What Happens If You Return To The Gang Hideouts As John Marston After Beating Red Dead Redemption 2?

[@MrBossFTW]

What Happens If You Return To The Gang Hideouts As John Marston After Beating Red Dead Redemption 2?

[@msgtgalarza9946]

Speaking of Red Dead 2 & the Gang hideout I did hear a little girls will I want to see a little girl's voice but she was 19 years old and I know she said something about love or something but it was a spirit in that scared the living crap out of me when I first heard of it when I returned but I did not see any gang spirits. And not only that but you know the one thing I will want more in campaign and online is basically a musket for hunting rifle as a hunting rifle that's the one thing I would use it for hey if GTA V can get a musket I'm pretty sure Red Dead Can too

[@msgtgalarza9946]

Speaking about spirits and ghosts invoices about that if you go to the Civil War battlefield you can actually hear the Civil War man screaming and you can actually hear cannons firing it's horrifying I tell you that and I know there's like maybe two or three Civil War battlefields I think there is but at least it takes like a couple of hours for you to hear it it's really rare and I know I heard it in Red Dead and that scared the living s*** out of me because you can actually hear muskets firing cannons and people strangling each other and yelling charging as well too and swords cuz we all know that generals had swords in the Civil War

[@msgtgalarza9946]

@AdamWayneone yes indeed it was especially the Civil War one down was actually horrifying it was really cool but horrifying especially when you're here must get swords and cannons firing it was around at least nighttime sometimes I will happen in a daytime and just takes a couple of hours for it to happen though if so it might be really where to hear it

[@msgtgalarza9946]

@Colm O’Driscoll oh no it's an O'Driscoll

[@ethandavis4847]

You never went to Colter

[@Dmeza05]

*I don't think it's ghost voices, i think it's just in John's head, and what he remembers from all camps*

[@jjs12345]

Sherlock 69: mystery solved

[@Arabon]

Interesting theory and I think I agree

[@rogersmith3295]

I agree. Many of the voices are still alive so how would it be ghosts ? Lol

[@silasboy-fz2og]

Yeah

[@warrenkemp4004]

It's all in his head.

[@TheGrimArcher]

when you write an essay but you keep repeating all your main talking points to meet the word count

[@Rb889]

Yeah... Christ, shut the hell up and play the damn audio clip instead of talking about it and replaying the clip with your own voice drowning out everything. We get it, you like the sound of your own voice.

[@BrandonReyVids]

me in highschool

[@Scoochin]

gotta hit that 10 minute mark for monetization somehow ;)

[@anonymous.d7555]

Rb889 I went there heard the voice

[@NomaD7801]

You know what's interesting and unique? Not repeating yourself in different phrases.

[@luci_0975]

When Arthur died I wanted to sue rockstar

[@GrindyVine]

Hey rockstar never been sued becauss of a character death. Thats just stupid. Rockstar are not EA

[@iashay8326]

Blud 2soon 😂oms

[@iashay8326]

Mr canoe key word “wanted”

[@hey_im._bea162]

@@GrindyVine ....you know what a "joke" is.. do ya?

[@th-ft3dg]

Blud 2soon I wanted to do that when Lenny n Sean n Hosea died

[@PhamBoy91]

They're not ghost voices, John's just, mentally, reminiscing about his past. The voices are coming from the thoughts of his memories in his mind, they're not ghost voices, most of the voices you hear are of people who didn't even die so how could they be ghosts? Lol.

[@anthonyeconomy4180]

Phamboy 8791 good point

[@pedrosoliz7]

🤣🤣

[@3sTrey]

Fr

[@keithmag3007]

Yes axactly

[@jaydominguez9271]

Phamboy 8791 you buggin

[@johndasalty111]

You enter Horseshoe Overlook In the distance: Bill: HEY! WHO'S THERE? Arthur: IT'S ME, YOU DAMN MORON!

[@2exclusivedxotn-479]

Lol! 😂

[@cillianswan]

@brave cringe

[@joaquingonzales5364]

@@cillianswan no u

[@ghost.rdr2]

charles: whos there?! arthur: its arthur you dumbass (charles did not ride with arthur after that)

[@thewardenmohdizuddin5407]

​@@cillianswanget out of here you cringe

[@Shockwave99999]

Sean's welcome back party was the happiest time in the game: *Change my mind*

[@bonesmalone5802]

Jack's return was better

[@Atriox2004]

But so many had died since Jack’s return. The best parts of the game was while Sean was present.

[@Atriox2004]

I hated Rhodes and Shady Belle. Kieran’s death ruined Lemoyne for me. Damn them all!

[@peachykeen4741]

LENNAY IF FOUND YA MAH BOAH Do I really need to say anymore

[@tobiasschaede397]

I started to play the game recently and Sean's death made me almost throw my controller away, I mean I know that most of the gang will die but it still came out of nowhere

[@danandersen1482]

I heard someone say: “I’m looking for an englishman called GAVIN. Have you seen him?”

[@sonsybaton925]

Is name is Nigel and he is looking for his friend Gavin..... Has any body seen Gavin. Lol, .. OK if you rope him and then loot his pockets you will find a letter back home ( Scotland UK) explaining there journey however Nigel is a liar so check out that letter

[@kevinwilliams8767]

The thing is you never actually find Gavin what you do find a letter like this guy just said

[@Sperkyx]

I just realised while playing as Marston, he still never found Gavin since Arthur was alive

[@angela_kitty2679]

I swear to god I’ve seen that man in more than 1 place and he can’t stop talking about Gavin!!😂

[@cuahutemocramirez7675]

I saw him at saint dennis and now he is in blackwater

[@samuelleahy4780]

The saddest part of this game for me, was when Charles and Sadie left at the end. It felt like I was losing family, knowing I'll never see them again.

[@blueski4823]

that's how I felt as well, knowing you won't see them again. it's hard my dude

[@romanbellic6571]

Samuel leahy If your lucky, Charles can come back to John’s ranch but it’s a bug/glitch. He talks about killing Micah even tho he was already killed.

[@salovel23]

There is a random event in which Charles comes back to John's house, you can talk to him and he says something very sad bro.

[@salovel23]

It is not a bug

[@ved591]

Good news also means you don't ever have to hunt them down or kill them in rd1 still feel bad about locking Javier after playing this one

[@CultOfPersonality091]

You can hear Arthur say "OUT OF THE DAM WAY"

[@mjfishstick1275]

When

[@ironsight_guy]

@@mjfishstick1275 i think its a joke

[@Camelotsmoon]

I never I heard that, but I did hear "There's always a god damn train.".

[@joshhencik1849]

A man after my own heart!

[@titushite3106]

@@ironsight_guy no this is real I went back to colter to live in the snow and I heard old gang members voices

[@jejisland]

Micah was NEVER part of the gang. >:(

[@specs6310]

Kermit The Frog hey

[@georgeamandagoffjr9407]

Ty

[@savannahhameleers7206]

Thank you Kermit, someone needed to say that

[@amberporter6560]

HES A RAT

[@Confucioses]

Thank goodness someone said that because if not I would have

[@yewnammak750]

I wish we could play Arthur and have the gang back after the game has completed with full map unlocked. I really miss them.

[@4lkbhoy]

U can if you made game saves

[@xmissviolencex]

Me too. I just want to play as Arthur again.

[@rubydream4527]

Everyone except Micah, who will be tied up and be the human punching bag who will never die but always be in pain. Damn rat...

[@rekrah8074]

I feel like rockstar sees that so many people want to play more of Arthur and the gang which males me hope that they make RDR3 and it follows durch, hosea and Arthur while they collect members of the game ultimately ending at blackwater where rdr2 starts

[@Mac_8]

Dirty it would be the better idea if they did another red dead, after all Arthur has been with Dutch for 20 years so there’s storey to tell

[@percygoodbeard4827]

Hearing their voices isn’t scary, it’s depressing

[@D-A-1776]

It really is, this is the most depressing game I've ever played

[@the_real_shrek5042]

Sure is

[@bulla7317]

Rdr 2 and witcher 3 two of the most depressing games I ever played it's so fucked up the amount of things that happens

[@CraigLedden]

Nice little touch from rockstar. Was so devastated when Arthur dies! Especially the part where he comforts his dying horse. Got me right in the feels! When I’ve fully completed it I’m going to restart it and stay as Arthur on a separate save file. I prefer Arthur to John.

[@bleachboi7097]

I agree

[@somepersonmcsomebody7501]

In rdr nobody wanted to play as jack because they loved John. In rdr2, nobody wants to play as John because they love Arthur.

[@tophershepetvlogs9120]

Same but I think they could have done better like you can save arthur or you can swap characters but arthur would be a ghost

[@joshhencik1849]

@@somepersonmcsomebody7501 To be fair, at least in RDR2 I know that John turns into a good character (in RDR1). Jack is always just an annoying brat.

[@somepersonmcsomebody7501]

Yeah, I guess you're right.

[@nigel387]

Was Gav hiding in any of these places?

[@a13kfr]

Nigel NIGEL QUIT ASKING PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF GOD I HAVEN’T FOUND GAVIN HES IN SCOTLAND, OK... quit asking I’m not going to help you.

[@JJ-ok8ju]

😂😂

[@fristnamelastname5549]

Maybe, Gavin kidnapped the Duchess of Luxembourg? That, explains why "Gavin" (If that was his true name) can't be found.

[@micheledeleo2616]

Nigel bothers me in rdr2

[@enclavef]

Maybe Gavin is in Tahiti

[@crisis3120]

Man that is so depressing that at the first camp you can hear how happy everyone was upon Sean’s return and then seeing how everything turned out it’s just sad man.

[@straightfuckingwater389]

Technically it's the second camp not first

[@glennfunderburk7420]

If you stay at the saloon all you hear is LENNY MY BOAH

[@TheCaz23]

Lennnnmmm....

[@CJ2808]

Lemmy??

[@lisawilliams3555]

Ynnel?

[@fx6794]

@@lisawilliams3555 m

[@lavarockgaming12]

*dramaticly goes on to a mountain and screams where are ya Ynnel?! While the house building theme plays)

[@connermetz9148]

"I swear to God, he talked the whole way and never said a damn thing." - Charles Smith

[@xwmcu2700]

???

[@adamtemplo99]

Mr Boss Trelawny

[@JABoyle3875]

Trelawny, or the guy who makes these videos 2-3x longer than they need to be with all the extra clips and yapping?

[@clarawonders4812]

but for real that’s the best line ever

[@Ap209nda]

@@xwmcu2700 it’s because mrbossftw talks a lot but never actually says anything significant,much like trelawny

[@yizzirman]

My man ..... they ain't ghosts, they're memories. How's he gonna hear his own ghost voice??

[@ejosjek52.87]

Tru

[@respiratoryfailure3780]

Beating the game made me so depressed. All that money I invested at the camp foe upgrades ;-;

[@landonmoser34]

Well it’s a good thing you get 20k I’m the end

[@landonmoser34]

In the end

[@ikubarus.6966]

After the epilogue 2, john will get 20k.

[@milesinwyatteandcora]

Kinda felt disappointed with the camp mechanic I sorta wished there was some sort of repercussion if you dont support your camp

[@zahiraattou6821]

Some Random Asian Dude i donated $1000

[@1upSniper]

So many people don't even play the story mode and hop straight online. It makes me not want to live anymore.

[@Jodrac]

Red Dead online's dead dude

[@1upSniper]

@@Jodrac yup. I hit lvl 80 something, got my black Arabian, then Apex Legends came out. Lol

[@fx6794]

Yeah right, this is Not gta 5 where the online Mode is better than the Story Mode IT is goddam rdr2 where you can so so much Things im Story but in online too I personally THINK Story is better cuz u can Do Stranger Missions and the Story is long I DONT KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT ONLINE BECAUSE IVE ONLY PLAYED IT ONCE, SO DONT GET MAD IF I GOT SOMETHING WRONG

[@TheKman1014]

iTZ_ZuFaX. You're not missing anything. The online sucks besides the 5 or 6 missions.

[@bigchungus2121]

I have literally never seen a single person skip it to play the online lmao. The online sucked

[@FrehleyFan3988]

Brings tears to my eyes, because it makes you feel like you were actually there after completing the game

[@D-A-1776]

This game was legitimately so depressing

[@shadowlilman]

3:50 5:45 8:10 9:30 you’re welcome

[@GiselleSaintClaire]

Thank you!

[@diismal9666]

You’re*

[@hidayahtripusayanti8551]

A legend

[@shadowlilman]

Kkhalifa still learning English, your language has to many redundant rules and words that sound the same but mean something different but thanks anyways for the spell check

[@diismal9666]

Godric I understand. I have the same problem while learning another language. Just for future reference, “you’re” means “you are” & “your” is showing owner ship (ex: YOUR comment/YOU’RE still learning).

[@postmcglone7106]

R.I.P. Lenny. You will be missed

[@lennysummers2376]

I ain't dead no more! I aint.

[@Pretzel-_]

Lenny! You’re alive!

[@lennysummers2376]

@@Pretzel-_ Yes I am alive

[@roddydicch]

He was my favorite

[@jillcabezut6176]

I miss sean he was cool until chapter 3 until the Rhodes disaster

[@loganentertainment1814]

9:33, That whistle made me sad, because I'm pretty sure its Arthur whistling. Arthur Morgan was my favorite character. RDR 2 was the only game that made me cry, because it was such a great story. I have no clue to what Rockstar will do next, but I hope some day, they'll make another Red Dead game that comes after RDR 1. This game has been one big adventurous, gun slinging, and emotional ride that I enjoyed. I 100% recommend that anyone who hasn't played this game should buy it. P.s. Anyone in 2021 or any other future timeline???

[@ValorantGuardian]

ehh? after 1914 the world changes, mostly into more civilizations, ww1 and ww2 happens, shit kinda gets boring, though, personally i think having the world go back even farther into like, well idk, dutches past, or hoseas past, but thats just my personal opinion :D

[@andyeverett93]

2022, just finished both games and restarted rdr2. Such an incredible story. I’d love to see another prequel. Maybe something that leads up to the whole blackwater mess. Would also love to not have my heart broken a third time

[@lilbeanbop]

Just finished the game, playing the epilogue. Heartbroken lol

[@Joey-js3og]

I’m pretty sure rdr3 is being worked on and if so I think you’ll play as Arthur again?

[@geffphishnutz7140]

mer-fee brewd* is how its pronounced

[@kalvinmcbride1048]

Hearing Arthur’s voice broke me

[@cillianswan]

fr

[@imperialspy8202]

Same

[@Liamiscool-xw8ei]

honestly, they should make a undead nightmare rdr2

[@igotbaited4047]

All I heard was........... L U M B A G O.

[@yalib0988]

LuMbAgO

[@vector5188]

1umb4g0

[@noogie1]

Gavin!

[@rtuel7803]

What I heard was...... L O O K O U T M A R S T O N

[@was880]

Lumbuwugo

[@achmatomar6415]

After finishing the game, I went back to the first camp site and I heard Arthur's voice saying Just do one thing or the other, "Don't try to be Two people at Once..." This really hit me hard in the feels!

[@MoonBeamsAndDreams]

I walked into a barn and I heard Arthur's voice say, "I never thought I'd be happy to see you John Marston" from when John saved him from being shot on a mission... you didn't cover that one... I'll have to play and get the exact location of the barn.

[@Chaotic_Sumi]

Oracle Whisper which mission if I may ask ? (I don’t remember this for some reason)😅

[@Kibaheart]

You might be thinking of the flashback of stuff that happened at Colter. The first flashback quote i ever heard while exploring these was there when walking by the barn and other broken houses/sheds. You hear John say “I never thought I’d be happy to see you, Arthur Morgan.” From when he saved him from the wolves. I heard a second quote come from that place from a female but it was too faint for me to make out

[@Atriox2004]

Hiding in a barn after a coach robbery gone wrong? That in fact, has Uncle’s name written all over it. It was Arthur, Charles, Uncle, and Bill who hid in the burning barn.

[@unfunnycrow7683]

it hurts me when he thinks its ghosts

[@waynotv504]

It's not necessarily ghosts that he's hearing but it's more like his memories whenever you reach an old gang hide out it's like he's jus going down memory lane. Rockstar dug deep with the symbolism in the game.

[@The_Almighty.]

I swear going back to these campsites again feel like Memorial sites for me it's so depressing Rockstar did a great job for us to connect with the players and have emotions for them

[@kobekeller1999]

It must be different every time because when I went to beaver hollow ( it worked right away for me in the cave) Arthur said “you gotta run and don’t look back”

[@nicholasrangel7099]

When you were at horseshoe overlook, that was Sean singing “Rye Whiskey” along with Uncle at Shady Belle, you could hear Abigail thanking Arthur and Dutch when jack came back

[@bri-fl1wf]

Nicholas Rangel i miss that irish bastard so much 🥺

[@kaylavice9714]

Did you really play through the entire game and can’t pronounce anything?

[@hyrum5038]

Jyn Erso pronouncing things wrong makes people comment, the more comments, the more views, the more views, the more $$$.

[@hyrum5038]

probably not what he’s doing but it works!

[@tempo550]

Jyn erso you need to shut up

[@AAA-uc8mj]

Orrustu I think you need to watch the video to comment. More comments doesn’t equal more views

[@albinoman4248]

Jyn Erso lol ikr

[@The.Reilly]

You didn't go to Colter. Maximum disrespect.

[@shineandcriss]

Sid Reilly plus he said “all the sudden”

[@alabamabro1162]

But he did go to colter

[@ksming_]

He still remembers Arthur... I’ve always been wondering since I completed rdr2 just not the epilogue Edit: yet

[@kalvynhavenhill3366]

"Hey guys boss ftw im here ready to waste your time".

[@koolisid1707]

I know he’s terrible but like 45000 people have said this and it gets annoying

[@rocknroll_jezus9233]

@@koolisid1707 you know what's more annoying?

[@rocknroll_jezus9233]

@@koolisid1707 his time wasting

[@savannahhameleers7206]

Have some faith son

[@bradwise7856]

kalvyn havenhill sorry your lil bitchy self thinks this is a waste of your time maybe you should of just watched something else

[@michaelgutierrez8404]

If you listen really closely you can hear someone saying...I HAVE A PLAN!!

[@mopeylemming7669]

and something about lumbago

[@grandwizard9062]

T A H I T I

[@CultOfPersonality091]

OUT OF THE DAMM WAY

[@lavish263team5]

And if you listen closely you can hear millions of little voices cursing micah

[@fx6794]

We just need money, one more, decent take.

[@kendrickhernandez9695]

It broke my heart when i went to shady belle i heard a voice... Arthur's voice R.I.P Arthur Morgan😭😭 Edit: i didnt watch this until now 5/20/19

[@wds2436]

Shld hv watched a month prior🤣

[@ketchr4295]

John's memories not ghosts, duh. I suppose you think time actually slows down during deadeye too as opposed to it being a representation of the character's skill for the player.

[@thatoneguy7290]

ketchr42 ikr but he’s only saying that to get views and likes. He’s trying to hide that he’s begging for views

[@donnielocklear6318]

ketchr42 - You don't have to be a douch about it and leave a smart-ass comment, he is just showing us something that he discovered and thought it would be cool to show us. Chump!!!

[@SpinningTurtle66]

You’re the only person I’ve ever known who has mentioned this, so you must be speaking from experience

[@Eazydatdude91]

What do you expect from a guy who pronounces "Lakay" as "Lacky"? lol

[@Bailers426]

ketchr42 but time does slow down... to us... if we were in the game it could be considered skill. Since you want to be a technical smartass.

[@completelydrainingyou]

If you'll notice, specifically all the memory audio is all what John Marston cannonically would have been able to hear and remeber.. so it is indeed him just reminiscing over what he remembers from the camps.

[@anirudhnpuvvada5535]

It isn’t spooky, it’s nice, brought tears to my eyes, and it isn’t ghost voices it’s John remembering conversations with old members

[@theskyress]

This game is perfect. Beatiful history, amazing details, a lot to explore... This game should be the game of the year

[@adamc3390]

Kevin_Vita3 when a game makes you genuinely feel for characters that don’t exist definitely makes It a good game

[@Fishlicker2695]

And peek comedy

[@crazyadrian4793]

It should have been game of the year not sekiro

[@dakshvora5773]

Crazy Adrian this game was released in 2018 while sekiro won the 2019 goty. God of War beat this game to win the goty

[@ThatPaleMexican]

@@dakshvora5773 gow was a good game, ya cant lie. If you think otherwise, its probably just not your taste in video games. Gow is my taste and I enjoyed every second of it

[@bleedzorange1490]

THIS VIDEO JUST NEEDS A BIT MORE MONEY AND SOME GOD DAMN FAITH

[@luke_of_the_galvan255]

Josh Williams ok Dutch

[@breadskate138]

I got a plan

[@MS-hb3ol]

This is the last one, my son

[@Egg-df6pl]

Then can we go to Tahiti 🤩

[@sebastianmaregatti]

Dutch I insist we don’t need that no more

[@Pumpydog98]

Am I the only one who noticed it’s not called “pleasants point” I thought it was called Clements point

[@mbashasyed]

It is Clemen's Point. He didn't notice it properly. I've heard npcs say it in the game too.

[@Kae.Woiderski]

Clemens point

[@kcroz1104]

I’ve already done this. It makes you feel nostalgic

[@kcroz1104]

FIREWATER 1960 No, I just played the game too fast. 2nd time through I took my time and did the side missions, that’s when it felt nostalgic. That’s why I recommend taking your time in games like this. Playing it just to get to the end can ruin the game for you.

[@shrimp5499]

It made me so sad because I was so attached to Arthur in the end. When I was at one old hideout, wanting to feel a bit nostalgic, this happened and it wrecked me so hard I just quit the game and paced around the house aimlessly.

[@kcroz1104]

@@shrimp5499 Same, this game has a way with making you feel very attached to every one of the characters. Easily one of the best games I've ever played.

[@gallupswon]

Sir Chank I was pretty sad when Arthur died as well. I feel he was really a good person, just caught up with the wrong crowd. When the horse died though, that was it.

[@kcroz1104]

@@gallupswon Yep, had the same horse the whole game and never changed horses. That was one of the saddest parts of any video game I've ever played.

[@shazrcsqueen]

Bruh it’s just Johns memories from when everyone was alive 🤦🏽‍♀️

[@collinsims2413]

@@Mr_Maskins John doesnt die in the first part of the game, even if Dutch would have us believe otherwise.

[@blackevilunicorn9771]

All I heard was: "wE nEed MoRE moNeH!!!"

[@whereuwannabe7796]

Clemens Point not Pleasance Point lol. And they're memories not ghosts.

[@fenil7319]

where u wanna be exactly even clemens point was written on the map

[@matthewdulay175]

I don't the think this dude has play the game.

[@katiesmith98]

& then he says “lakIE” instead of laKAY.. like have you played the game tho 🤔

[@dylantraynor776]

I wish i took advantage of being able to play the story ,, like i have completed the game now and just wish there was another 4 chapters,,, anyone feel the same ?

[@ahmedabdelaziz2244]

Dylan Traynor yeah same

[@ikamj_kaze]

I wish RDD 1 has the same graphic and I will just continue the journey. :(

[@rolandpolak75]

Same

[@minusfriends7835]

hell nah, this shit was long as hell

[@landonmoser34]

98.Vlone true, but it was fun

[@errorglitch8674]

“Help me help me I’m being kidnapped” doesn’t even turn to look

[@thegrinch304]

Pearson works at the general store in Rhodes.

[@Crow-nc1oo]

Tilly you can find in Saint Denis and Mary Beth can be found in Valentine at the train station.

[@zackkennedy1056]

Rains Fall you can find him at the train station in Annesburg.

[@lilya6402]

Yeah I nearly robbed him by accident

[@koolisid1707]

Many people know, tho thanks to the people who replied on this comment

[@thegrinch304]

@@koolisid1707 🤔 No channel content.

[@spiezzynl720]

Why Did I saved micah from strawberry. He was a racist he did mean to lenny and javier and killed people like arthur

[@moazahmed5443]

the shittest mission ever

[@KurtisWest]

Because it was what the mission asked you to do? Well you didn’t have to save him you just would progress

[@ontologicallysteve7765]

Because you completed the mission.

[@Itscallum-cw9vx]

spijkie en Chloe yup I agree why did I save the rat

[@jacqulineball2284]

The second time around I only did it for my other holster (and cos you have to anyway) But i made sure to take some nice photos of him in the celll first. Ha ha ha!

[@davidc.]

I'm on chapter 6 and the first camp feels so long ago. Same with the second one. Feels like a decade I was trying to get up a mountain and my level 4 bonded horse (Roosevelt was his name) falls killing me and him. Brave soul he was. I was fighting bountyhuntets and he ran randomly and ran over 2 of them.

[@jfoley1987]

6:23 is the best part of this video

[@darkman965]

😂😂

[@deepriyal]

10:59 is more like it

[@landonmoser34]

I’ve always hated that music I kept playing from my tent

[@landonmoser34]

Little Delicious be quiet John!

[@ibbyquayle0235]

Then why the hell did you play it to annoy everyone? You do that already when you say hAve SoMe FaItH

[@bootybouncinblood3390]

Dutch Van der Linde what’s your goddamn plan now?

[@ibbyquayle0235]

@@bootybouncinblood3390 he doesn't have one and if he does its not a good one and will get everyone killed

[@michaelgranja7260]

Dutch how about you put in some money

[@kaylawilcox2491]

When I heard Arthur’s voice I was so sad😑😭

[@reasonfranken8672]

Btw the lemonye raiders take shades belle back the moment your gang leaves

[@the_unleashed88]

I miss having a camp 😢

[@M3RKMAFlA]

But now you have a house 😁 let's take that negative and turn it to a positive

[@officialdream7823]

The_Unleashed I miss Arthur

[@M3RKMAFlA]

@@officialdream7823 but atleast you still have john 😁

[@Splashmaster97]

Nah, I like Arthur more

[@lucaseneroth2741]

I took my horse too the first camp in the mountains and when I Walked in too one off the house and I heard a voice and it was johns voice saying “I never thought I was gonna say this but good too see you Arthur Morgan” damn bro after that a got so depressed rip arthur Morgan and the next red dead redemption 3 is coming out 2025-2026

[@freshsteppa14]

who tf r u the next sernandoe

[@aghostfromyourtown]

replying to you after 4 years guess rdr iii will come out in 2031

[@papalifts7970]

At night at shady bell u can here athur scream Dutch

[@budget_b3758]

Arthur*

[@connorhagen355]

Belle*

[@peterkovacs7943]

hear*

[@hamzze211]

You*

[@burnttoast1354]

Shady*

[@danilin5637]

I’m going to cry, I miss Arthur sooo much.

[@LazerBeam69]

Man i went there just to see the old camp places and suddenly i heard voices and i FREAKED OUT XD until i realized they were the gang's voices, this is actually cool and sad at the same time

[@miaoakward7638]

3:53 DEER!!!! Coincidence I think not

[@jakailyn6862]

Mia Oakward I think so

[@heatherkrause8724]

Mia Oakward Exactly!! I am playing right now and walked right into "Horseshoe overlook" and the deer was there.

[@stevennieves6590]

Isn't it an Elk?

[@animebro14]

That's actually sad considering what happened to them

[@cottony4dr]

Wasteland nomad you talking about tuberculosis or Micah killing him?

[@animebro14]

@@cottony4dr both. That and the gang fell apart

[@cottony4dr]

Wasteland nomad oh ok

[@animebro14]

@@cottony4dr i blame staruss for Arthur's TB

[@areasonableguy3]

@@animebro14 He didn't force Arthur to beat that poor bastard. 😂. You must blame other people for your problems as well.

[@jedimindtrick75]

I love Arthur. But when I hear his voice I keep waiting for him to go all Sling Blade and start asking for french fried tators and mustard.

[@beast_boy97]

8:40 I didn't think it was possible to butcher the word "Murfree Brood" that bad, but I stand corrected!

[@syke_clan6356]

Beast Boy muff-ree brud

[@ItZViPeR12]

Arthurrr 😭😭😭😭😭 best Charecter Best Voice I miss Him 😩😭

[@nightmarez7772]

My favourite camp is at the clesent point..after the valentine camp..near to lake..i can fishing and give pearson..no need to go hunt

[@poppaw0415]

He's remembering the conversations they had

[@loganflorea3165]

8:25 was a random event that happened on the front porch. Arthur could listen to John and Abigail decided to move in together.

[@lisajames2683]

Those aren't weird creepy voices, we're literally hearing John's memories of things from each camp.

[@bitzthe8bit668]

All I got from horseshoe overlook is Arthur saying "-he'd probably run off again!"

[@jaydenwhite4166]

You know wouldn't it have been magic if once you finished Arthur's story and the epilogue, the game continues along the timeline into the events of red dead 1 and you can replay the events of rdr in a remastered environment. That would literally make this the best game of all time

[@lizziescott5769]

I hope red dead 3 is about Arthur growing up and meeting Dutch and falling in love with Mary and seeing his how his dad died and his relationship with his mother and his kid and ‘girlfriend’

[@capo8509]

Lizzie Scott and you call the shots and plan with Hosea and Dutch

[@lsh7349]

Awwww.. I didn’t think the voices were creepy. It’s kinda sad, he’s reminiscing about events that happened at each of those locations. Makes me tear up again hearing Arthur’s voice. 😭 That’s pretty amazing that Rockstar added that stuff though, I love the detail they put into this sort of stuff.

[@apallok54]

Same

[@galwayj6991]

"Pleasance Point?" "Mufree Blood?" SERIOUSLY???

[@xwmcu2700]

Well it may be hard to read them depends on its size

[@nickolauselliott8265]

Also he says lackee when it’s lakay

[@edwinjustinamahanii1783]

Galway J Yeah IKR? I think the guy skips a lot of cutscenes or pays less attention to details to get all those names wrong. Or maybe he just never played the game and just watched some videos of other people playing the game then decided to make a video of his own even claiming the voices to be "ghosts" instead of John's memories.

[@xwmcu2700]

@@edwinjustinamahanii1783 or that. Yes

[@zackw.9793]

LOLL he must not have played much

[@Br3adless]

It isn’t spooky, it’s just really sad 😭 I miss em, Ol’ Hosea, Lenny, Sean, Arthur… 😢

[@BaguetteBob]

I think that deer that ran away when you came was authors spirit animal, and if you had low honor it would be the coyote

[@aaliyaheverage1294]

Lower honor a wolf higher honor a eagle

[@iloveandhatelifeatthesamet1453]

Rip arthur u will be missed

[@stephenieburkett4027]

That was amazing from the pass hearing the camp voices from 8 years ago, We miss you Arthur Morgan 😢😭

[@wtfcheesenips2098]

“Maybe it’s his memories from the camps.” .... yeah... MAYBE... just... MAYBE...

[@ryeregular]

It is!

[@xxdcwolfxx836]

What happens when Mrbossftw quits youtube?? WORLD PEACEE

[@nicegarry7421]

XxDcWolfxX As Lenny says in chapter 1, “there’ll be a party.”

[@chriswright9720]

Probably dutchs plan

[@redlinemando]

@XxDcWolfxX For The Win...……..lol…........Absolutely, positively, assuredly, undoubtedly, & definitely................................... nothing. The world will keep on turning till the Lord comes back & some other yuppie will take his place.

[@landonmoser34]

Chris Wright what’s so bad about my plan

[@bandithimself6841]

XxDcWolfxX African hunger solved

[@natoshy7882]

He let the girl get kidnapped 🤦🏿‍♂️💯😭😂💯

[@FDC42585]

She wasn't kidnapped, she got arrested

[@brianmay5452]

Been there done that your a bit behind with your content many youtubers have already covered this and you can’t pronounce many of the names right it’s frustrating *Edit: I actually forgot my account name was Arthur Morgan I have 2 accounts and thought I was using my other one then I saw all the comments and I was pissing myself obviously this comment wasn’t when I was being Arthur*

[@Memento_Mori_504]

Have some goddamn faith Arthur

[@MrIKILLYOU212]

@Colm O’Driscoll God damn O'Driscoll

[@jeffoliver2652]

Who else read that in his voice

[@Lenny-nh3xi]

AUTHUR I MISS YOU.

[@ahmedabdelaziz2244]

😂 he said lackey instead of lakay

[@thomasrice8466]

All I heard was, THERES ANOTHER SETTLEMENT THAT NEEDS YOUR HELP, I’LL MARK IT ON YOUR MAP

[@jjs12345]

Fallout 4? Rdr2? Oh yeah.

[@fastcarzrc4349]

Dont think its ghost voices I think its John's memories returning to the camps brings back the memories

[@wibisonowibi6392]

Even though you already beat the game WHERE IS GAVIN?

[@chilly6470]

I just started RDR1 and I'm finding it hard to adjust to the graphics and even worse clunkiness....

[@fristnamelastname5549]

They should remaster RDR1, with the updated graphics, and storyline from RDR2.

[@stephenmiles8424]

the attention to detail in this game is incredible

[@jayo5376]

I love this game so much that I just cant play it cause I dont want Arthur to die lol

[@cuahutemocramirez7675]

Bro! That was me!!

[@blakebutlin657]

Same, I just can't play through again because of that

[@jasonclark9963]

I'm glad the game let you play as John

[@generalseal6948]

Wraith Arthur when uncle cant even pick up a hammer because of his lumbago and Arthur had TB and was coughing his lungs out and constantly fighting (Y) to shame

[@felixherland]

Those memories just makes me cry...

[@lilchromo225]

Its his memories

[@rlafount]

Mr Boss, I recently started playing this game. I know I’m way behind the curve but I just love your videos they’re amazing. I’m on my third play through of the game and I feel such a strong attachment to Arthur it’s getting harder to play it. Anyhow I hope all is well with you not sure if I wanna play grand theft auto but this game is one of the best of all time for me cheers mate

[@rpfcreates4476]

“Stick with me” .... We always will. All of us.

[@Robert5hw]

This game was amazing. I only just started Epilogue II and I keep getting hit with emotions. Getting the "Paying Respects" trophy by visiting the 9 graves was painful. The first time I took John to a fence and saw he had Mary's ring from Arthur just hurt. Maybe I'm just getting hit by seasonal depression, maybe not. But this game's story is just so good.

[@Dzqnn]

These are the voices from the past that John hears in his head, I think! He's feeling nostalgic and he starts reminiscing.