What If Knuckles Was In Smash? (Moveset Ideas: 38)

[@BrawlFan1]

And because I know people are going to comment on it, yes, I know that Knuckles is already in Smash as an Assist Trophy. If you watch the video before commenting, you'll see that I bring that up in the video. "What If *** was in Smash" is just a better title that roles off the tongue when compared to "What If *** was Playable in Smash" or What If *** was a Fighter in Smash* I prefer the shorter title that I have, and I'm fairly certain most people know what I'm talking about without the extra words.

[@blazzer7136]

I'm just interested how many people requested Eevee in this series Like me

[@gamersgamestorm8291]

BrawlFan1 these movesets are amazing! Just asking when are we getting more Undertale characters. My previous comment on this video described an idea for Mettaton. It would be cool if you made Nabstablook(Dummy as alt) and Muffet as Echo Fighter Moveset to.

[@gamemesa]

You know this is not going to stop most people from commenting it right?

[@jacksone8282]

I just hope Midna finally gets a moveset

[@BrawlFan1]

@@gamemesa I'm aware, I figured I'd put it here anyway to try and help some people from wasting their own time.

[@ultim8lifeform697]

If Knuckles doesn’t say “oh no” after every death, we riot

[@toastNeko]

I disagree

[@toastNeko]

LET HIM YELL OH NO!

[@jspaceman]

Toast Man YES

[@greenhawk1285]

U typed the impossible

[@tomsky4751]

Ultim8 Lifeform agreed

[@10.ikadekanandadwipayadnya83]

"He hates the air but loves the ground" Lil mac: ah yes, a man of culture

[@Youonyouon]

I want them to add a character that is an air fighter.

[@Youonyouon]

And MAN of culture? He is a hedgehog.

[@StarlightMagician]

@@Youonyouon *Echidna.

[@griffinkimball2454]

@@Youonyouon They already have an air fighter. It is called Jigglypuff

[@Youonyouon]

@@StarlightMagician oh... oof.

[@CarlosLopez-yt2qu]

Smash Trailer for Knuckles: Sonic: *Breaths* Knuckles: *UnLiKe SoNiC I DoN't cHuCkLe*

[@user-em7ig3lk7l]

Sonic: Big Chungus Knuckles: Punch

[@Silverwind87]

I'D RATHER FLEX MY KNUCKLES

[@jamiegioca9448]

This gives me an idea for the trailer: Sonic enters a match and realizes he's the only one on stage, which makes him confused. He then shrugs whiie saying "Okay." and prepares to leave, but the second he says "okay", SA2's version of Unknown from M.E. plays at full blast and Knuckles comes out of the ground, startling Sonic. Knux notices he scared him and chuckles, saying "I scared ya, didn't I?". The splash screen then reads "Knuckles chuckles and flexes his muscles!" After some of his moves and Final Smash have been showcased, the duo prepares to rumble, charging towards each other, ending the trailer

[@thenecromancer4113]

@@Silverwind87YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES YES

[@messagerticv4795]

“I’ll make you eat DIRT!” Bruh, no one’s gonna be chuckling after Knuckles is done with them. That taunt is POWERFUL.

[@RHYUshin]

word that >:)

[@jamiegioca9448]

He should say "We gonna rumble?" instead

[@MetaDHedge28]

Either when he gets launched or KOd, he needs to say his iconic "Oh no!"

[@BushBumperBaker]

He's in the Brawl hackless mod: Project+ and he does indeed say "Oh No" when he dies. Truly blessed.

[@jtothepmoreno1010]

“What if a Goomba was playable in smash?”

[@CallmeKeyiii]

But the Koopa Troopa ;-;

[@jspaceman]

OMG IM NOT THE ONLY ONE THAT WANTS THAT

[@hurt4322]

@@jspaceman ME NEITHER

[@finleymaster101]

Hahahahahahaaha!

[@shaplaflower]

Ok. Jab... aww crap

[@dirpycatkittymeowmeow9099]

Knuckles: **digs staight down** Lava: I'm about to end this ekindna's whole career

[@dakota3047]

I laughed so hard at this.. Also it's Echidna

[@plasmetal8225]

Steve: Creeper, no! Creeper: What? Steve: Sorry. Force of habit. Knuckles, no!

[@jamiegioca9448]

I got dat reference

[@countertopconfessions9975]

"he wouldn't be able to climb walls in smash" Well why not? New characters bring new abilities all the time in smash

[@Madcat56]

it would be way to op, completely free recovery if you get to a wall.

[@Madcat56]

most stages do have walls, there are only 3 non-walk-offs that i know of that don't (not counting transitions), and a few walk offs have walls. to give you an idea, those stages are halberd, mario circuit, and delfino plaza. i don't count walk offs because the special is already for horizontal recovery, and is great on walk offs anyway. even final destination has walls.

[@Madcat56]

even if limited or with some start lag, it's free recovery, and most characters couldn't really punish that before it gets to ledge, so it would be so easy to recover that it wouldn't be fun to play as most other characters against knuckles, especially you could wall jump out of it

[@countertopconfessions9975]

@@Madcat56 ok how about if they make his vertical recovery really poor? Like DK? That would hinder his off-stage game as well as make his recovery predictable since all he can do is glide. There must be a possible way to balance wall climbing. It's a big part of his character and it would be such a shame to leave it out of his moveset

[@lukeygroovy8593]

if we went by project m, he technically can climb walls.

[@FizzleBurger]

I like this moveset, though I would like to propose wall-climbing as an alternate Up Special that triggers when he's in his wall-cling state. I think it could still fit into his playstyle if it was a single, rapid wallclimb that quickly brings him up to the ledge, so that it doesn't encourage players to camp by climbing up and down walls. We could also discourage camping by only letting the player use it once until they touch the ground again (otherwise, the input will trigger a rising uppercut, even if the player is clinging to a wall). For cases where he doesn't reach a ledge (e.g. he encounters an overhang, or climbs for more than a second on the infinite wall on Shadow Moses), it would just trigger freefall. An unlimited wallclimb would obviously be overpowered and exploitable, but I think he needs some variant of the move to feel like the complete Knuckles package.

[@bediebysstar1939]

I know “This awesome dude” clearly isn’t the character I would like to see, but... “What if Madeline was in Smash?”

[@axelperez2917]

YEAH!! MADELINE!!

[@cingkrayz1959]

Thank you!

[@leololcat]

Heck yeah Especially if its Madeline from Celeste

[@BigFearedBalloon]

Yeah. I once saw a moveset on Twitter which was awesome, so I would also want to see BrawlFan1 take on it. Madeline is one of the high third parties I would want in Smash alongside Shantae, Dr. Eggman and Monokuma.

[@Mewatron]

How would madeline work she does not fight

[@OfficialMisterBoo]

My List: 1. Madeline (Celeste) 2. Goose (Untitled Goose Game) 3. Bendy (Bendy and the Ink Machine) 4. Eevee (Pokémon) 5. Kratos (God of War) 6. Flowey (Undertale) 7. The 3 Heroes (Deltarune) 8. Ashley (WarioWare Inc.) 9. Silver (Sonic The Hedgehog) 10. Chorus Kids (Rhythm Heaven) 11. Captain Toad 12. Yooka-Laylee 13. King Boo (Luigi's Mansion) 14. Vaati (The Legend of Zelda) 15. Earthworm Jim

[@awesomeclown]

He did a lot of these

[@fleshdadbot6852]

Eight, exactly

[@smt64productions40]

@@fleshdadbot6852 Nine since he counted Captain Toad for Base Toad and had him as a costume

[@TrulyAtrocious]

Bro had a vision

[@ImfernusRizen]

"This Awesome Dude" Damn, BJ.... Never expected you to make a moveset on yourself

[@axelperez2917]

Yeah, true, is nice to see someone to have the same idea, like

[@axelperez2917]

sorry, was to the coment behind you XD

[@respektertfilosof9005]

I didn't know Brawlfan1 liked to brat

[@bowserwithpants9764]

Knuckles would be interesting in Smash *But he’d rather flex his knuckles*

[@dakota3047]

He could flex his muscles in Smash

[@jvbon646]

"This Awesome Dude" It better be BrawlFan1 or we Riot >:l

[@matthewoakes9166]

Awesome.... Wait. I do not want to riot

[@cow4]

we riot

[@mojonoahgamer5647]

Riot

[@octotune39]

Riot

[@sw1shstyx777]

*Laughs in Knuckles*

[@trunksfutureprinceofhype4385]

That Final Smash idea alone has me sold on him being a fighter. Creative stuff

[@QyfieK]

”What if labo man was in smash?”

[@Youonyouon]

WHY DID YOU SAY THAT, HE MIGHT BE IN SMASH. Lets see... we have mii fighters, wii fit trainer, and a plant... yup labo man has a pretty good chance at getting into smash.

[@pedro_6120]

@@Youonyouon at least plant is pretty good in smash bros

[@Youonyouon]

@@pedro_6120 plant boi is funny. He is bad he has nonexistant combos, he has no gameplan and has a lot of end lag on most of his air moves. I like the funny plant though.

[@misslunch1802]

"What if Albert Wesker was in Smash?!" "What if Sly Cooper was in Smash?! Dimentio(meaby too op to be in Smash) was in Smash?!" Also,other undertale character I would love yo see are: "What if Flowey was in smash?!" "What if Mettaton was in Smash?!' (He could switch between his box and Ex forms, box being slower but heavy and stronger,and Ex being faster but lighter. He could also transform into Mettaton NEO,giving him better air movility and damage)

[@octotune39]

Wait, what if it’s Mettaton? He has a gigantic ego! (Also, IMO, he’s an awesome dude!)

[@arturoayala1004]

I thought it was a she!

[@petergriffin2616]

Same

[@petergriffin2616]

Besides I tried making a move set for mettaon but......... it didn’t go so we’ll

[@theterminator546]

I really really really really really really want Mettaton.

[@Baconator2558]

@@arturoayala1004 Why?

[@reesethegrease8959]

“What if a Terrarian got in Smash” I’d love to see it

[@F4nthom]

Yeah that would be great!

[@loudboyslive9112]

Same

[@rachaelchampion6195]

He did it

[@pedronovais4130]

Plague and Specter Knight are the ones I would want next, I cant wait for a moveset for them

[@eefa2821]

Haza a fan of quality

[@NothingSpecificGaming]

Knuckles is such a fitting character to be playable in Smash I'm surprised he didn't make it into ultimate as more than a assist trophy

[@QyfieK]

I have an idea for a spinoff of these moveset videos. What if you tried to remake old characters movesets that aren’t really up to date? Characters like Mario, Donkey Kong, Bowser, Ganondorf and Samus could use an update to represent their more modern games more accurately.

[@chippotato5647]

What's wrong with representing the old games?

[@QyfieK]

Chip Potato There’s nothing wrong with representing old games. It’s just that characters like Mario and Samus have so much more material to base movesets on. Samus has the prime trilogy and Mario could use Cappy. And then there’s Donkey Kong. His moveset is mostly based on a real gorilla instead of his games.

[@sumerapaleema610]

I like to imagine Mighty and Ray also live on Angel Island and they're the ones to guard the Master Emerald when Knuckles is away.

[@mememan8421]

"The awesome dude" me: shrek

[@bingoviini]

"The awesome dude" me: Me

[@marioandco.6366]

True

[@sw1shstyx777]

*Laughs in Knuckles*

[@mememan8421]

the blow flower

[@SnakesAnimations]

Rajang from monster hunter "Rajang carts the competition" The intro cutscene shows link and ganon on a stage fighting rathalos. Suddenly, a roar rings out from the forest. Rajang launches out of the trees, grabbing rathalos by the tail and slamming it a few times, before throwing them off the stage. Rajangs turns back just before ganon releases his punch. There's a cloud of smoke, and when it clears, rajang's blocked the attack, smiles, and throws ganondorf off the edge. He looks back at link, and jumps at him, and the screen shows "Rajang carts the competition"

[@daone2311]

Eventually this guy'll have made more characters than in Smash Ultimate. And they say Sakuri needs a brake Edit: Firstly, thanks for the likes! Secondly, this isnt meant to dis Sakuri or anything

[@PokeTaleG]

The One And Only Memebot But also, he has a team to help do so.

[@PulseAnimations878]

@@PokeTaleG and also coming up with ideas is still way easier than making models coding move effects and all that stuff even with a team

[@daone2311]

I know sakuri has to code them but he's got his whole team as well Plus brawlfan1 makes a character every week

[@daone2311]

@@terrykeeper8251 And his own. He's got 38 of em!

[@tailsdude9069]

Oof

[@ashbasher22nerd93]

Awesome move set for Knuckles. Suits him a lot. I think though three alt colours based on Team Chaotix would be better than just blue, yellow and green hues (Them being Victor, Charmy and Espio) For characters I like to see get ideas for a what-if Smash. I have a long list: Sly Cooper Alucard (Castlevania) Midna & Wolf Link and/or Zant (Twilight Princess) Ghirahim (Skyward Sword) Yuga (Link Between Worlds) Krystal, Leon Powalski and/or Peppy & Slippy as a duo (StarFox) Crono (Chrono Trigger) Viridi, Hades, Medusa and/or Magnus (Kid Icarus) Scorpion (Mortal Kombat) Tiny the Tiger and/or Dingodile (Crash Bandicoot) Daroach and/or Malagor (Kirby) Tifa Lockhart (Final Fantasy VII) Aran Ryan, King Hippo, Super Macho Man and/or Doc Louis (Punch Out) Toad (Super Mario) Count Bleck (Paper Mario) Ivy Valentine, Cassandra and/or Nightmare (Soul Caliber) Guile and/or Vega (Street Fighter) Sobble and/or Corviknight (Pokemon Sword and Shield) Mettaton Ex (Undertale) Lara Croft (Tomb Raider) Isaac (Golden Sun) Raiden (Metal a Gear Solid: Revengeance) Dante (Devil May Cry) Riki, Mecha-Fiora, Dunban, Melia and/or Reyn (Xenoblade Chronicles) Mumbo Jumbo (Banjo Kazooie) Geese Howard (Fatal Fury) Iori Yagami (King of Fighters) Homarado (Samurai Showdown) Travis Touchdown (No More Heroes) Bomberman Skull Kid & Majora (Majora's Mask) Samurai Goroh (F-Zero) Morgana (Persona 5) Springman and/or Minmin (Arms) Ashley (Warioware) Silver the Hedgehog and/or Blaze the Cat (Sonic series) Chibi-Robo And any joke character you can think of.

[@orangejuicemann3251]

Might my fondest dreams act as premonitions and come to fruition? Will The Batter finally take his swing? Shall the switch be turned OFF?

[@merchantziro4285]

Or will this be judgement in the form of The Judge/Pablo? Hence nothing remains except for his regrets.

[@orangejuicemann3251]

Perhaps. But purpose is impossible to evade, as doing so will only lead to corruption. That said, there is one rather “cool” individual who might fit the specifications of the very one we send our requests to. Ha ha ha ha.

[@merchantziro4285]

@@orangejuicemann3251 ZACHARIE SELLS OUT

[@finalshade8592]

I do like that analogy. Yes.. like gods... Precisely..

[@maverickREAL]

No, OFF sucks.

[@toxinfrog6137]

Great work on the move set, as always: I could believe this being a possible move set of Knuckles were to be included in Smash, and it sounded fun to play, too. As far as suggestions go, I think it’d be interesting to see what one of the Contestants from Dicey Dungeons could do in Smash Bros.

[@openinginawe5518]

Character moveset 38 and Knuckles Also I love that Final smash. Reimu (Touhou) Lloyd Irving (Tales of Symphonia) Neku Sakuraba (The World Ends With You) Champion Cynthia ( Pokemon Platium) And Arle (Puyo Puyo)

[@Mike-sy4hh]

“What if Neku Sakuraba was in Smash?”

[@linkisoptrmm]

It might just happen

[@sanxit_]

so that happened

[@laughingarrancar6859]

So good video. This moveset is just perfect to Knuckles. Agumon from Digimon

[@kailani-madelineb.7060]

I was expecting Zero to be the awesome dude but hey, I was close with the red-colored Assist Trophy who debuted in Ultimate! Anyway, great and interesting moveset as always! Can`t wait for the next one!!

[@omegaverserex9487]

I want either of these classic mobile games icons: Peashooter/Sunflower or Red from Angry Birds Godzilla!

[@raedza1604]

Angry birds red

[@strudeldulce4427]

Sunflower a moveset?

[@danielr5946]

I think seeing a new mii fighter would be cool like a mii mage who uses spells

[@thesymbiotenation.4552]

We got Knuckles... so now we need Silver and or Blaze!

[@possumorb3770]

We got Silver, all we need is a certain fiery cat from another dimension.

[@mondaindoodles8667]

Both

[@weirdomcfreak]

Brawlfan1:Says that knuckles in sonic boom is funny Me:I ABSOLUTELY AGREE!!

[@rikkawhiterose662]

Hey guys, Ragna's an awesome dude, maybe it's him? ...please. Edit: Knock knock.

[@bodgmasterxionobst3r983]

I Keep requesting him and Sol for Smash, but I fink ice Boi Jin would not be happ bout that, also BBTAG is kinda good, but it's a bit overrated, I bought Central Fiction the 2nd of November(my birthday),to get an expirience of the franchise to start with.I don't remember if I asked for him in this channel tho. PS:I ALSO REQUEST A LOT ASH CRIMSON BEFORE TERRY'S REVEAL, BUT... Brawlfan1 didn't do him.

[@rikkawhiterose662]

@@lankylank274 What a lovely ball of sunshine you are.

[@CPURianaElmori8879]

Ragna and yu narukami for smash #blazbluecrosstagforsmash

[@ambushandscorp]

Random “what if blank was in smash” suggestion: Snap Shot from Skylanders.

[@shawnburke-hutchinson5901]

What if this blank was in Smash? Bullet Kin because you can use blanks in Gungeon.

[@minepro48isundead]

Here's a interesting character idea if it hasn't been done yet *Parappa The Rapper!*

[@ditto7047]

BON PARA PARA

[@darkcopyman9453]

I Gotta Believe!

[@aura_flower3385]

Omg yes lol

[@FoxTube_Editz]

I G O T T A B E L I E V E

[@ikatulo_yt]

Dude the editing got so good!! Keep it up!

[@reissbelle-ffrench2738]

This was amazing, Knuckles is one of my characters I want to see get upgraded into the roster too. Also do one for Silver The Hedgehog next or E-123 Omega.

[@dakota3047]

Brooo... I just couldn't stop smiling. This is just amazing!!! It all just works so perfectly!!!!!!!!!

[@patrickramseyart]

I just thought of one that could be really interesting. What if you did a moveset for Chase McCain from Lego City Undercover? There's a suprisingly large amount of potential there to speculate about.

[@skysmash9310]

Yeah! We'd be able to reference the lego series of video games and not have to worry about trademarks from DC, Marvel, and other trademarked lego video games!

[@therealboy23]

YES! MCCAIN FOR SMASH!!!!!!!!!!

[@badgerlord5390]

This is second only to Waluigi for my Ultimate Playable Wishlist. Very well done; I love all the inspirations you drew from.

[@mushroomfusion245]

A little surprised Tikal is just a costume instead of an echo fighter, since the multiplayer mode of SA2 has shown us that she’s capable of doing pretty much everything Knuckles can do.

[@shaunacatalano38]

Hearing what you said at the end made me so damn happy, glad to know they're are others that want him in smash too! :)

[@crobatgaming6156]

Hmm, I think its a character who has a big Ego.

[@greekletterphi9620]

Zote the Mighty, a knight of great renown?

[@ianbowling9396]

Maybe Porky from Earthbound.

[@garielgames4018]

Dimentio?

[@BenN64]

Mettaton

[@BenN64]

Mettaton EX

[@epicgamersaurus]

My most wanted character uploaded on my birthday!

[@sethgreenie]

Be cool to see one for decidueye or a skylander

[@edwardramos4591]

Classic Mode Route: Way to go, Knucklehead! (This Classic Mode has Knuckles fight a good guy followed by a villain) Stage 1: Mario then Bowser Jr. Stage 2: Samus then Dark Samus Stage 3: Zelda then Ganondorf Stage 4: Captain Falcon x2 (default then Blood Falcon) Stage 5: Donkey Kong then King K. Rool Stage 6: Sonic then Giant R.O.B. (standing in for an Eggman mech) Boss Stage: Kirby then Marx

[@Theo-on2ig]

Kyubi or venoct in smash? They have so much potential plus kyubi is my favourite yokai

[@randomdecidueye4533]

yokai😑😨 hell no i used to like it but now I don't

[@TheCeeverse]

What if Ganondorf was accurately in Smash? What if Travis Touchdown was in Smash? What if Amy Rose was in Smash? What if Metal Sonic was in Smash? What if Gooey was an Echo Fighter? What if Tingle was in Smash? What if Samurai Goroh was in Smash?

[@mushroomfusion245]

One more until Sonic is tied with Pokémon as the most represented series on this channel! (If you count the trainers as one character) To give the 2 other highly represented series on this channel a boost: Undertale: Mettaton Asgore Flowey\Asriel Mario: Captain Toad King Boo Pauline Gooigi

[@sneakygoomba5042]

Thank you for making this! I love Knuckles, and this moveset would be near perfect for him! And that Final Smash! XD

[@melissabarnes1063]

One request: scorpion or Johnny Cage from mortal Kombat. Why these two is because scorpion is the most iconic character. And Johnny because he's funny and has charm that would fit into the child friendly game of smash

[@melissabarnes1063]

@RockyProductions True, but I commented this months before it happened

[@waffloesh7862]

Just back from a very stressful and long day of school, Knuckles was exactly what I needed today 😭😭 ty

[@zek2195]

Please, give us Goose. If this video is goose, I am a very happy man Edit: wasn't goose, maybe next time

[@gamersgamestorm8291]

Creepypasta Zekrom Goose is not an awesome dude they are a trouble making goose

[@zek2195]

@@gamersgamestorm8291 How dare you. You have offended the gods. Goose is the most powerful being on earth, which everyone shall worship.

[@gamersgamestorm8291]

I want a Moveset for him but goose is not awesome dude

[@zek2195]

@@Shwiffle What do you mean? Goose is a living god, everybody knows him.

[@zek2195]

@@gamersgamestorm8291 Correct, he is a godly dude.

[@teamplayz6354]

What If Mettaton was in smash? •He could have a bar like Frisk, And One side could be Mettaton EX, and the other could be Mettaton NEO. •His Final Smashes: •If the bar has NOT filled up, He could use all or most of his shows before the EX fight OR, •If the bar is filled up, He could have a HUGE Attack, (probably 75% damage) Where he could use a lot of bombs and Mini Mettatons. Like so BrawlFan1 can see.

[@ashbasher22nerd93]

Can you do a what if move-set for these characters please: Sly Cooper Dust (Dust: An Elysian Tail) Peppy & Slippy (as a duo), Krystal or Leon Powalski (StarFox series) Alucard or Dracula (CastleVania series) Midna & Wolf Link, Ghirahim, Impa, Zant or Yuga (Zelda Series) Mettaton Ex (Undertale) Tiny the Tiger (Crash Bandicoot Series) Geese Howard (Fatal Fury Series) Scorpion (w/Smoke as an echo fighter as he fought like him in MK2) (Mortal Kombat Series) Morgana (Persona 5) Guile or Vega (Street Fighter series) Aori Yagami (King of Fighters series) Mumbo Jumbo (Banjo Kazooie series) King Hippo, Aran Ryan, Doc Louis or Super Macho Man (Punch Out Series) Fawful, Toad, Count Bleck or Goomba (Mario Series) Tifa or Noctis (Final Fantasy series) Lara Croft (Tomb Raider series) Crono (Crono Trigger) Medusa, Viridi or Magnus (Kid Icarus series) Samurai Goroh (F-Zero series) Plague Knight (Shovel Knight series) Daroach, Chef Kowalski, Malagor or the Mage Sisters (Kirby series) Ratchet and Clank Poo, EVE or Paula (Mother series) Mecha Fiora, Riki, Dunban or Reyn (Xenoblade Chronicles) And any joke character you like. Loved how you did Slime.

[@titanictnt7476]

If Knuckles was in Smash, they would have to call it “Super Smash Bros. Ultimate & Knuckles.”

[@razeboxanimations3215]

Yup

[@donaldtoon5601]

Requests: Requests: -tracer from overwatch -gordon freeman from half life -chell from portal -reimu hakurei from touhou -ashley from warioware -dante from devil may cry -dixie kong -sash lilac from freedom planet -doomguy from doom -isaac from golden sun (felix as a echo fighter) -chibi robo -bomberman -krystal -travis touchdown from no more heroes -marco from metal slug -ryu hayabusa from ninja gaiden -scorpion from mortal kombat

[@cyan_64]

Knuckles: an assist trophy waluigi: an assist trophy knuckles: gets the "what if" video waluigi: still trying to get into smash

[@Mr._Maniac]

I mean, Waluigi also got a What If video.

[@cyan_64]

@@Mr._Maniac yea i posted the comment before i saw the video

[@Mr._Maniac]

@@cyan_64 ah. Gotcha.

[@wyvernknight]

knuckles: do u know da way to smash sakuri: yes hop into this assist- i mean teleporter

[@andysnider4593]

Wrong Knuckles, dude. That is Ugandan Knuckles

[@therealboy23]

@@andysnider4593 it doesn't matter, it's still a dead meme involving knuckles!

[@kirbyinabox3881]

The space that characters pull stuff out of is often known as "hammerspace"

[@boris0032]

What if You were in smash 🤔

[@tazzaditonno4299]

What if this comment were in smash🤔

[@randomdecidueye4533]

or decidueye (day 99999999999 still no decidueye)

[@precieux6303]

@@tazzaditonno4299 *was

[@masterofmicrospace1820]

AHHH WHY IS EVERY PREMIERE DURING SCHOOL BUT seriously I just started watching this and I'm super excited for Knux and also Silver and Chell in Smash ahhhhhhh!!!!!

[@liamdonnelly4488]

Request's round 8 Junkrat from overwatch Morgana from Persona 5 Metal Sonic Felicia from darkstalkers Geese howard from fatal fury Kuma from Tekken And Yosuke hanamura from Persona 4

[@ragnamalamity]

Shoulda guessed it'd be Knuckles... who else would fit the description before the video aired? "This Awesome Dude," if I recall. Nicely done! Also, I'd like to throw in a request for either Sir Arthur (Ghosts 'n Goblins) or Firebrand (Technically, also Ghosts 'n Goblins, but mostly the Gargoyle's Quest / Demon Crest series).

[@lebossbolosse8786]

"what if the monster hunter was in smash" would be cool, after all the prey is already in smash so there's a need for an hunter

[@DarthZ01]

Me and bj have brainstorned mh a lot. I thought it would be neat giving them an incentory of tools, potions, and traps you can cycle through but have limited uses that only refill on ko. He hasnt decided on that, or just picking a few and setting one per special attack. (Like in mine they could have both pitfall and lightning traps that bury or stun, but you only get 2 or 3 of each. His he would just put pitfall on like down b) He did like the idea of needing to sharpen to keep up higher than average damage, or not sharpening and after a number of attacks your damage drops below average.

[@lebossbolosse8786]

@@DarthZ01 the idea is cool but I think that the inventory of the hunter be just a down b in the style of the hero, he select by holding the b bottom and use the stick to select and he will use the item by just pressing the down b

[@lebossbolosse8786]

@@DarthZ01 and I think a good gimmick could be that his neutral b when used into an normal attack he would strike with a combo using the weapon that he has in hand, for exemple if his donw smash is using the hammer he will borrow the use the big bang combo, ect...

[@lebossbolosse8786]

It would ease the process to represent the 14 weapon in monster hunter

[@Supermariorpg6]

You uploaded a video about Knuckles getting into Smash, while Pizzadudemanguy uploaded a video about Tails.... Coincidence? I think not!

[@BrawlFan1]

Actually it was a coincidence.

[@gryotharian]

Why does knuckles have legos on his shoes

[@shanerotandi5956]

Great video man! Subbed

[@ScrappySora]

Can I request 2B from Nier. Automata? That would be cool :D

[@jonathanboutell8767]

My favorite Sonic character! Yay! Also, this is a very small nitpick, but I've noticed in a lot of your videos you use the word "apex" to describe the end of a move (like apex of the punch at 4:01 in this video). Apex is actually the highest point of something, so it doesn't really make sense to say unless you're talking about a move that goes up. An up special would have an apex at the top, but a forward smash wouldn't. Sorry if this was too nitpicky, but it's been bothering me for a while now. Thanks for all the work you do and I look forward to what you're doing in the future!

[@willofthewinds3222]

Ideas for characters that need movesets: Tressa from Octopath Travis Touchdown from No More Heroes Amateratsu from Okami Perhaps one of the Lords from Fire Emblem 3 Houses The Hunter from Bloodborne

[@grittytenacious6004]

BrawlFan1! I've just had a great idea! What if we had... Mordecai and Rigby! Think about it, neutral b would be the Fists of Justice. Mordecai lunges forward, and if he grabs the opponent, Rigby runs up and punches them away. Or one of their skins could be them wearing shirts saying "Mordecai and the Rigbys" Anyways, think about it. I'm a huge fan of the show and i'd think it would be really cool. Maybe they could have a gimmick of some kind, like coffee or... I'll stop talking.Anyways, think it over, and if you want, make a move set. Have a great day!

[@grittytenacious6004]

Also Another thing, I made my own moveset (on paper_ of Godzilla, WHICH I'M A KAIJU NERD of that franchise. If anyone's interested, I'll try my best to upload it here someday. %'s and everything

[@juddyfruity3917]

What if Ristar was in Smash? (I’m never giving this up until it happens)

[@d4n737]

0:30 That. That's Knux's entire trailer. Nothing more, no context. Sakurai just drops this on Twitter and that's it

[@ailingstar8856]

Characters I still want to see: Goose from Untitled Goose Game Kefka from FFVI Grovyle from PMD explorers Zoroark from Pokemon Quote from Cave Story Saki from Sin and Punishment Crono from Chrono Trigger Team Chaotix from Sonic The Kid from Bastion The Dart Monkey from Bloons Tower defence Henry Stickmin from the Henry Stickmin series. Chell from Portal

[@BrawlFan1]

I already did Grovyle in my Hoenn Trainer moveset.

[@ailingstar8856]

@@BrawlFan1 yeah, but I feel like there should be a representative for the Pokemon Mystery dungeon franchise, and unless you do Emolga, Dunsparce, or Virizion from Gates to Infinity, Grovyle's really the only major enough character, since the main character and the partner are different for each player. Besides, between the items unique to PMD (orbs, gravelerocks, spikes), Grovyle's reputation as a cunning and overwhelming fighter, and his most important move being Dig, I think you could figure something out. I wouldn't be opposed to the characters from Gates to Infinity appearing, though.

[@rodrigomorales563]

YES! Thank you SO much for doing knuckles man. He is one of my favorite sonic characters right along the rest of team sonic and eggman. In fact, your moveset was really close to my moveset. And even though it's different, I love your final smash idea. So unique! I'd say, you did an excellent job with this moveset. So how about doing toad sometime? Again, regular toad, not just captain.

[@mushroomfusion245]

Let’s see, this channel A. Has basically no rules B. Gives warnings for characters whose content is mature. C. Is for characters who will probably never get in. I think Mai from King of Fighters is a perfect fit for this series! (Insert bad boys and girls joke here. There, I did it for all of you repliers)

[@mann-nova9392]

This is a super cool moveset! I love the Final Smash and victory animations. I can see you took some inspiration from the Project M moveset. ;)

[@Mr._Maniac]

Actually no. He doesn't look at any movesets so he doesn't feel like he's stealing ideas. Anything that's similar to another moveset is simply a coincidence.

[@lexsamreeth8724]

Snake: "Otacon, did Sonic dye his quills or something?" Otacon: "No, that's Knuckles the Echidna. He's a close friend of Sonic, and a rival." Snake: "Hmm. He seems a bit gullible." Otacon: "Well, he has lived in isolation for years, guarding the Master Emerald. That massive gem is capable of tapping into the power of the Chaos Emeralds, allowing for almost reality-warping power. And that constant exposure to its power has made him incredibly strong. He can cause earthquakes and volcanic eruptions by punching the ground, and destroy massive robots with a single strike. But the weirdest thing is, he can glide!" Snake: "Wait...you're telling me that thing can glide? He doesn't have wings or anything!" Otacon: "Chalk it up to the chaos energy. Just be careful. He might be light, but his punches can match the heaviest of heavyweights." Snake: "Still, he seems really gullible. Probably won't take much to outwit him..."

[@chu-pay]

I hate how this isn’t real bruh T-T I voted for Knux too when Wii U was out BTW, maybe knuckles could have the yellow spring. This references how he can’t jump high compared to sonic, and how the red spring that sonic has launches him higher than the yellow one. So the shorter vertical distance spring could go to knux

[@borahbros1664]

Bendy - bendy in the ink machine Toad - mario Gooigi - Luigi’s mansion Kris - deltarune

[@therealboy23]

Yes! Gooigi for smash!!!

[@PrinceEomer8102]

A video for Bendy was just released, so you should watch it

[@WalnutAnimations]

A-man therealboy23 he would just be an echo

[@braydenp2478]

Here’s some ideas - Ayano Aishi - Spider Man - LEGO Batman - Peppa Pig (If you want to)

[@ianbowling9396]

Please do Dark Matter. He has GOOD move set potential.

[@fandomtrash5851]

(sorry for poor spelling. btw maybe spoilers for deltarune) i have a some-what out there idea "What if the thrash machine was in smash". For context, the thrash machine is from a part in deltarune where lancer and suzie, after teaming up against you, make you make a plan for a machine to be built to ,in there words, "thrash your own ass".you are then thrown into a sort of create your character screen where you select the head,body,and shoe/foot that will make up the machine (even selecting the color of the parts).the head section has a selection of:laser (which gives cool and guns),sword (which gives elegant points and lively points),flame (which gives cute points and hot points) and duck (which gives no points and has a discription of "garbage. You're going to lose points).The body section has a selection of:Plain (which gives elegant points and cute points),Wheel (which gives lively points and cool points),tank (which gives hot points and guns points) and duck (with a discription of "just looking at this is making you lose points").Finally, the shoe section has a selection of:Sneak (which gives lively and cute points),A.whl (wheels) (which gives you hot points and cool points),tread (which gives you elegant points and guns points), and finally duck (with a description of just simply "you're going to lose points"). those points (or lack there of) mean apsolutly nothing except different diolog after completion of the machine but maybe you could work them into there gimmick. after you finish building the machine and hit "END" susie apeares out of a bush,exchanges words, and than runs of with lancer.after escaping the forest maze, you come across the machine you built and its ... worse than the preview in the creation menu (unless it's the duck in which case it will be exactly like in the menu). eventualy susie and lancer blowup the machine and say that it sucked so they decided to blow it up. i already thought of some ideas but i will only share one and than leave the rest to you, i think the the player will start off as the duck set but almost every move will tranceform different parts of the body to the different body parts from the character creator. (SORRY FOR THE LONG READ)

[@kenmurray457]

Prinny from Disgea, dude.

[@michaelkindt3288]

@12:15-.-Why not make it as green as his master emerald form in the Archie comics?

[@christophergyamfi7550]

My Requests: Decidueye (Pokémon) Porky (Earthbound/MOTHER)

[@willoxergaming3124]

a better idea for knuckles options while down special is active would be to use up special and knuckles would use the fire from the punch to form a mini volcano which if it hits an enemy it will deal massive damage and knock back and will be very similar to Luigi's up special and will also have lots of end lag so this option is a very high risk high reward option (also i love your content and ive just been going through the playlist and its hella awsome man keep up the good work)

[@pacdad6864]

What if Classic sonic from sonic the hedgehog Blaze from sonic the hedgehog Silver from sonic the hedgehog Koopa troopa from mario Rouge from sonic the hedgehog And Amy from sonic the hedgehog Were in smash

[@seanelmlinger1198]

Quite a interestingly used introduction, I've never seen anything like it.

[@oj_cruzz4372]

Can you make earthworm jim pls

[@blaze4109]

This man knows the way.

[@TheKillerMoth]

Me : think out of the box THINK OUT OF THE BOX Brawl fan: It’s Mickey Mouse Me : ....... REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

[@RedKing12000]

A fellow Knucklehead, eh? Excellent, even if I think Eggman is a better pick over all, it’s always nice to hear from a kindred spirit. As for character requests, I’ve always thought Commander Shepherd would make a pretty cool out of the blue third party power addition. On top of being a more contemporary third party icon, they would net BioWare( *sigh* and I suppose by extension EA) some well deserved glory, but I’ve never been quite sure how best to go about trimming them down to a Smash savvy move set.