Kamal was a freemason. He has pictures posing as such. He was a pragmatist. He "liberated" Ottoman lands off Islam. He rose to power. Then he betrayed his lodge, closing down the lodges in Turkey. As he did that, he was marked to death per his initiation oath, which in a way described in the oath itself as following: "... under no less penalty than that of having my body severed in two, my bowels taken from thence and burned to ashes, the ashes scattered before the four winds of heaven...". His demise brought by his "brothers" can be observed in his grave, as his bowels were taken out, burned to ashes and put into the cups around him. The overarching goal of establishing the New Babylon, the one world government mandates the abolishment of all the religious and political authority, creating a power vaccuum which will be filled by the "promised god king". All the hailstrom the world had been under for the last few centuries were steps to this goal, nothing else. M. Kamal was once serving that purpose knowingly or not, then betrayed that goal and paid the price. Everybody who does that pays the price the same way. They get killed in a most grotesque way than deified by their killers. Just look at JFK, Adnan Menderes and Turgut Ozal and many other leaders who got the same sticky end. They were killed, dishonored and deified when necessary. M. Kamal knew what was going to happen in Turkiye in the coming century which he famously told in his Oration to the Turkish Youth: "This is the very foundation of your existence and your future. This foundation is your most precious treasure. In the future, too, there may be malevolent people at home and abroad who will wish to deprive you of this treasure. If some day you are compelled to defend your independence and your republic, you must not tarry to weigh the possibilities and circumstances of the situation before taking up your duty. These possibilities and circumstances may turn out to be extremely unfavourable. The enemies conspiring against your independence and your republic, may have behind them a victory unprecedented in the annals of the world. It may be that, by violence and ruse, all the fortresses of your beloved fatherland may be captured, all its shipyards occupied, all its armies dispersed and every part of the country invaded. And sadder and graver than all these circumstances, those who hold power within the country may be in error, misguided and may even be traitors. Furthermore, they may indentify their personal interests with the political designs of the invaders. The country may be impoverished, ruined and exhausted.". These are not prophecies, but the knowledge he received after his initiation. This was the plan he first served to and then betrayed. That's how he knew what was coming, hence it started just recently...

[@sakirsingh3500]

Yes, you are right. I think he betrayed them only when he realized that they are going to cut the turk nation into zones. French zone, Greek zone etc.

[@zeknoss]

@@sakirsingh3500 I don't think so. That happened before he rose to power, in fact his fight in those wars against that plan led him to power. After he grabbed the power, he was already very deep into nationalism. The people around him were mostly Turkish named Jewish. He was being groomed into the role. His betrayal, I think, came when he thought he was invincible. This led to him being marked for death, he became paranoid, closed down the masonic lodges, then killed by them all the same. He became distant with his friend in cause Ismet Inonu, I think that began at those times as well because right after his death Inonu continued the masonic program.

[@saranpatel1114]

May Allah swt's curse be on Ataturk and his family and friends until the judgement day and then they become the firewood of Hellfire.

[@zeknoss]

@@saranpatel1114 amîîn.

[@arsalanmirza3411]

“And those who believe will say: "Are these the men (hypocrites) who swore their strongest oaths by Allah that they were with you (Muslims)?" All that they did has been in vain (because of their hypocrisy), and they have become the losers. O you who believe! Whoever from among you turns back from his religion (Islam), Allah will bring a people whom He will love and they will love Him; humble towards the believers, stern towards the disbelievers, fighting in the Way of Allah, and never afraid of the blame of the blamers. That is the Grace of Allah which He bestows on whom He wills. And Allah is All-Sufficient for His creatures' needs, All-Knower. Quran: Surah 5 al Ma’idah ‘The Table Spread with Food’ Verses 53-54.

[@rodzitazainal19]

Pls cover the Balfour Declaration historically and ensuing impact to the Middle East.

[@suleymancoskun4212]

very sad ,the truth hurts .......allahü akber

[@fehaazeusuf2176]

I am South African Muslim. We intend to Invest In Turkey, Insha Allah. We also Hope And Pray Erdogan wins this Election, but he should win and he should Implement Shariah Law in the Country , Ameen

[@atheistturk2509]

Don't come, you aren't welcomed here.

[@britishqueen94]

Er Dog Cunts biggest partner is Israel and he supports gay rights...what makes idiots like you think he would implement Shariah?

[@britishqueen94]

@Malik what is organic way? Learn some Islam either it is Haraam Mubah or Fardh.....Allah has given a Muslim no choice

[@britishqueen94]

@Malik You're too stupid for me to talk to...go learn some figh before you comment

[@fehaazeusuf2176]

He has the support of Allah SWT. That's all the support he needs, Yes it should be done slowly, and he has taken 20 years and achieved much. But he need to take to step for Shariah Law. He will be victorious, Insha Alalh. The way the Ottomans did it.

[@ismailakviranl9174]

Dear channel owner and the guest speaker, I thank you for your statements here. I would love to share my thoughts here. The actual perception of abolishing the khilafah in Turkiye's agenda is not natural, but artificial. Because the natural course of a political regime's building, actually constitutional backbone of the society should most likely be compliant with the essential belief of the very society at least on the basis of a scope of common grounds if there are different interpretations of the belief. Shortly the people of Turkiye at the moment can not evaluate the situation open mindedly. Ironically the tyrant minority whom seemingly muslim but actually not, accuses the majority of the society for being not open minded or being supporter of anti-science mindset.(That s a clichee of seculars in Turkiye) In the early years of our republic maybe more than 40.000 islamic scholar were hanged just because they were teaching Islam and leading the society on spritual basis. Maybe 400000 of religious people were prosecuted or persecuted in order to frustrate and intimidate. Therefore between 1924 through 1950 the brainwashing of generations had been conducted. After 1950, maybe 5% of religios education could be resurrected. That achievement has been increased gradually but it is not at the level it should be (not even close). So maybe in England you could see a Turkish muslim whom pondering competency is impaired and actually the product of several generations that had gone through a very tyrant brainwashing periods. But there are a few groups who could survive not just bodily but mentally and intellectually. Thay maintain the job of sahabei kiram(the companions of Resulallah). Bediuzzaman once said Ottoman empire is pregnant to an atheist child but Europe is pregnant to a muslim child in the last years of Ottomans. That methaphorical statement is being taken place today. Sorry for my english is not perfect but I tried my best to convey what is my mind.

[@jirensays6994]

Please discuss why The British left Indian Sub continent on their own

[@Sheen023]

The reason lies centuries back in Jamaluddin Afghani and Abdul Wahab (l.a)

[@zulhafis9858]

Thank you BT....now I understood how Palestine fall to other until now. Very shame when power have closed our eyes about the truth.

[@user-hw9ei4cs8g]

Atatürk hated Kemalizm so much , the text was written in France,he said 'They are making me idolized,he got angry.

[@HFC786]

Should be fascinating to listen to

[@Kuppasy]

How did Abdul Majid became caliph? Because his father was a caliph. How did his father became one? His grandfather held the title. They lived like royals! If Islam’s goal is to build royals in the name of caliphs, emirs, sultans, Islam has lost its case

[@kapand7547]

va lillahi mulku ve cunudussamawati well ardy ve kanallahu aziyzan hakiymen..... wallahu ahkamul haakimiyn...

[@anwarabrahams2413]

❤️🤲🇿🇦

[@rimacalid6557]

The hate of Arabs or Arabophobia, I wish it has been addressed here , it the first symptom of foreign intervention if not the main one.

[@YahiyaKhan-bk3bc]

Ironically the separation of religious study and modern subject studies are practised in Indian subcontinent now who supported caliphate in whom state power and religious power was vested with.

[@nopurposeposting1548]

18:22 that quote might have describe the reason why some turks even entertain the idea of applying western civilization model on the turks. I do think instead of this idea push being the catalyst, its actually the weakened state of the ottoman caliphate that allows this to happen while the idea to push western ideology is just one of the many result it caused.

[@Kuppasy]

Not sure how would having caliphate would have helped Turkey otherwise! Turkey was poor, weak and still the caliph lived like royal. Let not forget it was caliph who has surrendered to allies. If Ataturk didn’t step in the Turkey today would have been much smaller country!

[@blade4048]

I think there's great divine wisdom behind the abolition of the caliphate and the rise of secular states. Just think if the caliphate and religion-based states survived, how would Islam enter the heart of the west? Would states allow a large number of Muslims to become citizens of those nations? Muslims by default would be loyal to the caliphate, and would not have the spirit of nationalism toward the state. So spread of Islam would be halted in the west and other regions due to this. "But they planned, and Allah plans. And Allah is the best of planners"

[@alhazenmediax]

It was decay, such as Muslims were actually fighting Turkey(why?), and owing to decay, he decided to abolish it. What would you have done to safe Turkey?

[@TURKISLAM4EVER]

It was the best day ever

[@thomasnewton8690]

Watching on the 3rd of March 2024

[@lyjugufugyjkt586]

Make 1 video about abdelkareem el khetabi,Moroccan/Berber freedom fighter.

[@muhammadnursultan9704]

Aceh Sultanate and Ottoman Empire ❤️

[@laylapaz8822]

"Hello everyone?" What happened to "As salaam alaikum!"

[@shafi.j]

You took the first impact

[@rafatdurdana663]

The famous couplet that resonated in those times in support of Khilafah in India was بولين امان محمد علي كي. جان بيتا خخلافت پہ دیدو

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

Nothing simply because the prophet said The caliphate is thirty years, and the rest of them are kings, and the caliphs and kings are twelve Narrator: safina | The narrator: Shoaib Al-Arnaout | Source: Sahih Ibn Hibban’s graduation Page or number: 6657 | A summary of the hadeeth’s ruling: its chain of transmission is good : so what ataturk did was nothing because there was no caliphate in this time the ottomans were just a Turkic empire as any other Asian or European dynasty The caliphate is thirty years, then it becomes kingship Then he said: Hold the caliphate of Abu Bakr for two years, and the caliphate of Umar for twelve, and for Othman twelve, and for Ali six. He said: Yes. brief presentation.. Narrator: safina | The narrator: Shoaib Al-Arnaout | Source: Explanation of the Sunnah Page or number: 3865 | A summary of the hadeeth’s ruling: its chain of transmission is good then it will be again caliphate by the mahdi inshallah because he is a qurashi and the caliphate is only for qurayish as the prophet said

[@teukufadel8293]

Not every scholar actually agree that a Caliph Have to be from the lineage of Quraysh , If that was the case ..then the whole Ottoman Caliphate is not legit .. and so does the Sokoto Caliphate (which unified many parts of the western Africa)

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@@teukufadel8293 yes all of them are not and no scholar opinion is above the prophet words that’s the difference between we ahl al sunnah and you, the prophet words is above our necks

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@Malik as imam al shafie said if people will think that I am shia because my love to banu hashim then let them think listen to me heretic all the scholars of the first 300 hundreds years of Islam who are the salaf agreed and gathered all the Hadiths that the caliphate is in qurashi only plus shia has no correct Hadith but I put a two and have more alhamdullah may Allah guide your blind heart Al-Mawardi said in al-Ahkam al-Sultaniyyah in the conditions of the caliph: (the seventh condition): lineage, which is that he be from Quraysh because of the text on it and consensus on it, and there is no consideration for harm when it is abnormal, so it is permissible for all people, because Abu Bakr Al-Siddiq, may God be pleased with him, protested on the day of the Saqifah against the Ansar in He pushed them away from the caliphate when they pledged allegiance to Saad bin Ubadah over it, with the words of the Prophet, may God bless him and grant him peace: The imams are from Quraysh. So they gave up on being alone with it and turned back from participating in it when they said: From us is a prince and from you is a prince. And the Prophet, may God’s prayers and peace be upon him, said: Go to Quraysh, but do not advance them. There is no suspicion with this Muslim text for a dispute, nor a saying for a contradiction.

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@Malik are you out of your mind to say that the prophet Hadith is ummyad propaganda may Allah curse you and your ottomans look moron those Hadith is proving the the ummyad too were not caliphate because they were not in the 30 years which the prophet mentioned wallahi you Asians know nothing about Islam just an emotional weak creatures who did nothing but to scream go and free yourself from china and India and learn Islam

[@ahmedfarahat8489]

@Malik banu ummyah lasted nearly 70 years and the scholar who I mentioned was after them with 800 years probably plus banu Ummyad were the largest Islamic empire ever yes they did mistakes but at least they were not infidels like your Sufi grave worshipers Turks I see that you dwarf Asians hate Arabs and it’s a heresy too it’s called the nationalism it’s appeared in Iran during the last days of sayydnia Ali rule and was in its peak during the ummyads wallahi you Asians are always useless and only what you can do it’s to scream we support turkey we support Palestine but no real actions you can not even read Quran in it’s original language to know what surat al shura means alhamdullah I am not 100% Arab because Egyptians are not really Arabs but we know that loving Arabs is the sunnah unlike you non educated heretic Asians

[@plutopluto6699]

The Turkish nationalism is started when Arab, Greek, Serbian, Bulgarian NATIONALISM blossomed and used against the TURKS! Arabs celebrate for kicking out the TURKS out of their lands: Jordan, S. Arabia, Egypt, Syria.. I am not against my Arab brothers at all, but only some facts from the history. Today some Muslim brothers are very regretful about the historical facts, but it is too late!

[@hms8836]

Yea but it was because France invaded Egypt and occupied Algeria so Arabs criticised khilafa on how could you allow a muslim land to be occupied. Any way it was a big conspiracy on muslim world

[@ninjaandpaitar2770]

Ottoman empire was the last safe guard for muslim world wide.

[@lhamed5013]

16:22 the the guest mispronounces the word al-islam and says bil-islam in aya 3, surah al-ma'ida. No big deal except when it comes to Quran.

[@adamp2426]

Attaturk has a statue in his honor, in Israel. Do people in Turkey know this?

[@ulgenkoc2893]

So what ,Atatürk has a statue in his honor in lot of coutries ex Cuba,Kazakistan,Azerbaycan.....

[@shifanur8261]

he is the only person who made himself statue before he even die.

[@tamarkan]

I don't understand all that talk around that. If Muslims thought it was so essential, why did nobody act and established it in its own country. Turks abolished their office. Not the concept of hilafet overall..

[@ulgenkoc2893]

Exactly .caliphate can be everywhere.

[@plutopluto6699]

I disresepctfully disagree with my brother for his comment on why aid for the earthquake vistims did not ariive to Idlib area! The problem is SYRIAN GOVERNMENT and the internal Syrian affair! If there was a peace in Syria, if Syria was not in a civil war, if the Syrian people were united, they would get so much help from other nations like Turkey did...

[@brotheryosef3066]

I now somehow know who Mustafa Kamal was. Thanks

[@shafiqazizi2538]

Not very honest by guest, he didn’t touch very much on MIAW’s takfir which had played critical role in apposing Othmans.

[@xshiro83]

Interestingly, we had the illusion of liberty and fell into nationalism then became divided and weaker than before.

[@cogthusiast1150]

One thing that's sorely missing from this analysis is why were the Muslims so easily intoxicated and influenced by Europeaness at the time.

[@muhsinider6181]

Ottoman is not the name of a state. (Devlet-i ALi) Sultans callled the state big state. They were not calling the state with a nation name or tribal name. It was the state of muslims. Fatih called himself the sultan of muslim roman empire. It was not about race it was about islam. There can be only one state for muslims. Muslims can not be different states. People dont understand that. That is how enemies of Islam destroyed the muslim unity, by nationalism and divide and conquer policy. World war 1 was about destroying İslam.

[@almazchati4178]

There is not much influence of Ziya Gökalp on Mustafa Kemal's thinking. Gokalp believed in Turkish union with Russian and Central asian muslims. Mustafa Kemal had no such idea. He believed that Islam is the cause of every evil, and believed in the adoption of western culture in every sphere. He invented a lot of theories about Turkish roots. He wanted to abolish every link to Turkey's past.

[@ahmadalias6407]

(No disrepectful to our muslim brothers in Saudi n Other Gulf Nation)., my POV, the dates marks an achievement to all the personality, the people & groups that involved in that struggle including the religious entity & the outcome of the mission, the establishment of a number of Arab / Gulf Kingdom Nation has fulfill the desire of all the people n parties involved

[@ahmadalias6407]

The demised of the caliphate, the loss of' the Haram. of Baitul Muqaddis n the expel of Phalestine people from their home through the birth of God Nation Kingdom,the ownership n control of the two holy city by the Saudi family is just a colateral, that the ummah has to accept as the reality & fact which the state ofvdcummah.🎉

[@KabsatLa7am]

It’s not disrespect my brother it’s ignorance because if you bothered to read about our Hijazi history we weren’t even part of the Saudi kingdom/shiekhdom when we revoluted against the turks. We were under Hashmites {Sharif] kingdom which was later ended when King Abdulaziz won against Sherif Hussain may Allah’s mercy be on both of them. Allah has united us in an Arab country and we had an Arab king after another, schools are built hospitals established after years of dark history under racist turks we finally have hopes and dreams. This makes haters Shoubies burn with hate lol but I sincerely pray all Muslim would also focus on thier countries, hold themselves and their leaders accountable and stop living in fantasies of a false pas, and work for a prosperous and safe future inshalla.

[@hamadalkhalifa2323]

​@@KabsatLa7am Sharif Hussien was a traitor. Most of the Arabs didn't revolt against the Ottomans. Except few Arab traitors bought by the British.

[@falloufaye534]

@@KabsatLa7am My view is a muslim should not have a specifique country but should consider his home every where he find his muslim brother. We should care about the conditions of all our muslim brother wherever they may live.

[@ansarshalla7969]

Indian khilafat movement was one reason for british