What if I rewrote Ash's Sinnoh Journey?

[@raidguy78]

Thank you for giving Torterra spotlight cause Torterra is one of my favorite Pokemon and I’m sick and tired of fans hating on the poor Turtle.

[@sakuraa1770]

You're welcome! I'm glad I was able to give something to Torterra because I think he deserved more attention.

[@penguincjp]

While I don’t agree with every change here, I do think your idea for Lucas is pretty cool I think a more interesting explanation on why he tries out contests and Gyms is because while his main goal is to fill out the Pokédex, he believes that active;y participating with Pokémon in various activities is the best way to gather true research Which would also lead very well into Dawn’s argument with him that he shouldn’t even do Gyms or contests because all he sees it as is research But overall, another great video

[@sakuraa1770]

Wow, your idea is so much better than mine XD Thank you for your feedback :D

[@nojorooney]

I really like how you gave infernape less spotlight throughout the series, and then gave some of that spotlight to some of Ash’s lest used Pokémon like torterra and gliscor, although infernape is my favorite of Ash’s Sinnoh Pokémon I have to agree he got too much spotlight which is unfortunately common for Ash’s aces (with journeys being the worst offender of this, once Lucario evolved, Gengar had an entire 80 episode gap between wins and dragonite was not used at all after the battle with Iris until Raihan and the masters 8 where it was literally just fodder until the battle with Leon’s dragapult)

[@sakuraa1770]

I glad you enjoyed that. As much as I liked Infernape's story, it definitely shouldn't have led to the other team members getting so neglected.

[@sameermehmood6589]

I just came across your videos and I have to say you are working really hard stay motivated some days you may feel like you are not going anywhere but you entertain many people thank you

[@sakuraa1770]

Thank you for your lovely comment :D

[@Mermain123]

so for your idea for berry i thought of a fun arc for him when we first meet him he and ash will battle but berry loses he and ash will battle several times in the series but each time he loses to ash but every time it's a closer match then during there last battle before the league they tie thus it'd feel like a real win for berry in the sinnoh league

[@sakuraa1770]

That would be a cool story :D

[@YoungLingslayer2023]

Thanks for helping buizel torterra

[@sakuraa1770]

You're welcome, I'm glad you liked it :)

[@NOLJAK101]

This is actually really good, I love some of the changes such as some of ash’s other Pokémon getting more work such as torterra who Is one of ash’s most controversial Pokémon of all time, he had potential and I’m glad you were able to give him some wins and do what the writters couldn’t, I actually thought it was really cool that ash has a fully evolved torterra like his rival Paul, especially that Paul was a big jerk to ash and ash coming to chimchars defense for being treated poorly by Paul, also defenitly understandable why you cut gible from the cast he was introduced late in the anime, sure I think he should have evolved into at least gabite during the battle againts conway and he would have handled Draco meteor a lot better then in his prevolve form, also it as a Brock fan you definitely made you point on why you thought he didn’t need to happen in the sinnoh saga just for doing mostly the same stuff, Lucas to me may sound like a generic pick as a companion since he’s a avatar in the games but I love the development idea for his character in this rewrite of yours which makes him a lot more interesting, and yeah I have to agree with dawns ambipom being released it felt like another primeape case (not a good look for ash’s monkeys 😢) and Zoey was cool too, not much to change for her or Paul, besides that, Barry being introduce late in the series wasn’t the best idea I definitely think they could have Easley introduced Barry in the tag team tournament arc at least, I really hated that ash got paired with Paul and Paul mostly made ash just stand there leaving Paul doing all the work instead, and I felt like that was unfair to ash and they could have giving them different partners or not have Paul get involved at all in those episode, but it’ll defeat the purpose of ash catching chimchar, besides that this is a great way to fix ash’s journey in sinnoh, the original version was good by it still had its flaws and they can be fixed it’s not that hard at all.

[@sakuraa1770]

OMG Barry appearing in the Hearthome tournament would have been brilliant!

[@Masonicon]

How about my takes on Pokemon anime: where Ash ans his friends only go to Sinnoh whwn Dawn and Lucas got overwhelmed there?

[@ItzGhost77]

I like what you do with ash’s team and how everyone got some spotlight. Also with infernape and still being the main focused but not being the star of the show the whole time like how in xy when ash got frokie he didn’t use him all time and did lose in battles even when fully evolved and how all his Pokémon got some development and spotlight so good job and nice video

[@sakuraa1770]

Thank you :)

[@megalucariotrainer2245]

Glad in this Torterra and floatzel get more time to shine.

[@sakuraa1770]

Glad to hear you enjoyed it :D

[@pukenmg284]

My opinions on games protagonists than weren’t appear in the main series anime (so far) Red (As I told you the main series anime): Even I like to see him it would be a mess since Ash is based on Red anyway Leaf/Green: The only protagonist who appear in manga before the games I guess Ethan (They already confirmed that his official name is Ethan not Gold): I guess Jimmy is his anime counterpart though Kris: Same Marina probably her counterpart also I think in the remakes they could redesigned her instead of replaced her with Lyra Brendan: They could have added him instead of Max Lucas: Really forgettable also thanks that you made this video Hilbert: Am I the only one who think he doesn’t really fit in the anime Hilda: Same as Hilbert Nate: They could put him as a character in the events or at least Pokestar studios Rosa: They could use her as a rival too or in the studios too but I’m glad they didn’t Black and White anime sucks anyway Calem: I always forgot his name Elio: Seriously they could 100% added him in the anime as Ash’s friend Selene: Same as Elio Victor: They could add him to cheer Ash anyway Gloria: Also she could cheer Ash together with Victor and Hop Akari: Yeah I see the point since Dawn dressed like her anyway also it’s a very good theory that the protagonist in Legends Arceus is Lucas/Dawn that got teleported to the past If you ask me what about Chase and Elaine, we’ll Let’s go aren’t canon

[@sasmitagouda7780]

The best part was 22:01

[@acetrainerleo483]

I wanted torterra to get even with pauls honchcrow

[@sakuraa1770]

That would have been nice. At least it could have given him some focus later on.

[@dre9501]

Ok, I'm interested in the idea if your story, but I liked Gible, he wasn't bad an if used properly wouldve been a young version of Cynthia's

[@ariohandoyo5973]

Wow great! The sound is lounder now you improve a lot, thanks for Accepting my suggestion.😊

[@sakuraa1770]

You're welcome, thanks for letting me know :D

[@ariohandoyo5973]

@@sakuraa1770 my pleasure, please keep improving keep going.😊

[@Chris-g1p2h]

Do you think ash should have a leafeon

[@sakuraa1770]

I love Leafeon, so I think it would be cool with Ash!

[@Chris-g1p2h]

@ plus it’s a fast grass type so it would work well

[@Chris-g1p2h]

I wanna play through sinnoh with Ash’s team this is my favorite team along with his kanto team his hoenn and kalos team

[@sakuraa1770]

I agree, it was a good team!

[@IceMaster20108]

I’d make Ash catch that aura sphere riolu and other stuff

[@sakuraa1770]

That would be interesting.

[@IceMaster20108]

@@sakuraa1770and make him catch that Snover from that one episode and it would carry out Torterra’s battles after it sucked

[@hiddenfan-37]

I do love Floatzel and I'm glad that you let Buizel evolved, since a lot of fans were all "Buizel is a strong cute unevolved Pokemon who doesn't need to evolve to become strong". Yet, learning one new move, having a lack of focus in the latter half of DP because of Infernape and not becoming Floatzel is the best development the writers can come up with?! And then you wonder why everyone blamed Infernape for making his Sinnoh teammates look bad (wasting 129 episodes for Chimchar just to become a Monferno aside), even if he had a good story arc. For the actual anime, besides Gliscor, Torterra, Staraptor, Infernape, Floatzel, Garchomp and Lucario, what other Sinnoh Pokemon do you think should Ash get? Personally I'd pick Hippowdon, Abomasnow, Magnezone, Bastiodon and Honckrow.

[@sakuraa1770]

I agree on Floatzel, and your additional picks for Ash are cool! As for a new Sinnoh team for Ash, I'll be going over that very soon in our 1k subscriber special :)

[@hiddenfan-37]

@@sakuraa1770 Can't wait to hear the story.

[@Chris-g1p2h]

I wonder what it would be like if ash kept aipom and evolved it

[@sakuraa1770]

I liked Aipom with Ash. I would be interested in seeing how Aimbipom would have faired under him

[@Chris-g1p2h]

@ he could definitely use its speed for gym battles and give him so more type diversity

[@sakuraa1770]

@@Chris-g1p2h Agreed. I liked the Gardenia battle a lot because Aipom was the star!

[@Chris-g1p2h]

@@sakuraa1770 so I do have a remade sinnoh team for ash pikachu ambipom staraptor infernape buizel and gliscor

[@sakuraa1770]

@@Chris-g1p2h Very nice team :)

[@Grievousapprentice15]

Thank you so much for the changes, especially nerfing Infernape, which I hate, it’s my least favorite Pokémon ever, and what ultimately ruined Sinnoh for me because a stupid monkey kept stealing the spotlight from Ash’s other Pokémon. It was unbearable in the final battle because seriously it should have fainted after taking all of those big hits, getting poisoned and recoiled by its own moves. I’m glad your version had it nerfed to a more reasonable level.

[@sakuraa1770]

Yeah, Infernape really did not need to be as much of a screentime hog as he was. Glad you appreciated those changes.

[@whyidkwhy]

be funny if people confused Ash and Lucas for Twins and Barry bumping into Lucas more alot and FINE HIM! lol

[@sakuraa1770]

Ash and Lucas don't really look similar, but Barry wanting to fine them both would be funny!

[@Chris-g1p2h]

If they wanted her to have togekiss they could have Gaven her one earlier or not give her mamoswine so my dawn team would be piplup buneary pachrisu ambipom togekiss and Quilava

[@sakuraa1770]

I agree. I always felt Mamoswine was an odd pick of Dawn anyway.

[@Chris-g1p2h]

@@sakuraa1770apparently the reason they got rid of ambipom was because the writers thought it looked ugly

[@sakuraa1770]

@@Chris-g1p2h That seems like a weird reason. Why give her a Pokemon in the first place if they don't like the way it looks? I also find it weird for them to even consider Ambipom ugly, especially when they had no issue giving her Mamoswine.

[@Chris-g1p2h]

@ I personally like ambipoms as a Pokémon I’ve grown more attached to it because of the anime it had so much potential but the writers had to ruin it they were hyping ambipom so much only to throw it away

[@howtogoogle8031]

hmmm paul could have used torterra against ash's infernape difference is that he has a raichu pikachu would and might evolve because lets say he meets a female raichu and wants to impress her

[@adamjyuken3449]

Why not give Lucas a starter?

[@sakuraa1770]

He really didn't need one considering Ash and Dawn had all 3 between them.

[@adamjyuken3449]

@@sakuraa1770 no like why not give him turtwig

[@sakuraa1770]

@@adamjyuken3449 Because Ash already has Turtwig.

[@randommason7323]

You’re a tortteraa fan huh

[@sakuraa1770]

Not really. Honestly the only one of the Sinnoh starters I really like is the Chimchar line. I just felt bad for how Ash's Torterra was treated later in the show.

[@terryweston1694]

Look at gibble's evolution evolve into intro gacha

[@pn2294]

I don’t think Buizel would want to evolve based on his performance against Wake’s Floatzel.

[@sakuraa1770]

I don't think Buizel ever really had anything against Floatzel or evolving in general, I think he just wanted to prove that he was strong enough to beat his evolved form in that particular battle.

[@singsongsign]

Disqualify Tobias!

[@sakuraa1770]

He doesn't need to be disqualified if he doesn't exist.

[@GuranPurin]

I think some of these were some great changes. I overall enjoyed Sinnoh but I dislike that every time they make a plot relevant decision, the explanation is literally just "because the plot demanded it". Ash needs to lose so have him lose to a Darkrai. :/ Or Ambipom needs to be released for Togekiss so she suddenly has a life-long passion for ping-ping. I suppose you could argue that you don't know what your true passion is until you experience it for the first time, but it's just very weird since Ambipom had been built up as having Contests as her true passion. It felt a bit out of nowhere for her to suddenly be thrown into this ping pong plot. I'd have rathered Dawn sent her to Johanna instead and Dawn take Togekiss that way so she could still potentially be with a coordinator.

[@sakuraa1770]

Same, they could have given Ambipom to a top coordinator or someone, but the ping pong was way too weird :(

[@alexandrapagan3222]

​​@@sakuraa1770 And to make it weird to worse, is that Ambipom's final contest was against Kenny, and it took a freaking L! That's character assassination to the fullest!

[@sakuraa1770]

@@alexandrapagan3222 I hadn't even remembered that. Yeah, Ambipom was truly done dirty.

[@Quillion-lq4bx]

I get what you're saying with this video, but I have 1 problem with it. You said you wanted to give spot light to the entire team, and that's fine. The problem is I felt you instead made Gligar/Gliscor the ace of this generation.

[@sakuraa1770]

I didn't make any ace, whatever that means. I just distributed the win rate among the rest of the team. As I mentioned, Infernape STILL gets the most major wins out of the entire team even with the changes I made.

[@terryweston1694]

I think gibble's stay on the team because evolution go bite

[@sakuraa1770]

Well Gible never evolved, so that doesn't really mean anything in terms of Ash's team here. Even if he did make it to Gabite, I'd still prefer to keep Gliscor over him because I just felt his story was good as it was and his departure felt forced.

[@albro5274]

Make it infernape learn Thunder punch.

[@sakuraa1770]

Eh, I thought his moveset was fine so I didn't feel the need to change it like I did for a few others.

[@1992holycrap]

Torterra will forever be the most abused 'mon in the entire anime and the writers' continued insistence that Ash use exclusively fast and agile powerhouses is downright comical, considering how static and sluggish the battles have become in Journeys.

[@sakuraa1770]

I haven't watched Journeys, but I do prefer when Ash has more variety in his teams. I honestly would like to see Ash use more slower Pokemon.

[@amiyaarchit5248]

@@sakuraa1770 i do prefer varieties of Pokemon for ash.. Like you see Paul he caught alot of Pokemon and uses them according to gym...I still choose gible but not that late..I want ash to catch him early and evolve him into garchomp by the start of Pokemon league... with garchomp he will be High chance to win

[@sakuraa1770]

@@amiyaarchit5248 Even with a Garchomp, I doubt Ash would have have closer to beating Tobias. I guess having Gible would be fine so long as he wasn't caught super late and Ash hadn't caught Gligar.

[@hiddenfan-37]

@@sakuraa1770 I did enjoy Ash getting a Lucario in Journeys (besides being an obvious BDSP promo, he was a fan requested Sinnoh Pokemon for Ash to have plus Ash had connection to Aura as shown in the Kidnapped Riolu 2-parter and the 8th film Lucario and the Mystery of Mew, along with the fact he can Mega Evolve). He is one of my favorite Sinnoh Pokemon.

[@sakuraa1770]

@@hiddenfan-37 I like Lucario as a Pokémon, though I feel like I would have preferred him on a different team. I'll be going over that soon though.

[@unclebrian8156]

I’m glad you let buizel evolve because I thought it was stupid that ash got gyped in that trade where aipom evolved after dawn got it but buizel didn’t evolve after becoming ash’s trainer. Also I really liked how you gave all of ash’s other Pokemon more time in the spotlight and didn’t make it the chimchar/infernape show like the writers did.

[@sakuraa1770]

Thank you very much :D

[@unclebrian8156]

@@sakuraa1770 you are very welcome

[@side-klipps]

Ash Sinnoh team should be Torterra/Staraptor/Toxicroak Infernape/Floatzel/Gabite

[@sakuraa1770]

Interesting team idea

[@side-klipps]

@@sakuraa1770 thanks