What If Qui Gon Jinn's Force Ghost Trained Anakin Skywalker

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

We are announcing a NEW 75,000 Subscriber Lightsaber Giveaway, Sponsored by Artsabers: instagram.com/p/CrdsW99OsLw/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y= Instructions: Subscribe to PPSW on KZbin Follow @artsabers on Instagram: instagram.com/artsabers?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y= Share post on your personal story Like the Instagram post & tag 2 friends and you’ll be entered to win! (Comment multiple times by tagging 2 friends per comment to get extra entries for a better chance to win!)

[@IcedNFire]

great story by the way will there be a season 2 of What If the Sith Empire Returned During the Clone Wars?

[@brokenbridge6316]

As usual this "What if" story was a good one. If only this had happened for real.

[@DarthKilaj85]

Why do you always still kill Kit Fisto when Anakin stays behind despite that it's been said that it was cause Fisto sensed Anakin coming that distracted him enough for Palpatine to kill him.

[@mgjmiller1995]

10:04 "How can a politician not have pure intentions with their words?" Bet it was fun for Pente to record that 😂

[@franklinsisson1281]

Japanese American enturnment camps be like

[@captaintitus4637]

@@franklinsisson1281 Trump be like

[@Wolffman109]

Good on him. I don't think I'd be able to say that without laughing.

[@Thatrandomguy00105]

That’s what I was going to say

[@99thJediWarrior]

@@captaintitus4637 Same for Biden

[@sideways_chip_eater6420]

13:06 Anakin: *Having the urge for murder and destruction* Qui-gon: "oh cool you got taller."

[@Duskoi]

Anakin: "how could a politician not have pure intentions with their words" Me: oooo boy u gon learn today

[@nathanwhite2689]

The only very unbelievable thing apart of this "what if" is clones defeating Mace Windu.

[@CPUReddragon24]

What if anakin was declined training by the Jedi order and following that obi wan left the order and took anakin to train him on mandalore

[@RipCityBassWorks]

This would be a really good one.

[@garrettadyns3927]

Gimme this story

[@TheUncivilizedNation]

Or what if he didn’t want to become a Jedi period so while he’s found he’s left alone until the Clone Wars when he joins the military because he learns the Separatists support slavery

[@fumkioyuki8457]

i just want anakin's reaction to obi-wan statine's relationship.

[@manssundstrom9573]

YES! THAT'S THE STUFF I WANNA HEAR!

[@cartoonzentertainment]

THIS IS WHERE THE FUN BEGINS, one request I have that could be weird but I’m curious to is what if Anakin and Padme adopted Boba Fett after the Battle of Geonosis?

[@I-amthe-new-hokn-ucks]

That is a good quastion

[@ServantOfOdin]

Good point. No one elaborated what he did in the intermediate years. We see him in a later Clone Wars arc where he's already into the criminal business, trying to avenge his fathers death with the help of other bounty-hunters (and it ends him up in prison). But we don't know what happened immediately after the battle. I mean a lone human child on a planet of insects?

[@davey12334]

@@ServantOfOdinthere’s a book about it he went to tattooine to meet Jabba

[@ServantOfOdin]

@@davey12334 ah, interresting

[@vodkalord6941]

what if the rebel soldiers somehow killed Darth Vader on the Tantive IV? what if Obi wan lost to Anakin on Mustafar, was burned, found by Yoda and made into a cyborg like Grievous? what if it was Bo Katan that obi wan was in love with instead of Satine?

[@kuunt6065]

Leia locks in and beats his ass

[@samk3lly]

We heard what if Mace trained Obi-Wan. But what if... now just hear me out. What if Yoda trained Obi-Wan? 🤔

[@jspeedstar1129]

Never been done before, I'm curious too 🤔

[@shaveyodamust8505]

That would be a great one. A What if Plo Koon trained Obi Wan would also be a great one.

[@kensosaramos]

Has dooku trained Obi-Wan and Yoda Qui-Gon?

[@tweso1499]

Would make the quote from TESB make sense in a matter of speaking

[@Nostalgia244]

“Well technically Yoda did train Obi-Wan” 🤓💬

[@Dove01s]

"How could a politician not have pure intentions with their words" - I was watching this while eating a sandwich and nearly choked on my food at that line. XD

[@shaveyodamust8505]

What if Anakin were born during the Old Republic Era and fell in love with Satele Shan during the Great Galactic War.

[@lost4468yt]

Nah dude needed a full on council of master therapists to help him.

[@RyanTheDark]

I'm glad Anakin was allowed to grow as a person and gained wisdom by the end. Thankfully he had managed to change the Jedi Order for the better. Windu's death would definitely led Obi-Wan to become the Master of the Order and perhaps eventually Anakin, meaning that this is not out of the realms of possibilities.

[@marikam2998]

Well, Anakin's Psychological Growth as a Personality is really the biggest plus In Stories like this. More Stories where Anakin's Destiny as a Jedi ends differently and not tragically.

[@MonkeyDBoomE]

Good job, my good sir. Good job. No redundant dialogue. Fluent transitions. Impactful moments. One of my favorites.

[@joshadley]

great story, very well done, hope your feeling better

[@spawnofragnarok9267]

What if Luke Skywalker had been raised by Yoda ?

[@nsmi28]

what if anakin was frozen in carbonate during episode 3, replaced by a clone of anakin. and then 20 years later, he’s broken out by han?

[@omega1845]

I think that would be pretty interesting

[@camilomercado5607]

so the clone would be vader but instead of carbonite freeze him in stasis something like kixx or freeze him along side with kixx by palpatine but then got unstasis by han or luke

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Qui-Gon was the mentor Anakin needed. Even in Spirt Form, Anakin should be better prepared now against the Sith. Edit: Correction the Father Anakin needed, sorry.

[@omega1845]

No he was the father he needed

[@marikam2998]

Well, Yoda. And Mace was also suitable for this role. At what even much more better than Qui Gon Jinn. Qui Gon Jinn was a good human. And The Jedi, but, he wasn't not the best choice for Anakin's Master. If Qui Gon trained Anakin, then the story could repeat itself with Xanatos, who in many ways was similar to Anakin, only Anakin would have been in place of Xanatos. In addition, Qui Gon wanted to train Anakin because, he wanted to believe Anakin was The Chosen One. Qui Gon wanted to believe it because he was overwhelmed by Anakin's Potential In The Force. The number of Anakin's Midichlorians. And because he wanted to believe in the Anakin's Immaculate Birth as indisputable proof of Anakin's Chosenness. Although, The Prophecy that Qui Gon blindly believed could be actually referring to Luke and not Anakin, because, Luke's Personality was more like that of The Chosen One than Anakin's Personality. As for Obi-Wan, then Obi-Wan From Attack Of The Clones Or From Revenge Of The Sith was a better fit as Anakin's Master in terms of age. And experience than Obi-Wan From The Phantom Menace.

[@hamstey1603]

​@@marikam2998 Anakin WAS the chosen one. It referred to him (as said by the man himself, George Lucas) and he still completed the prophecy even after his turn to the dark side (once again, as said by George Lucas)

[@marikam2998]

@@hamstey1603 Well, Then, The Fulfillment Of The Prophecy turned out to be somehow very doubtful. Because, I don't believe that the Force could want to Enslave The Galaxy. Destruction Of The Republic. And The Destruction Of The Old Jedi Order for this. Not to mention, we even do not know what exactly could be in the 2 part of The Prophecy, which was presumably considered lost?

[@hamstey1603]

​​@@marikam2998 The Sith were intervening and manipulating the force in ways that the force itself did not like. This disrupted balance and thus, Anakin was born. However as always, the sith caused more imbalance by killing Qui Gon and the fate of the galaxy was sealed (as shown by the name of the duel, "duel of the fates") So basically, the prophecy was likely going to be done normally with the death of the sith without much trouble, but the sith caused more disruption in the force which is what causes balance to be achieved by the enslavement of the galaxy. Either way, the prophecy was going to be completed whether the galaxy suffered or not, the force doesn't really care. Or maybe, it's just psychotic af or something lmao.

[@nightspawnson-of-luna4936]

10:06 LMFAO This just gives me the vibes of "You really think someone would do that? Just Go on the internet and tell lies?"

[@keiroty7187]

I think he’d be able to confine in this surrogate father figure as a force ghost when obiwan learns of that he’d cry

[@dianesinger9729]

Great story so happy to see Anakin's maturity this the Anakin I wished we saw

[@dls1970]

If Qui-Gon had fully trained Anakin, Anakin probably wouldn't had fallen to the Dark Side. This is from Legends Material, but with Qui-Gon's previous (sublime) relationship with Master Tahl, he would've easily sensed Anakin's connection with Padme and served as a more proper guide for them both, and would have been more accepting of them both. Secondly, the Clone Wars probably would have been stunted or probably never have happened altogether as Qui-Gon was much more attuned to the Living Force than the rest of the senior Jedi (poor Obi-Wan included), and he would've taken a chance to take Palpatine down due to both of them being maverick Force-sensitives. I honestly see that. ☺

[@BRouge]

What if Anakin left the jedi order (not necessarily to join Sidious) before the Clone War (because of Windu's comments)

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin fell in love with Bo katan. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin and Obi-Wan left the jedi order when Anakin was still an Pawan

[@chesskinge4627]

What if Jar Jar Binks was a jedi? If Sheeve Palpatine could be a jedi and have a good What if, then a serious story with Jar Jar Binks as a jedi could happen.

[@darthnexus9570]

What if Mace Windu decided to take Master Anakin Skywalker to confront Palpatine/Darth Sidious???

[@Historyexplorer4563]

master!?

[@sammiller4070]

Assuming Anakin somehow was granted the rank of Master prior to the confrontation, I expect.

[@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom]

Star Wars "What ifs" I would like to see next: 1. What if Cal Kestis and Galen Marek met. 2. What if Tarkin joined the Separatists. 3. What if the Rebel Alliance used clones. 4. What in the Empire used droids. 5. What if Rahm Kota trained Cal Kestis.

[@wolfdotzip4053]

the rebels did use some clones

[@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom]

@@wolfdotzip4053 Ya, but those clones were retired and old.

[@wolfdotzip4053]

@@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom all of them were retired and old by the point of the ot so like at the very beginning the could go find some rouge clones that abandoned the empire like the bad batch younger rex and maybe wolf

[@wolfdotzip4053]

@@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom to make it sound more sense at the beginning of the rebellion

[@alduintheanti-dragonborn]

I laughed at "How can a politician not have pure intentions with their words?"

[@resnify]

rebels fanfic ideas : -What if Ezra joined Maul? -What if Palpatine accessed the world between worlds? -What if Maul killed Kenobi -What if Sabine Wren was force sensitive (darksaber)

[@theonlyjjparker]

This was very in-depth an thought out! This was fantastic. Thank you.

[@irBribe]

Hey pente patrol. I just wanna say thank you from the bottom of my heart for these videos. They are awesome to listen to while i do nothing but pack boxes at amazon. It helps keep me sane and my mind active rather then dwelling on bad thoughts or cringe things i did as a kid. So thank you. Keep it up!

[@Bearhoff]

One story I've never heard someone take on that I always thought would be interesting is Yoda's entire life. Like how kickass would he be at like 350 years old?

[@anduinxbym6633]

10:03 _"How could a politician not have pure intentions with their words?"_ 😂🤣😂🤣

[@danielharman572]

I like this story. I think that only one change could be made but it's a minor change the jedi contact bail organa, Mon mothma and the other delegation of 2000 sharing all the information about sidious being palpatine controlling both sides of the clone wars ect. In short with the help of senators loyal to the Republic the jedi don't need to take over the senate. Kind regards from Daniel Harman. Ps get well soon and all the best.

[@darthbane3937]

In the movie Mace talks about taking over the senate to secure a peaceful transition. Most fanfics and even Phaloni dodge around that saying that if Palps had been arrested, the senate would have let him off. The Jedi would've entered the senate with lightsabers drawn. Yoda said that was a dark line of thought.

[@chrisrisner3165]

That was really good story line I really enjoyed it! You are doing a great job 👍

[@charleslee8313]

1 AM Coruscant Standard Time That's a nice touch.

[@LiteraryOverflow]

You know the beginning with Palpatine always reminds me frustrated I get when people ignore the fact that he groomed Anakin and that child grooming is child abuse.

[@chadbrewer1214]

What If yoda trained obi wan sounds awesome you should do it

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Yaddle was Dooku's instructor instead of Yoda

[@Rudelights]

What if Bo-Katan became friends with Anakin skywalker? What if the Mandalorian helped the rebels? What if luke skywalker and luke starkiller both existed in the same time and were friends? What if Leia was the chosen one? What if captain Rex raised luke skywalker? What if the rebels used clones? What if Ezra became maul’s apprentice? What if Luke Skywalker became the ruler of mandalor?

[@joseph20yearsago61]

So Qui gon is basically the HOLY SPIRIT

[@robertruse6552]

Okay I was really like this story I do wish it was longer I Oprah part 2 keep up the good work and May the force be with you

[@neossendaris1725]

What if Padme was a Jedi ? What if Tarkin was good and/or joined the Rebellion ?

[@krisculin9679]

I've watched most of your "What if?" videos for the most part I enjoy them. But I have to admit that this is my all-time favorite. I think the idea of Qui-Gon's ghost helps augment Obi-Wan's training is perfect. The fact that Anakin does not go to the Senate because he's listening to the will of the force is important, too. Maybe there is a Galactic Civil War eventually but instead of Darth Vader being the big bad, it would instead be Thrawn. I would see it kind of like the First Order in Force Awakens where there is the Republic Government in place but the First Order also exists. It would be an interesting idea to persue. Great job on this one, though.

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

Great fan fiction man these are always really good every time i tune into what your doing , keep it up 👏🏾🔥

[@AlexFantasy88]

There are so many what if stories that are good including this one. But i wonder what the best what if story would make everyone happy. like what is the best happy ending what if for everyone

[@Cander617]

Was great the only part I take issue with is the clones killing mace and palpy, and army couldn't take those 2 lol

[@Istoleyoursweetroll]

What if YOU trained Anakin Skywalker? Theory idea. What if one of us trained the chosen one.

[@astephens3600]

Qui-Gon Jinn almost sounds like Master Orgus from Star Wars The Old Republic

[@snapeinvader]

I get that Qui-Gon wouldn't want Anakin to give in and kill the Tuskan raiders, but doesn't that just leave them to do the same thing to other innocents? Stopping just the ones that killed Shmi would at least lessen the likelihood of further deaths.

[@drejenkins8801]

OMG THE WORDING IN THIS IS FIRE 🔥🔥 ALMOST POETIC

[@randymarshislorde]

Another good one

[@Ghostman128x]

Good what if, but one flaw. There was still one sith still around. And without Sideous around he could have been a problem in the shadows conjuring up a plan for the sith to return. The sith I’m referring to is of course Maul

[@imember7375]

what if caleb dume and cal kestis swapped places

[@somethingforsenro]

qui: _dying_ oh no how will i train the boy qui, force ghost: fuck it we do it anyway

[@fiddlerfinskysaccount411]

Do "What if Count Dooku killed Yoda, Obi-Wan, and Anikan on Geonosis"

[@jackstoli]

Would be awesome if Qui Gon's ghost trained an Anakin clone.

[@SirFlooberis]

I would love a two part or more series about what if the separatist had won the war instead of the republic.

[@Mike-the-monster]

What if darth bane killed his apprentice xannah during their final confrontation to see if the apprentice was worthy

[@NickolosBreedlove]

What if now what if palpatine trained Grogu

[@toothhair3676]

what if the jedi explored more galaxies

[@JeremiahWiebe]

The fact that he didn’t feed Dooku by himself sucks

[@patrick.d4999]

What if Anakin stayed on umbara

[@danielharman572]

What if Qui-gon Jinn's force ghost talked with rey on jakku. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@stangundam01]

another what if would be what if the qui gon found & used the holocrons of the hero of typhon & the barsanthor along the noetacrons of light, science & secrets to help his & then kenobi & anakin's training?

[@Mech299]

What if the Jedi trained Anakin ON Tattoine to help him process and come to terms with his emotions and allow him to more healthily separate from his connections? Basically? What if Anakin was more emotionally healthy going into his Jedi Training? As it is, they basically consentually kidnapped Anakin. I know that that's their way, but that's for young, YOUNG children, and Anakin was already an exception. Setting up a small, remote Jedi presence on Tattoine would both alert the Jedi to the goings on in the outer rim, and allow them to perhaps set up a new base of Jedi Operations in the outer rim ahead of the clone wars, based off of this simple decision. It allows Anakin time to come to terms with his new life, have a proper goodbye with his mother as she watches him grow up and naturally drift apart due to his actions and decisions, and it would help sponsor bonds of family with the jedi because his existing friends and mother could approve of his new family.

[@marikam2998]

None of The Jedi Anakin abducted even by mutual consent. Shmi herself understood that Anakin would be better off with the Jedi than with her. As much as Shmi loved Anakin, she would never have agreed to leave Tatooine, even for Anakin, which she considered her home, unlike, Anakin. Otherwise, Shmi would not have agreed to marry Cliegg. And left Tatooine right after Cliegg released her. Because Of Anakin's Force Sensitivity made he it dangerous to remain on Tatooine. Because, if he had stayed there then Palpatine would have found a way to kidnap him. And letting Anakin go after what happened at the Battle of Naboo was also dangerous. After all, thanks to Maul, it became clear that the Sith had not completely disappeared.

[@colethelin9203]

Great Video

[@cancellations1546]

What if obi wan put Anakin on the defensive?

[@danielharman572]

What if Qui-gon jinn and obi-wan kanobi captured darth maul. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@californiacommando232]

What if Cal had met with kenobi to train Luke

[@frankolioman]

What if the republic, separatists, empire and rebellion each had their own death star?

[@Pheenix9900]

Now I'm wondering if Obi-Wan or Yoda's force ghost will train Grogu

[@cole56alibata]

What if Qui Gon fell for Smee and raised Anakin in tatooine

[@nerdwatch1017]

What if Padme in episode 1 once Naboo was safe sent a ship off to Tatooine and purchased Shimi’s freedom and offered her a place working as a personal servant. Say as a gift for young Anakin for the major role he played in shutting down the Droid army. How would knowing his mother is safe and living/working on Naboo in service to queen Amidala. Would that help him be able to focus much better those first couple of years!!?

[@ch62013]

What if Cal Kestis was called by Grogu from the Seeing Stone?

[@technoplane-db8ni]

What if quigon jin never got stabbed and him and obi wan defeated Darth maul

[@matthewmann8969]

What if Anakin was born in a billionaire household?

[@darthnexus9570]

Like one of the top houses of Kuat...

[@forresterscalan3921]

Pretty sure the richest people in star wars are quadrillionares lol

[@maxwhite8616]

​@@forresterscalan3921better than a slave then

[@daruphir]

Hey Pente idea. What if Palpatine had successfully possessed Reys body in Rise of Skywalker

[@gavinminton210]

What If Yoda and Obi Wan Kenobi defeated Sidious and Vader at the end of Revenge of the Sith

[@darthjeager9056]

can you do what if plaugeis and palpatine abandoned the rule of two and tried to rebuild the sith empire

[@stephendrigans3667]

What if plagues, trains Anakin, what if pomkrell trained Anakin

[@alexDaviiid]

What if idea what if full potential Anakin went back in time to when he was a slave boy

[@box1del1idiote]

What about a side character for the next one in a later series like say What if Phoenix Team rescued and Maketh Tua and prevented her death Sometimes stories with side characters is more fun because either snowball effect or nothing at all, just a bit of fun

[@darthmaul4773]

You should do what if Savage Oppress was in episode one with Maul?

[@brenersilva7361]

What if anakin and padme had a child before luke and Leia

[@JeremiahWiebe]

The fact that he did not kill those evil people who are slavers also sucks

[@naseembegum121]

What if anakin was born in a billionaire family

[@twilliamspro]

Always wanted to see some youngling Anakin Adventures As good as hayden Christianson was i would have been interested to see how jake lloyd could do

[@ikillzuepicly316]

What if Jabba The Hutt joined The Republic during The Clone Wars

[@crynosinso8324]

What if Watto accepted Qui-Gon's bet for both Anakin and his mother.

[@jamiemurnaghan1405]

What if Ashoka and Anakin fell in love

[@BlufireTheifprince]

There was one factor that could change the outcome of the war in The republic's favor, With dooku detained, Greivous wouldn't have been as well trained in lightsaber combat. Do you think Greivous would last all the way to ROTS?

[@Fenix_816]

What if anakin had visions of Darth Vader as a child? What if Darth Vader interrogated Leia in Obi Wan Kenobi instead of Reva?

[@tythesithari4356]

Mace dies and Anakin gets his happy ending? The perfect what if scenario.

[@Master_Reven69]

Interesting 🤔 can’t wait

[@hi-vx4lk]

For sure Obi 1 would hav been a way better influence on young Anakin.

[@toomanygrenades]

Qui gon is stuck in a tunnel.

[@padmeSkywalker]

What if Padme had gained consciousness during the battle of Obi Wan and Anakin on mustafar? Would she had find a way to gain their attention or would she see her husband being chopped into half?

[@adamk9303]

What if Ahsoka Tano was secretly being trained by Palpatine Plo find out first where is Asoka where about are

[@animefreak9798]

I've got a what if for you. What if Kit Fisto trained Anakin? BTW Kit Fisto is one favorite characters from Star Wars Right up there with Plo Koon and Rex.

[@FireFlame.]

He already did that