What If Anakin Was EXPELLED From The Jedi Order

[@FantasyFolklore]

Pinning my favorite comment after 24 hours!

[@degenratex4834]

The Jedi: you are here by expelled from the order Also the Jedi: why do we hear imperial March music?

[@xenencross1717]

It seems Order 66 will come early.

[@Shocktrooper-TR8R]

Could you please do what if mace windy killed Dooku in attack of the clones. Also what if leia went to tattooing and Luke went to alderan and what if Ashoka joined maul on mandalor I know I said this twice I just didn’t know where to put it to get it pinned

[@gacharose5908]

That has got to be the stupidest decision the Jedi order could ever make. The Jedi are now goners for sure.

[@renaldwagner4299]

well Sounds like Mace Windu to me, he said his friend Dooku isn't a Sith and he wasn't after padme.🤔

[@TheHighborn]

if they were gooners it'd have been different

[@YamamotoKazuo]

This proves the Jedi are evil

[@renaldwagner4299]

@@YamamotoKazuo Yes, certainly some, but not all, many are lazy and naive like normal people, but there are both good Jedi and good people in real life. I say that if I had been Anakin before the Jedi Council when they gave the order to spy on the Chancellor because of the Sith Lord thing, I would have said that I don't need to look for the Sith Lord. His name is Mace Windu, ever since I met him he has been nothing but trouble for me and my student. Not to mention the Dooku file and he is close to the Chancellor and thanks to him I am not a master. But if an incident had occurred, I would have used power over the Republic because the Chancellor gave Ankin his post including, considering all the evidence collected by the Jedi, let Master Windu when the Sith was arrested, or at least as dark Jedi who worked for him, so get rid of him in the cell. It turned out it wasn't true, but in the end they would come to the conclusion that Anakin was thinking correctly if the behavior involved Windus. If you look good in the cell for a while and think about how you always behave.😏

[@ebonaparte3853]

Which is probably why they wouldn’t have made that decision. Windu and some other Jedi would have wanted him expelled, but the rest would realize that the outcome could be terrible for them.

[@someonlinedouche6992]

Aankin... no... you can't 1v1 the entire Jedi Order. You need Papa Palps and his legion of similarly faced legion of helmeted goons.

[@jtbfilmsofficial]

Man, Windows really dug his own grave with those last words.

[@hackman669]

He deserved it. Least tolerant of all Jedi. 😅

[@darthyetgon]

Part 2 needed for this one 100%

[@swordvader4]

The Jedi essentially knew about Padme's relationship and kept silent about it. It was why he wasn't granted the rank of master, but they wouldn't expel him over padme.

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Obi-Wan had a side chick, forehead come head guy had a wife… Windu was probably dipping his wick every chance he got ….. they’d be a bunch of ridiculous hypocrites if they kicked Anakin out for having a hot wife

[@Matt-yg8ub]

Expelling the chosen one from the order would be one of the stupidest things that the Jedi could do…. But expelling the galaxy renowned hero without fear is by far the stupidest thing they could do short of window being a complete moron, marching into the chancellor’s office and trying to commit treason without any evidence.

[@jaczylijaaleniepowiemkto3243]

Well, at least this time Palpatine seemingly views Anakin as a worthy successor and somewhat cares about him? His life definitely won't be as miserable as canon Vader's... What if Anakin's Kyber crystal naturally turned red when he built his first lightsaber? (I want to see the Jedi Council freak out)

[@28467Vanus]

What if Anakin Skywalker and Ahsoka Tano were a force dyad? What if Palpatine saved Shmi Skywalker as a way to bind Anakin even closer to him? What if Mace Windu trained Shaak Ti? What if Count Dooku ordered an unaltered clone of himself to be his apprentice and heir? What if Shaak Ti found Anakin Skywalker on Tatooine and trained him? What if Illum bestowed a naturally red kyber crystal on Anakin? How would the Jedi react? Just a few what-if ideas...

[@yaqubsatti3846]

Maybe palpatine could marry shimi to make himself even closer to anakin

[@28467Vanus]

@yaqubsatti3846 interesting idea you have there. What if Palpatine fell in love with Shmi and married her? Or what if he was more cynical in being with her, hoping to manipulate Anakin further? I prefer the idea of him falling for her... it would be a what-if I've never seen done before...

[@Fortnite_Frost_Clips]

Windu called Amakin the S word 15:03

[@FantasyFolklore]

Silly Windu

[@darylsdesigns6679]

And in doing so, it sealed his fate

[@cts9254]

It was at this moment that he knew, he f***ed up

[@jacobcave1587]

Windu you flipping idiot 😂

[@Alilou279]

​@jacobcave1587mace mf window should shut his damn mouth if he didn't say one stupid word the jedi order will have live

[@darkseid1341]

What if anakin skywalker found out palpatine was Darth Sidious during the clone wars.

[@THEREALMCRUSHER]

day i lost count: what if mace windu attacked anakin in the council chambers in front of the high council?

[@christophercardoza2872]

Why would he do that? Sounds like Anakin would be the impulsive one in that scenario; not the calm and focused master of the order.

[@shelledcrane0177]

What if Yoda was a addict for death sticks.

[@Noah_dark4562]

Ok that would not be good because he dead if he does that

[@MonkeyDBoomE]

I think I saw this one before. Or maybe it was Spice...?🤔

[@Noah_dark4562]

@@MonkeyDBoomE maybe

[@Hiftco]

“Hmmm good Kush, this is *yoda laugh*”

[@Noah_dark4562]

@Hiftco MASTER NOOO

[@toddkurzbard]

"...You are off this council, and you will never be a Master." "This is outrageous!!! It's unfair!!! BTW, have you ever heard The Tragedy of Darth Plaguis The Wise? It's not a story you told me......"

[@jonnylake9625]

17:06 anakin would 100% kill palpatine here. padme wasn’t the last tether to the light, his children were and he would have known it was palatines fault

[@FantasyFolklore]

I think Palpatine perfectly manipulated it so Anakin believed it really was the Jedi who did everything to him. He's undoubtedly the best manipulator the galaxy had ever seen!

[@jonnylake9625]

youre right, but I think it could have gone either way after a scenario like this. Btw huge fan, watched almost every vid of yours keep it up!

[@jtbfilmsofficial]

It could honestly go either way. The deciding factor would be how much he’d take Windu’s words as evidence over his raging emotions.

[@snafuthegreat]

Same scenario, but what if Revan was the proverbial monkey wrench in Palpatine's scheme? What if Revan got to Anakin first and became his new Master?

[@drackestalentorgen166]

The jedi council would absolutely expell him if they knew of his marriage as stupid as it would be...is the same council that rejected him originally even if untrained he had more potential than yoda...

[@Achuidian179]

I’m surprised that you made Anakin made a yellow lightsaber. Day 139 of my suggestion. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme (Pentre Patrol did his version), Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@77wolfblade]

What if Obi-Wan used pocket sand instead of the high ground?

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see Anakin being expelled from the Jedi Order getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we can all agree that this is probably one of the most interesting/unique scenarios in SW…but it’s a welcome one. Also if Anakin was expelled from the Jedi Order…then it would definitely be an interesting opportunity to show another side of their characters and make it even more interesting. It was also nice to see Anakin forge his own path in the most unorthodox way getting shown some love, since he usually never gets the chance to do crazy stunts (at least more than usual) like this that much and it was a nice change of pace to see him take the initiative and definitely made us all impressed. Plus it was nice to see Anakin get that opportunity to make a major impact in the galaxy…afterall it was nice to see him have a solid plan, afterall this was probably the smartest course of action he could take, so it was nice to see him come up with this plan to shift the power balance of the galaxy, since he knows that there’s still opportunity and hope in the galaxy. Also it’s always nice to see just how determined Anakin truly is…also this was definitely something Anakin would do/would happen to him. It was also nice to see Anakin become a powerful individual…whether he’s a Jedi or not, he still helps people. Anakin is definitely more powerful than we think. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@matthewrosenthal753]

There are two major flaws in this particular scenario. Anakin having been ousted from the order. Would not have been able to sit back and be a poster boy for anyone. And more importantly being able to be with Padme freely and openly would have brought them closer. Strengthening his anchor in the light. He would have been forced to deal with his emotions which would have led to him gaining true control of them and himself. Leading Anakin to become something more like his son in Legends lore.

[@FantasyFolklore]

I disagree, I think being with Padme would've only increased his fear or allow Palpatine to increase it himself. What do you mean to able to sit back and be a poster boy?

[@matthewrosenthal753]

@ sitting in an office, directing things from the sideline is not Anakin. And having the freedom to be with Padme removes a stressor on Anakin and Padme. They would likely never be out of contact. He would likely have talked everything over with Padme. Which would separate him from Palpatine. Anakin is a good man at his core. It’s why he feels guilt and remorse for what happened with the Tuscans. Being in closer contact with Padme would weaken those fears of losing her.

[@thomasw695]

Okay but anakin would have enough sense when he sees the red light saber from palps

[@FantasyFolklore]

He didn't in the original story when he saw him use sith lightning!

[@ricardokojin7]

@@FantasyFolklore Honestly, Anakin's turn always felt forced to me tbh. At least this time he was spending A LOT more time with uncle palps before the whole thing (even during meetings, which would make him not question the need of an empire) I still don't see him going youngling slayer 9000% tho.... that's something that never sits right with me. I can see him not caring if they are killed, but not going lightsaber go brrr on them. And padme.. well, she should've focused a bit more on her husband if she didn't want him to go nuts... he always had those tendencies.. and Anakin was not good at shutting the f up.. so I doubt he wasn't mentioning somewhat often / venting his issues

[@BudokaiMan-mr9tw]

Oh shit! There goes the Jedi.

[@Matt-yg8ub]

My only nitpick here would be to point out that I don’t think we’ve ever seen anyone killed by force lightning…. At least not outside of some weird Disney thing.

[@dukejordan8147]

What if: Anakin built his own government and took over part of the galaxy?

[@bmendez3782]

You know idk if you heard the movie the final countdown (1980) where its about this us navy ship that goes back in the time to the day of pearl harbor in 1941 but you should do a story like that but what if the rebel fleet from episode 6 were to encounter a black hole, causing them to end up going back in time to events of the battle of naboo.

[@joekauffman9690]

Then the Jedi are giving the sith what they want, they are blind, arrogant, corrupt, dogmatic, stupid and only care for power, Padma is also blind and stupid on this, she didn’t realise that the Jedi are just as bad as the sith, she could had said to Mace, this is your fault, if you including the Jedi order didn’t expelled Anakin and didn’t treated them like this, this all wouldn’t had happened

[@garrinvr]

The Jedi knew Anakin was Palpatine's head of security, and that He'd be responsible for defending Him, So why didn't any of them meet with Anakin to give Him proof of Palpatine being Sidious due to Anakin being a Former Jedi, and give Him a heads up about why they were in the Hospital, knowing He'd react this way to a swarm of Jedi appearing in close proximity to His wife and lifelong friend with no justification. Things may have went differently if a bit of reason or communication was involved, as Anakin was (presumably) still a friend of a few Council members, and interested in defending the republic, but instead The Jedi acted as if Anakin was simply just another enemy/collaborator after He was removed from the order, and were forced to suffer the consequences of that betrayal.

[@Alexrocks2024]

This was a dark shirt storyThis was a bit of a dark side story. This had white lightning and the Sith took over when Anakin was expellws from the Jedi Order.

[@Acuas]

Funny thing, this what if sounds like something that could've really happened, the way they treated Anakin, and how they acted, if we take out Plo Koon, Obi-Wan, Shaak Ti, and Yoda (in some cases), any other Jedi in the council was really lost to what being a Jedi mean, and they didn't really care or trust Anakin, which was exactly what made him end up turning, so this is something I could believe 100% to happen.

[@Homie_1111]

The whole time I was wondering if Satine had been killed yet or not. If she's alive during all this Obi-Wan might just bail for Mandalore after seeing how they treated Ani. If there is a part two this could be why he just kinda disappeared during all the crazy events, if she's still around he's going to have to be weighing his thoughts on staying or being with her.

[@davidrodrick2109]

What if when Obi Wan was heading to his ship to leave for Utapau, Anakin breaks down and begs Obi Wan to stay

[@imember7375]

what if maul killed obi wan on tatooine and then trained luke

[@richardbarrett4488]

What if Palpatine, publically, somehow, discovered he was force sensitive (obviously duping the Jedi and senate)

[@jotheunissen9274]

Windu: "Take a seat, young Skywalker" Anakin: "No, I'll take a stand, middle-aged Windu"

[@nabarisealey7366]

What if padme was a jedi temple guard but still falls in love with anakin and has luke and leia in secret

[@MountainCarver]

From the thumbnail it looks like the Jedi are going to expel Anakin for being close with the Chancellor/the Chancellor trying to make Anakin a council member and the Jedi not agreeing with it.

[@santicollectionprime7128]

What if Anakin skywalker and Edward kenway swaped places, so Anakin lives the events of AC Black flag and kenway becomes and jedi. What if Ahsoka became connor kenway's aprentice after leaving the jedi order.

[@edisonlaw934]

What if the council refused to expel Ahsoka? What if Anakin defended the temple during order 66 What if Padme had a dream of Order 66 What if Order 66 was deleted What if Padme told the council about Anakin's killing of the tuskens What if Leia time traveled to save Padme What if Anakin was born during the Imperial era What if Anakin reached his full potential during the Clone Wars

[@JoshuaCharles-zc9ke]

when if Asoka join mall on Mandalorian

[@havco501st7]

I bet the 5 in favor was Obi-Wan,Plo,Kit,yoda,shaktii

[@michlasandersen6128]

I will guess the same

[@henryrevan1998]

Mace Windu is big part of why the Galaxy is fucked in this what if.

[@MrMichaelisaacs1]

Then the Jedi deserved everything coming to them.

[@joekauffman9690]

I agree with you 100%, the Jedi are careless, arrogant, blind, dogmatic, corrupt and only cared about power, this is one of the reasons why Count Dooku left and Gui Gon would had left too, Padma was blind and stupid on this, she doesn’t realise how bad the Jedi are, she should had blamed Mace Windu and the Jedi order, she said if you didn’t expelled or treated Anakin like this and actually cared about the people instead of your power, this could had been avoided

[@5on7YT]

this was very well written

[@FantasyFolklore]

Thank you!

[@VexNovaYT]

Windu, first expelled him for having feelings then called him a slave.

[@Wasilele]

What if anakin as a vader was only just a dream

[@Josiah-o2h]

I can already tell there is going to be alot of drama here

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin trained Sabine wren

[@chromxrobinandcorrinxcamil9031]

*Sees title and thumbnail* Rip everyone.

[@FantasyFolklore]

Lmao

[@hopduncan7905]

What if Mace W8ndu told Anakin he was expelled from the council, and then Anakin said, "Uh uh, you are expelled! Then Yoda says Expelled you are and then Anakin says, "Uh uh, you are expelled. The Yoda glances to Ki Adi Mundi then he tells Anakin " Anakin have been expelled from the Jedi council then Anakin says "Uh uh, You have been expelled from the Jedi council and then he thrusts his Hands forward using all the might of the Force force pushing the masters out of theirs seats and through the glass and they plummet to their doom. What if that happend huh?

[@shawnmoun9849]

They found out about padme ya'll

[@TheForcesWrath]

Damn that was a good one! Part 2 please!

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

Fantasy folklore my friend tell me for real. When can we see what if Anakin Skywalker killed the son with the dagger of Mortis and kept it afterwards, please, bro

[@FantasyFolklore]

That would be cool, but why would he keep it!

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

@ because everything in Mortis is his like the father but look man if anyone can do it during impossible it’s you bro😉👌👍😁

[@TenkoBerry]

Pretty Sick one IOoOI👌 A What if? What if Obi-wan was the One at the Edge of the Window by Palpatine after defeating Windu and the rest of the masters Obi-wan came back to investigate due to the force pulling at him

[@vieuxreveur617]

What if Schmi was a retired sith lord , secretly survive and saved Anakin during the Order 66 ?

[@sovazeleny]

1:10 Which five masters were most probably against Anakin being expelled?

[@The_Melonn]

What if there was no chosen one and anakin was just an ordinary jedi. I feel like that could be a good story, half the reason anakin got into the order was because he was the chosen one, would he even get accepted?

[@patrickd2853]

What if the clone wars continued after order 66?

[@ccooley824]

Hi your my favorite youtuber ❤

[@FantasyFolklore]

Thank you!

[@MRGaines12YT]

Rise lord Vader

[@rodgerscott8808]

The sith have no problem doing stuff like that but are still against using trakata?

[@FantasyFolklore]

I might have to integrate it here

[@ivanhunter6492]

What if Anakin had a twin?

[@Followerofchrist221]

I write this simply to get feedback on what people think of the little bits about my character and if anyone has tips or advice. I actually created a Sith character that was based in the old republic and sense it is technically a alternate universe if we go by Lucas As I have heard he said anything not in the movies that means books games etc take place in an alternate universe. I wonder what would happen if i introduced him as I made him a Sith however the main difference comes down to philosophy and how he goes about Things is the key difference where as the traditional Sith are destructive and tend towards being power hungry what would happen if you had one that actually used his power for good? A Sith that follows the Sith code as a philosophy but not as a Sith of the rule of two as he wouldn’t know what that even is as my Sith would be from the time of malgus. As for his interpretation of Sith philosophy. It would be about passion and strength not just the negative but the positive as well Passions and strength while good and can do great things needs wisdom and knowledge to not only guide it but to know when and how to properly apply it. Power and victory would be more as direct byproduct of these first four things. Power over yourself and your life the power to change things and your circumstances as well as others eventually. As for victory it comes at the end of what you set out to achieve regardless of what it is or what it means good or ill. The force will set you free whether in life or in death for their is only the force at the end. As to how he trains he’d train a student one at a time to give them proper instruction and education and then from there they would become equal to him and then in turn they would select an apprentice who would learn under them while my character would teach his own student after all just because you train one doesn’t mean you stop at just one. As he is less of a physical threat and more of an ideological threat or a philosophical challenge not to say he’s weak but he’s not stupid he knows he can’t fight the galaxy without vilifying himself however if he plays the cards correctly and shows genuine Good character or intentions this would throw a massive wrench into palpatines plans as he wouldn’t be able to say I’m Darth Sidious as that would give up the rule of twos grand plan. An he would be forced to sit and seethe not being able to do anything about it openly least he shoots himself in the foot because he wants to from the empire legally. If he says bring a Sith is illegal then the Jedi have every authority to remove palpatine in episode 3 do he wouldn’t do it just to save his own hid. Also if we count deleted scenes he’s says to windu about it being religious persecution.

[@MrCadeRay]

So like no one questions who sent the tape? Or why it's being sent? Like he is the chosen one. Seems really stupid to just accept this at face value

[@MrCadeRay]

I mean I can still see them expelling him still. But some sort of investigation should happen, or even a delay for the war effort

[@MrCadeRay]

I mean it really was the Jedis fault They were dumb AF in this story

[@GonkRex8621]

this video came to my page when i was looking for xbox 360

[@FantasyFolklore]

Did you like it!

[@GonkRex8621]

@FantasyFolklore Yes i did

[@linda-0587]

Welp, the Republic will likely turn against the Jedi, since the Republic loved Anakin, and practically idolized him

[@whatsupmason6514]

What if Delta Squad disobeyed orders and went after Sev! Please! We need more Delta squad!

[@Steamblade14]

What if Yaddle trained Ahsoka Tano? What if Cin Drallig trained Kanan Jarrus? What if Darth Maul trained Morgan Elsbeth?

[@Paul-vt6tx]

What if Anakin Skywalker found The Tardis and it took him to the day of Order 66 ?

[@MausStoleYourCheese]

The Jedi must be on spice and death sticks to get rid of Anakin.

[@gbear0385]

there’s a lot of problems in this story first off he was with padme and padme watched him kill a bunch of jedi and didn’t say anything? second padme hated palpatine ain’t no way she would’ve agreed with anakin to become his head of security especially after he strips power from the senate

[@FantasyFolklore]

She didn't hate Palpatine especially at this time in the clone war. And no, she wouldn't have seen him kill the JEdi since it would have been outside

[@gbear0385]

@@FantasyFolkloreshe absolutely hated palpatine and knew he was corrupt have you seen the clone wars? She told anakin multiple times she did not trust him

[@BowedUpWitMike]

This one is probably my favorite of yours.

[@FantasyFolklore]

Thanks!!

[@YamiRondo2]

What if Vader let Luke strike Palpatine down on the DS2

[@davidwood481]

Wow as if I didn't hate the Jedi order before but this is top level, not only are they hypocrites but they are even super brain dead great

[@jotheunissen9274]

He said the S-word to Anakin Should really not have done that

[@private_c]

"In my point of view the Jedi are evil!"

[@evangamer5752]

Then Wonder Woman cut anakin’s head off the end

[@0predaking0]

Now this is a good story!!!

[@FantasyFolklore]

Thanks!!!

[@ChrisMovieUniverse]

What if Anakin developed force lightning ⚡ in attack of the clones?

[@jeremyalvarado1358]

Wasn’t this one already done?

[@Jacksonville9000]

What if both qui gon and sifo dyas survived

[@luciferneverchanges5841]

Good story but I don't think that's how Vaapad works.

[@jacob6125]

What if Darth vader survived untill the first order

[@ThegaminglionXD]

The jedi are absolutely cooked😂

[@FantasyFolklore]

Hahhaa

[@Italianeditprime]

Yes but what happened to dooku greaovus and Obi-Wan 🤔

[@Alilou279]

I have an idea can you make a video what if the council isn't dumb

[@Shocktrooper-TR8R]

Could you please do what if mace windy killed Dooku in attack of the clones. Also what if leia went to tattooing and Luke went to alderan and what if Ashoka joined maul on mandalor

[@Shocktrooper-TR8R]

I know I said this twice I just didn’t know where to put it to get it pinned

[@noelgalloway1232]

If this the second year of the clone wars it’s only been 1yr and a bit maybe 2 years max lol windu really be doing the most

[@ushikucrisafulli]

The Jedi are taking ovah!

[@Italianeditprime]

What if Vader and starkiler kill sidius in the force unleashed 1

[@Alex-yy5wo]

Palpatine is the ultimate groomer

[@JackBlackYakAttack]

What if obi wan became an inquisitor??

[@harunathelover4494]

What if obi wan married satine and leave the order it would be an interesting video❤❤❤

[@Karaoke_today04]

Aftermath??

[@hes1shot671]

Obiwan, Ahsoka, and more would leave

[@Jedi-master-ki-adi-mundi]

What if I trained Anakin

[@theevanthompson]

The most based outcome. 👍

[@cecilarthurton3795]

what if anakin was born a girl

[@lightingmc5538]

What if Rey was born after Revenge of the Sith and trained during the OT

[@Zephyr947]

The Jedi councile make such stupid decisions