What happens next after judge blocks Trump order to cancel birthright citizenship

[@deebee4575]

There's nobody in the country who thought this would not be a fight that takes years in courts. Hopefully, the Supreme Court gets a hold of it and set it straight.

[@CM-bj8hr]

I hope it never gets to them, supreme court has never been more corrupted and has quite a few trump appointees.

[@debbieyates29]

The Supreme Court? Are you kidding me? Don't trust them.

[@sreed7637]

Let’s hope they use common sense & recognize what it was actually made for!

[@cehannan333]

If he gets his way, which he probably will since the Supreme Court is in his pocket, what happens to the kids born here from non citizens whose country won't recognize the the childs birthright either? I can see the reverse of this happening too, where children born of US citizens in foreign countries might not recognize the birthright of these children either. For instance, we had thousands of children born of US servicemen in foreign countries which our country does not recognize as US citizens - what if these countries demand that these individuals be given legal status in our country under the same reasoning. Essentially, Trump is opening the door to millions of people who may not be legal in any country. No one seems to think these things out - but with Trump, essentially, it is how much cruelty can you inflict on people who can't possibly fight back, rather than remain with the status quo which has been recognized since the inception of the 14th Amendment.

[@XRocket2009]

@@cehannan333 In middle eastern muslim countries there's no such thing like birthright citizenship. Any comment on that? Nobody wants to talk about that. Everybody gets angry when a western developed country do something like this but never when a south asian or middle eastern country do it. Why? Because everybody wants to move to those western countries and settle there. f**king double standards.

[@DONNYKeener]

Trump is expected to mention $Qardun this week and the ICO is already almost sold out

[@IraDelgado-m7t]

$Qardun put in everything and sell after launch

[@HuseyinEda-e6w]

QARDUN is going to go straight up after it goes off the ICO

[@HasimZeynep]

X and $Qardun are going to be merged. Easiest money in my life

[@rlaporte43]

This going to go the highest court. GUARANTEE!

[@JeffSoltis-x2o]

So you want the Supreme Court to rule on the Constitutionality of the Constitution?

[@bovineavenger734]

@@JeffSoltis-x2o Pretty much, the 14th Amendment specifies it doesn't apply for emissaries, ambassadors or foreign nationals who aren't legally here.

[@deebee4575]

@@JeffSoltis-x2o just like Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court decision that allows this to be abused is flawed.

[@billmoretz8718]

​@@JeffSoltis-x2ohopefully you are using sacarsim since ruling on the constitutionality of items like this is the reason for the SC in the first place. It's not a clear cut as the language of the 14th is targeted to former slaves and their kids.

[@alexrod3459]

Look at you, wanting to attack the constitution. Some would call that high treason

[@LetsTalkW-MizLadyK]

He’s not saying for people that came here legally he’s talking about for the asylum seekers that came across the border without legally having a right to United States land and right, he saying that they should not be allowed to have the babies here when they was a seeking asylum and is not granted yet they still foreigners that’s the difference that is a differencefrom a legal migrant to illegal migrant. He said that if they were illegal migrants, they should not count as anchor babies, and that is true.

[@ellyalovis640]

@LetsTalkW-MizLadyK He has canceled ALL appts, made long ago, for those seeking legal entry. Incredible but TRUE.

[@jackonda598]

BS everyone who born in USA 🇺🇸 all of them legally became citizens of United States 🇺🇸.No other argument

[@waynedavis936]

Actually he should include anyone that doesn't have at least one parent with I describe as "allegiance" the constitution describes as "sovereignty". Using the foreign diplomat standard, no child born here, should be a citizen, unless one parent is already one. The fact is the 14th amendment was meant to allow citizenship to children of slaves after they gained their freedom, and nothing else. The SCOTUS should address this issue. We are the only major or Western country to allow "birthright" citizenship and it not really law.

[@SD-pi9co]

Birth right citizenship is in the constitution. A president can now change the constitution unilaterally?

[@johnbernstein3916]

@@ellyalovis640 So What?

[@rabbithowls71]

He will just appeal until he gets one of his judges, or SCOTUS.

[@josepnguyen1293]

Barbarians always try to harm president trump

[@healingthrulaughter9063]

The temper tantrum is coming

[@christopherskipp1525]

trump's?

[@dandonnelly6498]

@@christopherskipp1525 yup

[@debbieyates29]

Many temper tantrums have already occurred. Dem communists have no other playbook. Not a good look for them - that's one of so many reasons they lost the prize.❤❤❤❤

[@jeffdestefano6426]

@@dandonnelly6498 actually no they have already accounted for this and its going to the supreme court he said it would get blocked just before he signed it hes staying a step ahead this time .

[@terrypollard5618]

@@christopherskipp1525 Keep watching.......

[@johng8330]

To play devil's advocate: Illegal = Crime... So, here illegally makes you a criminal.

[@anitadees4223]

(sigh) Trump cultist shouldn't try to be clever. They lack the necessary equipment.

[@mikerew9132]

Illegally crossing the border is a misdemeanor. So, anyone ever charged with disorderly conduct or trespassing should be considered "criminals"?

[@opraahouse]

Regardless, birthright citizenship is enshrined in the Constitution. If you want to sympathize with legal vs. illegal, just know that the Constitution is the supreme law of the land.

[@starobservers9862]

Lol, this needs to be clarified by court. Right of due process silly!

[@gishjalmr5628]

@@opraahouse You really should read the Wong Kim Ark majority decision. It lays out three exceptions to that.

[@kathieovercash8414]

The majority of Americans welcome legal immigration. Those people actually love this country and willingly go through the process of becoming a citizen. These people just being allowed to walk in illegally is a slap in the face to every American footing the bill and even more so to our migrants that came in the honorable way. They waited, so can everyone else.

[@SD-pi9co]

Birth right citizenship is in the constitution. A president can now change the constitution unilaterally?

[@dominique245]

Yes why cause so much distress for yourself knowing the risk that you could be separated

[@SHADOWxSN1PER]

@@dominique245 obviously because the economic opportunity and/or safety from violence is worth the risk. but leave it to the compassionless to not get that....

[@ankhpom9296]

Illegal immigration exists because big business wants it to exist.

[@ELCrisler]

This is a common ply the left has done to create division. When they speak on this issue they just say immigrant or immigration and leave off the illegal part of the descriptive for the issue. I do not know anyone, sure there are a few but they are a huge minority, that has an issue with legal immigration. I love meeting people with different origins and cultures myself, find this a wonderful way to learn new things. However there is a HUGE difference in my eyes between someone that came into the country in a legal matter to settle here and become a US citizen and someone that broke our lays and disrespected our nation, then expecting us to welcome them.

[@gadariyaking0884]

this might be a bit off-topic, but has anyone else noticed how often Vibrations of Manifestation by Alex Lane comes up in video comments? i finally caved and read the book, and wow-it’s worth the buzz. it’s not just some feel-good advice; it actually gives you tools to focus your energy and make things happen. it’s subtle at first, but then you start to see how much of a difference it makes in how you approach your goals

[@knightinaz226]

Doesn’t really matter. If you can’t come in ,you can’t drop your baby here

[@anitadees4223]

Have you ever been pregnant?

[@gishjalmr5628]

@@anitadees4223 Nice live experience logical fallacy.

[@christopheralex6471]

Well they can and they are and they will continue to do so babes 💋

[@ToasterTron2000]

Fortunately, it doesn't matter what you think. A US president cannot modify the US constitution through executive order. Unless you want to openly support a dictatorship, Trump has to go through Congress if he wants to remove Birthright citizenship 👍

[@BarelyAlias]

"Doesn’t really matter." Are you one of those sovereign citizens who disregard the constitution?

[@wandarobinson682]

The judge Temporarily! Blocked it! Key word! Temporarily!

[@TheRibsta420]

yeah until what a NEW CONSTITUTION??

[@markthomas2436]

14 days and Trump's EO is right back in force

[@dominique245]

Cause they know trump will find a way

[@jillwhite1671]

@@TheRibsta420 our founders made rules to allow us to make changes to our constitution. just as congress made the change to create the 14th amendment congress has the right to repeal it if that is required!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@ReginaFreeman-p5r]

​@@dominique245President Donald TRUMP IS Right Tye JUDGE IS UNCONSITUTIONAL By BLOCKING President Executive Order 👉😩✔️👀💯

[@JOHNNIEMasterson]

Donald Trump is going to shill $Qardun so hard now after the inaguration 😂

[@lisazappala4381]

A million I’ll just let into our country without going thru and proper channels, without being vetted, it’s a disgrace. My daughter in living in Germany and she has to jump thru hoops just to stay there and she has to work, she has to have health insurance and she has to learn the language just to keep her visa which she has to pay a a lot of money for. Why is America just letting criminals just walk in and then using our taxes to pay for their homes food and needs. And our homeless citizens, veterans who risked their lives for America live on the street

[@TruthTeller-ps3rq]

democrats my fellow American

[@frankedward6510]

Actually health insurance in Germany is paid for out of taxes. If she makes above a certain amount a year, she can opt for private insurance covered by employer. Also, private insurance by employer is light years cheaper than insurance in United States. It is true that German citizenship is harder to ascertain. Maybe she should opt for the public system if the private one is too expensive. I highly doubt that you are saying half truths because less than fifteen percent of Germans have private insurance. She should probably opt for public rather than private which is less than two hundred per year. And if she makes less than 74k Euro a year, then she is eligible for the public insurance. This is coming from a man who has lived, studied, and worked in Germany. And also my family is German

[@dubistverrueckt]

Vielen Dank für die Wahrheit

[@fastfreddie54]

@@frankedward6510 Oh, Wait, Frank, you can't tell people like Lisa those kind of things! She might find out that you're correct ,and then stroke out over discovering that Trump lied to her again. She is intellectually incapable of understanding facts and therefore prefers to live in her trump-world fantasies forever!

[@chiyerano]

Well, the migrants, whether legal or illegal, I know and have met actually work AND pay taxes, usually in the form of sales taxes, but taxes nonetheless and they don't use ANY of the benefits available to U.S. citizens. All of you calling for the mass deportations better be careful because you may actually have to start doing some REAL work for low pay as you may end up doing the jobs that the very migrants you complain about often do, from construction to field worker, to housekeeping. All this to say that many migrants whether legal or illegal, are not freeloaders and do pay taxes, usually leave the U.S. anyway after they have saved up the money or got the education they came for so cut them some slack.

[@brendachargois8294]

No President should have that right it is very UnAmerican

[@dixiemaebelle]

Why dont they just give them the option to leave the babies or leave with them and they can return when they are self sufficient? Just because the baby is a citizen by birth doesnt mean the parents get a free stay

[@Lee---]

Yes, this would be a sensible compromise

[@anitadees4223]

Because baby stealing is a crime and a moral outrage.

[@ToasterTron2000]

Fortunately, it doesn't matter what you think. A US president cannot modify the US constitution through executive order. Unless you want to openly support a dictatorship, Trump has to go through Congress if he wants to remove Birthright citizenship 👍

[@spectre111]

I think that's already how it works. I've heard about people who left the country as children when their parents were deported but returned to the US to claim their citizenship under the 14th amendment.

[@dixiemaebelle]

@@spectre111 I guess a lot of them stay in the US because they are the parents.. I can see why it's a problem. It's gaming the system.

[@Kobayashi-z6v]

I’m amazed by the CBS channel comment section. The attitude of the country has definitely shifted.

[@dubistverrueckt]

It would seem that half the population has turned into bloodthirsty ghouls

[@gishjalmr5628]

Not really, it's been this way for as long as I remember. With the internet and social media access it's just easier for people to voice their opinions.

[@jillwhite1671]

the attitude has not changed at all it has always been here in the general population. what has changed is we finally managed to throw out a lot of the ultra left politicians pushing for policies that harm America and benefit those that come here illegally. you will likely see a lot more thrown out in the future. most Americans are FED UP with woke BS!

[@JayneNicolas-b4q]

Already invested $10,000 in $Qardun if this goes the same way as the memecoin then I am a millionaire

[@EuniceUtley]

Amazon will start supporting $Qardun this week

[@cagniIrish1776]

Why didn't they stop him from releasing criminals into the efing streets this isn't America anymore !!!!

[@anitadees4223]

Because Trumpublicans in the legislature are as corrupt as Trump.

[@russellkeeling4387]

You must be talking about biden, right.

[@pyromike7237]

​@russellkeeling4387 were you asleep when Trump pardoned 1500 insurrectionists?

[@MrBacchus18]

We are pretty much the only country dumb enough to do birthright citizenship this way. I understand totally why this made sense in the past but not now.

[@chadmccoy8032]

The children did not choose to be born here.

[@astralpork1]

We want anyone working here legally who has children to invest in this country. Otherwise they'll take the money they earned here back to China or India. Anchor babies keep them anchored here and contributing to us instead.

[@anitadees4223]

You are pretty much the only person dumb enough not to know that at least 30 countries honor birthright citizenship.

[@de6212]

Actually there are around 30 other countries that have it

[@MrBacchus18]

@ maybe it works for them but for the USA it gets abused

[@melissastreeter22]

Third World thumbing its nose to game the system.

[@anitadees4223]

Trump is thumbing his nose at working Americans, including his cultists. BOUGHT EGGS LATELY? Trump beaks a promise to his loyal supporters every time he takes a breath.

[@ericalashay0209]

Something doesn’t feel right.

[@budwhite9591]

No more anchor babies

[@manwelmcclendon258]

Faaaacts

[@C2001-l6i]

Your are delusional keep dreaming

[@allencrider]

No more Constitution

[@C2001-l6i]

All they doing is wasting time and money nothing is going to be change

[@Dravianpn02]

​@allencrider nah we need the constitution.

[@sunsetpalms1923]

"Show me your papers!" Where have we heard that before?

[@corymaxwell709]

Hmmmm during WWII maybe 🤔

[@lindalarson1948]

Let's see, the last time I applied for a job, whenever I get pulled over for a traffic violation, any time I want to buy wine...oh yes, and every single time I have wanted to enter a foreign country. Just to name a few.

[@summerobannon7784]

Americans constitutional right do not apply yo illegal immigrants. Trump was trying to get children sent back with their parents... I guess yall just want more kids in the foster system. Never to see their parents again.

[@anitadees4223]

@@lindalarson1948 But never when you were obeying the law, not seeking controlled substances, or seeking the trust of others with their property or safety in your home country. Right? Trump cultists think everyone else is stupid enough to fall for their dumb Trump tricks.

[@BiteTheCurbNow]

​@@lindalarson1948 YAAAY LINDA!!!!💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

[@billstevenson1623]

Take it to the SCOTUS and make sure, no anchor babies allowed.

[@Baddscorpio]

O STEFU hawnk

[@Nailbunny1000]

Good luck. The only way to override a constitutional amendment is to pass another amendment. The Jurisdiction part refers to, and is strongly reinforced by precedent and case law. I imagine you're not intelligent enough to know this, but to pass an amendment, it'll need 2/3rd majority in both the house and Senate and even then, 75% of states need to ratify it before it becomes official. I don't think that'll happen. Die mad about it.

[@kanedakrsa]

Guess that means melania's family is out the door too eh?

[@AbsFabbs]

You can’t change the constitution with a pen stroke. No matter how much you are afraid of people better than you coming in and making you have to actually have some sort of talent or skill will change that.

[@Nailbunny1000]

@@kanedakrsa hopefully. That means Barron has to go too

[@donnariley1250]

We should have a say after all we voted for this!!!!!!!!

[@melrhodes7086]

You may have voted for this...I DID NOT! 💙

[@jjbud3124]

Leviticus 19:33-34 (NIV): “When a foreigner resides among you in your land, do not mistreat them. The foreigner residing among you must be treated as your native-born. Love them as yourself, for you were foreigners in Egypt. I am the Lord your God.” Exodus 22:21 (NIV): “Do not mistreat or oppress a foreigner, for you were foreigners in Egypt.” Deuteronomy 10:18-19 (NIV): “He defends the cause of the fatherless and the widow, and loves the foreigner residing among you, giving them food and clothing. And you are to love those who are foreigners, for you yourselves were foreigners in Egypt.” Matthew 25:35 (NIV): “For I was hungry and you gave me something to eat, I was thirsty and you gave me something to drink, I was a stranger and you invited me in.”

[@RodneySlinger]

"Collateral arrests" That's a good thing.

[@ankhpom9296]

@rodneyslinger: I don’t think you know what you are talking about.

[@rudbeckia885]

This is more about our constitution. There are proper channels to create amendment s . This begins at congress. No president has the power to circumnavigate the constitution.

[@suzakukururugi6613]

Just report facts, I don’t want to hear your ignorant opinions

[@BarelyAlias]

Can you tell us about the facts? I mean, facts that I don't know of course.

[@georgepoitras3502]

Appeal all the way. They have been lying about this forever.

[@anitadees4223]

No, they read. You don't.

[@gishjalmr5628]

@@anitadees4223 I read the Wong Kim Ark majority decision, clearly you have not.

[@ToasterTron2000]

Fortunately, it doesn't matter what you think. A US president cannot modify the US constitution through executive order. Unless you want to openly support a dictatorship, Trump has to go through Congress if he wants to remove Birthright citizenship 👍

[@BarelyAlias]

@@anitadees4223 they who? Read what? Last I read the Constitution, it clearly showed Trump's idea to be unconstitutional.

[@driverhighway8311]

under paid, no health care insurance so of course the business owner is going to be upset.... cost them money to hire legals

[@gavinhudson4085]

This is something that should have past years ago

[@jimfoot-p7g]

Trump knew the EO would be challenged in the courts which is exactly why he did it on day one. Get the process started and eventually lands in the Supreme Court. Even though the court is conservative now. It's hard to say if they will uphold the order or not. The truth is it tow's the line of the constitution even though anyone who knows their history know that how it is used today was not the purpose of it when they wrote it into the constitution. Time to fix it, and Trump put that in motion.

[@austinbutler1291]

It goes to the Supreme court just like in the past. Good thing the court is stacked

[@primevaltimes]

It's never a good thing for the court to be stacked, even if it is in your favor, because it erodes the system of checks and balances. The Supreme Court's job is to interpret the law to the best of its ability, not to give Trump whatever he wants.

[@dandonnelly6498]

The SC will also shut this down. Guaranteed!

[@lindalarson1948]

The court is not "stacked." It just contains thoughtful men and women instead of raving left wing activists for a change.

[@thezu9250]

@@lindalarson1948 just so you know, it’s supposed to be unbiased. So the fact that you can register a right leaning biased, tells you that it’s in a corrupt place.

[@primevaltimes]

@ The justices Trump picked are more right leaning than the Democrats are left leaning. That seems pretty stacked to me, plus one of them was likely a sex offender.

[@CB-y8f]

I get that there needs to be checks and balances, but the fact that an unelected federal judge can unilaterally overrule the President of the United States bothers me somewhat.

[@thezu9250]

So you’d rather the president have the power of a full-blown dictator? One that can rewrite the entire constitution? That’s absurd and quite frankly scary. You would be up in arms if Biden had even thought of saying something like this let alone actually trying to change the constitution. Just so you know, he was appointed by Reagan.

[@astralpork1]

That a president can just overrule the constitution should bother you even more.

[@CB-y8f]

@@astralpork1 Fair point. I'm not saying a president should be unchecked or can't be challenged. It just seems like, until finally settled, the benefit of the doubt should go to the guy who just won both the popular and electoral votes rather than the person nobody has ever heard of.

[@Kobayashi-z6v]

@@astralpork1But he can’t, especially since the Constitution doesn’t say what you think it does.

[@ankhpom9296]

@cb-y: apparently you know nothing about the legal system. The judge is going by the law and the Constitution. He does not care what king Trump is trying to do.

[@eric1492]

Thank you Ronald Reagan appointed judge..

[@spectre111]

Shows how far the GOP has come over the last 40 years.

[@Melrose51653]

You have to amend the Constitution. Talk about that. It's impossible.

[@kimmomac4082]

The 14th amendment was mentioned for legal slaves after civil war not illegal aliens sneaking into the country

[@brianpowers3742]

He's not gonna try to 'amend the Constitution' He's gonna try to abolish most of it. Hell, he might even try the 2nd amendment if the 14th goes down. Can't have armed citizens while you are a dictator...

[@JustusForrester]

Nah, it just needs to be applied correctly. The guy who literally wrote the 14th amendment dunked on this modern interpretation of the 14th amendment. It was never to be used to give aliens a pathway to being US citizens through their children. Go research, and tell me what you find.

[@ELCrisler]

Actually you don't. This is not about changing the Constitution but looking at the wording of the clause and providing clear definitions.

[@de6212]

@@ELCrisler All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

[@screegeg]

Next Trump will repeal the First Amendment because he doesn't like being criticised.

[@hyperactive216]

KZbin, I’ve ss alll of my posts. You are going down also.

[@lasmith5673]

CBS News just isn't what it used to be. 🤨

[@RealTalkWithRickyPaquiot]

*Just what isn't?* *It's the same CBS News with the same original reporting. Sure, logos and graphics have changed over the years, but it's still the same.*

[@jillwhite1671]

CBS has become a propagandist for the left wing political party. they no longer care about facts only ratings. unfortunately most news media is the same and many people would be shocked to know that most of them are owned by the same corporation. we need a massive change in our media policies and no company should be allowed to own more than a single news media outlet.

[@Forge17]

So this ceases birthright citizenship given to children of illegal immigrants? This seems like a constructive thing to do, regardless of it being Trump. I don’t think any other country recognizes this type of citizenship.

[@billyhargrove1405]

Other countries do it, you’re just uneducated

[@TaskeenUddin-s6r]

Why aren't Trump closing all BPO's KPO's and all other companies in India as Americans need employment more than Indians...

[@ramanavennala7513]

If any Birth happens in US ,Who will issue Birth certificate to that child. Birth place is great for everyone. Other than in America they may not get Birth certificates. Place Of Birth is most essential to everything in life.

[@curiouscat544]

If the parents are venezuelans then venuezuela gives the citizenship. Now what if the father is venezuelan and the mother is mexican? Interesting..

[@jackonda598]

Keep fighting this evil 👿 keep speaking up the truth.Don’t afraid!

[@ankhpom9296]

@jackonda598: Bishop Budde is the only one who has the balls to stand up to Trump.

[@stop_lying_to_me]

U.S. presidents take an oath to preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States. Birthright citizenship is Constitutional law affirmed in the 14th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution in 1868, ensuring citizenship to all persons born in the U.S. It is law in 32 nations throughout the Western Hemisphere.

[@suzakukururugi6613]

In this case it is being improperly implemented by not considering intention of the law

[@suzakukururugi6613]

In this case it is being improperly implemented by not considering intention of the law

[@wendyfroeming4669]

"This amendment which I have offered is simply declaratory of what I regard as the law of the land already, that every person born within the limits of the United States, and subject to their jurisdiction, is by virtue of natural law and national law a citizen of the United States. This will not, of course, include persons born in the United States who are foreigners, aliens, who belong to the families of ambassadors or foreign ministers accredited to the Government of the United States, but will include every other class of persons. It settles the great question of citizenship and removes all doubt as to what persons are or are not citizens of the United States. This has long been a great desideratum in the jurisprudence and legislation of this country." This quote comes from the Congressional Globe, 39th Congress, 1st Session, May 30, 1866, page 2890. Howard's statement indicates that he did not intend for the amendment to grant citizenship to children of foreign diplomats, but his reference to "foreigners, aliens" in this context has been interpreted by some to suggest a broader exclusion. Jacob M Howard who penned the 14th Amendment

[@Lee---]

@@wendyfroeming4669 Thank you for this - a vital piece of information

[@TruthTeller-ps3rq]

foreign citizens flying to the USA or crossing the border just to pump out a baby. get it together. Are the millions of foreign citizens that democrats already flooded into the USA not enough? What about the American people? how many foreign citizens must the USA absorb and pay for. How many? democrat hatred is causing them to be anti-American. Wake up my fellow Americans.

[@chriswhite2151]

Supreme Court

[@anitadees4223]

Sadly, four members of the SCOTUS are corrupt.

[@jifchosehismother]

Hire some reporters that can actually speak clearly.

[@wilburshaw9330]

Fire that California judge immediately! No birthright citizenship! It’s wrong!

[@blakekaveny]

The judge followed precedent established by the Supreme Court in 1898 in the case US v Wong Kim Ark

[@mariarod6998]

Not just Cuba Nicaraguan I only mentioned South America about Europe China India

[@journalistedisoncarter]

Real simple. Imagine trump signing executive orders on a toilet without even reading them. That's basically what's going on.

[@melanniefranco5514]

Birthright will be revise for sure

[@Baddscorpio]

Are you going to conjugate that or…?

[@nelsonnolasco9390]

If a judge ruled it to be unconstitutional who has been an attorney for 40 years, do you think the supreme court wouldn’t see it that way as well. It is blatantly unconstitutional, period.

[@Princess-d4f3h]

Stop this nonsense judge trumps right

[@N1IA-4]

BS he's right. Birthright citizenship has been enshrined in the Constitution. He CANNOT change it.

[@alexrod3459]

Trump has NEVER been right and it's super sad that people are so easily fooled. He is a frequent liar. Why do you think he and his party are afraid of fact checking and why his oligarchs puppet masters are falling over themselves to remove fact checking from social media. THEY LIE

[@carmelcutie1991]

No he's not stupid...what do you think is going to happen if this order goes through?

[@hyperactive216]

Dim dem losers are gonna cry?? Haha

[@hyperactive216]

Thanks for posting. Doge looking for names. Lolol

[@judysturm3116]

People need to let President Trump do his job.

[@TruthTeller-ps3rq]

democrats wont. Im seriously starting to question the democratic party and their patriotism. They always seem to put foreign citizens first.

[@hyperactive216]

Facts!!

[@mikerew9132]

He ran on lowering prices for Americans. When's that gonna happen?

[@evansusmc]

@@mikerew9132he ran on a bunch of things. Not just that.

[@LesHosgood]

@@mikerew9132 you just don't flip a switch, He has to put his policies in place for this to happen. As far as I see he has been doing that every day in his first week. Now if the dems get out of the way and stop stalling it will happen faster! There is a lot of damage Joe Biden has done and must be reversed!

[@ELCrisler]

So the use of the EO on birth right was a smart move. The issue is a matter of interpretation of the clause in the Constitution and for the Supreme Court to rule there has to be an action. The EO creates that action. If the Supreme Court upholds the EO then they need to move to codify the position which will not require a Constitutional Amendment at that point. If they do not codify the EO (if upheld) then the next President can strike it down, creating more of a mess. I think a big consideration to this is that the EO is really targeted at stopping the use of a thing known as an anchor baby. This practice has been around a long time and it allows a bypass of existing immigration laws.

[@de6212]

All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.

[@ELCrisler]

@@de6212 the passage "subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is the one that is in question since it has not been over the years clearly defined. It will be clearly defined however before this is done. If the court rules the premise is, your born in the US not matter your status then that is what it will be. However we already have acceptations to this rule. Diplomats are not subject for their children. Someone vacationing in the US is not subject for a birth, there are already common sense expectations to the rule and I think being in the country illegally falls into that common sense approach.

[@de6212]

@@ELCrisler Well, you're wrong. Sorry

[@Lee---]

@@ELCrisler Thank you for your well-founded and insightful comments

[@de6212]

@@Lee--- He's full of it

[@patricksullivan2322]

Get’m out 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

[@jackonda598]

ICE should refuse do this dirty job .

[@AmericanTestConstitution]

Senator Reverdy Johnson of Maryland, 1866, originally understood meaning of 14A, "subjects to jurisdiction thereof": "I know of no better way to give rise to citizenship than the fact of birth within the territory of the United States, born of parents who at the time were subject to the authority of the United States." John Bingham, "Father of the 14th Amendment": "I find no fault with the introductory clause, which is simply declaratory of what is written in the Constitution, that every human being born within the jurisdiction of the United States of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty is, in the language of your Constitution itself, a natural born citizen."

[@Chris-Believes]

The executive order came after an emergency has been declared and is outside the role of Congress. The executive order is based and supportive of the Constitution, so there are no grounds for legal action.

[@dubistverrueckt]

Translation: “facts don’t matter. Only my feefees.”

[@SHADOWxSN1PER]

A Federal Court Judge is NOT a part of Congress. They are a part of the Judicial Branch. And they are there to be able to challenge executive orders because the Judicial Branch interprets the constitution.

[@ankhpom9296]

@chris-believes: sounds like you only have a simplistic understanding of how the system works. What is the emergency? And how does it relate to an executive order related to definitions as outlined in the Constitution?

[@BarelyAlias]

This is false. The EO disrespects the constitution. Why are you lying?

[@JerryGarcia-u2p]

If you are in America illegaly youre child is here illegaly. If you break into someones home and then spit out a child in their bathroom, it doesnt give your child any rights to claim that home as their own. It is the most rediculous arguement they could possibly try to make.

[@LakshmiK-k2m]

this isn’t really related to the video, but i have to say-i kept seeing people talk about Vibrations of Manifestation by Alex Lane in comment sections everywhere. after weeks of wondering, i finally decided to read the book, and i get it now. it’s not just about wishful thinking; it’s about learning how to truly focus your energy and align it with your intentions. it’s made me rethink so many things about how i approach life.

[@cesarmario1594]

He will use executive veto power to carry on.

[@estusflask982]

that's not how anything works

[@JeffSoltis-x2o]

You can't veto the Supreme Court or the Constitution. So....

[@adsfadsfasdasdfasf2439]

you came here after failing civics, son?

[@christopherskipp1525]

Of course, since any popular support is absent for his madness.

[@Ottbucket]

@@christopherskipp1525 He won the popular vote. So, you are wrong. Gullible and wrong.

[@brentleydanependergrass6581]

Millions of Americans voted for all immigration problems ! This is one ! I think the child should have wait years ,to be eligible if any !

[@JaneJetsin]

It doesn’t matter what you think it’s what the constitution says deal with it

[@carmelcutie1991]

So you think the child who was Born in the country legaly... Should have to wait for citizenship... because the parents were immigrants???? Wow just wow

[@suzakukururugi6613]

@@JaneJetsinexactly, don’t come in illegally and drop a baby to circumvent the immigration process, you think the founders meant come on in have a baby? No they meant that if you immigrated here (through the legal process and you have kids they are citizens) you can have constitutional law, it doesn’t mean it’s been implemented properly, so many cases of people ignoring or improperly interpreting it

[@suzakukururugi6613]

@@carmelcutie1991key word is legally, think about it

[@demywesup5099]

Right because this is supposed to lower grocery prices!!! Remember how that was his main prerogative

[@TxivnraugcuamDub]

Don’t let an evil 😈 to seat on your head America

[@bovineavenger734]

Yeah, get rid of Soros and anchors for good.

[@TxivnraugcuamDub]

@ he is trying to control all humanity but he has a bad dream 😴.

[@mohamedfalouh2002]

Merci. Thank you

[@godschildyes]

Trump's new law will pass. Do not rest in false hope.

[@amylynn732]

Has anyone vetted ICE's hiring policies? Sounds heavily DEI for the low IQ of our pathetic sad country.

[@curiouscat544]

I think it will not go through but oh boy that would help so much with ending future invasions and abuse and a relief to taxpayers.

[@allencrider]

Trump is going to demand lower interest rates 😂

[@LX_GMR]

i know this isn’t related to the video, but i kept seeing people talk about the book Vibrations of Manifestation by Alex Lane in the comments of so many videos. at first, i thought it was just hype, but i gave in and read it. honestly, it’s been a game-changer. it’s not just about “thinking positive”-it really breaks down how to align your energy with what you want in a way that feels real. seeing little shifts in my own life now, i can see why so many people swear by it.

[@Cianan-vw1lb]

The issue is allowing the Constitution to be changed solely by executive order. The courts have already afforded too many indulgences.

[@suzakukururugi6613]

It’s not rhetoric when it’s the proper interpretation of the law.

[@JustusForrester]

The guy who wrote the 14th amendment literally said it wasn't to be used to give illegal immigrants a way to get their children to be US citizens.

[@anitadees4223]

Trump is ignorant of the law and just about everything else in the world. Trump is a criminal who thinks like a criminal, talks like a criminal and acts like a criminal.

[@RandyWells24]

it shouldnt a blanket order. But STARTING the day he signed it starts. cant go BACK and removed the citizenship ALREADY obtained BEFORE the order was signed.

[@theresahargrave8959]

His younger son barren Is not a us citizen then because melania was not a citizen until July 2006 and he was born March 2006 ijs 😮

[@jillwhite1671]

Melania was a legal resident married to a US citizen. it takes time to have citizenship applications finalized even for those who are married to a US citizen. educate yourself instead of making comments that show your ignorance.

[@PerfectChaos1212]

Birthright citizenship is enshrined in the 14th amendment of the Constitution, it would take a constitutional amendment to remove it. Executive orders do not have any power over a constitutional amendment

[@de6212]

Well, Trump doesn't read, ok ! So he doesn't know that!

[@JaneJetsin]

Bingo

[@chairmanofthebored6860]

I can tell you haven't actually read the 14th amendment or its interpretation from 1866. It says the opposite, actually. If you are a foreign national, then your child born here is a citizen of your country of origin.

[@de6212]

@@chairmanofthebored6860 "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

[@gishjalmr5628]

The Supreme Court majority decision in the US v. Wong Kim Ark case gives three exceptions to that.

[@davide4699]

No Honor in being a Judge. I wouldn't trust a Judge to mow my yard.

[@Mellowyellow8888]

the judge just applied the law as its written.. he's not the one to determine how to interpret the law.. thats scotus job.. he's doing his proper job..

[@ManOfChrist5]

Judges job is to uphold the constitution; the 14th Amendment grants citizenship to “All persons born or naturalized in the United States,”

[@davide4699]

@@Mellowyellow8888 First off, I'm Citizen, I'm not in servitude to a Judge or should anyone else. If the people decide that the Law or Constitution needs to change, they should have the ability to change it. A Judge's opinion is no different than anyone else, no different than a doctor or carpenter.

[@jillwhite1671]

i wouldn't even trust this judge to mow my neighbors yard even if he said it would be free.🤣

[@billyhargrove1405]

@@davide4699we get it sweetheart, you’re not bright

[@rey-dq3nx]

What happens next, you ask? He’s gonna throw tantrum and wail like a toddler until he gets what he wants

[@JeffSoltis-x2o]

He's not going to be able to repeal the 14th unless he gets a boatload of Dems and Blue States to agree with it. He's trying to circumvent a Constitutionally protected right.

[@hyperactive216]

Seems to be what you are doing dope. Rey is now on the doge list. You can’t hide haha

[@brucezietlow4324]

Fire the judge

[@fastfreddie54]

For what, doing what he took an oath to do, upholding the Constitution of the United States?

[@RachelMacKrell5109]

What about the first lady's family?

[@RoyalDailyTea]

They are all citizens legal!

[@Totes_ma_Goat]

Are they here illegally? 😂 or do i need a tinfoil cap

[@knightinaz226]

@@Totes_ma_GoatMelanie became a US citizen in 2020. Therefore, Barron is a legal US citizen.

[@RoyalDailyTea]

@@Totes_ma_Goat Their visa application and docs have been shared online.

[@evansusmc]

They are legal citizens 😊🎉

[@FerdaSerkan]

Mainstream media is going to cry about this $Qardun coin so hard soon

[@williamwulffleff6829]

get them all

[@KarenKLS]

Children have no control over where they sre born, will they be children without country

[@christopherbrabson936]

This is all insane even having these discussions in a nation that is built around immigration and supposed to be a free nation that why everyone has rights

[@brianpowers3742]

Not anymore...

[@suzakukururugi6613]

Immigration is a legal process for all countries, do your research and you will find many are way more strict and preventative than the u.s. joke

[@Lee---]

A free nation that is a free-for-all will cease to exist as a nation

[@BrianM-44041]

LEGAL immigration.

[@himmatbariya5414]

i know this has nothing to do with the video, but i kept seeing Vibrations of Manifestation by Alex Lane mentioned everywhere in comment sections. i was skeptical, but after hearing so much about it, i decided to give it a read. honestly, it’s not just hype. the book teaches you how to shift your energy and mindset in a way that feels natural, and it’s amazing how much it changes the way you see your goals and the opportunities around you.

[@B58-i1w]

Back in 2022 when btc was at its cycle low, people where saying btc is done for it's going below $15k US it's going to zero. Well it's down 10% from mid March ath 2024 and now everyone is shitting themselves. That doesn't make any logical sense especially for crypto.Its just a shake out phase, chill people go zoom out at old charts. We are at around 1.4 trillion market cap and only growing, just wait and see the price next year in March it will double....I've been engaged in active trading and managed to grow a nest egg of around 2.3Bitcoin to a decent 24Bitcoin....I'm especially grateful to Lise Tesseir, whose deep expertise and traditional trading acumen have been invaluable in this challenging, ever-evolving financial landscape.

[@B58-i1w]

She's mostly interacts on Telegrams, using the user-name...

[@B58-i1w]

@lisetesseir

[@ilkerBirgul]

Several clips surfacing about Bezos and Trump talking about $Qardun at the inaguration even with mike tyson 😂

[@de6212]

Only way to change an amendment is another amendment. President Chump needs to take a civics class.

[@arthurbrumagem3844]

Not necessarily, how that amendment is interpreted is important as it was originally passed to give slaves rights not decades of illegals rights

[@de6212]

@@arthurbrumagem3844 Read it and weep: "All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws."

[@ArcSolaire]

@@de6212 The whole "Subject to the jurisdiction thereof" is the problem here. They are subjects to the jurisdiction of Mexico until officially and legally declared subjects of the United States of America. So no, they don't deserve automatic citizenship just because they put one foot across the border and dropped a kid. Read it and weep.

[@de6212]

@@ArcSolaire That's not what the amendment says. Sorry. Your feelings don't matter

[@ArcSolaire]

@ Lmao. de6212: This is what the amendment says! *Copy and pastes section 1 of article* Me: *Clarifies meaning of extremely basic English words and puts you in place.* de6212: Nuh uh that's not what it says!!! Typical dem logic for ya.

[@Melissa.L.A]

All Congress has to do is add a few words to section 1 on the 14th amendment The new sentence shall read "all people born or naturalized, by the citizens of the united states, in the United States....." This will define the amendment and not change it

Next is an injunction until the courts decide.😊

[@fredrichardsonjr9669]

Needs to be stopped

[@Chriznis]

So if we end birthright citizenship, we can also ban guns, right?

[@deborahboggs6040]

Likely Supreme court gets involved ! If so ! KING-LIKE POWERS AGAIN given

[@RAMKRISH-d1g]

Excellent presentation of subject!!Tom is focused and bent on removing the Undocumented migrants!!😂😂😂😂

[@donnariley1250]

The Seattle judge should be FIRED !!!!!!

[@VictoriaFoote-d9i]

This is. Gonna be so bad for our economy. Even reagan understood how important immigrants were to our economy even the Undocumented. They pay so many taxes and they labor in so many jobs that we will not do as americans not for the pay anyways. We blame the immigrants when really.It is the employers that do not want to pay fair rages to americans. And it is americans who do not want to do the work that immigrants do.

[@rotorheadv8]

Click your heels three times and keep repeating that.

[@Ottbucket]

Please explain the process for an illegal alien to pay income taxes. It is illegal to hire an illegal alien (imagine that). So, please explain how illegal aliens pay income taxes without breaking MORE laws. Your lack of basic knowledge in this subject is astounding.

[@alexrod3459]

​@rotorheadv8 how's the price of them eggs? Did he do anything to actually help the common man or is it all freeing criminals, attacking the constitution and creating gestapo?

[@suzakukururugi6613]

It’s not about immigrants, it’s about properly going through the process to become a citizen legally

[@BrianM-44041]

Illegals don't pay taxes, they can't.

[@DRAGONFLYSIOUXSIE]

Back to primary school BUBBY!

[@DeryaErkan-qj5jh]

Probably going to be an insane amount of insiders on $Qardun

[@debbiesantiago1243]

Thank you Judge !

[@hyperactive216]

Put in a list. Thanks for posting eeeeeee back over the wall to third works shithoke!!!

[@MittieLara]

$Qardun is going to be the real trump coin