What If DUNCAN was ELIMINATED in DODGEBRAWL? | Total Drama Island

[@Charles-xe4ow]

Fun fact: During the episode. Courtney said that if Duncan didn't help them, they would vote him off, so I don't get why people eliminate Sadie here if the Killer Bass loose

[@sau7255]

Because she's overweight

[@Simplyywoodland]

It was probably just a bluff. In the previous episode they voted out Eva, one of their strongest players, so I don’t think they’d make the same mistake twice

[@Charles-xe4ow]

@@Simplyywoodland Yeah lol

[@theleandrox1809]

If anything they'd vote off Tyler, it's hard to believe that they'd vote off rather than Tyler who despite trying to help a lot, showed that he was very useless. I love Tyler but things as they are

[@daniii_BH]

That was almost a foreshadowing, the person that Bridgette most hates, after being eleminated made her win lol

[@jordancollins444]

You totally glared over Sadie after sucky outdoors, oh no wait, that was cannon

[@drjasper528]

Love this sm can you do what if katie and sadie were on different teams?

[@pixelrakurai]

I feel like in an alternative version of this idea, Tyler is voted off instead since he was actively hanging out with a member of the other time and did bad in the challenge. But this is interesting nonetheless.

[@supermontythomas2159]

Idea: What if Alejandro, Sierra, and Blainley were in Island? Another idea: What if the teams in Total Drama Island were decided by first eleven to show up, and the last eleven who showed up?

[@anchorsaway9500]

I was actually surprised how long Justin lasted in this timeline. Being on opposite teams I didn’t think Duncan affected his elimination but I guess Noah being his scapegoat helped him. I like the idea of Bridgette getting to the end so I’m all for this timeline. Duncan getting eliminated that early didn’t have a massive effect in total drama at first glance but there are some differences that are noticeable. Shows how big of a character Duncan was

[@Scribblebob9990]

He did make the merge in every season after all.

[@DravenEgg]

​@@Scribblebob9990 Yep

[@comfyghost]

eh… justin not getting voted off is questionable. for one thing, just the addition of an extra player makes building an alliance harder, but also it'd be a lot easier to blame someone who arguably lost the challenge, and justin's act was really weird and confusing while noah didn't even get a chance to ruin anything. but as i said, it'd be hard for heather to build an alliance, since with one extra player, she now needs an extra vote to guarantee her safety, and she needs that safety because she definitely is responsible for their loss, and between noah and justin, i think it'd be a lot easier to convince noah to vote with her instead of against her (and she'd also see justin as a bigger threat since people seem to like him)

[@Totally_Awesome56]

Omg yes I have wanted to see a what if like this forever

[@supermontythomas2159]

Just subscribed! This was amazing btw.

[@RandomName-2222]

This could also change Action to be fair because Bridgette and Geoff might focus on the challenge more

[@SSTSpas-12SGSTL]

You should do if there was actually voting in Lindsay’s elimination episode

[@ilovefionagubelmann]

my duncney wouldnt exist.

[@rosamendoza5949]

Suggestion: what if bridgette never tried to cheat on geoff

[@tulipmango8876]

Good job really enjoyed the video :)

[@RainbowDashFan364]

Fun fact: if Duncan got the boot, Courtney would have lasted much longer.

[@-goofygoober-.-]

Suggestion: what if the heather alliance never happened?

[@ThatOneSandwichGuy]

Idk if Courtney would still vote for Sadie in Who Can you Trust i think Courtney showed her dislike towards DJ a few times and if he threw the challenge cause of a Rabbit Courtney would def have something to say about it i think Courtney, Sadie and Harold might be tempted to vote for DJ this time, Bridgette, DJ and Geoff vote for Sadie causing a potential tie clearly obvious DJ would win the tie but it's just a potential scenario i see could happen

[@BlueTotalDrama]

Suggestion: What if MK never stole Julia's phone (julia stops her or MK just decides not to)

[@ThrarmAnimation]

I really think it would have been smarter to boot Courtney during Phobia Factor in this timeline, Courtney stays as long as she does because she has plot relevance, but without Duncan she doesnt. Tyler has a thing for Lindsay and Lindsay is in Heather's alliance, that could create a really good plotline and potentially set in place Lindsay abandoning the alliance for Tyler. I think eliminating Tyler there was unwise from the story-telling perspective.

[@artichopes]

Great Vid! Would be nice to see ‘What If Laurie Didn’t Get Bitten By Ants’

[@raymondthefiregod5598]

Suggestion: What if Ridonculous Race was a Blood VS Water season of Total Drama?

[@tomidrac9719]

I see blood vs water everywhere but what does it mean??

[@raymondthefiregod5598]

@@tomidrac9719 Basically it means that a duo gets put on opposite teams.

[@midnalazuli793]

@@raymondthefiregod5598 Not quite. “Blood vs. Water” pits familiar relationships against intimate ones. Basically, “blood” refers to people who are related by blood, while “water” refers to people who aren’t. For example, Alejandro and Jose are brothers, so they are blood, while Geoff and Brody are best friends, so they’re water.

[@tristianfigueroa6302]

You should make a "what if total drama action with the full cast?"

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Ezekiel kept his mouth shut?

[@LarryStewart-hj7ky]

I loved the video 10/10 ♥️. Can you do what if all stars had Owen and brick.

[@entymash]

How about what if DJ never took off his blindfold? Or if he didn't, but Chris didn't care about the rules?

[@googamp32]

Suggestion: What if Gwen and Trent never broke up?

[@realteamwall]

the only thing i would change is having the finale be bridgette and geoff and then i would decide the action cast based on their placements compared to the canon placements of the real action cast on island 24th - Ezekiel 23rd - Eva 22nd - Duncan 21st - Noah 20th - Katie 19th - Tyler 18th - Izzy 17th - Cody 16th - Beth 15th - Sadie 14th - Harold 13th - Courtney 12th - Eva 11th - Trent 10th - Justin 9th - DJ 8th - Heather 7th - Lindsay 6th - Izzy 5th - Leshawna 4th - Owen 3rd - Gwen 1st/2nd - Bridgette and Geoff

[@Novaughe]

Idea: what if courtney chose Justin over duncan in action for the princess episode? It can carry on to the love triangle in world tour

[@scottyoung7233]

cannot wait for another multi season what if.. speaking of, I have another one(s) for ya. What if (Insert TD couple here) never got together

[@ultimatetoelicker]

ooh thats a really good suggestion

[@fnfhax77950]

Can you do what if? Heather was eliminated instead of justin

[@jaydenbrown9314]

Can you do a what if video about what if Sadie and Katie never stop to eat the berries or just tell their team they're grabbing some berries. So can you please make a video about it.

[@rEdbrICkmArOOnAUbUrn4975]

Mr Coconut always getting robbed 😔✊

[@Supreme-AMVs]

Could you do what if Katie and Izzy didn’t switch teams, or what if izekiel and Staci switch seasons

[@LarryStewart-hj7ky]

2 people already did this.

[@ethancleveland1450]

What if All-Stars had Owen or Leshawna instead of Sierra and Brick instead of Sam?

[@lennasims_13]

i love it just bcz of bridge, my diva would totally win it

[@vjvtobar9736]

Part2?

[@doyourememberme]

What if Noah had helped with the DODGEBRAWL?

[@blankblankness2971]

Final ranking: 22. Ezekiel (Point of divergence below) 21. Duncan 20. Noah 19. Katie 18. Tyler 17. Cody 16. Beth 15. Sadie 14. Harold 13. Courtney 12. Eva 11. Trent 10. Justin 9. Lindsay 8. DJ 7. Heather 6. Izzy 5. Leshawna (4.5. Mr. Coconut) 4. Owen 3. Geoff 2. Gwen 1. Bridgette Not qualified for the next season: Ezekiel, Noah, Katie, Tyler, Cody, Sadie, Courtney, Eva

[@ahmadstewasamlrt2202]

What if Goku was in Total Drama Island🏝

[@semvermeulen7039]

Dis will not end well but it can be a good one for a April Fools What if

[@J-G9991]

I feel like I might get some flack for this, but food for thought: from a social perspective isn't he just Owen but fit, straight and without the fart jokes? Both are well meaning, but with a somewhat child-like naivety people who love food. Saiyans like to test their skills in combat too, but this characteristic is more comparable to Harold if anyone.

[@PerpIsPerp]

Goku will slaughter everyone 🤣🤣

[@coriseoris]

Heather fodder

[@MrGreen-jx2kw]

@@PerpIsPerpHarold would beat goku to it

[@Thierrynascarandarca]

What if transformers g1 had a elemonation order

[@Cactusrahhhhh]

I’m 90% Noah’s elimination in this CANT happen. In that episode (unless Im wrong) the only 3 up for elimination were those who participated in the talent show.

[@LightroStorm]

There's nothing implying that in the show, I'm afraid.

[@Cactusrahhhhh]

@@LightroStorm I assumed that because (if I remember correctly) they were the only 3 sitting down, and it’s a common assumption

[@LightroStorm]

@@Cactusrahhhhh Only Justin and Heather were sitting. Trent was with everyone else.

[@Cactusrahhhhh]

@@LightroStorm ohh I see

[@Kibbygams]

wow

[@czerwonystudio6301]

I like those videos i really do, but PLEASE don't do the same cast for action for no reason... it feels like a middle finger to us when you say "let's just say that Chris chooses random cast and it is the same as the orginal cast". NO! if you want go with randomisation you are acually doing randomisation, not picking what results will be. Sorry I just find it kinda annoying. Everything else is great, just you forcing the same cast for action is an issue. I am not trying to hate or be mean, it is serious sugestion to help you improve.

[@razordog4667]

What if ezekiel wasnt raised sexist

[@-goofygoober-.-]

I think they did that

[@razordog4667]

@@-goofygoober-.- no they did wt with 2 teams and zeke in all stars

[@icemariofan2746]

Fourth maybe 🤔

[@ronswanson7371]

Third probably

[@vjvtobar9736]

I just found out by the KZbinr drama Dairy that LaShawna was eliminated in the episode because of her voice actor couldn't come to the studio and that's why she doesn't say anything it was supposed to be a fashion challenge also the network is the reason behind why Duncan returned into World Tour what if Duncan didn't return

[@Dinksteredits]

OK That's Just Not True Lol

[@reidavi2323]

Chef gets the sole vote in the final 4, so I think would be: 4. Geoff 3. Bridgette 2./1. Owen and Gwen

[@semvermeulen7039]

Like 50

[@Mudkip_lieker13]

Tdi would be better

[@fallshello65]

Help me out pls