What If Eva WON Immunity? | Total Drama Island

Eva's return in Total Drama Island was very short-lived. But what if she was able to gain immunity and avoid elimination?
More Total Drama content: • Total Drama
Discord: / discord
Twitter: @LightroStorm
Edited by supersavage789: / @supersavage789
Less Rake by tubebackr / tubebackr
Creative Commons - Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported - CC BY-ND 3.0
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/45bHCJr
Music promoted by Audio Library • Less Rake - tubebackr ...
Epic by Bensound: • Bensound: "Epic" - Orc...
Change Your World by Artificial.Music / artificial-music
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0
Free Download: bit.ly/3Hv3kNZ
Music promoted by Audio Library • Change Your World - Ar...
feellikedying by Loxbeats spoti.fi/34tPBBO
Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported - CC BY 3.0
Free Download / Stream: bit.ly/2RjmWP3
Music promoted by Audio Library • feellikedying - Loxbea...

[@user-zd5si5hr2r]

What if Dawn proved that she was innocent? (TDROTI) What if Sammy managed to expose Amy? (TDPI) What if Lindsay knew how to drive a baby carriage? (TDAS) What if Leshawna never talked smack about the other contestants? (TDA)

[@zaineoakley5555]

Lindsay knew how to she pretended to not know because she didn’t want to be on the show

[@LikableFish243]

@@zaineoakley5555 I actually think she just said that to annoy Courtney as payback for Action because at that point in the episode she wasn't fed up with the competition and she didn't want to go yet. Also she made dumb remarks and actions specifically to the people that she hates (saying Heather misses Alejandro, not mentioning that Courtney was in the baby carriage when Sierra got in despite clearly seeing her. ect.) a classic case of proving the haters right in a way to get back at them.

[@ABHBD_]

​@@zaineoakley5555that's just a theory

[@Blankspace-unrelated-to-song]

Leshawna could’ve made finals in both Action And Island if the writers were logical

[@icemariofan2746]

What if Ezekiel was in team Amazon or What if Harold voted out Duncan instead of Courtney?

[@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800]

Courtney out meant it wasn’t obvious Duncan out would make it obvious who did it Fyi

[@icemariofan2746]

@@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800I don’t care

[@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800]

Ok

[@OpticalSorcerer]

1. Team Victory may not have went on a losing streak, and Team Amazon would've voted him out at the first chance. He'd have the most potential on Team Chris, as Alejandro would find him easy to manipulate for voting power. 2. If Harold got Duncan gone, Chris may have brought him back instead of (or with) Eva for the drama. Harold may have framed someone else for the vote since it'd be obvious that it was him--but then again, it's not hard to buy that Duncan wasn't popular. Courtney wasn't unhinged in TDI, so she'd make it far, but I think she'd eventually get flustered and lose her cool later on. Harold would probably still be eliminated for the Xtreme sports challenge--unless Courtney and Lindsay are together for the ski challenge, and Courtney may give her a rougher time than Duncan. Or alternate take: she pulls a TDWT and tries to throw challenges to get Harold gone (if she knows he got rid of Duncan), but she might get eliminated instead.

[@alexmfs]

​@@reversedizzythebackwardsth7800how? Many people hated duncan

[@kharihammon9784]

I think Eva goes around 7th. She could feasibly win all the challenges before that, but even if she does win this challenge it doesn’t matter because she isn’t gifted with immunity regardless.

[@CarolinaBeanies]

What if Cody wasn’t dazed in world tour, and voted Courtney?

[@lordkinesis4432]

It's interesting to me that Eva and Izzy returned in the same episode and Eva would've then gotten eliminated in Izzy's episode.

[@langdonledwig3734]

For this then Heather would most definitely be booted in that episode

[@akiraa2.0]

finally! some eva development.

[@OpticalSorcerer]

This is a fun AU! I do prefer Heather as the overall villain, though. Could you do an AU where Courtney fails to convice Harold to eliminate Leshawna in TDA?

[@user-zd5si5hr2r]

Courtney had invincibility, so Duncan would be out instead.

[@OpticalSorcerer]

@@user-zd5si5hr2r Oh, that's true. I forgot about that. I'd like to see how that threw her off her game.

[@StxxrStruck]

I have an idea for a what if - What if Sierra Didn't Fall in love with Cody before World Tour? some Ideas I thought of for it aswell: -Sierra doesn't blow up the plane in the final 4 bc she doesn't know its Cody's birthday due to not extensively searching him up -People treat Sierra much nicer due to her not being seen as an obsessive stalker -Cody could actually fall in love with her after Gwen leaves, although im not sure if he would be able to make it that far due to Sierra not carrying him -Sierra can actually utilise her knowledge about the show aswell due to not obsessing over Cody (She would be able ti figure out Alejandro's nice act and wouldn't be manipulated by him in New York into making Chris hate her, allowing her to get benefits in the competition due to Chris' favouritism of her gloating about him) I jul love to see this as Sierra is one of my favourites and she got robbed in the final 4, despite it being in character. Just sucks for her tbh

[@zackmenard7501]

What If Ideas 👀👀 What if Wayne/Raj weren't evacuated? What if TDWT followed Survivor format & Team Victory merged to other teams? (DJ/Lindsay) What if the TDROTI team forming at been consistent?

[@mymorganfn]

if wayne and raj weren't evacuated there would be more gay kissing☠☠☠☠

[@Robert___98]

@@mymorganfnAnd?

[@mymorganfn]

i didnt say nothing was wrong with it lil bro@@Robert___98

[@mihaitavraciu2248]

​@@mymorganfnoh fuck no

[@gabrielrodriguesmilech3605]

Survivor format?

[@jakubwiktor5874]

3:27 this is such duncan move I LOVE IT!!!

[@PepsieCat]

Loved the video man.

[@LikableFish243]

What if Cartoon Network didn't interfere with the show. This would mean Trent stays sane and the love triangle never happens which both affect the show a lot.

[@LeonDeLlama]

Nice vid, very insightful

[@mariachrzski18]

I do like the idea of having the tie win between Geoff and Owen and having them both as the winners in all parts of the world

[@stevnethecoolguy]

Alt ending where Eva never got voted off in Wawanakwa Gone Wild and made it to the finale: Eva hears Izzy let out a war cry and dodges the tranquilizer dart, makes it to the bear cave and mauls the bear, she brings the hairless bear to the cage just by carrying it and wins immunity. Izzy gets eliminated instead. In Trial By Tri-Armed Triathlon, Eva and Duncan become a duo, Eva force feeds Duncan the food as quick as possible to which Duncan ends up choking, and Owen and Bridgette win the first challenge, for the second challenge, Geoff and Gwen win just like in the canon version (if i remember correctly), and in the last part of the challenge, Eva yells at Duncan to keep stacking the heads and they end up winning the last round so no one gets immunity, Since everyone decides to vote Geoff off in the canon version instead of Heather, the same thing happens here but everyone votes off Geoff instead of Eva. In Haute Camp-ture, Katie and Sadie voted Bridgette for her positivity and everyone else votes Bridgette off on accident. In Camp Castaways, Eva uses her strength to beat up the snake and everyone makes it back to camp in their tribal wear, Mr Coconuts sadly gets eliminated. In Are We There Yeti? Eva once again uses her strength and her and Gwen end up winning immunity, Duncan gets eliminated like in the canon version. In I Triple Dog Dare You, Eva wins all her dares (Heather's Dares) and gets a lot of freebies, when she has to shave her head, which Gwen passed onto Eva, Eva uses a freebie and Owen has to get his head shaved instead, but before Chef can shave his head, Owen freaks out and runs away, so Owen gets eliminated instead, In the finale its Gwen vs Eva, mostly everyone roots for Gwen, since Owen isnt in the finale, the brownies never appear to make Owen charge toward them, and Gwen ends up winning with Eva coming in second place FINAL RESULTS Eliminated in Wawanakwa Gone Wild- Izzy Eliminated in Trial By Tri-Armed Triathlon- Geoff Eliminated in Hatue Camp-ture- Bridgette Eliminated in Camp Castaways- Mr Coconuts Eliminated in Are We There Yeti?- Duncan Eliminated in I Triple Dog Dare You- Owen 2nd Place in The Very Last Episode, Really!- Eva (Alternative Ending) 1st Place in The Very Last Episode, Really!- Gwen (Canon Ending

[@LightroStorm]

This is really good. If I were to do "What If Eva Won?" it would pretty much follow this path, but I'd have Gwen lose in ITDDY, since I think Owen and Eva would be able to do more than her. Great job (:

[@stevnethecoolguy]

@@LightroStorm Thanks! The only reason I put Owen getting eliminated in ITDDY is because Gwen used her freebie to pass it onto Heather so I just kept that but with Eva instead

[@itslele_]

I wanted to suggest a what if like: what if who didn’t sing in Total Drama World Tour was instant elimination (or something like that)? Since in the very first song Chris (or I guess Bridgette) says that to stay in the game they need to sing each song, but I have no idea how this could work out

[@LikableFish243]

If I'm correct Cody, Noah Tyler and DJ assuming instances where Chris said only some people had to sing (Stuck to a pole, Fight for the gold. ect.) don't count because if they did then almost all of the cast would be gone by episode 4.

[@KDawg92801]

There’d be no show cause everyone would’ve been eliminated

[@itslele_]

@@KDawg92801 not necessarily, like every episode you take someone and then in episode with songs like stuck to a pole or the Amazon one the ones that actually sings gets immunity and the others don’t. For example: in the Amazon episode they still lose, Courtney and Cody are the ones that didn’t sing so the other 3 are allowed to only vote for one of the two, then Chris would still say is a non elimination episode so nobody goes. Sure there will be a point where will be impossible to determine who didn’t sing since there’s different/ missing people, then it will be just a normal what if with a different cast but could still be fun with some imagination 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@pokehunterhd]

I think a funny what if would be if they took justin's suggestion and voted chef off in the sandwich project instead of D.J.....this would probably be more suited for april fools day.

[@Rabbitolucas200.]

TDWT: What if Ezekiel was actually good at anything

[@ethanalgicosathlonchannel1110]

I’m really excited to watch this!

[@ifli8681]

Do what if Heather never took Eva’s mp3 player

[@pepemunoz7845]

They most likely wouldve kept Eva all the way since she is the best player

[@TotaldramaEzekiel129]

Eva has the least screen time from the original cast.

[@anemoia-cx9vg]

YEESSS MORE EVA CONTENTTTT!!!

[@_heather.feather]

I still don't think Bridgette would have been voted out there. They barely had any interactions with her, but Gwen. Lindsay and a lot of them liked Gwen, people start saying "Don't say GWEN" and even the parrot does that. So, in the end, Gwen would be eliminated. Then, I think Duncan and Bridgette will vote for Owen because if it's a fighting challenge or something, he is winning. Although, Owen and Geoff vote for Bridgette, since they both form an alliance. So, it's a tie. But, surprise, surprise, they get that dare challenge and have to fight each other. That was the first and hardest dare, so, no one has a freebie and neither can they give to the other one because it will be the same. As a result, Owen wins and Bridgette goes home. Now, the question may be: "Why didn't they vote Duncan instead of Bridgette?" Answer: They found out about their little alliance. They also knew that Bridgette is the weaker one if them. Geoff resisted at first, but he knew that if he wins, he will split the money with her. Now that the fighting challenge is over, there is nothing Geoff can't beat him in. Next episode, is a race. Owen did something smart for once, he threw Geoff very far and he quickly reached the finish line, winning immunity. It made it obvious that they had an alliance and hence voted Duncan off. Doesn't matter what the next challenge was, but it made Geoff the official winner with Owen being the alt winner.

[@LightroStorm]

Lindsay did not like Gwen. Gwen literally threatened to beat her up 😭

[@_heather.feather]

@@LightroStorm Yeah, but one time she did. Probably because of the prank

[@Cherry_coke_pop]

What if Sadie swapped onto the screaming gophers instead of Katie switching to the killer bass?

[@havikrogers1801]

Who would switch to the Killer Bass then?

[@Cherry_coke_pop]

@@havikrogers1801 not sure maybe Lindsay given that she’s gullible I see heather taking advantage of the besties when they’re on her team

[@bigshaqexegaming5748]

Never really understood why Eva lost that challenge in the first place. Like she won her competition. She only lost because she went before Leshawna? Seems a bit dumb. It would make sense if she lost because she wanted Bridgette to get punished but I don't think that's what happened.

[@Tele230]

yeah its cause she “challenged” Leshawna to go, and Leshawna completed her challenge which eliminated her. I feel like there should have been an exception but they wanted Eva out so they did what they wanted to

[@bigshaqexegaming5748]

@@Tele230 oh okay that makes sense. I guess I wasn't paying enough attention. Thanks for clarifying this for me!

[@OpticalSorcerer]

​@@Tele230I think the writers just brought Eva back for shock factor. It would've been a cool plot twist if Heather was eliminated earlier and we think she's a good person, but she's brought back and manipulates her way through without most people realizing it. Eva didn't really shake things up since she isn't a manipulative competitor.

[@scottyoung7233]

this was a fun video, though I can Guarantee that the writers will want to keep Heather in the Game so I think they'd swap Lindsay and Heather Around. also I have some what If's for you. What if Katie and Sadie hosted the Aftermath in Action/What if Geoff and Bridgette weren't booted first in Action. What if Everyone qualified for Action and WT

[@user-fc3xd3yi3i]

Chris never said anything about immunity in episode 20 so it makes sense not every episode needs someone have immunity

[@bentleybutidk]

What if Ezekiel didn’t lose the stick.

[@blankblankness2971]

Final ranking: 22. Ezekiel 21. Noah 20. Justin 19. Katie 18. Tyler 17. Cody 16. Beth 15. Sadie 14. Courtney 13. Harold (Point of divergence below) 12. Heather 11. Leshawna 10. Trent 9. Lindsay 8. DJ 7. Eva 6. Izzy 5. Bridgette 4. Duncan 3. Gwen 2. Owen 1. Geoff (I chose Geoff because he’s nicer than Owen, so I think CN would choose his ending. Plus, he won The Ridonculous Race on Cartoon Network.)

[@leociresi4292]

Eva Vs Ty (Dude Perfect)😂

[@Supreme-AMVs]

Can you do; what if Noah played in the dodgeball challenge.

[@iLikeTheWordRetro]

Still a better way of getting rid of Leshawna than her actual elimination

[@JaxIsNotReal]

What if Courtney never got the idea to wake up Duncan during the dodgeball game

[@TD_Scottyboi]

I love Eva

[@Charles-xe4ow]

What if Leshawna didn't fake cry in episode 9? (TDA)

[@gxzing]

what if sierra and izzy never swapped teams?

[@laurenf11x]

can u do what if leshawna didnt throw heather down the cliff in episode 1??

[@brunolike8631]

I think instead of Bridgette, the eliminated contestants would've voted Owen, wich would leave Geoff and Bridgette VS Dunkan and Gwen. After that, Bridgette gets out, Geoff and Gwen team up to defeat Duncan and we have our finalists: Gwen VS Geoff.

[@trentsdandruff]

What if Trent won immunity in Search and Do Not Destroy?

[@anchorsaway9500]

This is clever but I think this would affect TDA somewhat. Duncan would now have a grudge against Trent and Lindsey still being cool with Heather could affect the season considering the writers originally planned for Lindsey to win TDA. (Yeah that was the plan rather then Beth but Lindsey’s VA wasn’t available at the last second which resulted I. The swap)

[@thebois6651]

The Linsday VA thing is a fake rumor

[@ElPsySneak]

There is no evidence for the Lindsay theory.

[@theultra5482]

The WORST team alliance to deal with is: Eva, Jo and Axel.

[@OBJECTADVENTURES]

Noo i get out 5th atleast i made it further

[@hzbybitch]

What if Sierra and Alejandro were never in World tour?

[@deandrewpowell]

Eva and lashana and lizy was my favorite sad Eva lost Early

[@BadasslynGinger9monthspregnanc]

If she won she would probably join Season 2 or 3

[@Duuuuude603]

What if mal existed in revenge

[@Catvinity]

Find a what if so duncan survives 4th place 😭

[@Cryptic3000]

What if gwen won the tiebreaker?

[@stephenxue5607]

I feel like this screwed leshawna more than the og (izzy flip, duncan winning the tiebreaker before its even announced)

[@ahmadstewasamlrt2202]

What if goku was raised by demons.

[@user-xn1xt2wc2e]

What If Eva debuted In total drama action Instead of Courtney

[@miaimotoc]

What if ezekiel didn t come back to team victory

[@Pleasehelpmeihave0willtolive]

What about Gwen in the bike one??😅

[@LightroStorm]

Her bit remains the same, since none of the changes involve her.

[@Pleasehelpmeihave0willtolive]

Ok

[@TessDCAS]

See I love this and wish this was what actually happened But I don’t like both Geoff and Owen making the finale, and Heather getting out first in methe

[@marklisowski6549]

Based on this what if, my elimination order would be: 12th: Heather 11th: Bridgette (Eva wins immunity, but Eva is out for blood for Bridgette and the rest of Bass. With the Bass and Gwen’s trio having to go against each other, Izzy, being a double agent for Duncan and Eva, initially is on board to help Duncan oust Trent (Duncan’s replaces Heather watching Trent and Gwen kiss. This sparks Duncan’s denial with Gwen and his jealousy of Trent. Izzy reports this Eva and Owen, and with this armor, Eva exposes Duncan. While Gwen’s trio wants Duncan out, Eva gives the ultimatum of either Trent or Bridgette. Not wanting to lose Trent, the rest of the Gophers, minus Izzy to screw with Leshawna, vote Brigette out by a vote of 6 to 4 (Trent) to 1 (Leshawna) 10th: Geoff (Eva’s gift basket, with Eva giving the pop Lindsay, forms a genuine friendship between Eva and Lindsay to reveal a softer side to Eva. Thus, unlike Heather hogging immunity, Eva shares busting DJ and Geoff with Lindsay to both win immunity alongside Leshawna. During the challenge, Duncan tries, even reluctantly with Trent, to form the guy’s alliance, but that quickly falls apart since Owen can’t keep his mouth shut, causing to Trent to secretly leave the alliance. Luckily for Trent, Owen blabs that he exposed the alliance to have Dj and Duncan believe Owen really turned traitor). This sparks tense debates between the Gophers and Eva, especially with Eva, Gwen and Leshawna. Then, Lindsay pitches a pecking order of Geoff, DJ, Duncan, and Owen, which everyone agrees with, followed by Lindsay painting Eva’s nail to her delight. Thus, Geoff gets ousted by a vote of 5 (Eva and Gophers minus Owen and Izzy) to 4 for Izzy (process of elimination to neither vote a another guy or Gwen) (The boys’ alliance minus Trent) to 1 for Leshawna (Thanks Izzy again). 9: Lindsay (To show her appreciation for Eva giving her immunity last round, Lindsay helps Eva win the challenge, but by doing so, Lindsay, by challenge technicality, eliminates herself. Eva, feeling bad, wants to save Lindsay, but Lindsay says it too risky and accepts her elimination fate and Eva’s friendship) 8th: DJ (same reason) 7th: Trent: Tensions between Trent and Duncan really boil from the last 2 challenges. After Eva realizes that she has no actual issue with Duncan, they form an unholy, but short lived alliance with Duncan. Also, Eva is over Gwen and Leshawna. So, she gets Owen and Izzy to help Duncan finally blindside Trent over Duncan by a vote of 4-3 7th: Eva (Gwen is paired with Eva while Owen and Izzy are together. Despite Owen and Izzy winning round 1, Gwen throws the rest of the challenge to ensure Leshawna and Duncan parts 2 and 3, and takes advantage of Duncan’s denial of her. With Leshawna immune, Eva wants to target Gwen next but Duncan refuses. Then, he warns Gwen and Leshawna about this, and after coercing Owen to vote their way, Eva is blindsided over Gwen by a vote of 4-2. 5th: Leshawna (same reason) 4th: Owen (Owen bombs the challenge to go after the sticky buns, causing Izzy and himself to lose. Unlike Duncan, Izzy’s face-off(s) with Chef actually admires her spunk. Even if he doesn’t respect Izzy, Chef is still more pissed at Owen for the sticky buns (over anything Izzy has done) and eliminates him. 3rd: Duncan: Gwen is over all of Duncan’s bullshit, especially not over Trent’s blindside. Thus, she brokers a deal with Izzy in the challenge, which Izzy readily accepts more than Owen. Thus, Duncan gets double-teamed to miss the finals. Finalists: Gwen and Izzy

[@skinny9246]

I would’ve preferred this cuz Eva’s just him. Eva >>>>>