What If Darth Vader Survived Return of the Jedi - Star Wars Explained

[@kennyherron6529]

Medical robot: Vader is safe Princess:Leia: we need to execute Vader Medical robot: am I a joke to you

[@potatochingachinga6329]

Lol

[@bartbart3832]

1k like

[@thefsrrussiaball2707]

Luke: no, cuz Vader my father brah

[@tj8132]

Medical droid: years of acandamy training wasted!

[@Anjum730]

Lixyy GòDzíllà ,,man,mm,n

[@ROMAN-ry6sd]

vader: kills palpatine vaders respirator: Ight ima head out

[@matthewsudnick2499]

Yes

[@thefsrrussiaball2707]

Luke: **goes off script** hey can someone call 9/11? George Lucas: You weren't supposed to do that Harrison Ford: so what I really wanted to die in Star Wars anyway

[@teeprice7499]

What?

[@medall9191]

AloneGodzilla YTGamer It’s 911 not 9/11 cuz that’s two different things, one with a sinister meaning

[@katzenmama203]

Disney took his reboot card

[@ukiyo1371]

“The only reason you’re not in restraints right now is because of your contributions” “The only reason you’re Not dead right now is because I’m a Jedi and not a Sith”

[@justin2308]

Mothma: Well, shit, you got me there....

[@relphdonovan312]

Yo If this all actually happened that would have been the most badass thing Luke could ever say

[@sqeeter]

Top comment hands down

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Ooh, would've loved that mic drop

[@iycephoenixx4249]

@@relphdonovan312 Ikr? Fuck Disney's scripts

[@DerahSr2011BSU]

It kills me how Rise of Skywalker has made Vader’s sacrifice to kill Palpatine in Return of the Jedi completely worthless.

[@jcrews8582]

Micah Burney Well, Vader’s sacrifice was made worthless in Legends continuity, and I don’t hear anyone b**ching and moaning about that!

[@nolesquad5162]

@@jcrews8582 yes people do. I've even seen comments that say it was the worst thing in the EU, but since RoS is more recent, it is obviously more talked about.

[@spit4007]

It's not worthless because Vader defeated Palpatine for a limited of time and saved his son

[@darthlemon]

J Crews well technically video destroyed popped his true form his most powerful form and then help him came back as a clone which wasn’t even a quarter as powerful as his full form was and he wasn’t even as threatening as he was before.

[@richardreyes6873]

Factsssssssss that’s why it’s the worst Star Wars our rhere

[@-jtd-5576]

This medical droid is a freaking legend

[@max1muslegend772]

JTDSW D didn’t even care about his identity and gave him a second chance. Legend

[@clarkee_09]

It's the droid that gave Luke his new hand

[@ThisHandleIsInteresting]

Shit, what if it's the same droid that "prescribed" Anakin's mechanical hand? O______O

[@dukedevlan5457]

@@ThisHandleIsInteresting he is the Skywalker's stann

[@typicaltale172]

Droids are better than rebels

[@kfuj1815]

Vader picking up a handful of sand, shedding a tear- “I forgive you.”

[@cezarjulian0320]

K Fuj why did this make me sad lmao

[@justin2308]

And then he woke up from the nightmare he was having. Luke: Dad, what is it? Anakin: Nothing, Luke, I just hope that dream never comes true. Luke: What was-? Anakin: Don’t ask.

[@edoboleyn]

Character growth.

[@jancurin7607]

That will never happen. The hate has its roots too deep in his suit.

[@coronelkittycannon]

Wow, what a redemtion! Honestly, i would like to see that.

[@HuyGia-wp5tx]

Leila: “don’t you remember what he done, he destroy my home!!!!” Luke: “it had *Sand*”

[@someonerandom8912]

LOL

[@bananatank9048]

Lmao

[@phitthawatinthavong8401]

LMFFFAO

[@Charlie81-16]

Leila😂

[@guifdcanalli]

Actually Vader didnt want to destroy Aldearaam It was all Tarkin

[@Everik-ct6pg]

Everyone in the rebel base: Luke, we need to kill Vader! He killed millions! Luke: _YOU CAN'T. HE MUST STAND TRIAL._ Vader: *That's my son!*

[@p.istvan8744]

*cuts off Leia's arm*

[@reaganford8076]

LOL

[@joshuadesautels]

Or maybe Anakin would have understood the Rebels wanting to put him on trial?

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Lol

[@drax_fabianek845]

Copperlock Luke is probuarly stronger Then you piece of shit

[@myopia9032]

Anakin WAS the chosen one to eradicate the Sith, Luke was just a guide.

[@BanditOfBandwidth]

He brought balance to the force, by basically eradicating both sides. X)

[@barrysky6277]

BanditOfBandwidth and teaching luke how to the force like the Jedi should while trying to cut his head of but we ignore that

[@xnAqua]

@@BanditOfBandwidth tru

[@FramedGamer]

The Chosen One = Reset Button

[@myopia9032]

gamerkid1962 sigh, sad but true

[@blueruin4552]

What if Luke and reborn Vader found his padawan ahsoka and rebuilt the Jedi order. I think that would pretty cool

[@theacehealer3235]

Good point since Ahsoka never died.

[@reubenbell1980]

Luke is dead though, Vader is probably still dead

[@reubenbell1980]

Knight 5521 You didn’t comment at all before? My comment wasn’t bait, all you did was waste my time with that reply

[@arhael3594]

Luke has done exactly that without either of them

[@emirozer9280]

Sounds like an ending from a disney animation

[@coolyoda2]

He would start a crusade against all the sand in the universe.

[@sneekapart]

they're too coarse

[@mamd-t2p]

😂

[@mortenpedersen763]

Deus vult?!

[@airsoft9077]

Starwars the sand awakens

[@jaypea30]

Lol star wars the sand wars

[@justin2308]

Leia: Vader is responsible for the death of my people! Tarkin: *Laughs*

[@thermslusitania1151]

Yeah Vader didn't destroy Leia's Homeworld General Tarkin was the one who did that Vader just watched even if you didn't approve of it he couldn't stop him because that would mean he turns on the emperor and that means death and he killed way more people so yeah

[@eletricalplugandoutlet1540]

Tarkin: "You two stand here amidst MY ACHIEVEMENT! *NOT HIS!"*

[@nopity3057]

Firstly I like the comment just before this one. Secondly Vader is Leia's people not Bail Organa.

[@reddeaddude2187]

*From beyond the grave*

[@diosoth]

Everyone forgets that, in the first film, Tarkin was in charge. The Emperor as a character had barely been moved past a rough draft(by then Lucas had it in mind the Emperor was good but stupid, a puppet used by the senators 7 moffs) and is only mentioned one time in passing in the movie. Vader is more or less an enforcer to Tarkin, someone with flimsy backstory given and "Darth" at the time was probably his name. Much of the established "lore" wasn't even written yet. Making a lot of changes then writing the franchise out of order probably caused more problems than it fixed, in hindsight.

[@jpmoney53]

Jedi: why should you be a force ghost? Vader: I killed sidious. Jedi: But you destroyed the Jedi and killed children. Vader: Yeah but I'm good now so yeah.

[@dirtnugget5968]

You can never undo errors of the past. All you can do is be better moving forward, and not make the same mistakes twice.

[@davidhatcher7016]

@@dirtnugget5968 yes

[@Aiden-0915]

I knew Anakin would do the right thing

[@mixhaeltech324]

You are all wrong Vader didn't turn into a force ghosts anakin did that's why he is younger when we see him in episode 6 not Vader because at end of episode 3 that is when anakin died

[@mixhaeltech324]

Atilla Kayaş ur wrong

[@alexanderstilianov]

"Father, do you want to go to the beach?" "Son, it's time I told you why I dislike sand."

[@prosplays3443]

ngl, I would watch Vader giving a 1 hour deep documentary/ analysis/explanation for disliking sand.

[@Joelksk]

@@prosplays3443 with intense hand gestures

[@prosplays3443]

@@Joelksk So Luke the reasons why I dont like sand is because *aggressive hand swinging* *Punches Luke* Its coarse *pulls out lightsaber* *has flashbacks to younglings* And rough *deactivates lightsaber* And irritating *force pushes and entire boulder and yeets ot to the ocean* And it gets everywhere *Fkn destroys Tatoinne* (Forgive if I spelt the planet wrong)

[@Joelksk]

@@prosplays3443 then he does into an in depth explanation about why it sucks. You see sand isnt just course but it's super rough and irritating. OH! AND it gets everywhere. You know when there is sand in your shoes and it's annoying. Ye That

[@prosplays3443]

@@Joelksk wait but that's what I just explained

[@DemonHunter371]

The original Star Wars movies were perfect but this made me really wish so much that this happened I would’ve loved to see this on the big screen

[@ALittleMessi]

Perfect is going a little far. One of the greatest Sith ever was picked up and tossed like an old man down the stairs. The movies were very good overall, but stuff like that can't be washed away with "technology of the time" or nostalgia

[@hamishgaffaney5323]

I would settle for a half decent fan film

[@Golemoid]

far from perfect, but it's still the best movie trilogy in history.

[@michellelucas4673]

F#?+ off hacker

[@Potatopot724]

Anakin/Vader is by far my favorite SW character and this would no doubt be really cool to watch...but the fact is, Vader had to die at the end. He was irredeemable after all the atrocities he'd committed, no amount of remorse could rectify what he'd done. I do think Anakin's "destiny" lay incomplete (as he while did technically bring balance to the force by wiping out both the jedi and the sith- yes I'm choosing to blatantly ignore RoS-, he never got a chance to truly reach his power potential as the chosen one as the clone wars teased it) but to have their story cut short is the nature of a tragic character like him and fits nicely.

[@daimondswords1271]

Rebel soldier: "How could you save this sith lord, this man is responsible for thousands of deaths!" Luke: "I find your lack of faith disturbing."

[@Olgasamson1989]

Daimondswords 1 lol

[@Xen06660]

Vader be like "THAT’S MY BOY!"

[@mreviews5476]

Vader: *Thats my son!*

[@aiko1000]

*Cough* have any ice for that burn

[@Yoisaki_K.]

Grievous: *Palps sabers will make a FINE ADDITION TO MY COLLECTION*

[@carolinedebouver8535]

What if C-3PO betrayed Luke&co and stayed king of the ewoks?

[@atomic9706]

Bahahaha

[@carsonmccord6226]

haha Skywalker yasssss

[@jasongrayson2101]

Yes

[@Felipe03000]

lol

[@mhardie100]

haha Skywalker defo

[@cantina2425]

this is perfect for Disney+ “What If” series

[@owenhunt6548]

cantina that’s just for marvel though

[@ninaa4192]

That's a brilliant idea I would so watch that

[@christopherwashi]

@@owenhunt6548 make one for star wars

[@toebbad]

Marvel makes Star Wars comics,

[@honeyspice4014]

cantina marvel has that and tbh I would love one for star wars

[@darqshark3506]

God damn this would've made a great movie

[@_abowlofruit_6803]

Darq Shark it would lol

[@typicalchineseguy5818]

You got 66 likes, now execute Order 66.

[@searay83]

"Do it!"

[@themeddite]

Yes m'lord (shoots jedi in the back)

[@galaxy_apollo13]

Darq Shark how u doing

[@notdrake5001]

Plot Twist: the medical droid is a Sith Lord

[@pluto8923]

haha

[@paolorodriguez2580]

haha

[@trollmaster4523]

A better Sith than Ren no doubt...

[@mrfrog8882]

Well guys we did it! We hit 69 likes

[@ch4rlesiv115]

A Sith *Lord*

[@turtleninja16tn66]

Luke is the most sympathetic, most kindest person, in the Star Wars series

[@buckshotbandit7262]

*attempts to kill Kylo*

[@AlexKaneROTN]

+Chris Elmer Luke never attempted to kill Kylo Ren, you dumbfuck!

[@diegobrando6498]

Then what the hell was he trying to do with his lightsaber near Kylo?

[@lukeskywalkerjediknight2125]

TurtleNinja16 TN 💕

[@jennyberger8229]

TurtleNinja16 TN until DISNEY messed it up, Disney messed up a beautiful series AND a beautiful person

[@thomasarcanine]

What If Qui-Gon Jinn had successfully convinced Watto to include Shmi Skywalker with Anakin in his bet at the Podrace scene to free both her and Anakin?

[@KoalaTart]

that's a really good idea

[@TheGrandShadow_DERPTASTIC]

good suggestion.

[@chrisking7744]

oooh I like this one

[@AndrewSmith-kd9wr]

do it

[@thomasarcanine]

+SoulcreeperYT Gaming What If Qui-Gon freed both Anakin and Shmi???

[@DnycAlchemist]

hey stupendous, all joking aside but I believe Disney needs to hire you for their creative writing team. you have so many gems in that brain of yours.... thank you for sharing

[@TheStupendousWave]

That would be an absolute dream come true, thank you for your support:)

[@SPECTRE_Madman]

+The Stupendous Wave what is snoke is really as big as the hologram of him

[@mike4999]

I agree man you really rock on all these videos....you should try your hand at a fan film

[@kevinsolomanmcbride139]

+The Stupendous Wave I really enjoy your video you are amazing

[@nerfultimatehackhd9737]

Exactly what I said in the last vid

[@eoc811]

anakin didnt kill those younglings, those people darth vader did as vader said he killed anakin

[@thatgirlinamask8699]

Did you die? Anakin: sadly yes Anakin: but I lived

[@KangarooFam]

@ThatGuyInAMask Nice Ice Age reference.

[@noanimepenguin4321]

Cryptic Knot *froze in confusion*

[@xentiment6581]

only reason why Anakin survived was love for Padme. Otherwise Vader would actually manage to kill Anakin.

[@tk78junior64]

Nice

[@Sean_Last1995]

what if obi wan Joined Count Dooku when he was imprisoned on Geonosis.

[@ohmsri14]

Nice one!

[@Sean_Last1995]

blazeviper04 thanks

[@Sean_Last1995]

***** thank you

[@TheBigfranco1]

Thumb this up!

[@Sean_Last1995]

TheBigfranco1 cheers

[@obi-wankenobi1455]

Oh shit, when Luke sneaked Vader out I thought Luke was gonna go fishing with his father to catch up on father-son bonding time.

[@jamesashcroft8170]

You have 66 likes

[@bignate6568]

James Ashcroft execute Order 66

[@Gembarn]

Vader: hunts and kills hundreds of jedi Also vader : well that was a mistake and I killed palpatine on the space station that was going to explode jedi : you also killed tortured hundreds of republic troops , and didn't do anything else good except that vader : .... i still killed palpatine jedi : hmm okay

[@kelbihn]

gemma bridgewood Vader, not Anakin Skywalker.

[@_Tzer]

he brought balance to the force by destroying both the light and dark.

[@herrdoctor2895]

@@michaelverdon7252 Anakin:I AM THE JEDI

[@Theunfriendlyneighborhoodman]

I bring the balance by joining both side And after I finished my jobs I died

[@Nanaminanamin]

Gotta remember that Anakin kind of was a victim himself

[@VortexKiller2]

Luke: "hey dad, wanna make a sand castle?" Anakin: "NOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!"

[@darkflame4392]

Vader suit should be different, remember the reason of the old one was to make Vader angry all the time

[@paulus121212]

i was thinking tht like cream with brown trim just like jedi robes

[@deaclavilis6760]

Definitely. Old one symbolizes Lord Vader, not Anakin and it inspires terror and ultimate authority.

[@zeemer7040]

what if luke tell the soldiers that anakin killed the emperor?

[@poofyoof9657]

get back to bed nigga

[@gregvincent4136]

Damn aight

[@noone-pl2gj]

told*

[@ICCUWANSIUT]

no one or “was to” before tell

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Doesn't matter

[@CaseyRedgrave]

This sounds way better than Disney's trilogy

[@JragonBread]

William Jacobs i think he meant this would be better Than the first order and other stuff happening

[@CaseyRedgrave]

@William Jacobs It says Disney trilogy , not prequels or OT , Disney aka Rey trilogy.

[@nobodyatall2649]

Wait wut I thought you were evil

[@JragonBread]

It'sJustCasey I understand, but I think he means the ongoing story of the Disney story, if Vader wasn’t killed wouldn’t it change a lot? Yes.

[@Zack_410]

Stop with this shit

[@jonathanwat8567]

Leia would've felt Vader had turned to the light side because she is a force user as well, and she had connections with him as well.

[@Bubatanka]

correction, she was force sensitive. She never really used the force at that point as far as we know.

[@jonathanwat8567]

@@Bubatanka Thanks mate

[@VideosGalacticos]

@@Bubatanka wrong, she used "force" in episode 5 to feel where Luke was. But I understood what you meant.

[@thedarkknightdetective2559]

I would love to see a series of what if books.

[@mr.mortysnipez5919]

there are comics

[@TheBest-lx4jq]

Daniel Mann I can't read books. I have short attention span

[@pineappleparadox1288]

Daniel Mann ya

[@captinron2151]

Daniel Mann me too man

[@riyadh7948]

Extreme Lolz420 it’s not a book it a comic it’s all pretty short but explains a lot it also comes with 2 very articulated 6inch figures white Vader and princess Leia

[@Bear_4243]

I think you nailed this, great job.

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thank you!

[@Sierdunn]

Great Job! I think this would be nice to see in a saga.

[@skylinechris181]

what do u think would happen to kylo ren if darth vader survived, would he be a jedi? sith? or maybe take a different path

[@Krosstic]

he would have dish duty for killing Han solo

[@mannyg137]

what if anakin crashed his pod racer and died

[@Allwaysexcel]

It would be cool if star wars had a "what if" animated series or something like that.

[@javaman3403]

There is a comic about that. Forgot the name though.

[@maximus6844]

Star Wars Rebels - what if Star Wars had space Aladdin?

[@Yeentenology]

*05:13* i personally consider this the video's thumbnail.

[@smolmen7674]

What if disney didn't fuck up star wars

[@vanndymaywho1910]

It probably will now with how many spin off shows Disney is making... god I don’t want to see Disney milk this franchise to death.

[@Yes_Fantasy_419]

Anakin Skywalker: hey y'all I'm back! New republic: .......... arrest that monster and we'll have him tried and executed for crimes against the galaxy!!!

[@justin2308]

Anakin: Well damn, what did I miss?

[@reyhanjoger2512]

New republic:you have been accused of anti Jedi behaviour the senate find you guilty and sentence to be shot

[@MonkeyPopper]

Reyhan Joger lol

[@nopity3057]

Darth Vader: I am the newly reformed senate.

[@nopity3057]

@@michaelverdon7252 Darth Vader: "For doing what? Fulfilling my duty as the 'Chosen One' by bringing balance to the force?"

[@zachchilton4013]

I feel like vader would have accepted whatever fate the new republic had for him, i cant see him running away with so much regret weighing on him

[@bestoflife4395]

Vader died when he picked Palpatine up and Anakin was reborn for a short life.

[@xavierlauzac5922]

uncle drew they are the same person

[@MrDamning]

@@xavierlauzac5922 its a figure of speech dude

[@xavierlauzac5922]

DJ Anchlusszeit I know.

[@flexdon5188]

@@xavierlauzac5922 obviously not, else you wouldn't of felt the need to point that out

[@xavierlauzac5922]

HellsSelectiveAiden69 yes, I know... you don't believe me, do you.

[@hamakuasledgehammer1920]

How about a new suit? Replacing the cybernetics would really aid him in not having to rely on the dark side. Much of his pain would be eased.

[@williamwest9204]

In some of the books the empire did have better and proposed better equipment for vader but palps chose not too so vader would remain weaker than him.

[@z3ta624]

I need a book based around this. I’ll read it no matter how many pages.

[@brunoveloso5693]

honestly, the more pages the merrier

[@meghanreed9788]

999,999,999,999 page wha bout that

[@vacantsix1586]

I'm your 69th like

[@michaelverdon7252]

Me too and there are books on it on the book app watt pad I have it and there are at least a few books on it hope that helps

[@deadloaf8479]

Wat if Anakin liked sand

[@b.c2810]

Deadloaf 847 lol

[@paulmarcusmusic]

Then it will be *i like sand*

[@tahjircooper9218]

Not trying to be smart but what is with Anakin/Vader and sand??

[@glendamoncayo7641]

I like sand, it’s coarse, but comfortable

[@davids1854]

There is a vidoe abouy that

[@thefreeze6023]

What if Padme used her belief that there is still good in Anakin as a way to cling on to life and not die. In Return of the Jedi, Padme, Luke and Leia would retrieve Anakin together as a family.

[@jackieboychapps95]

The Freeze Yes

[@biddie6789]

YES

[@lolboisss8428]

If it weren’t for obi wan, then Padme would have turned Vader to the light side

[@eggstxrboi8118]

Because she wasn’t a thing back then

[@commander4460]

But If Vader would have survived Kylo Ren never would have turned to the dark Side... I Like it!

[@Herm.Q-92]

More than likely Kylo Ren would not exist as he'd more than likely have remained Ben Solo. A loss I'm sure a lot of us would accept and be content with.

[@scottriley3949]

Not exactly, Kylo Ren or Ben Solo as is his actual name. Was always different at the academy than other students. If Vadar had turned back to the Jedi Order its possible Ben Solo wouldn't have turned but his curiosity of the power the dark side holds from stories I'm sure Anakin would share would probably peek his interest, only furthering his fall to the Dark side. Also Vadar had nothing to do with the rise of Kylo Ren. The betrayal and fear for his life from Luke turned Ben Solo to the dark side and ultimately into Kylo Ren. But I like where your head is at.

[@VisualiseTheFun]

Hey McFly huh?

[@wsxaris1686]

Or if he did turn, Vader would snap him like a twig

[@cnobu8160]

No Sequel Trilogy... *I LIKE IT*

[@julianvdr8808]

2:32 why is that guy in the back pointed a gun at his own face

[@justin2308]

Julian vdr Picture this: Your ship has been boarded by imperial troops and you’ve heard what they do to people like you. And you’re losing the fight.

[@paeden5431]

Clearly how to clean your blaster in a safe and professional manner.

[@lpkintheuk7362]

Julian vdr he's just testing the barrel

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Haha

[@iycephoenixx4249]

It's an imperial E-11 blaster I'd say

[@Werrf1]

Two thoughts...first, I don't think Anakin should be using his old suit. The suit was deliberately designed by Palpatine to be intimidating to others and painful to Vader himself. There should be a mention of replacing the suit with a new one, perhaps one modeled on the Jedi temple guards. Second, the name Vader shouldn't be used nearly as much in this story. After his redemption, Vader was destroyed, and Anakin returned. The names used in the story should reflect this.

[@FreedomforHaiti]

I agree that the name Vader is used used too much in the wording of this video (still an enjoyable video, though). And the armor should definitely be changed. I suppose it wouldn't have come up yet with so much going on (i.e., the rebels pursuing Luke and Anakin and Anakin barely managing to survive). Basing the new armor on Jedi temple guards is a great idea! Or maybe basing it on something else in Jedi history/culture that we haven't seen yet. ........... When Star Wars Infinities (briefly) explored this scenario, they merely had Anakin in the same armor only white. I thought the redesign needed to be more profound.

[@Werrf1]

FreedomforHaiti You're right, I can imagine that there just might not be time to build a whole replacement suit for Anakin before breaking him out. It's probably something that should have been mentioned after the break out.

[@FreedomforHaiti]

Yes, I think the video should've gone on long enough to address this. The armor's a huge part of Vader's persona and is one of the first things I think of when this scenario comes to mind.

[@Yutakakobayakawa2014]

A white suit?

[@Sezporo]

+Pekka H They used the suit because it was the only thing to support Anakin from dieing.

[@xXOPT1CSXxHD]

Vader may have killed millions, but also saved millions in the clone wars, although that war was a lie

[@mattcunningham9235]

Nice meandering thought vomit

[@Ketjow]

Damn it, if Vader would survive, it would open soooo many story posibilities, with the best character "him" in this universe. Definitely would love it.

[@hagamapama]

I think Vader had to die exactly because he was so awesome. Sometimes a character transcends his setting so greatly that the setting runs the risk of becoming all about the character. Vader is an example of this. I think Swars needs to break away from that and spend a lot of time telling stories that aren't about Vader.

[@broski9938]

yup. All the other characters are shallow and crap. Ani is the best. Easily (except old bat Kenobi. Obviously).

[@tipperary4525]

Ommallaredpanda I disagree, I don't believe Ani is the best, I'd say my favourite character would be the first ever gonk droid.

[@theromanempire5280]

Ketjow he did

[@randya915]

Ketjow who is the villain though?? Because sid is dead

[@xtension7791]

Honestly, he should’ve just cut of Palpatine’s head

[@supersmileyface]

Dude his lightsaber was cut off when he was fighting Luke

[@xtension7791]

Then use Luke’s

[@supersmileyface]

@@xtension7791 Luke threw his out when he realized that Darth Vader was pulling him to the dark side

[@jeffkeatonsora9726]

This brings a question to me, why didnt Vader just force push/throw Sidius into the core instead of touching him and dying from the lightning?

[@undercovervisiter5881]

@@jeffkeatonsora9726 maybe because he was weaken from the duel with luke and if the force push didn't work then well no one is there to help Vader

[@riddledknight2755]

what if Kylo ren finds out that Darth Vader killed the emperor and turned good

[@riddledknight2755]

Julian O. what if Kylo and luke fought would he tell him about Darth vader

[@LibeliumDragonfly]

Too emo to care by then

[@carolinedebouver8535]

Rodger Brown Hahahahh he will probably crash! 😄

[@mrkings2535]

despairedboy How is he emo?

[@BrennaUrbangirl]

+ Julian O. I seriously doubt Luke kept that secret from his own sister, from Leia. I would have thought that he owed to Leia to tell her what he had seen on the second Death Star of their father returning to the light and sacrificing himself for Luke. He might not have told Han or anyone else but I think he definitely would have told Leia.

[@girumon16]

I saw some fan theories that CT-7567 (Rex) is still alive during ROTJ. So he can be in the picture too trying to convinve Mon Mothma to pardon his old friend during the Clone Wars.

[@Death-bd1tl]

Abu Bundin As-Solowi. He is star wars rebels so "rex joined the biggest cell (all of em) of the rebels

[@idioticmerc1512]

Rebels season 4 final episode it's confirmed Rex is the white bearded rebel soldier in ROTJ

[@tanith117]

​@@idioticmerc1512 That would have been an interesting reunion for this story. That and the Fact that Asoka might also be alive.

[@whiterunguard5316]

Abu Bundin As-Solowi impossible clones age 2x faster

[@taxult]

@@whiterunguard5316 but it was confirmed that he was in the battle of endor

[@anders_solace]

What if Darth Vader survived his redemption, and was training the new Jedi at the time of Kylo Rens betrayal?

[@TheProdigyAccordion]

Kylo Ren looked up to vader, so maybe it wouldnt have happened

[@chancereed6745]

+Anthony Ibarra He could have felt disgusted with how Vader was wooed over back to the light, and use that as his motivation to become stronger than vader

[@TheProdigyAccordion]

True, and to my knowledge Vader would be the only Dark Jedi/Sith Lord to ever get redemption and return to the Light. With that in mind, i think he could be able to get Kylo Ren out of his little Rebellious stage since he has been through alot.

[@chancereed6745]

+Anthony Ibarra That makes sense

[@Helbore]

Vader would have spanked Kylo's arse - literally. Vader: Boy, you think I'm letting you down that path? Oh, you think I'm joking, do you? You think I'm a pushover?

[@charlotterae08]

Don’t underestimate the power of the *medical droid*

[@AlexS-sc3gb]

I wish Darth Vader survived. Maybe that happened in a different timeline.

[@whythatspreposterous]

We are living in the unlucky timeline where Star Wars goes through stage after stage of cruel disfigurement after the OT until it is left a burnt and empty shell on the floor of our collective memories. In most of the other timelines, Star Wars just gets better and better... :(

[@generalgrievous2496]

I don’t think so....

[@Bads08]

Maybe a different type of legends?

[@TonySpike]

It was in a comic

[@Kanefan701]

If Vader had survived just imagine how episode 7 and the rest would've turned out as? I'm sure Vader will return as a ghost be the cost for Kylo Ren to be killed in revenge for his son.

[@daniellemusella1594]

I wonder how a surviving Vader would try to bond with his daughter, & later his grandson.

[@FreedomMiner]

Danielle Musella Not to mention Luke may have had children, being less troubled by the force and having a Jedi to help and look up to.

[@plutarchvonpluto6439]

And let's not forget all the jedi students who may have suffered because of him.

[@GenericUsername-qp1ww]

"I have a grandson too?!?!? this is wonderful!!" *faint exclamations of Vader shouting his status as a grandfather to anyone who will listen in the background.

[@broski9938]

I now need a fic of that. Vader walked in, all looming armour and swirling black cape, only for a young toddler to rush to him, screaming in delight. He stooped down and gave them a giant hug. And then there'd be like Mon Mothma standing in the background with a battalion of Rebels just like "Hmmmmmm... We must unearth this scum's superior motive!" Then, like something really embarrassing and cute happens (Vader gets pounced on when he least expects it by a pile of toddlers/fixes everything he can get a hold of because he's worried about Leia's recent pregnancy/gives Han da evilly Sith evils cus that what dads do) and yeah. Like, yeah... I'm sad. Don't judge.

[@userdawg6335]

Bonding with kylo ren

[@illogicalbear6200]

So Luke And Reborn Vader would be Pulling a Revan. Cooh.

[@GlitteringToothpaste]

Brian Halphin Why Are You Capitalizing Every Word?

[@plutarchvonpluto6439]

I Do Not Know But He Is Right.

[@Alex-xq6ju]

So Do I ^

[@felippebaricuatro1281]

As Do I ^

[@frozenace3337]

Me Too!

[@brianc6884]

Luke:” ...my sister has it..yes Leia it’s you.” Leia: “I know it’s true, somehow I’ve always known.” Me: *thinks back to when she said to Han “I guess you don’t know as much as you think.” Then stuck her tongue down Luke’s throat* 0__O

[@eletricalplugandoutlet1540]

Weeaboos: "First time?"

[@iycephoenixx4249]

Ooh, love tongue

[@RanMaru144]

@@eletricalplugandoutlet1540 is this an attack?

[@_Tzer]

SWEET HOME ALABAMA

[@sentabup7572]

SwEet HoMe AlaBaMa

[@GianCasanovaMusic]

What if Mace Windu agreed with Anakyn and took Palpatine under arrest?

[@MizanQistina]

Palpatine will use unlimited powah on both Windu and Anakin, then he execute order 66 anyway

[@talesoffan4718]

I highly doubt Palpatine could take on both of them at once.

[@GianCasanovaMusic]

Me neither, and he lost his lightsaber. So it would be him versus Windu and Anakyn, he would never win. Probably they would be able to prove that Palpatine was responsible for the war.

[@AsianIdiots323]

+Nizaris1 Mace Windu blocks the force lightning and Anakin just slices him. Your Unlimited POWAH!!! SUCKS!

[@MizanQistina]

Dr.Philry it just a trick to persuade Anakin, Palpatine know Anakin will fall...it is his destiny, he have foreseen it...but the future is always in motion, so if Anakin didn't fall, Palpatine will kill both of them then create a cover up story that Windu try to kill him, Jedi want to take over, Anakin try to save him but die, execute order 66 It will not be as grand as if Anakin fall, but there is no other way, some Jedi will resist the clones at Jedi temple, but they're outnumbered, some manage to escape...but they cannot face Palpatine because they have being labelled traitor. Palpatine create Galactic Empire anyway but not as successful, sooner or later many corruptions exposed...Palpatine must seek new apprentice as soon as possible to hunt down the Jedi and cover up all traces

[@thegageinator805]

What if Luke took up Han's offer on helping Han in crime in A New Hope?

[@bishop6881]

I like this one, ANOTHER

[@ethanmiranda-gale819]

+Bishop Gale hit brother

[@ethanmiranda-gale819]

+Bishop Gale Hi, not hit.

[@bishop6881]

+Ethan Miranda-Gale well this is weird

[@ethanmiranda-gale819]

+Bishop Gale haha, how are you, I didn't know you watched this channel

[@argurueg]

What if Mace Windu killed Palpatine before Anakin intervened?

[@karlsmith6690]

GG

[@FreedomforHaiti]

Or if Yoda succeeded after that?

[@karlsmith6690]

It'd be going accordingly to Master Jar Jar's plans.

[@Reskov]

Palpatine would just be a distraction while Jar Jar takes over.

[@jonsweat1981]

I think he did do something like this were Anakin stayed Light and Palpatine escaped.

[@ourmando]

No one: Vader at the end of RoTJ: " -We- I -were- was bad, but now -were- im good "

[@micahbarnett870]

We’re moving into your neighborhood

[@louiswebtser]

Shay Hates You. English please

[@hdallanstudios9568]

r/whooosh

[@quasar7951]

What if obi wan never said "hello there"

[@Betoruffo]

A Person 🤣

[@qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm2643]

Nothing (I know, r/woosh)

[@brushmepapa9662]

The world would end

[@SpartanTF]

@@qwertyuiopasdfghjklzxcvbnm2643 shut the fuck up reddit needs to stay on fucking reddit dont reference it on KZbin

[@cheese6207]

@@SpartanTF why is that many other sites then youtube have been mentioned on youtube and there is no reason to not do an reddit reference on youtube do you even know what an reference is?

[@dsgarland]

That was aweso..... I mean stupendous. Very, very, VERY WELL DONE. I'm subscribing right now.

[@TheStupendousWave]

Yay!

[@ohyeahgamer3736]

+The Stupendous Wave I like yours more

[@JohnCena-fp4qg]

The Stupendous Wave you should do Infinite Empire vs Yuuzhan Vong (post force removal) for your next what if episode.

[@Jeczman]

John Cena agreed!

[@twobgaming4709]

ya I agree

[@drac3650]

Mon Mothma isn't Luke's superior in Rebel Hyerarqy, Admiral Ackbar and Generals Solo and Organa would also have word of decision

[@Randomdude-dm7wb]

Ackbar would thing this Vader thing was a trap.

[@realtedbear]

Bill Clinton, you have no business here. Get back to fucking Lewinsky.

[@The_Bad_Guy.]

Bill Clinton yes she is. she is one of the founders of the alliance. in rank she most certainly outranks Luke and just about everyone else.

[@moffeetoffee1701]

I don't want to be rude, and it seems no one else minds, but.... "Hyerarqy"

[@SciAntGaming]

+Vaughn Kole Yeah was about to point that out myself, lol.

[@godzillakingofthemonsters6540]

If this happened then Star Wars Episode 7: A sith’s redemption Star Wars Episode 8: In search of the darkest holocron Star Wars Episode 9: The Prophecy’s fulfilment/conclusion

[@michellejaxon5245]

Godzilla 2019 terrible names

[@michaelverdon7252]

That would be cool due to vaders redemption in a good way and definitely the way the Jedi should be he changed the way the Jedi were and are he at least compared to before despite how it technically always was the same vader made the Jedi where it’s not about the light side or dark side it’s about the force itself balance and where someone could choose and go back and forth like himself for example and Luke and vader when he killed sidious did fulfill the rule of two and Luke became his apprentice so vader is now the master and Luke is the apprentice

[@mr.potato8270]

You should be hired

[@colinj5291]

Those names are almost as bad as "The Phantom Menace" and "Attack of the Clones".

[@godzillakingofthemonsters6540]

@@colinj5291 can’t argue with that statement

[@lizzanga3154]

I wished Darth Vader was still alive😫 I like the story more

[@felixdesjardins4030]

Lizzie's World Yeah, he would be the only one to Have survived from épisodes 1 to 9 except for r2 n c3po

[@radogaming5710]

If vader was in Force Awakens he would totally SHRED Kylo Ren cuz Kylo Ren didn't kill ANY jedi as for vader oooh vader has countless kills so vader is the strongest in this situation

[@joylove2324]

Lizivro me to

[@StarWarsGeek_03]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 unfortunately thanks to Disney Starkiller doesnt exist

[@StarWarsGeek_03]

@TheLatiosnlatias02 I agree. I was just stating the facts

[@CoolMoeDea21]

What if Anakin helped Mace Windu instead of Palpatine.

[@stephenpeterson6694]

My say the Empire would never rise as the Sith would be made extinct by full might of the Jed, or Anakin could have helped the Jedi evacuate the Jedi Temple by sacrificing himself after telling Mace Windu to go and get the younger Jedi off Coruscant as well as tell Windu about his wife being pregnant with his kid (which he hopes is a girl).

[@australianspartan4574]

This has already been done

[@903IDFOLEY]

Would Order 66 even be issued? I know Sidious had a huge number of Orders implanted into the clones, and some might be contingencies that are activated with the news of his death. But Order 66 was definately an order that Sidious needed to personally activate, which he could never do due to Anakin allowing Windu to execute him on the spot. News of Sidious's death would be slow to spread due to being only witnessed by Anakin and Windu. The Jedi would use the time to investigate the deceased Sith Lord's influence in the senate and armed forces, and would likely discover the Clone Wars was instigated by Sidious who played both sides. The Jedi could inform the trustworthy senators who would in turn back the Jedi and ugre the Republic to sue for peace with the Separatists. Since the Separatist no longer have the backing of their Sith Lord, they would likely quickly fall in line. The Jedi would probably also learn the truth about the clone army from their investigation, but even if they don't they would still be on alert since the clone army was the Sidious's pet project. If the Clone Army does eventually rebel due to some hidden order activating with Sidious's death, the galaxy will again be thrown into turmoil. But since the Jedi and their allies had time to prepare, don't have a second enemy to occupy them, it is unlikely the Clones would be able to wipe out the Jedi, especially since there are no living Sith to lead them.

[@ocbee6175]

+903IDFOLEY Noice

[@nathanielweller25]

The sith would be gone for good. Essentially what happens in how Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith should have ended

[@Myjacob99]

What if vader helped defeat Yuuzhan Vong, if he was still alive that would be a big step to righting his wrongs

[@keeganshelby885]

The Conquistador You mean righting his *wongs*

[@nathanjosephbay-andersen329]

and help Ben Solo make better choices

[@Bidoofus]

The Conquistador This is solely canon

[@bryanv3340]

Barney cow

[@Bidoofus]

Knuckles you mean righting his vongs?

[@darthvaderschild6164]

Luke Skywalker: Vader is your father Leia: *hugs Luke in tears*

[@salvadorrico21]

My friends: Vader would die of old age Me: *cough* *cough* *cough* Yoda

[@juliaj7939]

Vader was like in his 40s when he died

[@miguelpadeiro762]

900s*

[@skinnylegend0272]

Landon Pogreba no I think people who have force abilities can live longer

[@youtubeblows]

No way. Anakin was around 27 when he turned to the dark side (and when Luke and Leia were born). Based on everything we know, Luke was 24-26 at the time of Vader’s death in ROTJ. Anakin/Vader was at least in his mid 50’s when he died.

[@skinnylegend0272]

Kamdyn Eisele no I think he was probably 24-25 or younger because he was 10-11 in the phantom menace and the clone wars takes place 10 years after which makes him 20-21 and then revenge of the sith takes place 2-3 years after the clone wars so I’d say he was 23-24

[@dff1286]

I liked this. the outcome felt very logical.

[@odinallmight4481]

yes very much!

[@jennarevan6909]

Lucasarts actually released a special action figure pack in 2004 which included a comic that completely undermines this what if video.

[@robrockstar9648]

There were a few moments that I thought were slightly off but I would consider this a possibility and any changes I would make would end up at pretty much the same result

[@alexanderkazakov9861]

In this scenario, Luke, in his attempt to protect Vader from the Rebels, kinda turned to the dark side because of his feelings. Anakin did the same years before that.

[@adarkwind4712]

Alexander Kazakov how so everything he did was in defense not attack. Like a Jedi.

[@Theunfriendlyneighborhoodman]

Luke was trying to protect me from the rebellion

[@Apollosonic]

"Maybe it's Snoke" lmao

[@zacharyschafer9493]

Grant Howell bruh

[@Axel_Xirics_Music]

I still remember how i cried like a mad man when i saw Anakin giving his last breath on the second Death Star. And i still shed a tear for a man seeking redemption beyond the material plane. As a force ghost. He is where he belongs :3

[@mikeyjnson]

The Man Who Sold the World Star Wars: Infinities

[@DrPickleful]

What if the Jedi sent Anakin to kill Grievous like he suggested?

[@trevorfeller9361]

omg that would change the whole series after revenge of the with that's a good what if because I wonder if he would have died by order 66 also he wouldn't have been able to tell mace windoe that palpateen is a sith

[@santoconnor4116]

there WOULDN'T be a Order 66^^

[@capes_and_tights]

Yes there would lol

[@Velticus]

What should have happened is he should have kept his ass put like Windu ordered him to

[@mattirwin140]

I would like to see what would have happened in that scenario

[@Rensune]

First, he'd change his colors to White.

[@davidsmith3949]

Yeah. He did that in Infinites.

[@Durovnax]

lmao

[@FatrickAteman]

WHOA RACIST

[@FatrickAteman]

nobody on the internet will ever pause to think "maybe he's joking?"

[@ashmyblunt]

Anakin wore black before he was Vader anyway

[@Soup-man]

You understood Luke's character more than Rian Johnson. Wow!

[@Yeentenology]

Seriously?🤣🤣🤣

[@dexmoses6887]

who's Rian Johnson ?

[@Edude117]

Wow... this brought a tear to my eye. A redeemed Darth Vader is the very definition of a happy ending.

[@QuinSkew]

What if Jar Jar really is a Sith Lord but was basically hiding his power making his own empire

[@willhammer9805]

That's not a 'what if' though

[@The_world_is_not_worthy_of_Him]

Yeah, that's canon lol

[@bigbancebarnage]

+Raging “GeekyGaming” Gamer lmao

[@jointhe6461]

I have it on good authority that Jar Jar is the key to all this.

[@GrimDankHeretic]

messa discovered dah secret to sith immortality now messa can be in starwars forever with yousa XD

[@realtedbear]

It would've sounded cooler if you said "That monster killed not thousands, not millions, but billions of innocent people."

[@lordmorgoth7]

Ted Bear trillions

[@imadethisaccounttocomment294]

Ted Bear it is in the billion range. orders to blow up planets, ending planets personally.

[@nathanwygal5526]

He never gave the orders to destroy planets. Tarkin was in charge of the first Death Star that blew up Scarif and Alderaan and Krennic was in charge of it when it blew up Jedha. So the most murderous dude of the bunch besides Palpatine is definitely Tarkin in the OT.

[@imadethisaccounttocomment294]

Nathan Wygal according to a few comics he also did in a couple planets, non-canon now though....

[@CarlosSanchez-uo2zi]

I got two idea for your what if series what if Mace Windu call a emergency meeting for the Jedi Council before going to arresting Palpatine or what if Anakin tell Padme about Palpatine being Darth Sidious

[@tilly7689]

This ain’t among us

[@MadWonderXL]

Possible video idea, What if Obi Wan never had the high ground in ep 3

[@Oddragnar]

MadWonderXL Vader kills Palpatine and becomes emperor it's in one of the games

[@MadWonderXL]

Not what I expected but alright

[@kingdom99hearts]

+MadWonderXL Well it makes sense. Anakin was much weaker in his connection to the force after he was put into the suit. If he wasn't put into the suit he could have killed Palpatine.

[@MadWonderXL]

+SonOfSin It definitely makes sense. I was just wondering who would have won the fight on mustafar? would Obi have killed Anakin, would Anakin kill Obi and if so ho would of mentored Luke? Assuming he wasn't pushed into the lava during the fight he wouldn't be in a suit meaning that he wouldn't necessarily die at the end of Return of the Jedi. I just find myself wondering about these things.

[@kingdom99hearts]

+MadWonderXL There's a good chance Anakin would have raised and mentored Luke, however it gets hard to guess what would happen if the characters actions deviate.

[@saltiestorm1767]

I would enjoy it if Vader survived. Just imagine how cool it would be in the last jedi if not just Luke arrived, but Vader too.

[@Yeentenology]

Oh, Lord! 🤩

[@atulvikram5279]

People get this fact wrong, Vader is dead, he died the moment he saved his son. Anakin Skywalker was reborn and alive and saved by luke

[@saltiestorm1767]

@@atulvikram5279 you've completely missed the point of what I just said.

[@atulvikram5279]

@@saltiestorm1767 oh "in" the last jedi. Sorry my bad

[@saltiestorm1767]

@@atulvikram5279 no it's fine, it's easy to misread stuff online all the time, doesn't matter either way. You're good.

[@johnpinkston3818]

What if Anakin left the Jedi Order when Ahsoka did?

[@knightguard1724]

No empire

[@welch1nc240]

I think the empire would still happen but would just take longer to happen

[@talesoffan4718]

I think it would happen quicker depending on his continued friendship with Palpatine. Because if he left, Anakin would not have been quite so conflicted by his loyalty towards the jedi.

[@dante3664]

Emperor: screw it! Execute order 66!

[@Zerath0]

Anakin leaving the order wouldn't stop order 66, just think about, was there real reason Palpatine needed Anakin to become the Emperor? No.

[@yoyo1425]

I would've liked to see Vader surviving and get his suit upgraded and help the Jedi Everyone deserves a second chance Maybe a movie one day

[@DarkAnon100]

well there is an one-shot what if COMIC of Return of the Jedi that was released a few years ago that shown what would have happened if Anakin came back to the light, but that Palpatine also survive and Basically, that comic end with Anakin joining the the rebels and vowing to eliminate Palpatine, while wearing a White Version of his Darth Vader Armor, it's actually pretty cool, you can probably found it or pictures of it on google

[@raspberryjam3724]

I thought that said "get his shit upgraded"

[@Bubatanka]

You underestimate the power of the Dark Side. That second chance would end up becoming the new Sith Empire under Emperor Vader.

[@perseus6107]

all this could have been avoided if an-akin just let windu kill palpatine

[@felixdesjardins4030]

Perseus Yea ..

[@scottaitchison7167]

Sure. That's why Anakin was a Jedi and Darth Vader the sith. Sidious was the master manipulator and twisted his mind until it was broken. Of course sidious knew anakin was the chosen one. The ending to rotj is perfect!!! Anakin finally defeating Vader and returning to the light.

[@commanderneyo6152]

Order 66 is cool tho but still sad

[@Helljumper3096]

All of this could have been avoided if the Jedi Council actually trusted Anakin, and didn't screw him over at every turn.

[@death-bn4os]

Gage Minor it's like they wanted him to turn to the dark side !

[@joshmansfield1123]

What if Dooku had revealed to Anakin that Palpatine was Sideous right before he was killed?

[@FieryMeltman]

Sideous would probably kill both of them.

[@mattirwin140]

not that good of a what if im afraid

[@mariabatti7356]

I would have loved to see Count Dooku tell Anakin Skywalker: "All those years ago, Chancellor Palpatine was the one who tried to assassinate Padme Amidala. Chancellor Palpatine is the Sith lord that the Jedi counsel have been searching for." Then Anakin would take Count Doodu's light saber and kill Palpatine with it. And it would all be over.

[@barcabocalda2583]

+FDrybob _ hahahahaha YEA NO XD. It won't be that easy Dooku would die though AnakinSkywalker would bring balance to the force right their

[@barcabocalda2583]

+Maria Batti and Dooku would redeemed

[@TheRevenantEdits]

If DV was still alive, he prolly would've just ordered Luke to leave him to die in a prison cell so that he may pay for his crimes and that he may finally see the face of his beloved Padme once again.

[@TheRevenantEdits]

Or just do something that'll get him killed-off later, or maybe do a sacrifice.

[@jonathanmichael771]

Luke wouldn't let him die no matter how bad he wants to die

[@ljsports2844]

Elijah Patriarca No because y'all forget he also loved his kids, wife and mom, I think he would love to see his kids.

[@SarynPrime]

I'M CRYING

[@AlexKaneROTN]

You're an idiot

[@cheez2550]

Do you realise that the most op character in Star Wars is the medical droid 1) it could’ve killed Vader 2) it could’ve taken Luke’s hand off (and probably kill him) 3) it is a legend

[@dr.toxicgamingmadscientist]

This comment is like around 5 others where it comments about the droid, ITS PROGRAMMED TO DO AS IT IS TOLD, HOW IS THAT OP?!

[@kianbb7452]

I wish Star Wars was like this it would be such a great story

[@bloodcontagion]

KBBCraftBattle88 8 but the original way is so much more dramatic, tragic and memorable.

[@JeremWatts]

nah this story is much better

[@onlybrad8434]

tbh they would have done that if they had planed to make more episodes after 6, but they didn't. so they killed all the bad guys.

[@kevingipe702]

This would've been way better, I'd love to see what a post suit light side anakin would be like

[@MaaruiSeikatsu]

It’s impossible to wish for this. Anakin, the chosen one, was meant to die when he killed Palpatine. Because only by dying, he can bring back balance to the Force, fulfilling the prophecy he has carried his entire life. The true balanced world means that there is no dark side or light side in the Force. And as Yoda passed away and Luke was not a Jedi yet, when Anakin killed palpatine, there was no light side left and Anakin was the only dark side Force user. So by passing away himself, Anakin made it possible that all the light and dark sides of the Force vanished in the world. This is what the prophecy meant. This, I believe, is the core idea of the entire Star Wars stories. All the incidents in the series happen centering around this. So if we wish for Anakin alive after The ROJ, the entire plot meant nothing.

[@CanMav]

Excellent video. Perhaps another "What if?" could be, "What if Luke had died on Hoth at the hands of the Wampa?"

[@hew966]

Smart idea I agree

[@yoda8308]

What if I (Yoda) had died before I could train Luke?

[@MrSlicker13]

read star wars inifinities

[@Star-ht2tz]

Then rip the galaxy

[@mannerchannel7540]

Yeah, good ideas!

[@ncc74656m]

Also, I don't think Anakin could truly have survived the shame of everything he had done. The way he died said everything we needed to know about who he was and how he felt. "It is too late for me, son," Vader, or perhaps it was Anakin even then, trying to find a way out, said at the shuttle pad. After the throne room, it was more than just too late to save his physical body, but too late for true redemption. Anakin's last act had been not just for redemption or a symbol of his change, but largely motivated almost exclusively to save his son, at any cost. Anakin came with him to the shuttle not because he thought he would live to escape, he had to know he was dying. He came because he realized Luke would never leave without him, and he could not save him only to let him die now.

[@MrSurferman93]

katie_incredible But Anakin was redeamed..

[@MrConstantine02]

Anakin turned back to the light, but that doesn't erase the terrible things he had done. Most likely, after turning back to the light, the shame and guilt for all the evil he did and the pain he caused onto others would have been too much for him. He wouldn't have been able to live with himself.

[@yellowbricks5538]

If there’s ever a Star Wars what if I’m Disney+ this would be absolutely awesome

[@fruitylerlups530]

Just like 30 minute animations, maybe by LucasFilm animations, of different scenarios

[@chiefbigsad7995]

what if obi wan did not leave anakin on mustafar, instead taking him with him and trying to help him return to the light.

[@lonen6687]

*anakin

[@coreblue762]

Then Anakin would probably have died. Palpatine had that suit specifically prepared because of Anakin's injuries. Obi-Wan would probably take him to Polis Massa where he would die, even with their medical resources.

[@jaketimberlake9023]

Maybe before he caught fire

[@ovs8691]

My very own fanfiction is actually about this very question. In my story, everything happens the same except that there is much more talking then there is fighting and it is clear that ObiWan is getting through to him. At the end, ObiWan still maims him, but the lava river bank isn't as steep and Obiwan commences talking without having to worry about him attacking him. Anakin in the end does catch fire, but the flames don't engulf him, they stop at his waist, but what is burned is twice as bad to the point of were his muscles would never recover. Anakin calls to ObiWan in a very weak voice to help him. Sensing change in him, ObiWan realizes that the boy he met all those years ago is back, there is no hate inside of him, only pain and sadness. He picks up Anakin and carries him toward the shuttle and places him next to Padme. He extends his remaining arm, trying to reach her, but he can't she's too far away and he is too weak. They arrive on Polis Massa and Padme gives birth to both Luke and Leia, but dies due to Palpatine draining her energy and life. In another room, Anakin is stable, but looks down to see 3 stumps. ObiWan and Yoda enters and tells him that his wife has perished, filled with grief Anakin lets out a powerful scream and the wall panels begin to crumble and fold, Anakin has lost everything, again. As he cries in his bed a medical droid brings him two beautiful babies and tells him that they are his children. Colour returns to his face as he smiles with tears running down his cheeks. "I will protect them with all my hart padme." he mumbles.

[@Freezer7596]

This please

[@captaintaco2345]

Now I want to see Luke and Vader battling an army of Sith together. I bet Vader would have a different suit though.

[@andrewcarmichael2371]

I think Vader would replace is suit for something better.

[@MegamanZXOmega]

There actually is a non-canon comic that details a what-if on if Vader survived. I don't remember the full details of it, but what I DO know is that Vader's suit is replaced with an all white colored version of it to signify that he's back in the light. And really, it looks a bit off.

[@commanderneyo6152]

Mon motho ma has a bowl cut😃

[@commanderneyo6152]

Mon mothma

[@erikodinson9288]

I have the comic I think the white looks awesome

[@nightmaretrooper5064]

Erik Odinson Star Wars Infinity.

[@ERACLAB]

its good and everything, but did they actually expect to apprehend Luke with small number of troops or even restrain him?

[@justin2308]

Xitrin Well, you see, politicians and military officers in the Star Wars universe have this really bad habit of not thinking with their heads- which, come to think of it, is actually a realistic problem we have in the real world.

[@ayushbanerjeeroll1197]

Yup

[@themis467]

Or Darth Vader? He could break all of their necks.

[@maddyhoke3907]

I would love to see a series exploring Luke and Vader's relationship. What would they disagree about? How would they react to different situations? Does Luke completely forgive Vader for everything? Plus, you could get some really cool action scenes with Luke and Vader fighting together.

[@temko6710]

What if all clones disobeyed Order 66 and turned turned against Anakin & Palpatine?

[@itsarkow8481]

Yes thats great

[@saintjimmy_ajh]

He's already made a video on that, I think it was called "What if order 66 never happened"

[@tristanlau1213]

This is possible if the bio-chips in the clones' brain is not working

[@sameershahzad293]

Then they Fucked, simple...

[@Wishiwasagoat]

Yes!

[@hetgoudenduo3480]

i like this ending better

[@nicrolooes5315]

Ya but it wouldn't be as good as the original

[@EliteZilla2019]

me too

[@m.r.o.]

What if: Palpatine was good since beginning and Yoda was evil in secret.

[@evantaylor2883]

Yeah that empire of his did a lot of good mmmm.

[@thermslusitania1151]

@@evantaylor2883 yes but they have slavery they blew up a planet that had many loyal to the Empire on it and the top it all they have labor camps basically concentration camps read those in the book and Darth Vader Slaughter children Indian boy killed many innocent people so we think that please

[@stephenquinn7931]

@@thermslusitania1151 aren't you vader?

[@jacob414]

Wolfy Reaction I don’t remember them having slavery and Alderaan was less populated so the empire chose them to avoid many more deaths

[@griffinhillner3501]

What are you talking about? Palpatine was always the good guy. #empiredidnothingwrong