What If Trixie Mattel & Katya Swapped Seasons?

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

Hello everyone! I have a Discord server now! discord.gg/QksZ5BKqWx

[@valeryyy5558]

Let's be honest. This video can be retitled to "I want Trixie and Katya to both be winners" and I love that.

[@satansgrandma6728]

I love seeing "what if" seasons, they're so interesting to me. One idea I think would be interesting is all stars 7 but the winners are replaced with their runner-ups

[@Mudkip0408]

Ok but Manila, Alaska, Brooke, Gigi, Divina, Mo, Naomi and Jujubee would be such a fierce cast

[@dakaramotto.]

@@Mudkip0408 I wouldn’t count Alaska. She’s a winner. I would put roxxxy

[@AlexandreFilho1705]

Bold statements were made... i don't think Trixie would slay that hard, as her talents didn't translate too well to Drag Race both times she competed. Love her though.

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

I really do think she got screwed by challenge selection. She was never going to win in a Rusical/Talent Show, but she can definitely pull off a verse or an acting challenge. Fair point though

[@chogiboo8010]

the way this could singlehandedly revive the AS3 trixie hate train 💀

[@Jamar84]

I dont know if its me, but I have a hard time determining the placements based on the position and colors of the boxes. Maybe include some text to make it easier to read. Loved the idea though! Keep the videos coming

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

It’s not just you, and thank you for the input! I’m looking for changes to make to fix the format, so I will definitely give that a shot!

[@Jamar84]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged awesome! Love the content by the way. Alternate timelines are always so fun to explore 🤩

[@YoBubCo]

Love love love Trixie but she would have been absolutely steam rolled in AS2.

[@cardboardcreationsart]

seeing trixie's snatch game performance.... she likely would have been in the bottom with roxxy and tati, and without a win, she would've gone home 😅

[@jakubpuchalski2583]

But her runway tho

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

Her runway was great, and track records didn’t matter at that point. Even if she were in the bottom, she’d be viewed as safe by the top queens (like Detox was)

[@c.k.8585]

If Trixie had done Snatch Game on AS2, it would have been Dolly Parton. She wouldn't have used Dolly on the immediately previous episode. Would she kill it? No idea. But she'd definitely do better than Roxxy or Detox.

[@GabrielPereira-nl2xt]

Trixie is amazing. But bit Alaska in AS2? HAHHAHAHA What a joke! Thanks for making me laugh so hard

[@melpomenathemuse]

Trixie would be sent home episode two.

[@clenshin97]

We get it, you're a Trixie stan

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

🤷‍♂️

[@santiagovelasco2742]

Love this scenario. I'm shocked, but i do agree 😂

[@squid438]

DEFINITELY DELULU, but I love this channel 😝

[@giorgiod.219]

De Lu Lu fan, I can't with you! ROFL

[@kyra_kuntillia_rose]

I think people’s forget Trixie wasn’t polished when that season was filming

[@rutgernewman828]

I don’t think switching Trixie and Katya would work. HOWEVER…I think Ben’s role on all stars 3 was similar to the role Katya had on all stars 2. Switching those two and seeing how it would shake out is the real swap I’d like to see. Ben’s performance on all stars 2 definitely would’ve been different with the rolaskatox aspect, and I think Katya wouldn’t have quit ala Ben on all stars 3 and would’ve won instead.

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

I really like that!

[@JakobTennisMB]

How was Ben's role similar to Katya's?

[@moonlightbae6143]

I dont think Trixie even had an album released during the time AS2 was filmed 😂 nor had unhh started. It would of been a complete mess

[@deadassnick]

Yeah, she needed that extra time before as3 to marinate

[@seanhawkins6565]

Trixie would’ve been out at snatch game…

[@alexanderbassett2901]

Katya on the bitchleor my god

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

In retrospect, Katya is winning that challenge. It would be absolutely insane

[@c.k.8585]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged Trixie has said that kennedy did even better than what was shown. I don't think anyone would be winning over her. But yeah, I could see Katya being able to handle Milk better and getting second place over Ben.

[@GabrielPereira-nl2xt]

Say that Trixie would bit Alaska in AS2 is like sayng Aquaria would bit Jinkx in AS7

[@themosteliteyoutuberintheu3162]

I can’t see Trixie beating Alaska

[@apigeon2212]

trixie flopped snatch game harder than roxxxy or tatianna who were forgettable but not as cringe, and trixie wouldnt have a talent show win so i imagine she’d get eliminated

[@averykoi]

i think alaska would always win all stars 2 no matter what happens, alaska was a fan favorite and she did slay the season, while she might not have the fans when against trixie mattel, at that time, trixie wasnt as big as she is today, and also, katya was a fan favorite and probably universally preferred for the win, and she still didnt :/

[@davilemme3360]

i love that Trixie had a latex runway on AS3 to fit right into the AS2 ep2 category!

[@Oniromanciee]

At that point it's fanfiction but why not!

[@Psshyeahbby]

so sad to think kennedy wouldn’t be around for the bitchelor challenge! that’s one of my favorite moments in drag race period. kennedy is amazing

[@OccamsSledgehammer]

I’ll be here waiting….

[@moonlightbae6143]

Trixie from S7 winning AS2 is an absolutely insane thought 😂 wtf is this

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

Specifically what decision do you disagree with?

[@moonlightbae6143]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged literally the entire thing, I don’t think you took into account where Trixie actually was in 2015 when AS2 was filmed, she’d just came off being 4th eliminated on season 7 and not had any experience really yet how on earth would she of won All Stars 2 😂

[@Nukemoth]

I’m sorry, but the delusion is real here. There is no way that Trixie would win All-Stars two. she only won her own All-Stars because of the twist at the end, and all stars 2 has a MUCH stronger cast

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

Specifically which decision do you disagree with

[@citrinethecorgi]

I'm sorry but just based off of trixie's 2015-16 makeup she would not win all stars 2 😭

[@gasonile8024]

You're so delulu if u think Trixie would have the best track record lmao be serious

[@johnsjogerstenturner9204]

girl you're wildin out w nick cannon

[@m1rr0rdemon]

sanest trixie-katya fan. cute video though

[@shutid987]

ooh i can already see this'll be fun

[@jpmedina8328]

Please go back to the format of placement you used to do lol. I dont think this is good ngl...its also messy imo and the older one was easier to follow.

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

I’m still going to try and fix, but it definitely needs a fair amount to work. If I can’t get it to a point where it’s fine by the end of the year I’m going back to the old system

[@azsazazsa]

People are gonna read you for this, but I actually agree - under the condition that we’re moving AS3 Trixie to AS2, not the level of Trixie that was around _during_ AS2.

[@azsazazsa]

Also, hot take about AS3: Shangela should’ve been low for the Snatch Game. It was very Safe, but that Snatch Game was really good. Aja and Ben (or Katya and Ben in this timeline) should’ve won, with Bebe (or Katya) being High.

[@c.k.8585]

@@azsazazsa Shangela had like two good jokes in that Snatch game. The menopause joke which she simply forced in and did not really fit the Snatch Game and a confessional that wasn't even during the game. Meanwhile Aja was doing an absolute legend of drag justice.

[@chriscolourshair4925]

Love this video idea

[@redduskironsky1058]

I love both of them a lot but even to me this sounds like having an edible😂and I have never had one😂

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

At bare minimum I stand by the Katya on AS3 choices

[@redduskironsky1058]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged ok those sound more plausible yes

[@ThePearlision]

I would love to see what if aja and valentina switched places or what if rajah o hara won as6 and Kylie returned for Canada vs the world

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

At bare minimum I’m making the Aja/Valentina season. That sounds really interesting!

[@SaB576]

Now I wanna know if they were both on the same all stars season

[@ohandthefracking]

this video wasnt a serve you thought it was im sorry

[@felipemath]

Or it also could be: AS2: Trixie would bomb snatch game harder than Tati and Detox, so she would be second out. AS3: Katya would be in the bottom for the Rusical against Kennedy (with Thorgy being safe), so Shangela would eliminate Katya but Thorgy would be able to excel in all the other challenges, so she would win the season, Woo!!

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

If Thorgy stays and Katya goes, Thorgy is getting at least 3-4 wins and is 100% winning the season

[@c.k.8585]

Both Rusicals were rigged by production to high heaven anyway.

[@klimisioannidis]

Thank god somebody pointed out how weird that Shangela fatsuit lipsync was. I was so weirded out watching it and even more weirded out at Ru and the rest judges enjoying it, let alone viewers loving it, that was horrible. And trust me, it had nothing to do with fat-shaming or anything. I just found it not funny, assuming that there was a joke there in the first place. And I find it so pretentious in the end of the day that Ru loved that lipsync but hated Trinity's old-lady bodysuit one. So many choices that Ru makes that have aged so badly. Same energy as Ru seeing Milk walk in the runway on Season 6 dressed as Werkroom Ru and visually disliking it, clearly also discliking the her bearded runway, but then next season they do a beard runway, Kennedy wiining the Snatch game as a male character and some years later crowning Danny Beard on DR:UK. All these Allstars Season 3 jury queens being bombarded by unfair critisism from the people for not making "the fair choice". These queens voted the way they did because they were able to see throught the production's BS and what the viewers were refusing to see and were complicit to all of production's shenanigans. Sigh.

[@c.k.8585]

I honestly felt it was so cringe. Not as cringe as Trinity's but still cringe.

[@lachlanhenry9785]

Honestly my Jantasy

[@victorjustino4461]

Trixie would be SAFE ELIM.

[@shawnbay2211]

Trixie winning is already insane in the timeline we’re living in. I just don’t think either of them would or should b winners but it’s just kinda sad that 1 of them is a winner & the other isn’t.

[@leoaurch]

okayyyyy

[@DrowzeeVirus]

I think this is literally the fairest it would be, these other people in the comments are delusional.

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

If there was no jury and Trixie had just won over Shangela, I think her run would’ve been viewed as good but not great. She’s really not that bad at drag race, the editors were just bad at highlighting her when she actually did a good job

[@DrowzeeVirus]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged I mean, if they wanted her to be great, she would have been only low in snatch game in AS3 since she landed her intro joke but Kennedy & Chichi (rip) didn't land any. Also, in her other bottom placements, she could have been literally safe or in the top (im looking at the kitty girl group challenge)

[@c.k.8585]

@@DrowzeeVirus Honestly I feel she did better than Ben in the girl group challenge.

[@DrowzeeVirus]

@@c.k.8585 Same here tbh

[@Jamar84]

also, if it hasn’t been done already, would it be worth to see the timeline if Ben stayed? 👀 😂 is there a scenario where she actually loses?

[@Discretion234]

Yes bc of the jury vote she could lose very likely.

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

I’d say if Ben stays, Ben and Trixie win the acting challenge and Morgan goes home. Then for the finale, the jury is voting in Trixie and Ben, with Ben winning. At least that’s my thought

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

It depends who she’s with. Bebe and Shangela are not making the final two, so if DeLa makes it with them and Trixie, I think she wins

[@c.k.8585]

If Ben stays, Kennedy is out. Ben very likely wins the acting challenge together with Trixie and has 6 wins. The queens simply did not like Shangela and would not vote Bebe for a second crown. Ben vs Trixie with Ben winning simply on track record.

[@fefossss]

girl lets be honest, trixie's makeup was blobby that time and katya already went crazy by that time so neither would win

[@vekskunk2685]

But would they have kept the jury twist in these switched timelines?

[@tiagopetersm]

in what universe jaremi wins the snatch game and trixie isnt in the bottom?

[@danielquezada3066]

I mean, i believe that katya can slay all stars 3 but Trixie could never, based on her previous seasons

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

Trixie really wasn't that bad on AS3. Her runways were top tier, and if DeLa didn't compete she would've won 4/7 challenges

[@danielquezada3066]

@@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged and that moment I don't think so, but I'm this moment I think that she can do a really good job

[@ingridsoleil]

Definitely some interesting takes here. However Jorgeous won the design so anything is possible. I'd definitely like to see the timeline that has this play out though

[@jforeal]

just my opinion but trixie would definitely do at least good (or safe) in snatch game tho? given if she got the chance to do dolly since that was her initial pick on AS 🤷‍♂️

[@jforeal]

makeover, acting, and branding is definitely on her wheel house as well, so i could see why she’d place high or safe for those challenges

[@alonlenger6955]

Im sorry but its not right how trixie won over alaska

[@Girlsaregirling09]

Mhm imo: All stars 2 Trixie: Talent: safe Snatch game: elim Stand up: win + lost lip sync against Alyssa = elim All stars 3 Katya: Talent: safe Rusical: safe Improv: high Snatch game: top2 (against Dela) Ball: safe Girl groups: win (against Bebe) + Ben quits Acting: top2 (against Shangela Finale: winner

[@OccamsSledgehammer]

Katya should have won AS2 and AS3.

[@Tony-mi2sf]

Trixie would not win season 2 for sure, I can easily see her out before final 3, she just not that strong in the competition.

[@essgee621]

Trixie 100% would not make it to the finale in that season of titans lol...trixie sucks at drag race lol love her though

[@marcusmelancon3426]

I don’t see Trixie in final 4 let alone win allstars 2 she easily could’ve been eliminated at snatch game since hers was so bad and as2 just had a stronger cast overall Trixie was on arguably not competitive season and still didn’t do good until the end and only won because of a twist

[@k4y5h4w]

katya did not beat alaska in cherry bomb like you said. dont blame u though, she should've...

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

100%

[@inventions178]

Trixie wouldn't win the acting, phi phi and alaska stil would win, she was amazing at Improv rather than acting. However she'd be safe until the makeover and commercial where she could win both.

[@jegocalderone]

Trixie wouldn't survive the power cast of AS2. She was barely noticeable on AS3 with Ben and Shangela in that season. even Bebe had a better track record than her

[@aphroguyte214]

baby this is biased

[@RuPaulsDragRaceRejudged]

I see that point, but I also think a lot of people tend to downplay Trixie’s run because she didn’t do as well as they thought she would. Her AS3 track record very easily could’ve been SAFE SAFE HIGH LOW WIN WIN WIN

[@Mylittleaddiction2802]

Girl i love this fantasy video and i m fully for katya and trixie winning but i don t think the judges like them as much🤣🤣🤡

[@samuelflorez6998]

i do think trixie would've been a runner up but i don't see her beating alaska, with katya i kinda agree with everything