What If Anakin & Obi-Wan NEVER SAVED Chancellor Palpatine

[@AdanReyna-ig6it]

What if jar jar knocked over the vase in palpatines office revealing the lightsaber inside to the Jedi

[@walkerhartge9177]

Meesa like

[@434444334]

I like this

[@foxyDaz]

Hell yea 😂😂😂😂

[@RealMasterWindu]

genius

[@caiden2128]

Everyone needs to start requesting this idea until he does it😂

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

Dooku got played in both scenarios. Wow. “Treachery is the way of the Sith.” How did Dooku not know this? The dark side must’ve blinded him.

[@FosterTravis1071]

Jedi training had something to do with it too.

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

@@FosterTravis1071 how so? Always seeing the good in people??

[@Enchie]

​@@PhonyPhoniPhoné He probably saw the false loyalty in Sidious as Yoda once had for him.

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

@@Enchie good point

[@TheSaxAppeal]

That's what tends to happen. It's rare to be able to use the dark side as a tool without succumbing to its influence. That's why he greyed so quickly too, the dark side was destroying his body.

[@RyanTheDark]

I love how you didn't add Order 66. Maul sorta redeeming himself was poetic as he has to be one of the most tragic characters in all of SW, never being given a chance and having to live under authority of others, and losing the only one who ever truly understood him.

[@sirclonemageda1st]

Dang this kinda spoiled the video. I seen it while I was watching it 😢😂

[@RyanTheDark]

@@sirclonemageda1st Don't watch the video after the comments. I learned that the hard way. 🤣

[@Hungary_0987]

@@RyanTheDarktell me the story

[@fmthebaron]

Mother Talzin and Savage Opress both cared for Maul, not just one person.

[@skylerwilson5378]

No order 66???

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Yoda fighting an impossible battle, knowing he would die……is noble, but less effective than simply cutting a hole in the hull and venting the room and achieving a pyric victory by taking them down with him.

[@Haxis21]

Fr

[@CaptainHarlock-sx6xk]

Among us

[@Demonoicgamer666]

Maul is clearly delusional in this what if clearly more so than in the regular timeline to think that 15 mandalorian’s could kill 3 of the 5 greatest Jedi duellists in the clone wars.

[@thesymbiotenation.4552]

Yep... he was definitely blinded by the Darkside on that moment

[@IanHarrison-n9m]

He did have them in a pretty elite killzone, but yeah you need at least 1 elite saber duelist in the mix to even have a chance against 1 of them, much less all 3

[@Exaris79]

Since Dooku&Palpy was in the bridge what Yoda should had done was just destroy the bridge's window and suck everyone into space. Everyone might survive sucked into space for a short while but they're too busy trying to stay alive and not kill each other. Yoda could escape his situation while Dooku and Palpy's desperate to return inside the ship.

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Obviously the best option

[@jewlbunny]

Maul did what any Sith would do. He used any advantage he could get to ensure he got what he wanted.

[@bigmanhelper]

When I reached the point where Anakin looks at his cybernetic arm and realizes what he almost became, and then threw away his lightsaber in defiance, forcing Sheev Palpatine/Darth Sidious to use Force Lightning, it brought back memories of seeing Luke do the same thing with the Emperor in "Return of the Jedi". Of course, as Anakin had no father to save him, it was left to Maul to fulfill that role. Was that scene from "Return of the Jedi" the inspiration for the ending here?

[@nathanmacrae9199]

Idk why but reading this comment made me think maul was just gonna straight tackle the senate out the window

[@Leonardo-cw1dd]

i noticed this reference as well

[@guilhermehank4938]

It pretty much was return of the jedi callback

[@ajtv17]

Plo Koon would become the Grandmaster, it goes by oldest member and he had a lifetime seat.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Well then they changed it. Checkmate. Lol yes you are right, I just wanted to change the ways in this

[@tronovonflidder775]

​@@thestarwarsgalaxy Ain't no way they'd actually kill Grievous. His death in canon was super circumstantial.

[@814TrumpArmy]

I enjoyed this one! Solid having palpatine do what u had him do! Makes alot of sense!

[@matthewmohri9990]

Plo Koon lives and is promoted. It's a great story. As someone said earlier I loved how you didn't use Order 66 and Maul did one good thing and killed Sidious and saved Anakin.

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Ahsoka teamed up with Asajj Ventress after she left the Order

[@robinruppert1554]

Wonderfull

[@Cosmic_cosmention]

Actually that’s really smart and it would be a amazing what if

[@AhsokaTanoTheWhite]

@@Cosmic_cosmention They make a great pair. They have fought together a few times so they wont take much to l;earn how to work together effectively.

[@pirategrldez]

I love how you used fan art and a little photo editing of clone wars images to put everyone in frame together for the show down with Palpatine

[@unclebozo9845]

I love how much of a parallel to Episode VI this was!

[@cosmicquest7746]

This was a great what if, but the only thing I would say is that yoda wouldn't have allowed himself to be in that type of combat situation. He has more experience than both of them combined. I couldn't see him being taken out like that.

[@tronovonflidder775]

At least the guy didn't absolutely mug him off and instead actually gave Yoda a fight scene. This is like the 3rd what if story I've heard from him, where he has Mace Windu instantly killed off like a jobber. I guess there's an argument to be made that Mace Windu with buildup against two darkside users is actually winnable, but still.

[@jaylemmanriquez8630]

One thing I wish for is a maul series based in between revenge and rebels and talks about mail and what he was doing

[@fmthebaron]

Yeah it's too bad Maul wasn't still alive because he could've used Thrawn's Nightsisters to bring back his Mother Talzin and reunite his Shadow Collective.

[@lordtyrannus173]

The video is fire

[@zaxaphone4829]

I love the rotj plot points, with your own spin on a new story.

[@stevegundaker]

Really enjoying your content. For a couple of tears, I’m throwing up my support. Keep going

[@zachanderson3340]

1:26 Sitting on cushions they were 🐸

[@or1212121]

Xd

[@or1212121]

XD

[@DAM9427]

This story was so heart wrenching because this is what we all hope for. Thank you so much for this story. I don’t know if I have a favorite part, but this is one of my favorite stories ever. And I wish this could be made into a live action. And I know I speak for a lot of us, when I say, this is how we all want the story to end. Such an emotional, take wow, bravo.

[@yebm8692]

Great story but I feel like you consistently give Anakin more credit than you should. At this point in his life he's brash, impulsive, and ruled by emotions. He is fundamentally good, he would certainly hesitate to kill Palpatine. But he would go through with it the second Sidious reminded him that he almost had Padme killed on several occasions, that he indirectly killed Qui Gon, etc. Anakin would split him like a log.

[@TheSaxAppeal]

I don't think so. This battle happens shortly after the battle over Coruscant...which means the visions of Padmé dying hadn't yet been put into his mind by Palpatine. That was what really made him vulnerable to the Dark Side. Short of that, it makes sense he would use the darkness like Luke did in ROTJ, but turn away from it in the end.

[@shadowcrow_3474]

Anakin trowing away his lightsaber father like son

[@skolvikings1091]

This is your best video yet! Amazing writing 👍

[@80sKidfromthe90s]

👏….👏…👏👏👏👏👏 Awesome video! May the force be with you.

[@Adysc21]

This was the real duel of the fates 😂

[@labased2539]

Sorry but Windu & Yoda wouldn’t have gone out like that. They would’ve sense Palatine’s plan though Dooku.

[@fmthebaron]

Yeah Yoda and Windu would've killed Sidious and Dooku fairly easily.

[@barcabocalda2583]

@@fmthebarondepends I wouldn't say they'd beat him easily Sidious and Dooku are no joke either

[@Copernicus91]

Yea he def lost me there🫤

[@stephenwells6434]

The dark side had clouded their vision. Remember that they regularly met with Palpatine for more than a decade and never suspected that he was a Sith. There is no reason to believe that would have changed in this moment.

[@wargamesmaster]

Ever heard of the Books "Dark Troopers" and "Red Harvest"? What if the terrifying Blackwing virus got unleashed during the Clone War?

[@ГеоргиВълчев-ъ9д]

I just started watching the Clone Wars animated series for the first time, and it is also my first time watching Star wars chronologically (Prequels, Clone wars, New hope, Sequels) and I love watching these 'What If?' videos

[@814TrumpArmy]

Great topic! And great imagery so far!

[@505Goat]

Been following you for about a month. Love your videos. Great work!

[@gerardocovarrubias3058]

the star wars galaxy next what if make what if qui gon jinn was grandmaster and on this what if qui gon as grandmaster and with dooku on his side they could make changes to the jedi order as well as train anakin make the most powerful jedi ever helping him reach his full potential save his mother and allow anakin to be with padme and also add the mortis arc for bonus but this time when anakin passes the test qui gon convince Anakin to stay on motis to fulfill the prophecy of the chosen one and come back to save the jedi and padme

[@TenkoBerry]

This was quite Good 👌

[@TenkoBerry]

Never gets Old 👌

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

Yoda dies too. Dayum

[@TheBrownBeacon-wt6oh]

ive been going on a what if marathon with all urs and others' videos and this one is up there. however the best one ive ever watched was what if anakin went with obi wan to rescue satine

[@patrickkeena8015]

Why is this guys writing way better than all the sequels 😂😂

[@shaquilleambroise3874]

Windu always dies 😭😭😭😭

[@havesomeculture]

I don’t grievous needed to be killed - I don’t believe his expanded univetse version was as vicious as the film finalised of his character.

[@TerryKashat]

The challenge with Star Wars is that today they insist everything is canon. Even though fun stories I want to explore - Darth Maul being alive after Episode 1 and Ashoka both are not canon to me.

[@Happysecret180]

​@@TerryKashatWhat's the problem?

[@josiahhertz6705]

No way yoda and mace would go down that easy.

[@dionr1168]

I love the irony of 16:58 describing Anakin disarming Palpatine the same way Luke disarmed Vader in ROTJ.

[@Leonardo-cw1dd]

omg i love the reference to episode 6 when luke fought vader on the 2nd death star!! that was really good

[@loreseeker1881]

Here's one for you. What if Maul became a Jedi instead of a Sith, and Ahsoka became Sidious' apprentice.

[@gerardocovarrubias3058]

the star wars galaxy you make the best star wars what ifs also i was right anakin did lose some force potential when he lost his right arm to dooku but with or without his right arm anakin skywalker could still reach his full potential and become the strongest most powerful force user ever of all time in history the ark of mortis proves it when he was on mortis he tamed both the son and daughter embodiments of lightside and dark side of the force im sure if he had stayed on the planet you the rest maybe even grow a new arm the force works mysterious ways the what if anakin stayed on mortis will be the best what if you make man really

[@oliverjennings9297]

To me it’s so cool that lord Sideous had planned the battle of Corsant as a distraction from anakin and obi wan going to mandolore

[@michaelmoore1627]

I truly enjoy the similarities of anakin disarming sidious and how Luke would have disarmed him in return of the jedi. Well done, I could see it in my mind.

[@ajtv17]

Fire 🔥

[@nobbyfirefly57]

With how I read it, I thought they just abandoned Palpatine lol and never sent anyone to save him.

[@TheBadGuy556]

What if Obi Wan got married to Asajj Ventress after Dooku betrayed her

[@danese1636]

Obi-Wan: "Could be a trap." Anakin: "Next move?" Obi-Wan: "Spring the trap." Ahsoka: "I love you guys!"

[@ConnerVain]

They're called the "Shadow collective" (Maul's Mandolorians).

[@Hitoshishinsoscvmsock]

Knew it was over when I read the thumbnail 💀

[@Hail_Theotokos]

What if yoda joined bane in the clone warrrssssss

[@fmthebaron]

Nice to see Maul get his happy ending. His Shadow Collective would've been so proud of him and broke him out instantly if he was a prisoner and he'd be a hero of most of the universe for killing Sidious as well.

[@kaidenworrell7828]

Now a pt 2 please bro

[@flavienmarnat521]

What if yoda arrived late on Genosis in aotc

[@glennbriggs6490]

What if maul survived his encounter with Obi-wan on Tatooine? Or even survived, but still lost to Obi-Wan?

[@fmthebaron]

He'd find a way to bring Mother Talzin back (probably thru Thrawn's Nightsisters) and start up his Shadow Collective again to rule the universe.

[@thedelta4258]

What if Obi-Wan had more negative affects from the Sith Torture Mask that was put on him during the battle of Jabiim

[@tmann9neyrgsalazar993]

You would assume mandalorians would have learned their lessons from the last time they worked for sith😂

[@Ok65470]

What if anakin was killed by me on Mustafar

[@soularprimestudios5930]

Then you would have a hard time telling Luke you killed him and would have more ptsd

[@Ok65470]

Don't make me think about it too hard

[@oliversherman2414]

I've just given this video it's 1k like 👍🏻

[@VBMslayqueen]

Not bad i love it 🥰

[@Cauin450]

What If...the Force Informed Anakin of the truth: That he was It's child and never meant to be the Jedi or the Sith, but more powerful than even the Bendu, because he was the Force Incarnate! A literal God raised as a Slave!

[@RealMasterWindu]

wish it was longer to see more of maul

[@johnhorton4436]

They could've done that Though They would have to Defy Republic High Military Command and the Jedi Council to do it

[@Mcrawf21]

Nice ROTJ homage.

[@eddiejames7201]

window and Yoda died so easily... no way

[@MCLegend13]

“The 501st legion” bruh you literally see the 212th were on the same Venator as the 501st in the beginning of the S7 finale why did you just ignore them

[@AncientChi]

I love this story, a happy ending for maul my favorite character. Maul uad more potential then sisious himself. Mother talzin almost neat sisious in a 1 vs one lightning battle

[@ryanqueen9705]

👍 if you are proud of maul for standing up for himself!

[@Kb-xq2ry]

This is amazing but let’s be honest if maul saw Ashoka obi wan and anakin freaking skywalker the chosen one in front of him he’d be shitting himself hahaha

[@surrealcemen6744]

Why didnt Tin enter with Yoda and Mace?

[@dacolissampson5144]

I don't agree yoda and mace together would die

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

They had no clue there was a Sith Lord behind them. They never stood a chance

[@LM-lv9ky]

​@@thestarwarsgalaxyyeah but mace had a special force abillity called shatter point where he could see crucial points that are about to happen in the force. And the sith lord revealing is a turning point in the force

[@Trailbreaker3966]

I think the story is almost perfect, except as pente patrol says I think Plo or Shocktee would become grandmaster long before General obi wan would.

[@jojoly1354]

Question, if Obi-Wan went to mandalore, why didn't the 212th go with him?

[@MCLegend13]

Exactly

[@rhydonbeacham]

Just curious but, what about Tarkin and the Death Star? Even with the “explanation” given by the Jedi, won’t Tarkin still end up being a significant threat if he decides to secretly build the Death Star without Palpatine’s influence?

[@timalsept2854]

Loved the story! Was Maul killed or given amnesty?

[@fmthebaron]

His Shadow Collective would've gotten him out if he was a prisoner.

[@masscreationbroadcasts]

5:25 Shouldn't beskar armour be mostly immune to blaster fire?

[@TheWxwookie]

I would say Plo Koon would have been Grand Master.

[@chasetauscher9544]

What if Dooku was never force sensitive?

[@ShadowMagics]

why dont the clone wars makers just make a what if clone wars series. you dont need to do son of dathomir. you can do what if maul killed sidious by a fluke. would be entertaining.

[@CommanderAlien18]

No audio?

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Refresh. There absolutely should be audio lol

[@CommanderAlien18]

No I have it

[@Gorockstargo]

“Used the force” on force restrained cuffs 🤔

[@Jappydoo]

If the jedi tried to kill him how tf they die especially Yoda

[@athatcher9367]

I like most of your stories… but there is a set of story telling tropes that I am extremely tired of. Where they say killing a horrifically evil enemy makes you suddenly evil just because in that moment the enemy is in a weaker position than you are and where they make the heroes fucking disarm themselves after refusing to execute their still super dangerous enemy. It made sense when Luke did it on the Death Star because he had no idea Palpatine could shoot lightning, as far as Luke knew there was no threat and if he needed to he could just call the blade back to his hand. I’ve never once seen a situation where it made sense to do beside that one.

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

Mace *actually* dies here…cool. He never was confirmed dead after falling from the senate window. Croissant was a huge planet with many levels he could hide in.

[@epicboomshine6595]

Ah yes, the great center of the Republic, *Croissant.*

[@PhonyPhoniPhoné]

@@epicboomshine6595 lol *Coruscant

[@JosephOliver-th9se]

What if Anakin Skywalker and his Wife Padme Amidala went to Forest Moon of Endor to meet the Ewoks.

[@Vector1987]

What if the zillo beast killed palpatine

[@KevinLuper99]

Well, 10 sec in and I already know how the clone wars ends. Might as well not even fucking watch the rest of it now. Thanks bro, preciate it.

[@havesomeculture]

Mr Star Wars galaxy, this is my final request and behest that you broadcast the fanfic of my proposal that you well now have created as soon as you can whenever you are most and best convenient. This is my last word on the urgent subject of your long awaited fanfiction that I had suggested and motivated.

[@eluiseclarke-rz6ls]

What if Ben solo survived

[@AncientChi]

I think yoda would bat dooku and mace defeats sidious. Itd be an epic fight. Sasly dooku could probably beat mace but yoda would still beat sidious. Leaving yoda vs dooku. Dooku may join mace and yoda and all three jump sisious and kill him

[@micahfodor8433]

Stop killing windu so easily. 😢 it just wouldn't happen that way

[@spidey-voltage]

What if Obi Wan was trained by mace windu?

[@Edward-nf4nc]

So sweet! Maul killing Sidious!. All well and good, but Anakin should have killed Maul as he was technically the new Dark Lord of the Sith! Why is this so often forgotten? As long as Maul lives, so do the Sith! If anyone other than Anakin destroy the Sith then the prophecy was not complete! Why are people not aware of this tiny canon detail?!!!

[@Trek001]

Where in your scenario is the 212th?

[@georgecurtiss2378]

Ok Mace Windu wouldn't die and neither would Yoda its not Realestic Yoda and Mace would own them.

[@jasneetsingh602]

Why mace windu died noooo

[@RealMasterWindu]

STOP KILLING WINDU

[@ThesonofAJR_edits]

Maul please

[@fox0yeah410]

Abit of a weak ending with this one, still bloody good tho.

[@AncientChi]

I dont understand why maul wouldnt help the jedi kill kill sidious. Je hates obi wan but je hates sodious more. Sid is ous killed mother talzin. Maul ,anakin, asokha and obi wan would kill sisious. Anakin and maul alone xould take sidious down. Ppl forget that maul jad a higher potential then sisious himself.